Military Family Services Program Compliance and Assurance Review 2015/2016 Fiscal Year (NAME OF MFRC) (Date of Compliance and Assurance) (Name of MFRC) COMPLIANCE AND ASSURANCE REVIEW PROGRAM – Fiscal Year 2015-2016 Ref Requirement MOU 6.3.1 Method of verification Military Family Resource Centre (MFRC) is a (federally/provincially/territor ially) incorporated, not-forprofit organization in good standing. MOU The MFRC will obtain 8.1 property, liability, errors and omissions and directors’ and officers’ liability insurance coverage in accordance with the minimum standards established by MFS. MOU 6.3.11 MFRC conducts Community Needs Assessment (CNA) at least every three years. Official MFRC provides services in language both official languages in Act and accordance with MFSP Department of National Parameters Defence (DND) standards for Practice, and the principles of family Sect 3. support. Confirm with the province or territory to ensure that MFRC is incorporated and in good standing at the time of the audit. MOU 6.3.12 MFRC clearly identifies the Military Family Services Program (MFSP) logo on all printed material, signs, website, advertising and promotional material intended to promote the programs and services that Review of at least six promotional pieces, to determine compliance with the MFSP National Graphics Standards Manual (Version June 2014) 2/12 Observation Mode of review Onsite Reviewer to ascertain what the minimum standards established by MFS are at the time of the visit. Confirm with the insurance company used by the MFRC that they have the recommended level of insurance. Onsite Was the last Community Needs Assessment completed within the last 36 months? Review of at least six communications pieces that reflect that services are provided in both official languages. Onsite Onsite . (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite fall under the purview of the MFSP. MOU 6.3.3 MFS Letter 5390-4, Screening of MFRC Staff 07 Aug 2014 DMFS briefing at Professional Development Symposium for MFRC EDs and Board Chairs Nov 2013/ED Briefing 11 June 2014 Ottawa. 3/12 MFRC ensures that it adheres to applicable labour legislation, which forms the basis for its employee policy, standards and guidelines. Does the MFRC have a policy and procedure in place to ensure that all staff who work with or come into contact with children and/or vulnerable individuals have undergone a criminal reference check and a vulnerable sector screening? Does the MFRC have a benefit plan in place for its staff that meets the minimum MFS requirements? In order for the reviewer to confirm that the MFRC adheres to applicable labour legislation they should be provided with a letter of opinion. This letter would verify adherence to labour legislation and would be signed by an appropriate authority. It would not be appropriate for this letter to be signed by a member of the Board. Verify that policies and procedures exist. Onsite Onsite Random spot check HR files for criminal reference check and vulnerable sector screening documentation. Confirm with the Benefit providers that the MFRC has benefit insurance in place that meets the minimum MFS requirements. (Alternatively, the MFRC should have a copy of a signed agreement/contract with the benefits provider and could show monthly remittances.) Compare the MFRC’s benefit summary with minimum MFS requirements 1 Oct 2014. (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite Review a sample of eligible employee files to ensure that each is enrolled in the plan. MOU 6.3.13 MFRC ensures that Verify that Privacy formalized procedures are in Procedures to protect and manage Code and place to manage personal personal information exist Privacy information as Procedures to manage complaints recommended in the MFSP and enquires about adherence to Privacy Code and the Code exist Base/Wing regulations as Procedures to communicate and applicable. train the staff about privacy Recommendations from the principle and accompanying Commissioner of Canada procedures exist are also reliable business practices. Onsite (physical filing and storing of information) MOU 6.3.10 MFRC coordinates a minimum of four meetings per year with the local Commanding Officer, the MFRC Board Chair and the MFRC Executive Director. Ask the ED, and note how many meetings were held during the year . Onsite MOU 6.3.2 MFRC complies with the provisions of its own organizational bylaws. Review bylaws. Randomly spot check that Board practices parallel provisions of the bylaws. Cross check with Annual General Meeting (AGM) and Board minutes to verify. Focus on bylaws that are relevant to the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU). (Note observations in Appendix A of audit report.) Onsite MOU 6.3.4 In addition, and subject to the applicable Ensure that Military Family Services (MFS) requirements for Board Onsite 4/12 (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year (federal/provincial/territorial) legislation under which it is incorporated, ensure appropriate representation on its Board of Directors consistent with: 1. Civilian family members of serving full-time Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) personnel, constituting at least 51% of the voting membership. composition are met at the time of the review. Requirements for minimum numbers are stated in MFRC MOU. 2. A minimum of seven voting members (or in communities of less than 1000 CAF personnel, five voting members is acceptable). MOU 6.3.4 Item 4 MOU 7.3.8 5/12 3. A Commanding Officer or a senior member of the command team sits on the Board as a nonvoting representative. MFRC must ensure members of the local CAF community have a formal opportunity to nominate and elect members to the MFRC Board of Directors. Review bylaws, Board minutes, AGM report and AGM minutes to establish that members of the local CAF community had the formal opportunity to nominate and elect members to the MFRC Board. Onsite MFRC will obtain an annual external and independent financial audit conducted by a designated Public Review audit and note any emergent issues. Review management letter that accompanies audit and note salient Onsite (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Accountant licensed in his/her respective province. MOU 7.3.3 Best Practices 6/12 Follow generally accepted accounting principles and practices, as well as the Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants guidelines for Not for Profit accounting. MFRC is managing/investing any surplus funds in a manner observations. Review notes to audited financial statement. Verify that credentials of auditor indicate that he/she is licensed in the province. Verify that accountant has no connections other than professional with the MFRC. Ensure that he or she is “independent”. Enquire as to how many years the current auditing company has performed the audit at this MFRC. Verify by reviewing annual financial audit conducted by Public Accountant. Verify by reviewing management letter that accompanies financial audit. The reviewer will meet with the accountant in person or via phone and discuss the annual audit process with questions such as: did the auditor meet with the ED, Board Chair and Treasurer, who provided all of the documents the auditor required, was the audit done on the premises or completely in the auditor’s own office? Post audit, before the production of final audited statements – did the auditor debrief with the ED, Board Chair and Treasurer? Did the auditor present the financial statements at the AGM? How many years did this company audit the MFRC? Review how surplus funds have been invested during the past 24 months. Given the MFRC’s risk tolerance (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite Onsite that minimizes risk to those funds. profile, surplus funds should only be invested in GICs, term deposits, money market funds or similar “cashequivalent” vehicles. List all exceptions during the past 24 months (amount, date invested, type of investment, who authorized, and name of financial institution). Best Practices Does the MFRC do fund development through other funders, charitable donations and/or special events? Is info available to enable management’s evaluation of whether they are working at capacity in this area? MOU 6.3.7, 6.3.20 7/12 MFRC develops and submits its Request for Funds, Service Delivery Agreement, Quarterly Financial, Service Level Agreement, Supplemental Agreement and If the MFRC is managing/investing any surplus funds, then a list of eligible investments should be incorporated into the by-laws. The bylaws should stipulate that all other types of investments are specifically prohibited. Does the MFRC have a written fundraising plan for the current fiscal year? Onsite What is the MFRC’s fundraising goal, in dollars, for the current fiscal year? (ie other funders, charitable donations and special events) ? How many staff person-years are dedicated to fundraising? Review applicable documents within the last 12 months Note: The process for financial reporting to MFS will be changing for this coming year, starting with the Request for Funding procedure which will be part of this audit. (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite Performance Reports, in the manner prescribed by MFS. MFSP Parameters for Practice, Sect 5 MFRCs are expected to report on the expenditure of MFS provided funds; therefore the MFRC chart of accounts must segregate these funds. Review chart of accounts to ensure that MFS funds are identified and therefore possible to track. Onsite MOU 7.3.1 MFRC uses funds provided by the DND through MFS exclusively for MFSP Mandated Services in accordance with MFSP: Parameters for Practice and its approved Service Delivery Agreement. Onsite MOU 7.3.4 The MFRC will provide to MFS Quarterly Financial and Performance Reports in the format prescribed by MFS, detailing the service provided and funds expended. To confirm that MFS funds are being appropriately expended: Verify that MFS funds are segregated and therefore possible to track. Review quarterly expenditure reports and cross reference with financial journal entries, financial records and cancelled cheques. Inspect invoices and receipts. Verify that quarterly reports report expenses in accordance with identified budget items in the Service Delivery Agreement. Monitor that these records clearly indicate purpose for which funds were expended. Verify with MFS that submissions of quarterly financial reports are up to date at the time of the audit. Review quarterly reports for prescribed format. Ensure that the Board is reviewing these reports at their meetings. For assurance of accuracy in reporting, compare the fourth quarter of most recent fiscal year to the 8/12 (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite MOU 7.3.5 MOU 7.3.1 9/12 Subject to approval from MFS, the MFRC may retain up to a maximum of 10 percent of unexpended funds within a given fiscal year. Funds retained must be expended in such a way that is “in keeping with” the overall goals and objectives of the MFSP. Expenditure of and future reporting on the use of the unexpended funds will be in accordance with MFS provisions. Invoices, receipts and/or other records that demonstrate the purpose for which the funds were expended will be held on file at the MFRC for a period of six years, and made available to MFS or its representative on request. figures reported in the audited financial statement for that year. If there are discrepancies, ask the MFRC if it has submitted a revised report to MFS. If applicable: Confirm that approval from MFS was obtained. Track expenditure of funds by crossreferencing with financial journal entries, financial records and cancelled cheques. Monitor that these records clearly indicate purpose for which funds were expended. Spot check records. (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite Onsite MOU 7.3.1 Ensure proper control of accountability documents. MOU 7.3.1 Proper internal control over payroll 10/12 Verify through sample review that the following acceptable practices are being followed: Proper serially numbered documents are used for processing the following transactions: a. cash receipts from customers; b. disbursement cheques; and c. charitable donation receipts. Ask to see sample of records for each. Serial documents are recorded in a master control log that is maintained by someone independent of the bookkeeper. Ask to see log. Daily usage of serial numbered forms is controlled by someone other than the bookkeeper. Ask to see control system. Cash receipts are reconciled to the value of the deposit. Ask how this is being done and ask to see sample. Independent verification of serial numbered forms is conducted semi-annually by the Executive Director (ED). Verify that the following acceptable practices are being followed: If an external payroll service provider is used, time sheets and pay rates must be approved by the Executive Director. Ask to see sample of completed timesheets. (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite Onsite MOU 7.3.3 11/12 If payroll is completed in house, payroll cheques must be signed by the Executive Director who must review and initial the supporting payroll records. Ask to see sample of supporting payroll records. Adequate segregation of Verify that the following practices are duties. Management should in place and the following duties are follow acceptable guidelines segregated: for segregation of duties to cheques must be signed by two prevent and detect both authorized signing officers; intentional and unintentional source documents must be errors. attached to or presented with separation of the custody cheques at the time of signature, of assets from initialed by those signing the accounting; cheques and stamped “paid" to prevent double payment; separation of the authorization of bank reconciliations must be transactions from the completed by the Treasurer or custody of related third party and must be approved assets; by the ED; separation of duties ED should have read-only access within the accounting to online balance and transactions function; and on the bank account. separation of operational all incoming cheques / mail are responsibility from received, opened and recorded in record-keeping a log by someone other than the responsibility bookkeeper; incoming cheques are immediately stamped with a “For Deposit Only to MRFC account #”; and bank deposit is taken to the bank by someone other than the individual who prepared it. (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Onsite APPENDIX A The reviewer will examine Board bylaws & policies and randomly select five provisions to spot check. The bylaws to be cross checked must be relevant to the provisions of the MOU (i.e. Board composition; AGM requirements; requirement for an annual financial audit; and so on). Using the table below, the reviewer will note five policies or bylaws. The reviewer will then verify the extent to which these are put into practice via analysis of Board and AGM minutes as well as interviews with Board members where appropriate. Board Policy Observation A.1 A.2 A.3 A.4 A.5 12/12 (Name of MFRC) MFSP Compliance and Assurance Review Program: 2015/2016 Fiscal Year Mode of review Onsite Onsite Onsite Onsite Onsite