Monetary Policy the “Fed” Alan Greenspan Remember, our goal is to keep the aggregate demand curve (AD) stable and intersecting the short-run aggregate supply curve (SRAS) at full employment (FE). This is where the economy operates at its most efficient potential. PL FE SRAS PL1 AD O Q1 GDPr But do to the ups and downs of the business cycle, the aggregate demand curve constantly moves to the right or left, causing economic instability. FE PL PLe SRAS AD2 AD1 O GDPr per year Peak Peak Trough Time Qe GDPr To stabilize the economy Federal Reserve carries out monetary policy. Monetary policy; the deliberate changes in the money supply to influence interest rates and thus the total level of spending in the economy. Only “fiscal or monetary policy” can get me back on my feet and allow “Sam” to get back up. Goals of Monetary Policy Maintain; • price-level stability • Fullemployment • Economic growth “Help” “When the economy is partying hard (inflation), it’s the job of the Fed to take away the punch bowl.” When the economy is not partying at all (recession), the Fed job is to “spike the punch.” Tools Of Monetary Policy 1. Open Market Operations - This is the main tool of monetary policy. - It consists of the buying and selling of government securities. Open-Market Operations during a recession When the Fed buys bonds from commercial banks, banks give up some of their securities and the Fed pays money for those securities. Thus they increase the excess reserves of the commercial banks by the amount of the purchase. Commercial banks are then able to loan out more money from their excess reserves. This increases Ig, which stimulates the economy. When the Fed buys bonds from the public, the public gives up the securities and the Fed gives them money. Some of this increased wealth is consumed (MPC) and some is saved (MPS). The amount consumed stimulates the economy. The amount that is saved is deposited in commercial banks, which increase the bank’s excess reserves, which stimulates the economy. 2. The Reserve Ratio - The most powerful & seldom used - Lowering the reserve ratio transforms RR into ER, which enhances the banks ability to create New money through lending. RR - Atomic Bomb of Monetary Policy Atomic Bomb of Monetary Policy Suppose the banking system has $500 billion in DD. The RR is 12% & AR are $60 billion. There are no ER in this system, thus no new loans can be made (500 x .12 = 60). Now, what if the Fed lowers the RR to 10%, what would be the affect on the banking system? Banks will have to keep $50 billion in reserve, so ER will increase from zero to $10 billion, and more new loans will be made. Atomic Bomb of Monetary Policy Why is it called the atomic bomb of monetary policy? Because changing the RR will also changes the Mm. In the example at 12% RR, the Mm equaled 8.33, but when the Fed changed the RR to 10% the Mm increased to 10. Changing the reserve ratio not only increase ER for loans, it also increased the multiple by which those loans will increase the money supply. 3. The Discount Rate - The interest rate that the Federal Reserve charges commercial banks for emergency loans Discount Rate: When the Fed provides loans to commercial banks, 100% of those funds are excess reserves (not subject to the reserve ratio). Banks can loan out all of these funds. A lowering of the discount rate encourages commercial banks to increase excess reserves by borrowing from the Fed. These excess reserves are then loaned out and increases the money supply. Easy money Policy: When the economy faces a recession the Fed will decide to increase the money supply, called easy money policy. • Lower the reserve ratio; changing required reserves to excess reserves. • Lower the discount rate; enticing borrowing to increase excess reserves. • Buy securities; increasing excess reserves and the DI of the public. Fed will do this 9-10 times! Money Market Investment Demand MS MS2 RIR DI RIR 1 10% 10 8% 8 6% 6 0 Pl DM AS/AD AD AD 1 2 P P2 AS 0 QID1 QID2 Qm Qm E2 E1 1 QR Q* GDPr Buy Bonds MS I.R. QID AD Y/Emp/PL Tight money Policy: When the economy is suffering from inflationary pressures the Fed will decide to decrease the money supply, called tight money policy. • Increasing the reserve ratio; changing excess reserves to required reserves. • Raise the discount rate; discouraging borrowing to increase excess reserves. • Sell securities; decreasing excess reserves and the DI of the public. The Fed will do this 9-10 times. Investment Demand Money Market RIR Dm MS2MS1 10 RIR Di 10% 8 8% 6 6% 0 Price level AS/AD P1 AS AD1 AD2 P2 Qm QID2 QID1 Qm E1 E2 Q* QI Sell Bonds MS I.R. QID AD Y/Empl./PL Strengths of Monetary Policy 1. Speed and flexibility –Compared to fiscal policy monetary policy can be quickly altered. The buying & selling of bonds can occur on a daily basis. 2. Isolation from political pressures – because the Board of Governors serve 14 year terms. They can enact unpopular policies which might get a member of Congress fired, but is best for our economy’s health. 3. Success since the 1980s – a tight money policy helped bring inflation from 13.5% in 1980 to 3.2% in 1983. An easy money policy helped the economy recover from the 2000 recession. Shortcomings of Monetary Policy Kiss my tail! I wont drink! Cyclical Asymmetry “You can lead a horse To water but you can’t make him drink” An easy money policy during depression does not guarantee that banks will give out loans if people don’t have jobs. Does not account for Velocity of money; During inflation, when the Fed restrains the money supply, velocity may increase. During a recession, when the Fed increases the money supply, the public may hold more money due to lower interest rates & fear. Less Control by the Fed in future; Increased global banking may led to policies that are inappropriate for domestic monetary policy. The End