Unit 3: Aggregate Supply & Demand Consumption Function Development • • • John Maynard Keynes originated idea Measures economic performance of an economy Focuses on the relationship b/w Consumption & Savings Simplifications • • • • Private/closed economy (no int’l influence & gov’t ignored) • C + Ig Assume that all saving is personal Depreciation & net foreign factor = 0 Reminder: w/ no gov’t or foreign trade, GDP = NI = PI = DI (all the same!) Consumption Function Tools • • • Theory assumes that the level of output & employment depend directly on the level of aggregate expenditures • Changes in output reflect changes in agg. spending Consumption • The most important determinant of consumer spending is DI (income) 45° angle represents all points where consumer spending equals DI (1:1) • 45° line represents zero savings • If DI increases, both consumption & savings will increase Consumption Function Tools • Consumption Schedule • Historically, households spend a larger proportion of small income than of a larger income • Breakeven: C = DI • total income level when H consume all income • Dissavings occurs at low levels where consumption exceeds income & households must borrow (credit cards) Consumption Function Tools • • Non-income Determinants of Consumption & Saving • Wealth • Expectations • Household Debt • Taxation Shifts & Stability • Consumption & saving schedules will shift in opposite directions • UNLESS caused by a tax change • Consumption & saving schedules are generally stable unless deliberately shifted by gov’t action Consumption Function Consumption 1:1 Savings $500 Break Even Dissavings 45° $500 DI Savings Function Savings Savings Dissavings Break Even DI Marginal Propensity to Consume & Save • MPC: what effect a ∆ Income has on amount C • MPC = change in consumption change in income • MPS: what effect a ∆ Income has on amount S • MPS = change in saving change in income • MPC + MPS = 1 Marginal Propensity to Consume & Save • Calculate MPC/MPS • If disposable income changes from $10,000 to $12,000 and consumption changes from $9,000 to $10,000: • What is MPC? • What is MPS? • Why do MPC & MPS always equal 1? MPC & MPS Level of output & income (NNP=DI) (1) Consumption (2) Saving (1)-(2) (3) MPC Δ(2)/Δ(1) (4) MPS Δ(3)/Δ(1) (5) $12,000 $12,100 -100 .90 .1 13,000 13,000 0 9/10 1/10 14,000 13,800 200 .8 .2 15,000 14,500 500 .7 .3 16,000 15,100 900 .6 .4 The Multiplier Effect Why do cities want the Superbowl in their stadium? An initial change in spending will set off a spending chain that is magnified in the economy. Example: • A Seahawks fan spends $120 on dinner at John’s diner. • John’s income has increased by $120. • John spends $100 on a new bench from Carol’s furniture shop. • Carol spends $80 on wood from Dan’s lumber yard. • Dan spends $50 on lunch at Sharon’s restaurant… The Multiplier Effect shows how spending is magnified in the economy & doesn’t end at the initial purchase/investment. Multiplier • Multiplier Effect • • Any increase in spending will result in an even larger increase in GDP due to the fact that every $ spent is spent again multiple times. Increases in spending can come from either government (G) or businesses (Ig) • Any money spent is someone else’s income & thus subject to spending. • Contingent on MPC & MPS … WHY? • Limiting factor of multiplier is MPS • Multiplier = 1/MPS or 1/(1-MPC) • Larger the MPC, larger the multiplier Multiplier • What is the multiplier if the MPC is equal to ¾? • 1 / (1 - 0.75) = 4 • What is the multiplier if the MPC is equal to 9/10? • 1 / (1 - 0.9) = 10 • What is the multiplier if the MPS is 1/5? • 1 / 0.2 = 5 Multiplier • Multiplier Effect • Multiplier is used to calculate how any change in spending will change total spending (AD) or income (GDP) • ∆ Spending x Multiplier = ∆ AD/GDP George Bush, in an effort to increase GDP during a recession, proposed a stimulus package which provided every American family with $200 more of disposable income. The marginal propensity to consume at that point in time was 0.75. Calculate the multiplier and identify how much more spending this would generate per family. 1/0.25 = 4 4 x 200 = $800 Multiplier • Would the multiplier be larger or smaller if people saved more of their additional income? (MPS = .25 vs. .3) • • What would happen to the multiplier if people saved all of their income? • • Smaller ( 4 vs. 3.33) It would be 1 & thus spending doesn’t multiply (Multiplier = 1/1) What would happen if people spent all of their income? • It would be infinite & thus spending would be replicated for every transaction (Multiplier = 1/0) Multiplier • If the multiplier were 4, how much money would the gov’t spend to increase aggregate demand by $1 million? • $250,000 ( spending x 4 = 1,000,000 ) • If the gov’t needed to cut AD by $2 million and the multiplier were 4, how much would gov’t spending have to be reduced? • $500,000 ( spending x 4 = 2,000,000 ) Multiplier • How does the multiplier explain why changes in investment spending cause large fluctuations in GDP? • Because increases in investment cause endogenous increases in consumption, the ultimate increase in GDP is larger than the initial investment • i.e. minor injections/leakages cause even greater growth of GDP ($1 M injection can yield growth of $5 M) MPS/MPC & Multiplier • If disposable income changes from $15,000 to $19,000 and saving changes from $10,000 to $11,000: • MPS: .25 • MPC: .75 • The MULTIPLIER: 4 MPS/MPC & Multiplier • If disposable income changes from $15,000 to $16,000 and consumption changes from $10,000 to $10,750: • MPS: .25 • MPC: .75 • The MULTIPLIER: 4 Interest Rates & Investment Demand • What is investment? • Investment decisions made using cost/benefit analysis. • • • Benefit = expected rate of return (r) Cost = interest rates – the “cost” of money (i) • make sure i is adjusted for inflation Rules: • If expected return ≥ real interest – INVEST • If expected return < real interest – DO NOT Interest Rates & Investment Demand Why is the ID downward sloping? Shifts in Investment Demand • • Cost of Production • Lower costs shift ID Higher shifts ID Business Taxes • Lower business taxes shift ID Higher shifts ID • Technological Change • New technology shifts ID • Stock of Capital • Low on capital shifts ID High shifts ID Expectations • Positive expectations shifts ID Negative shifts ID • Interest Rates & Investment Demand The real interest rate is 2%. What is investment at that level? investment Investment Schedule If real interest rate was 2%, we would assume that businesses are investing $2T at all levels of output. $2 T Ig $1.8 Ig0 The amount invested is very unstable/volatile, however, and investment can & does occur irregularly. GDP = DI Aggregate Expenditures Model • Measures Aggregate Demand/Expenditures against real GDP • POLICY GOAL IS TO MOVE IT UP (increase GDP) • Leakages (withdrawal of spending from income/expenditure stream) imports, taxes, savings • Injections (addition of spending to the income/expenditure stream) spending (G or Ig), investment, net exports • Must equal each other: S( savings) + M ( imports) + T ( taxes) = I ( investments) + X ( exports) + G( government purchases) Aggregate Expenditures Model 1:1 AD/AE C + Ig C 45° Equilibrium GDP is the intersection of ____ & ____. GDP (NI, NO) International Trade & Equilibrium Output • Xn & Aggregate Expenditures • Closed economy: • AE = C + Ig • Open economy: • AE = C + Ig + Xn • Measuring AE for domestic goods (X – M) Government Purchases & Equilibrium GDP • • • A mixed economy – adding gov’t spending & taxes. Government spending is subject to the multiplier. • Balanced Budget Multiplier: a change in G is more powerful than a tax change of the same size \ • (spend & tax at same amount will yield growth) Taxes are leakages • Lump Sum: tax that provides equal amounts of revenue at each level of GDP • a tax increase shifts AE downward only by the amount of the tax times the MPC Aggregate Expenditures Model 1:1 AD/AE U. S. C + Ig + G + Xn C + Ig + G C + Ig + G + (Xn) C + Ig C 45° GDP (NI, NO) Government Purchases & Equilibrium GDP • Recessionary Gap: • The amount by which AE at full employment GDP falls short of those required to achieve full employment GDP • Inflationary Gap • The amount by which an economy’s AE at full employment exceeds those just necessary to achieve full employment Aggregate Expenditures Model 1:1 C + Ig AD/AE C 45° GDP (NI, NO) AE Model AD Curve AE1 (at P1) AE2 (at P2) Price Level AD/AE 1:1 P2 P1 AD 45° 3500 4000 GDP Thus, GDP is less at P2 (higher price level) than P1 0 3500 4000 GDP Aggregate Demand • • Shows the amounts of real GDP that buyers desire to purchase at each price level. If the price level: • Increases (inflation), then Real GDP demanded ___ • Decreases (deflation), then Real GDP demanded ___ Price Level AD = C + I + G + Xn Real domestic output (GDPR) Aggregate Demand Why downward slope? • Real-Balances Effect: • price level reduces purchasing power – GDP • Interest Rate Effect: • price level leads lenders need to charge higher interest rates – GDP • Foreign Purchases Effect: • price level reduces foreign D of U.S. goods & increases U.S. D of foreign goods – GDP (due to –Xn) Determinants of Aggregate Demand An increase in spending shifts AD right & decrease in spending shifts AD left. Price Level AD1 AD2 AD = C + I + G + Xn Real domestic output (GDP) Determinants of Aggregate Demand 1. Change in Consumer Spending Consumer Wealth (Boom in the stock market…) Consumer Expectations (People fear a recession…) Household Indebtedness (More consumer debt…) Taxes (Decrease in income taxes…) 2. Change in Investment Spending Real Interest Rates (Price of borrowing $...) Rate of Return: Future Business Expectations (High expectations…) Productivity and Technology (New robots…) Business Taxes (Higher corporate taxes…) Determinants of Aggregate Demand 3. Change in Government Spending (War…) (Decrease in defense spending…) 4. Change in Net Exports (X-M) Exchange Rates (If the us dollar depreciates relative to the euro…) National Income Abroad AD = GDP = C + I + G + Xn Aggregate Supply • • Shows the level of real GDP that firms will produce at each price level. Three ranges: Price Level D Classical C A B Keynesian Q1 Q2 Q3 GDPR Cost-Push Inflation vs. Demand Pull Inflation • Outcome on price level is the same, but GDP differs. AS Price Level AD D Classical C A B Keynesian Q1 Q2 Q3 GDPR SRAS & LRAS • AS differentiates b/w short-run & long-run • SRAS: immediately after change in PL (input costs haven’t yet adjusted to change in PL) • LRAS: measures potential output / NRU; point at which input prices have adjusted to change in PL Actual GDP = SRAS Potential GDP = LRAS SRAS & LRAS The LRAS & SRAS curves also indicate our PPF & can be used to identify GDP gaps. LRAS Price Level SRAS Consumer Goods • C P1 A B Capital Goods 500 550 600 GDPR Determinants of Aggregate Supply • Firms are able to produce more or less at every price level. • per-unit production costs change for reasons outside changes in real GDP • SRAS shifters mostly AS3 AS1 Price Level Q1 Q2 Q3 AS2 GDPR Determinants of Aggregate Supply 1. Inputs • Costs of Domestic Resources Factors of Production • Cost of Imported Resources Exchange rate value • Market Power Competition Determinants of Aggregate Supply 2. Legal-Institutional Environment • • Business taxes & subsidies Gov’t regulation: Anti-trust laws Labor laws Environmental laws 3. Productivity worker education management skill technology Equilibrium Price Level & Real Output • Shifts in SRAS/AD will reveal inflationary/recessionary gaps. Price Level Recessionary Inflationary Gap Gap LRAS GDPR Fiscal Policy • The use of government spending (the BUDGET) & revenue collection (TAXES) to influence the economy • Fiscal year o October 1- September 30 • Federal Budget: o Revenues = Spending… Balanced Budget o Revenues > Spending… Budget Surplus o Revenues < Spending… Budget Deficit National Debt Federal Debt = accumulated deficits - accumulated surpluses $17.3 T Types of Fiscal Policy T O O L S Contractionary: works to fight inflation but can lead to a fall in GDP. 1. Raise taxes: take money out of circulation 2. Reduce gov’t spending: cuts back on funding social programs & business contracts Results in… • Budget surplus Resolves inflationary / recessionary gap. Republicans would prefer which option? Types of Fiscal Policy Expansionary: works to fight deflation, unemployment, & recessions. Used to raise the level of output in the economy. T 1. Reduce taxes: gives consumers more to spend O & less to pay the gov’t O 2. Increase gov’t spending: gov’t spends money L on social programs & business contracts S Results in… • Budget deficit Resolves inflationary / recessionary gap Republicans would prefer which option? Demand Side Economics • • • • Focuses on changing AD Gov’t or consumer spending to help the economy. Policy used traditionally by Democrats John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946) o Gov’t should depend more on public works to fix unemployment. o Gov’t should decrease spending to fix inflation. Supply Side Economics: • Focuses on changing AS • Stresses influence of taxation on the economy, especially businesses • Gov’t should cut taxes on personal & corporate income • Gov’t should reduce regulations to decrease the costs of production • John Baptiste Say o Says Law: supply creates it’s own demand? o If you make a product, people will get paid and have money to spend and therefore purchase more goods • Reaganomics Nondiscretionary/Automatic Fiscal Policy • Built-in Stabilizers: automatic changes in G & T as the economy changes • Don’t require new legislation – already embodied in law • e.g. unemployment compensation, food stamps, SS, Medicare • Progressive Tax System • Recession: as incomes drop, ppl pay less of their income in taxes – more to spend • Inflation: as incomes rise, ppl pay more of their income in taxes – less to spend