CHAPTER The Cost of Capital Sources of capital Component costs WACC 9-1 Cost of Capital The items on the financing side of the balance sheet are called capital components. The major capital components are equity, preference and debt. Capital like any other factor of production has a cost. A company’s cost of capital is the average cost of the various capital components or securities employed by it. Put differently, it is the average rate of return required by the investors who provide capital to the company. 9-2 Cost of Capital Cost of the capital is the central concept in financial management. It is used for evaluating investment projects, for determining the capital structure, for assessing leasing proposal etc. 9-3 What sources of long-term capital do firms use? Long-Term Capital Long-Term Debt Preferred Stock Common Stock Retained Earnings New Common Stock 9-4 Concepts of weighted average cost of capital A company’s cost of capital is the weighted average cost of various sources of finance used by it. For example, Equity, Preference and Debt. Suppose that a company uses equity, preference and Debt in the proportion of 50, 10 and 40. If the component costs of equity,preference and debt are 16%, 12% & 8% respectively, Calculate WACC. 9-5 Concepts of weighted average cost of capital WACC = (proportion of equity)(cost of equity)+(proportion of preference)(cost of preference)+(proportion of debt)(cost of debt) WACC = (.5)(16)+ (.10)(12)+ (.4)(8) WACC = 12.4% For the shake of the simplicity, we have ignored other forms of capital like convertible or callable preference, convertible or callable debt, bonds with payment linked to stock market index, bonds that are puttable or extendable, warrant so on and so forth. 9-6 Cost of Debts conceptually the cost of debt instrument is the yield to maturity of that instrument. Let us apply this concept to different types of debt instruments such as Debentures, Bank Loan and commercial paper. I+(F - Po)/n Formula for rd= 0.6 Po+0.4 F 9-7 Cost of Debts where, I = annual interest payment Po = current market price of the debenture F = Face value n = remaining period of maturity. Example, Face Value Coupon rate Remaining period to maturity Current market price = = = = 1000 12% 4 years 1040 9-8 Cost of Debts 120+(1000 - 1040)/4 r= The Yield to maturity or d 0.6 x 1040+0.4 x 1000 The cost of a bank loan is simply the current interest the bank would charge if the firm were to raise a loan. For example, Multiplex limited has a Tk. 300 million outstanding bank loan on which it is paying an interest of 13%. however, if Multiplex limited were to raise a loan now, the bank would charge 12%. This then represent the cost of the bank loan. 9-9 Cost of Debts Commercial paper is a short term debt instrument. Which is issued at a discount and redeemed at par. Hence the cost of commercial paper is simply its implicit interest rate. For example: Multiplex limited has outstanding commercial paper that has a balance maturity of 6 months. The face value of one instrument is Tk. 1,000,000 and it is traded in the market at Tk. 965,000. The implicit interest rate for 6 months is, 1,000,000 - 1 = 0.0363 or 3.63%. 965,000 Annualized interest rate = (1.0363)2- 1= 0.0739 = 7.39% 9-10 Cost of Debts When a firm uses different instrument of debt, the average cost of debt has to be calculated. In our example of Multiplex Limited, the following data on the debt employed are reviled. Debt Instrument Face value Market Value Coupon Rate YTM or Current rate NonConvertible Debenture Tk. 100 Million Tk. 104 Million 12% 10.7% Bank Loan Tk. 200 Million Tk. 200 Million 13% 12.0% Commercial Paper Tk. 50 Million Tk. 48.2 Million N/A 7.39% Total Debts Capital employed = 352.25 Million 9-11 Cost of Debts The average cost of debt is calculated using the market value proportions and yields/current rate of various debt instruments. The Average Cost of Debts of Multiplex Limited = 10.7% [104/352.25] + 12.0% [200/352.25] + 7.39 [48.25/352.25] = 10.98% Tax Adjustment Post-Tax Cost of Debt = Pre-tax Cost of Debt (1 – Tax rate) 9-12 Cost of Preference Preference capital carries a fixed rate of dividend and is redeemable in nature. Given the fixed nature of preference dividend and principal repayment commitment and the absence of tax deductibility, the cost of preference is simply equal to its yield. Problem: Consider the preference stock of Multiplex Limited for which the following data are given, Face value : Tk. 100 Dividend rate : 11 % Maturity Period : 5 years Market Price : Tk. 95 11 + (100 - 95)/5 The Yield to maturity = 0.6 x 95+0.4 x100 = 12.37% 9-13 Cost of Equity Equity Finance may be obtained in two ways (1) Retention of earnings (2) Issue of additional equity The cost of equity or the return required by the equity shareholder is the same in both the cases. Cost of Equity : The SML Approach According to SML Approach, the required return on a company’s equity is, rE= Rf+ β (RM - Rf ) Where, Rf = Risk free rate β = beta of the equity of the company RM = Expected return on the market portfolio. To use the SML Approach, the following inputs are required Rf = the risk free rate β = the beta of the equity stock, (RM - Rf ) = the market risk premium. 9-14 Cost of Equity The Dividend Growth Model Approach Financial analyst who do not have faith in the SML approach often prefer Dividend Growth Model to estimate the cost of equity. D1 D2 P0 = + + ……………………. (1+rE)1 (1+rE)2 Where, P0 = current price of the stock Dt=dividend expected to be paid at the end of year t rE = Equity shareholders required rate of return If dividend are expected to grow at a constant rate of “g” percent per year, then Equation becomes, 9-15 Cost of Equity D1 D1(1+g) + (1+rE)2 P0 = + (1+rE)1 This simplifies to, D1 P0 = rE – g Solving the above equations for rE we get, D1 rE= +g P0 D0(1+g) +g = P0 D1(1+g)2 + ……………. (1+rE)3 9-16 Calculating the weighted average cost of capital WACC = wErE+ wprp + wdrd(1-T) Where, wE = Proportion of Equity rE = Cost of Equity Wp = Proportion of Preference rp = Cost of Preference Wd = Proportion of Debt rd = Cost of Debt 9-17 Calculating the weighted average cost of capital The cost of specific sources of capital for “X” company limited are: rE = 16% wE = 0.60 rp = 14% Wp = 0.05 rd = 12% Wd = 0.35 The Tax Rate for “X” company limited is 30% Required: Calculate the WACC 9-18 Calculating the weighted average cost of capital Source of Capital Debt Proportion Cost .60 16% Weighted Cost (1)x(2) 9.60% Preference .05 14% 0.70% Equity .35 12(1-.30) 2.94% = 8.4% WACC = 13.24% 9-19 Calculating the weighted Marginal cost of capital The relationship between additional financing and WACC can be estimated by the WMCC. The procedure for determining WMCC involves Estimate the cost of each source of financing for various level of its use. Identify the level of total new financing at which the cost of new components would change. These level is called breaking points, can be established using the following relationship TFj BPj = Wj 9-20 Calculating the weighted Marginal cost of capital BPj = breaking point on account of financing source j TFj = Total new financing from source j at the breaking point Wj = proportion of financing source j in the capital structure Calculate the WACC Prepare the WMCC schedule 9-21 Calculating the weighted Marginal cost of capital Assume “Y” Company Limited plans to use equity and Debt in the following proportion Equity : 40 Debt : 60 “Y” Company Limited estimates the cost of its sources of finance for various levels of usage as follows, Source of Finance Range of New Financing Cost (Taka in Million) Equity 0 - 30 18% More than 30 20% Debt 0 – 50 10% More than 50 11%9-22 Calculating the weighted Marginal cost of capital: Determination of Breaking Point Source of Capital Cost (1) Range of new Financing (2) Breaking point (Tk. In Million) (3) Range of total new financing (Tk. In Million) (4) 18% 0-30 30/.40 = 75 0 – 75 20% Above 30 - Above 75 10% 0-50 50/.60 = 83.3 0 – 83.3 11% Above 50 - Above 83.3 Equity Debt Firm’s weighted average cost of capital will change at Tk. 75 million and Tk. 83.3 Million. 9-23 Calculating the WACC for various ranges of Total financing for “Y” Company Limited. Range of total new financing 0-75 Source of Capital (1) Proportion (2) Cost % (3) Weighted Cost % (2)x(3)=(4) Equity 0.4 0.18 0.072 Debt 0.6 0.10 0.060 WACC = .132 75-83.3 Equity 0.4 .20 .080 Debt 0.6 .10 .060 WACC = .140 9-24 Calculating the WACC for various ranges of Total financing for “Y” Company Limited. Range of total new financing Source of Capital (1) Above 83.3 Equity Debt Proportion (2) Cost % (3) Weighted Cost % (2)x(3)=(4) 0.4 .20 0.080 0.6 .11 0.066 WACC = .146 9-25 Calculating the WMCC Range of Total Financing (Tk. In Million) 0 – 75 Weighted Marginal Cost of Capital (%) 75 – 83.3 14.0 Above 83.3 14.6 13.20 9-26 Calculating the weighted Marginal cost of capital Assume “Z” Company Limited plans to use equity,preference and Debt in the following proportion Equity : 0.45, Preference: 0.05, Debt : 0.50 “Z” Company Limited estimates the cost of its sources of finance for various levels of usage as follows, Source of Finance Range of New Financing Cost (Taka in Million) Equity 0 - 10 15% 10 – 30 16.50% More than 30 18.00% Preference 0–1 14.50% More than 1 15.00% Debt 0 – 15 7.50% 15 – 40 8.00% More than 40 8.40% 9-27 Problem Assume “Z” Company Limited plans to use equity, preference and Debt in the following proportion Equity : 0.45, Preference: 0.05, Debt : 0.50 “Z” Company Limited estimates the cost of its sources of finance for various levels of usage as follows, 9-28 Problem Source of Finance Equity Preference Debt Range of New Financing 0 - 10 10 – 30 More than 30 0–1 More than 1 0 – 15 15 – 40 More than 40 Cost 15% 16.50% 18.00% 14.50% 15.00% 7.50% 8.00% 8.40% 9-29 Step 1: Determining the Breaking points and the Resulting ranges of Total new financing Source of Capital Equity Preference Cost (1) Range of new Financing (2) Breaking point (Tk. In Million) (3) Range of total new financing (Tk. In Million) (4) 15.00 0 – 10 10/0.45 = 22.22 0 – 22.22 16.50 10 – 30 30/0.45 = 66.67 22.22 – 66.67 18.00 30 and Above - 66.67 – Above 14.50 0–1 1 / 0.05 = 20.00 - 0 – 20.00 1 and Above 20.00 and above 7.50 0 – 15 15 / 0.50 = 30.00 0 – 30.00 8.00 15 – 40 40 / .50 = 80.00 30.00 – 80.00 8.40 40 and Above - 80.00 and Above Debt 9-30 Step 2: WACC for various range of total new financing Range of Total Cost(%) New Financing (Tk. In Million) Source of Proportion Cost Capital [1] [2] 0 – 20.00 Equity Preference Debt WACC 0.45 0.05 0.50 15.00 14.50 7.50 6.750 0.725 3.750 11.225 20.00-22.22 Equity Preference Debt WACC 0.45 0.05 0.50 15.00 15.00 7.50 6.750 0.750 3.750 11.250 22.22 – 30.00 Equity Preference Debt WACC 0.45 0.05 0.50 16.50 15.00 7.50 7.425 0.750 3.750 11.925 30.00-66.67 Equity Preference Debt WACC 0.45 0.05 0.50 16.50 15.00 8.00 7.425 0.750 4.000 12.175 [3] Weighted [(2) x (3)] 9-31 Step 2: WACC for various range of total new financing Range of Total Cost(%) New Financing (Tk. In Million) Source of Proportion Cost Capital [1] [2] 66.67 – 80.00 Equity Preference Debt WACC 0.45 0.05 0.50 18.00 15.00 8.00 8.100 0.750 4.000 12.850 Above 80.00 Equity Preference Debt WACC 0.45 0.05 0.50 18.00 15.00 8.40 8.100 0.750 4.200 13.050 [3] Weighted [(2) x (3)] 9-32 Step 3: Weighted Marginal Cost of Capital Schedule Range of Total Financing (Tk. In Million) 0 – 20.00 20.00-22.22 22.22 – 30.00 30.00-66.67 66.67 – 80.00 Above 80.00 Weighted Marginal Cost of Capital (%) 11.225 11.250 11.925 12.175 12.850 13.050 9-33 Finding a divisional cost of capital: Using similar stand-alone firms to estimate a project’s cost of capital Comparison firms have the following characteristics: Target capital structure consists of 40% debt and 60% equity. kd = 12% kRF = 7% RPM = 6% βDIV = 1.7 Tax rate = 40% 9-34 Calculating a divisional cost of capital Division’s required return on equity Division’s weighted average cost of capital ks = kRF + (kM – kRF)β = 7% + (6%)1.7 = 17.2% WACC = wd kd ( 1 – T ) + wc ks = 0.4 (12%)(0.6) + 0.6 (17.2%) =13.2% Typical projects in this division are acceptable if their returns exceed 13.2%. 9-35