SHORT-TERM FINANCING Financial Management II 2002/2003 Sergio Diez Petr Mestančík Rosalia Flamarique Jari Axen INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................. 3 Current Assets Financing Policies .............................................................................. 3 Conservative Approach .............................................................................................. 3 Maturity Matching or “Self-Liquidating” Approach ................................................. 4 Advantages of Short-Term Financing........................................................................ 5 Speed .......................................................................................................................... 5 Flexibility ................................................................................................................... 6 Costs........................................................................................................................... 6 Disadvantages of Short-Term Financing ................................................................... 6 Risk ............................................................................................................................ 6 MAIN SOURCES OF SHORT-TERM FINANCING ......................................... 6 Accruals ........................................................................................................................ 7 Accounts Payable ......................................................................................................... 7 Bank Loans ................................................................................................................. 12 Secured Loans .......................................................................................................... 12 Unsecured Loans ...................................................................................................... 14 The Cost of Bank Loans .......................................................................................... 16 Commercial Papers .................................................................................................... 21 Corporate Bond Market ........................................................................................... 22 Other Sources of Short-Term Financing ................................................................. 23 Factoring .................................................................................................................. 23 Pledging Accounts Receivable ................................................................................ 26 Inventory Financing ................................................................................................. 27 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................... 27 SOURCES ..................................................................................................... 28 -2- Introduction Some companies use current liabilities as a major source of financing for current assets, while others rely more heavily on long-term debt and equity. Since the different sources of financing have got different proc and cons, the aim of this paper is to analyze possible current assets financing policies with emphasis on short-term sources of financing. The short-term credit is defined as any liability originally scheduled for payments within one year. The four main sources of short-term financing are accruals, accounts payable, bank loans and commercial papers. In order to determine company’s current assets financing policy, we divide current assets into two main categories - temporary and permanent current assets. There are some periods in which the enterprises accumulate more assets than in others. In the periods in which the economy is strong, all the businesses must build up current assets. These assets are called temporary current assets. Other types of assets that the company has are the permanent current assets, which are the current assets that the companies maintain also in the periods when the economy slacks off. Considering the proportion between short-term and long-term financing, we can find three different manners of current asset financing policy. Current Assets Financing Policies Conservative Approach Here we can see the first financing policy. In this model all the permanent capital is being used to finance all permanent assets requirements and also part of the seasonal needs. In this model the firm uses a small amount of short- term debt. It is because the enterprise meets a part of the seasonal needs by storing liquidity in the form of marketable securities. It is a very safe, conservative current asset financing policy. -3- Figure 1 Conservative Financing Policy Marketable Securities Short-Term Requirements $ Permanent Level of Current Assets Long-Term Debt + Equity + Spontaneous Current Liabilities Fixed Assets Time Period Maturity Matching or “Self-Liquidating” Approach In this model the enterprises try to match assets and liabilities maturities. Here the maturity structure of its assets and liabilities match exactly. But in the real life we cannot see exactly this model. Firms use short-term and long-term sources of financing, but not with an exact maturity matching because: There is uncertainty about the lives of assets, so it is impossible to match exactly the assets and liabilities maturities. Some common equity must be used; common equity has no maturity. Figure 2 $ Maturity Matching Financing Policy Temporary Current Assets Short-Term Financing Requirements Permanent Current Assets Long-Term Debt + Equity + Spontaneous Current Fixed Assets Liabilities Time Period -4- Aggressive Approach In this approach, a part of permanent current assets and the temporary current assets are financed by short-term sources. Here we can find different degrees of aggressiveness depending on what proportion of permanent current assets and/or fixed assets is financed by short-term financing instruments (more aggressive approach, the lower the dashed line). In this non-conservative position, the firm would be very much subject to dangers from rising interest rates as well as to loan renewal problems, but some firms prefer this position because short-term debt is often cheaper than longterm debt. Figure 3 $ Aggressive Financing Policy Temporary Current Assets Short-Term, Nonspontaneous Debt Financing Permanent Current Assets Lon-Term Debt + Equity + Spontaneous Current Fixed Assets Liabilities Time Period Advantages of Short-Term Financing Speed It is faster and easier to obtain a short-term loan than a long-term loan. Lenders will make a deeper financial examination before they approve a long-term loan than in a case of short-term loan. Long-term loans have to be concreted in a considerable detail, because a lot can happen during the life of a 10 to 20 year loan. -5- Flexibility If the needs for funds are not periodic, investor might prefer short-term financing by three reasons. Firstly, flotation costs are smaller for short-term debt than for long-term debt. Secondly, if the firm decides to repay the long-term debt earlier, the long-term loans include a prepayment provision, which makes long- term debt more expensive. Finally long-term agreements always contain provisions, or obligations, which are specified in the contract. These restrictions constrain the firm’s future actions. Costs It is usual that the interest rate, which is paid in short-term debt, is lower than in longterm debt. Hence, the yield curve is normally upward sloping. Disadvantages of Short-Term Financing Risk Short-term credit is riskier than long term credit because: Interest rate, which is charged in a long-term financing, is usually stable over the time, while in short-term financing, the interest rate fluctuates widely. If a firm borrows heavily in a period of time, in which a recession is recorded. The company might be then forced into the bankruptcy, because it might be unable to repay the loan. Main Sources of Short-Term Financing The companies have got several possibilities of short-term financing. Since the different sources of short-term financing have got different advantages and disadvantages, in the following part, we focus on each type of short-term financing. First, we deal with accruals, then with accounts payable and bank loans, and finally with commercial papers and other financial instruments. -6- Accruals Accruals are kind of a debt that have been incurred or accumulated over a period of time, but not has been paid yet. In a balance sheet of a company, we can find accrued wages and/or accrued income taxes, which increase automatically as the company is expanding its operations. On the one hand, this type of debt is free and the company can use it without having to pay any explicit interest. On the other hand, the companies have got a little control over the levels of these accounts1. Accounts Payable Another possibility of short-term financing represent accounts payable, which are also called trade credit. Although accounts payable are the largest single category of shortterm financing, their role is often neglected, because some managers confuse company’s account payables management with the vendor’s account receivable management, and simply adopt supplier’s credit policy. In this case, the payables system is often seen as the bill paying mechanism only. Since the bills must be paid on time, the standardization and automation of the process of settling the bills with keeping the track of when and to whom should the company pay, might be seemingly the only opportunity for operating efficiency gains. This is really far from truth. Since accounts payable can be easily controlled, they are together with inventory and accounts receivable probably the best place to improve the company’s cash position. This holds especially for small businesses, which are likely to have limited access to capital, so they often rely especially on accounts payable2. Accounts payable are spontaneous source of short-term financing; they are customary part of doing business. They are the obligation due to trade partners, they exist, because customers prefer to receive goods now and pay later, so the seller offers delivery of goods or services prior to receiving cash payment. Instead of collecting 1 Since the timing of paying wages is set by economic forces and industry customs, the company can not change it. 2 In the case that company’s level of accounts payables exceeds the level of accounts receivables, the company is said to be receiving net trade credit, which is usually the case of small companies; otherwise company is extending its extending net trade credit. -7- money, supplier, in fact, provides a loan to the customer. The amount of loan, or credit, provided by the vendor depends on two main factors. The level of sales, and consequently the level of purchases is the first one, and the grace period, or the time gap between invoice date and payment date is the second one. The size of time period provided differs from company to company and depends on the vendor’s credit policy. Trade terms might, for example, take form Net 30 from invoice date, which requires payment within 30 days from invoice date; or Net 30 from shipment, which requires payment within 30 days from the shipment date; or 1/10, Net 30. In the last example, 1% discount is offered from the market, or the list price, if the payment is made within 10 days from the invoice date, otherwise customer is obliged to pay the full list price within 30 days from the invoice date. The last possibility is the most complex and the most interesting one, because company has got several options when to pay its bills. First, the company might decide to take the discount and pay within 10 days. Second, the company might pass up the discount and pay within 30days. Third, the company might get away with late payments and pay, for example, within 60 days; Fourth, the company might pay its bills, for example, on 15 th day and still take discount. The main objective of accounts payable management is to decide the payment date. Which option will be taken depends on two offsetting factors. On the one hand, there are the benefits from holding on the cash; on the other hand, there are also the costs. So the only problem is evaluation and comparison of the benefits and the costs. Although solution might look simple, it is actually rather complex, especially in the case of late payments, because of the presence of the indirect, subjective costs, arising from broken relationship, late payer treatment and so on. In order to determine the cost of trade credit in general, we assume that the company buys from its suppliers it terms X/Y, Net Z. As was already explained, that means that the company is offered discount of X% from the list price if it pays within Y days from the invoice date, otherwise it has to pay the full list price within Z days. We first -8- consider only two possible actions – the company can take the discount and pay in X days, or not to take discount and pay the full list price in Y days without delaying the payments beyond this date. We also assume payments on the last possible day of given period, because as we will see later, there is no sense in paying earlier. Using this trade term, trade credit can be divided into two components. Firstly, there is a free trade credit, which contains trade credit obtained during the discount period. Secondly, there is a costly trade credit, which is the remainder after the deduction of a free trade credit from overall trade credit. When the company decides not to take discount and extend its trade credit, it has to pay the full list price, or in other words, the company must pay financial charge to its supplier for providing additional funds. That means that the list price can be also treated as consisting of two components, the true price list price * (1 - X) and the financial charge list price * X . This distinction is important not only for accounting purposes3, but also for determining the cost of trade credit. Since the average accounts payable are determined by the level of purchases and the time gap between invoice date and the payment date, the average company’s accounts payable in the case of taking discount and paying on day Y are equal to average daily purchases multiplied by the number of days in discount period, thus (list price * (1 - X) * Q) / 360 * Y . Q in the previous term denotes yearly purchased quantity. If the company decides not to take discounts, its average accounts payable will be equal to ((list price * (1 - X) * Q) / 360) * Z. If the company passes up the discount, it gains additional funds ((list price * (1 - X) * Q) / 360) * (Z Y) . The company is not given additional funds for free, but for the price of the lost discount, or list price * X * Q . Hence, the nominal annual cost rate of the additional trade credit (NAR) is NAR list price * X * Q X 360 * ((list price * (1 - X) * Q) / 360) * (Z Y) 1 X Z Y The nominal annual cost rate of trade credit can be also interpreted as the cost of trade credit per period - expressed by the term X /(1 X ) , multiplied by the number of periods a year, in which is additional trade credit provided - term 360 /( Z Y) . 3 According to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles it is allowed to record gross purchases unless the discounts take material form. If the discount is in material form, purchases must be recorded net of discounts. -9- Since the (NAR) formula does not take into account compounding, the nominal annual cost rate of trade credit will be lower than effective annual cost rate of trade credit (EAR). To obtain effective annual cost rate of trade credit we use the following relationship EAR (1 period rate) #of compounding periods 1 . Thus, in our case, the effective annual cost rate of trade credit is equal to EAR (1 X /(1 X)) 360 /(ZY ) 1. If the company is effectively borrowing money, it should pass up the discount only if there is no other possibility of shortTable 1 term financing at a lower cost than the Sensitivity analysis Credit terms 1/10, Net 20 1/15, Net 20 1/10, Net 30 1/15, Net 30 1/10, Net 45 1/15, Net 45 3/10, Net 20 3/15, Net 20 3/10, Net 30 3/15, Net 30 3/10, Net 45 3/15, Net 45 5/10, Net 20 5/15, Net 20 5/10, Net 30 5/15, Net 30 5/10, Net 45 Nominal cost 36.36% 72.73% 18.18% 24.24% 10.39% 12.12% 111.34% 222.68% 55.67% 74.23% 31.81% 37.11% 189.47% 378.95% 94.74% 126.32% 54.14% Effective cost 43.59% 106.19% 19.83% 27.28% 10.89% 12.82% 199.38% 796.26% 73.02% 107.72% 36.79% 44.12% 510.69% 3629.47% 147.12% 234.10% 67.70% 5/15, Net 45 63.16% 82.79% cost of trade credit. As we see from the table, the cost of trade credit, expressed both in nominal annual cost rate and effective annual cost rate, is highly dependent on the discount granted as well as on the grace period provided by the supplier to foot the bill, and might significantly vary. In general, when managing accounts payable, for companies, it is too expensive to turn down the discount and pay the full list price. However, there are some possible actions companies can take in order to reduce unfavorably high cost of trade credit. In short, companies might get away with late payments, or in other worlds, stretching their accounts payable. For example, company might buy in term 1/10, Net 20, but actually behave in term 1/10, Net 45; or buy in term 1/10, Net 20, but in fact pay on 15th day and still take the discount. As we see from the table, befits from such behavior are obvious. As was already mentioned, the costs of trade credit in case of paying late are the direct, objective ones, but also indirect, subjective ones, which are hardly measurable. The explanation of determination of the subjective variables is beyond the scope of this presentation, but we would like to present here at least the basic features of the model. Although the concept of taking into account both direct and indirect cost is rather complicated, the - 10 - basic idea is still the same – as long as the costs are lower than the benefits, the payment should be delayed and the cash withhold in the company. Whenever the company decides such an action, it must carefully consider possible impacts on relationship with its supplier. Having all the cost available, we can use the following formula to obtain number of days the company should delay its payments beyond the date provided by the supplier (Daily benefits - Daily direct costs)/Dai ly indirect costs . Further delaying payments beyond the optimal date that was obtained from the above equation is inconvenient for the company, because it brings more costs than the benefits. From the previous section we know that the company should use costly trade credit only if there is no other possibility of short term financing from other sources at a lower price. Since the various sources of short term financing have got different impacts on the appearance of financial statements, it this section we focus our attention to that aspect of accounts payable. For simplicity, we assume the company that needs to raise additional $550.000 to cover its operations. The company buys in term 1/10, Net 30 and takes the discount. It has only one supplier and average yearly gross purchases of $10.000.000. We consider two possibilities of financing. First, 10% interest bank loan. Second, turning down the discount and extending trade credit. In both situations, we assume accruals and common equity accounts to be unchanged. In the first case, the company borrows the amount needed from the bank. In the second situation, the company passes up the discount and extends its payment term, but it still pays its bills on time. In the first case, the average level of its accounts payable is $275.000. In the second case, average payables are $825.000. If the company carries on taking the discount, an interest expense is incurred, but it avoids the discounts loss. Since in this example the cost of trade credit - discount loss is higher that the cost of bank loan - interest expense, the company should follow the policy of taking discount and borrowing from the bank, which results in higher net income, thus, in higher stock price. - 11 - Table 2 Company buys in terms 1/10, Net 30 Effects on the Financial Statements Do not take discounts; Take discount; use maximum trade Difference (1)borrow from bank credit without delaying (2) (1) payments (2) Balance sheet Cash and equivalents Account receivable Inventories Current assets Fixed assets Total assets 500,000.00 1,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 3,500,000.00 2,980,000.00 6,480,000.00 500,000.00 1,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 3,500,000.00 2,980,000.00 6,480,000.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Accounts payable Notes payable Accruals Current liabilities Common equity Total liabilities and equity 275,000.00 550,000.00 655,000.00 1,480,000.00 5,000,000.00 6,480,000.00 825,000.00 0.00 655,000.00 1,480,000.00 5,000,000.00 6,480,000.00 -550,000.00 550,000.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 14,000,000.00 9,900,000.00 3,000,000.00 55,000.00 0.00 1,045,000.00 418,000.00 627,000.00 14,000,000.00 9,900,000.00 3,000,000.00 0.00 100,000.00 1,000,000.00 400,000.00 600,000.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 55,000.00 -100,000.00 45,000.00 18,000.00 27,000.00 Income statement Sales Cost - Purchases - Labour - Interest - Discount loss EBT Taxes (40%) Net Income Bank Loans Loans are for non-financial corporations the second in importance after trade credit as a source of short-term financing. Short-term loan is a debt, for which the scheduled repayment and the anticipated use for the money is expected to be a year or less. Bank loans to businesses are frequently written as 90-days notes, so the loan must be repaid or renewed at the end of 90 days. Short-term loans are often used to raise the cash for cyclical inventory needs, accounts payable, and working capital. Secured Loans Secured loan is a form of debt in which specific assets have been pledged to guarantee payment. A secured loan is a promise to pay a debt, where the promise is secured by granting the creditor an interest in specific property of the debtor. If the debtor - 12 - defaults on the loan, the creditor can recover the money by seizing and liquidating the specific property used as collateral on the debt. Collateral may be defined as property that secures a loan or other debt, so that the property may be seized by the lender if the borrower fails to make proper payments on the loan. When lenders demand collateral for a secured loan, they are seeking to minimize the risks of extending credit. Because the value of pledged collateral is critical to a secured lender, loan conditions and covenants, such as insurance coverage, are always required from borrower. You can also expect a lender to minimize the risk by conservatively valuing your collateral and by lending only a percentage of its appraised value. The maximum loan amount, compared to the value of the collateral, is known as the loan to value ratio. In addition, many lenders will require their claim to the collateral to be a first secured interest, meaning that no prior or superior liens exist, or may be subsequently created, against the collateral. By being a priority lien holder, the lender ensures his/her share of any foreclosure proceeds before any other claimant is entitled to any money. Properly recorded security interests in real estate or personal property are matters of public record. Because a creditor wants to have a priority claim against the collateral, being offered to secure the loan, the creditor will search the public records to make sure that prior claims have not been filed against the collateral. If the collateral is real estate, the search of public records is often done by a title insurance company. The company prepares a "title report" that reveals any pre-existing recorded secured interests or other title defects. If the loan is secured by personal property, the creditor typically runs a "U.C.C. search" of the public records to reveal any pre existing claims. The cost of a title search or a U.C.C. search is often passed on to the prospective borrower as part of the loan closing cost. In start up businesses, a commonly used source of collateral is the equity value in real estate. The borrower may simply take out a new, or second, mortgage on his or her residence. In some states, the lender can protect a security interest in real estate by retaining title to the property until the mortgage is fully paid. - 13 - Example: A lender might be willing to loan only 75 percent of the value of new commercial equipment. If the equipment was valued at $100,000, it could serve as collateral for a loan of approximately $75,000. Unsecured Loans Unsecured loan is also a promise to pay a debt. Unlike a secured loan, the promise is not supported by granting the creditor an interest in any specific property. The lender is relying on the creditworthiness and reputation of the borrower to repay the obligation. An example of an unsecured loan is a revolving consumer credit card. Sometimes, working capital lines of credit are also unsecured. If the borrower defaults on an unsecured loan, the creditor has no priority claim against any particular property of the borrower. The creditor can try to obtain just a money judgment against the borrower. Until a small business has an established credit history, it cannot usually get unsecured loans because of the business's risk. If the debtor encounters financial difficulties, an unsecured creditor is often the last in line to collect. If a small-business debtor is forced into bankruptcy, an unsecured loan in the bankruptcy estate will usually be "wiped out" by the bankruptcy, but no assets typically remain to pay these low priority creditors. Aspects that can include one loan: Promissory note - traditional bank lending arrangement. When a bank loan is approved,, the agreement is executed by signing a promissory note. The note specifies the amount borrowed; the interest rate; the repayment schedule, which can call for either a lump sum or series of installments; any collateral that might have to be put up as security for the loan; and any other terms signed, the bank credits the borrowers checking account with the funds, so on the borrowers balance sheet both cash and notes payable increase. Compensating balances Sometimes, the banks require borrowers to maintain an average demand deposit balance equal to 10 to 20 percent of the face amount of the loan. This makes the money unavailable for use and increases the cost of borrowing, because the interest is - 14 - paid on the total amount of borrowing, which includes the money the borrower can not touch. Recent surveys indicate that compensating balances are much less common now than 20 years ago. In fact, compensating balances are now illegal in many states. Different Types of Unsecured Loans Informal Line of Credit: relatively informal, nonbonding agreement between the bank and borrowing firm that specifies the maximum amount that can be borrowed during a time period. Example: M&M Beverage Company has a $300,000 line of credit that requires a compensating balance equal to 10 percent of the loan amount. The interest rate paid on the loan is 12 percent annually. $200,000 is borrowed for a six-month period. The firm does not currently have a deposit with the lending bank, so the compensating balance has to be borrowed. loan borrowed = amount wanted + (%CB* loan borrowed) loan borrowed - (%CB * loan borrowed) = amount wanted (1 - %CB) loan borrowed = amount wanted loan borrowed = amount wanted/(1-%CB) loan borrowed 200,00/0.9 = 222,222. → borrow = $222,222 → get 200,000, CB 10%*222,222 = 22,222 borrow $222,222 for 6-month period interest is 12% per year interest = 12% * 222,222 * 6 /12 = $13,333.32 Annual Percentage Rate (APR) = pay/get * 360/n = 13,333.32 * 12/6 = 13.33% borrow $222,222 → get only $200,000 C.B. $22,222 If the loan is discounted, the loan interest will be deducted from the loan amount when borrowed. get only $ 222,222 - $22,222 (CB) - $13,333 (Int.) = $186,666.68 - 15 - *APR = 13,333.32/186,666.68 * 12 /6 = 14.29% Revolving Credit Agreement: is a formal line of credit. Bank guarantees the availability of funds up to a maximum amount during the specified time period. The borrower pays a commitment fee that can be explained as a percentage interest on the non-borrowed balance of the agreement. Interest rates are generally variable and tied to the prime rate. This revolving credit agreement is very similar to an informal line of credit, but whit an important difference: the bank has a legal obligation to honor a revolving credit agreement, and it receives a commitment fee. Clean-up clause often appears in line of credit. It requires the borrower to reduce the loan balance to zero at least once a year. The Cost of Bank Loans We can say in general that the cost of bank loans varies for different types of borrowers at any given point in time and for all borrowers over time. The borrowers have to pay higher interest rate if they like risk and if the quantity of the loan is small because of fixed cost involved in providing and servicing loans. The prime rate is one of the lowest rates. If the firm has financial strength, it can borrow to this rate, and if the firm is strong customer, sometimes it can borrow at rates below than prime rate. Bank rates vary widely over time depending on economic conditions and Federal Reserve policy. The terms regarding short-term bank loans are spelled out in the promissory note. This are the principal elements contained in most promissory notes: Interest only versus amortized Interest only: only interest is paid during the life of the loan and the principal is paid when the loan matures. Amortized: Some of the principal is repaid on each payment date. Collateral. Loan guarantees If the borrower is a small corporation, its banks will probably insist the larger stockholders personally to guarantee the loan. Nominal, or stated, interest rate - 16 - The interest rate can be either fixed or floating. Frequency of interest payment Maturity Tells when the loan must be repaid or renewed. Short-term loans may or may not have a specified maturity. Discount interest Add-on basis instalment loans Other cost elements Some loans require compensating balances or commitment fee, this increases the cost of the loan. Key-person insurance Some companies use this possibility to avoid failing to repay the loan when one of the key individuals dies. The Financing Cost The financing cost is the rate that must be earned to satisfy the required rate of return of the firm's investors. If financing cost is reduced, NPV increases, more projects end up with NPV > 0, more wealth is created to shareholders. We will analyze the calculation of the effective cost of different bank loans. There are two procedures for short-term business loans: regular, simple interest and discount interest. Regular and Simple Interest This is the most common procedure for short-term bank loans, based on an interestonly loan. When we have to negotiate the conditions of the loan with the bank, we have to get an agreement to when will be the interest paid. The effective interest rate on a loan depends on frequency of interest payments, the more frequently, the higher effective rate. We will demonstrate this with two examples, first with interest paid annually and second with quarterly payments. For illustration, we assume a loan of $11000, at a nominal interest rate of 13%, by 365 days a year. First of all, we calculate the interest rate per day: - 17 - Interest rate per day Nominal rate Days per year Interest per day = 0.13/365 = 0.000356164. If we want know the quantity we have to pay for period, we have to apply the following formula: Interest charge for period Days in period Rate per day Amount of loan ) Interest Paid Annually If the interest is paid annually, the borrower gets in period 0 $11000 and he has to give back 11000 plus the interest that will be calculated 11000 1 0.13 11300 The effective cost of the loan is 13%. Interest Paid Quarterly If the interest is paid quarterly, and each year has 365 days, each quarter is 91 days, but one quarter will be 92. If we want to calculate the interest we have to pay, we will use the previous formula. Hence, we have 92 0.000356164 11000 360.437. This amount will be paid three periods. At the end we have to pay $12430. The effective interest rate in this period is equal to: Effective Annual Rate= (1+i/n) n –1. Thus, we obtain (1+0.13/4) 4 -1=13.64%. As we can see in these examples, if the interest is paid more times, the effective annual rate increases. The effective annual rate would be higher if the bank used a 360-day year. Discount Interest If the agreement with the bank is discount interest loan, the bank deducts the interest in advance. Thus, the borrower receives less than the face value of the loan. We are going to considerate the same characteristics than in the previous case. And as above we are going to illustrate in two examples, when the interest is paid annually and when is paid quarterly. Discount Interest, Paid Annually - 18 - If the loan is $11000 and the interest rate is 13%, the interest amount will be: 11000*(0.13)=1430, this is why the borrower only can use 11000-430=$9570 With this we can calculate the effective interest rate. We get $9570 in period 0, but after one year we have to give back $11000. We know the present value and the future value, so the effective interest rate is 11000=9570*(1+i)1, hence 14.94 percent. If a discount loan matures in less than a year, for example after one quarter, we have this situation: Discount Interest, One Quarter If the annual interest rate for one year is 13 percent, for one quarter will be, (divided by 4) 0.0325 The amount that we will use is: 11000*(1-0.0325)=$10642.5. Our effective interest rate will be: 11000=10642.5*(1+i) ¼ Hence, effective interest rate is 14.13 percent Unlike the regular interest we have explained before, in the discount interest shortening the period of a discount loan, lowers the effective interest rate. Installment Loans: Add-On Interest An installment loan is a structured loan to be paid back in a specified timeframe, available with both fixed and variable rates. Loan term can vary from a few months to a few years. You can obtain competitive rates that reward your strong payment history, and you have multiple payments options. Business installment loans offer predictable monthly payments that can be incorporated into a company's budget. They're ideal for companies that need fixed-asset financing for machinery, office equipment or a new vehicle. We can calculate the charge of installments loans as simple interest or add-on interest. Now we will explain the add-on interest. The addon interest means that the interest is calculated and then added to the amount received to determinate the loans face value. - 19 - To illustrate this, we borrow $10000 on an add-on basis at a nominal rate of 12% percent to buy a car, with the loan to be repaid in 12 monthly installments: Finance charges are calculated on the original loan amount: (10000)*(0.12) = 1200. Have to be added these charges to principal: $1200+$10000 = 11200. Since the loan is paid off in monthly installments, you have the use the full money for the first month only, and the outstanding balance declines until, during the last month, only 1/12 of the original loan will be outstanding. We can calculate the approximate annual rate as follows: Approximate annual rate Add-on =Interest paid/(amount received)/2 1200/(10000/2) = 24%. The monthly payment is 11200/12 = $933.3. We pay all months 933.33$, but we receive today $10000 that will be the present value of the annuity. We calculate the internal monthly rate and we obtain 1.7880 percent. The effective annual rate Add-on = (1+kd)n -1 = (1.01788)12-1 = 23.7%. The annual percentage rate will be = 21.46%. APR rate = (periods per year)*(rate per period) = 12*(1.7880%) = 21.46%. How to Choose a Bank? Considering the fact that banks offer an increasing number of financial services at widely varying fees, choosing one to handle your particular financial needs might seem to be a difficult and confusing task. Although there is much to consider, it is best to select a bank the same way you would choose any product or service—first evaluate your needs and then compare cost. Some aspects to be considered when choosing the bank are highlighted bellow. Willingness to Assume Risks Banks have different basic policies towards risk. Some follow relatively conservative lending practices, while others engage in creative banking practices. Advice and Counsel Some bank loan officers are active in providing counsel and in granting loans to firms in their early and formative years. - 20 - Loyalty to Customers Banks services might be different in the confidence with the customers. While there are banks that in bad times can support the company if it has difficulties in liquidating the loan, others can put pressure. Specialization Banks differ in the degrees of loans specialization; larger banks have separate departments that specialize in different kinds of loans. Maximum Loan Size The maximum loan bank can make to any one customer is limited to 15 percent of the banks capital accounts and this can not be appropriate for large firms to have a borrowing relationship with small banks. Merchant Banking Merchant banking is generally the business of making private equity investments in non-financial firms, in particular equity investments with a venture capital character. Others services There are others services you have to consider when choosing a bank. Some banks provide cash management services, assist with electronic funds transfers, help firms obtain foreign exchange, etc. Commercial Papers The three principal means employed in the funding of economic enterprises are equity instruments, bonds, and bank lending. Over the years, much attention has been focused in the optimal ratio of debt to equity. In contrast, the “optimal” or best balance between bond financing and bank financing has scarcely been addressed. This is somewhat surprising because heavy average reliance on one or the other can have far reaching effects, especially on systemic risk, since the banking system is heavily leveraged and subject to regulatory imperfections. Investors in corporate bonds and related instruments appear to do a better job than bankers in deciding which enterprises to fund and on what terms – and thus in preventing the economy from - 21 - ending up in a crisis, while factors such as monetary policy, fiscal policy, and policies concerning capital controls clearly have an impact on economic performance. The only country with a well-functioning corporate bond market at this time is the United States. As a percentage of GDP, bond market financing in other countries is a small fraction of the U.S. number. Incidentally, countries where banks play a large role need higher savings rates to reach the same level of benefits, because returns on bank deposits are typically smaller than on bonds and on equities. Thus, a welldeveloped corporate bond market is associated with a substantial degree of disintermediation as well as a well-functioning market in derivatives, in which interest rate and currency risks, for example, are readily hedged. To qualify as well developed, a corporate bond market must also be free from government interference with the lending process. In addition, a smoothly operating market in government securities would typically be present in such an environment as well. Corporate Bond Market Having elaborated on the shortcomings of an over-bearing banking system, it is reasonable to ask just what it is that a well-developed corporate bond market brings to the party. The discipline of market forces as it relates to bonds, however, has many dimensions. A pre-condition of a genuine corporate bond market is that it must be free from government interference. Investors must feel free to base their decisions on economic criteria alone, such as risk and expected return. Pressure on bond investors or prices based on industrial policy, either direct or indirect, must be absent. Probably the single most important element of a well-functioning bond market is a financial reporting system for companies, which are relevant, reliable, and timely. The higher the quality of the borrower’s financial statements, the sounder the basis on which the potential investor can make decisions. There is some evidence that the higher the quality of a firm’s disclosure practices, the lower the effective interest cost at which its debt can be issued. A second key ingredient of a healthy corporate bond market is a strong community of financial analysts. The role of (buy-side) financial analysts is to provide investors with independent and informed advice. In effect, the value of a sound financial reporting system is multiplied by the presence of profession of financial analysts, since their evaluation of the companies is now made easier and can therefore result in a better product. Thus, an informative accounting system also tends - 22 - to raise the quality of analysts’ recommendations. Groups of analysts long ago began Table 3 Standard & Poor's A-1+ A-1 A-2 A-3 B C D forming rating agencies, of which Rating the best known are Moody’s, Moody's P-1 P-2 P-3 NP Explanation Prime rating High prime rating Medium prime rating Low prime rating Not prime rating Approaching insolvent Liquidation Insolvent liquidation Standard & Poor’s, and Fitch Investors. specialty Their is to particular assist bond investors by assigning companies and new issues a grade from a predetermined and well-known scale. Their reports provide a clear, objective basis for determining the “fair” interest rate for a given bond issue. Respected rating agencies are thus a key ingredient of a mature bond market. When rating short-term debt, you distinguish between prime ratings and not prime ratings, which are modified by 1, 2 and 3. Recent years have seen the emergence of new types of corporate debt instruments, in particular high-risk (junk) bonds and mortgage- and other asset-backed securities. This in turn has led to a sharp increase in demand for credit analysis, since sizing up the risks of default now becomes central in assessing the proper yields to make these instruments attractive to investors. As a consequence, a strong corps of credit analysts has become a central element of a well-developed corporate bond market. Other Sources of Short-Term Financing Factoring At some point a growing businesses usually faces a cash flow problem. In fact, research has shown that many growing businesses that fail do so because they owe more in the short term than they can pay short term. Traditionally businesses have gone to credit lines, credit cards and expensive shortterm bridge loans to get the cash they need to pay their bills. Often they will forgo tax payments to make ends meet. If their credit lines are tapped out, they may have to go - 23 - through a lengthy process to find new financing. If this process takes too long, the flow may be just too negative to survive. This seems paradoxical. How could a growing business -- that is actually profitable -go under? On closer examination it is not so ironic or surprising -- a large contract comes in that does not pay on time or a new market open up and management ramps up production and related costs. There are many other scenarios as well. But there is an alternative to going under. The general term for this alternative is factoring and accounts receivable financing. If your company has receivables or outstanding invoices you can get advances on these receivables. A factoring -- A/R financing company can advance you funds based on your receivables. Factoring can bridge the gap between billing and collections, enabling a business to match cash flow with cash needs. These companies can be finance companies, banks, factoring companies, capital corporations, etc. The dynamics are rather simple: you get up to about 80% of your receivables before your account pays. In some situations your customers may pay you directly and in other situations they pay the factoring company directly. When the balance is paid you get that as well -- minus the financing fee. This fee usually runs from 2-4% which does not sound like much except that the 2-4% can be the equivalent of a monthly fee. So the rates end Sup being somewhat comparable to a credit card rate. The factoring company does take on some degree of risk that they cover with their own insurance. Another big advantage is that most factoring can be done within several working days. Since factoring companies are not banks they do not have to go through a lengthy loan approval process. Some factoring companies boast they can have money in your hand in less than 24 hours. This can be very appealing if the proverbial wolves are at your door. One huge advantage is that these companies can advance money to companies with poor credit or even companies involved in bankruptcy proceedings. Obviously the easing of cash flow pressure is the primary benefit of factoring and A/R financing. Another benefit is that it does not require tying up assets as collateral to guarantee the loan. In other words, your company could use factoring-- A/R financing and still applies for traditional loans, credit lines, credit cards, etc. Since factoring is not a true 'loan' it does not affect the balance sheet, as would a traditional loan. - 24 - Another true advantage of factoring is that working capital can be recycled to fund growth. Many companies use factoring to recoup cost of goods sold so they can reinvest in expansion and meet increased market demands. In effect, through factoring they leave about 20% of their receivables 'out' so their future collections are their profit margins. Approval by factoring companies is not automatic. Normally your company must have a solid product/service, satisfied customers and credit-worthy customers. And factoring companies will not deal with small companies. Just like banks, they have to make profit. Many factoring companies will allow you to apply even before you need the money. This is very important if your company is in a cyclical or seasonal marketplace. The best business advice is to watch your money and monitor your cash flow. If you see your company running short of working capital, try to find a solution before your creditors do. Factoring and A/R financing may be a very desirable option! Example of Factoring Your company will bill your customers in the usual way, along with sending a copy of the invoices to the factoring company. The factoring company will then advance your business 75% to 90% of the face amount of the invoices thus retaining 10% to 30% as a reserve. The factoring company then takes the responsibility for collecting payment from your customers. Once the factoring company is paid on the invoices, they will release to your company the reserved amount previously withheld on the invoice, minus the appropriate financing fee for advancing the cash. The financing fee is based not on the strength of your company but rather on the quality of your accounts. The cost fluctuates according to the creditworthiness and performance of your customers. The fees can range from as low as 1% to 5% of the invoice amount normally 3 %, depending on the level of risk involved. The funding time for your first factoring transaction is usually 5 to 7 days. Once your account has been set up, cash can be advanced on your invoices and can be wire transferred to your bank account anywhere in the country within 24 hours. You can customize the program to fit your needs. There is no requirement to factor all your - 25 - invoices, you choose when and how much is factored (depending of course on your customers’ credit). Therefore, if you need cash to meet payroll or other expenses, you factor the invoices necessary to cover these bills. If not, you may retain the invoices and collect the cash as you are doing currently. OK so what are the differences? First, you will receive between 75% and 90% immediately. The difference is retained by the factor for his protection and fees. The interest is charged to you based on the number of days the cash was advanced to you. The retained amount (less the interest and factors fees) will be sent to you once your customer makes the payment to the factor. Here is an example: Face amount of Client's invoice $1000,000 Reserve Fund held for security $ 200,000 Cash Advanced to client from Factor $800,000 Customers Payment Received $1000,000 Factor Reserve Fund Refund Paid to Client $170,0004 Cash proceeds Retained by Factor $30,000 (fee) When you factor, you do not incur any debt, and there are no monthly payments. You control your cash flow by determining how much to factor, and when. When compared to the cost of maintaining receivables for 30 days or more, and the administrative expense associated with collections, factoring is a wise alternative to traditional financing from banks. Pledging Accounts Receivable The financial institution wants to protect itself and that’s why wants some pledges. Institutions never give loan what is the full of the pledged receivables. This is not so popular than factoring. 4 Fee is deducted from reserve. - 26 - Inventory Financing Blanket liens- the inventory blanket lien gives the lending institution a lien against all the borrowers’ inventories. But borrower can sell inventories and the value of the collateral can be used to the loan. Trust receipts- the inventory is held in trust for the lender. The borrower manages the goods and stock can be public warehouse or borrowers stock. All the sales have to pay to lender that means like daily payments. Warehouse receipts are one way to use inventory as security. This means that company uses inventory as security and that requires public notification, physical control of the inventory, and supervision by a custodian of the field warehousing concern. Warehouse is independent third-party and only stock for goods. Borrower has rights those good what is in the stock. Conclusion Companies have got several alternative policies they can follow in order to finance their current assets. Current assets’ financing policies differ from company to company and depend on the level of risk companies are willing to take. On the one hand, there is a very safe conservative approach, in which companies use very low amount of short-term financing; on the other hand, there is risky aggressive approach, in which proportion between short-term and long-term financing is higher. The higher is the proportion between short-term and long-term financing, the higher level of risk involved. Sources of short-term financing can be divided into four main categories. First, there are accruals, which are spontaneous source of short-term financing arising from accrued wages and taxes. Second, there are accounts payable, which are also spontaneous source of short-term financing, customary part of doing business. Accounts payable are obligations due to trade partners. They are usually the largest single category of short-term financing. Third, there are bank loans. The last main category of short-term financing represent commercial papers, which are issued by large corporations. - 27 - Sources [1] Brigham, Eugene F., Daves, Phillip R. – Intermediate Financial Management [2] http:// www.i2m.org/ftp/freepubs/1505.pdf [3] http://uwadmnweb.uwyo.edu/SBDC/fod/253.html [4] http://www.bof.fi/ [5] http://www.vm.fi/ - 28 -