Chapter 13 BOND PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT The Passive and Active Stances OUTLINE • Interest Rate Sensitivity • Duration • Convexity • Passive Strategies • Immunisation : A Hybrid Strategy • Active Strategies • Interest Rate Swaps PASSIVE VERSUS ACTIVE STRATEGY • A PASSIVE STRATEGY SEEKS TO MAINTAIN AN APPROPRIATE BALANCE BETWEEN RISK AND RETURN. • AN ACTIVE STRATEGY STRIVES TO ACHIEVE RETURNS THAT ARE MORE THAN COMMENSURATE WITH THE RISK EXPOSURE INTEREST RATE SENSITIVITY 1. THERE IS AN INVERSE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BOND PRICES AND YIELDS. 2. AN INCREASE IN YIELD CAUSES A PROPORTIONATELY SMALLER PRICE CHANGE THAN A DECREASE IN YIELD OF THE SAME MAGNITUDE. 3. PRICES OF LONG-TERM BONDS ARE MORE SENSITIVE TO INTEREST RATE CHANGES THAN PRICES OF SHORT-TERM BONDS. 4. AS MATURITY INCREASES, INTEREST RATE RISK INCREASES BUT AT A DECREASING RATE. 5. PRICES OF LOW-COUPON BONDS ARE MORE SENSITIVE TO INTEREST RATE CHANGES THAN PRICES OF HIGH-COUPON BONDS. 6. BOND PRICES ARE MORE SENSITIVE TO YIELD CHANGES WHEN THE BOND IS INITIALLY SELLING AT A LOWER YIELD. RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CHANGE IN YIELD TO MATURITY AND CHANGE IN BOND PRICE Percentage change in bond price 200 150 Bond Coupon A 12% B 12% C 3% D 3% 100 Maturity 5 years 30 years 30 years 30 years Initial YTM 10% 10% 10% 6% 50 0 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 -50 Change in yield to maturity (%) 2 3 4 5A B C D DURATION - 1 DURATION IS A MEASURE OF THE AVERAGE LIFE OF A DEBT INSTRUMENT. IT IS DEFINED AS THE WEIGHTED AVERAGE TIME TO FULL RECOVERY OF PRINCIPAL AND INTEREST PAYMENTS. USING ANNUAL COMPOUNDING WE CAN DEFINE DURATION (D) AS: n t=1 Ct x t n t=1 Ct (1+r)t D = (1+r)t t = TIME PERIOD IN WHICH THE COUPON / PRINCIPAL PAYMENT OCCURS Ct = INTEREST & / OR PRINCIPAL … t r = MARKET YIELD ON THE BOND DURATION - 2 TO ILLUSTRATE HOW DURATION IS CALCULATED CONSIDER BOND A. BOND A RS 100 15 PERCNET PAYABLE ANNUALLY 6 RS 100 RS 89.50 18 PERCENT FACE VALUE COUPON (INTEREST RATE) YEARS TO MATURITY REDEMPTION VALUE CURRENT MARKET PRICE YIELD TO MATURITY CALCULATION OF DURATION BOND A : 15 PERCENT COUPON YEAR CASH FLOW 1 2 3 4 5 6 15 15 15 15 15 115 PRESENT VALUE AT 18 PER CENT 12.71 10.77 9.13 7.74 6.56 42.60 PROPORTION OF THE BOND'S VALUE 0.142 0.120 0.102 0.086 0.073 0.476 DURATION YEARS PROPORTION OF THE BOND'S VALUE TIME 0.142 0.241 0.306 0.346 0.366 2.856 4.257 DURATION AND VOLATILITY – 1 D* = D/(1+y) D* = modified duration D = duration y = the bond’s yield to maturity P/P – D*y Percentage price change — Modified duration Change in yield X Example D* = 3.608 y = 0.2 percent P/P – 3.608 x 0.2 = – 0.722 percent in decimal form PROPERTIES OF DURATION –1 1. THE DURATION OF A ZERO COUPON BOND IS THE SAME AS ITS MATURITY. 2. FOR A GIVEN MATURITY, A BOND’S DURATION IS HIGHER WHEN ITS COUPON RATE IS LOWER. 3. FOR A GIVEN COUPON RATE, A BOND’S DURATION GENERALLY INCREASES WITH MATURITY. 4. OTHER THINGS BEING EQUAL, THE DURATION OF A COUPON BOND VARIES INVERSELY WITH ITS YIELD TO MATURITY. 5. THE DURATION OF A LEVEL PERPETUITY IS: (1 + YIELD) / YIELD PROPERTIES OF DURATION 6. THE DURATION OF A LEVEL ANNUITY APPROXIMATELY IS: 1 + YIELD NUMBER OF PAYMENTS YIELD (1 + YIELD) NUMBER OF PAYMENTS -1 FOR EXAMPLE, A 15 YEAR ANNUAL ANNUITY WITH A YIELD OF 10 PERCENT WILL HAVE A DURATION OF: 1.10 15 = = 6.28 YEARS 0.10 1.1015 - 1 7. THE DURATION OF A COUPON BOND APPROXIMATELY IS: 1+y (1 + y) + T (c - y) y c [(1 + y)T - 1] + y WHERE y IS THE BOND’S YIELD PER PAYMENT PERIOD, T IS THE NUMBER OF PAYMENT PERIODS, AND c IS THE COUPON RATE PER PAYMENT PERIOD. DURATION OF A COUPON BOND 1+y (1 + y) + T (c - y) c [(1 + y)T - 1] + y y C : COUPON RATE PER PAYMENT PERIOD T : NUMBER OF PAYMENT PERIODS y : BOND’S YIELD PER PAYMENT PERIOD 14% COUPON BOND, 8 YRS MATURITY, PAYING COUPONS SEMI-ANNUALLY YTM = 8 PERCENT PER HALF-YEAR PERIOD 1.08 (1.08) + 16(.07 - .08) - .08 .07 [)1.08)16 - 1) + .08 = 9.817 HALF-YEARS = 4.909 YRS NOTE : MAINTAIN CONSISTENCY .. TIME UNITS OF PAY’T PERIOD & INT. RATE CONVEXITY • IF THE DURATION RULE WERE AN EXACT RULE, THE PERCENTAGE CHANGE IN PRICE WOULD BE LINEARLY RELATED TO THE CHANGE IN YIELD. YET WE KNOW FROM THE BOND-PRICING RELATIONSHIPS DISCUSSED EARLIER THAT THE ACTUAL RELATIONSHIP IS CURVILINEAR. • THE DURATION RULE PROVIDES AN APPROXIMATION WHICH IS FAIRLY CLOSE, FOR SMALL CHANGES IN YIELD. HOWEVER, AS THE YIELD CHANGE BECOMES LARGER, THE APPROXIMATION BECOMES POORER. CONVEXITY 20-YEAR MATURITY, 9 PERCENT COUPON BOND, SELLING AT AN INITIAL MATURITY OF 9 PERCENT. MODIFIED DURATION IS 9.95 YEARS. THE FOLLOWING EXHIBIT SHOWS THE STRAIGHT LINE PLOT OF -D*y = - 9.95 x y AS WELL AS THE CURVED LINE REFLECTING THE ACTUAL RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN YIELD CHANGE AND PRICE CHANGE Percentage change in bond price 80 60 40 20 • 0 -5 - 4 - 20 - 40 -3 -2 -1 0 1 Change in YTM (percentage points) 2 3 4 5 CONVEXITY • THE TRUE PRICE-YIELD RELATIONSHIP IS CONVEX, MEANING THAT IT OPENS UPWARD. • CLEARLY, CONVEXITY IS A DESIRABLE FEATURE IN BONDS. PRICES OF BONDS WITH GREATER CONVEXITY (CURVATURE) INCREASE MORE WHEN YIELDS FALL AND DECLINE LESS WHEN YIELDS RISE. • SINCE CONVEXITY IS A DESIRABLE FEATURE, IT DOES NOT COME FREE. INVESTORS HAVE TO PAY FOR IT IN SOME WAY OR THE OTHER. PASSIVE STRATEGIES TWO COMMONLY FOLLOWED STRATEGIES BY PASSIVE BOND INVESTORS ARE: BUY AND HOLD STRATEGY AND INDEXING STRATEGY. A BUY AND HOLD STRATEGY SELECTS A BOND PORTFOLIO AND STAYS WITH IT AN INDEXING STRATEGY CALLS FOR BUILDING A PORTFOLIO THAT MIRRORS A WELL-KNOWN BOND INDEX DURATION AND IMMUNISATION - 1 CAPITAL VALUE INTEREST RATE RETURN ON REINVESTMENT OF INTEREST CAPITAL VALUE INTEREST RATE RETURN ON REINVESTMENT OF INTEREST FOR IMMUNISATION SET DURATION EQUAL TO INVESTMENT HORIZON DURATION AND IMMUNISATION - 2 MAY BE DEFINED . . PROCESS … FIXED INCOME PORTFOLIO IS CREATED HAVING . . AN ASSURED RETURN FOR A SPECIFIED TIME HORIZON IRRESPECTIVE OF INTEREST RATE CHANGE. MORE CONCISELY, THE FOLLOWING ARE IMPORTANT CHARACTERISTICS • SPECIFIC TIME HORIZON • ASSURED RATE OF RETURN • INSULATION FROM THE EFFECTS OF POTENTIAL ADVERSE INTEREST RATE CHANGE ON PORTFOLIO VALUE CAPITAL CHANGES BALANCE INVESTMENT RETURN ILLUSTRATION AN INVESTOR WHO HAS A FOUR-YEAR INVESTMENT HORIZON WANTS TO INVEST RS.1,000 SO THAT HIS INITIAL INVESTMENT ALONG WITH REINVESTMENT OF INTEREST GROWS TO RS.1607.5. THIS MEANS THAT THE INVESTOR WANTS HIS INVESTMENT TO EARN A COMPOUND RETURN OF 12.6 PERCENT [1,000 (1.126)4 = 1,607.5 THE INVESTOR IS EVALUATING TWO BONDS, A & B Par value Market price Coupon rate Yield to maturity Maturity period Duration Rating Bond A Bond B Rs.1,000 Rs.1,000 12.6% 12.6% 4 years Less than 4 years A Rs.1,000 Rs.1,000 12.6% 12.6% 5 years 4 years A EXHIBIT 13.4 SHOWS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE INVESTOR BUYS BOND A AND BOND B UNDER DIFFERENT ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT MARKET YIELD TERMINAL VALUE WITH BONDS A AND B Part I : Year 1 2 3 4 Part II Year 1 2 3 4 Bond A: Market Yield Remains at 12.6% Reinvestment Cash flow Accumulated value rate Rs. 126 12.6% 126 (1.126)3 = 179.9 Rs. 126 12.6% 126 (1.126)2 = 159.8 Rs. 126 12.6% 126 (1.126)1 = 141.9 Rs. 1126 NA 1126.0 Total 1607.6 Bond A: Market Yield Falls to 10% in year 2 Reinvestment Cash flow Accumulated value rate Rs. 126 12.6% 126 (1.10) (1.10) (1.10) = 167.7 Rs. 126 10.0% 126 (1.10) (1.10) = 152.5 Rs. 126 10.0% 126 (1.10) = 138.6 Rs. 1126 NA 1126.0 Total 1584.8 contd TERMINAL VALUE WITH BONDS A AND B Part III Bond B: Market Yield Remains at 12.6% Reinvestment Year Cash flow Accumulated value rate 1 126 12.6% 126 (1.126)3 = 179.9 2 126 12.6% 126 (1.126)2 = 159.8 3 126 12.6% 126 (1.126)1 = 141.9 4 126 NA 126.0 4 1000* (sale of bond) NA 1000.0 Total 1607.6 Part III Bond B: Market Yield Falls to 10% in Year 2 Reinvestment Year Cash flow Accumulated value rate 1 126 12.6% 126 (1.10) (1.10) (1.10) = 167.7 2 126 10.0% 126 (1.10) (1.10) = 152.5 3 126 10.0% 126 (1.10) = 138.6 4 126 NA 126.0 4 1023.6** (sale of NA 1023.6 bond) Total 1608.4 * (126 + 1000)/ (1.126) = 1000 ** (126 + 1000)/ (1.10) = 1023.6 CASH FLOW MATCHING CASH FLOW MATCHING INVOLVES BUYING A ZERO COUPON BOND THAT PROMISES A PAYMENT THAT EXACTLY MATCHES THE PROJECTED CASH REQUIREMENT. IT AUTOMATICALLY IMMUNISES A PORTFOLIO FROM INTEREST RATE RISK BECAUSE THE CASH FLOW FROM THE BOND OFFSETS THE FUTURE OBLIGATION. A DEDICATION STRATEGY INVOLVES MATCHING CASH FLOWS ON A MULTIPERIOD BASES. ACTIVE STRATEGIES • HENRY KAUFMAN, A RENOWNED BOND EXPERT, ARGUES THAT “BONDS ARE BOUGHT FOR THEIR PRICE APPRECIATION POTENTIAL AND NOT FOR INCOME PROTECTION” • MANY BOND INVESTORS SUBSCRIBE TO THIS VIEW AND PURSUE ACTIVE STRATEGIES. THEY SEEK TO PROFIT BY: • FORECASTING INTEREST RATE CHANGES AND/OR • EXPLOITING RELATIVE MISPRICINGS AMONG BONDS. INTEREST RATAE FORECASTING - 1 IRF1 MODELS BASED UPON FORECASTING EXPECTED INFLATION EXPECTED INFL’N .. KEY DETERMINANT SOLID EVIDENCE .. LINK +S RELATIVELY SIMPLE APPROACH -S MAY NOT HELP IN SHORT TERM FORECASTING EXPECTED INFL’N .. NOT EASY .. PREDICT MODELS THAT FORECAST INTEREST RATES BASED UPON PAST INTEREST RATE CHANGES THESE MODELS EMPHASIZE THE TIME SERIES BEHAVIOR OF INTEREST RATES & USE DISTRIBUTED LAGS OF PAST INTEREST RATES IN PREDICTING FUTURE INT. RATES + SIMPLE .. INFOR’N AVAILABLES SHIFTS .. FUNDAMENTAL FACTORS … BREAK IN TRENDS INTEREST RATE FORECASTING - 2 MODELS THAT ASSUME THAT INTEREST RATES MOVE IN A NORMAL RANGE (WHICH IS KNOWN) MEAN REVERSION + IF THE NORMAL RANGE .. KNOWN … SIMPLE TO BUILD … ONLY SPEED ADJUSTT FACTOR - THE NORMAL RANGE .. MAY SHIFT OVER TIME IF FUNDAMENTAL VARIABLES (LIKE INTEREST RATE SHIFT) COMPREHENSIVE MULTI - SECTOR MODELS OF THE ECONOMY THAT ATTEMPT TO PREDICT INTEREST RATES MODEL ALL FLOWS .. ECONOMY S & D OF FUNDS IMBALANCE INT. RATE CHANGES + COMPREHENSIVE … FUNDAMENTALS - NUMEROUS INPUTS .. ERRORS IN THESE INPUTS … ERRORS IN INTEREST RATE FORECASTS INTEREST RATE FORECASTING - 3 PERFORMANCE OF FORECASTING MODELS INTEREST RATE GENERALLY, IRFMs HAVE NOT PERFORMED WELL IN FORECASTING SHORT - TERM MOVEMENTS. THEY PERFORM BETTER IN EXPLAINING WHY INTEREST RATES HAVE MOVED & IN PREDICTING LONG - TERM MOVEMENTS IN INTEREST RATES. HORIZON ANALYSIS HORIZON ANALYSIS IS A METHOD OF FORECASTING THE TOTAL RETURN ON A BOND OVER A GIVEN HOLDING PERIOD. IT INVOLVES THE FOLLOWING STEPS. SELECT A PARTICULAR INVESTMENT PERIOD AND PREDICT BOND YIELDS AT THE END OF THAT PERIOD. CALCULATE THE BOND PRICE AT THE END OF THE INVESTMENT PERIOD. ESTIMATE THE FUTURE VALUE OF COUPON INCOMES EARNED OVER THE INVESTMENT PERIOD. ADD THE FUTURE VALUE OF COUPON INCOMES OVER THE INVESTMENT PERIOD TO THE PREDICTED CAPITAL GAIN OR LOSS TO GET A FORECAST OF THE TOTAL RETURN ON THE BOND FOR THE HOLDING PERIOD. ANNUALISE THE HOLDING PERIOD RETURN. EXPLOITING RELATIVE MISPRICINGS AMONG BONDS • SUBSTITUTION SAWP • PURE YIELD PICKUP SWAP • INTERMARKET SPREAD SWAP • TAX SWAP INTEREST RATE SWAPS AN INTEREST RATE SWAP (IRS) IS A TRANSACTION INVOLVING AN EXCHANGE OF ONE STREAM OF INTEREST OBLIGATIONS FOR ANOTHER. KEY FEATURES • NET INTEREST DIFFERENTIAL IS PAID OR RECEIVED • NO EXCHANGE OF PRINCIPAL REPAYMENT OBLIGATIONS • STRUCTURED AS A SEPARATE TRANSACTION • OFF BALANCE SHEET TRANSACTION INTEREST RATE SWAP 6.05% Swap Dealer MIBOR MIBOR 5.95% Company A 6% coupon Company B MIBOR SUMMING UP • Interest rate risk is measured by the percentage change in the value of a bond in response to a given interest rate change. • The duration of a bond is the weighted average maturity of its cash flow stream, where the weights are proportional to the present value of cash flows. • The proportional change in the price of a bond in response to the change in its yield is as follows: P/P D* y • The two commonly followed passive strategies for bond portfolio management are: buy and hold strategy and indexing strategy. • If the duration of a bond equals the investment horizon, the investor is immunised against interest rate risk. • Those who follow an active approach to bond portfolio management seek to profit by (a) forecasting interest rate changes and /or (b) exploiting relative mispricings among bonds. • A wide range of models are used for interest rate forecasting. • Horizon analysis is a method of forecasting the total return on a bond over a given holding period. • An interest rate swap is a transaction involving an exchange of one stream of interest obligations for another.