Security for Public Deposits Act Overview and Recent Developments Department of the Treasury April 21, 2010 1 Presentation Outline • Virginia Security for Public Deposits Act • Definitions • Program Overview • Responsibilities of Public Officials • Program Statistics • Recent Developments • Contacts • Fraud Prevention Disbursement Accounts 2 Virginia Security for Public Deposits Act • The Virginia Security for Public Deposits Act (SPDA), Chapter 44 Title 2.2 was enacted by the 1973 General Assembly. • The Virginia Security for Public Deposits Act Regulations were enacted by the Treasury Board of the Commonwealth of Virginia on November 18, 1993. • SPDA creates a single body of law to secure public deposits of Virginia governmental entities. • SPDA centralizes the procedures to secure public deposits at the state level to promote efficiencies in administration. 3 Definitions 4 Public Deposit Defined Section 2.2-4401 of the Code of Virginia ‘public deposit’ means moneys of the Commonwealth or of any county, city, town or other political subdivision thereof, including moneys of any commission, institution, committee, board or officer of the foregoing and any state, circuit, county or municipal court, which moneys are deposited in any qualified public depository in any of the following types of accounts: nonnegotiable or registered time deposits, demand deposits, savings deposits, and any other transaction accounts, and security for such deposit is required by other provisions of law, or is required due to an election of the public depositor. 5 Participants Defined • Qualified Public Depositories "Qualified public depository" means any national banking association, federal savings and loan association or federal savings bank located in Virginia, any bank, trust company or savings institution organized under Virginia law, or any state bank or savings institution organized under the laws of another state located in Virginia, that receives or holds public deposits that are secured pursuant to this chapter. "Located in Virginia" means having a main office or branch office in the Commonwealth where deposits are accepted, checks are paid, and money is lent. • Treasurer and Public Depositors The terms “treasurer” and “public depositor” shall mean the State Treasurer, a county, city or town treasurer or director of finance or similar officer and the custodian of any other public deposits secured pursuant to this chapter. 6 Public Depositors Accounts established by Commonwealth of Virginia governmental entities State Courts Cities Counties Towns Other Political subdivisions Accounts established by component units of the above Agencies Authorities Boards Departments Funds Institutions Commissions Committees Officers Schools (does not include activity fees) 7 Participants Defined • Treasury Board The Treasury Board of the Commonwealth created by Section 2.2-2415 of the Code of Virginia consists of the State Treasurer, the State Comptroller, the State Tax Commissioner, and four citizen members appointed by the Governor. • Escrow Agent An escrow agent is selected by a qualified public depository for the purpose of holding collateral pledged to the Treasury Board under SPDA and must meet the selection criteria outlined in Section 140 of the SPDA regulations. 8 Treasury Board Duties, Powers and Responsibilities Make and enforce regulations to perform its functions under the SPDA Fix terms and conditions by which public deposits may be held Determine securities that are eligible to be held as collateral Ensure that all Code of Virginia and SPDA Regulations requirements are met by each qualified depository Establish escrow agent criteria In case of default or insolvency, take action as deemed advisable in accordance with program requirements to recover public funds Report to public depositors any non-compliance with the Code or Regulations by qualified depositories Require additional collateral in excess of required collateral as it may determine prudent 9 Program Overview 10 How Does SPDA Work? • Creates a single body of law to secure Virginia public deposits. • Requires qualified public depositories to secure public deposits by pledging securities as collateral to be held in escrow for the Virginia Treasury Board. • Provides Treasury Board a perfected security interest in pledged collateral. • Empowers Treasury Board to make and enforce regulations to administer SPDA. • Creates a pooled collateral method to secure public deposits among qualified public depositories: • mutuality of responsibility among depositories • cross guarantee among depositories • 50% minimum collateral requirement • In the event of a default, assesses each qualified public depository its proportionate share of the loss of any uncollateralized and uninsured public deposits held by the defaulting depository based on the ratio that each depository’s average public deposits bear to the average total of all public deposits for the preceding twelve months. 11 Public Deposit Security Agreement TREASURY BOARD QUALIFIED PUBLIC DEPOSITORY ESCROW AGENT 12 Execution required before public depository can accept or retain any public deposit. Tri-party agreement. Perfected security interest to the collateral by the Treasury Board. Reporting TREASURY BOARD • Summary of Depository Status Report •Monthly and Quarterly Statistics • Monthly Qualified Depository Listing ESCROW AGENT •Monthly securities report •Confirmations of deposits, substitutions and collateral withdrawals Qualified Public Depository • Monthly Depository Report • List of Public Depositors • Quarterly Depositor Notice 13 Public Depositor SECURITY FOR PUBLIC DEPOSITS SUMMARY OF DEPOSITORY STATUS FOR THE MONTH ENDED NOVEMBER 2009 UNDERCOLLATERALIZED DEPOSITORIES: STATUS: None NEW QUALIFIED DEPOSITORIES: WashingtonFirst Bank Washington, DC MERGED QUALIFIED DEPOSITORIES: None DEPOSITORIES WITH NAME CHANGES: None 14 Summary of Qualified Depositories As of November 2009 Bank Name SPDA contact location Access National Bank Reston, VA Alliance Bank Chantilly,VA American National Bank and Trust Company Danville,VA Bank of America Dallas, TX Bank of Botetourt Buchanan, VA Bank of Charlotte County Phenix, VA Bank of Clarke County Berryville, VA Bank of Essex Tappahannock, VA Bank of Fincastle Fincastle, VA Bank of Floyd Floyd, VA Bank of Georgetown Washington, DC website link: http://www.trs.virginia.gov/documents/ops/Report.pdf 15 Audit Certification In accordance with section 110 of the Virginia SPDA Regulations With the submission of the “Public Depository Monthly Report” to the State Treasurer for the month ending June 30, qualified public depositories shall attach an annual certification from an independent certified public accountant or their internal audit department, attesting to the accuracy of the public deposit balances reported to the State Treasurer during their previous fiscal year. 16 Audit Certification Recommended Audit Procedures Testing of the compilation and accuracy of public deposit account balances reported Calculation of average daily deposit balances reported Omission of public deposit accounts Accuracy in the calculation of FDIC for public deposit accounts 17 Responsibilities of Public Officials Responsibilities of Public Officials Section 58.1-3158. Duties of treasurers -No treasurer shall permit any public deposit to be deposited with any depository unless it is a “qualified public depository” as defined in Section 2.2-4401. All such deposits shall be secured pursuant to the Virginia Security for Public Deposits Act (Section 2.2-4400 et seq.) Section 58.1-3177.B Duties of the clerk; deposit of funds; investment of funds; failure to pay out. -All moneys received by the clerk shall be deposited intact as soon as practical and secured in accordance with the Virginia Security for Public Deposits Act (Section 2.2-4400 et seq.) 19 Responsibilities of Public Officials Section 2.2-4408. Authority to deposit public funds. A. All treasurers and public depositors are hereby authorized to deposit funds under their control in qualified public depositories securing public deposits pursuant to this chapter. B. Local officials handling public funds in the Commonwealth may not require from a depository institution any pledge of collateral for their deposits in such institution which is in excess of the requirements of this chapter. Section 2.2-4410. Liability of treasurers or public depositors. When deposits are made in accordance with this chapter no treasurer or public depositor shall be liable for any loss thereof resulting from the failure or default of any depository in the absence of negligence, malfeasance, misfeasance, or nonfeasance on his part or on the part of his assistants or employees. 20 Responsibilities of Public Officials To ensure public deposits are deposited in a “qualified public depository” as defined in Section 2.2-4401 of the Code of Virginia. Ensure that locality’s funds remain with a qualified depository during mergers, acquisitions and name changes. To ensure locality’s depositories know that locality’s demand deposit accounts and non-negotiable certificates of deposit are considered public deposits under the SPDA and are collateralized accordingly. To ensure locality’s depositories comply with the SPDA by reviewing the Summary of Depository Status Report (available at www.trs.virginia.gov in the Operations Division). To review quarterly public depositor report (bank statements) and notify the State Treasurer’s office of any discrepancies between the statement and the depositor’s records. To notify locality’s depository of large deposits pending so the depository can have sufficient collateral pledged to cover the deposit. 21 Program Statistics 22 Statistics as of September 30, 2009 Total Public Deposits $4,980,997,063 •$3,406,834,368 (net of FDIC coverage) Total Market Value Collateral $4,208,218,256 Total Required Collateral $2,594,631,522 Percentage of Public Deposits held by the six largest Public Depositories 64% Total Qualified Public Depositories 121 Total banks required to pledge at 100% - 24 Total savings banks required to pledge at 110% - 1 23 Public Deposits by Bank Type September 30, 2009 Bank Type September 30, 2009 Total Public Deposits % of Total September 30, 2009 Treasurer of VA Accounts % of Total Virginia National Banks 197,531,263.95 5.80% 24,405,510.21 18.20% Virginia State Chartered Bank 932,916,021.54 27.38% 28,064,281.62 20.92% 1,130,447,285.49 33.18% 52,469,791.83 39.12% 862,780,272.91 25.32% 58,291,169.08 43.46% Out of State- State Chartered Banks 1,411,990,902.10 41.45% 23,363,738.12 17.42% Total Out of State Banks 2,274,771,175.01 66.77% 81,654,907.20 60.88% 1,615,907.58 0.05% 3,406,834,368.08 100.00% Total Virginia Banks Out of State National Banks Savings and Loans Grand Total 24 0 134,124,699.03 0.00% 100.00% Recent Developments 25 Need for Change (Fall 2008) Continued weakness in banking sector Concentration of Virginia public deposits-Six banks hold 64% of public deposits Only 50% collateral requirements for most banks Desire on the part of banks to opt out of collateral pool, reducing their risk of loss under the SPDA program 26 Change in Collateral Requirements Increased collateral that banks holding public deposits must pledge (effective February 2009) public deposits (net of FDIC) under $50 million collateralized at 50% public deposits between $50 million and $250 million collateralized at 75% public deposits over $250 million collateralized at 100% 27 2009 Legislative Action Enactment of HB1761 by 2009 General Assembly Allows banks that fully collateralize their public deposits to “opt out” of the collateral pool and be responsible for only securing their public deposits; no partial liability for the loss of Virginia public deposits held by another bank that defaults Implementation effective January 1, 2010, Treasury Board established guidelines to allow banks to opt out of the pooled arrangement 28 Collateralization of Public Deposits Effective January 2010 Two choices: Pooled Method Dedicated Method Annual Election Period November 1 thru December 1 for next calendar year Savings banks can only use dedicated method 29 Pooled Method Liable for proportionate share of losses of uninsured and uncollateralized public deposits held by SPDA bank in default Collateralization requirements same as those adopted by Treasury Board in February 2009 100% collateralization of public deposits if ranked “below average” by IDC bank rating service Monthly reporting of public deposit balances Monthly reporting and pricing of collateral No change in types of eligible securities that can be pledged as collateral 30 Pooled Method Collateral Calculation Public Deposits (net of FDIC) $500,000,000 Collateral Requirement Tier 1 (50% of $50 million) $ 25,000,000 Tier 2 (75% of $ 200 million) $150,000,000 Tier 3 (100% of excess balances) $250,000,000 Total $425,000,000 31 Dedicated Method No contingent liability for losses of public deposits when another qualified public depository fails. Collateral requirements based on financial strength of each banking institution Financial strength based on ratings assigned by IDC bank rating service Weekly and monthly reporting of public deposit balances Weekly and monthly reporting and pricing of securities held as collateral Mortgage-backed securities and non-Virginia municipal securities valued at 80% of market value Virginia municipal securities valued at 90% of market value 32 Dedicated Method Collateral Requirements Banks rated superior – 105% Banks rated excellent – 110% Banks rated below average – 120% Banks rated lowest rating tier – 130% 33 Dedicated Method Collateral Calculation Public Deposits (net of FDIC) $500,000,000 Collateral Requirement Bank rated “Average” @ 110% $550,000,000 34 Composition of Pooled and Opt-out Banks 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Pooled Banks opt out banks # of banks $ deposited 35 2010 Legislative Action Legislation was introduced to amend Security for Public Deposits Act for recent changes Codifies the pooled and dedicated methods Redefines “public deposit” Simplifies payment of losses Sections 2.24403 and 2.2-4404 SB456 and HB1036 36 Public Deposits Defined-Effective July 2010 “Public deposit” means moneys held by a public depositor who is charged with the duty to receive or administer such moneys and is acting in an official capacity, such moneys being deposited in any of the following types of accounts: non-negotiable time deposits, demand deposits, savings deposits, or any other transaction accounts. 37 Contacts 38 SPDA Treasury Contacts (As of January 2010) Thelma Ingle Manager, Agency Accounting(804) 371-6009 Thelma.Ingle@trs.virginia.gov Kristin Reiter Director, Operations Division Kristin.Reiter@trs.virginia.gov E-mail: (804) 225-3240 SPDAMail@trs.virginia.gov SPDA information on Treasury’s website: www.trs.virginia.gov/Operations/operations.aspx 39 Department of the Treasury Fraud Prevention Disbursement Accounts 40 Payee Match Positive Pay Definition The Payee Match Positive Pay service provides the Commonwealth of Virginia (COV) with a high level of protection against unauthorized disbursements and fraudulent checks. Checks presented for payment, including those presented for encashment in the branches, are matched by check number, dollar amount and payee name against COV’s check issue file. COV is then notified of any checks that do not match this criteria and instructs the bank to pay or return the item. 41 Payee Match Positive Pay MAJOR FEATURES COV issues and mails checks on behalf of each agency. 24 hours prior to the issuance, COV sends an electronic data transmission file containing the check information to the bank. The bank updates the check issue information to the teller system several times per day, which assists in making sure the most recent check data is available to the tellers for verification. The bank matches the paid (posted) checks against the issued checks and notifies the COV of unmatched items via an Internet-based bank information reporting service. 42 Payee Match Positive Pay How It Works COV’s check-issue information is electronically transmitted to the bank at least 24 hours prior to the issuing of checks. Any manual check issues or cancellations are entered via the bank’s Internet-based information reporting service up until the end of each business day. As checks are presented for payment, the bank matches the check number, amount and payee against the issue file to identify unauthorized items. Notification of any checks that do not match COV’s issue information is provided through the bank’s Internet-based information reporting service, whereupon COV indicates its decision to accept or return each check online. Images of the checks in question are provided. The pay/no pay decision must be made by 2 p.m. ET. If a pay or return decision is not made by the daily cut-off time, exceptions are either paid or returned based on COV’s pre-determined default decision. 43 Payee Match Positive Pay Benefits COV is protected against unauthorized check disbursements. Reduces research time and expense as only authorized checks are paid. Reduces potential legal expenses for COV. Helps control/reduce audit costs associated with fraudulent checks. 44