Volcanoes and Mt. Pinatubo Lesson Plans Summer Scarlatelli Grade Level 9th Grade Earth Science or Integrated Science Objectives Students will complete this lesson after the chapter on plate tectonics. Students will be able to better describe the zones of Earth, Earths crust and plate tectonics. Students will be able to describe convection currents and how they relate to the lithospheric plate boundaries Students will be able to describe what magma is and how it forms at plate boundaries where one lithospheric plate is subducted beneath another plate, thus forming a volcano. Students will be able to locate the Pacific Ring of Fire, discus how it forms and identify several large volcanoes that exist there (ie: Mt. Pinatubo). Through research and discussion the students will be able to give an accurate and detailed description of several effects that volcanoes have on the biosphere, atmosphere and lithosphere. They will also be able to specifically correlate it to the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo. Key Words Plate tectonics, convection, convection current, magma, crust, mantle, core, transform fault boundary, convergent plate boundary, divergent plate boundary, aesthenosphere, listhosphere, subduction, Pacific Ring of Fire. Teaching Time Five 45-minute class periods (to allow time for research and filming) Curriculum and Instructional Strategy 1. Have students take a “Pre-test” survey and grade themselves on how much they think they know about change and the terminology that encompasses it. They will rate themselves 4 – 1, four feeling they know a lot through one meaning they feel that they know very little. The questions will look like the following. a. How well can you explain plate tectonics? b. Can you identify the three major zones of Earth? c. Can you locate and describe the Pacific Ring of Fire? d. Can you describe the word subduction and are you able to identify how it correlates to plate tectonics and the creation of volcanoes. e. f. g. h. 2. Hook a. Can Can Can Can you you you you identify and describe the two major zones of the mantle? describe convection currents and how they correlate to volcanism? describe how magma creates a volcano? describe how a volcanic eruption affects each of Earth’s four spheres? To excite and entice students to pay attention to the following lesson plan about volcanoes, the students will watch a brief one minute clip of the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo on youtube.com. b. After the video is completed the students will notice that lying on the front desk there will be a beaker filled with water beginning to boil and hard boiled eggs for each student. i. The following questions will be written on the board: “What do the egg and the water have to do with volcanoes? ii. The students will then be given five minutes to write down their guess on a blank piece of paper. iii. The teacher will then proceed to explain the answer to the question. 1. The hard boiled egg represents earth and its layers. 2. The shell is its mantle, the while membrane is the mantle and the yolk is the core. 3. The shell of the egg or the mantle is made up of two zones called the lithosphere and aesthenosphere. The lithosphere is broken into plates that ride along like passengers on the denser aesthenosphere. 4. The movement of the lithospheric plates is due to convection. a. Have the students cut the egg in half (with a plastic knife) and look at its three layers. b. The students will then gently twist the shells of each half to model how convection in the mantle works. 5. Convection is the transfer of heat though the movement of heated fluid material (like the putty of the aesthenosphere) which then turn into convection currents which is a cycle of a warm liquid rising while a cooler liquid sinks to replaces it. a. This is very similar to what happened when we boil water when we cook pasta. 6. Convection is also what is going on in the boiling water in front of us. a. The teacher will then add cold colored water to the already boiling water with a pipette and the students will watch the cold colored water sink. iv. The teacher will then ask, “well we know how plate tectonic and convection works but how do volcanoes come into play”? 1. The students will then write down their hypothesis v. The teacher will then explain how. 1. Most active volcanoes are found in areas near the boundaries of lithospheric plates (more specifically convergent and divergent plate boundaries) because this is where the most magma is formed. 2. The magma then slowly pushes up into the crust because it is less dense than the solid crust. The magma along with other volcanic material slowly builds up and creates a volcano. 3. Map the Pacific Ring of Fire a. The Pacific Ring of Fire is a major zone of active volcanoes surrounding the Pacific Ocean. b. Students will be given a map of the Pacific Ring of Fire that looks similar to the attached picture and a computer to do a small amount of research. i. Students will then complete the following tasks. 1. Identify at least eight major volcanoes located along the Pacific Ring Of Fire 2. Label the countries that border the Pacific Ring of Fire. 3. Identify the other major natural disaster that is common along the Pacific Ring of Fire 4. Identify the plates that the Pacific Plate lies next to (the above right map may be useful for this). 5. Identify how convection and convection currents affect the Pacific Ring of Fire. 6. Identify what causes the Pacific Ring of Fire (Hint: subduction zones). 4. Student Research and Documentaries a. Now that the students have a basic understanding of how and why volcanism occurs, they will now go more in depth on volcanoes and learn specifically about the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo. Mt. Pinatubo was specifically chosen because of its large size, force of eruption and how it influenced all parts of the globe. i. The teacher may choose a new volcano as the specified topic as each school year changes. b. The teacher will divide the class into four groups, i. Each group will represent a different type of scientist and their view on how Mt. Pinatubo affected or influenced their area of study. Upon the start of the student research, the teacher will hand each group a paper with suggested websites to visit that correlate with their given topic. Each group will be labeled one of the following: 1. Geologist – will research on the internet how plate tectonics and the earthquake influenced the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo. 2. Climatologists – will research on the internet how the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo affected the atmosphere and climate. 3. Botanists – will research on the internet how Mt. Pinatubo affected the plant life and growth of the area surrounding the eruption. 4. Biologists – will research on the internet how the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo affected humans and animals. ii. Students will then create new groups of one scientist from each group 1. They will then create a short documentary indicating how the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo affected each of their researched areas. 2. Students will then present all of the documentaries in class. 3. As a bonus, awards could be presented to each documentary group with topics that may include: most in depth, most precise, best use of props or best use of humor to convey scientific information 5. Have each student retake “Pre-Test” survey and compare their results. a. Include the following questions i. Can you identify what plates lay next to the Pacific Ring of Fire? ii. Can you identify how subduction affects volcanic activity? iii. Can you name at least four major volcanoes located on the Pacific Ring of Fire? iv. Can you identify the other natural disaster that occurs along the Pacific Ring of Fire? v. Can you identify four types of scientists that would be interested in studying Mt. Pinatubo and why? Teacher Rubric 1. The teacher will evaluate the student’s depth of understanding of global climate and class participation through the following rubric. Each category will be graded on a four to one scale, four meaning the student became an expert in the area while a one means that student did not actively participate in the activities or did not pay attention. a. Knowledge of Volcanoes i. The student can identify the three zones of Earth and explain how they correlate to a hardboiled egg. ii. The student can describe the two parts to Earth’s mantle. iii. The student can describe how lithospheric plates move and how the create volcanoes. iv. The student can explain how convection works in a pot of water and in the Earth itself. v. The student will be able to describe how convection currents work and how they help create volcanoes. vi. The student actively watched the demonstrations on the hardboiled egg and the boiling of water and then participated in writing hypothesis about what was occurring. b. Participation in the Pacific Ring of Fire Activity i. The student completed the activity on their own. ii. The student was able to identify at least eight major volcanoes located along the Pacific Ring Of Fire iii. The student was able the countries that border the Pacific Ring of Fire. iv. The student accurately identified that the other major natural disaster that is common along the Pacific Ring of Fire are earthquakes v. The student was able to locate and list the plates that the Pacific Plate lies next to. vi. The student accurately researched that the Pacific Ring of Fire is caused by the subducting of plates around the Pacific Ocean and is able to explain why. c. Participation in Research i. The student actively and accurately researched how Mt. Pinatubo affected or influenced their area of study. ii. The student used reputable resources for their research. d. Participation in Documentary i. The student actively participated in making the documentary, giving ideas on how to film it, where to film it and how to enhance it. ii. The student was able to bring valuable information as a “scientist” to the documentary iii. The student was able to accurately describe how his research correlated to Mt. Pinatubo Individual Reflection This sphere report and lesson plan on volcanoes and Mt. Pinatubo has most definitely improved my knowledge on volcanoes and turned me into a more knowledgeable Earth Science teacher. It has been extremely helpful because I literally just finished teaching my 9th graders about plate tectonics and am starting the chapter on volcanoes next week. Through my lesson plans I have been able to create a nice transition between the two topics, using convection currents and plate tectonics as a stepping stone into how volcanoes are created. The sphere report itself I felt was the hardest one that we have done so far because not only did we have to research an event like volcanoes but we also had to correlate it specifically to Mt. Pinatubo. I also felt that it was hard finding ways that the atmosphere affects the eruption of volcanoes. Despite finding these things difficult I was finally able to get a lot more in depth with the research. I have been really trying hard to put everything into my own words and am better understanding where to look on the internet for the most valid websites. Through my research and my classmates research I have learned a lot about Mt. Pinatubo and volcanoes. I have learned that there are a variety of gasses like ozone, carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, fluorine and sulfur dioxide that are omitted during a volcanic eruption and how they affect the biosphere positively and negatively. It has been interesting to learn how volcanoes can cause cooling of the climate for a few years after a major eruption and that the largest cooling in North America after the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo affected the Hudson Bay. It was endearing to hear how the cold climate from the massive explosion of Mt. Pinatubo could actually help the polar bears located half the way across the world. I also really thought that it was interesting to learn that Mt. Pinatubo was awakened by a magnitude 7.8 earthquake in 1990 and the actual 1991 eruption coincided with Typhoon Yunya, sounds like some bad luck for the citizens of the area. The most important thing I have learned from this is how to use the Earth Science book more effectively. Not only was I able to read the chapters on plate tectonics and volcanoes more indepth (I no longer can just identify the three major lithospheric plates but I can actually describe how they work and how they create volcanoes) I now know how to connect chapters together (convection currents>plate tectonics>subduction zone>volcanism) and add information and labs to these sections. Through looking for ideas on labs for my lesson plans I was able to find two labs from www.oceanexplorer.noaa.gov called “What’s the Difference” and “The Biggest Plates on Earth” that will be wonderful additions to reinforce the curriculum. I did however run into a problem while I was writing my lesson plans, I felt like I was writing a very similar lesson plan (besides from the content) to last two that I have written for this class. Because ESSEA is so specific with what they want in our lesson plans, it seems like you can only get so creative with the Pre-test, Post-test, rubric and jigsaw. Luckily Dr. Root gave me some great ideas to go off of for the jigsaw, so that helped the morale a bit. Overall, this was a fun topic to discuss and I found it really rewarding to see how my hard work in school benefits me at work in the classroom. Peer Review Hi Summer, I read your lesson plan- really interesting and detailed! Its great you were working on a similar unit in your real class at the same time. Sorry I don't have any helpful comments/suggestions- I think the lesson is great as it is. I loved using the hard-boiled egg to demonstrate the different layers of Earth. I also really liked your jigsaw documentary film component- the jigsaw component in my lesson plan was a documentary film as well. Your rubric was also very clear and detailed. Great job! Sarah