Council Please Contact: Emma Denny Please email: emma.denny@north-norfolk.gov.uk Please Direct Dial on: 01263 516010 17 February 2014 A meeting of the North Norfolk District Council will be held in the Council Chamber at the Council Offices, Holt Road, Cromer on Wednesday 26 February 2014 at 6.00 p.m. Sheila Oxtoby Chief Executive To: All Members of the Council Members of the Management Team, appropriate Officers, Press and Public. If you have any special requirements in order to attend this meeting, please let us know in advance If you would like any document in large print, audio, Braille, alternative format or in a different language please contact us Chief Executive: Sheila Oxtoby Corporate Directors: Nick Baker and Steve Blatch Tel 01263 513811 Fax 01263 515042 Minicom 01263 516005 Email districtcouncil@north-norfolk.gov.uk Web site northnorfolk.org AGENDA 1. PRAYER Led by Reverend Paul Neale, Assistant Minister, Cromer Parish Church with St Martins. 2. CHAIRMAN’S COMMUNICATIONS To receive the Chairman’s communications, if any. 3. TO RECEIVE DECLARATIONS OF INTERESTS FROM MEMBERS Members are asked at this stage to declare any interests that they may have in any of the following items on the agenda. The Code of Conduct for Members requires that declarations include the nature of the interest and whether it is a disclosable pecuniary interest. 4. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE To receive apologies for absence, if any. 5. MINUTES (attached – page 1) To confirm the minutes of the meeting of the Council held on 18 December 2013. 7. ITEMS OF URGENT BUSINESS To determine any other items of business which the Chairman decides should be considered as a matter of urgency pursuant to Section 100B (4)(b) of the Local Government Act 1972. 8. PUBLIC QUESTIONS To consider any questions received from members of the public. 9. APPOINTMENTS a) To put forward Councillor T FitzPatrick for appointment as Director of Norse Environmental Waste Services Limited (NEWS) company number 08714244 b) To appoint a Member to the Norfolk Waste Partnership 10. RECOMMENDATIONS FROM CABINET 3 FEBRUARY 2014 a) AGENDA ITEM 10: BUDGET MONITORING 2013/14 – PERIOD 9 (Cabinet Agenda 03 February 2014 – p. 31) To agree and recommend to Council the updated budget as set out in section 5.1, Table 3 of the report. RECOMMENDATION FROM OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE The Overview and Scrutiny Committee endorsed the Cabinet recommendation at their meeting on 12 February 2014. b) AGENDA ITEM 11: TREASURY MANAGEMENT STRATEGY (Cabinet Agenda 03 February 2014 – p. 30) That the Treasury Management Strategy statement is approved RECOMMENDATION FROM OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE The Overview and Scrutiny Committee endorsed the Cabinet recommendation at their meeting on 12 February 2014. c) AGENDA ITEM 12: 2014/15 BUDGET REPORT (Cabinet Agenda 03 February 2014 – p. 40) That Council approves: 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) 8) 9) 11. The 2014/15 revenue budget as outlined at Appendix E; The surplus of £533,425 be allocated to the general reserve; The demand on the Collection Fund, subject to any amendments as a result of final precepts still to be received be: a. £5,205,386 for District purposes b. £1,599,741 (subject to confirmation of the final precepts) for Parish/Town Precepts; The statement of and movement on the reserves as detailed at Appendix I of the report; The updated Capital Programme and financing for 2013/14 to 2016/17 as detailed at Appendix J of the report; The new capital bids as detailed at Appendix K of the report; The prudential indicators as included at Appendix L of the report; The approval of a three year arrangement for the provision of Monitoring officer through NP Law as detailed within section 5.3.4 of the report; That members note the current financial projections for the period 2015/16 to 2017/18. BUDGET AND COUNCIL TAX SETTING 2014/2015 (Agenda note: This item will be dealt with in two parts. The Budget for 2014/15 will be considered first followed by the Council Tax Setting 2014/15) (attached – page 9) (Appendix A – p.28) (Appendix B – p.29) (Appendix C – p.33) Summary: Options considered: Conclusions: This report presents for approval the budget for 2014/15 and to make statutory calculations in accordance with the Local Government Finance Act 1992 to set the Council Tax for 2014/15. The report also includes the Chief Financial Officer’s report on the robustness of the estimates and adequacy of reserves. It is a statutory requirement to set the budget each year, whilst there are options around the content of the budget presented for approval, the budget now recommended reflects the recommendations made by Cabinet at its meeting on 3 February 2014. It is the opinion of the Council’s Chief Financial Officer that the budget for 2014/15 has been set within a robust framework and the impact of this resolution will maintain an adequate level of financial reserves held by the Council. Recommendations: That having considered the Chief Financial Officer’s report on the robustness of the estimates and the adequacy of the proposed financial reserves, the following be approved: a) The General Fund Revenue Budget for 2014/15 (Appendix A) ; The Policy Framework for the Earmarked Reserves and the Optimum Level of the General Reserve 2014/15 to 2017/18 (Appendix B); The level of the General Reserve maintained at a minimum of £1.75 million; The General and Earmarked Reserves are employed as shown in the Reserves Statement (Appendix C); That members undertake the Council Tax and statutory calculations set out at section 4, and set the Council Tax for 2014/15; The final demand on the Collection Fund for District purposes (NNDC) for 2014/15 be £5,205,386; The final demand on the collection fund for Parish/Town precepts for 2013/14 be £1,635,884. b) c) d) e) f) g) Reasons for Recommendations: Cabinet Member(s) Ward(s) affected Contact Officer, telephone number, and e-mail: 12. To approve the 2014/15 budget for revenue and capital and to make the statutory calculations in respect of the 2014/15 Council Tax. All All Karen Sly 01263 516243 karen.sly@north-norfolk.gov.uk PAY POLICY STATEMENT (attached – p.35) (Appendix D – p.37) Summary: Section 38 of the Localism Act 2011 (“the Act”) requires the Council to produce an annual pay policy statement (“the statement”) for the start of each financial year. The attached statement is drawn up in compliance with the Act to cover the period 2014/15. It is a legal requirement that Council formally signs off this statement and the responsibility cannot be devolved to any other person or committee. Conclusions: The attached statement sets out current remuneration arrangements including the Travel Policy for staff. Recommendations: 1) To adopt the attached Pay Policy Statement and to publish the statement for 2014/15 on the Council’s website. 2) To adopt the revised Travel Policy shown at Appendix D. 13. Cabinet Member(s) Ward(s) affected Tom FitzPatrick All Contact Officer, telephone number, and e-mail: Julie Cooke 01263 516040 julie.cooke@north-norfolk.gov.uk RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE CONSTITUTION WORKING PARTY 03 FEBRUARY 2014 RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL: To include the following criteria for appointments to Outside Bodies within North Norfolk District Council’s Constitution: Is the appointment relevant to any Council responsibilities (portfolio, chairmanship, for example)? Does the appointee bring skills and experience to the appointment? Does the appointee have the time and resources to devote to the role Does the appointee have a low likelihood of conflicts of interest Has there been any expression of preference / approval from the outside body? What is the term of appointment - long or short term? Is appointee able to commit to this length of term? 14. TO RECEIVE THE APPROVED MINUTES OF THE UNDERMENTIONED COMMITTEES Members are requested to note that the minutes of the undermentioned committees have been approved. Copies of all the minutes are available on the Council’s website or from Democratic Services. a) b) c) d) e) f) g) 15. Constitution Working Party – 15 November 2012 Standards Committee – 05 November 2013 Overview & Scrutiny Committee – 13 November Cabinet – 02 December 2012 Overview & Scrutiny Committee – 11 December 2013 Development Committee – 19 December 2013 Overview & Scrutiny Committee – 15 January 2014 REPORTS FROM THE CABINET OR MEMBERS OF THE CABINET To receive reports from the Cabinet or Members of the Cabinet. 16. QUESTIONS RECEIVED FROM MEMBERS To receive questions from Members. 17. OPPOSITION BUSINESS To receive any opposition business. 18. NOTICE(S) OF MOTION None received 19. EXCLUSION OF PRESS AND PUBLIC To pass the following resolution – if necessary: “That under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the following item(s) of business on the grounds that they involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph(s) _ of Part 1 of Schedule 12A (as amended) to the Act.” 20. PRIVATE BUSINESS Circulation: All Members of the Council. Members of the Management Team and other appropriate Officers. Press and Public COUNCIL Minutes of a meeting of North Norfolk District Council held on 18 December 2013 at the Council Offices, Holt Road, Cromer at 6.00 pm. Members Present: Mrs S A Arnold Mr M Baker Mrs L Brettle Mr B Cabbell Manners Mrs A ClaussenReynolds Mr N D Dixon Mrs H Eales Mrs A M Fitch-Tillett Mr T FitzPatrick Mrs A Green Mr T Ivory Mr G Jones Mr J H A Lee Mr N Lloyd Mrs A Moore Mr P W Moore Mr W J Northam Miss B Palmer Mr J Perry-Warnes Mr R Price Mr R Reynolds Mr J Savory Mr E Seward Mr R Shepherd Mr B Smith Mr N Smith Mr R Stevens Mrs A Sweeney Mr P Terrington Mrs V Uprichard Mrs L Walker Mr P Williams Mr R Wright Mr J A Wyatt Mr A Yiasimi Mr D Young Officers in Attendance: The Chief Executive, The Corporate Directors, the Monitoring Officer, the Head of Finance and the Democratic Services Team Leader Press: The Press were in attendance Members of the public: Mrs P Porter, Chairman of Walcott Parish Council 89. PRAYERS The Chairman introduced Reverend Canon Dr David Court, vicar of Cromer Parish Church who led the meeting in prayer. 90. PRESENTATION The Head of Finance gave a brief presentation on the processes involved in determining council tax discounts and the determination of the council tax base. 91. CHAIRMAN’S COMMUNICATIONS The Chairman spoke about recent events that she had attended. She mentioned the carol services at Great Yarmouth and Cromer, the pantomime at Sheringham Little Theatre and the Christmas Show on Cromer Pier. She then went on to talk in length about the recent storm surge, paying tribute to the resilience of local communities and praising council officers who had worked particularly hard to provide immediate support and advice to local residents. She reminded members that the surge had been worse than the 1953 floods and that because of the planning and preparation put in place there had been no injury or loss of life on this occasion. The Chairman concluded by reminding members about the carol service at the Council Offices on 23 December. A collection would take place during the service for Sheringham Salvation Army, BREAK and Glaven Caring. Council 1 1 18 December 2013 92. 93. TO RECEIVE DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST FROM MEMBERS Member Minute No & Heading Nature of Interest Mr T Ivory Minute 104 Reports from the Cabinet Non pecuniary interest – professional interest in the legal case mentioned. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE Apologies for absence were received from Mrs H Cox, Ms V Gay, Mrs P Grove-Jones, Mr B Hannah, Mr P W High, Mrs B McGoun, Mr R Oliver, Mr R Smith, Mr S Ward and Mr G Williams. 94. MINUTES The minutes of the meeting of Council held on 26 November 2013 were approved as a correct record, subject to the insertion of the following wording: Minute 88: ‘The Chairman advised members that they would now be voting on the following motion:’ Mr D Young raised a query about Minute 98: ‘Budget Monitoring 2013-14 Period 6’. He asked whether any further information was available regarding postage charges for the PCC elections. The Head of Finance provided the following response: ‘Registration Services – 2012/13 Police and Crime Commissioner election postage costs yet to be charged (£34,000) I can confirm that the variance relates to the amount that has not yet been reimbursed in full by the Home Office for the Police and Crime Commissioners Election. Claims for costs are submitted to the Electoral Claims Unit (the deadline for this was June and the claim was submitted on time). The Home Office will pay an element up-front and the balance is payable once the claim has been authorised. The variance reported relates to the balance outstanding.’ 95. ITEMS OF URGENT BUSINESS There were two items of urgent business: The first item was an urgent question submitted by Mrs L Walker and addressed to the Leader: ‘That the Council supports the idea that we cannot ignore the issues on coastal erosion and need to seek ways of securing the future of our coastal communities. Can the Leader tell us what steps the Council are taking to call down more funding on this urgent, vital matter? The Leader, Mr T FitzPatrick replied that the Council had already taken steps to address this matter. He and the Chief Executive had met with representatives from the DCLG in Whitehall and provided them with details of the damage and the costs incurred. They had sought assurance that the money that had been spent would be reimbursed and were encouraged Council 2 2 18 December 2013 that the DCLG had not ruled this out. Helen Edward, Director General for Localities at the DCLG was visiting Walcott on 19th December to see the damage for herself. This would be followed up by a meeting of regional Chief Executives in Norwich. The Council was also intending to produce a total coast plan to help with preparations for any future similar events. Mr FitzPatrick concluded by saying that the Council would continue the dialogue with the DCLG and the Environment Agency and the focus going forward would be on enhancing and strengthening sea defences rather than just repairing them. The Chairman thanked Mr FitzPatrick for his response and invited the Monitoring Officer to introduce the second item of urgent business. The Monitoring Officer explained that the recent tidal surge had meant that the Council had used emergency powers to undertake immediate repair work. To do this, standing orders had been suspended and Council’s approval was now sought for the endorsement of these actions and to approve the consequential changes to the budget and policy framework and the use of the Council’s reserves to cover costs. Mr FitzPatrick outlined the funding that was available to the Council that would go towards covering the costs incurred, such as insurance, the Bellwin Scheme, Council reserves and Government support. He went onto explain that the initial financial estimates of damage to NNDC assets which were insured was in the region of £1.61m. The excess for these claims would be approximately £90,000 - £96,000. In addition, storm damage to the sea defences which were not insured was expected to be in the region of £1.349m. There was also additional expenditure relating to the initial response and support for the incident which totalled £55,000. Mr FitzPatrick concluded by advising members that there was a risk that the costs associated with repairing the damage would not be recovered in full by either insurance or external funding. Equally, there was the risk that failure to carry out the repairs would increase the risk of further damage. It was therefore recommended that: ‘Members note the content of the report, endorse the use of the emergency powers delegated to the Chief executive, the suspension of standing orders in relation to the works and approve the consequential changes to the budget and policy framework and approval to use the Council’s reserves as required for the works and other related costs’. Members were invited to debate the Motion: a. Mr G Jones said that it was important that a report was made to Council at the earliest opportunity on the full costs to the Council and the implications for the budget. The Chief Executive replied that a report would be made to Cabinet in the New Year and an information pack would be circulated to all members and key stakeholders outlining the extent of the damage and the resultant losses suffered by local communities. b. Mr P W Moore said that the Council had done an excellent job and councils held reserves for such events. c. Mr E Seward commented that it was very important that feedback on the situation was provided through the relevant committees. He said that the updates and briefings provided to members to date had been excellent but warned that there were likely to be significant challenges ahead and he was concerned that momentum could be lost. d. Mr P Williams queried whether residents made homeless by the tidal surge would automatically receive redemption on their council tax. The Chief Executive confirmed that this had already happened. e. Mr T Ivory expressed his thanks to all staff who had been involved in providing support to local communities following the tidal surge. He said that criticism from central government regarding the level of local authority reserves had been negated as recent events had Council 3 3 18 December 2013 demonstrated the value of them and also shown that local councils were the first port of call in such situations. f. Mrs A Fitch-Tillett, Portfolio Holder for the coast, thanked staff for their hard work and support. She commented that although the floods were worse than the 1953 floods, noone had been hurt or killed which was huge relief and showed the effectiveness of the coastal defences. She said that any members who wished to receive information going forward, were welcome to attend meetings of the Coastal Forum. g. Mr R Price agreed with members’ comments so far. He queried whether the Environment Agency would be supplying similar information in respect of costs. Mrs A Fitch-Tillett, replied that a report would be made to the regional Flood and Coastal Committee during the second week of January and she offered to circulate this to members. h. Mr M Baker said that he was disappointed that the Prime Minister had only made a fleeting visit to the district. He commented on the level of international aid and suggested that the Council should write to the Government and push for additional funding. i. Mr G Jones said that there needed to be a change of philosophy on sea defences – especially for high risk areas such as Walcott. The Chief Executive said that herself, the Leader and Helen Edward, Director General for Localities at the DCLG were visiting Walcott on 19th December. She added that the Head of Economic and Community Development and the Coastal Engineer were compiling a detailed report on the district’s sea defences which would be circulated to members. j. Mr P Terrington said that he believed that there were not sufficient resources available to protect the whole coastline and that difficult choices would have to be made going forward. k. Mr R Reynolds commented that the fact that many of the sea defences had held indicated that they were effective. l. Mr R Shepherd said that he was shocked to see caravans sited on the sea wall at Walcott and that residents should be advised of the dangers they were exposed to. Mr G Jones said that he would like to see his proposal to report back to Council included within the Motion. Mr T FitzPatrick said that this was not necessary as the Chief Executive had already confirmed that this would happen. It was proposed by Mr T FitzPatrick, seconded by Mrs A Fitch-Tillett and RESOLVED To note the content of the report, endorse the use of the emergency powers delegated to the Chief executive, the suspension of standing orders in relation to the works and approve the consequential changes to the budget and policy framework and approval to use the Council’s reserves as required for the works and other related costs. Mr G Jones voted against the motion. 96. PUBLIC QUESTIONS Democratic Services had not been notified of any questions prior to the meeting, however, Mrs P Porter, Chairman of Walcott Parish Council, indicated that she wished to speak. Mr P W Moore proposed that standing orders were suspended to allow her to ask a question. Mr T FitzPatrick seconded this proposal. Mrs Porter said that she was aggrieved to hear Mr R Shepherd’s comments regarding the siting of caravans at Walcott. She said that they were people’s homes and there was nowhere else for them to go. Mr G Jones commented that Mrs Porter should have been allowed to speak without the suspension of standing orders. He then left the meeting. Council 4 4 18 December 2013 97. APPOINTMENTS It was proposed by Mr T FitzPatrick, seconded by Mrs A Fitch-Tillett and RESOLVED a) To appoint Mr Smith to the Member Development Group b) To appoint Miss B Palmer to the Constitution Working Party c) To appoint Mr J Punchard as a substitute to the Constitution Working Party 98. DETERMINATION OF COUNCIL TAX DISCOUNTS AND CHARGES FOR 2014/15 Mr W Northam, Portfolio Holder for Finance introduced this item. He explained that the report recommended the level of council tax discounts and premiums which would apply to second homes, empty properties and uninhabitable dwellings for the financial year 2014/15. It was proposed by Mr W Northam, seconded by Mr J Perry-Warnes and RESOLVED That under section 11A of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, and in accordance with the provisions of the Local Government Finance Act 2012 and other enabling powers that: the council tax discount for dwellings defined as being within Class ‘A’ remains at 50% for the year 2014/15; the council tax discount for dwellings defined as being within Class ‘B’ remains at 5% for the year 2014/15; those dwellings that are specifically identified under regulation 6 of the Council Tax (Prescribed Classes of Dwellings)(England) Regulations 2003, which will retain the 50% discount; those dwellings described or geographically defined at Appendix A which in the reasonable opinion of the Head of Finance are judged not to be structurally capable of occupation all year round and were built before the restrictions of seasonal usage were introduced by the Town and Country Planning Act 1947, will retain the 50% discount; the council tax discount for dwellings defined as being within Class ‘C’ to remain at 100% for three months for the year 2014/15; the council tax discount for dwellings defined as being within Class ‘D’ to remain at 50% for twelve months for the year 2014/15. That under section 11B(2) of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, and in accordance with the provisions of the Local Government Finance Act 2012 and other enabling powers: A premium is charged for properties which have been empty and substantially unfurnished for two years or more of 50% of the council tax payable in relation to that Council 5 5 18 December 2013 dwelling. In accordance with the relevant legislation these determinations shall be published in at least one newspaper circulating in North Norfolk before the end of the period of 21 days beginning with the date of the determinations. One member abstained. 99. DETERMINATION OF THE COUNCIL TAX BASE FOR 2014/15 AND THE TREATMENT OF SPECIAL EXPENSES Mr W Northam introduced this item. He explained that the purpose of the report was to determine the Council’s 2014/15 tax base and the 2014/15 tax base for each parish in accordance with the legal requirements. The determination of the tax base for a financial year has to be undertaken in accordance with legislative requirements between 1 December and 31 January of the preceding financial year. Mrs A Moore queried whether the recent damage caused by the tidal surge would come under special expenses. The Head of Finance explained that this was outside the Council’s funding and would fall to the relevant parish councils. Mr P Williams queried whether costs incurred by Hickling Parish Council would count as special expenses. The Chief Executive replied that special expenses related to non-parished areas. It was proposed by Mr W Northam, seconded by Mrs S Arnold and RESOLVED a) That the calculations set out in the report used to produce the Council’s tax base be approved, and the tax base for 2014/15 be determined as 36,769; b) That the tax base for each parish area for the financial year 2014/15 be as set out at paragraph 2.1. of the report 100. DRAFT PROGRAMME OF MEETINGS 2014/15 Mr T FitzPatrick introduced this item in the Portfolio Holder’s absence. He said that the programme had been circulated to members and any amendments had been incorporated. Mr P Terrington queried the long gap between meetings of the Coastal Forum. He said that given the impact of the recent tidal surge on coastal communities, it might be beneficial if the forum met more frequently. Mrs A Fitch-Tillett replied that the Coastal Management Board met bi-monthly and regular updates would be provided via the Members’ Bulletin. It was proposed by Mr T FitzPatrick, seconded by Mr R Reynolds and RESOLVED To approve the draft programme of meetings for 2014/15. 101. RECOMMENDATIONS FROM CABINET 02 DECEMBER 2013 AGENDA ITEM 10: FEES AND CHARGES 2014/15 Council 6 6 18 December 2013 Mr W Northam, Portfolio Holder for Finance presented this item. He explained that the fees and charges recommended in the report would be used to inform the income budgets for 2014/15. He added that when recommending changes to fees and charges, the Council considered inflation and the charges that the Council itself paid. Mr M Baker queried the introduction of charges for the installation of wood burners. Mr S Blatch (Corporate Director) replied that the proposal had come from the Council’s Building Control Service as more householders were requesting a certificate of installation and this had a cost implication for the Council. He said that he would provide the legislative context for the proposals to members as soon as possible. It was proposed by Mr W Northam, seconded by Mr P W Moore and RESOLVED To agree: a) The fees and charges from 1 April 2014 as included at Appendix A; b) The fees for the certification for the installation of wood burners to come into effect from 1 January 2014 as follows: Installation of a solid fuel appliance (eg. Wood Burner): (i) Where the appliance is commissioned by a third party, a Building Notice Charge, including VAT, of £180; (ii) Where the appliance is tested by NNDC a Building Notice Charge, including VAT, of £312. To note the updated budget as set out in section 5.1, Table 3 4 members voted against the recommendation, 3 members abstained. AGENDA ITEM 11: HOUSING BENEFIT AND COUNCIL TAX SUPPORT COUNTER FRAUD POLICY AND PROSECUTION POLICY Mr W Northam, Portfolio Holder for Revenues and Benefits introduced this item. He explained that the introduction of the Council Tax Support scheme in April 2013 meant that the Housing Benefit and Council Tax Support counter fraud policy and prosecution policy needed to be revised. The new policies reflected the introduction of council tax support and the supporting legislation that enabled the council to take appropriate action to investigate suspected fraud and impose sanctions. It was proposed by Mr W Northam, seconded by Mr P W Moore and RESOLVED To adopt the revised Counter Fraud Policy and Prosecution Policy. 102. RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE 11 DECEMBER 2013 The Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Mr P W Moore, introduced this item. He said that the committee had considered 4 items and accepted the recommendations for each of them. 103. TO RECEIVE THE MINUTES OF THE UNDERMENTIONED COMMITTEES RESOLVED Council 7 7 18 December 2013 to note the approved minutes of the undermentioned committee: Cabinet – 04 November 2013 104. REPORTS FROM THE CABINET OR MEMBERS OF THE CABINET Mr T FitzPatrick reiterated his earlier comments regarding the recent tidal surge. He again thanked all the staff that had worked so hard in the days after the event. He then extended his thanks to everyone within local communities that had worked tirelessly to provide support to all those that had been affected. He said that Mrs Porter, Chairman of Walcott Parish Council, was an excellent example of this. He added that local businesses had also been very supportive and praised the Lighthouse Inn in Walcott and staff at Bacton Gas Terminal. He concluded by thanking the Eastern Daily Press (EDP) for maintaining a high level of publicity and setting up the support fund. Mr FitzPatrick then informed members of the outcome of the Court of Appeal action regarding the development of a lorry park by Crisp Maltings in Great Ryburgh. He confirmed that the Court of Appeal had published its judgment in respect of the joint appeal made by the Council and Crisp Maltings Ltd against the decision of the High Court in May 2013 to quash the planning permission granted by the Council in September 2011 for a lorry park, silos and associated development at Great Ryburgh. The Court of Appeal had allowed the appeal, which meant that the original permission granted by the Development Committee remained valid. The Chairman of the Development Committee expressed her thanks to Roger Howe, Planning Legal Manager, for all his hard work. 105. NOTICE(S) OF MOTION The notice of motion had been dealt with under Urgent Business.. The meeting concluded at 7.26 pm. _________________________ Chairman Council 8 8 18 December 2013 Agenda Item No_____11_______ COUNCIL TAX 2014/15 Summary: Options considered: This report presents for approval the budget for 2014/15 and to make statutory calculations in accordance with the Local Government Finance Act 1992 to set the Council Tax for 2014/15. The report also includes the Chief Financial Officer‟s report on the robustness of the estimates and adequacy of reserves. It is a statutory requirement to set the budget each year, whilst there are options around the content of the budget presented for approval, the budget now recommended reflects the recommendations made by Cabinet at its meeting on 3 February 2014. Conclusions: It is the opinion of the Council‟s Chief Financial Officer that the budget for 2014/15 has been set within a robust framework and the impact of this resolution will maintain an adequate level of financial reserves held by the Council. Recommendations: That having considered the Chief Financial Officer‟s report on the robustness of the estimates and the adequacy of the proposed financial reserves, the following be approved: a) b) c) d) e) f) g) Reasons for Recommendations: The General Fund Revenue Budget for 2014/15 (Appendix A) ; The Policy Framework for the Earmarked Reserves and the Optimum Level of the General Reserve 2014/15 to 2017/18 (Appendix B); The level of the General Reserve maintained at a minimum of £1.75 million; The General and Earmarked Reserves are employed as shown in the Reserves Statement (Appendix C); That members undertake the Council Tax and statutory calculations set out at section 4, and set the Council Tax for 2014/15; The final demand on the Collection Fund for District purposes (NNDC) for 2014/15 be £5,205,386; The final demand on the collection fund for Parish/Town precepts for 2013/14 be £1,635,884. To approve the 2014/15 budget for revenue and capital and to make the statutory calculations in respect of the 2014/15 Council Tax. 9 LIST OF BACKGROUND PAPERS AS REQUIRED BY LAW (Papers relied on the write the report and which do not contain exempt information) Budget reports and briefings, precepts (NCC, Police and Parishes) Cabinet Member(s) Ward(s) affected: All All Contact Officer, telephone number and email: Karen Sly, 01263 516243, Karen.sly@north-norfolk.gov.uk 1. Introduction 1.1 This report presents for approval the 2014/15 General Fund revenue and capital budgets along with the Council Tax for 2014/15. It also presents for information only the current budget projections for 2015/16 to 2017/18. 1.2 The budget for 2014/15, along with detailed projections for the following three financial years, was considered by Cabinet on 3 February 2014 and then by Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 12 February 2014. 1.3 This report includes the updated position for the 2014/15 budget and future projections following the final Local Government Finance Settlement announcement on 5 February 2014. Further details on the outcome of this announcement are included in section 2 of the report. 2. 2014/15 Budget 2.1 Since the budget report was produced for Cabinet earlier this month the position for 2014/15 has been updated for the following: 2.1.1 Final Local Government Finance Settlement - The budget report presented to Cabinet and Scrutiny earlier this month included the provisional Local Government Finance Settlement figures as announced on 18 December 2013. Confirmation of the Councils final finance settlement for 2014/15 was issued on 5 February 2014. The only financial change within the settlement funding assessment was in relation to the „returned funding‟ element which totalled £841 additional for 2014/15. It was also announced that the “Efficiency Support for Services in Sparse Areas” would in future be known as “Rural Services Delivery Grant” to better reflect its purpose and would be rolled into the settlement. There was a further announcement made on 12 February regarding the extra funding for rural authorities, nationally an additional £2million has been allocated of which North Norfolk‟s share is £11,945. 2.1.2 New Homes Bonus - The final settlement announcement included final figures for the New Homes Bonus. There has been a slight change in relation to the number of affordable homes that are eligible for the bonus and in financial terms this equates to £2,520. 10 2.1.3 Drainage Board Levies – Final figures have now been confirmed by the Internal Drainage Boards which has resulted in a movement of £2,666 compared to the position previously reported. 2.2 The impact of the adjustments detailed above has increased the reported surplus by £18,188; these have been reflected in the appendices (A and C) attached to this report. 2.3 When the budget was reported to Cabinet on 3 February 2014 a number of final parish precepts were still to be confirmed. At the time of producing this report two final notifications are outstanding, although they have notified the Council of the planned precepts. 2.4 It should be noted that as the billing authority, the setting of the parish precepts will have an impact on the total billed amount although not on the element which represents the District Council. This means the total District amount billed for an average Band D for 2014/15 will be £183.36 (see para 4.6), comprising District element £138.87 and parish element £44.49 (subject to receiving the final two parish precept forms). 2.5 In making decisions in relation to setting the Council Tax, section 25 of the Local Government Act 2003 requires the Chief Financial Officer of the Council to report to the Council on the following matters: the robustness of the estimates made for the purpose of the budget calculations and the adequacy of the proposed financial reserves. 2.6 This is provided in section 3 of the report. 3. Chief Financial Officer’s Report The Robustness of the Estimates 3.1 This section of the report provides a commentary on the robustness of the estimates now presented and provides an analysis of the risks facing the Council in relation to the control of income and expenditure flows compared to the budgets that are recommended for 2014/15. 3.2 The framework within which the budget for 2014/15 has been constructed is similar to that of previous years and takes into account the following: a) Previous financial year out-turn position (2012/13) (3.3) b) Financial Strategy 2014/15 to 2016/17 (3.4) c) In-year budget monitoring and associated reports (3.5) d) Cash flow monitoring (3.6) 3.3 The final 2012/13 out turn position, following external audits review, was reported to Members in September 2013 and secures the starting position for developing the Council‟s budget. This position is used to update the financial planning process and establishes the baseline for the current estimates by reflecting significant movements which will have an on-going impact on the future financial position of the Council. 3.4 The financial planning process is well established and starts each year with the production of a four year Financial Strategy, which includes high level financial projections. For the 2014/15 budget this process started earlier than in previous years and was reported to members during September. As part of this process the 11 Council critically examines the proposed expenditure and income on existing services and seeks to identify changed priorities in service delivery and planned future developments, in line with the Corporate Plan and in response to both local and national pressures. It also identifies changes to spending plans and income projections. These are informed by the previous years out-turn position and the current year‟s budget monitoring projections. The financial forecast highlights the more significant budget movements in preparation for producing the full detailed budget for the forthcoming year. At the same time the anticipated level of future external Government funding is reviewed along with the latest forecast of Council Tax income and New Homes Bonus funding. By consolidating the financial forecasts, the Financial Strategy seeks to identify future estimated budget requirements and funding shortfalls at an early stage of the annual budget process. It also highlights workstreams that will commence prior to the start of the following financial year that will deliver future savings for the authority. 3.5 In Year Budget Monitoring – The budget monitoring process is carried out throughout the year with all expenditure and income being monitored on a monthly basis. Not only does this provide an essential tool for ensuring that the current year‟s budget is achievable, but it is also fundamental in ensuring that the most up to date information is incorporated into the future budget and projections taking into account where budget pressures are highlighted during the year. The regular budget monitoring is used to inform the annual financial planning and budget process, of changes that will have an on-going financial impact in future years, as opposed to having only a oneoff implication in the current financial year. As part of the budget monitoring process, monthly variance reports are provided to budget managers and regular reports presented to Cabinet and Overview and Scrutiny Committee detailing the projected outturn position for the current year. Regular reviews of expenditure and commitments to date, along with income streams, are carried out to ensure that overspends or shortfalls in income are identified at the earliest opportunity and reported to Corporate Leadership Team and Members along with recommended action plans to ensure that the Council‟s overall budget can be met. 3.6 Cash Flow Monitoring – The Council remains debt free. It currently has no long term borrowing requirement and there have been no cash flow issues. Sufficient liquidity is generally maintained to cover day to day cash requirements. The cash flow position of the Council is monitored on a daily basis and managed within the Treasury Management Strategy which is approved alongside the budget each year. Monitoring of the treasury position is included within the in-year budget monitoring reports in addition to the half-yearly Treasury Management report. 3.7 Budgets are prepared using the best information that is available to the Council from its own sources and from external advisors for example the Council‟s treasury advisors, Arlingclose. However, many budgets are related to factors that fall outside the control of the Council, for example pay awards, demand led income levels, inflation and interest rates, and all can have a significant impact on the Council‟s overall budget. Forecasting in these areas requires an examination of recent trends as well as assimilating future projections from known factors. 3.8 There are a number of financial risks facing the authority which are relevant at both service and corporate levels. In order that these risks are managed, a number of key areas within the budget need to be closely monitored in the coming financial year, these include: a) Car park income – this area generates significant income for the Council which in turn supports the delivery of other services across the Council. The 2014/15 12 budget assumes gross income of just over £2.1 million from all car parking related fees and charges. b) Planning and building control fees – The 2014/15 base budget includes income totalling approximately £950,000 from planning and building control fees. c) Waste and recycling credits – this is a significant source of income to the Council and reflects the activity across the District in recycling domestic refuse. A total of £937,932 is included in the 2014/15 base budget. d) Planned Savings and Additional Income – the Council has identified a number of workstreams that are anticipated to deliver service improvements and cashable savings over the short to medium term. Achievement of the budgeted savings are monitored in-year as part of the budget monitoring process. New savings/additional income of £581,744 have been included in the budget for 2014/15 (this includes the additional income from rental of part of the Cromer Council offices from April 2014), these are anticipated to increase to £790,344 in the following year. e) Council Tax Support – the Local Council Tax Support Scheme (LCTSS) was implemented from April 2013, whilst there have been no changes to the Council‟s scheme for 2014/15, there still remains a risk of increases in the number of those eligible for Council Tax Support and the ability to collect Council Tax. f) Business Rates Retention – 2014/15 will be the second year of the business rates retention scheme. The implication of this system of funding is that the income from the Council‟s share of the business rates will fluctuate in-year and between years. The budget assumes the baseline funding as announced within the final Local Government finance settlement; this is essentially the starting point for the new scheme increased annually by RPI (or for 2014/15 capped at the increase in the Business rates multiplier of 1.95%). The actuals for the year will not be confirmed until the final National Non Domestic Rate (NNDR) return is completed for the year (annually in June). Furthermore the Government announced further reliefs for businesses from April 2014, including Retail Relief, New Build Empty Property Relief and Retail Premises Reoccupation Relief. These are in addition to the extension until March 2015 of the small business rate relief of up to 100% where eligible. Draft guidance has been issued by the Department for Communities and Local Government classing these reliefs as discretionary and that Councils will be reimbursed through a Section 31 grant for the amount of income foregone by providing the reliefs. Other factors that will have an impact of the level of rates retained are current and backdated appeals. g) Investment Returns – Over the past few years investment income has been significantly reduced in the light of the prolonged duration of low interest rates. The current investment strategy is looking for a return of 1.65% for 2014/15. The investment income budget assumes the investment portfolio is invested with counterparties in call accounts and term deposits in line with the Treasury Strategy 2014/15 as reported to Cabinet on 3 February 2014, and that existing deposits will continue to their maturity date. This also includes the £5 million investment in the Local Authorities Property Fund. 13 h) Tidal Surge/Storm Damage – Members have been made aware through regular updates including those within the budget and budget monitoring reports of the costs associated with the tidal surge that occurred on 5/6 December 2013. Whilst there are a number of confirmed sources for funding the costs, for example, through insurance claims, the Government‟s Bellwin Scheme (for emergency assistance) and the Severe Weather Recovery Scheme, there still remains a balance of potentially unfunded costs that could fall to the Council. Communications are on-going with various government departments regarding funding for the damage, the most significant being in relation to coastal defences. In the meantime, the budget report is recommending that funding be allocated from the general reserve to cover the impact of the damage. This will take the balance on the general reserve, significantly below the current recommended level. i) General Reserve – As mentioned above after allowing for funding of the tidal surge damage, the remaining balance in the General Reserve is below the current recommended balance. The past prudent financial management approach that the authority has adopted has ensured that the impact of the storm, should applications for funding be unsuccessful, has been mitigated at least in the short term. However the medium term financial planning process will need to take into account the reinstating of the reserve to the minimum recommended balance. 3.9 Looking forward beyond 2014/15, the financial projections included in the budget report indicate that further savings will have to be made; this is based on the assumptions about the future level of funding from 2015/16 onwards. The financial projections show a forecast budget gap of £239,122 in 2015/16, increasing to £1,326,790 in 2016/17 and £2,145,112 in 2017/18. 3.10 The capital programme relies on new capital receipts from the sale of assets for nonhousing capital projects; and preserved right to buy receipts and the VAT shelter arrangements for the housing programme. In both cases prudent estimates are made of the timing of such receipts and the expenditure profiles within the overall capital programme. 3.11 Budget monitoring throughout the financial year is critical to the robustness of the estimates. It is through the ability to manage and control the spending within the approved budgets and, where appropriate, identify and recommend appropriate actions, which serves to mitigate the Council‟s level of financial risk. 3.12 Throughout the process of preparing the Council‟s budget there is involvement of the Elected Members through Officer/Member meetings and reports to Cabinet and Overview and Scrutiny Committee. This includes both budget monitoring reports during the year and the Financial Strategy Report. 3.13 The Council also takes advice from third party organisations concerning a number of more technical factors that impact on the budget process, for example external advice in relation to treasury management, VAT and Insurance. By doing so the Council is able to monitor the wider implications of changes in interest rates, inflation and employment and take remedial action to mitigate financial risk. Adequacy of the Reserves 14 3.14 An assessment of the adequacy of the reserves, estimated to be available to the Council throughout 2014/15, is based on the possible commitments falling to be discharged against the following categories of reserves: General Reserve Earmarked Reserves. 3.15 Where there is budgeted expenditure to be funded from a reserve (earmarked or general) these will be allowed for within the reserves statement. 3.16 There are three main reasons for holding reserves: a) as a contingency to cushion the impact of unexpected events or emergencies; b) to cushion against the impact of uneven cash flows and to avoid temporary borrowing; and c) as a means of building up funds to meet known or predicted liabilities (earmarked reserves). 3.17 Reviewing the reserves is well established within the financial planning and budget setting process and is informed by the framework as set out in Appendix B to this report. An updated reserve statement is included at Appendix C to this report. 3.18 When assessing the level of reserves the Council should take account of strategic, operational and financial risks facing them. 3.19 In particular the risks associated with the Local Government funding mechanism including the retention of business rates continues to be a risk for the authority. The shift of risk to the Council of income and expenditure flows that form a proportionately larger part of the overall council‟s funding than when these risks were part of Central Government‟s budgets through the redistribution of business rates mechanism. These changes have increased the financial uncertainty facing local government and more local authorities are facing challenges to avoid financial difficulties whilst meeting their statutory responsibilities. 3.20 Other income streams from demand led services remain vulnerable both from economic factors and seasonal factors including weather that can influence for example car parking income. Steps have been taken to set prudent estimates of income from these services as appropriate but the activity that drives the income remains very difficult to predict. 3.21 The programme of savings identified as part of previous years financial planning and budget processes are set to continue throughout 2014/15 along with a number of new workstream savings. 3.22 The revised assessment of the General Reserve for 2014/15 and forward years, in total shows little change from the current policy. There have been some changes to the actual amounts allowed for certain elements within the General Reserve, most notably in relation to emergencies and other unknown events, but overall the recommended balance remains at £1.75million, which represents 13% of the net budgeted operating expenditure. The actual level of the General Reserve at the end of the financial year 2014/15 is estimated to be £723,879. 3.23 Earmarked reserves are estimated to total £6,078,114 by the end of the 2014/15 financial year. The main components of this total are the Capital Projects, the New Homes Bonus and the Restructuring/Invest to Save reserves. These reserves, along with all the other earmarked reserves have been reviewed against the framework in 15 appendix B, as decisions are made on the utilisation of these reserve the reserves position and projections will be updated accordingly. 3.24 The Capital Projects Reserve provides the funds for major asset purchases or other capital developments. It is supported by the VAT shelter receipts following the Large Scale Voluntary Transfer (LSVT) of the councils housing stock in 2006. 3.25 The New Homes Bonus Reserve is an un-ringfenced grant from Central Government predicated on the development of new dwellings within the district and calculated by reference to a prescribed formula. The balance in the earmarked reserve is earmarked for funding projects that will deliver growth. 3.26 The Restructuring/Invest to Save Reserve is held to provide one-off funding for projects and schemes that will deliver longer-term savings and efficiencies to the Council, for example the Business Transformation projects. 3.27 All of the earmarked reserves follow the protocol at paragraph 2.2 of the Policy Framework at Appendix B to this report Summary 3.28 In the opinion of the Chief Financial Officer the overall budgeted level of both the General Reserve and the Earmarked Reserves shown in Appendix C are considered adequate in the short term. For the reasons outlined within the report it is acknowledged that the General Reserve balance (£723,879) is forecast to be below that of the recommended balance (£1.75 million) and that work on the financial strategy to reinstate the balance to the recommended level will need to be undertaken early on as part of the next financial planning process. 3.29 When considering the robustness of the estimates and adequacy of reserves an holistic approach is taken, whilst there is a risk that the General Reserve is below the recommended balance, this is mitigated by the prudent estimates and also the overall level of earmarked reserves. 4. COUNCIL TAX SETTING FOR 2014/15 4.1 The following pages represent the information required for Members to set the Council Tax for the year commencing 1 April 2014. 4.2 Norfolk County Council is scheduled to meet on the 17 February 2014 to set its Council Tax, and the recommendation is to freeze the Council Tax at the same level as last year. An increase of 1.97% in the Council Tax for the Norfolk Police & Crime Commissioner was confirmed following the meeting of the Norfolk Police and Crime Panel on 31 January 2014. The figures used in this report are based on the assumption that there will be no increase for North Norfolk District Council (excluding town and parish council precepts) and Norfolk County Council, and a 1.97% increase for the Norfolk Police & Crime Commissioner. 4.3 The Localism Act 2011 makes provision for Council Tax referendums to be held if an authority increases its relevant basic amount of Council Tax in excess of principles determined by the Secretary of State. These excessiveness principles are set each year and the Secretary of State has decided that for 2014/15 an increase of 2% or more above the amount for 2013/14 will be excessive, and a referendum must be held. 16 4.4 The excessiveness principles apply in 2014/15 to billing authorities and major precepting authorities, and not to local precepting authorities (town and parish councils). However, in a ministerial statement the Department for Communities and Local Government stated “We have not determined principles for local precepting authorities in 2014 to 2015, but we are putting on notice that we are prepared if necessary to apply the referendum thresholds to larger town and parish councils from 2015 to 2016 onwards to provide protection for local taxpayers and extend the principle of direct democracy”. Statutory Calculations 4.5 That it be NOTED that at its meeting on 18 December 2013, Full Council calculated the following Council Tax bases for the year 2014/15 in accordance with regulations made under Section 31B of the Local Government Finance Act 1992 as amended: a) for the whole Council area as 36,769 (Item T in the formula in Section 31B of the Local Government Finance Act 1992) being calculated by the Council, in accordance with Regulation 3 of The Local Authorities (Calculation of Council Tax Base) (England) Regulations 2012, as its Council Tax base for the year; b) PART OF THE COUNCIL PART OF THE COUNCIL COUNCIL'S AREA TAX BASE COUNCIL’S AREA TAX BASE Alby with Thwaite 93.87 Little Barningham 38.74 Aldborough 205.27 Little Snoring 202.11 Antingham 116.50 Ludham 473.60 Ashmanhaugh 64.46 Matlaske 58.83 Aylmerton 195.36 Melton Constable 166.25 Baconsthorpe 79.03 Morston 54.16 Bacton 464.84 Mundesley 1,030.48 Barsham 95.03 Neatishead 228.50 Barton Turf 236.95 North Walsham 3,590.47 Beckham East/West 106.66 Northrepps 311.63 Beeston Regis 366.12 Overstrand 412.79 Binham 165.80 Paston 78.70 Blakeney 510.58 Plumstead 46.58 Bodham 153.91 Potter Heigham 385.49 Briningham 61.29 Pudding Norton 63.29 Brinton 119.93 Raynham 123.67 Briston 796.35 Roughton 310.41 Brumstead 24.54 Runton 682.81 Catfield 290.93 Ryburgh 217.39 Cley 301.20 Salthouse 112.26 Colby 181.77 Scottow 278.86 Corpusty and Saxthorpe 254.08 Sculthorpe 265.14 Cromer 2,672.30 Sea Palling 197.79 Dilham 129.88 Sheringham 2,920.48 Dunton 51.27 Sidestrand 43.51 East Ruston 179.57 Skeyton 84.34 Edgefield 177.47 Sloley 83.46 Erpingham 231.12 Smallburgh 173.64 Fakenham 2,303.74 Southrepps 311.48 Felbrigg 66.39 Stalham 970.68 Felmingham 177.49 Stibbard 128.11 17 PART OF THE COUNCIL'S AREA Field Dalling Fulmodestone Gimingham Great Snoring Gresham Gunthorpe Hanworth Happisburgh Helhoughton Hempstead Hempton Hickling High Kelling Hindolveston Hindringham Holkham Holt Honing Horning Horsey Hoveton Ingham Ingworth Itteringham Kelling Kettlestone Knapton Langham Lessingham Letheringsett with Glandford COUNCIL PART OF THE TAX BASE COUNCIL’S AREA 129.91 Stiffkey 169.45 Stody 139.62 Suffield 75.55 Sustead 160.26 Sutton 140.37 Swafield 92.47 Swanton Abbott 283.89 Swanton Novers 112.22 Tattersett 72.53 Thornage 172.44 Thorpe Market 382.33 Thurning 263.26 Thursford 190.31 Trimingham 223.47 Trunch 86.17 Tunstead 1,500.57 Upper Sheringham 115.85 Walcott 583.64 Walsingham 30.14 Warham 697.94 Wells-next-the-Sea 138.62 Westwick 39.89 Weybourne 57.30 Wickmere 83.25 Wighton 86.05 Witton 141.08 Wiveton 191.13 Wood Norton 214.90 Worstead COUNCIL TAX BASE 122.89 89.41 51.45 85.62 367.33 108.21 139.50 76.02 260.09 90.60 107.57 29.38 103.00 130.60 329.26 245.34 95.93 203.65 338.66 73.42 1,013.35 26.00 313.30 54.88 104.36 117.91 86.93 98.18 294.66 117.54 being the amounts calculated by the Council, in accordance with Regulation 6 of The Local Authorities (Calculation of Council Tax Base) (England) Regulations 2012, as the amounts of its Council Tax base for the year for dwellings in those parts of its area to which special items (parish precepts) may relate. 4.6 That the following amounts be now CALCULATED by the Council for the year 2014/15 in accordance with Sections 31A to 36 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992 and the relevant regulations and directions as follows:a) £61,261,593 b) £54,519,599 being the aggregate of the amounts which the Council estimates for the expenditure items set out in Section 31A(2) (a) to (f) of the Act. being the aggregate of the amounts which the Council estimates for the income items set out in Section 31A(3) (a) to (d) of the Act. This includes the amount the Council estimates will be transferred in the year from its collection fund to its general fund in accordance with Section 97 (3) of the Local Government Finance Act 1988 (Council Tax surplus of £99,276) and Section 97 (2A) (NDR surplus of 18 c) £6,741,994 d) £183.3608 e) £1,635,884 f) £138.8700 £720). being the amount by which the aggregate at (a) above exceeds the aggregate at (b) above, calculated by the Council, in accordance with Section 31A(4) of the Act, to be its Council Tax requirement for the year. being the amount at (c) above divided by the amount at 4.5(a) above, calculated by the Council, in accordance with Section 31B(1) of the Act, as the basic amount of its Council Tax for the year. being the aggregate amount of all special items (parish precepts) referred to in Section 34(1) of the Act. being the amount at (d) above less the result given by dividing the amount at (e) above by the amount at 4.5 (a) above, calculated by the Council, in accordance with Section 34(2) of the Act, as the basic amount of its Council Tax for the year for dwellings in those parts of its area to which no special item (parish precept) relates. g) PART OF THE COUNCIL'S AREA Alby with Thwaite Aldborough Antingham Ashmanhaugh Aylmerton Baconsthorpe Bacton Barsham Barton Turf Beckham East/West Beeston Regis Binham Blakeney Bodham Brinton Briston Catfield Cley Colby Corpusty and Saxthorpe Cromer Dilham East Ruston Edgefield Erpingham Fakenham Felbrigg Felmingham Field Dalling Fulmodestone Gimingham BASIC AMOUNT £ 164.4372 162.6192 156.5438 193.1672 169.4494 157.8501 168.6479 156.6538 159.9714 162.3089 171.9793 166.0111 200.3001 180.2253 155.5463 175.9943 173.4556 166.2604 219.9174 183.8676 217.0592 169.5290 161.1454 175.4959 166.6391 197.3036 173.1372 147.3211 160.6235 169.3863 169.9615 19 PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA Little Barningham Little Snoring Ludham Matlaske Melton Constable Morston Mundesley Neatishead North Walsham Northrepps Overstrand Paston Plumstead Potter Heigham Pudding Norton Raynham Roughton Runton Ryburgh Salthouse Scottow Sculthorpe Sea Palling Sheringham Sidestrand Skeyton Sloley Smallburgh Southrepps Stalham Stibbard BASIC AMOUNT £ 159.2107 174.4941 155.4156 143.9694 191.5677 156.7983 184.6108 167.7540 184.3579 180.2427 183.9558 190.1660 171.9743 168.2170 194.1709 182.3890 161.7461 153.0027 175.6702 172.0875 189.0744 160.5566 193.1144 206.7074 168.7481 151.1891 165.9728 170.4065 173.8128 191.4104 177.5008 PART OF THE COUNCIL'S AREA BASIC AMOUNT £ 178.5788 170.0693 151.6932 159.2766 161.5231 170.1924 160.6265 177.6487 228.3293 148.0016 175.6520 170.7400 167.8824 192.1830 156.1337 161.1440 171.2853 195.3605 147.5484 198.7847 173.7740 172.6718 178.3819 166.2374 170.5500 153.2022 155.8854 Great Snoring Gresham Gunthorpe Hanworth Happisburgh Helhoughton Hempstead Hempton Hickling High Kelling Hindolveston Hindringham Holkham Holt Honing Horning Horsey Hoveton Ingham Ingworth Itteringham Kelling Kettlestone Knapton Langham Lessingham Letheringsett with Glandford PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA BASIC AMOUNT £ 176.9284 165.2540 168.0245 156.9732 161.6478 172.7947 169.4148 171.5193 149.5278 155.7574 172.5503 167.9962 188.1885 189.8935 162.7715 191.0955 170.1737 192.0206 206.9713 199.0170 186.7474 202.6455 172.4077 146.6301 188.9102 164.3334 166.2473 Stiffkey Stody Suffield Sustead Sutton Swafield Swanton Abbott Swanton Novers Tattersett Thornage Thorpe Market Thursford Trimingham Trunch Tunstead Upper Sheringham Walcott Walsingham Warham Wells-next-the-Sea Weybourne Wickmere Wighton Witton Wiveton Wood Norton Worstead being the amounts given by adding to the amount at 4.6(f) above to the amounts of the special item or items relating to dwellings in those parts of the Council‟s area mentioned above divided in each case by the amount at 4.6(b) above, calculated by the Council, in accordance with Section 34(3) of the Act, as the basic amounts of its Council Tax for the year for dwellings in those parts of its area to which one or more special items relate. h) PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA VALUATION BANDS A £ Alby with Thwaite Aldborough Antingham Ashmanhaugh Aylmerton Baconsthorpe Bacton Barsham 109.62 108.41 104.36 128.77 112.96 105.23 112.43 104.43 B £ 127.89 126.48 121.75 150.24 131.79 122.77 131.17 121.84 C £ 146.16 144.55 139.15 171.70 150.62 140.31 149.90 139.24 20 D £ 164.43 162.61 156.54 193.16 169.44 157.85 168.64 156.65 E £ 200.97 198.75 191.33 236.09 207.10 192.92 206.12 191.46 F £ 237.52 234.89 226.11 279.01 244.76 228.00 243.60 226.27 G £ 274.06 271.03 260.90 321.94 282.41 263.08 281.07 261.08 H £ 328.87 325.23 313.08 386.33 338.89 315.70 337.29 313.30 PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA VALUATION BANDS A £ Barton Turf Beckham East/West Beeston Regis Binham Blakeney Bodham Brinton Briston Catfield Cley Colby Corpusty and Saxthorpe Cromer Dilham East Ruston Edgefield Erpingham Fakenham Felbrigg Felmingham Field Dalling Fulmodestone Gimingham Great Snoring Gresham Gunthorpe Hanworth Happisburgh Helhoughton Hempstead Hempton Hickling High Kelling Hindolveston Hindringham Holkham Holt Honing Horning Horsey Hoveton Ingham Ingworth Itteringham Kelling B £ C £ D £ E £ F £ G £ H £ 106.64 108.20 114.65 110.67 133.53 120.15 103.69 117.32 115.63 110.84 146.61 124.42 126.24 133.76 129.11 155.78 140.17 120.98 136.88 134.90 129.31 171.04 142.19 144.27 152.87 147.56 178.04 160.20 138.26 156.43 154.18 147.78 195.48 159.97 162.30 171.97 166.01 200.30 180.22 155.54 175.99 173.45 166.26 219.91 195.52 198.37 210.19 202.90 244.81 220.27 190.11 215.10 212.00 203.20 268.78 231.06 234.44 248.41 239.79 289.32 260.32 224.67 254.21 250.54 240.15 317.65 266.61 270.51 286.63 276.68 333.83 300.37 259.24 293.32 289.09 277.10 366.52 319.94 324.61 343.95 332.02 400.60 360.45 311.09 351.98 346.91 332.52 439.83 122.57 144.70 113.01 107.43 116.99 111.09 131.53 115.42 98.21 107.08 112.92 113.30 119.05 113.37 101.12 106.18 107.68 113.46 107.08 118.43 152.21 98.66 117.10 113.82 111.92 128.12 104.08 107.42 114.19 130.24 98.36 132.52 115.84 115.11 143.00 168.82 131.85 125.33 136.49 129.60 153.45 134.66 114.58 124.92 131.74 132.19 138.89 132.27 117.98 123.88 125.62 132.37 124.93 138.17 177.58 115.11 136.61 132.79 130.57 149.47 121.43 125.33 133.22 151.94 114.75 154.61 135.15 134.30 163.43 192.94 150.69 143.24 155.99 148.12 175.38 153.89 130.95 142.77 150.56 151.07 158.73 151.17 134.83 141.57 143.57 151.28 142.77 157.90 202.95 131.55 156.13 151.76 149.22 170.82 138.78 143.23 152.25 173.65 131.15 176.69 154.46 153.48 183.86 217.05 169.52 161.14 175.49 166.63 197.30 173.13 147.32 160.62 169.38 169.96 178.57 170.06 151.69 159.27 161.52 170.19 160.62 177.64 228.32 148.00 175.65 170.74 167.88 192.18 156.13 161.14 171.28 195.36 147.54 198.78 173.77 172.67 224.72 265.29 207.20 196.95 214.49 203.67 241.14 211.61 180.05 196.31 207.02 207.73 218.26 207.86 185.40 194.67 197.41 208.01 196.32 217.12 279.06 180.89 214.68 208.68 205.18 234.89 190.83 196.95 209.34 238.77 180.33 242.95 212.39 211.04 265.58 313.52 244.87 232.76 253.49 240.70 284.99 250.08 212.79 232.01 244.66 245.49 257.94 245.65 219.11 230.06 233.31 245.83 232.01 256.60 329.80 213.78 253.71 246.62 242.49 277.59 225.52 232.76 247.41 282.18 213.12 287.13 251.00 249.41 306.44 361.76 282.54 268.57 292.49 277.73 328.83 288.56 245.53 267.70 282.31 283.26 297.63 283.44 252.82 265.46 269.20 283.65 267.71 296.08 380.54 246.66 292.75 284.56 279.80 320.30 260.22 268.57 285.47 325.60 245.91 331.30 289.62 287.78 367.73 434.11 339.05 322.29 350.99 333.27 394.60 346.27 294.64 321.24 338.77 339.92 357.15 340.13 303.38 318.55 323.04 340.38 321.25 355.29 456.65 296.00 351.30 341.48 335.76 384.36 312.26 322.28 342.57 390.72 295.09 397.56 347.54 345.34 21 PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA VALUATION BANDS A £ Kettlestone Knapton Langham Lessingham Letheringsett with Glandford Little Barningham Little Snoring Ludham Matlaske Melton Constable Morston Mundesley Neatishead North Walsham Northrepps Overstrand Paston Plumstead Potter Heigham Pudding Norton Raynham Roughton Runton Ryburgh Salthouse Scottow Sculthorpe Sea Palling Sheringham Sidestrand Skeyton Sloley Smallburgh Southrepps Stalham Stibbard Stiffkey Stody Suffield Sustead Sutton Swafield Swanton Abbott Swanton Novers Tattersett B £ C £ D £ E £ F £ G £ H £ 118.92 110.82 113.70 102.13 138.74 129.29 132.65 119.15 158.56 147.76 151.60 136.17 178.38 166.23 170.55 153.20 218.02 203.17 208.45 187.24 257.66 240.12 246.35 221.29 297.30 277.06 284.25 255.33 356.76 332.47 341.10 306.40 103.92 106.14 116.32 103.61 95.97 127.71 104.53 123.07 111.83 122.90 120.16 122.63 126.77 114.64 112.14 129.44 121.59 107.83 102.00 117.11 114.72 126.04 107.03 128.74 137.80 112.49 100.79 110.64 113.60 115.87 127.60 118.33 117.95 110.16 112.01 104.64 107.76 115.19 112.94 114.34 99.68 121.24 123.83 135.71 120.87 111.97 148.99 121.95 143.58 130.47 143.38 140.18 143.07 147.90 133.75 130.83 151.02 141.85 125.80 119.00 136.63 133.84 147.05 124.87 150.20 160.77 131.24 117.59 129.08 132.53 135.18 148.87 138.05 137.61 128.53 130.68 122.09 125.72 134.39 131.76 133.40 116.29 138.56 141.52 155.10 138.14 127.97 170.28 139.37 164.09 149.11 163.87 160.21 163.51 169.03 152.86 149.52 172.59 162.12 143.77 136.00 156.15 152.96 168.06 142.71 171.65 183.73 149.99 134.39 147.53 151.47 154.50 170.14 157.77 157.26 146.89 149.35 139.53 143.68 153.59 150.59 152.46 132.91 155.88 159.21 174.49 155.41 143.96 191.56 156.79 184.61 167.75 184.35 180.24 183.95 190.16 171.97 168.21 194.17 182.38 161.74 153.00 175.67 172.08 189.07 160.55 193.11 206.70 168.74 151.18 165.97 170.40 173.81 191.41 177.50 176.92 165.25 168.02 156.97 161.64 172.79 169.41 171.51 149.52 190.52 194.59 213.27 189.95 175.96 234.13 191.64 225.63 205.03 225.32 220.29 224.83 232.42 210.19 205.59 237.31 222.91 197.68 187.00 214.70 210.32 231.09 196.23 236.02 252.64 206.24 184.78 202.85 208.27 212.43 233.94 216.94 216.24 201.97 205.36 191.85 197.56 211.19 207.06 209.63 182.75 225.16 229.97 252.04 224.48 207.95 276.70 226.48 266.66 242.31 266.29 260.35 265.71 274.68 248.40 242.98 280.46 263.45 233.63 221.00 253.74 248.57 273.10 231.91 278.94 298.57 243.74 218.38 239.73 246.14 251.06 276.48 256.39 255.56 238.70 242.70 226.73 233.49 249.59 244.71 247.75 215.98 259.80 265.35 290.82 259.02 239.94 319.27 261.33 307.68 279.59 307.26 300.40 306.59 316.94 286.62 280.36 323.61 303.98 269.57 255.00 292.78 286.81 315.12 267.59 321.85 344.51 281.24 251.98 276.62 284.01 289.68 319.01 295.83 294.88 275.42 280.04 261.62 269.41 287.99 282.35 285.86 249.21 311.77 318.42 348.98 310.83 287.93 383.13 313.59 369.22 335.50 368.71 360.48 367.91 380.33 343.94 336.43 388.34 364.77 323.49 306.00 351.34 344.17 378.14 321.11 386.22 413.41 337.49 302.37 331.94 340.81 347.62 382.82 355.00 353.85 330.50 336.04 313.94 323.29 345.58 338.82 343.03 299.05 22 PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA VALUATION BANDS A £ Thornage Thorpe Market Thursford Trimingham Trunch Tunstead Upper Sheringham Walcott Walsingham Warham Wells-next-the-Sea Weybourne Wickmere Wighton Witton Wiveton Wood Norton Worstead 103.83 115.03 111.99 125.45 126.59 108.51 127.39 113.44 128.01 137.98 132.67 124.49 135.09 114.93 97.75 125.94 109.55 110.83 All Other Parts of the Council‟s Area B £ C £ 121.14 134.20 130.66 146.36 147.69 126.60 148.62 132.35 149.34 160.97 154.79 145.24 157.61 134.09 114.04 146.93 127.81 129.30 D £ 138.45 153.37 149.32 167.27 168.79 144.68 169.86 151.26 170.68 183.97 176.90 165.99 180.12 153.25 130.33 167.92 146.07 147.77 E £ 155.75 172.55 167.99 188.18 189.89 162.77 191.09 170.17 192.02 206.97 199.01 186.74 202.64 172.40 146.63 188.91 164.33 166.24 F £ 190.37 210.89 205.32 230.00 232.09 198.94 233.56 207.99 234.69 252.96 243.24 228.24 247.67 210.72 179.21 230.89 200.85 203.19 G £ 224.98 249.23 242.66 271.82 274.29 235.11 276.02 245.80 277.36 298.95 287.46 269.74 292.71 249.03 211.79 272.87 237.37 240.13 259.59 287.58 279.99 313.64 316.48 271.28 318.49 283.62 320.03 344.95 331.69 311.24 337.74 287.34 244.38 314.85 273.88 277.07 H £ 311.51 345.10 335.99 376.37 379.78 325.54 382.19 340.34 384.04 413.94 398.03 373.49 405.29 344.81 293.26 377.82 328.66 332.49 92.58 108.01 123.44 138.87 169.73 200.59 231.45 277.74 being the amounts given by multiplying (as appropriate) the amounts at 4.6(f) or 4.6(g) above by the number which, in the proportion set out in Section 5(1) of the Act, is applicable to dwellings listed in a particular valuation band divided by the number which in that proportion is applicable to dwellings listed in valuation Band D, calculated by the Council, in accordance with Section 36(1) of the Act, as the amounts to be taken into account for the year in respect of categories of dwellings listed in different valuation bands. 4.7 That it be NOTED that for the year 2014/15 the Norfolk County Council and the Norfolk Police & Crime Commissioner have stated the following amounts in precepts issued to the Council, in accordance with Section 40 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, for each of the categories of dwellings shown below:VALUATION BANDS Norfolk County Council Norfolk Police and Crime Commissioner A £ B £ C £ D £ E £ F £ G £ H £ 763.38 890.61 1,017.84 1,145.07 1,399.53 1,653.99 1,908.45 2,290.14 136.50 159.25 182.00 204.75 250.25 295.75 341.25 409.50 23 4.8 That, having calculated the aggregate in each case of the amounts at 4.6(h) and 4.7 above, the Council, in accordance with Section 30 and 36 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, HEREBY SETS the following amounts as the amounts of Council Tax for the year 2014/15 for each of the categories of dwellings shown below:- PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA Alby with Thwaite Aldborough Antingham Ashmanhaugh Aylmerton Baconsthorpe Bacton Barsham Barton Turf Beckham East/West Beeston Regis Binham Blakeney Bodham Brinton Briston Catfield Cley Colby Corpusty and Saxthorpe Cromer Dilham East Ruston Edgefield Erpingham Fakenham Felbrigg Felmingham Field Dalling Fulmodestone Gimingham Great Snoring Gresham Gunthorpe Hanworth Happisburgh Helhoughton Hempstead Hempton VALUATION BANDS A £ B £ C £ D £ E £ F £ G £ H £ 1,009.50 1,008.29 1,004.24 1,028.65 1,012.84 1,005.11 1,012.31 1,004.31 1,006.52 1,177.75 1,176.34 1,171.61 1,200.10 1,181.65 1,172.63 1,181.03 1,171.70 1,174.28 1,346.00 1,344.39 1,338.99 1,371.54 1,350.46 1,340.15 1,349.74 1,339.08 1,342.03 1,514.25 1,512.43 1,506.36 1,542.98 1,519.26 1,507.67 1,518.46 1,506.47 1,509.79 1,850.75 1,848.53 1,841.11 1,885.87 1,856.88 1,842.70 1,855.90 1,841.24 1,845.30 2,187.26 2,184.63 2,175.85 2,228.75 2,194.50 2,177.74 2,193.34 2,176.01 2,180.80 2,523.76 2,520.73 2,510.60 2,571.64 2,532.11 2,512.78 2,530.77 2,510.78 2,516.31 3,028.51 3,024.87 3,012.72 3,085.97 3,038.53 3,015.34 3,036.93 3,012.94 3,019.58 1,008.08 1,014.53 1,010.55 1,033.41 1,020.03 1,003.57 1,017.20 1,015.51 1,010.72 1,046.49 1,176.10 1,183.62 1,178.97 1,205.64 1,190.03 1,170.84 1,186.74 1,184.76 1,179.17 1,220.90 1,344.11 1,352.71 1,347.40 1,377.88 1,360.04 1,338.10 1,356.27 1,354.02 1,347.62 1,395.32 1,512.12 1,521.79 1,515.83 1,550.12 1,530.04 1,505.36 1,525.81 1,523.27 1,516.08 1,569.73 1,848.15 1,859.97 1,852.68 1,894.59 1,870.05 1,839.89 1,864.88 1,861.78 1,852.98 1,918.56 2,184.18 2,198.15 2,189.53 2,239.06 2,210.06 2,174.41 2,203.95 2,200.28 2,189.89 2,267.39 2,520.21 2,536.33 2,526.38 2,583.53 2,550.07 2,508.94 2,543.02 2,538.79 2,526.80 2,616.22 3,024.25 3,043.59 3,031.66 3,100.24 3,060.09 3,010.73 3,051.62 3,046.55 3,032.16 3,139.47 1,022.45 1,044.58 1,012.89 1,007.31 1,016.87 1,010.97 1,031.41 1,015.30 998.09 1,006.96 1,012.80 1,013.18 1,018.93 1,013.25 1,001.00 1,006.06 1,007.56 1,013.34 1,006.96 1,018.31 1,192.86 1,218.68 1,181.71 1,175.19 1,186.35 1,179.46 1,203.31 1,184.52 1,164.44 1,174.78 1,181.60 1,182.05 1,188.75 1,182.13 1,167.84 1,173.74 1,175.48 1,182.23 1,174.79 1,188.03 1,363.27 1,392.78 1,350.53 1,343.08 1,355.83 1,347.96 1,375.22 1,353.73 1,330.79 1,342.61 1,350.40 1,350.91 1,358.57 1,351.01 1,334.67 1,341.41 1,343.41 1,351.12 1,342.61 1,357.74 1,533.68 1,566.87 1,519.34 1,510.96 1,525.31 1,516.45 1,547.12 1,522.95 1,497.14 1,510.44 1,519.20 1,519.78 1,528.39 1,519.88 1,501.51 1,509.09 1,511.34 1,520.01 1,510.44 1,527.46 1,874.50 1,915.07 1,856.98 1,846.73 1,864.27 1,853.45 1,890.92 1,861.39 1,829.83 1,846.09 1,856.80 1,857.51 1,868.04 1,857.64 1,835.18 1,844.45 1,847.19 1,857.79 1,846.10 1,866.90 2,215.32 2,263.26 2,194.61 2,182.50 2,203.23 2,190.44 2,234.73 2,199.82 2,162.53 2,181.75 2,194.40 2,195.23 2,207.68 2,195.39 2,168.85 2,179.80 2,183.05 2,195.57 2,181.75 2,206.34 2,556.14 2,611.46 2,532.24 2,518.27 2,542.19 2,527.43 2,578.53 2,538.26 2,495.23 2,517.40 2,532.01 2,532.96 2,547.33 2,533.14 2,502.52 2,515.16 2,518.90 2,533.35 2,517.41 2,545.78 3,067.37 3,133.75 3,038.69 3,021.93 3,050.63 3,032.91 3,094.24 3,045.91 2,994.28 3,020.88 3,038.41 3,039.56 3,056.79 3,039.77 3,003.02 3,018.19 3,022.68 3,040.02 3,020.89 3,054.93 24 PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA Hickling High Kelling Hindolveston Hindringham Holkham Holt Honing Horning Horsey Hoveton Ingham Ingworth Itteringham Kelling Kettlestone Knapton Langham Lessingham Letheringsett with Glandford Little Barningham Little Snoring Ludham Matlaske Melton Constable Morston Mundesley Neatishead North Walsham Northrepps Overstrand Paston Plumstead Potter Heigham Pudding Norton Raynham Roughton Runton Ryburgh Salthouse Scottow Sculthorpe Sea Palling Sheringham Sidestrand VALUATION BANDS A £ B £ C £ D £ E £ F £ G £ H £ 1,052.09 998.54 1,016.98 1,013.70 1,011.80 1,028.00 1,003.96 1,007.30 1,014.07 1,030.12 998.24 1,032.40 1,015.72 1,014.99 1,018.80 1,010.70 1,013.58 1,002.01 1,227.44 1,164.97 1,186.47 1,182.65 1,180.43 1,199.33 1,171.29 1,175.19 1,183.08 1,201.80 1,164.61 1,204.47 1,185.01 1,184.16 1,188.60 1,179.15 1,182.51 1,169.01 1,402.79 1,331.39 1,355.97 1,351.60 1,349.06 1,370.66 1,338.62 1,343.07 1,352.09 1,373.49 1,330.99 1,376.53 1,354.30 1,353.32 1,358.40 1,347.60 1,351.44 1,336.01 1,578.14 1,497.82 1,525.47 1,520.56 1,517.70 1,542.00 1,505.95 1,510.96 1,521.10 1,545.18 1,497.36 1,548.60 1,523.59 1,522.49 1,528.20 1,516.05 1,520.37 1,503.02 1,928.84 1,830.67 1,864.46 1,858.46 1,854.96 1,884.67 1,840.61 1,846.73 1,859.12 1,888.55 1,830.11 1,892.73 1,862.17 1,860.82 1,867.80 1,852.95 1,858.23 1,837.02 2,279.54 2,163.52 2,203.45 2,196.36 2,192.23 2,227.33 2,175.26 2,182.50 2,197.15 2,231.92 2,162.86 2,236.87 2,200.74 2,199.15 2,207.40 2,189.86 2,196.09 2,171.03 2,630.24 2,496.36 2,542.45 2,534.26 2,529.50 2,570.00 2,509.92 2,518.27 2,535.17 2,575.30 2,495.61 2,581.00 2,539.32 2,537.48 2,547.00 2,526.76 2,533.95 2,505.03 3,156.29 2,995.64 3,050.94 3,041.12 3,035.40 3,084.00 3,011.90 3,021.92 3,042.21 3,090.36 2,994.73 3,097.20 3,047.18 3,044.98 3,056.40 3,032.11 3,040.74 3,006.04 1,003.80 1,006.02 1,016.20 1,003.49 995.85 1,027.59 1,004.41 1,022.95 1,011.71 1,022.78 1,020.04 1,022.51 1,026.65 1,014.52 1,012.02 1,029.32 1,021.47 1,007.71 1,001.88 1,016.99 1,014.60 1,025.92 1,006.91 1,028.62 1,037.68 1,012.37 1,171.10 1,173.69 1,185.57 1,170.73 1,161.83 1,198.85 1,171.81 1,193.44 1,180.33 1,193.24 1,190.04 1,192.93 1,197.76 1,183.61 1,180.69 1,200.88 1,191.71 1,175.66 1,168.86 1,186.49 1,183.70 1,196.91 1,174.73 1,200.06 1,210.63 1,181.10 1,338.40 1,341.36 1,354.94 1,337.98 1,327.81 1,370.12 1,339.21 1,363.93 1,348.95 1,363.71 1,360.05 1,363.35 1,368.87 1,352.70 1,349.36 1,372.43 1,361.96 1,343.61 1,335.84 1,355.99 1,352.80 1,367.90 1,342.55 1,371.49 1,383.57 1,349.83 1,505.70 1,509.03 1,524.31 1,505.23 1,493.78 1,541.38 1,506.61 1,534.43 1,517.57 1,534.17 1,530.06 1,533.77 1,539.98 1,521.79 1,518.03 1,543.99 1,532.20 1,511.56 1,502.82 1,525.49 1,521.90 1,538.89 1,510.37 1,542.93 1,556.52 1,518.56 1,840.30 1,844.37 1,863.05 1,839.73 1,825.74 1,883.91 1,841.42 1,875.41 1,854.81 1,875.10 1,870.07 1,874.61 1,882.20 1,859.97 1,855.37 1,887.09 1,872.69 1,847.46 1,836.78 1,864.48 1,860.10 1,880.87 1,846.01 1,885.80 1,902.42 1,856.02 2,174.90 2,179.71 2,201.78 2,174.22 2,157.69 2,226.44 2,176.22 2,216.40 2,192.05 2,216.03 2,210.09 2,215.45 2,224.42 2,198.14 2,192.72 2,230.20 2,213.19 2,183.37 2,170.74 2,203.48 2,198.31 2,222.84 2,181.65 2,228.68 2,248.31 2,193.48 2,509.50 2,515.05 2,540.52 2,508.72 2,489.64 2,568.97 2,511.03 2,557.38 2,529.29 2,556.96 2,550.10 2,556.29 2,566.64 2,536.32 2,530.06 2,573.31 2,553.68 2,519.27 2,504.70 2,542.48 2,536.51 2,564.82 2,517.29 2,571.55 2,594.21 2,530.94 3,011.41 3,018.06 3,048.62 3,010.47 2,987.57 3,082.77 3,013.23 3,068.86 3,035.14 3,068.35 3,060.12 3,067.55 3,079.97 3,043.58 3,036.07 3,087.98 3,064.41 3,023.13 3,005.64 3,050.98 3,043.81 3,077.78 3,020.75 3,085.86 3,113.05 3,037.13 25 PART OF THE COUNCIL’S AREA Skeyton Sloley Smallburgh Southrepps Stalham Stibbard Stiffkey Stody Suffield Sustead Sutton Swafield Swanton Abbott Swanton Novers Tattersett Thornage Thorpe Market Thursford Trimingham Trunch Tunstead Upper Sheringham Walcott Walsingham Warham Wells-next-theSea Weybourne Wickmere Wighton Witton Wiveton Wood Norton Worstead All Other Parts of the Council‟s Area VALUATION BANDS A £ B £ C £ D £ E £ F £ G £ H £ 1,000.67 1,010.52 1,013.48 1,015.75 1,027.48 1,018.21 1,017.83 1,010.04 1,011.89 1,004.52 1,007.64 1,015.07 1,012.82 1,014.22 999.56 1,003.71 1,014.91 1,011.87 1,025.33 1,026.47 1,008.39 1,167.45 1,178.94 1,182.39 1,185.04 1,198.73 1,187.91 1,187.47 1,178.39 1,180.54 1,171.95 1,175.58 1,184.25 1,181.62 1,183.26 1,166.15 1,171.00 1,184.06 1,180.52 1,196.22 1,197.55 1,176.46 1,334.23 1,347.37 1,351.31 1,354.34 1,369.98 1,357.61 1,357.10 1,346.73 1,349.19 1,339.37 1,343.52 1,353.43 1,350.43 1,352.30 1,332.75 1,338.29 1,353.21 1,349.16 1,367.11 1,368.63 1,344.52 1,501.00 1,515.79 1,520.22 1,523.63 1,541.23 1,527.32 1,526.74 1,515.07 1,517.84 1,506.79 1,511.46 1,522.61 1,519.23 1,521.33 1,499.34 1,505.57 1,522.37 1,517.81 1,538.00 1,539.71 1,512.59 1,834.56 1,852.63 1,858.05 1,862.21 1,883.72 1,866.72 1,866.02 1,851.75 1,855.14 1,841.63 1,847.34 1,860.97 1,856.84 1,859.41 1,832.53 1,840.15 1,860.67 1,855.10 1,879.78 1,881.87 1,848.72 2,168.12 2,189.47 2,195.88 2,200.80 2,226.22 2,206.13 2,205.30 2,188.44 2,192.44 2,176.47 2,183.23 2,199.33 2,194.45 2,197.49 2,165.72 2,174.72 2,198.97 2,192.40 2,221.56 2,224.03 2,184.85 2,501.68 2,526.32 2,533.71 2,539.38 2,568.71 2,545.53 2,544.58 2,525.12 2,529.74 2,511.32 2,519.11 2,537.69 2,532.05 2,535.56 2,498.91 2,509.29 2,537.28 2,529.69 2,563.34 2,566.18 2,520.98 3,002.01 3,031.58 3,040.45 3,047.26 3,082.46 3,054.64 3,053.49 3,030.14 3,035.68 3,013.58 3,022.93 3,045.22 3,038.46 3,042.67 2,998.69 3,011.15 3,044.74 3,035.63 3,076.01 3,079.42 3,025.18 1,027.27 1,013.32 1,027.89 1,037.86 1,198.48 1,182.21 1,199.20 1,210.83 1,369.70 1,351.10 1,370.52 1,383.81 1,540.91 1,519.99 1,541.84 1,556.79 1,883.34 1,857.77 1,884.47 1,902.74 2,225.76 2,195.54 2,227.10 2,248.69 2,568.19 2,533.32 2,569.73 2,594.65 3,081.83 3,039.98 3,083.68 3,113.58 1,032.55 1,024.37 1,034.97 1,014.81 997.63 1,025.82 1,009.43 1,010.71 1,204.65 1,195.10 1,207.47 1,183.95 1,163.90 1,196.79 1,177.67 1,179.16 1,376.74 1,365.83 1,379.96 1,353.09 1,330.17 1,367.76 1,345.91 1,347.61 1,548.83 1,536.56 1,552.46 1,522.22 1,496.45 1,538.73 1,514.15 1,516.06 1,893.02 1,878.02 1,897.45 1,860.50 1,828.99 1,880.67 1,850.63 1,852.97 2,237.20 2,219.48 2,242.45 2,198.77 2,161.53 2,222.61 2,187.11 2,189.87 2,581.39 2,560.94 2,587.44 2,537.04 2,494.08 2,564.55 2,523.58 2,526.77 3,097.67 3,073.13 3,104.93 3,044.45 2,992.90 3,077.46 3,028.30 3,032.13 992.46 1,157.87 1,323.28 1,488.69 1,819.51 2,150.33 2,481.15 2,977.38 4.9 Excessiveness Determination 4.9.1 The Council‟s basic amount of Council Tax as calculated in paragraph 4.6 (f) above is the same as that calculated for 2013/14, and therefore within the 2.0% increase limit at which a referendum would be required. 26 4.9.2 The Council has determined that its relevant basic amount of Council Tax for 2014/15 is not excessive in accordance with principles approved under Section 52ZB Local Government Finance Act 1992. As the billing authority, the Council has not been notified by a major precepting authority that its relevant basic amount of Council Tax for 2014/15 is excessive and that the billing authority is not required to hold a referendum in accordance with Section 52ZK Local Government Finance Act 1992. 5. Financial Implications and Risks 5.1 The Council is required to set the Council Tax each year in accordance with the legislation set out above in this report. If this is not done, there is a risk that the council will be unable to bill in a timely manner with a consequential loss of revenue, and this may prevent the prudent management of the Council‟s financial affairs. By maintaining the Council Tax at the same level as 2013/14, the Council will receive a Council Tax freeze grant of £57,969. This will not be payable if Members decide to set a higher level of Council Tax. The Council will be required to hold a referendum if it decides to increase its Council Tax by 2.0% or more. 5.2 The overall budget for 2014/15 is balanced and delivers a surplus of £551,613 which has been transferred to the General Reserve. Section 3 of the report presents the Chief Financial Officers statement on the robustness of the estimates and the adequacy of reserves. This statement is informed by a number of risks that are facing the authority, in particular those detailed at 3.10. It is recommended that the level of the General Reserve is maintained at £1.75 million. 6. Sustainability – None as a direct consequence of this report. 7. Equality and Diversity 7.1 The Council is legally required to consider the equality duty in its decision-making and this includes the budget process. As part of any savings or investments the Council must consider how it can: Eliminate unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation; Advance equality of opportunity between different groups; and Foster good relations between different groups by tackling prejudice and promoting understanding. 7.2 As part of the 2014/15 budget process savings proposals were put forward by Heads of Services for consideration. A cumulative assessment has been undertaken in relation to the equality forms and the savings proposals and no negative impact has been highlighted as a result of this exercise. 7.3 It is not considered that the budget presented for 2014/15 will have any significant impact on equality and diversity issues. 8. Section 17 Crime and Disorder considerations – None as a direct consequence of the report. 27 Appendix A General Fund Summary 2014/15 Base Budget Service Area Assets & Leisure Corporate Leadership Team/Corporate Customer Services Community & Economic Development Development Management Environmental Health Finance Organisational Development Management Structures 2013/14 Base 2014/15 Budget Base Budget £ £ 2,325,691 2,376,094 0 0 697,597 721,046 4,294,675 7,932,005 1,285,771 1,346,891 4,311,587 4,144,772 2,974,845 3,083,806 875,690 955,462 (23,000) 0 2015/16 Projection £ 1,926,975 0 662,301 3,004,797 1,235,031 3,893,652 3,121,116 1,050,222 0 2016/17 Projection £ 1,948,956 0 709,771 2,226,470 1,278,423 3,914,676 3,196,671 976,797 0 2017/18 Projection £ 1,967,562 0 710,654 2,208,375 1,290,717 3,902,775 3,197,021 978,882 0 Net Cost of Services 16,742,856 20,560,076 14,894,094 14,251,764 14,255,986 Parish Precepts (Estimate from 14/15 onwards) Capital Charges Reffcus Interest Receivable Revenue Financing for Capital IAS 19 Pension Adjustment 1,429,824 (2,292,529) (2,511,401) (392,490) 400,000 266,577 1,635,884 (2,135,334) (5,564,241) (363,710) 420,950 265,787 1,635,884 (2,222,775) (684,578) (372,290) 225,000 265,787 1,635,884 (2,036,594) 0 (392,410) 225,000 265,787 1,635,884 (1,969,715) 0 (384,150) 225,000 265,787 Net Operating Expenditure 13,642,837 14,819,412 13,741,122 13,949,431 14,028,792 (9,449) 169,735 (21,180) 30,000 0 (142,000) 0 628,496 (68,358) (43,304) (31,500) (15,000) 0 (10,000) 489,095 (200,000) 39,658 (332,585) 0 30,000 (60,000) 0 (5,005) 197,651 (19,020) (72,839) (115,000) 0 (50,000) 0 0 (591,011) 0 0 0 (60,000) 0 0 0 285,422 (18,126) (4,000) (38,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 30,000 0 0 0 351,550 (18,126) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 30,000 0 0 0 329,792 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 551,613 0 0 0 14,419,372 14,392,874 13,906,418 14,312,855 14,388,584 (1,429,824) (5,082,610) (2,817,506) (4,337,274) (1,635,884) (5,205,386) (2,873,112) (3,331,376) (1,635,884) (5,152,784) (2,951,673) (2,294,088) (1,635,884) (5,173,719) 0 (1,599,741) (5,194,655) 0 (22,740) 0 0 (729,418) 0 0 (57,969) 0 (1,277,202) (11,945) 0 (57,969) (58,177) (1,516,721) 0 (4,418,741) 0 0 0 (1,757,721) 0 (3,800,117) 0 0 0 (1,648,959) 0 (14,419,372) (14,392,874) (13,667,296) (12,986,065) (12,243,472) 0 0 239,122 1,326,790 2,145,112 Contributions to/(from) Earmarked Reserves: Capital Projects Reserve Big Society Fund Carbon Management Elections Enforcement Board Housing Legal New Homes Bonus Reserve Pathfinder Planning Revenue Restructuring/Invest to save The Pier Unspent Grants Whistleblowing Contribution to General Reserve (Reallocation) Use of General Reserve Transfer of Surplus to General Reserve Amount to be met from Government Grant and Local Taxpayers Collection Fund – Parishes Collection Fund – District Retained Business Rates Baseline Revenue Support Grant (RSG) Forecast Funding (RSG & Business Rates Baseline) LCTS Transitional funding Council Tax Freeze (2014/15) Council Tax Freeze (2015/16) New Homes bonus Section 31 grant Rural Services Delivery 2014/15 Top-up Income from Government Grant and Taxpayers (Surplus)/Deficit 28 Appendix B Policy Framework for the Earmarked Reserves and Assessing the Optimum Level of the General Reserve for the period 2014/15 to 2017/18 1 Background 1.1 In accordance with statute (principally the Local Government Finance Act 2002) and following the Guidance Note on Local Authority Reserves and Balances (LAAP Bulletin No. 77 – November 2008), North Norfolk District Council maintains a range of reserves. 1.2 Two types of reserves are discussed in this policy framework: Earmarked Reserves The General Reserve 1.3 There are also a number of other reserves which local authorities hold in relation to legislation and proper accounting practices, these are not resource-backed reserves and therefore are not considered as part of this policy framework. 1.4 In making decisions in relation to setting the Council Tax, section 25 of the Local Government Act 2003 requires the Chief Financial Officer of the Council to report to the Council on the adequacy of the proposed financial reserves. 1.5 This Policy framework has been informed by both the LAAP Bulletin No. 77 and the Audit Commissions report published in December 2012 ‘Striking a Balance’ Improving Councils’ Decision Making on Reserves’. 2 Earmarked Reserves 2.1 Purpose 2.1.1 Earmarked reserves are a means of building up funds to meet known or predicted liabilities. 2.1.2 Typically earmarked reserves are used to set aside sums for major schemes, such as capital developments or asset purchases, or to fund reorganisations and restructurings. Reserves can also be held for trading and business units built up from surpluses to cover potential losses in future years, or to finance capital expenditure. In certain circumstances, if expenditure is delayed on specific budgets, it may be agreed that the underspending at a year end is carried forward for future use in an earmarked reserve. 2.2 Earmarked Reserves Protocol 2.2.1 For each reserve the following arrangements have been established: the reasons for / purpose of the reserve how and when the reserve can be used procedures for the reserve’s management and control a process and timetable for review of the reserve to ensure continuing relevance and adequacy. 2.2.2 In North Norfolk, the establishment and use of earmarked reserves is reviewed at the time of budget setting and then controlled through the year as part of the regular budget monitoring processes. 2.3 Review of Earmarked Reserves 2.3.1 The Reserves Statement in Appendix C gives full details of the earmarked reserves. Each earmarked reserve has been assessed by the Chief Financial Officer whose Reserves Policy Framework, February 2014 29 Appendix B judgement is that they are properly established in accordance with the protocol and that their level and proposed use is appropriate. 2.3.2 It is considered that sufficient provision for the Council’s capital programme (as recommended) has been included in the capital estimates and capital reserves, and that nothing further is required. 2.3.3 Where in-year expenditure is being funded by earmarked reserves, the relevant transfers from the reserves have been allowed for within the reserves statements at Appendix C. 3 The General Reserve 3.1 Purpose 3.1.1 The general reserve is held for two main purposes: a working balance to help cushion the impact of uneven cashflows and avoid temporary borrowing; a contingency to help cushion the impact of unexpected events or emergencies. 3.2 The Optimum Level of the General Reserve 3.2.1 There are two recommended approaches for deciding the optimum level of the general reserve: A risk assessment of the budget which takes full account of the context within which the budget has been prepared. The budget report itself provides this contextual information. To set the reserve at a percentage of expenditure. Too low a level puts the council at unacceptable risk of failing to meet its obligations, too high a level unnecessarily ties up resources. 3.2.2 This appendix sets out the framework for considering a risk assessment approach and validating the result against a percentage calculation. At the end of the day, the level of reserves is a matter of opinion informed by the judgement of the Council’s Chief Financial Officer. 3.3 Assessment Framework 3.3.1 The issues to be considered include the following: The Council continues to operate on an ongoing basis. The robustness of the budget process including recognition of the linkages with the corporate plan, the strategic risk register and the financial plan update. The adequacy of the earmarked reserves and the movements on the general reserves both in the past and planned. The extent to which savings and planned service reductions are required and can be relied upon to support corporate plan targets. The risk of major litigation and legal claims, both currently and in the future. The impact of future Government funding reductions. Implications of changes to Local Council Tax Support Schemes and increase in the demand for support. Fluctuations in retained business rate income and funding from the government for the extensions to reliefs for example retail relief and small business rates. Reserves Policy Framework, February 2014 30 Appendix B Fluctuations around certain income streams and grants, for example demand led services such as planning, building control income, land charges and car parking and fluctuations in investment income. Unplanned volume increases in major demand led budgets, particularly in the context of the current economic climate for example housing benefits, council tax support and homelessness. The need to retain a general contingency to provide for any unforeseen circumstances that may arise including inadequately funded Government initiatives. The Government’s Bellwin scheme does provide financial assistance to local authorities in the event of an emergency. However, assistance is only available above a threshold and is normally limited to 85% (unless extensions allowed to the scheme as has been seen in 2013/14) of eligible costs and relates to events that are exceptional resulting in damage to local authority infrastructure or local communities. In the short term all costs have to be met pending Government reimbursement. The implications of the Local Government Finance Act 2012 in relation to the implementation of the new business rates retention system and the localisation of Council Tax support. The move in local authorities to do less by direct service provision (either through the Localism Agenda or through third parties, including outsourcing) is increasing the risks borne by authorities. There is a risk that these arrangements fail and there are many circumstances when a statutory liability remains with the local authority. Such risks may not be insurable at an economic level and demand rigorous risk minimisation strategies and this is an area that will be considered in more detail if the Council pursues these arrangements in future years. The need to retain reserves for general day to day cash flow requirements. 3.3.2 All these issues interlink and any one incident is likely to span across many of the issues. Risks change over time and the general reserve needs to be considered across the medium term financial plan. What might be an adequate level of reserves now could be inadequate in years two to four. 3.4 The Assessment of the General Fund Reserve 3.4.1 When undertaking the assessment it must be remembered that the items considered are merely guides to assessing the overall level of the reserve. In no way is it a budget for any of the items being created since by its nature a general reserve is designed to protect against the unexpected and unquantifiable for whatever reason. 3.4.2 Having considered the relevant risks and the mitigation measures already in place, it is felt that the following indicative items should be taken into account in the budget risk assessment for 2014/15: Item 2014/15 1 Pay and Price Inflation (0.5% above budget assumption) 2 Interest Rates (0.25% below budget prediction on non-fixed investments) 3 Failure to Achieve Planned Savings and Cost Pressures from Corporate Plan Targets (to ensure core services are maintained) Reserves Policy Framework, February 2014 31 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 44,000 44,000 44,000 44,000 43,000 43,000 43,000 43,000 44,200 64,600 65,800 66,300 Appendix B Item 2014/15 4 Major Litigation and Legal Claims (to provide additional comfort above earmarked reserves) 5 Emergencies and Other Unknowns (to recognise the risks associated with unpredictable events) 6 Treatment of Demand Led Pressures (recognising the impact of increase or reduction in demand and compensating increase or reduction in expenditure or income) 7 Cash Flow (it is felt that in relation to the new statutory obligations in paying set amounts to the major preceptors and central government as part of the new funding arrangements, an amount needs to be included for the impact on the short term cash flow needs) 8 Future Funding Fluctuations (due to the changes in the future funding regime an allowance should be made within the general reserve to mitigate the impact within and between financial years) Total Indicated General Fund Reserve Recommended % of Net Budgeted Operating Expenditure (excluding parish precepts) Budgeted General Fund Reserve (at yearend, after taking account of planned use) % of Net Budgeted Operating Expenditure (excluding parish precepts) 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 150,000 150,000 150,000 150,000 600,000 600,000 600,000 600,000 180,000 180,000 180,000 180,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 620,300 620,600 620,300 620,300 1,731,500 1,751,900 1,753,100 1,753,600 13% 14% 14% 14% 723,879 723,879 723,879 723,879 5% 6% 6% 6% 4 Chief Financial Officer’s Opinion 4.1 The Earmarked Reserves detailed in Appendix C are proper and appropriate with regard to purpose, level and proposed use. 4.2 Based on the assessment detailed above it is recommended that the level of the general reserve should remain at £1.75 million. It is acknowledged that the balance of the general reserve at the end of 2014/15 is forecast to be below the minimum level. This is due to the budget assuming that the costs of the tidal surge will be funded by the Council at least in the short term. Should the Council be successful in securing external funding for the damage, then the impact will be reduced. In considering the budget put forward for approval the balance on the General Reserve is not considered in isolation but is considered along with the level of earmarked reserves, and the robustness of the estimates presented for approval. Whilst earmarked in nature unless amounts are budgeted to be taken from the reserves, commitments have not yet been made from these reserves. 4.3 Actions to re-instate the general reserve to the recommended balance will need to be considered early on in the next financial planning process and initially as part of the 2013/14 outturn reporting process. Reserves Policy Framework, February 2014 32 Appendix C Reserves Statement 2013/14 onwards Reserve General Fund General Reserve Purpose and Use of Reserve A working balance and contingency, current recommended balance is £1.75 million. Balance at 31/3/2013 Updated Budget Movement £ £ Estimated Balance at 1/4/2014 £ Budgeted Contributions to Reserves 2014/15 Budgeted Contributions From Reserves 2014/15 £ £ Total Budgeted 2014/15 Movement £ Balance at 1/4/2015 Budgeted 2015/16 Movement Balance at 1/4/2016 Budgeted Movement 2016/17 Balance at 1/4/2017 Budgeted Movement 2017/18 Balance at 1/4/2018 £ £ £ £ £ £ £ 1,745,452 (982,175) 763,277 551,613 (591,011) (39,398) 723,879 0 723,879 0 723,879 0 723,879 Earmarked Reserves: Capital Projects To provide funding for capital developments and purchase of major assets. This includes the VAT Shelter Receipt. 2,063,225 (583,382) 1,479,843 235,608 (195,950) 39,658 1,519,501 0 1,519,501 0 1,519,501 0 1,519,501 Asset Management To support improvements to our existing assets as identified through the Asset Management Plan. 64,718 (53,049) 11,669 0 0 0 11,669 0 11,669 0 11,669 0 11,669 Benefits To be used to mitigate any claw back by the Department of Works and Pensions following final subsidy determination. Timing of the use will depend on audited subsidy claims. 671,792 0 671,792 0 0 0 671,792 0 671,792 0 671,792 0 671,792 Big Society Fund The Budget and forecast projections assume the return of the second homes funding from County continues to be received and is utilised on the related grants and communtiy expenditure. 542,065 173,927 715,992 0 (332,585) (332,585) 383,407 0 383,407 0 383,407 0 383,407 Carbon Management To fund revenue invest to save initiatives and projects within the Carbon Management Plan. 21,180 (21,180) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Coast Protection To support the ongoing coast protection maintenance programme ands carryforward funding between financial years. 60,000 (60,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Common Training To deliver the corporate training programme. Training and development programmes are sometimes not completed in the year but are committed and therefore funding is carried forward in an earmarked reserve. 36,270 (8,820) 27,450 0 0 0 27,450 0 27,450 Economic Development and Tourism Earmarked from previous underspends within Economic Development and Tourism Budgets along with funding earmarked for Learning for Everyone. 32,248 (25,000) 7,248 0 0 0 7,248 Election Reserve Established to meet costs associated with district council elections, to smooth the impact between financial years. 30,000 30,000 60,000 30,000 0 30,000 90,000 Enforcement Board Established to meet costs associated with district council enforcement works as per report to cabinet on the 2nd December 2013. 0 158,222 158,222 0 (60,000) (60,000) 98,222 Environmental Health Earmarking of previous underspends and additional income to meet Environmental Health initiatives. 33,200 (20,000) 13,200 0 0 0 13,200 13,200 13,200 13,200 Unspent Grants Revenue Grants received and due to timiing issues not used in the year. 47,963 2,037 50,000 0 (50,000) (50,000) 0 0 0 0 Housing Previously earmarked for stock condition survey and housing needs assessment. 242,000 (142,000) 100,000 0 0 0 100,000 0 100,000 0 100,000 0 100,000 Land Charges To mitigate the impact of potential income reductions. 50,356 0 50,356 0 0 0 50,356 0 50,356 0 50,356 0 50,356 33 27,450 27,450 7,248 0 7,248 0 7,248 (60,000) 30,000 30,000 60,000 30,000 90,000 0 98,222 0 98,222 0 98,222 Appendix C Reserves Statement 2013/14 onwards Balance at 31/3/2013 Updated Budget Movement Estimated Balance at 1/4/2014 £ Reserve Purpose and Use of Reserve Legal One off funding for Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO) work and East Law Surplus. 47,555 (42,550) 5,005 Local Strategic Partnership Earmarked underspends on the LSP for outstanding commitments and liabilities. 82,677 (30,949) 51,728 LSVT Reserve To meet the cost of successful warranty claims not covered by bonds and insurance following the housing stock transfer. 435,000 0 New Homes Bonus Established for supporting communities with future growth and development.* 611,678 Organisational Development To provide funding for organisation development to create capacity within the organisation and address anomalies within the pay structure. Partnership Budgets This reflects the balance of funding on the Revenues and Benefits Partnership project. This will be utilised in 2013/14. Pathfinder To help Coastal Communities adapt to coastal changes. £ £ Budgeted Contributions to Reserves 2014/15 Budgeted Contributions From Reserves 2014/15 £ £ Total Budgeted 2014/15 Movement £ Balance at 1/4/2015 Budgeted 2015/16 Movement £ £ Balance at 1/4/2016 £ Budgeted Movement 2016/17 Balance at 1/4/2017 £ £ Budgeted Movement 2017/18 Balance at 1/4/2018 £ £ (5,005) (5,005) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 51,728 0 51,728 0 51,728 0 51,728 435,000 0 0 0 435,000 0 435,000 0 435,000 0 435,000 675,207 1,286,885 255,440 (57,789) 197,651 1,484,536 285,422 1,769,958 351,550 2,121,508 329,792 2,451,300 69,997 (69,997) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 35,000 (35,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 265,825 (128,358) 137,467 0 (19,020) (19,020) 118,447 (18,126) 100,321 (18,126) 82,195 (44,108) 38,087 134,954 35,596 170,550 0 (72,839) (72,839) 97,711 (4,000) 93,711 0 93,711 0 93,711 37,837 0 37,837 0 0 0 37,837 0 37,837 0 37,837 0 37,837 Previously unspent Housing and Planning Delivery Grant Planning - Revenue (HPDG) for use on related revenue projects, timing to be confirmed. Regeneration Projects Carry forward of underspends relating to Regeneration Projects. Restructuring & Invest to Save Proposals To fund one-off redundancy and pension strain costs and invest to save initiatives. Transfers from this reserve will be allocated against business cases as they are approved. Timing of the use of this resrve will depend on when business cases are approved. 694,074 217,118 911,192 0 (115,000) (115,000) 796,192 (38,000) 758,192 0 758,192 0 758,192 Sports Hall To support renewals for sports hall equipment. Amount Equipment & Sports transferred in the year represents over or under achievement of income target. Facilities 24,820 (7,070) 17,750 0 0 0 17,750 0 17,750 0 17,750 0 17,750 The pier 15,000 (15,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Treasury (Property) Property Investment (Treasury), to smooth the impact on the revenue account of interest fluctuations. Reserve 66,068 0 66,068 0 0 0 66,068 66,068 0 66,068 0 66,068 Whistle blowing 10,000 (10,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8,170,954 (942,423) 7,228,531 1,072,661 (1,499,199) (426,538) 6,801,993 165,296 6,967,289 363,424 7,330,713 315,684 7,646,397 Total Reserves To be used to support the costs of works to Cromer pier. Commissioning investigation activity as required. 34 Agenda Item No____12________ Pay Policy Statement 2014/15 Summary: Section 38 of the Localism Act 2011 (“the Act”) requires the Council to produce an annual pay policy statement (“the statement”) for the start of each financial year. The attached statement is drawn up in compliance with the Act to cover the period 2014/15. It is a legal requirement that Full Council formally signs off this statement and the responsibility cannot be devolved to any other person or committee. Conclusions: The attached statement sets out current remuneration arrangements including the Travel Policy for staff. Recommendations: 1) To adopt the attached Pay Policy Statement and to publish the statement for 2014/15 on the Council‟s website. 2) To adopt the revised Travel Policy shown at Appendix D. Cabinet Member(s) Ward(s) affected Councillor Tom FitzPatrick All Contact Officer, telephone number and email: 1. Introduction 1.1 Section 38 (1) of the Localism Act 2011 (“the Act”) requires English and Welsh local authorities to produce a pay policy statement (“the statement”) for each financial year. The first statement went to Full Council on 22 February 2012 to cover the period 2012/13. 2. The Statement 2.1 The statement must set out: A local authority‟s policy on the level and elements of remuneration for each chief officer A local authority‟s policy on the remuneration of its lowest-paid employees (together with its definition of “lowest-paid employees” and its reasons for adopting that definition) A local authority‟s policy on the relationship between the remuneration of its chief officers and other officers A local authority‟s policy on other specific aspects of chief officers‟ remuneration: remuneration on recruitment, increases and additions to 35 remuneration, use of performance related pay and bonuses, termination payments, and transparency. 2.2 With regard to the process for approving the statement, it must: 2.3 Be approved formally by Full Council and cannot be delegated to any sub committee. This includes any amendments in each financial year Be approved by the end of March each year Be published on the authority‟s website and in any other manner that the Council thinks appropriate as soon as it is reasonably practicable after it is approved or amended Be complied with when the authority sets the terms and conditions for a Chief Officer For the purpose of the statement the term „Chief Officer‟ in a local authority context is defined as set out in the Local Government and Housing Act 1989 as: The Head of Paid Service (Chief Executive) The Monitoring Officer A statutory Chief Officer and non statutory Chief Officer (section 2 of that Act) A deputy Chief Officer (section 2 of that Act) 2.4 This definition of Chief Officer is wider than that contained within the Constitution where the term „chief officer‟ indicates the senior posts which sit on Corporate LeadershipTeam i.e. the Chief Executive and Directors. 3 Travel Policy 3.1 The Travel policy is appended to the Pay Policy Statement and has been reviewed to remove historical references to „transitional arrangements‟ which are no longer applicable and to amend the mileage range for staff travel in line with the HMRC mileage range. The mileage rates payable to staff have not been amended. (See Appendix D). 4 Conclusion 4.1 The statement meets the statutory requirements of the Localism Act and it is therefore recommended that the statement be approved. 5 Financial Implications and Risks 5.1 There are no increased risks or resource implications as a result of setting and publishing this statement. The report and the statement outline current arrangements. This statement builds on the publication of senior officer salary information which is already available on the website at http://www.northnorfolk.org/council/8105.asp 6 Equality and Diversity 6.1 The Equality act 2010 places requirements upon all public sector bodies to ensure that its policies and procedures promote equality, this document supports that requirement. 36 Appendix D PAY POLICY STATEMENT 2014/15 Context This policy statement has been produced in accordance with Sections 38 to 43 of the Localism Act 2011 (“the Act”), which, from 2012 onwards, requires all local authorities to publish an annual statement of their policy for the relevant financial year in relation to: The remuneration of their most senior employees (which the Act defines as the Head of Paid Service (Chief Executive), the Monitoring Officer, the Chief Officers (or Directors), and the Deputy Chief Officers (i.e. managers who report directly to a Chief Officer)); The remuneration of their lowest-paid employees; and The relationship between the remuneration of their most senior employees and that of other employees. The Secretary of State has produced guidance on the provisions in the Act relating to transparency and accountability in local pay, which local authorities must have regard to in preparing and approving their annual pay policy statements. This Pay Policy Statement takes full account of this guidance as well as the provisions of the Act. Additionally it takes account of: The Code of Recommended Practice for Local Authorities on Data Transparency, issued by the Department for Communities and Local Government in September 2011 Guidance issued by the Joint National Council (JNC) for Local Authority Chief Executives on pay policy statements which was published in November 2011 Employment and equalities legislation which impacts on local authority employers The policy statement also refers to information which the Council already publishes under other legislation: Information on the level of remuneration paid to senior managers, as required by The Accounts and Audit (Amendment No. 2) (England) Regulations 2009 Policies on the exercise of its discretions over payments upon termination of employment under the Local Government Pension Scheme, as required by Regulation 66 of the Local Government Pension Scheme (Administration) Regulations 2008 Policies on the exercise of its discretions over payments upon termination of employment under the Local Government (Early Termination of Employment) (Discretionary Compensation) (England and Wales) Regulations 2006, as required by Regulation 7 of those regulations. 37 Appendix D This Pay Policy Statement must be reviewed on an annual basis and a new version of the policy will be submitted to Full Council for approval by 31 March immediately preceding the financial year to which it relates. The pay policy statement can also be amended during the course of the financial year, but only by a resolution of the Full Council. If it is amended during the year to which it relates, the revised version of the statement must be published as soon as possible after the amendment is approved by Full Council. This policy statement was considered by Full Council on 26 February 2014. It is available on the Council‟s website. The Council‟s website also includes separately published data on salary information relating to Senior Officers and this can be viewed at http://www.northnorfolk.org/council/8105.asp For the purpose of the pay policy statement the term „Chief Officer‟ in a local authority context is defined as set out in the Local Government and Housing Act 1989: a) b) c) d) The Head of Paid Service (i.e. the Chief Executive) as designated under section 4 of that Act; The Monitoring Officer designated under section 5(1) of that Act; A statutory Chief Officer and non statutory Chief Officer under section 2 of that Act; A deputy Chief Officer mentioned in section 2 of that Act. Remunerating Chief Officers/Deputy Chief Officers The remuneration for Chief Officers/Deputy Chief Officers within the Council can be found at Appendix A – C. The Monitoring Officer service is contracted through Norfolk County Council and as such, the Council does not directly remunerate the Monitoring Officer. Remunerating the Lowest Paid in the Workforce The Council applies terms and conditions of employment that have been negotiated and agreed through appropriate collective bargaining mechanisms (national or local) or as a consequence of Council decisions, these are then incorporated into contracts of employment. The lowest pay point in use by the Council for employees is spinal column point (SCP) 5. This relates to an annual salary of £12,435 (full time equivalent (FTE) and can be expressed as an hourly rate of pay of £6.4454 as at 31 March 2014. Employees on this pay point are defined as our lowest paid employees. This pay point and salary were determined by the National Joint Council (NJC) on 1 April 2013. The Relationship between Chief Officer Remuneration and that of other employees The highest paid salary in the Council is that of the Chief Executive at £99,771 as at 31 March 2014. The median for Chief Officers is £52,806 and for non-Chief Officers is £19,317. This gives a ratio of 1:2.733. The Council does not have a policy on maintaining, reaching or applying a specific pay multiple. However the Council is conscious that remuneration at all levels needs to be adequate to secure and retain high-quality employees but not be seen as excessive. 38 Appendix D Other Aspects of Chief Officer Remuneration Other aspects of Chief Officer remuneration are appropriate to be covered by this policy statement, these other aspects are defined as remuneration on recruitment, pay increases, additions to pay, performance related pay, earn back, enhancements of pension entitlements and termination payments. These elements are shown in Appendix A and B. Review The Localism Act 2011 requires relevant authorities to prepare a Pay Policy Statement for each subsequent financial year. The next statement will be submitted to Full Council for approval by 31 March 2015. As necessary, the Council may by resolution amend the pay policy statement at times other than that of the prescribed annual statement. 39 Appendix D Post Salary grade Chief Executive 1 Expenses / car allowances Travel and other expenses are reimbursed through normal Council procedures. Bonuses / PRP / Earn Back The current terms and conditions of employment does not provide for any of the above elements Honoraria / Acting Up Honoraria and acting up payments for any increased duties and responsibilities do not apply Market/Salary Supplements A salary/market supplement has not been applied to this post Car allowances are paid in accordance with the rates set out in Council‟s Travel Policy (see Appendix D) Election Fees As the Returning Officer (RO), the Chief Executive will receive a fee, locally in respect of County, District and Parish Elections. The fee for undertaking this role in Norfolk is determined by an independent panel made up of the Chairs of Norfolk Local Authority Member Remuneration Panels. Fees for conducting Parliamentary and European Parliamentary Elections, National Referendums and other Elections such as for the Police and Crime Commissioner. etc. are determined by Government. The RO is a separate appointment and therefore not factored into the salary range shown.The fees will be published on the Council‟s website (once agreed). As above (where applicable) Severance Arrangements The Council‟s normal policies regarding redundancy and early/flexible retirement apply to the postholder Corporate Directors x 2 Head of Finance/s151 Officer 2 As above As above As above As above As above 4 As above As above £4464 pa (s151 responsibilities) As above (where applicable) As above Head of Planning 4 As above As above Could be applied where appropriate on authorisation of Corporate Leadership Team As above As above (where applicable) As above Head of Service x 6 4 As above As above As above £ 4464 pa (specialist delegated responsibilities) Could be applied where appropriate on authorisation of Corporate Leadership Team As above (where applicable) As above Appendix A 40 Appendix D Appendix B Aspect of Chief Officer Remuneration Recruitment Council Policy The post will be advertised and appointed to at the appropriate approved salary for the post in question and individuals will be placed on the appropriate SCP within the pay grade for the post that they are appointed to. Employees will receive an annual increment (and in some cases, 6 months after starting work with the Council), subject to the top of their grade not being exceeded. Where the Council is unable to recruit to a post at its designated grade, it will consider the use of temporary market supplements. Access to appropriate elements of the Council‟s relocation Scheme may also be granted in certain circumstances, when new starters move to the area. Pay Increases Additions to Pay Professional Subscriptions Employee Assistance Programme (EAP) (includes access to advice and counselling) Contract for Services Redundancy and payments on termination The above applies to all employees. The Council will apply any pay increases that are agreed by the relevant national negotiating bodies. The Council will also apply any pay increases that are as a result of Council decisions to significantly increase the duties and responsibilities of the post in question beyond the normal flexing of duties and responsibilities that are expected in senior posts. This applies to all employees. The Council would not make additional payments beyond those specified in the terms and conditions of employment. This applies to all employees. These are payable where they are required for the post and should be limited to one subscription per Officer. This applies to all employees. Access to the EAP scheme is available to all employees and Elected Members. Where the Council remains unable to appoint chief officers on recruitment, or there is a need to provide interim support to cover for a vacant substantive chief officer post, the Council will, where necessary, consider engaging individuals under „contracts for service‟. These will be sourced through a relevant procurement process ensuring the Council is able to demonstrate value for money from competition in securing the relevant service. The Council has a single policy which applies to all employees. Where termination of employment is subject to a compromise agreement that agreement may include a negotiated payment in exchange for which the employee undertakes not to pursue claims against the Council. This is always subject to the completion of a business case and appropriate authorisation as laid out in the above policy. 41 Appendix D Appendix C Salary grades for Chief Officers and Deputy Chief Officers (2014) Grade 1 SCP Annual Amount 300 301 97,680.00 99,771.00 Grade 2 SCP Annual Amount 310 311 312 313 314 66,516.00 68,190.00 73,311.00 75,192.00 77,307.00 Grade 3 SCP Annual Amount 320 321 322 323 324 54,054.00 55,719.00 57,270.00 62,868.00 64,284.00 Grade 4 SCP 330 331 332 333 334 Annual Salary 45,177 46,404 47,613 48,831 52,806 42 Appendix D Appendix D TRAVEL POLICY INTRODUCTION The purpose of this policy is to set out North Norfolk District Council‟s policy on travel arrangements that employees are eligible to claim in reimbursement for journeys made in carrying out their duties. GENERAL TRAVEL PRINCIPLES Employees will be required to ensure that:- the use of public transport is prioritised above a car where the journey time is comparable to that of a car - the choice of travel mode should always be the most cost effective to the Authority, taking into account both claim costs and staff time - they ensure that journeys are planned to do the least number of miles possible, through good route planning and car sharing - a full record of their journey is kept including the reason for travelling and the names of official passengers carried - they do not use their own vehicle on journeys where there is room in the car of another officer making the same journey on the same business. In this situation, an essential car user should drive in preference to a casual user, if possible - they have included and maintain in their policy of insurance a clause indemnifying the Authority against all third party claims (including those concerning passengers) arising out of the use of the vehicle on official business - all claims exclude home to work mileage (and vice versa) if the journey starts or ends from the officers home i.e. they should only claim for excess business mileage over and above their normal daily commute mileage - all claims must be made using the appropriate claim form (these can be obtained from the intranet or HR) - VAT receipts are obtained and attached to the travel claim form to enable the Authority to reclaim VAT - they are familiar with and comply with the Driver Policy and Handbook CAR ALLOWANCES North Norfolk District Council recognises that employees will be required to use their own motor vehicle for the efficient performance of their duties and that it is appropriate to reimburse for additional authorised expenditure. All employees are designated as casual users unless their post attracts an essential car user allowance or they are currently in receipt of either a lease car or cash equivalent payment. 43 Appendix D ESSENTIAL USER ALLOWANCES Essential users are those whose duties are of such a nature that it is essential for them to have a motor car at their disposal whenever required. If the employee uses a private car in carrying out those official duties then they shall be entitled to receive the lump sum allowance and mileage rates set out in this policy. To determine eligibility to an essential car user allowance, the Essential Car User Assessment Form (obtained from HR) must be completed by either the line manager (for vacant posts) or the postholder. The assessment form will be scored by HR and eligibility will be confirmed or declined based on that assessment. If the postholder is not satisfied with the outcome, they can request an assessment by a Corporate Director in consultation with UNISON. A record of the request and scoring will be kept on the post file and where appropriate, the personnel file. The essential car user allowance will be paid to all employees whose eligibility is confirmed and they will receive a lump sum in accordance with their terms and conditions of employment along with the approved mileage rate for claimed business miles undertaken. Eligibility for essential car user status will be checked annually via completion of the car allowance scheme assessment form and if the post does not meet the criteria for this allowance, it will be removed immediately and the employee will be re-designated as a casual user. The employee will be entitled to appeal this decision and eligibility will be rechecked and the decision confirmed by a Corporate Director in consultation with UNISON. CASUAL USER ALLOWANCES Casual users are those for whom it is desirable that a car should be made available when required and as such are eligible to receive the appropriate mileage rate set out in this policy. ALLOWANCES AND MILEAGE RATES See Appendix A – please note these rates are reviewed and where appropriate, updated and published annually. CAR LOAN SCHEME Employees may apply to the Authority for a loan to purchase a vehicle if it is deemed necessary by a Corporate Director for them to use a vehicle for work purposes. Details of the scheme can be obtained from the Payroll Officer. 44 Appendix D OTHER MILEAGE RATES Lease car scheme Training1 Motorcycle Cycle Car sharing- - 15.47 pence per mile 15.47 pence per mile 24 pence per mile 20 pence per mile 5 pence per mile (not per person(s) carried) MILEAGE CLAIMS All claims must be submitted on the appropriate claim form and passed to Payroll for payment within 3 months of undertaking the journey/expenditure. All claim forms are to be authorised by the appropriate authorised line manager according to the „authorised signatories list‟. See Appendix B for details of what can be included in a mileage claim. Failure to submit a claim within 3 months of undertaking the journey would mean that, except under exceptional circumstances, the claim would not be met. OTHER ALLOWANCES SUBSISTENCE2 Subsistence will be paid to employees who necessarily incur additional expense in the course of their work. Reimbursement will be on the actual cost incurred up to the maximum amount shown below. This is subject to producing a receipt which shows the actual cost of the meal. Maximums are:Breakfast Lunch Tea Evening meal - £6.88 (Where work/travel commences before 7.30 am) £9.50 (When away for entire lunch period 12.00 – 14.00) £3.76 £11.77 (When work/absence extends beyond 7.30 pm) OVERNIGHT ALLOWANCES Overnight £3.63 Max per week £14.55 Any exceptions to the above (subsistence and overnight allowances) would need to be agreed in advance with a Corporate Director. LINK TO OTHER RELEVANT POLICIES 1. Driver Policy and Handbook – employees are required to comply with the requirements of this policy. 2. Environmental Policy – found within the Environmental Sustainability Strategy and Implementation Plan. 3. Green travel Plan. MONITORING This policy will be reviewed, updated and published on an annual basis by the Head of Organisational Development in line with the national agreement or as required by the Authority. 1 2 There is a specific claim form for qualification based training – speak to HR for details Rates are updated annually and are correct with effect from April 2010 45 Appendix D APPENDIX A TRAVEL RATES3 Casual User Rate Mileage:Per mile first 10,000 Per mile after 10,000 52.2p 14.4p Essential User (based on NJC rates for 1000-1199cc band) Lump sum £963 per annum (paid pro-rata on a monthly basis) Mileage:Per mile first 10,000 Per mile after 10,000 3 40.9p 14.4p Rates are updated annually and are correct with effect from April 2010 46 Appendix D APPENDIX B MILEAGE CLAIMS Mileage claims can be made as follows:1. Journeys from home to first visit: a) If the mileage is less than that from home to work base then no claim is made b) If the mileage is more than that from home to work base then excess mileage can be claimed 2. Journeys from last visit to home: a) If the mileage is less than work base to home then no claim is made b) If the mileage is more than that from work base to home then the excess mileage can be claimed 3. Extra journeys out of hours: When work is undertaken that results in additional journeys out of normal hours then the extra mileage may be claimed 47