San Diego Astronomy Association Celebrating Over 40 Years of Astronomical Outreach http://www.sdaa.org A Non-Profit Educational Association P.O. Box 23215, San Diego, CA 92193-3215 SDAA Business Meeting Next meeting will be held at: 3838 Camino del Rio North Suite 300 San Diego, CA 92108 January 14th at 7pm Next Program Meeting January 18th, 2014 at 7pm Annual Banquet Handlery Hotel & Resort CONTENTS January 2014, Vol LII, Issue 1 Published Monthly by the San Diego Astronomy Association $2.50 an issue/$30.00 year Incorporated in California in 1963 Annual Banquet...................1 December Minutes...........................3 February Program Meeting....................5 TDS Schedule.....................5 Januar y Calendar.........................6 S DA A C o n t a c t s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 AISIG Galler y..............................8 We b O n l y - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Space Place Partners’ Article..........11 AstroShort...........................13 January 2014 Annual Banquet Date: January 18th, 2014 Speaker: Dr. Douglas Leonard Topic: Supernovae, the catastrophic explosions of stars, are some of the most luminous events in the universe for the few weeks that they are at peak brightness. Dr. Leonard summarizes what we have learned about the nature of stars that ultimately explode as core-collapse supernovae from the examination of images taken prior to the explosion. Douglas Leonard is Associate Professor of Astronomy at San Diego State University, having previously served as National Science Foundation Astronomy and Astrophysics Postdoctoral Scholar at the California Institute of Technology and, prior to that, as a Postdoctoral Fellow with the Five College Astronomy Department in Amherst, MA. Dr. Leonard received his B.A. in astronomy and astrophysics from the University of Pennsylvania, and his M.S. and Ph.D. in astrophysics from the University of California, Berkeley. His publications include over 50 articles in the technical literature. A passionate science educator, his latest endeavors include work on several BBC/Horizon videos on black holes, cosmology, and the deaths of stars. Photo by Kelly Calligan / Daily Aztec Newsletter Deadline The deadline to submit articles for publication is the 15th of each month. Link to BBC/Horizon video on black holes, cosmology, and the deaths of stars. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mx5210jP7yY San Diego Astronomy Association You are cordially invited to The San Diego Astronomy Association’s Annual Banquet Saturday, January 18, 2014, 5:45 – 11:00 pm Handlery Hotel & Resort- 950 Hotel Circle North, San Diego, CA 92108 ____________________________________________________________ Speaker: Douglas Leonard, Associate Professor of Astronomy at San Diego State University. Topic: Supernovae, the catastrophic explosions of stars, are some of the most luminous events in the universe for the few weeks that they are at peak brightness. Dr Leonard summarizes what we have learned about the nature of stars that ultimately explode as core-collapse supernovae from the examination of images taken prior to the explosion. Cocktail hour is from 5:45 to 6:45 and dinner 7:00. Menu Choice of Entrees: Pork tenderloin, mint tomato jelly, veggies, apple sage dressing Cornish game hen with rice & veggies Chefs choice vegetarian dish Dessert: White chocolate cheesecake with raspberry sauce SDAA Banquet Order Form Use this form or order online at http://sdaa.org/banquet.htm Name______________________________________________________ Address____________________________________________________ City, State, Zip______________________________________________ Telephone__________________________________________________ Email______________________________________________________ Dinner Selections (Enter number of each) Pork____ Fowl ____ Vegetarian ____ Check here if requiring Sugar-free dessert____ Number Attending ____ @ $45 each Total Payment included $ _________ Mail to: San Diego Astronomy Association P.O. Box 23215 San Diego, CA 92193-3215 Page 2 *Make checks payable to SDAA Orders must be received no later than 01/14/2014 NO TICKETS WILL BE SOLD AT THE DOOR SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 San Diego Astronomy Association SDAA Board of Directors Monthly Business Meeting Minutes December 10, 2013-Unapproved and Subject to Revision 1. Call to order. The meeting was called to order at 7:14 pm with the following board members in attendance: Michael Vander Vorst; President; Mike Chasin, Vice President; Ed Rumsey, Treasurer; Kin Searcy, Corresponding Secretary; Brian McFarland, Recording Secretary; Jim Traweek, Director; Mike Finch, Director; Dave Wood, Director. 2. Approval of Last Meeting Minutes. Approved. 3. Priority / Member Business. None. 4. Standard Reports. Treasurer/Membership Report. • The report was approved. • Current membership tally is 497 members. Five (5) new members. Site Maintenance Report. No report. Observatory Report. • The dovetails for the Lipp scope arrived. • The Board approve the purchase of the following items for the observatory: lamps for the desks, two pairs of binoculars (the current pair is shot), miscellaneous tools for the warming room, and a 17mm Nagler to fill the gap between the 20mm and the 13mm (the Mose memorial may help to offset this purchase). Private Pad Report. • All pads are paid up and current. • Eleven pads are available. • One pad won’t be charged an annual fee due to unfortunate circumstances involving a recently expelled SDAA member. Program Report. • Michael Vander Vorst will emcee the banquet and Mike Chasin will assist with the auction. • Will try and schedule the IDA for May or June to coincide with the science fair winner awards. TDS Network. Dave W. will troubleshoot the system. We have a limited number of spare parts on hand. RoboScope. Dave W. will send the draft lease agreement to the BRIEF project for concurrence. AISIG Report. January will be the planning meeting, and February will probably be a beginner catch-up session. Governing Documents. Dennis Ritz may take this on. Newsletter. Great as always. Website. The webmaster has been adding door prizes/donations to the banquet and banquet donations pages as they come in, and removed “Roboscope” from the Contacts page and replaced it with “Loaner Scopes” associated with Ed Rumsey. SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 Page 3 San Diego Astronomy Association Outreach Committee Report. • The Poway Unified School District (PUSD) imposes far too many onerous rules and regulations on the SDAA for conducting star parties for their students. Contract signatures, special insurance riders, post party clean up responsibilities, etc., etc. are a few examples. No other school district imposes such bureaucracy. The SDAA cannot participate until PUSD corrects these issues. • Kin will be running a Boy Scout Astronomy Merit Badge program at Mission Trails. Merchandise. • Michael V. will solicit volunteers to fill the position of Merchandise Chairperson and for help with sales at the banquet. • Jim T. will assist in gathering merchandise stock from TDS storage to sell at the banquet. • Will investigate internet solution for merchandise sales. New Member Mentor. The updated totals for 2013 New Members is provided below. The last group was early this month; so, we may still have some additional new members that come in December. A final 2013 total will be available in January. We have also answered many questions that new members have had; and, have sent out “welcome back” packets to several members who were returning to SDAA after multi-year absences. 2013 SDAA Total New Memberships Month January February March April May June July August September October November December Total 2013 Contributing 7 4 2 2 6 2 7 6 3 6 6 Family of Contributing 4 1 1 51 3 2 3 4 4 2 1 25 Basic 6 3 Family of Lifetime Basic 3 1 6 3 4 4 3 1 4 1 32 2 1 3 12 1 Family of Total per Associate Lifetime Month 20 1 10 3 2 2 20 4 16 14 11 9 14 1 1 2 124 5. Old Business. Only seven members have signed up for the banquet so far. We need to get the word out. 6. New Business. • Spring cleanup will take place on the 17th of May, and there is a lot of work to do so lots of volunteers are needed. The SDAA will host a BBQ and we will have a dumpster on site for the two weeks leading up to the event. • North Pad – we need to demo the pad as it continues to deteriorate and is becoming a hazard. We will hire a demo firm for this. Following the demo, we will seek volunteers with experience in concrete work to see if we can accomplish the reconstruction in-house (and save lots of $$). A proposal to form a committee to procure all needed repairs was rejected as too expensive. • Tax Seminar – Ed R. attended a tax seminar for non-profits and brought back a lot of valuable information. There are some possible areas of concern that need to be researched (nothing too serious). We may be able to reduce our property tax liability, too. 7. Adjournment. Adjournment at 9:03pm. Page 4 SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 San Diego Astronomy Association February 19th Program Meeting Speaker: Dr. Kam Arnold Topic: The Atacama Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization Telescope Dr. Kam Arnold is an Assistant Research Scientist at the University of California, San Diego Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences. He received his Ph.D. from the University of California, Berkeley Physics Department working on the POLARBEAR CMB Polarization Experiment. Cosmology has transitioned over the past several decades, from a field without many tested predictions, to the cross-checked investigation of a model with percent-level uncertainties on its parameters. An essential component of this transition was characterization of the intensity fluctuation pattern in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), radiation that has been travelling through the universe for more than 13 billion years, from a time in the early universe before any stars or galaxies had formed. These measurements are a cornerstone in our model of a Universe that is geometrically flat, is mostly composed of matter and energy we know very little about, and began in a hot, dense mystery. The precision with which we have measured cosmological parameters is impressive, but we lack an understanding of the physics behind them. CMB polarization, as opposed to its intensity, offers a unique window onto cosmology and addresses some of the most mystifying questions of physics. We built a telescope above 17,000-ft elevation in the Atacama Desert in Northern Chile to observe CMB polarization. He will discuss CMB polarization science, and the novel instruments that are required to measure this faint signal. 2014 TDS SCHEDULE DATE Dr. Arnold hiking above the telescope in Chile MOON DATA SUNSET JAN 4 25 S- 9:04P 13% R- 1:22A 36% 4:54P 5:12P PUBLIC FEB 1 22 S- 7:48P 4% R-12:13A 28% 5:19P 5:38P PUBLIC MAR 1 22 29 S- 6:31P 0% R- 1:05A 57% S- 6:19P 2% 5:43P 6:59P PUBLIC 7:04 APR 19 26 R-11:56P 81% S- 5:06P 9% 7:19P PUBLIC 7:24P May 24 31 S- 3:59P 20% S-10:15P 7% 7:44P PUBLIC 7:48P JUN 21 28 R- 2:18A 23% S- 8:53P 1% 7:56P PUBLIC 7:57P JUL 19 26 R- 1:00A 36% R- 6:42A 0% 7:52 PUBLIC 7:48P AUG 16 23 R-11:42P 61% R- 5:30A 1% 7:29P PUBLIC 7:21P SEP 20 27 S- 4:44P 1% S- 8:51P 10% 6:44P PUBLIC 6:35P OCT 18 25 R- 3:03A 18% S- 7:33P 3% 6:08P PUBLIC 6:01P NOV 15 22 R-12:46A 33% S- 5:15A 0% 4:44P PUBLIC 4:41P DEC 13 20 R-11:28P 60% S- 3:55P 3% 4:41P PUBLIC 4:44P SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 Page 5 San Diego Astronomy Association Sunday Monday January 2014 Tuesday Wednesday Thursday 1 2 Friday 3 Saturday 4 Member Night TDS New Moon 5 6 7 8 Stars in the Park 12 19 13 20 14 TDS Middle School SDAA Business Meeting 21 15 Lakeview Science Night 22 AISIG Meeting 26 27 28 Vista Grande Elementary Page 6 29 Marshall Elementary Jerabek Elementary 9 10 Bay Park Elementary 16 Full Moon 23 Stars at Mission Trails 17 Stars at Sycamore Canyon 24 Sherman Elementary 30 Tierrasanta Elementary 11 31 Cub Scouts Vallecito Stage Station 18 SDAA Banquet 25 Public Star Party TDS 1 Member Night TDS SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 San Diego Astronomy Association SDAA Contacts Club Officers and Directors PresidentMichael Vander Vorst President@sdaa.org Vice President Mike Chasin VicePresident@sdaa.org Recording Secretary Brian McFarland Recording@sdaa.org Treasurer Ed Rumsey Treasurer@sdaa.org Corresponding Secretary Kin Searcy Corresponding@sdaa.org Director Alpha Dave Wood DirectorAlpha@sdaa.org Director Beta -Vacant- DirectorBeta@sdaa.org Director Gamma Michael Finch DirectorGamma@sdaa.org Director Delta Jim Traweek DirectorDelta@sdaa.org (858) 755-5846 (858) 210-1454 (619) 462-4483 (858) 722-3846 (858) 586-0974 (858) 735-8808 (760) 440-9650 (619) 207-7542 Committees Site Maintenance Bill Quackenbush TDS@sdaa.org(858) 395-1007 Observatory Director Jim Traweek Observatory@sdaa.org (619) 207-7542 Private Pads Mark Smith Pads@sdaa.org(858) 484-0540 Outreach Kin Searcy Ourtreach@sdaa.org (858) 586-0974 N. County Star Parties Doug McFarland NorthStarParty@sdaa.org (760) 583-5436 S. County Star Parties Benjamin Flores SouthStarParty@sdaa.org (619) 885-1291 E. County Star Parties Dave Decker EastStarParty@sdaa.org (619) 972-1003 Central County Star Parties Kin Searcy CentralStarParty@sdaa.org (858) 586-0974 Camp with the Stars Doug McFarland CampWiththeStars@sdaa.org (760) 583-5436 K.Q. Ranch Coordinator MichaelVander Vorst KQ@sdaa.org(858) 755-5846 Newsletter Andrea Kuhl Newsletter@sdaa.org (858) 547-9887 New Member Mentor Dan Kiser Mentor @sdaa.org (858) 922-0592 Webmaster Jeff Stevens Webmaster@sdaa.org (858) 566-2261 AISIG Kin Searcy AISIG@sdaa.org (858) 586-0974 Site Acquisition -Vacant- SecondSite@sdaa.org Field Trips -Vacant- FieldTrips@sdaa.org (425) 736-8485 Grants/Fund Raising -Vacant- Grants@sdaa.org Merchandising -Vacant- Merchandising@sdaa.org Publicity-Vacant- Publicity@sdaa.org Loaner ScopesEd Rumsey (858) 722-3846 Governing Documents TBD TDS Network Dave Wood TDSNet@sdaa.org (858) 735-8808 Amateur Telescope Making Peter De Baan pdebaan@hotmail.com (760) 745-0925 SDAA Editorial Staff Editor - Andrea Kuhl newsletter@sdaa.org Assistant Editor: Craig Ewing Have a great new piece of gear? Read an astronomy-related book that you think others should know about? How about a photograph of an SDAA Member in action? Or are you simply tired of seeing these Boxes in the Newsletter rather than something, well, interesting? Join the campaign to rid the Newsletter of little boxes by sharing them with the membership. In return for your efforts, you will get your very own by line or photograph credit in addition to the undying gratitude of the Newsletter Editor. Just send your article or picture to Newsletter@SDAA.Org. SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 Page 7 San Diego Astronomy Association AISIG Gallery New AISIG member Hiro Hakozaki took this very detailed image of M-45 out at TDS on the 1st of December. Using a stock Nikon D800 with a Stellarvue 90mm APO for the optics all mounted on a Celestron CGEM, Hiro spent a total of about 3.5 hours collecting the data that created this stunning image. MEMBERSHIP INFORMATION Send dues and renewals to P.O. Box 23215, San Diego, CA 92193-3215. Include any renewal cards from Sky & Telescope or Astronomy magazine in which you wish to continue your subscription. The expiration date shown on your newsletter’s mailing label is the only notice that your membership in SDAA will expire. Dues are $60 for Contributing Memberships; $35 for Basic Membership; $60.00 for Private Pads; $5 for each Family membership. In addition to the club dues the annual rates for magazines available at the club discount are: Sky & Telescope $32.95 and Astronomy $34. Make checks payable to S.D. Astronomy Assn. PLEASE DO NOT send renewals directly to Sky Publishing. They return them to us for processing. Page 8 SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 San Diego Astronomy Association While Hiro was taking in the night of the 1st at TDS, AISIG member Steve Armen set up in his back yard in Carlsbad and imaged the same object. Steve’s imaging train consisted of a QSI 683WSG Monochrome CCD utilizing an Astrodon gen 2 RGB filter set with a Pentax 105SDP for the optics all mounted on a Astrophysics Mach 1 mount. Total exposure time is 45 minutes. SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 Page 9 San Diego Astronomy Association Jim Thommes continues to produce very high quality images. This image of LBN317 was captured out at Blair Valley located in the Anza Borrego Desert. His optics included a Explore Scientific MN152 Mak-Newt mounted on Losmandy G-11. He used an SBIG ST8300M to collect the photons. Page 10 SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 San Diego Astronomy Association Space Place partners’ article December 2013 The Big Picture: GOES-R and the Advanced Baseline Imager By Kieran Mulvaney The ability to watch the development of storm systems – ideally in real time, or as close as possible – has been an invaluable benefit of the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites (GOES) system, now entering its fortieth year in service. But it has sometimes come with a trade-off: when the equipment on the satellite is focused on such storms, it isn’t always able to monitor weather elsewhere. “Right now, we have this kind of conflict,” explains Tim Schmit of NOAA’s National Environmental Satellite, Data, and Information Service (NESDIS). “Should we look at the broad scale, or look at the storm scale?” That should change with the upcoming launch of the first of the latest generation of GOES satellites, dubbed the GOES-R series, which will carry aloft a piece of equipment called the Advanced Baseline Imager (ABI). According to Schmit, who has been working on its development since 1999, the ABI will provide images more frequently, at greater resolution and across more spectral bands (16, compared to five on existing GOES satellites). Perhaps most excitingly, it will also allow simultaneous scanning of both the broader view and not one but two concurrent storm systems or other small-scale patterns, such as wildfires, over areas of 1000km x 1000km. Although the spatial resolution will not be any greater in the smaller areas than in the wider field of view, the significantly greater temporal resolution on the smaller scale (providing one image a minute) will allow meteorologists to see weather events unfold almost as if they were watching a movie. So, for example, the ABI could be pointed at an area of Oklahoma where conditions seem primed for the formation of tornadoes. “And now you start getting one-minute data, so you can see small-scale clouds form, the convergence and growth,” says Schmit. In August, Schmit and colleagues enjoyed a brief taste of how that might look when they turned on the GOES-14 satellite, which serves as an orbiting backup for the existing generation of satellites. “We were allowed to do some experimental imaging with this one-minute imagery,” Schmit explains. “So we were able to simulate the temporal component of what we will get with ABI when it’s launched.” The result was some imagery of cloud formation that, while not of the same resolution as the upcoming ABI images, unfolded on the same time scale. You can compare the difference between it and the existing GOES-13 imagery here: http://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/goes/blog/wpcontent/uploads/2013/08/GOES1314_VIS_21AUG2013loop.gif Learn more about the GOES-R series of satellites here: http://www.goes-r.gov. Kids should be sure to check out a new online game that’s all about ABI! It’s as exciting as it is educational. Check it out at http://scijinks.gov/abi SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 Page 11 San Diego Astronomy Association Space Place partners’ article December 2013 The Advanced Baseline Imager. Credit: NOAA/NASA. Download photo at: http://www.goes-r.gov/spacesegment/images/ABI-complete.jpg. Page 12 SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 San Diego Astronomy Association AstroShort AGORA: Seeing the Invisible Elephant of the cosmic web of large-scale structure in the cosmos. At small scales, computational models can calculate such details as shock waves from supernova explosions, turbulence, and chemical composition of gas and dust with a resolution (ability to discern details) the size of our solar system. At gigantic scales, cosmological simulations trace the evolution of the cosmic web in volumes hundreds of millions of lightyears across. At such scale, even the biggest supercomputers have been limited to handling just gravitational interactions of dark matter, if calculations are to be completed in reasonable time (months) and at affordable cost. And in the real Universe, both size scales interact: local star formation within individual galaxies is activated or quenched by the way galaxies “breathe” in and out the gaseous intergalactic medium. Often computational simulations do not create realistic-looking galaxies with the right proportion of stars in the central bulge compared with the flat disk or the right amount of clumpiness. You know the familiar fable about the blind men trying to discern the nature of an elephant simply from feeling the animal with their hands: one at the side of the elephant thought it was like a wall, one at the trunk thought it was like a snake, and one at the tail thought it was like a rope. Each accurately perceived the elephant in part, but their tactile observations were inconsistent with one another. Astronomers are much in the same position in trying to discern the nature of the Universe. Most of the gravitating mass in the cosmos is cold dark matter—a slowly moving, weakly interacting elementary particle that holds together both individual galaxies such as our own Milky Way as well as entire clusters of hundreds of galaxies. But humans are blind to it: dark matter does not emit light or other electromagnetic radiation. Thus, astrophysicists must rely on two tools to discern dark matter’s nature: 1) observations of visible ordinary matter (which scientists call baryonic matter) that reveal dark matter’s effects, and 2) supercomputer simulations to “reverse engineer” and test ideas of how dark matter might interact with ordinary matter to Differences in supercomputer simulations to be compared in the AGO- form galaxies. Just one big problem: RA project are clearly evident in this test galaxy produced by each of nine like the blind men studying only parts of the eledifferent versions of participating codes using the same astrophysics phant but whose observaand starting with the same initial tional results are not conconditions. The goal of AGORA is to sistent for the entire anianalyze such differences to improve mal, astrophysicists have the realism and predictive power of been able to model only supercomputer simulations, and thus parts of the universe beastronomers’ understanding of astrophysical processes. Credit: Simula- cause of limits to computions performed by Samuel Leitner (ART- tational power. And the II), Ji-hoon Kim (ENZO), Oliver Hahn computer models have (GADGET-2-CFS), Keita Todoroki been inconsistent. Yet (GADGET-3), Alexander Hobbs (GADGET-3-CFS and GADGET-3-AFS), reproducibility is a funSijing Shen (GASOLINE), Michael Kuh- damental principle of the len (PKDGRAV-2), and Romain Teyssier scientific method: only if (RAMSES) a result from an experiment can be independently reproduced by other scientists can it be regarded as robust. Now, a new ambitious multiyear international project AGORA is figuring out how to reveal the entire elephant— and also discern which of the inconsistencies are due to complexities of astrophysics versus computational issues. Further reading: The AGORA website is at https:// sites.google.com/site/santacruzcomparisonproject/. A UCHiPACC press release is at http://hipacc.ucsc.edu/PressRelease/ AGORA.html. A UC Santa Cruz press release at http:// news.ucsc.edu/2013/12/agora-project.html. The flagship paper preprint “The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project,” for Astrophysical Journal Supplement, is at http://arxiv.org/abs/1308.2669/. The challenge of scales One major challenge, for example, has been numerically modeling astrophysical processes over the vast range of size scales in the Universe—all the way from the formation of individual stars to the formation of galaxies to the formation The University of California High-Performance AstroComputing Center (UC-HIPACC), based at the University of California, Santa Cruz, is a consortium of nine University of California campuses and three affiliated Department of Energy laboratories (Lawrence Berkeley Lab, Lawrence Livermore Lab, and Los Alamos National Lab). UC-HiPACC fosters collaborations among researchers at the various sites by offering travel and other grants, co-sponsoring conferences, and drawing attention to the world-class resources for computational astronomy within the University of California system. More information appears at http://hipacc.ucsc.edu Major international collaboration Now supercomputers are starting to have the computational power to simulate large regions of the cosmos with sufficient resolution and realism to create galaxies that look like ones actually observed. AGORA—an ancient Greek word for meeting place, and an acronym for Assembling Galaxies of Resolved Anatomy—aims to understand and resolve inconsistencies revealed among simulations. AGORA got its start in a kick-off workshop at the University of California, Santa Cruz, in August 2012, under the sponsorship of the University of California HighPerformance AstroComputing Center (UC-HiPACC). A second workshop was held at UCSC in August 2013. AGORA, a collaboration of more than 90 astrophysicists and computational modelers in over 40 institutions in eight nations, is described in a flagship paper by Ji-hoon Kim and 45 co-authors that has been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement. The collaborators have set up methodology to compare and contrast the results with nine variants of different codes (programs for computer simulations), which numerically handle the physics and the computation in significantly different ways. Although not the first comparison of supercomputer simulations of galaxy evolution, AGORA is the most comprehensive and the highest-resolution (finest detail). The project is expected to be completed in 2015 and result in many papers. Stay tuned! –Trudy E. Bell, M.A. SAN DIEGO ASTRONOMY ASSOCIATION NEWS AND NOTES, JANUARY 2014 Page 13