CONCEPT PAPER AND PROGRAMME 5-6 JUNE 2012, STRASBOURG 1 CONCEPT PAPER Background The European Court of Human Rights is under growing pressure due to the unprecedented number of applications being submitted to it by individuals who consider that their rights under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) have been violated and who have not been able to obtain redress within their national judicial systems. This pressure could be reduced if national legal professionals applied the Convention effectively and correctly in cases being brought in the national courts in Council of Europe (CoE) member states. That way human rights would be protected as closely as possible to the individuals concerned, in line with the well-known principle of subsidiarity. However the ECHR and its accompanying case law is a specialised field, and national judges, prosecutors and lawyers cannot be expected to be able to apply it without training and without information about how to take it into account alongside the applicable national law and jurisprudence. The Council of Europe has therefore for many years been supporting member states in implementing the ECHR at national level by developing a wide range of training tools aiming at assisting legal professionals in their own capacity development endeavours. The programme pursuing this objective is the European Programme for Human Rights Education for Legal Professionals (HELP programme). The overall objective of the HELP Programme is to support the 47 member states in implementing the ECHR at national level, in accordance with the 2010 Interlaken Declaration on the Future of the European Court of Human Rights. To achieve such an ambitious objective, it is crucial to take into account the feedback and inputs from the main actors concerned, i.e. National Training Institutions (NTIs) and Bar Associations (BAs), to further develop courses on the ECHR, reinforce national trainers’ skills as regards ECHR training, organise pilot E-learning training courses, promote the full availability of tools and materials by updating and expanding the HELP website (http://www.coe.int/help) and the publication of relevant national jurisprudence concerning the implementation and application of the ECHR at national level. The 2012 HELP Conference aims to address all these issues. Objectives of the conference For the first time, the 2012 HELP Conference is bringing together representatives of National Training Institutions and Bar Associations of the 47 member states. The conference provides a unique forum for discussing the importance of continuous training on human rights for judges, prosecutors and lawyers, and on the role of NTIs and BAs in integrating the HELP training resources in their initial and professional education programmes at national level. The main objectives of the HELP Conference will be to: - Allow a peer-to-peer exchange between NTIs and BAs on the current practices in training on human rights, and identify commonalities, differences and issues of mutual interest; Identify the most urgent training needs for judges, prosecutors and lawyers across the 47 members states and explore opportunities for development of future HELP curricula; Gain a better understanding of the HELP Programme’s objectives and how it can best serve the needs of the national legal professionals in their daily work in the longer term. 2 PROGRAMME DAY 1 (morning) Palais de l’Europe – Room 5 Tuesday 5 June 2012 OPENING PLENARY SESSION 9.00 – 10.00 Arrival and registration of participants - administrative matters 10.00 – 10.45 Welcoming Addresses Mr Philippe Boillat, Director General of Human Rights and Rule of Law Ms Ellen Berends, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of The Netherlands to the Council of Europe, Chairperson of the Assembly of Contributors of the Human Rights Trust Fund Ms Margarita Gega, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of Albania to the Council of Europe 10.45 – 11.15 The relevance of an improved human rights education of legal professionals in the context of the long term future of the European Court of Human Rights Ms Françoise Tulkens, Vice-President of the European Court of Human Rights 11.15 – 11.45 Coffee Break 11.45 – 12.15 International Human Rights Standards and their implementation by national tribunals Mr Fausto Pocar, Judge and former President of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, former Chairman and Rapporteur of the United Nations Human Rights Committee 12.15 – 12.45 The admissibility criteria and the work of the filtering sections of the Registry of the European Court of Human Rights: the importance of the specific training of lawyers on human rights Ms Karen Reid, Head of the Filtering Section, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights 12.45 – 13.00 The HELP Programme and the HELP Network: organisation and objectives of the conference Mr Roberto Rivello, Manager of the HELP Programme Ms Natacha De Roeck, Manager of the HELP Project on Admissibility Criteria 13.00 – 14.30 Lunch break 3 DAY 1 (afternoon) Palais de l’Europe – Room 11 Tuesday 5 June 2012 WORKING GROUP I (JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS) Moderator: Mr Roberto Rivello, Manager of the HELP Programme 14.30 – 15.45 The training of judges and prosecutors on the ECHR: forms, resources and methodologies Chairperson: Mr Fausto Pocar, Judge and former President of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, former Chairman and Rapporteur of the United Nations Human Rights Committee Keynote speaker: Ms Marina Naumovska-Milevska, Council of Europe International Expert 15.45 – 16.15 Break 16.15 – 17.30 Best practices in training on human rights and experiences of other international tribunals Chairperson: Mr Erik Møse, European Court of Human Rights, Judge elected in respect of Norway, former President of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda DAY 1 (afternoon) Palais de l’Europe – Room 14 Tuesday 5 June 2012 WORKING GROUP II (JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS) Moderator: Ms Milica Vesovic, Project Co-ordinator, Division for Legal Co-operation 14.30 – 15.45 The case law of the European Court of Human Rights: access and dissemination Chairperson: Mr Patrick Titiun, Office of the President of the European Court of Human Rights, Head of Office 15.45 – 16.15 Break 16.15 – 17.30 National jurisprudence based on the ECHR: sources of information and best practices Chairperson: Mr Ledi Bianku, Judge of the European Court of Human Rights, elected in respect of Albania 4 DAY 1 (afternoon) Palais de l’Europe – Room 12-13 Tuesday 5 June 2012 WORKING GROUP III (LAWYERS AND BAR ASSOCIATIONS) Moderator: Mr Sergey Dikman, Project Co-ordinator, Division for Legal Co-operation 14.30 – 15.45 Inclusion of the ECHR training into initial and continuous training of lawyers: mandatory or optional character Chairperson: Mr Georges-Albert Dal, former President of the Consultative Council of Bars of Europe (CCBE) 15.45 – 16.15 Break 16.15 – 17.30 The sustainability of the training programmes and the increased role of member states in the training of lawyers Chairperson: Mr Max Mamou, Lawyer, President of the Mémoire Albert Cohen Foundation DAY 1 (afternoon) Agora Building – Room G04 Tuesday 5 June 2012 WORKING GROUP IV (LAWYERS AND BAR ASSOCIATIONS) Moderator: Ms Natacha De Roeck, Manager of the HELP Project on Admissibility Criteria 14.30 – 15.45 The role of Bar Associations in the national implementation of the ECHR and their involvement in training on human rights Chairperson: Ms Zdravka Kalaydjieva, European Court of Human Rights, Judge elected in respect of Bulgaria 15.45 – 16.15 Break 16.15 – 17.30 The training of lawyers on admissibility criteria in applications submitted to the ECtHR Chairperson: Mr Jeremy McBride, Barrister, Monckton Chambers, London, Chairman of the Scientific Committee of the Fundamental Human Rights Agency of the European Union 5 DAY 2 (morning) Wednesday 6 June 2012 Palais de l’Europe – Room 11 WORKING GROUP I (JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS) Moderator: Mr Roberto Rivello 9.30 – 10.45 The training of judges and prosecutors on the ECHR: increasing impact and sustainability for an effective domestic implementation of the ECHR Chairperson: Mr Jean-Pierre Michel, Senator, France, Council of Europe rapporteur on “The European Convention on Human Rights: reinforcement and consolidation of the training of judges and lawyers” 10.45 – 11.15 Break 11.15 – 12.30 ECHR Curricula and content of training programmes for judges and prosecutors Chairperson: Ms Josiane Bigot, Judge and President of the Themis Association, France Keynote speaker: Mr Antonio Mura, Secretary-General of the International Association of Judges, Vice-President of the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (CCPE) 12.30 – 14.30 Lunch Break DAY 2 (morning) Wednesday 6 June 2012 Palais de l’Europe – Room 14 WORKING GROUP II (JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS) Moderator: Ms Milica Vesovic 9.30 – 10.45 Providing guidance on the implementation of the ECHR: the role and the training needs of Constitutional and Supreme Courts judges Chairperson: Ms Angelika Nußberger, European Court of Human Rights, Judge elected in respect of Germany Keynote speaker: Ms Christiane Schmaltz, Référendaire at the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany and former Judge, Lübeck, Germany 10.45 – 11.15 Break 11.15 – 12.30 Continuation of the discussion 12.30 – 14.30 Lunch Break 6 DAY 2 (morning) Wednesday 6 June 2012 Palais de l’Europe – Room 12-13 WORKING GROUP III (LAWYERS AND BAR ASSOCIATIONS) Moderator: Mr Sergey Dikman 9.30 – 10.45 ECHR training for lawyers: Curricula, contents methodology and resources Chairperson: Mr Jeroen Schokkenbroek, Special Representative of the Secretary General for Roma Issues, Council of Europe Keynote speaker: Mr Hasan Bakirci, Deputy to the Head of the Filtering Section of the European Court of Human Rights 10.45 – 11.15 Break 11.15 – 12.30 Continuation of the discussion 12.30 – 14.30 Lunch Break DAY 2 (morning) Wednesday 6 June 2012 Agora Building – Room G04 WORKING GROUP IV (LAWYERS AND BAR ASSOCIATIONS) Moderator: Ms Natacha De Roeck 9.30 – 10.45 The training on the procedure and practice of the European Court of Human Rights: the filtering of applications submitted to the Court Chairperson: Mr Hasan Mutaf, Lawyer of the Filtering Section at the European Court of Human Rights 10.45 – 11.15 Break 11.15 – 12.30 The added value of the training of lawyers to the effectiveness of the European Court of Human Rights Chairperson: Mr Yonko Grozev, Bulgarian lawyer and Council of Europe’s expert of the working group on admissibility 12.30 – 14.30 Lunch Break 7 DAY 2 (afternoon) Wednesday 6 June 2012 Palais de l’Europe – Room 5 CLOSING PLENARY SESSION 14.30 – 14.45 Opening speech Ms Tatiana Termacic, Head, Human Rights Capacity Building, Justice and Legal Co-operation Department, Justice and Human Dignity Directorate, Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law 14.45 – 15.30 Conclusions and recommendations of the Working Groups Mr Roberto Rivello Ms Milica Vesovic Ms Natacha De Roeck Mr Sergey Dikman 15.30 – 16.00 Discussion 16.00 – 16.30 Break 16.30 – 17.30 The 2012-2013 Road-Map for the HELP Programme Final interventions by the representatives of all NTIs and BAs Moderator: Ms Hanne Juncher Head of the Justice and Legal Co-operation Department, Justice and Human Dignity Directorate, Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law 17.30 – 17.45 Closing remarks Ms Marja Ruotanen, Director, Justice and Human Dignity Directorate, Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law 17.45 – 18.30 Reception – Vin d’honneur 8 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS 1. Mr Luigi Agostinacchio, Consiglio Superiore Della Magistratura, Italy, Working Group I 2. Ms Irina Aleshkova, Russian Academy of Justice, Russian Federation, Working Group I 3. Mr Gheorghe Amihalachioaie, Bar Association, Moldova, Working Group IV 4. Ms Galina Arapova, HELP Info Point Admissibility for the Russian Federation, Working Group IV 5. Ms Pelin Ataman, HELP Info Point Admissibility for Turkey, Working Group IV 6. Mr Hasan Bakirci, Deputy to the Head of the Filtering Section of the European Court of Human Rights, Working Group III 7. Mr Reuben Balzan, The Chamber of Advocates, Malta, Working Group III 8. Ms Ellen Berends, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of The Netherlands to the Council of Europe, Chairperson of the Assembly of Contributors of the Human Rights Trust Fund 9. Mr Leif Berg, Head of Case Law Information and Publications Division, European Court of Human Rights 10. Ms Märit Bergendahl, Courts of Sweden Judicial Training Academy, Sweden, Working Group I 11. Mr Ledi Bianku, Judge of the European Court of Human Rights, elected in respect of Albania 12. Ms Josiane Bigot, Association Themis, France 13. Ms Astrid Bink, Orde van Vlaamse Balies, Belgium, Working Group III 14. Ms Mirela Bogdani, HELP Focal point for Albania, Working Group II 15. Mr Besarion Bokhashvili, HELP Focal point for Georgia, Working Group I 16. Mr Grzegorz Borkowski, National School of Judiciary and Public Prosecution, Poland, Working Group 1 17. Ms Sandra Budimir, HELP Focal point for Croatia, Working Group II 18. Mr Rafael Bustos, Judicial School of the General Council for the Judiciary, Spain, Working Group I 9 19. Mr Serkan Cengiz, Council of Europe’s expert of the working group on admissibility, Turkey, Working Group III 20. Ms Olga Chernishova, European Court of Human Rights 21. Ms Victoria Cherniychuk, Lawyer, Legal Unit, Case-Law Information and Publications Division, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights 22. Ms Natia Chirikashvili, Bar Association, Georgia, Working Group IV 23. Ms Lana Chkhartishvili, Training Center of Justice, Georgia, Working Group II 24. Ms Michaela Chládeková, Slovak Bar Association, Slovakia, Working Group IV 25. Mr Alexandre Coelho, Centre for Judicial Studies of Portugal, Working Group I 26. Mr George-Albert Dal, Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe, Belgium 27. Mr Huseyin Ekinci, Turkish Justice Academy, Turkey, Working Group II 28. Ms Elina Elkind, Supreme Court, Estonia, Working Group I 29. Ms Tetyana Fuley, HELP Focal point for Ukraine, Working Group I 30. Ms Catalina Garay y Chamizo, German-Spanish Bar Association, Spain, Working Group IV 31. Ms Ana-Maria Garofil, Institut National de la Magistrature, Romania, Working Group I 32. Ms Margarita Gega, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of Albania to the Council of Europe 33. Ms Ivana Goranic, Judicial Academy of the Republic of Croatia, Working Group II 34. Ms Aida Grgic, Lawyer, Legal Unit, Case-Law Information and Publications Division, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights 35. Mr Yonko Grozev, Bulgarian lawyer and Council of Europe’s expert of the working group on admissibility, Bulgaria 36. Mr Maksim R. Haxhia, Dhoma Kombetare Avokatise of Albania, Working Group III 37. Mr Alonso Hernandez-Pinzon, Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe, Working Group III 38. 39. Ms Eli Hristova, Supreme Bar Council of Bulgaria, Working Group IV Ms Eva Hubalkova, European Court of Human Rights, Working Group IV 10 40. Ms Giovanna Ichino, Scuola Della Magistratura, Italy, Working Group I 41. Mr Blas J. Imbroda, Consejo General de la Abogacía Española (Spanish National Bar), Working Group IV 42. Ms Marta Isern Busquets, Barcelona Bar Association, Spain, Working Group III 43. Mr Bosko Kacanski, HELP Focal Point for Serbia, Working Group III 44. Ms Zdravka Kalaydjieva, European Court of Human Rights, Judge elected in respect of Bulgaria 45. Mr Irakli Kandashvili, Georgian Lawyers for Independent Profession, Working Group IV 46. Ms Ruta Kavaliauskiene, Prosecutor General‘s Office of Lithuania, Working Group II 47. Ms Eka Khimshiashvili, Georgian Bar Association, Georgia, Working Group III 48. Mr Nikolay Kipnis, Council of Europe’s expert of the working group on admissibility, Russian Federation, Working Group IV 49. Ms Korneliya Kirilova, National Institute of Justice, Bulgaria, Working Group I 50. Ms Eugenia Kistruga, National Institute of Justice, Moldova, Working Group II 51. Mr Vasilije Knežević, Bar Association, Montenegro, Working Group III 52. Ms Elira Kokona, Council of Europe’s expert of the working group on admissibility, Albania, Working Group III 53. Mr Christoforos Kosmidis, Hellenic School of Judges, Working Group I 54. Ms Anita Kovalevska, Latvian Judical Training Centre, Working Group II 55. Ms Lumnije Krasniqi, Kosovo Judicial Institute*, Working Group II 56. Ms Natasha Kravchuk, HELP Focal Point, Russian Federation, Working Group IV 57. Mr Yannis Ktistakis, Supreme Court Attorney at Law, Department of International Relations, Faculty of Law, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece, Working Group II * All reference to Kosovo, whether to the territory, institutions or population, in this text shall be understood in full compliance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 and without prejudice to the status of Kosovo. 11 58. Mr Nicklas Lagrell, Swedish Prosecutor Authority, Sweden, Working Group I 59. 60. Ms Saale Laos, Supreme Court of Estonia, Working Group II Ms Marie Laur, Lawyer, Legal Unit, Case-Law Information and Publications Division, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights 61. Ms Linda Lauritsen, Danish Court Administration, Denmark, Working Group II 62. Mr Mikhail Lobov, European Court of Human Rights, Working Group IV 63. Ms Caroline MacLeod, Scottish Prosecution College, United Kingdom, Working Group I 64. Mr Max Mamou, President of the Mémoire Albert Cohen Foundation, France 65. Ms Svetla Margaritova-Vuchkova, HELP Info Point Admissibility, Bulgaria, Working Group IV 66. Mr Jeremy McBride, Barrister, Monckton Chambers, Chairman of the Scientific Committee of the Fundamental Human Rights Agency of the European Union 67. Ms Erinda Meli, HELP Info Point Admissibility, Albania, Working Group 68. Ms Liudvika Meskauskaite, Lietuvos advokatūra, Lithuania, Working Group IV 69. Mr Jean-Pierre Michel, Senator, Rapporteur of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, France 70. Mr Vanche Mijalchev, Academy for Training of Judges and Public Prosecutors and their Deputies, "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", Working Group II 71. Mr Erik Møse, European Court of Human Rights, Judge elected in respect of Norway, former President of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda 72. Ms Amila Mujčinović, Advokatska - Odvjetnicka Komora, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Working Group III 73. Mr Antonio Mura, International Association of Judges, Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (CCPE), Italy 74. Mr Hasan Mutaf, Lawyer of the Filtering Section at the European Court of Human Rights, Working Group IV 75. Ms Marina Naumovska-Milevska, Consultant for the Council of Europe, "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" 76. Ms Angelika Nußberger, European Court of Human Rights, Judge elected in respect of Germany 12 77. Mr Mehmet Öner, High Council of Judges and prosecutors, Turkey, Working Group II 78. Mr Simon O'Toole, The Bar Council, United Kingdom, Working Group III 79. Ms Vanja Pavlović, Center for Judicial and Prosecutorial Training of the Republika Srpska, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Working Group II 80. Mr Daniel Pical, European section of the International Association of Youth and Family Judges and Magistrates (IAYFJM), France, Working Group I 81. Ms Déborah Piekarz, the Mémoire Albert Cohen Foundation, France, Working Group III 82. Mr Fausto Pocar, International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, Italy 83. Mr Cerni Pol, Collegi d'Advocats, Andorra, Working Group II 84. Ms Tetiana Pustovoitova, National School of Judges of Ukraine, Working Group I 85. Mr Raimundas Rakauskas, Training Centre of the Ministry of Justice, Lithuania, Working Group II 86. Ms Ivana Rakočević, Public Prosecutor's Office of Belgrade, Serbia, Working Group I 87. Mr Nenad Rebac, Advokatska - Odvjetnicka Komora, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Working Group III 88. Mr Jonas Regenfuss, Deutscher Anwaltverein DAV (German Bar Association), Working Group IV 89. Ms Karen Reid, Head of the Filtering Section, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights 90. Mr Shota Rukhadze, The High School of Justice, Georgia, Working Group II 91. Ms Jolanta Samuolyte, HELP Info Point Admissibility, Lithuania, Working Group III 92. Mr Grigor Sargsyan, Prosecutor's School, Republic of Armenia, Working Group I 93. Ms Sylvie Sarolea, Barreau de Nivelles, Faculty of Law, Université Catholique de Louvain, Belgium, Working Group III 94. Mr Meritxell Sauras Quetcuti, Barcelona Bar Association, Spain, Working Group IV 13 95. Ms Christiana Schmaltz, Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, Working Group II 96. Mr Francisco Segovia, Consejo General de la Abogacía Española (Spanish National Bar), Spain, Working Group III 97. Ms Mariana Semini, School of Magistrates of Albania, Working Group I 98. Ms Anne Souléliac, Paris Bar, France, Working Group III 99. Mr David Strupek, HELP Info Point Admissibility, Czech Republic, Working Group IV 100. Mr Gabor Szeplaki-Nagy, Prosecution Service of Hungary/ Training Centre for Prosecutors, Hungary, Working Group I 101. Ms Loredana Tassone, Strasbourg Bar Association, France, Working Group III 102. Mr Jugoslav Tintor, Bar Association, Serbia, Working Group III 103. Mr Patrick Titiun, Office of the President of the European Court of Human Rights, Head of Office, Working Group I 104. Mr Musa Toprak, Union of Turkish Bar Associations, HELP Focal Point for Turkey, Working Group I 105. Mr Pier Giovanni Traversa, Scuola Superiore dell’Avvocatura, Italy, Working Group I 106. Ms Françoise Tulkens, Vice-President of the European Court of Human Rights 107. Mr Viktor Vadász, Hungarian Judicial Academy, Hungary, Working Group I 108. Mr Arman Vardanyan, Judicial School of the Republic of Armenia, Working Group I 109. Mr Saulvedis Vārpiņš, Council of Sworn Advocates, Latvia, Working Group III 110. Mr Aliaksandr Vashkevich, The Society for Comparative Legal Studies, Belarus, Working Group II 111. Ms Kristel Voltenberg, Estonian Bar Association, Working Group IV 112. Mr Nenad Vujić, Judicial Academy of Serbia, Working Group II 113. Ms Agnieszka Wilk-Ilewicz, Supreme Administrative Court of Poland, Working Group II 114. Ms Jana Wurstova, Council of Europe’s expert of the working group on admissibility, Czech Republic, Working Group IV 14 115. Mr Alper Yazici, Justice Academy, Turkey, Working group I 116. Mr Vahe Yengibaryan, Association of Judges, Republic of Armenia, Working Group II 117. Ms Adisa Zahiragić, Centre for Judicial and Prosecutorial Training of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina 118. Ms Jovana Zorić, Belgrade Center for Human Rights, Serbia, Working Group IV COUNCIL OF EUROPE SECRETARIAT 119. Mr Philippe Boillat, Director General of Human Rights and Rule of Law, Council of Europe 120. Ms Marja Ruotanen, Director, Justice and Human Dignity Directorate, Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law, Council of Europe 121. Mr Jeroen Schokkenbroek, Special Representative of the Secretary General for Roma Issues, Council of Europe 122. Ms Hanne Juncher, Head of the Justice and Legal Co-operation Department, Justice and Human Dignity Directorate, Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law, Council of Europe 123. Ms Tatiana Termacic, Head, Human Rights Capacity Building, Justice and Legal Co-operation Department, Justice and Human Dignity Directorate, Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law, Council of Europe 124. Mr Roberto Rivello, Manager of the HELP Programme, Council of Europe 125. Ms Milica Vesović, Project Co-ordinator, Division for Legal Co-operation, Council of Europe 126. Mr Sergey Dikman, Project Co-ordinator, Division for Legal Co-operation, Council of Europe 127. Ms Natacha De Roeck, Manager of the HELP Project on Admissibility Criteria, Council of Europe INTERPRETERS English/ French/ Russian: Plenary sessions, Room 5, 5 June a.m. & 6 June p.m., and Working Group I, Room 11, 5 June p.m. & 6 June a.m.: 128. William Valk 129. Didier Jungling 15 130. Nadine Kieffer 131. Alexander Barchenov 132. Victor Prokofiev 133. Kolia Ilin English/ Russian – Working Group II, 5 June p.m. & 6 June a.m., Room 14: 134. Olga Berard 135. Kolia Ilin English/ French – Working Group III, 5 June p.m. & 6 June a.m., Room 12/13: 136. Sally Bailey-Ravet 137. William Valk English/ Russian – Working Group IV, Room G04, 5 June p.m. & 6 June a.m.: 138. Paul Belopolsky 139. Valerie Döhler ASSISTANTS 140. Ms Malika Assante, Documentalist 141. Ms Boyana Gantcheva, Administrative Assistant 142. Ms Nathalie Girard, Administrative Assistant 143. Ms Anne Le Vallois, Administrative Assistant 144. Ms Mireille Moegling, Administrative Assistant 145. Ms Christina Nicolaidou, Administrative Assistant 146. Ms Yolande Oswald, Administrative Assistant 147. Ms Yoni Stojanova, Administrative Assistant 148. Ms Despina Tramountani, Administrative Assistant 149. Ms Catherine Van Der Graaf, HELP Programme Support Assistant 16