BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR FORT LEWIS COLLEGE February 13, 2015 Vallecito Room, Student Union Fort Lewis College Vol. 15-106 Call to Order Chair Karen Wilde convened the regular meeting of the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College at 8:10 a.m. and stated that the Chair finds that although physical presence of four of the seven voting members of the Board is required to establish a quorum, the establishment of a quorum through physical presence would impose an undue hardship on Tom Schilling because of a prior commitment. Trustees Present: Karen Wilde, Chair; Steve Short; Ernest House; Alan Hill; Justin McBrayer, Faculty Representative; and Scott Greenler, Student Representative Absent: Nora Jacquez and John Wells Participating via Telephone: Tom Schilling and Peter Decker Staff Present: Dene Thomas, President; Barbara Morris, Provost & Vice President for Academic Affairs; Steve Schwartz, Vice President for Finance and Administration; Glenna Witt Sexton, Vice President for Student Affairs; Mark Jastorff, Vice President for Institutional Advancement; Michelle MerzHutchinson, Legal Counsel; Peggy Sharp, Deputy Secretary; and Mike Larson, Audio Consultant. Also Present: Dugald Owen, Faculty Senate President and Gene Bradley, Chair, Fort Lewis College Foundation PUBLIC COMMENT History Professor Michael Fry and English Professor Nancy Cardona, both of whom are members of Faculty Senate and AAUP members, spoke in support of the proposal put forth in Faculty Representative McBrayer’s report for additional faculty representation on Board committees and the establishment of a Faculty Liaison Committee. ACTION AGENDA – CONSENT: Steve Short moved to approve the Consent Agenda, with a second from Ernest House. Motion passed and the following Consent Agenda items were approved: Approval of Minutes of December 4, 2014 Meeting of the Investment Advisory Committee Approval of Minutes of December 4, 2014 Meeting of the Business Affairs Committee Approval of Minutes of December 4, 2014 Meeting of the Academic & Student Affairs Committee Approval of Minutes of December 5, 2014 Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College Approval of Minutes of January 26, 2015Teleconference Meeting of the Presidential Evaluation Committee Approval of Emeritus/Emerita Rank Designation CHAIRMAN’S REPORT/ANNOUNCEMENTS Chair Wilde called attention to the Board Planning Calendar, and the addition of the campus visit by the external evaluator, Dr. Beheruz Sethna, was noted for March 12, 2015. The newly appointed Board members, Alan Hill and Nora Jacquez will be confirmed in mid-April. In addition, she appointed the following voting members to the Board committees for 2015: Business Affairs Committee John Wells, Chair Steve Short Alan Hill Academic & Student Affairs Ernest House, Chair Tom Schilling Nora Jacquez Liaison to Foundation John Wells Presidential Evaluation Tom Schilling, Chair John Wells Steve Short Investment Advisory Committee Steve Short, Chair Ernest House Tom Schilling Committee Reports Academic & Student Affairs Committee Committee Chair Ernest House reported that President Thomas had given an enrollment update. The committee also endorsed the modification of the College’s Sexual Misconduct Policy & Grievance Procedure and the policy for providing the official statement of Fort Lewis College’s Mission for approval by the full Board. The sabbatical reports from two faculty were also received by the committee. Provost Morris also presented historical data on faculty who were awarded sabbaticals from 1997-98 through 2015-16. Business Affairs Committee Committee Chair Steve Short stated that the committee reviewed the proposed tuition schedules, fee schedules, and room and board fees for 2015-2016, and endorsed them for approval by the Board. In addition a report on the Financial Audit for June 30, 2013-14 was given by Controller Cheryl Wiescamp. The audit resulted in an unqualified opinion and there were no findings or recommendations. The committee also endorsed the 201516 Need-Based and Merit-Based Financial Assistance Program Policy for Board approval. Investment Advisory Committee Michele Peterson reported that the committee had not met since December, but a teleconference meeting is scheduled for early March. Presidential Evaluation Committee Chair Tom Schilling stated that Dr. Beheruz Sethna, a member of the evaluation team, will visit campus on March 12th to conduct interviews with various campus and community constituencies. The team consists of Dr. Stephen Portch, who conducted the comprehensive presidential evaluation in 2012, along with Dr. Sethna. They will make their report to the Board at the April 10, 2015. Foundation Liaison Trustee Short attended the full Foundation Board meeting on January 27, at which time election of officers for the coming year was held and there were round table discussions concerning future direction of the Foundation. Gene Bradley, chair of the Foundation stated that their priority is for more engagement by the full Board. He also highlighted several areas on the Foundation’s quarterly financial report. Standing Committees Faculty Representative Report Professor Justin McBrayer thanked the Board for attending the reception with faculty on Thursday afternoon. He stated that the proposal in his report is intended to bolster shared governance – specifically to form a new Liaison Committee made up of three Trustees and five faculty members and also to add a faculty member to serve on each of the Board’s standing committees and ad hoc committees. He indicated that these are recommendations by the American Association of University Professors and the Association of Governing Boards as best practices. Professor McBrayer further explained the structuring of the committees and the benefits for utilizing more faculty input. Ms. Merz- Hutchinson stated that she had researched other Colorado state institutions of higher education and did not find any that had a faculty liaison committee or allowed faculty members (other than the faculty representative) to sit on Board Committees. She further stated that in their capacity as non-voting members of the Board, both the faculty and student representative serve in an advisory capacity and are members of the academic and student affairs committee and are entitled to participate in other committee meetings. She stated that committee meetings are public and although it has not been the practice for public comment at these meetings, a decision to do so is within the discretion of the committee chair. She further noted that representation of faculty via membership at the Board level is relatively uncommon among public institutions. Discussion ensued and the Trustees provided their impression of the proposal. Several felt there were ways to achieve more interaction with faculty on an informal basis such as having a time for faculty to speak at committee meetings. It was also stated that the Legislature had created a role for the faculty representative in statute. The Board would be open to the faculty representative bringing more diversity to our discussions and to create an opportunity to address specific faculty concerns. Further discussion ensued and a suggestion was made to have a longer conversation at the Board retreat, and to look into any legal concerns. Student Representative Report Scott Greenler reported on several activities within student government including: three new student senators being elected bringing the number to the full fifteen; a student forum that was held to gather ideas for bettering student life; a letter was drafted to Cory Gardner to thank him for support of the Native American Tuition waiver; an endorsement for asking IT to switch the default search from Bing to Google; and a student survey that is being conducted for the presidential evaluation process. Foundation/Office of Development Report Mark Jastorff referenced the written report in the Board’s agenda and stated the office is gearing up for an aggressive comprehensive campaign. He announced that TLC for FLC will be held on April 26 in the Ballroom. He responded to questions regarding endowments and the level of alumni giving. BREAK ACTION AGENDA – NON-CONSENT Approval of Tuition Schedules for Academic Year 2015-2016 and Summer Sessions 2015 Michelle Peterson reviewed the proposed tuition schedules which indicate a 5.6% increase for resident tuition and a 0% for out-of-state tuition. She explained the rationale for a 0% increase in non-resident tuition. Steve Short moved that the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College approve the Tuition Schedule for the academic year 2015-2016 and summer semester 2016, and that the attached tuition rates be adopted thirty days from this date and that notice shall be given as of this date in compliance with CCHE Tuition and Fee Policy. Ernest House seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. Approval of Fee Schedules for Academic Year 2014-2015 Michele Peterson stated there are two pieces of the fee proposal: mandatory fees that are paid by every student and course specific fees paid only by students in a particular course. She stated that the mandatory fee increase is $1.25, resulting in a total of $58.15 per credit hour. It includes a $1.00 increase in the athletic fee to fund two new women’s teams and the remainder to be allocated to existing teams to help cover increased travel and operating costs; a five cent increase in the student life center fee to support a portion of the costs of the disk golf course; a fifteen cent increase to the Student Activities Fee to provide scholarships to ASFLC senators & court personnel. She also summarized the course specific fee increases. In response to a question regarding if there were any complaints concerning the increases, Scott Greenler responded that there was both opposition and support voiced by some students concerning the increase to fund scholarships for senators & court personnel. Michele Peterson stated that the all fees are vetted through the Institutional Review Board and approved by the Budget Committee. Steve Short moved that the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College approve the Fee Schedules for the academic year 2015-2016, and that the attached fee rates be adopted thirty days from this date and that notice shall be given as of this date in compliance with CCHE Tuition and Fee Policy. Ernest House seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. Approval of Room and Board Fee Schedules for Academic Year 2015-2016 and Summer Sessions 2016 Michele Peterson reported that a 3% increase is being proposed for the room and 3.5% board increase. The board increase is a pass through of the negotiated rates with Sodexo and the increase room rate just reflects the cost of doing business. Peter Decker moved that the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College approve the Room and Board Fee Schedules for the academic year 2015-2016 and summer sessions 2016, and that the attached room and board rates be adopted thirty days from this date and that notice shall be given as of this date in compliance with CCHE Tuition and Fee Policy. Tom Schilling seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. Approval of 2015-2016 State of Colorado Need-Based and Merit = Based Financial Assistance Program Policy President Thomas stated that this is a perfunctory action that must be approved by the Board each year. It follows state and Federal statutes and allows the Office of Financial Aid to award financial aid packages. Steve Short moved that as required by C.R.S. § 233.3-102 (3), that Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College approves the “2015-2016 State of Colorado Need-Based and Merit-Based Financial Assistance Policy” and directs the president or designee to implement the revised policy. Ernest House seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. Approval of Modification of Fort Lewis College Sexual Misconduct Policy and Fort Lewis College Discrimination Grievance Procedures Vice President Glenna Sexton stated this revision addresses the new requirements in the Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act brings the College into compliance. The modification in the Discrimination Grievance Procedures tightens the procedures for addressing and resolving complaints and taking away the time limits that were present. Peter Decker moved that the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College hereby approve the changes to the Sexual Misconduct Policy and the Discrimination Grievance Procedures. Ernest House seconded. Motion passed unanimously. Approval of a Policy for Providing the Official Statement of Fort Lewis College’s Mission Vice President Sexton gave a brief explanation of the impetus for putting in policy what we currently do in practice and is a result of the preparation for the reaccreditation by the Higher Learning Commission. Tom Schilling moved that the Board of Trustees for Fort Lewis College hereby approve the Mission Statement Policy. Ernest House seconded. Motion passed unanimously. REPORT AGENDA Report: Office of Sponsored Research and Federal Relations Angie Rochat, Director of the Office of Sponsored Research and Federal Relations presented an overview of the grant proposals submitted and the dollars awarded over the 2005-2014 period. She stated there are many factors that impacted the fluctuations in amounts awarded. However, in spite of the challenging fiscal situation, she reported that in FY 2014, the College submitted a $22 million dollar grant in collaboration with San Juan College and the University of New Mexico to create a regional education pipeline from the Associate to the Baccalaureate to the Doctorate for underserved STEM students. She also gave a brief summary on the status of the efforts to seek Federal support for the Native American Tuition waiver. PRESIDENT’S REPORT Native American Tuition Waiver Update President Thomas indicated that the College continues to receive strong support from the House but the Senate has been somewhat more reluctant to support the bill. Senator Cory Gardner is supportive of the bill and will introduce it at the 114th Congress. She stated that in addition to the legislative bill we are pursuing a line in the Higher Education Reauthorization Act. NCAA Report President Thomas provided a summary of the actions taken by the Division II presidents Council. She stated that a Strategic Plan was developed as well as priorities for Division II for the coming year. Colorado Legislative Update Vice President Schwartz provided a summary of several of the bills impacting higher education including a change in the funding formula from HB 1319. He also thanked the Trustees for attending the Legislative Coffee and reiterated the importance of their presence. COPLAC Conference This conference is held in conjunction with the American Association of Colleges & Universities Conference. She reported that two institutions were added to the membership and further stated that the COPLAC conference provides the opportunity for these similar institutions to share their concerns and interests. The Summer Institute will be held June 11-13, 2015. Enrollment Update Spring enrollment is paralleling Fall enrollment with the decline in continuing students. Consideration is being given at ways to rectify this issue. President Thomas reported that freshmen applications are up 43% for Fall, 2015 with a 28% increase in resident applications and 57% increase in non-resident applications. She stated that the College is using many new strategies for communication to prospective students. Presidential Metrics & Metrics that Matter President Thomas reviewed a few highlights in the metrics that matter. Richard Miller, Executive Director of Institutional Research & Planning, responded to questions regarding enrollment figures for student athletes. Professor McBrayer suggested some expansion in the metrics to include more information concerning academic quality such as percentage of faculty who are tenured and tenure-track; number of scholarships; and number of students conducting research with faculty. Mr. Miller explained that the Presidential metrics are a result of the evaluation conducted in 2012 and the Metrics that Matter are aligned with the Strategic Plan. OTHER BUSINESS Chair Wilde reminded the Trustees that if anyone was interested in attending the Association of Governing Boards Annual Conference in April, they should notify Ms. Sharp as soon as possible in order to get registered. Chair Wilde moved that they go into executive session, pursuant to section 24-6-402(3)(a)(II) of the Colorado Revised Statutes to receive legal advice on specific claims concerning Matthews Electrical, and specific legal questions concerning Board governance, and that the following individuals be invited to join the Board in Executive session to participate in the discussion: Michelle Merz-Hutchinson, Legal Counsel; President Thomas, Provost Morris, Vice President Schwartz, Vice President Sexton, Vice President Jastorff and Peggy Sharp. seconded the motion. Executive session convened at 11:05 a.m. Steve Short Public session reconvened at 12:05. Ms. Merz-Hutchinson stated that in her opinion, all of the foregoing unrecorded discussion constituted a privileged attorney-client communication. MEETING ADJORNED at 12:10 a.m.