REDWOODS COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT Minutes of the Meeting of the Curriculum Committee Eureka: 7351 Tompkins Hill Road, SSA 202 (New Board Room); Mendocino: 1211 Del Mar Drive, Room 201; Del Norte: 883 W. Washington Boulevard, Room D5; Members Present: December 13, 2013 Jeff Cummings (Ex‐Officio), Jay Dragten (Ex‐Officio), Marla Gleave, Toby Green, Michelle Haggerty, Sean Herrera‐Thomas, Erik Kramer, Ken Letko, George Potamianos, Harry Pyke, Franz Rulofson, Gary Sokolow. 1. Call to Order: Curriculum Committee Chair, George Potamianos, called the meeting to order at 12:01 p.m. 2. Introductions and Public Comment: 2.1 Curriculum Committee Chair George Potamianos thanked all the committee members for reviewing outlines on the MyCR Forum ahead of time. He also announced that a part of parliamentary procedure that if outlines have not addressed revisions requested on the MyCR discussion forum, the committee members should consider tabling that item. 3. Approval of the Minutes: Franz Rulofson moved to approve the minutes of the November 8, 2013 meeting, seconded by Gary Sokolow. There being no objections, the minutes were approved as written. 4. Action Items 4.1 BIOL‐16 Intro to Birds of the North Coast – Karen Reiss Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y ‐ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 5 of 7 – Current Course Transferability CB05: correct to “B ‐ Transferable to CSU only”. 4.2 BIOL‐26 Intro to Marine Plankton – Karen Reiss Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y ‐ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 4 of 7 – Representative Learning Activities #3: revise to “Discussing course concepts in class.” 2. Page 4 of 7 – Representative Learning Activities #6: revise to “Applying lecture materials to problem‐solving in homework exercises outside‐of‐class”. 3. Page 5 of 7 – Current Course Transferability CB05: correct to “B ‐ Transferable to CSU only”. 4.3 BIOL‐27 Biology of Marine Mammals – Karen Reiss Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y ‐ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 1 of 7 – Old/New Table: check boxes next to grading standard and maximum class size to indicate there has been a change. Erik Kramer [M], Gary Sokolow [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y ‐ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.4 Inactivation: ADCT‐40 Independent Study – Marcy Foster 4.5 Inactivation: PE‐40 Independent Study – Bob Brown 4.10 Inactivation: MATH‐380 Distance Education modality only – Mike Butler 4.31 Inactivation: PSYCH‐40 Independent Study – Michelle Haggerty 4.32 Inactivation: AG‐42 Agriculture Leadership – Franz Rulofson Franz Rulofson [M], Erik Kramer [2nd] to bundle Action Items 4.4, 4.5, 4.10, 4.31 and 4.32. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.6 KINS‐65 Foundations of Kinesiology – Bob Brown Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Discussion: 1. Bob Brown explained that there has been a change on the state‐level to reestablish the science component of physical education by having kinesiology as a discipline. Activity courses will continue to be categorized as Physical Education. 4.7 PE‐32 Cross‐Fit Circuit Training – Marla Gleave Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 5 of 8 – Course Types CCCCO approved degree: check yes and the restricted elective for degree boxes. Add “AJ.AS” as the program code. 2. Page 5 of 8 – Stand Alone: correct to “no”. 3. Page 5 of 8 – Current Course Transferability: correct to “B Transfers to CSU only”. 4.8 PE‐22 Soccer ‐ Marla Gleave Erik Kramer [M], Franz Rulofson [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.9 PE‐27 Power Weight Lifting ‐ Maggie White Franz Rulofson [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 2 of 7 – Total Units and Lab Units: correct to “0.5 – 1.0”. 2. Page 2 of 7 – Total Hours and Lab Hours: correct to “27‐54”. Page 2 of 12 4.11 MATH‐376 Pre‐Algebra ‐ Kevin Yokoyama Franz Rulofson [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 2 of 8 – CIP code: correct to 27.0101. 2. Page 3 of 8 – Prerequisite: remove “or appropriate score on math placement exam”. This is redundant; it will always be the case that students can place into a course based on placement test scores. 3. Page 5 of 8 – Required Assessment for all sections: remove #2. This is a department activity and does not need to be listed on the outline. Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.12 MATH‐380 Elementary Algebra ‐ Kevin Yokoyama Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 3 of 8 – Prerequisite: remove “or appropriate score on math placement exam”. This is redundant. 2. Page 5 of 8 – Required Assessment for all sections: remove #4. This is a department activity and does not need to be listed on the outline. Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.13 PHYSC‐10 Intro to Physical Science ‐ David Bazard, Mike Grady & Tony Sartori Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.14 Distance Education: BUS‐10 Intro to Business ‐ Chris Gaines & Michael Dennis Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, Gary Sokolow [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd] the motion to table was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: Page 3 of 12 1. Mark Winter’s feedback on this course was that it did not meet the standards for regular effective contact. The committee felt it was best to table this item until the proposal could be revised to meet the standard. 4.15 ECON‐1 Macroeconomics ‐ Michael Dennis Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.16 ECON‐10 Microeconomics ‐ Michael Dennis Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. There is some overlap between the microeconomics and macroeconomics courses. 4.17 New Degree: [AS‐T] Associate in Science in Business Administration for Transfer ‐ Michael Dennis Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, Erik Kramer [M], Marla Gleave [2nd] the motion to table this item was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Michael Dennis asked for this item to be tabled. He will be meeting with Jay Dragten to make sure the degree does not go over a total of 60 units. 2. Courses need to at least be submitted to C‐ID before the transfer degree is developed. 4.18 PHIL‐2 Intro to Political Philosophy ‐ John Johnston Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Discussion: Page 4 of 12 1. This course will be cross‐listed with POLSC‐2. Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Erik Kramer [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y N Y Y N Y Y N N Discussion: 1. This course is proposed for being approved for CR GE Humanities but POLSC‐2 is being proposed as CR GE Social Sciences. Ryan Emenaker said that many other community colleges have this same course and it is in both general education categories. 2. Franz Rulofson questioned if this course was broad enough to meet the criteria for breadth and generality. John Johnston said that this course is an introductory course to a branch of Philosophy. 3. Jay Dragten said that he would find out if it’s okay to have a course listed in two general education categories. He has the question out to an articulation officer in the CSU system. He suggested tabling this proposal. 4. Marla Gleave said that since we are not sure what the CSU system will do that the committee should move forward and let the CSU decide what category this course fits. 5. Jeff Cummings also suggested moving forward and proposing this course for both categories. If it’s rejected then CR will have to figure out what it more closely matches. 6. Erik Kramer said that the point of having different categories in general education is to have students branching out from their majors. He is okay with this course being approved for only one GE status. This course can be forwarded to CSU without this having CR GE approval. Erik Kramer asked that the committee members keep that in mind as they vote whether to approve this course for GE status. Michelle Haggerty called for a vote. The motion to end discussion and vote on the item was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.19 POLSC‐2 Intro to Political Philosophy ‐ Ryan Emenaker Michelle Haggerty [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Discussion: 1. This course will be cross‐listed with PHIL‐2 Marla Gleave [M], Franz Rulofson [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Y Green Y Haggerty Y Herrera‐Thomas
Y
Kramer
N
Letko
Y
Pyke
N
Rulofson N Sokolow
N
Discussion: Page 5 of 12 1. Erik Kramer said he doesn’t believe this course is broad enough to be approved in two different GE categories. Since PHIL‐2 was approved to fulfill the Humanities requirement, this course cannot be broad enough to also fulfill the Social Sciences GE criteria. 2. This is the same course as PHIL‐2 and will be cross listed. For the integrity of the curriculum, it’s the same course that will be held at the same time in the same classroom with the same instructor. 3. Sean Herrera‐Thomas expressed his support and applauds the authors for bringing this course to the committee. He feels with the strength of the content and excellent faculty, this course would be a win for students. He understands Erik Kramer’s concerns but feels this is an opportunity for innovation. He feels we should move forward and see what the blowback will be because we want to support this kind of curriculum innovation. 4. Erik Kramer clarified he is not against approving this course or this course having GE status. However, he is against this course having two GE statuses. The committee has to draw the line as to what is a GE course and what is not. Michelle Haggerty called for a vote. The motion to end discussion and vote on the item was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y N Y Y 4.20 New Degree: [AA‐T] Associate in Arts in Political Science for Transfer ‐ Ryan Emenaker This item was pulled by the author. 4.21 ECE‐1 Principles and Practices of Teaching Young Children ‐ Sydney Fisher Larson Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y AB Y Y Y Y Y Y Discussion: 1. This course is a part of the state‐wide alignment of Early Childhood Education because of that there is not much leeway to change or reduce learning outcomes. 4.22 ECE‐5 The Child in the Family and in the Community ‐ Sydney Fisher Larson Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y With the following revisions: 1. Page 4 of 7 – Assessment tasks: Move the tasks from the Required Assessments for All Sections to be listed under “Representative Assessment Tasks”. 4.23 ECE‐7 Intro to Early Childhood Curriculum ‐ Sydney Fisher Larson Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.24 ECE‐10 Field Experience in Childhood Education ‐ Sydney Fisher Larson Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Page 6 of 12 Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.25 CT‐21A Survey of Wood Technology ‐ Paul Kinsey Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.26 CT‐78A Residential Wiring I ‐ Paul Kinsey Franz Rulofson [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.27 CT‐78B Residential Wiring II ‐ Paul Kinsey Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Franz Rulofson [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.28 Non‐substantial change: [AT] Certificate of Achievement, Adv. Automotive Tech ‐ Michael Richards Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Discussion: 1. This is a non‐substantial change to the degree to remove the math requirement and the IT‐25 course. 4.29 CIS‐1 Computer Information Systems ‐ Chris Romero Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Sean Herrera‐Thomas [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, Erik Kramer [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]the motion to table the CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ With the following revisions: 1. Chris Romero wanted to propose this course for GE again for three reasons. First there are new members and they wanted those members to hear their argument and what the authors were trying to do. Secondly, because there are new members maybe they might have new idea how to address this conflict. Lastly to document that this course does in fact meet the GE standards but Page 7 of 12 2.
3.
4.
5.
there is not a category to place this course. If the committee does approve this course, maybe it would be the impetus for the GE structure being changed. There are other schools that have this type of course approved as general education. They are able to do this by having a separate math requirement. Chris Romero did clarify that the intent of this course is not to circumvent the math requirement. Erik Kramer said that when this course was proposed for GE two years ago, the committee agreed that the GE structure should be modified. Chris Romero asked that it be documented that the committee found value in this course being offered as a GE course. Jeff Cummings said the Curriculum Committee can write a recommendation to the Academic Senate and they can give that to their Ad‐Hoc GE committee. 4.30 ART‐43A Intro to Digital Art ‐ Cynthia Hooper Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.33 AG‐44A Agriculture Leadership I ‐ Franz Rulofson Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ With the following revisions: 1. This course equates to AG‐42. 4.34 AG‐44B Agriculture Leadership II ‐ Franz Rulofson Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.35 Non‐substantial change: [AG] Associate of Science, Agriculture, General ‐ Franz Rulofson Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Discussion: 1. Non‐substantial change to replace AG‐42 with AG‐44A and to add AG‐44B as an additional course. Electives have been reduced from 11 to 10. 4.36 Distance Education: HIST‐4 Western Civilization to 1600 ‐ Toby Green Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y AB Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Page 8 of 12 4.37 Distance Education: HIST‐5 Western Civilization: 1600 – Present ‐ Toby Green Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y AB Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.38 Distance Education: HIST‐8 US History through Reconstruction ‐ Toby Green Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y AB Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.39 Distance Education: HIST‐9 US History from Reconstruction to the Present ‐ Toby Green Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y AB Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.40 Distance Education: HIST‐12 Women in American History Since 1877 ‐ Toby Green Franz Rulofson [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y AB Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.41 New Degree: [AA‐T] Associate in Arts in History for Transfer ‐ George Potamianos Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y ‐ Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.42 PHYS‐4A Calculus‐Based Physics: Mechanics ‐ Erik Kramer Franz Rulofson [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y AB Y AB Y Y Y ‐ Discussion: 1. This update is to align the course with the C‐ID curriculum. 2. In the course title, the “B” in based needs to be capitalized. Franz Rulofson [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y N ‐ Discussion: 1. Calculus‐based physics is not a calculus course. This is an introductory course into calculus‐based physics. This course covers the mechanics of physics which is the basis for all physics. 4.43 PHYS‐4B Calculus‐Based Physics: Electricity and Magnetism Erik Kramer Page 9 of 12 Michelle Haggerty [M], Franz Rulofson [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Ab Y Y ‐ ‐ Michelle Haggerty [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ ‐ 4.44 PHYS‐4C Calculus‐Based Physics: Heat, Optics, Waves, and Modern Physics Erik Kramer Michelle Haggerty [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ ‐ Michelle Haggerty [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ ‐ 4.45 BIOL‐7 Human Physiology ‐ Karen Reiss Michelle Haggerty [M], Erik Kramer [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Discussion: 1. Jay Dragten said that any course with labs to be articulated with C‐ID or transfer to the UC system will need to note on the proposal there is a lab manual. With the following revisions: 1. Page 2 of 8 – New/Old Table: amend the new prerequisite to “ENGL‐150 and BIOL‐1 and BIOL‐6 and CHEM‐2”. 2. Page 5 of 8 ‐ Examples of Appropriate Texts: add “Instructor‐generated lab manual”. Franz Rulofson [M], Gary Sokolow [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as prerequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 4.46 HE‐7 Emergency Response: First Aid/CPR/AED ‐ Nate Kees Michelle Haggerty [M], Franz Rulofson [2nd]. Following discussion, Erik Kramer [M], Harry Pyke [2nd] the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ With the following revisions: 1. This course aligns to the C‐ID curriculum. 2. Erik Kramer pointed out that while the outline matches the number of outcomes as C‐ID, they are not the same outcomes. Some of the C‐ID outcomes were combined and new outcomes were added. 3. Marla Gleave explained that the outcomes were to justify the total units increasing from 2 units to 3 units. 4. Erik Kramer said that we should table this proposal and have it corrected before passing it through. This is an accreditation issue since we are still on sanction. Page 10 of 12 4.47 LVN‐111 Pharmacology Skills ‐ Jessica Howard Michelle Haggerty [M], Franz Rulofson [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ With the following revisions: 1. Page 1 of 7 – Old/New Table – Corequisites: under new correct to “LVN‐110A and LVN‐121”. Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as corequisite was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.48 ART‐11 Three‐Dimensional Design ‐ Shannon Sullivan Michelle Haggerty [M], Franz Rulofson [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ With the following revisions: 1. Page 6 of 8 – Currently Approved General Education: Mark “CR” and added “C” as the CRGE category. 2. Page 7 of 8 – Proposed CSU GE: check the box for rationale is same as above. Franz Rulofson [M], Michelle Haggerty [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 4.49 Instructional Material Fee forms: ART‐31A, ART‐31B, ART‐32, ART‐60/60L ‐ Shannon Sullivan Michelle Haggerty [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ Discussion: 1. This is to approve a change in the instructional material fees. 4.50 ART‐4 Art Appreciation ‐ Garth Johnson Michelle Haggerty [M], Sean Herrera‐Thomas [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ With the following revisions: 1. This is a correction to the Learning Outcomes. This course was previously approved with the outcomes for ART‐2. Erik Kramer [M], Marla Gleave [2nd]. Following discussion, the motion to approve this course as CR General Education was passed by the following roll call vote: Gleave Green Haggerty Herrera‐Thomas
Kramer
Letko
Pyke
Rulofson Sokolow
Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ‐ 5. Announcements and Open Forum 5.1 Articulation Update Page 11 of 12 This report was postponed until the January meeting. 5.2 Course Proposal Form Update Erik Kramer suggested modifying the course proposal form to include a section called course objectives. This would help in aligning our courses with C‐ID. Several proposals have been rejected by C‐ID for not include some of their course objectives in the Course Learning Outcome section of the proposal form. Outcomes are measureable while objectives are course goals. Marla Gleave suggested adding a spot on the form that allows faculty to write the C‐ID number. These changes to the form will be included as an action item on the Jan. 24th agenda. 6. Adjournment: On motion by Marla Gleave, seconded by Sean Herrera‐Thomas, the meeting was adjourned at 4:49 p.m. Next Meeting: January 24, 2014 Page 12 of 12