Project Completion Report
Please submit through your APEC Secretariat Program Director within 2 months of project completion.
SECTION A: Project profile
Project number & title :
Time period covered
in report:
Committee / WG / Fora:
Project Overseer Name /
Organization / Economy:
CTI SCSC 37/2010T
APEC SCSC Strategic Education Program for Trade Facilitation - Phase 3:
Exchange Program for Higher Education
Date submitted: 27 Jan 2012
Jan 2011
CTI/SCSC
Mr. Sang-Un JIN
Korean Agency for Technology and Standards
SECTION B: Project report and reflection
Briefly answer each of the questions below. Section B should be a maximum of 2-3 pages, inclusive of
the questions and tables provided.
1. Project description: In 3-4 sentences, describe the project and its main objectives.
This project is designed promote education programs about standardization at university level in the region. The
exchange program will include 1) a special workshop to share perspectives and practices at university level education
programs on standardization, and operate 2) trial program in eight individual universities within the region to trigger
standardization education programs and information exchange in practice.
2. Meeting your objectives: Describe how the project went, with reference to the objectives laid out in
your project proposal. Include any major changes to your project as proposed and any problems or
obstacles that you encountered and how you overcame them.
This project has been successfully completed on time as planned.
First, the special joint workshop was held in Washington, D.C., on February 28, 2011 "Opportunities and Challenges for
Education on Standardization in Universities" was a joint meeting of the APEC Subcommittee's Project Advisory Group
on Education and ANSI's Committee on Education. In total, more than 100 leaders from government agencies, industry,
and prominent universities from APEC economies were in attendance to discuss strategies for more effective standards
education in the Asia-Pacific region. This workshop was co-chaired by Korea (Mr. Donggeun Choi, KSA) and the US
(Mr. Erik Puskar, NIST). This workshop lunch and reception was sponsored by ANSI, UL, Qualcomm, and Microsoft.
The workshop has two keynote speeches and four panel discussions.
Second, trial program was participated by fourteen universities (originally planned by eight universities) and the outcome
is published as a guideline casebook in October 2011. The objective of this guideline, titled ‘Teaching about
Standardization in Universities: Past Experiences and Lessons Learned’, is to provide more practical comments and the
lessons learned from trial implementation programs for education programs about standardization in higher education in
the APEC region. This casebook can also be used in the senior level of the undergraduate program as well as for
professional training of business managers and government officials. This casebook is an outcome of the APEC project
CTI 37/2010T jointly funded by the APEC and Korean Agency for Technology and Standards (KATS). Eight
universities in Korea were funded by KATS while six universities in other economies are funded by APEC project
funding for their course operation. The project to develop this casebook was proposed and managed by the Korean
Standards Association (KSA).
3. Project evaluation: Describe how you evaluated the project and provide some details on the results of
the evaluation (e.g. participant evaluation, peer review of publication, measurement of indicators,
statistics demonstrating use of outputs etc.).
This casebook will provide future teachers and interested standardization- related organizations with details of education
programs on standardization. Each chapter contains a case report from one particular university, and therefore, this book
has 14 chapters of trial programs. Each chapter contains syllabus, class summary, course operation strategy, student
characteristics, key references, feedback from students, main activities of the class, and most importantly lessons learned.
Additionally, many of these chapters include extracted sample essays, case studies, and/or presentations by both students
and lecturers. Chapters are alphabetically sorted by the name of the contributing universities.
4. Key findings: Describe one or two examples of important findings arising from the project (e.g. results
from surveys or case studies, insights provided by participants or experts, policy recommendations,
roadblocks to progress on an issue etc.).
APEC SCSC Members appreciated the outcomes of the projects, and the key finding of each university are described in
the guideline above.
5. Next steps: Describe any follow-up steps or projects that you recommend. Have you already planned
or begun these? What role could APEC play in any follow-up?
APEC SCSC is now discussing about next step for the years of 2012-2016. The SCSC considers developing good
standards practices (GSP), which show good cases about standards development and deployment.
6. Feedback for the Secretariat: Do you have any suggestions for more effective management of projects
in the future? Any assessment of consultants, experts or participants that you would like to share?
(The Secretariat collates and examines feedback to identify trends for ongoing evaluation of our project
management and/or communications systems.)
7. Participant information: Please provide details, where applicable. Insert rows as needed.
Economy
# male
# female
Details
Other:
8. Outputs: Please provide details, where applicable. Change headings or insert rows as needed.
# planned
# actual
# of workshops / events
1
1
# of publications distributed
1
1
Details
2011 Joint Meeting of
the APEC CTI/SCSC and ANSI
# of CDs distributed
# of websites created
Other:
SECTION C: Budget
Attach a detailed breakdown of the APEC- provided project budget, including:
 Planned costs (using most recently approved budget figures): 59,500 USD
 Actual expenditures: 54,074 USD
 Variance notes: no budget line is under-spent 20%
SECTION D: Appendices or additions
Please attach any of the following. This information will help us better understand your project, support
overseers of similar projects and plan for future projects.



List of experts or consultants utilised, with job titles and contact details
see the Annex 2 (participating university consultants)
List of participants, with job titles and contact details
see the attached Annex 1 (workshop agenda)
Event agendas:
see chapter 15 of the Guideline.



Links to any relevant websites or online material (e.g. reports, resources created):
see www.wisestandard.org
Results of participant feedback or other project evaluation (raw and/or analysed)
Any other relevant information or resources that would help us learn more about your project
FOR APEC SECRETARIAT USE ONLY APEC comments: Were APEC project guidelines followed? Could
the project have been managed more effectively or easily by the PO?
No comments
Annex 1. Workshop Agenda
Joint Meeting of the
Subcommittee on Standards and Conformance’s Project Advisory Group on Education
and the
American National Standards Institute’s Committee on Education
“Opportunities and Challenges for Education on Standardization in Universities”
Ronald Reagan Building and International Trade Center
1300 Pennsylvania Avenue, Washington, DC, United States
February 28, 2011
8:00am - 8:30 Registration
8:30am - 8:45am
Introduction and Welcome by the Conference Co-Chairs
Mr. Dongguen CHOI, SCSC Project Advisory Group on Education and
the Korean Standards Association, Korea
Mr. Erik PUSKAR, ANSI Committee on Education
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), United States
8:45am -9:15am
Keynote Address
Mr. S. Joe BHATIA, President and CEO,
American National Standards Institute (ANSI), United States
9:15am – 10:30am
Panel 1: Voices of Industry, Government and University: Why
Standards Education Now?
This discussion will focus on needs and perspectives of business,
policy makers and academia from APEC Economies
Moderator:
Dr. Stephen KWAN, College of Business
San Jose State University, United States
Mr. Dan BEJNAROWICZ, Director of College of Safety Engineering
Underwriters Laboratory University, United States
Dr. Young Kyun KIM, Professor
Korea University, Seoul, Korea
Dr. Francisco Ramos GÓMEZ (Invited)
Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), Mexico
Dr. Wang YIYI, Director (Invited)
Education and Training Department
CNIS , China
10:30am -11:00am
Coffee Break
11:00am-12:30pm
Panel 2: Mechanics of Developing a University Level Standards
Education Program
5
This session would focus on mechanisms for sharing and validating
content at the university level (such as peer review, curriculum
delivery, textbook selection process) and on research activities and
topics on standardization
Moderator:
Dr. Bruce HARDING, Professor, Mechanical Engineering
Technology, Purdue University, United States
Mr. Donald E. PURCELL, J.D. Adjunct Faculty, Catholic University
School of Engineering Management Program, United States
Mr. Kenneth R. KRECHMER, Lecturer
University of Colorado, United States
Mr. Hajime YAMADA
Department of Economics in Tokyo University, Japan
Ms. Dewi Odjar Ratna KOMALA
Deputy Chairman for Information & Promotion of Standardization
Badan Standardisasi Nasional (BSN), Indonesia
Dr. Sergio ALCOCER de CASTRO, Secretary General (Invited)
Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), Mexico
Mr. Jose Carlos FLORES, Director
Institute for Quality of Catholic University
Peru
12:30pm-2:00pm
Luncheon
Luncheon Keynote
Dr. Patrick GALLAGHER, Under Secretary of Commerce for
Standards and Technology and Director, National Institute of
Standards and Technology (NIST), United States
2:00pm-3:30pm
Panel 3: Opportunities and Challenges in Standards Education
In this session, participants would discuss potential opportunities and
hurdles in how to introduce educational programs to meet diverse
needs of stakeholders, including how teaching material can best
address issues on which there are a diversity of views, such as
standards and intellectual property.
.
Moderator:
Mr. Clark SILCOX, Legal Counsel,
National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA), United
States
Ms. Monica BARONE, Senior Legal Counsel
QUALCOMM Incorporated United States
Mr. Brad BIDDLE, Legal Counselor, Intel
Adjunct Professor, Arizona State University, United States
Mr. George BARKER
Director, Centre for Law and Economics
Australia National University, Australia
6
Ms. Bonnie ROSE, President
CSA Standards, Canada
3:30pm-3:45pm
Coffee Break
3:45pm-5:00pm
Panel 4: Standards are Vital: Business, Legal, and Policy
Implications and Knowledge Transfer
This session would include a discussion of current topics and
inclusion of standards-related education in the curriculum of Business,
Legal, Public Policy as well as Engineering
Moderator:
Mr. Steven M. MILLS, Senior Architect
Hewlett-Packard Company
President IEEE Standards Association, United States
Ms. Julia DOHERTY, Chair, APEC Subcommittee on Standards and
Conformance and Senior Director, WTO and Multilateral Affairs
Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) United
States
Mr. Stephen MUTKOSKI, Senior Standards Strategist
Microsoft Corporation, United States
Economy,
(Japanese
(Pacific Area
Mr. Juichi NAGANO
Director, International Standards Strategy, METI (Ministry of
Trade and Industry) & Deputy Secretary General, JISC
Industrial Standards Committee) Secretary, PASC
Standards Congress) Japan
Dr. Wilfried HESSER,
Helmut-Schmidt-Universität
Universität der Bundeswehr Hamburg, Germany
Mr. Dongguen CHOI, SCSC Project Advisory Group on Education and
the Korean Standards Association, Korea
5:00pm-5:15pm
Concluding Remarks
Mr. Dongguen CHOI, APEC Project Advisory Group on Education,
Korean Standards Association, Korea
Mr. Erik PUSKAR, ANSI Committee on Education
National Institute of Standards and Technology, United States
5:30pm – 7:00pm
ANSI Hosted Reception
7
Annex 2. Trial Exchange Program – Selected Universities for Contracting
A2.1 APEC Funding - 8 Universities
University Information
Economy
no.
1
P.R.China
University
Course information
Department
Professor
/College
in Charge
Course Title
Level
Final
Assessment
China Jiliang
(two majors) business
Name: Song Mingshun
International
Undergraduate+
1. Approve for 5,000 USD
University (CJLU)
management or
Position/Title: Vice president &
Trade and
Master
funding (APEC)
(www.cjlu.edu.cn)
international trade
Professor
Standardizatio
Email: smsqm@cjlu.edu.cn
n
Phone: +86-571-86836008
2
3
Japan
Japan
Waseda
Global business and
Name: Takuro Sato
Global
Undergraduate+
1. Approve for 5,000 USD
University
standardization
Master
funding (APEC)
Master
1. Approve for 5,000 USD
Position/Title: Professor
business and
(www.waseda.jp/
Email: t-sato@waseda.jp
standardizatio
top/index-j.html)
Phone: +81-3-5286-9839
n
Kanazawa
Graduate Program in
Name: Yukiko Kamijo
Basics of
Institute of
Systems for Intellectual
Position/Title: Associate Professor,
Technical
Technology (KIT)
Creation (Graduate School
Patent Attorney
Standardizatio
(www.kanazawa-
of Engineering)
Email: kamijo@kanazawa-it.ac.jp
n1
it.ac.jp/tokyo)
4
Vietnam
funding (APEC)
Phone: +81-3-5777-2227
The National
Department of Business
Name: Prof. Nguyen Dinh Phan
Quality
Economics
Management
Position/Title: Chairman of The NEU
Management
University
Email: phannd@neu.edu.vn
(www.neu.edu.vn
Phone: 0913213160
Undergraduate
1. Approve for 5,000 USD
funding (APEC)
)
8
5
Peru
Pontificia
Insitituto para la Calidad
Name: M.Sc. José Carlos Flores
International
Specialized
1. Approve for 5,000 USD
Universidad
(Quality Institute)
funding (APEC)
Position/Title: Director
Trade and
Course (open
Católica del Perú
Email: jfores@pucp.edu.pe
Standardizatio
for graduate
(www.pucp.edu.p
Phone: (511) 6262267
n
students)
e/calidad)
6
Indonesia
Trisakti
(15)
Industrial Management
Prof. Syamsir Abduh
Management
Master
1. Approve for 5,000 USD
University
the_abduh2006@yahoo.co.id
of Technology
(30)
funding (APEC)
(www.trisakti.ac.i
62215663232 Ext. 8421
and
d)
 Upgrade for
Innovation
5,000 USD funding
Strategy:
Quality
Management
and
Standardizatio
n
7
Brunei
Universiti Brunei
BUSINESS &
Name: Dr. Yong, Chee Tuan
Innovation
Master
2. Approve for 2,500 USD
Darussalam
Darussalam
MANAGEMENT
Position/Title: Senior Lecturer
Management
(15)
funding (APEC)
(www.ubd.edu.bn
Email: cheetuan.yong@ubd.edu.bn
and
)
Phone: +673-8723483
Standardizatio
n
8
Indonesia
University of
Diponegoro
Industrial Engineering
Name: Bambang Purwanggono
Introduction
Undergraduate
2. Approve for 2,500 USD
Position/Title: Vice Dean
to
(60)
funding (APEC)
Email: purwanggono@undip.ac.id;
Standardizatio
purwanggono@yahoo.com
n
 Upgrade for 5,000 USD
Phone: +62247460053
9
A2.2 Korea Self-Funding - 8 Universities
University Information
Economy
no.
1
Korea
University
Department
Professor
/College
in Charge
Course Title
Hanyang
Business Administration
Name: Seo, Hwan-Joo
Strategy of
University
(College of Economics and
Position/Title: Associate Professor
technological
(www.hanyang.ac.
Management)
Email: seohwan@hanyang.ac.kr_
innovation and
Phone: 82-31-400-5638
Standardizatio
kr)
Final
Course information
Assessment
Level
Ph.D
1. Accept for 5,000 USD funding
(Korea)
n
2
Korea
Korea University
Electronics & Information
Name: Kang, Byung-Goo
Special Issues
Engineering
Position/Title: Professor
in Conformity
Email: bgkang@korea.ac.kr_
Testing and
Phone: 82-41-860-1562
Standardizatio
Master
1.Accept for 5,000
USD funding (Korea)
n
3
4
Korea
Korea
Kookmin
Elective Course for All
Name: Hyung-gin Kim
Future Society
University
Majors
Position/Title: Associate Professor
and
Email: heejinmelb@yonsei.ac.kr
Standardizatio
Phone: +82-2-2123-3288
n
Ewha Womans
MBA (Masters of Business
Name: Yang, Hee-Dong
Management
University
Administration)
Position/Title: Full professor
of Technology
Email: hdyang@ewha.ac.kr
and
Phone: 02-3277-3582
Intellectual
(www.ewha.ac.kr)
Undergraduate
1. Accept for 5,000 USD funding
(Korea)
Master
1. Accept for 2,500 USD funding
(Korea)
Properties :
Case Projects
on
10
Standardizatio
n and
Innovation
5
Korea
Korea National
Department of Technology
Name: Sangbong YI
Research on
University of
Education (College of
Position/Title: Professor
Instructional
Education (KNUE)
Secondary Education)
Email: sbyi@knue.ac.kr
Materials for
Phone: (office) +82 43-230-3759
Technology
(www.knue.ac.kr)
(Mobile). +82 10-3117-3759
6
Korea
Yonsei University
Master+Ph.D
2. Accept for 2,500 USD funding
(Korea)
Education
International Management
Name: Heejin Lee
Electronic
and International Trade &
Position/Title: Professor
Commerce
Finance
Email: heejinmelb@yonsei.ac.kr
and
Phone: +82-2-2123-3288
Standardizatio
Master
2. Accept for 2,500 USD funding
(Korea)
n
7
Korea
Choongang
Business Administration
University
Name: Taeha Kim
IT
Position/Title: Associate Professor
Management
Email: taehakim@chooang.ac.kr
(and
Phone: +82-2-2123-3288
Standardizatio
Ph.D
2. Accept for 2,500 USD funding
(Korea)
n)
8
Korea
Hankuk University
Dept. of Industrial &
Name: Kim, Moon-Soo
Management
of Foreign Studies
Management Engineering
Position/Title: Professor
Strategy for
(HUFS)
(College of Engineering)
Email: kms@hufs.ac.kr
Indusrial
Phone: +82-31-330-4979
Systems
(www.hufs.ac.kr)
Master+Ph.D
2. Accept for 2,500 USD funding
(Korea)
11