2012 Loras College Brian Kinney “THINK GLOBALLY, ACT LIKE MCDONALDS” Contents Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................ 2 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 3 Background of Brand ...................................................................................................................... 4 Definition of Global Brand ............................................................................................................. 7 The McDonalds Brand Diagram ................................................................................................. 7 Commentary on Global Brand Diagram ..................................................................................... 8 International Marketing efforts ....................................................................................................... 9 Standardization vs. Adaptation ................................................................................................... 9 Slogans .................................................................................................................................. 10 Olympic Games Involvement ............................................................................................... 10 Impact of Uncontrollable Forces On The Marketing Plan............................................................ 12 Economic Forces ....................................................................................................................... 12 Political & Legal Forces ........................................................................................................... 12 Cultural Forces .......................................................................................................................... 13 India ...................................................................................................................................... 13 China ..................................................................................................................................... 14 United States ......................................................................................................................... 16 Works Cited .................................................................................................................................. 19 1 Executive Summary McDonald’s has reached a level that other corporations can only dream of. What makes a brand truly global? What are the factors that cause a company to be successful not only in the domestic market but internationally? McDonald’s is a global corporate leader primarily because it has embraced two strategies: it has remained consistent to its core mission of providing a product based on value and efficiency, and it has embraced a robust and creative international marketing strategy that makes its products welcome from the affluent neighborhoods of Beverly Hills to the inner cities of the South American country of Brazil. 2 Introduction McDonalds hasn’t grown just by adapting to a different culture: McDonald’s has been at the forefront in adapting to the changing needs of its customers. For example, as consumers become more concerned about health, obesity, environmental footprint, and globalization, McDonald’s has altered its menu, its distribution and produce sources, and even incorporated green technology in the architecture of its restaurants. Throughout my research, I was able to see first-hand not only the impact that the McDonald’s brand on the domestic market of the United States, but their role in the globalization of the world. From a small fast service burger restaurant with no seating back in 1940, until the present day where they are located in 119 countries across the globe, enhancing the customer experience has always been their first priority (McDonald's Corporation). Their innovations are remarkable in both the products they offer as well as how they offer them. McDonald’s motto of “Think Globally, Act Locally” has allowed the company to maintain a consistent message across the world, but when necessary, they adapt to provide customers with the best locally-relevant experience. Through this school of thought, they are able to build the value of the brand and it is no mistake that when it comes to overall brand experience, McDonald’s is in a league of their own. Whether it is their presence in the Olympic Games, guest appearances by Ronald McDonald, or the always recognizable golden arches, the McDonald’s brand is impressive and embedded in consumers’ minds. This immense brand recognition is why I believe McDonald’s is 3 one of the most successful global brands not only in the past decade but one of the best of all time. Background of Brand McDonald’s began its journey towards becoming the world’s largest fast food restaurant world all that way back in 1955. Kroc saw an opportunity when he purchased the franchise from the McDonald brothers, Rich and Maurice, that it could be something special. He envisioned expanding the franchise all across America instead of just being located regionally. Expanding the brand was truly innovative because at the time fast food restaurants were only regionally located across the United States. No one had actually expanded their restaurant nationwide, but that was Kroc’s vision. In order to accomplish this nationwide expansion, he wanted to ensure that there was a standardized cooking process. By standardizing all processes no matter if you went to a McDonald’s in New York or in New Mexico, you were guaranteed to get the same great quality food. This standardized process of cooking made McDonald’s into a brand not only loved nationwide, but also globally. Kroc was also known as an extremely ethical businessman who kept the good of his customers as his main focus. Instead of following the trend of cost cutting methods, he instead focused on maintaining the best experience his customers could have. This excellent customer service base that Kroc laid out in the early days of McDonald’s has sustained the brand over the decades. Within ten years of the change of ownership, there were over 1,000 McDonald’s restaurants nationwide. Then in 1967, Kroc’s vision of expanding the restaurant worldwide was 4 brought to fruition as McDonald’s locations were opened in Canada as well as Puerto Rico. Today there are over 33,000 McDonald’s restaurants locations in 119 countries around the world. While the restaurant has expanded over the years and now includes over 100 menu options, McDonalds has never lost sight of the fact that the company’s roots go back to the burger and fries business. To better illustrate their brand presence worldwide, I have included the most recent BrandZ global brand rankings. BrandZ is a brand management tool that is based off of the world’s largest brand equity database. In the 2011 edition of the top 100 brands that was published by leading global research agency Milward-Brown, McDonalds was ranked 4th (MilwardBrown, 2011) . In more of a micro perspective, they hold such a dominant position in their industry that their brand is over five times more valuable than their closest competition, Subway. (Milward-Brown, 2011) 5 To further show how much of an impact their brand value has on global sales, the graph below shows global sales estimates for 2010 among fast food industry leaders (Kowitt, 2011). Also From 2008- 2010 alone, McDonalds was responsible for 90% of sales growth of the US fast food and fast casual industry (Kowitt, 2011). Global Sales 2010 (In Billions) 90 80 $77.4 70 60 McDonald's 50 KFC 40 Subway 30 20 $17.9 $15.2 $14.7 KFC Subway Burger King 10 0 McDonald's 6 Burger King Definition of Global Brand The McDonalds Brand Diagram BRAND BENEFITS Functional Provide body with food or drink Meeting place Familiar Keep on schedule BRAND SYMBOLS Emotional Joy Safety Acceptance Valued Righteousness Comfort BRAND FEATURES 7 Value Menu Wide variety McCafe Clean Consistent Breakfast Menu Globally located “I’m lovin’ it” Loyal Friendly Culturally Aware Caring On the go individual Problem Solver Family with kids Innovative On a budget Business Savvy Lacks time to prepare meals BRAND USER 24 hour DriveThru BRAND PERSONALITY BRAND PROMISE “To provide simple easy enjoyment to every customer at every visit.” Commentary on Global Brand Diagram In order to get the information I needed to fill out the brand diagram I needed to conduct primary research interview among my peers. I interviewed ten people in total with ages ranging from 21 to 56 to get their opinions on the fast food restaurant. I found that the younger people that I asked typically did not give answers that put McDonald’s in a positive light. It was only until I asked them if any experiences during their childhood where going to McDonald’s was a fond memory did I get a positive response. The few older individuals who I interviewed gave a different and more in-depth perspective. They believed that what McDonald’s was doing in the community was one of the reasons they felt good about visiting the restaurant as well as positive memories of the joy that it brought them to take their child there. The one area where I found to be very interesting was the typical brand user. McDonald’s is a unique place because it was be easy to say that the typical brand user of the restaurant is a certain demographic but that is not the case. What I have come to realize about McDonald’s is that they appeal to a very wide audience that vary in economic and cultural background. Although they perceived as a value restaurant that does not mean that they sacrifice quality. I believe there brand promise does justice on reiterating that no matter what type of consumer comes to their restaurant they ensure that they can provide them with enjoyment. 8 International Marketing efforts Standardization vs. Adaptation McDonald’s is continues to have great success globally due to its think globally, act locally philosophy. Being able to balance the two is essential to their success, and simply having standardized management processes is not enough. McDonalds succeeds because they firmly believe in the following: “The System” The alignment strength among the company, its franchisees and suppliers has been essential to McDonald’s success. This business model enables McDonald’s to deliver consistent, locally-relevant restaurant experiences to customers and be an integral part of the community they serve. It also facilitates the ability to identify, implement and scale innovative ideas that meet customers’ changing needs and preferences. (McDonald's Corporation) “Plan to Win” McDonald’s customer-focused Plan to Win (People, Products, Place, Price and Promotion) provides a common framework for global business yet allows for local adaption (Hollis, 2008). QSC&V Philosophy “Our customers are the reason for our existence. We demonstrate our appreciation by providing them with high quality food and superior service in a clean, welcoming environment, at a great value. Our goal is quality, service, cleanliness 9 and value (QSC&V) for each and every customer, each and every time.” (McDonald's Corporation) Slogans Current Campaigns with translation. You can see the adaptations McDonalds must make due to translation problems, but they all still have the standardized meaning I enjoyment. (Wikipedia) o English = I’m lovin’ It o Spanish = I love it o French = It’s everything that I love o Portuguese = I love all of that o Russian = That is what I love o Mandarin = I just like (it) Olympic Games Involvement (Tepper, 2012) McDonalds has also been heavily involved in the Olympic Games since the 1968 games. First became an official sponsor at the 1976 Games London Games will be the ninth consecutive Olympics where McDonalds will be the event’s official restaurant and the only branded food retailer feeding the athletes. 10 London 2012 Largest McDonalds in the world will open for 6 weeks during the London 2012 Summer Olympics. (Tepper, 2012) Seating for 1,500 customers and employ a staff of more than 2,000 (12,000 applied) Built from recyclable materials, the restaurant will have two floors and be about the size of half of an American football field (3,000 square meter) Ingredients are being sourced from 17,500 British and Irish farms Estimated 3 million customers from opening of Olympic games until end of Paralympic games (July 27th – September 9) Moscow 2014 Russia: Highest GDP per capita among BRIC, 2014 winter Olympic games, 2018 World Cup Brazil 2016 With the perspective of the 2014 world cup and 2016 Olympic games in Brazil, McDonalds plans to target the municipalities as they are only located in 150 out of 350 nationwide. To realize these projects and to stay on top of the concurrence, McDonalds Brazil announced a plan to hire four thousand employees across the country. They will join the existing 50,000 keeping the company’s position as one of the largest employers in Brazil. (Poirier, 2012) 11 Impact of Uncontrollable Forces on the Marketing Plan Economic Forces In a world where economic forces dictate whether business will succeed or not, McDonald’s is faced with a challenge of maintaining their standardized approach of providing great value economically. The Big Mac index is based on the theory of purchasing-power parity: that, in the long run, exchange rates should adjust to equal the price of a basket of goods and services in different countries. The specific basket consists of one McDonald’s Big Mac, and it’s compared it with the average price in America, $4.20 (The Economist, 2012). Also to clarify, India’s price is for the Maharaja Mac which contains no beef due to religious beliefs. Political & Legal Forces India is one of the toughest markets to enter for foreign business, due to the governmental hardships imposed by the Indian government. The government seeks to protect its 12 domestic businesses and employment for its citizens (Mujtaba & Patel, 2007). McDonalds adapts by hiring locals, specifically management in order to gain acceptance into the country by its citizens (Hollis, 2008). Cultural Forces India Due to religious restrictions, beef is not offered in India (Mujtaba & Patel, 2007). The only meat that is offered in Indian McDonald’s restaurants is chicken and fish. Vegetarian meals must also be prepared in separate areas of the restaurant. This forces McDonalds to adapt to not only what they offer but how they prepare what they offer. The diagram above is from the McDonalds website in India. While the idea of a drive thru may seem simple to a consumer in the United States, but that is a product of our culture and growing up with the availability of the quick service. In less developed countries such as India, the drive thru feature was not introduced until the summer of 2008 (The Hindu Business Line, 13 2008). To put that in more of a domestic prospective, McDonald’s opened its first drive thru in the United States in 1975. Cultural forces differences make the idea of a drive thru window very challenging to implement due to the lack of experience. There is a need for the company to teach the consumers in India of not only how to use the drive thru, but also teaching them a new way to eat. As Pierre Woreczek, Senior Vice President and Chief Brand Strategy Officer for McDonalds Europe, said in during an interview, “the only way to positively influence consumers is to create desire.” (Woreczek, 2010) I believe the introduction of the drive thru in McDonald's restaurants in India has created desire amongst consumers as they strive towards being a more developed country. China Chinese society as a whole usually seek to be more westernized in an effort to enhance their image and to serve the demands of their clients, McDonald’s has placed more of an emphasis on beef, which is a luxury item to some customers. In an attempt to adapt to the high power dimension of Chinese culture, McDonald’s has been advertising that eating beef increase sex appeal. This advertisement in particular is not in circulation anymore, but it still shows the attempt to appeal to the consumers in China who expect to gain face through their brand choice. Face according to Nigel Hollis is, “An important governing principle of Chinese Conduct, under which a Chinese person never does anything that would embarrass or undermine another person.” (Hollis, 2008) In order to successfully obtain face, all social classes must know the reputation of the brand for consumers to respect individuals who use the brand. Chinese consumers are practical and make purchase decision that deliver immediate personal advantage, in this case it would be the sex appeal of being western. 14 The next example that I found that of an uncontrollable cultural force was on McDonald’s website in China (McDonald's China). At first glance, you note that the website is completely in Mandarin which is the official language of China. I was unable to have this website translated, but I did find some interesting adaptations due to cultural differences. 1. The price of food is shown for every food item as well as very close up pictures of the food itself This is due to the Chinese typically being a high uncertainty avoidance culture (Hofstede & Mooij, 2010). Chinese consumers are less open to not being informed before their purchases. McDonald’s marketers took that into consideration and made sure that not only are the products labeled appropriately with prices, but also that the pictures of the food are clear. The presentation of the food was also interesting to me as well as it gave the feel that they were trying to showcase it in a way that a higher quality restaurant would. 15 United States In the United States, our culture has its own uniqueness and that can be seen by just observing the USA McDonalds website (McDonalds). Here are a few unique points that root back to cultural influence: “It’s your lunch. Take it” o Ties to consumer preference for personal expression (Milward-Brown, 2011). Also the United States is typically an individualistic culture, so by and large consumers look to benefit themselves. My Meal Builder (Top Right Corner) o With consumers becoming more concerned about personal health and wellness there has been a push for not only healthier options but also health resources provided by companies such as McDonalds (Milward-Brown, 2011). Supplier bio’s o American consumers want to feel good about their purchase (Milward-Brown, 2011). They want peace of mind, knowing that any pleasure they derived from the purchase did not come at the expense of the people who made it. By sharing 16 where the ingredients come from, consumers feel comfortable knowing they are supporting domestic workers. 17 Conclusion There is no doubt that due to its innovative marketing strategies and its ability to deal with uncontrollable forces; McDonald’s is at the pinnacle of corporate business. Remarkably, McDonald’s has proven itself not only to be a leader in its field – the fast-food restaurant business – but as a leader across the business spectrum. They have been a catalyst for the introduction of an iconic American brand to all corners of the globe. While they offer a quintessentially Western product and type of service, they have adapted to the cultural norms and practices world-wide and have thus built up a corporate empire that is truly global in its reach. Understandably, the success of McDonald’s is the envy of many corporations and businesses and serves as an inspiring model for future global brands and entrepreneurs. 18 Works Cited Hofstede, G., & Mooij, M. D. (2010). The Hofstede Model. International Journal of Advertising, pp. 85102. Hollis, N. (2008). The Global Brand. New York: PalGrave Macmillan. Kowitt, B. (2011, September 5). Why McDonald's Wins In Any Economy. Fortune, pp. 70-78. McDonald's China. (n.d.). Home. Retrieved May 4, 2012, from McDonalds China: http://www.mcdonalds.com.cn/ McDonald's Corporation. (n.d.). Mission & Values. Retrieved May 6, 2012, from McDonalds Corporate: http://www.aboutmcdonalds.com/mcd/our_company/mission_and_values.html McDonalds. (n.d.). Home. Retrieved May 6, 2012, from McDonalds US: http://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en/home.html Milward-Brown. (2011). BrandZ Top 100 2011. Retrieved May 1, 2011, from Milward-Brown: http://www.millwardbrown.com/BrandZ/Top_100_Global_Brands/Previous_Years_Results/2011 .aspx Mujtaba, B. G., & Patel, B. (2007). McDonald's SUccess Strategy And Global Expansion Through Customer And Brand Loyalty. Journal of Business Case Studies, pp. 55-64. Poirier, S. (2012, April 8). McDonald's Brazil Has Big Plans: Daily. Retrieved May 5, 2012, from The Rio Times: http://riotimesonline.com/brazil-news/rio-business/mcdonalds-brazil-has-big-growthplans/# Tepper, R. (2012, April 22). A Very Big Mac! World's biggest McDonald's with 1,500 seats to be built for games. Retrieved May 1, 2012, from Mail Online: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/30/worlds-largest-mcdonalds-londonolympics_n_1465450.html The Economist. (2012, January 14). Big Mac index. Retrieved May 2, 2012, from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/21542808 The Hindu Business Line. (2008, June 26). McDonald's opens first "Drive Thru" outlet in Hyderabad. Retrieved May 6, 2012, from PotatoPro: http://www.potatopro.com/Lists/News/DispForm.aspx?List=813b91f5-f5b5-46ec-95e2463829ed0100&id=1512 Wikipedia. (n.d.). McDonald's Advertising. Retrieved May 6, 2012, from Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald's_advertising Woreczek, P. (2010, March 10). How Transparency Saved McDonald's. (J. Simons, Interviewer) 19