Chapter 9 An International Perspective Advertising and Culture Culture X Culture Y Advertiser Consumers = Global Brand? International Advertising • Advertising that crosses national and cultural boundaries • Cultures, not nations, define advertising messages Cultural Influences 5–5 Cultural Constructs • Collectivism: In-group goals, family integrity, and harmonious relationships. – China, Japan, Korea, and Mexico. – Earlier generations of Asian Americans and Hispanic Americans. • Individualism: Individual goals, being different from and independent of others. – The U.S. and Canada. 5–6 Individualism vs. Collectivism 5–7 Eastern View In-group Out-group Self Western View In-group Self Out-group Language Negotiations “bombed” Failure Success “If you want to kill a message, translate it!” Mist Stick (Sunbeam) Mist = “manure” or “excrement” Silver Mist (Rolls-Royce) "It won't leak in your pocket and embarrass you." "It won't leak in your pocket and make you pregnant." “Got Milk?” “Are you lactating?” “Turn it loose” Mexico Chevy Nova “finger lickin’ good” “Suffer from diarrhea” “Chevy doesn’t run” “eat your fingers off” China Ford Pinto Pinto: “tiny male genitals” “Evitol” shampoo “Dandruff” shampoo Brazil Schweppes Tonic Water Italy Schweppes Toilet Water Back-translation • The translating of a foreign language version back to the original language by a different person than the one who made the first translation Reading from left to right? Arab U.S. countries Print Ad Dirty Clean Gestures U.S. “O.K.” Arab countries extreme hostility Korea & Japan “money” France “zero” or “worthless” Brazil & Greece Tunisia vulgar connotation “I’ll kill you” Gestures “Hi” “Wai” U.S. Thailand In a U.S. ad for Afrin… The voiceover notes… “When you’re congested, it’s like your nose takes over… you need Afrin. Afrin works fast. While cold tablets travel through your system, Afrin goes right to your nose. So it works four times faster than the leading cold tablet and relieves congestion in less than five minutes. Afrin. Because you shouldn’t have to wait to breath…” In US commercials, the product is positioned as fast acting, long lasting, allows users to avoid spending time unproductively. Religion Nike “Air Melt”, “Air Grill” “Flames” “Allah” in Arabic script High and Low Context High Context Culture Low Context Culture • Implicit, ambiguous communication • Long term relationships • Homogenous culture • Japan, Saudi Arabia • Explicit, unambiguous communication • Short term relationships • Heterogeneous culture • U.S., Switzerland “I am ____________________” Stacey – – – – – “I am charming” “I am a Roman Catholic” “I am tall” “I am honest” “I am with a sense of humor” Independent Self-construal Quentin – – – – – “I am a family man” “I am a resident of Syracuse” “I am smart” “I am an American” “I am a good friend” Interdependent Self-construal Analytical vs. Holistic Cognition • West – – – – – Analytical Content-focused Category-based Field-independent Internal attribution • East – – – – – Holistic Context-focused Relationship-based Field-dependent External attribution B A What goes with this? A or B Overcoming Cultural Barriers • Barriers to successful international advertising – Ethnocentrism • Tendency to view and value things through one’s own culture – Self-Reference Criterion (SRC) • Unconscious reference to own cultural values, experiences, and knowledge to make decisions Media Challenges • Availability and coverage – Not all media are pervasive – Some ads are not acceptable – Local knowledge is important for print • Costs and Pricing – Rates must be negotiated – Global coverage is expensive – Bidding can escalate prices further Regulatory Challenges • Can you use: – Ads directed to children? – Foreign languages in ads? – National symbols in ads? Ad Campaigns: Global versus local Global Campaigns Message Market A Local Campaigns Message 1 Market B Message 2 Market C Message 3 Would international consumers understand the storyline and characters? Click Bar To Start Video Rewind Video Next Slide Clydesdale • Wikipedia: – The Clydesdale is a breed of draft horse named after and derived from hard-working farm horses of Clydesdale (now Lanarkshire), Scotland. They are perhaps most famous for their use as the mascot of beer company Anheuser-Busch's Budweiser brand.