Research Themes Page 1 Meetings and Hotels: A Review of Leading Research Themes Carole Sox Doctoral Student University of South Carolina/School of Hotel, Restaurant and Tourism Management Columbia, SC USA soxc@mailbox.sc.edu Sheryl Kline, Ph.D. Associate Dean University of South Carolina/School of Hotel, Restaurant and Tourism Management klines@mailbox.sc.edu Sandy Strick, Ph.D. Interim Department Chair University of South Carolina/School of Hotel, Restaurant and Tourism Management strick@mailbox.sc.edu Research Themes Page 2 Meetings and Hotels: A Review of Leading Research Themes Abstract This article provides a review of the literature that has been published in the field of meetings and hotels over the past 10 years. This effort is particularly valuable in the sense that it illustrates that research is still rather limited within this area, which gives room for many topics to explore for future research. Specifically, 22 peer-reviewed articles have been published in academic journals over the past decades that are specific to topics on both meetings and hotels. Within these articles, six main themes have been identified and the articles have been categorized accordingly. These themes include customer satisfaction; legal considerations; room occupancy; sales; employee perspectives; and industry analysis and impact. This article will summarize the research, explore and outline the themes that have emerged, and identify areas for further research. Introduction The meetings, expositions, events and conventions industry (MEEC) (Fenich, 2010) has a significant impact on local, state and national economies (Lee & Back, 2005). The 2010 Economic Significance of Meetings to the U.S. Economy study recently released its findings and stated that the meetings industry (within the United States) directly supports approximately 1.7 million jobs, $60 billion in labor revenue, $14.3 billion in federal tax revenue and $11.3 billion in state and local tax revenue (PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP., 2011). In 2009, 205 million people attended 1.8 million meetings (including corporate meetings, incentive meetings, conferences, conventions, trade shows and exhibitions.) Out of those 1.8 million meetings, 1.3 million were corporate meetings and the overall spending contribution to the US economy was approximately $263 billion. This includes meeting planning, meeting production, and travel and tourism related expenses (PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP., 2011). This information highlights the important role that the MEEC industry plays within our economic environment. In fact, these numbers are projected to increase each year as additional individuals, corporations and countries further acknowledge this economic impact (Eisenstodt, 2010). Highlighting the economic impact of the MEEC industry offers a foundation for the significance of research within this area. Research Themes Page 3 Specific to hotels, 85% of meetings in 2009 were held at venues with lodging. Out of the 1.8 million meetings within the year, 250 million room nights were generated by meetings and out of the 205 million meeting participants, 117 million were located domestically and travelled over 50 miles or stayed the night when attending their meeting. Those travelling more than 50 miles accounted for 83 million meeting participants and international travelers accounted for 5 million participants (PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP., 2011). These figures indicate the impact that meetings have within the hotel arena and offer additional justification for further research with regard to meetings held within hotels. The purpose of this paper is to propose a thorough review of all of the academic research that has been accomplished with regard to meetings in hotels over the past 10 years. Researchers have investigated this area through several different avenues and approaches. While numerous topics have been covered over the past 10 years, there are 6 leading themes that appear throughout the academic research in which the majority of articles can be categorized. These themes are illustrated in Table 1. The Literature While the meetings industry has a significant economic impact on hotels (PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP., 2011), there does not appear to be a significant amount of research contributing to this area. In fact, within the past 10 year, the 22 articles that have been found related to this topic are categorized in Table 1 below. Table 1 Literature Review for Meetings in Hotels Topics Covered Author Customer Satisfaction Lee et al.,(2005); Lee, T. (2009); Oh et al. (2009); Knutson et al. (2009); Kuo et al. (2010) Campbell & Shaw (2000); Israeli & Barkan (2003); Choi & Punishment (2010) Phillips & Geddie (2005); Hilliard & Baloglu (2008); and Chen et al. (2007) Breiter et al. (2004); Toh et al. (2005); Fenich et al. (2009); Soyoung et al. (2010); Toh & Foster (2010); Kapoor et al. (2006) Soyoung & Miyoung (2010); Singh et al. (2010); Salazar et al. (2001) Gregory et al. (2005); Noone & Hultberg (2011) Employee Perspectives Industry Analysis/Impact Legal Considerations Room Occupancy Sales Research Themes Page 4 The methods in which these articles were found include searching the following platforms and databases: EBSCO host: o Hospitality and Tourism Complete (University of South Carolina) o Business Source Premiere (University of South Carolina) Google Scholar Specific Review of Hospitality Journals including: Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly; International Journal of Hospitality Management; Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research; International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management; Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Education; Journal of Hospitality & Leisure Marketing; International Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Administration; Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management; and Journal of Convention and Events Tourism. Searches were conducted for meetings, meeting planners, conferences, conference organizers, conventions, groups, SMERF, events, site selection, venues, sales and destinations, all with hotels, motels or lodging as the additional research components. Searches were also conducted for meetings in conjunction with literature review and/or research. While numerous articles appear within these searches that include hotels and meeting as one factor within a study, this paper attempts to focus on the publications that used hotels and meetings as the main focus of their topic choice. As thorough as the search process was, it is still possible that there are articles that may have been missed. These articles could include those that have been presented at conferences or those published in journals that are more narrowly indexed. This paper serves to give readers an overall picture of publications on this topic with the main highlights of each article included (Barrows and Ridout, 2010). There will also be a focus on each category mentioned and examined by those articles and included within those topics. It should be noted that articles have been included that could easily Research Themes Page 5 fit into multiple categories; however, they have been categorized into one area while attempting to determine the best fit (Barrows and Ridout, 2010). Customer Satisfaction The literature that has been published in the area of satisfaction covers numerous topics related to the customer perspective. The articles that have been included within this section address this topic by identifying the customer as either the meeting planner or the meeting attendee. Lee et al. (2005) article reviews the selling process between the meeting planner and the hotel salesperson. This study surveyed the members of Meeting Professionals International (MPI) and based on that data, created a model examining the “key relationship selling constructs in a meeting planner/hotel salesperson context” ( Lee, et al. 2005). This study concluded that there were certain characteristics of a salesperson, such as power, expertise and willingness that have an impact on the planner/salesperson relationship that moves the meeting forward. In another study pertaining directly to meeting planners, Lee (2009) addresses the needs of the meeting planners and the needs of the hotel’s hosting the meetings. This study also explores operational issues that hotels hosting meetings commonly face. The findings of this study conclude that there are definite differences between the meeting planner and the hosting hotels with regard to requirements necessary and the existing problems that occur when hosting a meeting. Another study published in 2009 (Oh et al.), explores the direct and indirect consequences of a hotel's meeting service performance and breaks the meeting process into four phases, including sales, pre-event, event, and post-event, of service performance. This study determined that the event-phase performance was most critical to the overall satisfaction of the meeting planners holding meetings in hotel venues. While these studies examine various aspects of the meeting planner and hotel venue relationship, they both underscore the importance of this relationship to the overall process of meeting planning within hotels. The relationship between the meeting planner and the hosting hotel requires the attention of both parties involved. Since this relationship is important to the parties on both ends of the transaction and can have a large dollar impact (Clark & McLeary, 1995), exploring and understanding this relationship can offer benefits to all involved. For the meeting Research Themes Page 6 planning organization, this relationship can have an impact on the final venue decision (Lee, et al. 2005) which can have a large influence on the number of attendees to the meeting which can help determine the success (or failure) of the meeting (Lee & Back, 2005). The suppliers, or host venues, need to understand the meeting planner/host venue relationship in order to continually position themselves to attract more meetings to their venue (Lee & Back, 2005). The category of customer satisfaction also includes those articles with research pertaining to the hotel meeting attendee as the customer. The meeting attendee has also been explored from various angles. In 2009, Knutson, Beck, Kim and Cha address the guest experience at a hotel and conference center. This study concludes that there are four main areas that impact guest satisfaction including convenience, incentive, benefit and environment. In 2010, Kuo, Chen and Lin explore how hotel service characteristics impact customer satisfaction at international conferences. This study surveyed 350 conference participants in Taiwanese hotels and the findings offer information to assist with future strategic marketing and the training of personnel to further enhance customer satisfaction. Again, while there are many articles available on hotel guest satisfaction, there appear to be only a handful of academic articles that pertain to guest satisfaction with regard to meetings in hotels. These studies can be emphasized by the many industry articles that are topic related, such as the article “Meetings on a Grand Scale” which addresses customer satisfaction at meetings in hotels and credits the relationship that is built between the salesperson and the meeting planner as one key to success (Gines, K. 2007). Legal Considerations Legal issues are found in almost every part of the meeting planning process (Hilliard, 2010). Some of the legal issues that pertain to meeting planning include contracts; local, state and national laws; employers and employees; the entertainment chosen; and the risk associated with the event. In almost every part of the meeting planning and execution process, there is an opportunity for legal complications (Hilliard, 2010). In fact, within the MEEC industry, legal factors are becoming increasingly important (Hilliard, 2010). Within the theme of legal considerations when reviewing literature (for the past 10 years), the main focus appears to be various aspects of meeting and hotel contracts. One of the main topics Research Themes Page 7 investigated within the contracts revolves around the attrition clause. Attrition is defined as the “difference between the actual numbers of sleeping rooms picked up and the number or formula agreed to in terms of the facilities contract” (Fenich, 2010). In 2004, Breiter, Vannucci, Kline and Gregory explored the areas of concern that meeting planners face with regard to the attrition clause found within meeting contracts. Specifically addressed was the issue of meeting participants booking rooms outside of the meeting planners room block impacting the attrition clause within the contract. This study surveyed 143 meeting planners and found that only one-third paid attrition damages when the room block was not filled. In 2005, Toh, DeKay and Lasprogata expanded this study. This study took a qualitative approach to the data and interviewed 25 hotel employees with regard to the topic of the attrition clause and how it is addressed with meeting planners. This study found that although the attrition clauses are included in the contracts, they are rarely enforced. The study found that the reason that these clauses are not often enforced was due to the potential loss of future business (Toh et al. 2005). In other words, the hotels did not enforce the attrition clause because they feared that it would impact the meeting planners bringing future business to their location (Toh et al., 2005). In 2009, Fenich, Chacko and Taylor reviewed “Important Elements of Hotel-Meeting Planner Contracts” and further expanded the topic. This study enlarged the scope of the topic beyond just the attrition clause and reviewed the entire contract (including the attrition clause). Within this study, reviewing the entire contract led to a creation of a 9-item checklist. The study found that there were many disparities between hotel contracts for meetings. This study also addressed the recommendations of the Accepted Practices Exchange (APEX) for meeting contracts (Fenich et al., 2009). In 2010, Soyoung, Hilliard and Jin expanded this topic again to include international contract clauses within hotel contracts for meetings. This study acknowledged the difference in contracts with regard to the country in which the meeting was being planned. The study focused on the cities of Shanghai, Washington, D. C. and Toronto. The study found that there were significant differences within the contracts for meetings specific to each country. The clauses of Research Themes Page 8 cancellation, attrition, force majeure, disability accommodations, dispute resolutions and deposits were all reviewed and compared. When compared, the study found that these clauses were significantly different according to country (Soyoung et al., 2010). Another study in 2010 by Toh and Foster examined a case between the Hyatt Corporation and the Women’s International Bowling Congress that went to court over contract disparities. This study examined the results of poorly written contracts between hotels and meeting planners. It specifies that the attrition clause should work for both the hotel and the client. This case is one of the few cases involving attrition clauses that went to court. Backtracking a few years, but falling outside of the “contract” review, Kapoor, Powell and Abbott (2006) explored the area of “Conventional Disputes, Unconventional Resolutions: An Analysis of Dispute Resolution in the Meetings, Incentives, Conventions and Exhibition Industry”. This study explored the relationship between the hotel industry and the convention industry. Specifically, it explored the disputes that take place within these relationships and how they are resolved (Kapoor et al, 2006). While the literature focus within this theme appears to center on some aspect of the contract, it is important to note that there are many areas outside of the contract that impact the meetings industry, and specifically impact the meeting/hotel dynamic (Hilliard, 2010). This leaves significant voids within the research that has been done in this area to date. Room Occupancy Meetings are not a hotel’s primary profit center, (Phelan, 2010). The main profit center in most hotels is the sale of overnight rooms (Phelan, 2010). In fact, meeting space in hotels is often considered to be a loss leader (Phelan, 2010). Meetings, therefore, are often used to attract customers to the hotel so that they will also stay overnight. With this in mind, several researchers have investigated room occupancy at hotels with regard to meetings. Two articles written in 2010 explore the topic of room occupancy. The first, a study by Soyoung and Miyoung (2010), explores the connection between meetings at convention centers and the impact on overnight stays in nearby hotels. This study reviews the performance of the convention center and the relationship with the demand for hotel room nights. The study found that the quantity of allotted meeting space, in addition to other performance factors of the Research Themes Page 9 convention centers, directly impacted the demand for hotel room nights. The findings of this study are useful to practitioners in that they can use this information to better develop their revenue management and marketing plans (Soyoung and Miyoung, 2010). In the second study involving this topic, Singh, Wright and Hayle (2010) explore the role that events play in the occupancy of hotels in Jamaica. Again, similar to the previous study, the relationship between events and overnight stays in hotels is examined. This study specifically reviews events taking place within the hotels (Singh et al., 2010) whereas the previous study reviewed how meetings at convention centers impact local occupancy rates (Soyoung & Miyoung, 2010). This study includes a review of economic factors impacting the hotels such as how events influence the length of stay at a hotel. Seasonality was also considered within this study (Singh et al, 2010). Salazar, Semoon and Girard (2001) explore the connection and relationships found between attendance at special events and conventions, hotel room occupancy rates and attendance at local attractions. While this study is broader in scope than the previous two studies discussed, it specifically looks at hotels, events and attractions within Mobile, Alabama (Salazar et al. 2010). Using factor analysis and regression analysis, they determined that there is a direct correlation between the events, attractions and conventions held within Mobile, Alabama and the increase in hotel occupancy rates within that city (Salazar et al., 2010). While the majority of meetings tend to take place on the property of the meeting participants (conference rooms, office spaces, etc), the second most popular place for meetings to take place is within hotels (Phelan, 2010). This fact paired in conjunction with the economic impact that meetings within hotels have on room occupancy, set the stage for various areas in which further research can be explored. Sales While at first glance the 2005 study by Lee et al. could easily fit into this category (sales), the authors have distinguished the selling relationship between the meeting planner and the sales person as falling into customer satisfaction while the specific theme of sales is intended to include those articles that pertain to revenue management with regard to group sales. Research Themes Page 10 In 2007, Gregory, Kline and Breiter reviewed how the group sales process has utilized online selling options such as the Internet and Websites. This study concludes that while these tools are being utilized within the industry, convention hotel managers do not see an increase in revenue from these tools. Noone and Hultberg (2011) analyze “The Role of the Revenue Management and Sales Functions in Group Revenue Management”. They explore the relationship between the revenue management department and the sales department in hotels and conclude that there are several enhancements that can be made to assist with improving the relationship between the two (Noone & Hultberg, 2011). The relationship is specifically examined with regard to group sales opportunities, thus it includes meetings within hotels. Two of the recommendations that came from this study included additional training and further education as necessary components of staff training (Noone & Hultberg, 2011). Employee Perspective Another theme that emerged when articles over the last ten years were identified and compared appeared to fall under the category of employee perspective. Within the category of employee perspective, articles were identified that explored how employees are impacted by meetings and events within hotels. In 2000, Campbell and Shaw conducted a pilot study in which the satisfaction of meeting planners was reviewed in conjunction with hotel employee interaction. This study highlighted the relationships that the meeting planners develop with the hotel employees as they go through the meeting planning process (Campbell & Shaw, 2000). In 2003, Isreali and Barkan published a study in which hotel events were reviewed with regard to their impact on employee satisfaction. This study focused specifically on events planned for employees and concluded that these events added benefit to the overall employment experience (Isreali & Barkan, 2003). Employee events allow for social interaction with peers and colleagues that assists in job satisfaction (Isreali & Barkan, 2003). Another area within the category of employee perspective was explored in 2010 when Choi and Dickson researched how management-training meetings impact hotel turnover and satisfaction. Research Themes Page 11 While this article could easily fall under a separate category for articles on management with regard to hotels, it does seem appropriate to include it within this area since it directly discusses training meetings and their impact on hotel employees. This study reviewed the benefits that management-training meetings have on the rate of turnover among employees and their job satisfaction. The study concluded that training meetings and programs held in hotels could lower employee turnover and improve customer satisfaction. Within this theme internal meetings/events are addressed as a way to increase job satisfaction (Isreali & Barkan, 2003). At a time when companies are cutting back due to budget restraints, our industry could benefit from information that provides justification for company meetings and offers a return on investment. If internal meetings are related to job satisfaction, we could see a true benefit from these efforts not only within the companies, but also within the industry. Industry Analysis and Impact The last theme identified, industry analysis and impact, is really a catchall for the literature that did not fall perfectly into a specific category other than following the pattern of analyzing specific topics that had a direct impact on the meetings industry. Phillips and Geddie (2005) analyze meetings on cruise ships. Specifically, the literature reviews the factors that influence meeting planners to choose a cruise ship for a meeting over a hotel. This study explores how cruise ships are now better positioning themselves in the market to obtain a share of the corporate and incentives meetings that take place each year (Phillips & Geddie, 2005). The second article within the category discusses security issues within hotels for meetings (Hilliard & Baloglu, 2008.) This article reviews the physical features of a hotel in terms of safety and investigates how security influences a meeting planners’ decision to choose a hotel as a meeting location. The study concluded that there are three dimensions to security features within hotels, including visible security features, training of staff and general safety features. The study also reviewed the perception of meeting planners with regard to safety certifications and the meeting planners’ willingness to pay more for a certified hotel (Hilliard & Baloglu, 2008). Research Themes Page 12 In 2003, the SARS epidemic caused significant economic losses within the hotel industry. In a 2007 study by Chen, Jang and Kim, the economic losses were attributed to thousands of meeting cancellations that were a direct result of the epidemic (Chen et al., 2007). This study researched the impact that this epidemic had on the hotels in Taiwan. This study concluded that in order to avoid such economic losses in case of future epidemics, hotels should better advertise the situation as temporary as found by this research (Chen et al., 2007). Conclusion While six themes of research did emerge as this analysis of literature since 2000 was executed, it was surprising how little literature has been written with regard to meetings and hotels. This analysis provided an opportunity to recognize that there are ample prospects available for additional research within this area. The most literature found within the themes was conducted within the legal considerations category and most of that research was contract specific. It did appear that at least three of the studies conducted (Breiter et al., 2004; Toh et al. 200; Fenich et al., 2009), focused on the same topic, but were not necessarily built upon each other. In fact, Fenich cites Breiter (et al. 2004), and Toh and Foster (2010) site both Breiter (et al. 2004) and Toh (et al. 2005) within their articles. Within the (legal considerations) literature reviewed, attrition was either focused on or mentioned in the majority of the articles. Since 85% of meetings in 2009 were held at venues with lodging resulting in the generation of approximately 250 million room nights (PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP., 2011) the financial impact that meetings have on hotels is obviously significant. Based on this financial impact alone, future research is necessary within the area to benefit both the practitioners and academics working within hospitality. Suggestions for Future Research While there a numerous industry articles covering some aspect of meetings within hotels over the past ten years included in publications such as Convene; Meeting News; Successful Meetings; and Meetings and Conventions, there appears to be very little scholarly literature written within Research Themes Page 13 this area. In fact, the clear majority of citations within the scholarly articles that have been written to date are within industry magazines, trade publications and books. One example to further illustrate this point can be found within the Fenich (et al. 2009) study. Within this article, 31 references were cited and out of those, only 11 came from peered-reviewed publications. Within those 11, only 2 were articles written specifically about meetings within hotels. The current research leaves ample research opportunities when reviewing meetings and hotels. It appears that researchers interested within this area have many directions from which to choose in order to pursue research opportunities. While there is a bounteous supply of topics and areas to address, however, there appears to also be a gap in the literature with regard to theoretical underpinnings and framework (within the area of meeting in hotels). There are theories that have been applied to the meetings area of study and also to the hotel area of study, but few that work together to bridge or link these two areas. Future research could easily be expanded within any of these topics, and could easily venture outside of these topics as well. Within these topics, studies could be done to further advance the existing research or review topics that are currently missing. Some of these categories could also be combined for additional research opportunities. In this case one could combine customer satisfaction and room occupancy. For example, when room occupancy increases (due to large meeting in hotels) does customer satisfaction then decrease? Some additional areas for future research could include, but are not limited to, unique venues and hotel room occupancy impact; format change within hotel meetings in order to stay cutting edge to attract additional meetings to the hotel venue; and the impact of the increased convention sizes compared to the frequency of hotel meetings, and the economic impact that has on hotel occupancy rates (Phelan, 2010). Since the scope of literature from the year 2000 is so small, there is also great opportunity for research outside of the six categories identified. In a recent study conducted by Meeting Planners International (2010), some of the current trends of meeting planners include planning meetings closer to home. The study found that fewer meeting attendees are willing to travel to their meeting destinations, so this might be a good area to explore as this could directly impact hotel occupancy. The topic could be investiaged further by exploring attendee percentage change in correlation to travel distance to the meeting location. Research Themes Page 14 Another area that the MPI study (2010) uncovered as a current trend is the focus on hosting sustainable meetings. Interestingly, there did not appear to by any literature about sustainable issues with regard to meeting in hotels. This could easily open up a door for research opportunities, such as how do hotels alter current procedures when hosting a green meeting? Are (sustainable/green) meeting packages encouraged and or supported within hotels? Since this is a current focus, it would seem that it would be extremely valuable to have some literature available addressing the impact of sustainability within the meeting/hotel relationship. To conclude, there has been little research conducted and/or published exploring the area of meetings and hotels. The meetings, conventions, exhibitions and incentive travel industry support an estimated 1.7 million jobs just within the United States (Eisenstodt, 2010). This significant economic contribution supports further exploration of the meeting/hotel relationship which could have substantial benefits for both academics and practitioners. There is great potential for future research within this area. Research Themes Page 15 Reference List Barrows, C., & Ridout, M. (2010). Another Decade of Research in Club Management: A Review of the Literature in Academic Journals for the Period 1994-2005. Journal Of Hospitality Marketing & Management, 19(5), 421-463. Breiter, D., Vannucci, C., Kline, S., & Gregory, S. (2004). The Attrition Condition: What Hotel Sales People Sales People Need to Know. Cornell Hotel & Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 45(2), 158-169. Campbell, A., & Shaw, M. (2000). Measuring Meeting Planner Satisfaction with Hotel Employee Interactions: A Pilot Study. Journal of Convention & Exhibition Management, 2(2/3), 59. Chen, M., Jang, S., & Kim, W. (2007). The impact of the SARS outbreak on Taiwanese hotel stock performance: An event-study approach. International Journal Of Hospitality Management, 26(1), 200-212. Choi, Y. & Dickson, D. (2010). A case study into the benefits of management training programs: impacts on hotel employee turnover and satisfaction level. Journal of Human Resources in Hospitality & Tourism, 9(1), 103-116. Clark, J. D. & McLeary K. W. (1995). Influencing association’s site selection process. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 36 (2), 61-68. Eisenstodt, J. L. (2010). Introduction to the meetings, expositions, events and conventions industry. Fenich, G. Introduction to the Meetings, Expositions, Fenich, G. Introduction to the Meetings, Expositions, Events, and Conventions Industry. 341. Boston, MA. Pearson Learning Solutions. Fenich, G., Chacko, H., & Taylor, M. (2009). Important Elements of Hotel-Meeting Planner Contracts: An Exploratory Study. International Journal Of Hospitality & Tourism Administration, 10(4), 283-295. Gines, K. (2007). Meetings on a Grande Scale. Successful Meetings, 56(4), 89. Gregory, S. R., Kline, S. F., & Breiter, D. (2005). Group Sales and Marketing in Convention Hotels: Internet and Web Usage. Journal Of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 18(1), 67-77. Hilliard, T. W., & Baloglu, S. (2008). Safety and Security as Part of the Hotel Servicescape for Meeting Planners. Journal Of Convention & Event Tourism, 9(1), 15-34. Hilliard, T. (2010). Legal issues in the MEEC industry. Fenich, G. Introduction to the Meetings, Expositions, Events, and Conventions Industry. 1 – 22. Boston, MA. Pearson Learning Solutions. Research Themes Page 16 Israeli, A. A., & Barkan, R. (2003). The Impact of Hotel Social Events on Employee Satisfaction: A Case Study. Journal Of Human Resources In Hospitality & Tourism, 2(2), 23. Kapoor, P., Powell, P., & Abbott, J. (2006). Conventional Disputes, Unconventional Resolutions: An Analysis of Dispute Resolution in the Meetings, Incentives, Conventions, and Exhibition Industry. Journal Of Convention & Event Tourism, 8(3), 4570. Knutson, B. J., Beck, J. A., Kim, S., & Cha, J. (2009). Identifying the Dimensions of the Guest's Hotel Experience. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, 50(1), 44-55. Kuo, C., Chen, L., & Lin, S. (2010). Exploring the Relationship Between Hotel-Based Service Attribute Importance and Customer Satisfaction at International Conferences in Taiwan. Journal Of Convention & Event Tourism, 11(4), 293-313. Ladkin, A. (1999). Hotel general managers: A review of prominent research themes. International Journal of Tourism Research, 1, 167-193. Lee, M. J. & Back, K. J. (2005). A review of economic value drivers in convention and meeting management research. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management. 17(5), 409 – 420. Lee, S., Hung-Jen, S., & Dubinsky, A. J. (2005). Relationship selling in the meeting planner/hotel salesperson dyad. Journal Of Hospitality & Tourism Research, 29(4), 427447. Lee, T. (2009). The successful conference venue: perceptions of conference organizers and hotel managers. Event Management, 13(3), 171-180. MPI study looks at meeting trends. (2010). Canadian Travel Press, 42(19), 26 Noone, B. M., & Hultberg, T. (2011). Profiting through Teamwork: The Role of the Revenue Management and Sales Functions in Group Revenue Management. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, 52(4), 407-420. Oh, H., Kim, H., & Hong, K. (2009). A dynamic perspective of meeting planners' satisfaction: Toward conceptualization of critical relevancy. Tourism Management, 30(4), 471-482. Phelan, K. V. (2010). Meeting and convention venues. Fenich, G. Introduction to the Meetings, Expositions, Events, and Conventions Industry. 1 – 22. Boston, MA. Pearson Learning Solutions. Phillips, W., & Geddie, M. (2005). An Analysis of Cruise Ship Meetings: Factors InfluencingOrganization Meeting Planners to Select Cruise Ships over Hotels. Journal of Convention & Event Tourism, 7(2), 43-56. Research Themes Page 17 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. (2011). 2010 Economic Significance of Meetings to the U.S. Economy Study. Retrieved from Convention Industry Council’s website: www.conventionindustry,org/ResearchInfo/Econotudy/ESSExecSummary.aspxmicSigni gicanceS Salazar, John P., Semoon C., & Girard, T. C. (2001). Visitor Sharing Among County Attractions and Hotels. Journal of Hospitality & Leisure Marketing. 8 (1/2). 11 – 33. Singh, D. R., Wright, A., and Hayle, C. (2010). Factors influencing hotel occupancy in Jamaica: The role of events 1991-2008. Tourism Anaylsis, 15(3), 357-356. Soyoung, B., Hillard, T., & Hui, J. (2010). International hotel meeting contract clauses: a comparison of multiple destinations. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research, 34(3), 388-412. Soyoung, B., & Miyoung, K. (2010). The influence of convention center performance on hotel room nights. Journal of Travel Research. 49(3), 297-309. Toh, R. S., DeKay, F., & Lasprogata, G. (2005). Attrition clauses: outstanding issues and recommendations for meeting planners. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 24(1), 107-119. Toh, R. S.; Foster, T. N.., (2010). Hyatt Corporation v. Women's International Bowling Congress, Inc. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, 51(2), 231-237.