Materials Sector: Stock Analysis Presented by: Rashid Mammadov Sei Zhang 11/2/2013 PRESENTATION AGENDA ROAD MAP • • • • • • • Brief Sector Overview Mosaic Company Valspar Corporation Alcoa Inc Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold, Inc Recommendations Class Discussion And Voting 11/2/2013 2 OVERVIEW SECTOR INFORMATION S&P 500 Sector Allocation Materials 3.5% Utilities Telecom. 2.5% 3.1% Sector Materials Market Cap 55,640.00 (MLN. USD) # of Companies 31 Median Market Cap Information Tech 17.8% Consumer Staples 10.2% Energy 10.5% Sector Materials Financials 16.1% Industrials 10.8% Consumer Disc. 12.5% 11/2/2013 12,015.22 (MLN. USD) SP 500 SIM Diff. 3.51% 2.91% -0.61% Target Sector Weight 2.91% ~ Mosaic Company 2.91% Health Care 13.0% 3 OVERVIEW STOCKS CONSIDERED AND RECOMMENDATION Company Name Symbol Cost Basis Mosaic MOS $53.45 $47.05 -12% $52.00 Valspar VAL ~ $71.01 ~ Alcoa AA ~ $9.54 FCX ~ $35.4 Freeport 11/2/2013 Current Gain, Target Upside Price % Price % SIM % Action 10.5% 2.91% Sell (2.91%) $68.60 -3.4% ~ No Action ~ $9.11 -4.5% ~ No Action ~ $40.43 22.9% ~ Buy (2.91%) 4 MOSAIC COMPANY - HOLD COMPANY OVERVIEW Incorporated: March - 2004 Headquarter: Plymouth, MN Main Business: Phosphates & Potash Revenues: $ 9,974 MLN Net Income: $ 1,889 MLN Exports: 40 Countries 11/2/2013 Net Sales Potash 35% Phospha te 65% 5 MOSAIC COMPANY - HOLD COMPANY OVERVIEW Mosaic stock price has dropped in mid-2013 and is slowly reverting back 70 70,000,000 65 60,000,000 Market Data Current Price: $47.01 Market Cap: 20.49 B Avg. Volume: 5,170 M Diluted shares: 426.9 MM Dividends: $1.00 Dividend Yield: 2.10% Institutional Owners: 58% 60 50,000,000 55 50 40,000,000 45 30,000,000 40 35 20,000,000 30 10,000,000 25 20 0 Volume 11/2/2013 Close 6 MOSAIC COMPANY - HOLD COMPANY OVERVIEW MOSAIC IS A LARGE GLOBAL PLAYER WITH EXPORTS TO OVER 40 COUNTRIES Operating Earnings Net Sales by Country United States 2% 2% 2% 2% 39% 8% Canpotex (b) Canada 5% Phosphat e 38% Brazil India 7% Others Potash 62% Argentina Japan 12% Australia 21% China 11/2/2013 7 MOSAIC COMPANY - HOLD Business Analysis Medium term business drivers remain modest Key Short/Medium Term: Weather patterns and field conditions US Import/Export of Crops Grain Prices Inventory in agricultural chemicals Exchange rates (India) Key Long Term Drivers: Positive demographic growth Need for bio-fuel energy Government Subsidies and Policies Long term technological trends Supply and Demand mismatch Price Performance 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 Nov-12 11/2/2013 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 May-13 Jun-13 Jul-13 Aug-13 Sep-13 Oct-13 8 MOSAIC COMPANY Industry Position Company Competitive Advantages in the Market: Access to resources Sales Team Distribution Channels Strong Presence in Overseas Markets Vertical Integration 11/2/2013 9 MOSAIC COMPANY Financial Analysis Direct Competitor Comparison MOS POT URALL CF Market Cap: 20.44B 27.86B 14.83B 12.46B Employees: 8,400 5,870 21,000 2,500.00 Qtrly Rev Growth (yoy): -0.24 -0.31 -0.278 -0.19 9.97B 6.86B 3.33B 5.63B 0.28 0.43 N/A 0.46 2.92B 3.11B 1.82B 2.83B 0.23 0.36 0.4174 0.43 1.89B 1.98B 1.16B 1.61B EPS (ttm): 4.42 2.25 1.98 26.47 P/E (ttm): 10.83 14.36 13.38 8.22 PEG (5 yr expected): N/A 5.46 N/A 1.93 P/S (ttm): 2.06 4.13 4.45 2.24 EV/EBITDA 6.22 9.69 9.71 4.73 Revenue (ttm): Gross Margin (ttm): EBITDA (ttm): Operating Margin (ttm): Net Income (ttm): 11/2/2013 10 MOSAIC COMPANY Multiple Analysis Absolute Valuation P/Forward E High Low Median Current 25.60 3.40 14.00 12.00 P/S 12.9 1.3 2.3 P/B 10.4 0.7 48.74 74.6 P/EBITDA P/CF #Your Target Multiple *Target E, S per Share Target Price 14.00 3.58 $50 1.3 2.3 22.02 $51 2.3 1.5 2.2 31.29 $69 4.09 9.54 8.75 9.5 5.4 51.30 5.8 13.1 9.3 13.1 5.1 66.81 Relative to S&P 500 Relative to the Industry Target Price $51 per share Median Current Median Current P/Forward E P/S P/B P/EBITDA P/CF 11/2/2013 1.2 1.8 1.0 1.44 1.4 0.94 1.4 0.6 1.13 0.8 0.96 0.8 0.6 0.95 0.9 0.74 0.7 0.5 0.86 0.7 11 MOSAIC COMPANY - DCF Analysis Year 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E 2019E 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E 2024E Revenue % Growth 9,573 10,340 11,374 12,284 13,021 13,763 14,533 15,333 16,099 16,824 17,455 8.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 5.7% 5.6% 5.5% 5.0% 4.5% 3.75% Operating Income Operating Margin 1,886 19.7% 2,366 22.9% 2,366 20.8% 2,555 20.8% 2,708 20.8% 2,863 20.8% 3,023 20.8% 3,189 20.8% 3,349 20.8% 3,500 20.8% 3,631 20.8% Interest and Other (9) (9) (9) (10) (10) (11) (11) (12) (12) (13) (14) -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% -0.1% Taxes Tax Rate 451 23.8% 528 22.2% 591 24.9% 641 25.0% 680 25.0% 718 25.0% 759 25.0% 800 25.0% 840 25.0% 878 25.0% 911 25.0% Net Income % Growth 1,423 1,580 11.0% 1,768 11.9% 1,923 8.8% 2,039 6.0% 2,155 5.7% 2,276 5.6% 2,401 5.5% 2,521 5.0% 2,634 4.5% 2,733 3.8% Depreciation/Amort % of Sales Changes WC 574 6.0% 565 620 6.0% (100) 682 6.0% (134) 737 6.0% (184) 768 5.9% (195) 798 5.8% (206) 828 5.7% (218) 859 5.6% (230) 885 5.5% (241) 908 5.4% (252) 925 5.3% (262) % of Sales Subtract Cap Ex Capex % of sales 5.9% 1,245 13.0% -1.0% 1,344 13.0% -1.2% 1,479 12.0% -1.5% 1,228 10.0% -1.5% 1,302 10.0% -1.5% 1,307 9.5% -1.5% 1,381 9.5% -1.5% 1,227 8.0% -1.5% 1,127 7.0% -1.5% 1,009 6.0% -1.5% 925 5.3% Free Cash Flow 1,318 757 838 1,248 1,310 1,439 1,506 1,803 2,038 2,281 10.7% 48.9% 19.8% 13.0% 11.9% Interest % of Sales % Growth 2.6% 5.0% 9.9% 4.6% 2,471 12 8.3% MOSAIC COMPANY DCF ANALYSIS (Continued) NPV of Cash Flows NPV of terminal value Projected Equity Value Free Cash Flow Yield 8,311 12,456 20,767 6.42% Current Price Implied equity value/share Upside/(Downside) to DCF Debt Cash Cash/share Debt free cash/ share 11/2/2013 40% 60% 100% $47.03 $ 48.65 3.51 % 1,011 3,697 8.66 $ 6.29 Terminal Discount Rate = 11.0% Terminal FCF Growth = 3.75% 13 MOSAIC COMPANY DCF Valuation Sensitivity to Growth / Discount Rate 1.75% 2.25% 2.75% 3.25% 3.75% 4.25% 4.75% 5.25% 5.75% 9% $55.94 $58.66 $61.82 $65.53 $69.94 $75.29 $81.89 $90.25 $101.2 9.50% $51.72 $53.99 $56.61 $59.64 $63.20 $67.44 $72.56 $78.90 $86.92 10% $48.03 $49.95 $52.13 $54.64 $57.55 $60.97 $65.04 $69.96 $76.04 10.50% $44.78 $46.41 $48.26 $50.35 $52.76 $55.55 $58.83 $62.74 $67.46 11% $41.90 $43.29 $44.86 $46.63 $48.65 $50.96 $53.64 $56.79 $60.54 11.50% $39.32 $40.53 $41.87 $43.37 $45.07 $47.01 $49.23 $51.80 $54.83 12% $37.01 $38.06 $39.21 $40.50 $41.95 $43.58 $45.44 $47.57 $50.05 12.50% $34.93 $35.84 $36.84 $37.95 $39.19 $40.58 $42.15 $43.93 $45.98 13% $33.04 $33.83 $34.71 $35.67 $36.74 $37.93 $39.27 $40.77 $42.49 11/2/2013 14 MOSAIC COMPANY TARGET VALUE MOSAIC TARGET PRICE - $52 PER SHARE THE DCF ANALYSIS TARGET PRICE IS $48.65 EXCESS CASH OF $3.35 PER SHARE HAS ALSO BEEN CONSIDERED AS AN ADJUSTMENT TO DCF VALUE THUS, TARGET PRICE FOR MOSAIC IS ESTIMATED AT $52 PER SHARE MULTIPLE METHOD VALUATION REVEALS PRICE OF $51 PER SHARE WHICH IS ALSO SUPPORTING THE ABOVE TARGET RATE 11/2/2013 15 VALSPAR CORPORATION COMPANY OVERVIEW Revenues - 4,104MM Op. Income - 492.42MM EPS - 3.49 Current Price - $70.88 Market Cap - 6.1B P/E - 22.19 Beta - 1.11 Dividends - $1.04 Operating Earnings Sales -5% 6% 29% Coating 40% 66% 11/2/2013 54% Paintings Others 16 VALSPAR CORPORATION BUSINESS ANALYSIS KEY DRIVERS: US HOUSING MARKET RECOVERY AND GROWTH IN GLOBAL ECONOMY BRAND AWARENESS AND EQUITY INVESTMENTS IN OVERSEES MARKETS - CHINA, INDIA, EUROPE. 11/2/2013 17 VALSPAR CORPORATION FINANCIAL VALUATION Averaging P/E, P/S & P/CF reveals target price of 58$ per share #Your *Target E, Target S per Multiple Share Absolute Valuation High Low Median Current P/Forward E 21.5 10.9 14.9 17.4 14.9 4.08 60.79 P/S P/B P/EBITDA 1.6 5.5 95.78 0.5 1.1 4.56 1 2.1 8.23 1.5 4.4 10.1 1.2 2.4 8 47.34 16.2 7.1 56.81 38.88 56.80 P/CF 16.5 7 11.6 15.6 12 4.56 54.72 11/2/2013 Target Price 18 VALSPAR COMPANY – FREE CASH FLOWS TO THE FIRM Year 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E 2019E 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E 2024E Revenue % Growth 4,511 4,829 7.1% 5,114 5.9% 5,395 5.5% 5,686 5.4% 5,987 5.3% 6,299 5.2% 6,614 5.0% 6,925 4.7% 7,222 4.3% 7,511 4.00% Operating Income Operating Margin 607 13.5% 670 13.9% 715 14.0% 754 14.0% 795 14.0% 837 14.0% 881 14.0% 925 14.0% 968 14.0% 1,010 14.0% 1,050 14.0% 68 1.5% 68 1.4% 72 1.4% 76 1.4% 80 1.4% 84 1.4% 88 1.4% 93 1.4% 97 1.4% 101 1.4% 105 1.4% 173 193 206 217 229 241 254 266 279 291 302 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% 32.0% Net Income % Growth 367 410 11.8% 438 6.7% 462 5.5% 486 5.4% 512 5.3% 539 5.2% 566 5.0% 592 4.7% 618 4.3% 643 4.0% Add Depreciation/Amort 113 121 128 124 131 138 145 152 159 166 173 2.5% (59) -1.3% 135 3.0% 2.5% (43) -0.9% 121 2.5% 2.5% (38) -0.8% 128 2.5% 2.3% (40) -0.8% 135 2.5% 2.3% (43) -0.8% 142 2.5% 2.3% (45) -0.8% 150 2.5% 2.3% (47) -0.8% 157 2.5% 2.3% (50) -0.8% 165 2.5% 2.3% (52) -0.8% 173 2.5% 2.3% (54) -0.8% 181 2.5% 2.3% (56) -0.8% 173 2.3% 285 367 28.6% 399 8.8% 410 2.8% 432 5.4% 455 5.3% 479 5.2% 503 5.0% 527 4.7% 549 4.3% 586 6.7% Interest and Other Interest % of Sales Taxes Tax Rate % of Sales Plus/(minus) Changes WC % of Sales Subtract Cap Ex Capex % of sales Free Cash Flow % Growth VALSPAR CORPORATION DCF ANALYSIS CONTINUED NPV of Cash Flows NPV of terminal value Projected Equity Value Free Cash Flow Yield 2,719 3,456 6,175 4.82% Current P/E Projected P/E Current EV/EBITDA Projected EV/EBITDA 16.1 16.8 9.5 9.9 Shares Outstanding 89.9 Current Price $ 71.08 Implied equity value/share $ 68.68 Debt Cash Cash/share 11/2/2013 44% 56% 100% 14.4 15.1 8.7 9.0 13.5 14.1 8.1 8.4 Terminal Discount Rate = Terminal FCF Growth = 10.5% 4.00% 4,643 3,697 41.12 20 VALSPAR CORPORATION RECOMMENDATION CURRENT PRICE: $71.08 TARGET PRICE: $68.7 RECOMMENDATION: NO ACTION (NEGATIVE) 11/2/2013 21 Alcoa Inc. Company Overview Alcoa Inc. produces and manages primary aluminum, fabricated aluminum, and alumina combined and participates in mining, refining, smelting, fabricating, and recycling. Its products are used in aircraft, automobiles, packaging & defense, among others. Key Fundamentals Current Price $9.54 Market Cap 10.25B P/E ratio 34.6 EPS 0.28 Revenue 23.43B Profit margin 1.27% ROE 1.97% Beta 1.85 11/2/2013 Alcoa Sales by Segments Alumin a 13% Engine ered Produc ts 23% Primar y Metals 32% Global Rolled Produc ts 32% 22 Alcoa Inc. Company Overview Source: Yahoo Finance. - October 8, 2013 , AA reported its third quarter results. - Trading at the highest level since 2012 11/2/2013 23 Alcoa Inc. Company Overview The company is making progress to boost earnings through productivity improvements. 11/2/2013 24 Alcoa Inc. Business Analysis Key Drivers - Productivity improvements - A possible recovery in aluminum prices - Speculation last week that aluminum price will risk - Down stream, less price sensitive profits business profits solid - Engineered products business which it’s a huge supplier to Boeing - Growing market in aerospace industry and automotive industry, brings huge orders 11/2/2013 25 Alcoa Inc. Business Analysis Risks - High debt - A reduction in demand, or a lack of increased demand, for aluminum by China, Europe or a combined number of other countries may negatively impact Alcoa’s results. - Poor pricing - Profitability of aluminum producers is heavily depend on the underlying commodity price. Source: MetalPrices.com. 11/2/2013 26 Alcoa Inc. Valuation Analysis 11/2/2013 27 Alcoa Inc. ALCOA (AA) Analyst: Sai Zhang 2013-11-26 Terminal Discount Rate = 11.00% Terminal FCF Growth = 3.00% DCF Analysis 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E 2019E 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E 23,679 23,016 -2.80% 23,775 3.30% 24,488 3.00% 24,978 2.00% 25,478 2.00% 25,732 1.00% 25,990 1.00% 26,250 1.00% 26,512 1.00% 27,042 2.00% 1,807 7.63% 1,857 8.07% 1,972 8.30% 1,469 6.00% 1,399 5.60% 1,401 5.50% 1,364 5.30% 1,377 5.30% 1,391 5.30% 1,405 5.30% 1,433 5.30% 544 2.30% 520 2.26% 644 2.71% 612 2.50% 624 2.50% 637 2.50% 515 2.00% 520 2.00% 525 2.00% 530 2.00% 541 2.00% 480 36.00% 503 36.00% 496 36.00% 309 36.00% 279 36.00% 275 36.00% 306 36.00% 309 36.00% 312 36.00% 315 36.00% 321 36.00% 784 834 6.37% 832 -0.21% 549 -34.06% 496 -9.66% 489 -1.29% 543 11.10% 549 1.00% 554 1.00% 560 1.00% 571 2.00% 1,374 5.80% 1,340 5.82% 1,384 5.82% 1,425 5.82% 1,454 5.82% 1,483 5.82% 1,498 5.82% 1,513 5.82% 1,528 5.82% 1,543 5.82% 1,574 5.82% 29 0.12% 1,261 5.33% 37 0.16% 1,215 5.3% 12 0.05% 1,001 5.3% 245 1.0% 1,308 5.3% 250 1.0% 1,334 5.3% 229 0.9% 1,361 5.3% 206 0.8% 1,374 5.3% 208 0.8% 1,388 5.3% 210 0.8% 1,402 5.3% 212 0.8% 1,416 5.3% 216 0.8% 1,444 5.3% 926 996 7.52% 1,227 23.21% 911 -25.74% 865 -5.02% 841 -2.83% 873 3.82% 882 1.00% 890 1.00% 899 1.00% 917 2.00% NPV of Cash Flows 5,580 57% NPV of terminal value Projected Equity Value 4,159 9,739 43% 100% Terminal Value 11,810 Free Cash Flow Yield 9.08% Free Cash Yield 7.77% Terminal P/E 20.7 Terminal EV/EBITDA 6.0 Revenue % Growth Operating Income Operating Margin Interest Interest % of Sales Taxes Tax Rate Net Income % Growth Add Depreciation/Amort % of Sales Plus/(minus) Changes WC % of Sales Subtract Cap Ex Capex % of sales Free Cash Flow % Growth Current P/E Projected P/E Current EV/EBITDA Projected EV/EBITDA Shares Outstanding Current Price 13.0 12.4 12.2 11.7 12.3 11.7 5.2 5.0 5.2 5.0 4.9 4.8 1,069 9.54 Implied equity value/share 9.11 Upside/(Downside) to DCF -4.5% 11/2/2013 Debt Cash Cash/share 7,340 1,020 0.95 28 Alcoa Inc. Recommendation Recommendation: Not action (Negative). 11/2/2013 29 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Company Overview Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. (FCX) is an international natural resources company with headquarters in Phoenix, Arizona. The company operates large, long-lived, geographically diverse assets with significant reserves of copper, gold, molybdenum, cobalt, oil and gas. Key Fundamentals Current Price $35.40 Market Cap 36.74B P/E ratio 12.9 EPS 2.74 Revenue 19.55B Profit margin 13.78% ROE 14.84% Beta 2.29 11/2/2013 FCX Sales by Segments Africa 8% Indone sia 23% South Americ a 21% North Americ a 48% 30 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Company Overview Source: Yahoo Finance. - 2013, declining commodity prices - Posted decent margins in the recent quarter despite the decline in commodity prices 11/2/2013 31 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Business Analysis Key Drivers - High dividend, 3.4% - Massive reserve base and hedged pricing - Can maintain the productivity level fro 30 years - Diversification into oil exploration - Acquisitions of Plains Exploration & Production Company - aims to double its production of oil & gas over the next five years 11/2/2013 FCX Sales by Commodity Diversification Oil and Natura l Gas 26% Mining 74% 32 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Company Overview Although the company is not performing well relative to the industry, it presents a good investment opportunity. 11/2/2013 33 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Business Analysis Risks - Economic Volatility - Slowdown in emerging market economies - Acquisition increased significant debt amount - High leverage ratio - Slowing U.S. and global GDP growth - Lagging demand of copper in China 11/2/2013 34 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Valuation Analysis 11/2/2013 35 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. FCX Analyst: Sai Zhang 2013-11-26 Terminal Discount Rate = 11.50% Terminal FCF Growth = 4.00% DCF Analysis Year 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E 2019E 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E Revenue 19,209 19,424 1.12% 21,599 11.20% 22,247 3.00% 22,024 -1.00% 22,244 1.00% 22,912 3.00% 23,599 3.00% 23,835 1.00% 24,074 1.00% 24,555 2.00% 5,324 27.71% 5,493 28.28% 5,246 24.29% 5,562 25.00% 5,506 25.00% 5,784 26.00% 6,186 27.00% 6,372 27.00% 6,435 27.00% 6,500 27.00% 6,630 27.00% 384 2.00% 491 2.53% 540 2.50% 556 2.50% 551 2.50% 556 2.50% 458 2.00% 472 2.00% 477 2.00% 481 2.00% 491 2.00% 1,616 33.00% 1,633 33.00% 1,484 33.00% 1,652 33.00% 1,635 33.00% 1,725 33.00% 1,890 33.00% 1,947 33.00% 1,966 33.00% 1,986 33.00% 2,026 33.00% 3,293 3,327 1.04% 3,026 -9.06% 3,354 10.83% 3,320 -1.00% 3,502 5.49% 3,838 9.57% 3,953 3.00% 3,992 1.00% ` 4,032 4,113 2.00% Capex % of sales 1,374 7.15% 1,080 5.62% 1,261 6.56% 1,130 5.82% (124) -0.64% 1,215 5.5% 1,257 5.82% (387) -1.79% 1,001 5.5% 1,295 5.82% -111 -0.5% 1,224 5.5% 1,282 5.82% -110 -0.5% 1,211 5.5% 1,295 5.82% -111 -0.5% 1,223 5.5% 1,333 5.82% -115 -0.5% 1,260 5.5% 1,373 5.82% -118 -0.5% 1,298 5.5% 1,387 5.82% -119 -0.5% 1,311 5.5% 1,401 5.82% -120 -0.5% 1,324 5.5% 1,429 5.82% -123 -0.5% 1,429 5.8% Free Cash Flow 4,487 3,119 -30.47% 2,895 -7.18% 3,314 14.44% 3,281 -1.00% 3,462 5.54% 3,796 9.65% 3,910 3.00% 3,949 1.00% 3,989 1.00% 3,990 0.03% NPV of Cash Flows 19,944 52% NPV of terminal value Projected Equity Value 18,630 38,574 48% 100% Terminal Value 55,331 Free Cash Flow Yield 14.30% Free Cash Yield 7.21% Terminal P/E 13.5 Terminal EV/EBITDA 7.0 % Growth Operating Income Operating Margin Interest Interest % of Sales Taxes Tax Rate Net Income % Growth Add Depreciation/Amort % of Sales Plus/(minus) Changes WC % of Sales Subtract Cap Ex % Growth Current P/E Projected P/E 9.5 11.7 9.4 11.6 10.4 12.7 Current EV/EBITDA Projected EV/EBITDA 4.8 5.9 4.9 5.9 5.0 6.1 Shares Outstanding 954 Current Price Implied equity value/share Upside/(Downside) to DCF Debt Cash Cash/share 11/2/2013 32.89 40.43 22.9% 3,525 2,700 2.83 36 Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. Recommendation Current Price: $35.40 Target Price: $40.43 Recommendation: Buy. 11/2/2013 37 OVERVIEW STOCKS CONSIDERED AND RECOMMENDATION Company Name Symbol Cost Basis Mosaic MOS $53.45 $47.05 -12% $52.00 Valspar VAL ~ $71.01 ~ Alcoa AA ~ $9.54 FCX ~ $35.4 Freeport 11/2/2013 Current Gain, Target Upside Price % Price % SIM % Action 10.5% 2.91% Sell (2.91%) $68.60 -3.4% ~ No Action ~ $9.11 -4.5% ~ No Action ~ $40.43 22.9% ~ Buy (2.91%) 38