Biol 321 Spring 2013 Final Exam Study Sheet Comments on final exam: By necessity the final exam is cumulative in the sense that much of the material that was covered earlier in the course is directly relevant to material we have discussed recently (ie. Linkage, meiosis and crossing over; mutations and cancer genetics and so forth). • The final exam is worth 90 pts. and will undoubtedly include questions testing your understanding of cancer genetics, DNA profiling, direct detection of genotype, gain and loss of function, linkage, haplotypes, positional cloning, geneXenviroment interactions & epigenetics • There will be at least one problem (~8 pts.) taken directly from either Assignment Set 8 or this review sheet • The content of your final will be similar to the S11 & W10 finals (posted online) • The Winter 2013 final was worth 90 pts: Section 1: 58 pts includes material covered before (some) and after (mostly) the midterm Section 2: 12 pts: choice of one of two options (reading comprehension & data analysis – mostly material predating midterm) Section 3: 20 pts: choice of two (10 pts each) of four options (new and old material) Option 1: Direct detection of genotype and other things Option 2: Genotype crunching and gene interactions Option 3: Probability Calculations Option 4: Choose one of two essay topics • Be sure to memorize the size of the human genome and the estimated number of genes in the human genome. • Be sure to review these lectures as you may see a couple of content-oriented questions: o From the last week of class: Complex traits, Epigenetics & DNA methylation o From earlier in the quarter: Genome structure and DNA profiling In addition to material covered most recently, be sure to review basic concepts: • Chapter 1 of text • Using models to explore biological processes • Mendel, basic probability and basic pedigrees • Polymorphic traits, alleles and sites • Complications to Mendel including the complex relationship between genotype and phenotype • Complementation, suppressors, modifiers, epistatic interactions • The molecular basis of mutation and the effect of mutation on gene function • Look at reading comprehension and data analysis problems from Assignment Set 5 & midterms exams 1 Final Exam Study Problems ** means that ANSWERS will be available for this question. Problem -1 ** Wild-type foxgloves have single flowers. In a population of flowers growing in British Columbia you discover a polymorphic variant that has double flowers. Pollen from the double plant is used to fertilize a wild-type plant obtained from the same location in BC. Two plants with double flowers are obtained from the cross. A second wild-type plant is obtained from the same area. A cross from this plant with the same double plant yields 4 single progeny. Assuming that this is a monogenic trait and that there are no complications, what can you conclude about dominance? Your answer should include: • Possible genotypes for each plant (be sure to define allele symbols) • A statement about what you can or cannot conclude • Be sure to support your conclusion with a clearly laid out set of arguments • Don’t be fooled by sample sizes here and include some probability calculations if you want Problem 0 Your mom sends you an email. She has read about a recent study indicating that regions of the human genome are evolving and have been under intense selection in the past 5000-15000 years since “we” as a species abandoned the hunter-gatherer lifestyle and took up agriculture. One gene that was discussed is this study is called the microcephaly (cephalon = head) gene. The investigators presented evidence that selection for certain allelic variations in this gene allowed our big brains to enlarge even further in the “recent” past. This gene had previously been identified in a study of a loss-of-function mutation in a Pakistani family. Your mom is puzzled by the name of this gene as it doesn’t seem to fit what she had read in the paper. Based on your understanding of how genes have traditionally been named, briefly enlighten your mother. Two sentences max. Problem 1 ** People with venous thrombosis suffer from blood that clots aggressively and inappropriately. This phenotype results from a mutation in the gene that codes for Factor V. This mutation (which we’ll call FVac for aggressive clotting) causes a single amino-acid substitution. Wild-type Factor V protein acts to accelerate the body’s clotting process and is normally under the control of a protein called APC that destroys Factor V after it has initiated the clotting process. The mutant Factor V is impervious to APC’s attack. Homozygotes for this mutant gene apparently show an even greater tendency to form clots than heterozygotes. Based on the information given above choose True, False or not enough Information given. T F I The FVac mutation is incompletely dominant to the wild-type allele. T F I The FVac mutation is a gain-of-function mutation. One sentence explanation Problem 2 More than 50% of severe childhood deafness is genetically determined. Recessive, loss-of-function mutations in any one of at least thirty different genes (named DFNB1….. DFNB-30) can cause severe childhood deafness without any other abnormalities. Recently 141 members of a large consanguineous (inbred) family segregating deafness were examined using a DNA based test for a specific mutant allele of the DFNB-26 gene. The frequency of this mutation allele in the general population is 0.0001. All deaf individuals (2 males and 6 females) were homozygous for the DFNB-26 mutation. Seven individuals with 2 normal hearing were identified that were also homozygous for this mutant allele. Interestingly, none of the deaf individuals, but all of the seven with normal hearing were found to heterozygous for a second mutation in another DFNB gene. (Nature Genetics 26: 431 2000) In 2-3 well-crafted sentences restate the content of this paragraph & use all the terms below that are applicable [to this example] pleiotropic sex-linked autosomal polymorphic variably expressed incomplete penetrance genetic heterogeneity dominant recessive suppression/suppressor modifier complementation additive gene action epistasis/epistatic Problem 3 ** A friend of yours gets a female cat from the pound that is deaf and has curled ears. He mates this animal with a male who is normal for both of these traits and came from a true-breeding normal line. Over a period of years, they produce a 4 of litters of kittens with the following phenotypes. Cross #1 deaf, curled female x wild-type male #of kittens Phenotype 10 deaf, curled ear 10 normal for both traits Your friend concludes that both ear problems result from a single pleiotropic mutation. Cross #2 Your friend selects a deaf, curled female cat who is one of the progeny from Cross#1. He mates her to a normal brother. To his surprise, one of 14 kittens (a female) has curled ears but is not deaf. Explanation #1 • Assumes that both traits result from a single pleiotropic gene. • Proposes that one of the parents of cross #1 was heterozygous for an unlinked recessive suppressor mutation that is specific for the hearing defect. Given this explanation, write out the genotypes of the parents of cross #2 and their curled kitten: s+ = wild-type allele s= recessive suppressor allele cd+ = wild-type cd = curled and deaf Explanation #2 Provide a completely different* genetic explanation for his observations from Cross #2. *This explanation cannot be variable expressivity due to developmental noise or the environment. • Define allele symbols and write out genotypes • Propose a simple experiment to differentiate between the two explanations. You experiment should include mating the curled cat. Briefly describe experimental design and the predicted results. Outline your answer as follows: • Experimental design: • Predicted results is #1 is correct: • Predicted results if #2 is correct: 3 Problem 4 About 5% of breast cancer cases are caused by an inherited susceptibility. Familial, early-onset breast cancer can result from a loss-of-function mutation in either the BRCA1 gene or the BRCA 2 gene. a. The BRCA I gene codes for a protein (on chromosome 17) that is involved in repair of double-strand breaks in DNA. Briefly explain why a defect in this function would increase the probability of developing cancer in general. 2-3 sentences • Your answer should include a very brief summary of the current model for the genetic basis of cancer • You do not need to address the issue of tissue-specificity b. Explain the graph With BRCA1 mutation: Notice that the probability of breast/ovarian cancer is not 100%. Also there is variable expressivity among family members with respect to the age at which the cancer appeared and which type cancer of developed. Recall our discussions in class of mechanisms underlying incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity of genetic traits. We discussed three general categories of factors that influence the phenotypic expression of a genetic trait. List these three categories and briefly explain how each could affect the development of cancer specifically. Give a specific relevant example of each. Without BRCA I mutation: A women shown not to have the BRCA I mutations has the same risk as the general population: 6% probability of developing breast cancer by age 70 and 1% probability of ovarian cancer. Why do people with no inherited risk nonetheless develop these cancers and why is it typically at an older age? two sentences 4 Problem 5 Gorlin syndrome is an autosomal dominant disorder that predisposes affected individuals to various cancers and developmental defects, which are obvious at birth. Examine the pedigrees on pg 2 of the DATA sheet. B1, B2 and B3 are alleles of a site (called D9S29) that maps to chromosome 9. A genotype of B1 means that the individual was homozygous for B1. (Likewise for B2 and B3). Each pedigree represents a different kindred group. Assume the disease shows complete penetrance and that the D9S29 polymorphism is 4 map units from the gene mutated in Gorlin syndrome. a. In kinship 2601, there is a B2B3 individual in generation III and one in IV. One has the disease the other does not. 1-2 sentences. b. In kinship 2102, the B1B2 male from generation II contacts you for some advice. His wife is expecting their third kid and a prenatal test indicates a genotype of B1B2. First: Define allele symbols for disease genes and write out the genotypes of the parents using notation for linked genes. [Assume Gen III kids are the products of non-recombinant gametes] Second: Calculate the probability that the kid is heterozygous for the Gorlin mutation. Show your work and circle your answer. c. Examine kinship group 2342. Here are two possibilities for the genotype of the first generation: affected male B2B2 X unaffected female B1B2 OR affected male B1B2 X unaffected female B2B2 Examine the entire pedigree. Which scenario is most likely? Circle your choice. No explanation required. 5 Problem 6 ** Jack and Jill have a child with Down syndrome (trisomy 21). They participate in a study to determine which parent contributed the abnormal gamete. In this study, a chromosome 21 microsatellite (STR) site is examined using PCR and primers that flank the microsatellite site. The data below shows the results of gel electrophoresis of PCR products generated from genomic DNA isolated from the parents and three hypothetical results from the child. Heavier bands indicate bands with double-intensity of staining. Note that this analysis is equivalent to a DNA fingerprinting gel and does not involve any restriction digest of the PCR products. Non-disjunction refers to a situation where either: (i) pair of homologs fail to separate in anaphase of meiosis I and end up in the same daughter cell OR sister chromatids fail to separate in anaphase II. For each hypothetical result (HR) indicate which parent contributed the abnormal gamete and in which meiotic division the non-disjunction event occurred. Assume that no recombination has occurred between the centromere and the microsatellite site during the generation of the gametes. If the results are inconclusive, indicate so and briefly explain. 6 Problem 7 ** Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is characterized by short stature, obesity and mental retardation. It is normally caused by a deletion (of a chunk of the chromosome) on the paternally derived copy of chromosome 15. Deletions of the same region of the maternal chromosome do not cause PWS. The corresponding region in the maternally derived chromosome is inactivated during oogenesis by a process known as genomic imprinting which involves silencing of the maternal allele via CpG methylation (see epigenetics lecture). This process is normal for this region of chromosome 15. [But imprinting occurs only rarely in the genome.] In the family shown below, neither parent has PWS. The trait shows complete penetrance. [In contrast to the usual type of PWS mutation, the father in this family does not have a deletion on either copy of chromosome 15 (data not shown)]. The agarose gel shows an STR polymorphism that has been tracked using PCR and is linked to the region of chromosome 15 associated with PWS. STR polymorphisms on other autosomes confirm that individual #3 is the father of #2. Larger PCR products Ô Smaller PCR products The lane numbers on the agarose gel correspond to numbers on the pedigree. Note that this analysis is equivalent to a DNA fingerprinting gel and does not involve any restriction digest of the PCR products. 1 2 3 4 5 (i). Examine the gel. What does the difference in band size represent? In other words, what is the molecular basis of the polymorphism. One sentence. (ii). Examine the data shown above. What is surprising about the genotype of the affected child (#2)? Be explicit. NOTE: ignore the faint bands in the gel; only anayze the dark bands. (iii). Read about non-disjunction in your text. The gamete that #2 received from his mother was produced by non-disjunction of chromosome 15 during meiosis in her germline. Assuming no crossing-over between the site of the microsatellite polymorphism and the centromere, in which meiotic division did the non-disjunction event occur? Circle the correct answer: a. Meiosis I a. Meiosis II c. either Meiosis I or II d. cannot determine from the information given Explain your answer with a diagram and one or two sentences of text: 7 Problem 7 continues on the next pagr (iv) Now assume that a cross-over event did occur between the site of the microsatellite polymorphism and the centromere. In which meiotic division did the non-disjunction event occur? Circle the correct answer: a. Meiosis I a. Meiosis II c. either Meiosis I or II d. cannot determine from the information given Problem 8 Risk or likelihood of a particular phenotype. By definition the wild-type genotype with no environmental exposure has a risk of 1.0. Part A: In 1-2 sentences summarize the main point(s) from Panel A. Part B: In 1-2 sentences summarize the main point(s) from Panel B Part C: State explicitly the main difference(s) between panels A and B. 1-2 sentences max. Part D: Recall the discussion of phenylketonuria in your text. Does either panel accurately reflect the gene X environment interaction seen in this disease state? {NOTE: no need to memorize details of PKU or any other trait or disease state. Questions of this sort would give you G X E info and you would be asked if it fit these models.} Part E: Review depression polymorph data from lecture on complex traits. Does either panel accurately reflect the gene X environment interaction seen in the data sets? {NOTE: no need to memorize details of paper. Question of this sort would give you G X E info and you would be asked if it fit these models.} 8 Problem 9 *Hints but not a complete answer will be available Panel A Panel B Shaded circles = Affected (Addictive personality) Unshaded and double circles = Unaffected Risk = contributes to addictive personality Each risk allele is presented as a puzzle piece of a different color or shape. Assume that different shapes indicate alleles of different genes and that the same shape but different color indicates alleles of the same gene This figure is taken from a review article on the genetics of addictive behaviors. You are charged with writing an article for the New York Times that includes this figure. Examine it carefully and write an essay explaining/interpreting panels A and B. Be sure to address all aspects of each panel. • Your answer should be several sentences long and should throughly explain each type of symbol and the difference in patterns in A and B. • Be sure to address the underlying causes of the double-circled symbols • You must use proper terminology. See extra sheet for a list of terms that we have examined. Be sure to apply all appropriate terms. • Take some time to organize your thoughts and start with a list of points that you want to make. NOTE: your answer should be in essay form -- the list is for you. • Put your answer on an extra sheet of paper or on the back of this exam. A list of terms that may be useful • suppression variable expressivity recessive lethal • incomplete penetrance polymorphic sex-limited/sex-influenced • pleiotropic genetic heterogeneity (heterogeneous trait) • complementation epistasis modifier haploinsufficient • multifactorial polygenic genetic background stochastic effects • probabilistic propensity monogenic 9 ESSAY QUESTION “We used to think our fate was in the stars. Now we know, in large measure our fate is in our genes.” James Watson, 1989. “Genetic determinism is one of those simpleminded errors that we are prone to commit when we think that genes are linked to diseases in a kind of inevitable fashion.... It invites you to think that ‘genes equal fate.’ ” Thomas Murray (ethicist) Many scientists are concerned that the flood of information available about human genetics and the human genome will lead to misunderstandings about the complexity of the relationship between genetic variation and the expression of a specific trait or disease. Based on what you have learned in this class about the relationship between genotype and phenotypes, fully analyze this issue of genetic determinism. NOTE: This should not be an essay concerning ethics or morality. This essay should deal with the science of biology and genetics only. Provide arguments/examples that support both quotes. ESSAY QUESTION Defining Disease in the Genomic Era: “……..Human genomic sequencing will reveal thousands of genetic variations among individuals that many will assume are associated with disease. But translating such genotypic differences into phenotypic states is prone to pitfalls…” Your mother has read this statement and doesn’t understand exactly what it means. Write an essay explaining this quote to your mom. Be sure to illustrate your essay with specific examples: real or hypothetical (either is OK). Cast a broad net in your answer to this question and be systematic with your analysis. In other words, you might start with an random SNP (located somewhere in the human genome) and go from there… There are a number of different points that need to be considered here. Some overlap with the first essay question. Others don’t. 10