Household Waste Disposal Practices Municipal Solid Waste Generation What is this? Municipal Solid Waste (MSW), or trash, is made up of household items that people commonly use and then throw away or recycle. MSW essentially includes all trash besides industrial, hazardous or construction waste. MSW trends over the past 50 years nationwide were used as a basis for measurement. When considering this indicator and how this translates into evaluating the Triangles abilities to connect people with nature, trends, disposal programs, economic benefits and disposal legislation issues were examined. Why is this important? MSW is an important factor to consider in an analysis of the state of the Triangle’s ability to connect people with nature because waste reduction and recycling trends, programs and legislation demonstrate the extent to which Triangle citizens take an active approach to protecting the environment. Did You Know? Quick Facts about MSW Generation: On average nationally, each person generates 4.50 pounds of solid waste a day. Recycling rates have increased from 10 percent of MSW nationwide in 1980 to 33 percent of MSW nationwide in 2008. Waste disposal to landfills has decreased from 89 percent of MSW generated in 1980 to 54 percent in 2008 of MSW generated. What Does this Measure Show? MSW Trends When looking at MSW trends an assessment can be made on waste reduction rates and recycling program development across the country. The graph below demonstrates that since 1960, total MSW generation has gone up nationwide. Though this is not surprising, it does not present the entire picture. Upon closer examination, recycling has increased: from 69.4 million tons in 2000 to 82.9 million tons in 2008, while trash production is decreasing slightly: from 169.7 million tons in 2000 to 166.7 million tons in 2008. 1 Millions of Tons 300 Nationwide Municipal Solid Waste Trash 250 200 Recycling 150 100 TTL MSW Generation 50 0 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2008 Triangle Waste Disposal Programs An examination of trash disposal programs and recycling programs in the Triangle demonstrate the best practices, or lack thereof, of waste disposal throughout the region. A survey of each county’s services was completed to understand the state of the triangle waste collection, a key part of the indication of the triangles capabilities to connect people with nature through environmentally friendly waste disposal practices. To complete this survey number of recycling centers, the availability of curbside recycling, number of convenience centers, landfills and other waste disposal practices were examined by county and by municipality. County Number of Recycling Centers Curbside Recycling? Number of Convenience Centers Number of Landfills Other Waste Disposal Practices Chatham County: 12 County: No County: 12 County: 1 - Hotline for illegal waste disposal Municipal: 2 (Public: Haw River, Siler City) - Environmental Enforcement Program - Recycling Fee to Collect: Yard Waste, Inert Debris - Recycling No Fee- Tires, Scrap Metal and Appliances, Motor Oil and Filters, Propane Tanks, Electronics, Car Batteries, Pesticide Containers. - Small Business Recycling Centers - Swap Shop - Household Hazardous Waste Collection Center - Solid Waste Advisory Committee 2 Durham County: 4 County: Yes County: 4 County: 1 - Household Hazardous Waste Center - Roll Off Container Rental Services - Swap Shop - No stationary container services Johnston County: 12 County: No Municipal: 2 (Benson, Smithfield Municipal: 4 (Public: Pine Level, Princeton County: 12 County: 1 - Disposal Services: Tire, Appliance, Batteries, Waste Motor Oil County: 6 County: 1 - House Hold Hazardous Waste Centers Private: Clayton, Selma:) Lee County: 6 County: No Municipal: 1 (Private: Sanford) - School Recycling Programs - Stop Junk Mail Program - Swat-A-Litterbug Program Orange County: 10 County: Yes County: 5 County: 1 - Recycling Services: Tire, Electronics, Scrap Metal, Appliance, Construction and Demolition Waste - Mulch and Compost Sales - Hazardous Waste Collection - Disposal for Household Garbage Recycling - Salvage Sheds - 24 hour drop off sites Wake County: 15 County: No County: 12 Municipal: 12 (Public: Apex, Cary, Garner, HS, Knighdale, Raleigh, Wake Forest, Zebulon County: 1 - School Recycling Programs - Roadside Litter Clean Up Programs - Household Hazardous Waste Centers - Backyard Compositing Program Private: FV, Morrisville, Rolesville, Wendell) - Electronics Recycling All counties in the Triangle offer multiple recycling centers, convenience centers (otherwise known as dumps) and a landfill with public access for the disposal of specific goods. Based off this table, it is apparent that throughout the Triangle region there are several different combinations of public and private MSW disposal services. When it comes to curbside waste pick 3 up, only Orange and Durham counties offer this service, while Chatham, Johnston, Lee and Wake offer private and public services. There are seven municipalities that contract private disposal services and 12 municipalities offering public curbside recycling in the region. Interestingly enough though, every municipality that has contracted services has curbside recycling as well. Private curbside recycling programs are voluntary and higher costs are incurred by the individual than if the program was public. This creates a disincentive to recycling in these municipalities. Evaluating if a county has public recycling centers or curbside pick up, and subsequently and evaluation at the municipal level should recycling not be offered at the county level, is interesting because it demonstrates the allocation of priorities and resources for recycling programs in each county Triangle wide. Economic Benefits from Recycling It is commonly stated that recycling costs more than disposal, but this is a myth. After full cost analysis of recycling versus disposal is completed, it is apparent that operating a recycling program can cost less than a solid waste collection and disposal program. Additionally, the higher the recycling rate, the more likely that recycling program operations will be less expensive than solid waste collection and disposal. Waste Disposal Legislation Effective October 1, 2009 the state of North Carolina has banned all rigid plastic containers from landfills. This legislation developed in 2005, with its main focus on the recovery of plastic bottles identified as number “1”. On top of implementing this ban, the state will be inspecting landfills for these plastic bottles. In addition, there are several items that have been banned from disposal at landfills via legislation: used oil, yard trash, white goods, antifreeze, aluminum cans, tires, lead-acid batteries, beverage containers, motor vehicle oil filters, wooden pallets and oyster shells. Legislation banning these items is accompanied by the implementation of county facilities for environmentally safe disposal of these items. Statewide legislation such as this positively affects the capabilities of the Triangle to promote environmentally friendly waste disposal practices. North Carolina Solid Waste Management Plan The Goals of the North Carolina Solid Waste Management Plan: 2003-2013 1. Ensure long-term environmental protection by improving future landfill technology and addressing public health and environmental concerns associated with closed landfills. 2. Substantially increase the amount of waste recycled and composted. 3. Reduce litter and illegal disposal by 50 percent from 2003-2004 levels. 4 4. Implement policies and procedures to provide information to the public and ensure public participation throughout the decision-making process regarding waste management facilities. 5. Create and continually maintain 20 years of landfill capacity in the state. Conclusions? Throughout the Triangle, waste disposal practices by county and municipal governments demonstrate the extent of the Triangles commitment to creating progressive and environmentally friendly behavior in waste disposal. National MSW trends show that environmentally friendly is being promoted nationwide as tonnage of trash is decreasing while tonnage of recycling is increasing. Though the numbers are not available for the entire Triangle, it is obvious that waste disposal practices in the Triangle could be more environmentally friendly as recycling practices Triangle wide show that county and municipal priorities are not necessarily promoting best recycling practices. Recycling practices is essential to this assessment because it is proven that when full cost analysis is performed, recycling programs are actually cheaper than waste disposal programs, concluding that there are environmental and economic benefits to recycling. Region wide information on trash disposal versus recycling disposal rates, broken down by county, is needed for a complete assessment on the full extent of the Triangle’s capabilities to promote and create progressive and environmentally friendly behavior in waste disposal. As the information demonstrates currently, the Triangle is on the right track offering a variety of recycling services in each county, yet it has not reached the true extent of its capabilities to connect people with nature by participation in environmentally friendly waste disposal behavior. 5 6