Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Overview This module is designed to be about 7-9 lessons/classes long at about 50 minutes per lesson. I want to crate a flipped classroom for a CTS moduled course because I always find that there is not enough time to spend on the actual work that needs to be done. Often CTS courses are seen as “options” and it is not likely that students will do home work because they are full with everything else, or they don’t have the products to be able to complete the assignments, such as with photoshop for a lot of students. This course is the second unit in what I would think of as an entrepreneurial class that incorporates running a small business with selling a product that is branded with the school logo. This is the marketing portion of the class and will use examples of print, video and online advertisements to illustrate the various methods and processes that are used in the marketing process. The module will start off with a quick overview of what the process of advertising is and how it relates to our scope of work in the classroom. Next we will move on to working on researching various methods of advertising, print, television/video, online, and who they are specifically targeted too. Finally the students will cap off this module by creating their own advertisements (print for the standard, video for students who need a challenge). There will then be a “break” from the advertising portion of the class as we focus on starting the business and picking a product to market. I chose to set the class up this way so that students can get use to the tools we will be using the “flipped” classroom atmosphere and collaborating together. Key Questions What methods are available when advertising? How is advertising changing with technology, youtube, facebook? Who is the target market of your advertisement? What is the best form of advertising for that market? What makes an effective print advertisement? How are you going to make an effective advertisement (print or other)? Resources and Materials In this unit we will be using Google Drive, Google Search, Weebly websites, Commenting online and In class, Youtube, Poll Everywhere, Photoshop and a projector. Students will use photoshop to create 2 ads, and Google Drive to write out a communication document to assist in the explanation of their ad to the teacher when submitting their final assignment on their Weebly website. I have sourced some of my ideas from AdMongo, put forward by the Federal Trade Commison. The link is in the lesson plan. University of Lethbridge 1 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Lesson Plan 1 Name: Mary Elizabeth Telfer Grade/Subject: Grade 11 Entrepreneurship Unit: MAM2090 – Print Advertising Topic: What is media? Date: Length of Lesson: 52 mins Alberta Program of Studies Outcomes General Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 1. Describe principles involved in the advertising process and apply these principles to print media. Specific Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 1.1 Explain what advertising is and what purpose it serves 1.2 Differentiate between publicity and advertising 1.3 Describe the various criticisms, controversies, laws and ethics regarding advertising Students will: Define the advertising Describe the purpose that advertising serves Distinguish between publicity and advertising Recognize the laws, criticisms and ethics when advertising Learning Objectives: Materials and Resources Teacher Resources Classroom Website: http://msmaryelizabethtelfer.weebly.com/les son-1---what-is-advertising.html Print Ad Cover Girl: http://krissy9090.files.wordpress.com/2011/ 09/taylor_swift_covergirl_ad_rev.jpg Apple iPod Ads: http://youtu.be/TaVFCdwT0hk Blake Shelton Surprises Fans at the CMA Fan Fest - youtube video http://youtu.be/wGUJMEpz1IU AdMongo - from the Federal Trade Commission: http://www.admongo.gov Technology in the Classroom Students will use computers and Google in the classroom to search for ads to present to the class. Students may also use sites such as youtube to find sources, or other video sites to find examples of television ads. Students may also use digital copies of various news papers or publications that the school subscribes to, to find various ads. Modification/ Differentiation Will depend on each class. You can use any ads that you want, and I would use ads that work with your classroom. These are just a couple of easy ads that I picked, but I would switch them out each year. Learning Resources Classroom Management Considerations Work Sheet 1 adapted from ADMongo.gov Will depend on each class. University of Lethbridge 2 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Lesson Plan Procedure Introduction (Set) (5 min.) What is advertising? Students should have viewed the following media on the online “class” website. o Print: Cover Girl Ad: http://krissy9090.files.wordpress.com/2011/09/taylor_s wift_covergirl_ad_rev.jpg o Video: Apple iPod Ad: http://youtu.be/TaVFCdwT0hk o Students will discuss the difference between advertising and publicity – SHOW: (2 mins) Blake Shelton Surprises Fans at the CMA Fan Fest - youtube video Link: http://youtu.be/wGUJMEpz1IU In Class “work period” Students will brain storm what they believe advertising is and come up with their own definitions of advertising in singles, then in pairs/trios. Google definition: The activity or profession of producing advertisements for commercial products or services Student answers will be discussed in class, as a whole, once the groups have come up with a definition. Publicity may look like an advertisement but it is not calling the consumer to actively buy a product. Assessment Methods Students will show their understanding through the definitions that they come up with The difference between publicity and advertising will be defined here. Students should have a basic understanding of advertising from the MAM1010 class that is one of the supporting modules covered before this module. Body of Lesson (40 min.) Using a search engine (Google, Bing ect) students will find examples of 4 ads (at least 1 video and 1 print). (15mins) Students will be grouped into groups of 4 and decide who will find what type of ad. They will then analyze the ads using the “Worksheet 1” provided with this lesson plan. This document can be found on the shared Google Drive. Link: https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0BzLVDKcwhCEBa EZNVlJNdFB2YzQ&usp=sharing Through “Work Sheet 1” students will answer essential questions about the advertisements they selected. What group/company is responsible for this ad? What does the ad say about the product? Who is the target market? What is the ad trying to get you to think/buy/do? Students will upload their print and video advertisements to their Weebly sites. (25 mins) As a modification to the traditional classroom students will have longer to search for and find their selected University of Lethbridge Students will show knowledge through the ads that they choose Walking around and asking questions such as : what does this ad say to you? Was this ad targeted at you? For diapers, who are the ads targeted at? Mothers or fathers? Questions along these lines. 3 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan advertisements. Additionally students will then upload their findings to their Weebly site and will find two other students Weebly sites to comment on. Closure (10min.) Students will be encouraged to comment on the findings of other students and give constructive criticism as to whether or not they thing the student chose the right category of advertising. What did you learn today? Students will answer teacher directed questions: o What is advertising? o What are some of the methods of advertising that we talked about today? o What is the difference between advertising and publicity? PollEverywhere – Students will answer a polleverywhere poll which is structured to allow short written responses. The question will be the same as the exit slips above. Sponge Activity Have students think of their favourite products and find the ads that made them want to buy that product. Reflection Ie. Classic apple ipod ads. Ect. 3 things that worked: 3 things I might change: University of Lethbridge Through the presentation of worksheet one students will show their knowledge. Students should show a basic knowledge of the forms of advertising, print, video, possibly online for more advanced students. 4 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan 5 Work Sheet 1 – MAM2090 Advertising Advertisement Type/Company What does the ad say about the product? Who is the target market? What is the ad trying to get you to think/buy/do? University of Lethbridge Is this an effective method of advertising? Explain. Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan 6 Lesson Plan 2 Name: Mary Elizabeth Telfer Grade/Subject: Grade 11 Entrepreneurship Unit: MAM2090 – Print Advertising Topic: Types of Media Date: Length of Lesson: 52 mins Alberta Program of Studies Outcomes General Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 2. Evaluate print advertisements 4. Demonstrate basic competencies Specific Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 2.1 Provide examples that illustrate a variety of target markets for the following types of advertisements, e.g., consumer products, consumer services, business products, business services, advocacy (institutional) advertising 2.2 Describe a variety of objectives that marketers use when developing advertising campaigns 2.3 Provide specific examples of geographical promotional strategies e.g. local, regional, national, international 2.4 Identify and provide examples of various print and broadcast media and describe the advantages and disadvantages of each Students will: Select ads to show an understanding of the various types of media (print, tv, online, ect) and geographical location Distinguish between ads that are shown in different types (consumer product, service, business service, ect) and levels of advertising (geographical consideration, local, vs national) Recognize and classify the tactics and objectives that marketers use to successfully market products to their consumers Learning Objectives: Materials and Resources Teacher Resources Since this is a “Print” advertisement class, I would choose ads from local (Metro, The Calgary Herald), and National (The National Post) as well as international (People Magazine) to show the students examples. AdMongo - from the Federal Trade Commission: http://www.admongo.gov www.Calgarycoop.com www.virginmobile.ca www.covergirl.com YouTube: http://youtu.be/tOSHxSCEudY http://youtu.be/6ykhvL45th4 Learning Resources Technology Students – Students will be using photoshop and possibly a search engine to research various ad elements. If the student desires they may use another software but it must be teacher approved. Modification/ Differentiation Classroom Management Consideration s University of Lethbridge Teacher – Prezi Presentation to show the levels of advertising as well as some elements and target market elements Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan 7 Lesson Plan Procedure Introduction (5 min.) Body of Lesson (40 min.) Recap of the previous lesson Definition of advertising - Google definition: The activity or profession of producing advertisements for commercial products or services Go through 3 examples from the previous days lesson Types of advertising Brainstorm as a class what types of ads you have seen over the past 1-3 days since the last lesson. Types of Advertising (7 min) Students should have reviewed the Prezi from the class website: http://prezi.com/zyl_uggvjzl0/?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=cop y There are three main types of advertising – Print, Broadcast (radio/ TV) and Online Print advertising is what you see in magazines, billboards and in your local newspaper. Broadcast is what you see on your tv and hear on radio Online are usually interactive ads that you click on and they then bring you to a website or to a specific area of a page Levels of Advertising (7 min) This information was given to the students on the class website before, but I would like to recap and discuss what the ads were specifically. There are also three levels of advertising o Local – only advertising in one area, small businesses, single stores or local grocery stores Ex. Calgary Co-op only advertises in Calgary Spacing in this ad is limited because Coop is trying to get you to come in for as many products as possible. Radio ads for homes in Calgary o National – Advertising that is seen nation wide, but is specific to one country Ex. Specific super bowl ads are only shown in the USA Phone Companies use online ads to bring you to the correct page for you depending on your province Banner ads give you just enough information to want to click on them to find more, usually less is more for a banner ad. o International – Advertising that is seen world wide Cover Girl / Rimmel– makeup campaigns that are seen world wide A model as well as the product show how the product looks, as well as the packaging that it comes in . Make up ads effectively use white space to not distract from the colours of the University of Lethbridge Assessment Methods Recall questions “What is an advertisement ” Class discussion The class assignment is a formative assessment to prepare students for their “final” assignment of creating an ad for the product that they are marketing through the entrepreneursh ip class. This assignment will use the same rubric, but will be a constructive critique Students will also assess their peers using the 2 stars and a wish discussions after the presentations Presentations are meeting the GLO of demonstrating basic competencies. Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan make up it self as well as it is a good background to make bright make up colours POP off the page. DISCUSSION QUESTION: Using the ads that we brainstormed earlier in the class, what categories do these ads fall into? Students should have reviewed the various design elements that they learned about in COM 1005. The link to the COM 1005 webpage is on the Class Website and here: http://msmaryelizabethtelfer.weebly.com/comm-1005---visualcomposition.html Students will watch the following videos to prepare for todays class discussion/ “work period”. Youtube Clip – What makes a good ad?(3 mins) http://youtu.be/tOSHxSCEudY Speaking on other aspects of advertising that students should think about when creating an ad. http://youtu.be/6ykhvL45th4 (7 mins) Target Audience (7 min) Who are you selling to ? Consumers o Are baby diapers targeted to babies? No they are geared towards parents so they play on the emotions of the parents Showing a smiling baby o Apple ads Play on status, the best iPhone yet, best iOS ever, ect. Elite, clean ads. Business to Business ads o Photo copier ads – lots of information, not a lot of pictures, need to know the details o Supply stores – ads featuring discounts Advocacy ads o Government ads Canadian Government ads – Upgrading road signs Be sure to make note of the girl saying that in Ireland they don’t have cars, but she still thought the ad was funny. In Europe most people do not drive. (knowing your target market) Creativity, humor, bright colours ect. Students will now receive their scenarios and the rubric for the assignment for which they will be creating an ad for. If there is time at the end of this class students will brainstorm with others who have the same scenario before they begin working on their ad. If not they will have time to do it the next class. University of Lethbridge 8 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Closure (10min.) Students will work until about 3 minutes before the bell. At this time they will log out, and fill out their exit slips. Exit poll questions: What scenario did you get? What target market are you thinking of marketing towards? What type of ad are you thinking of using? Reflection 3 things that worked: 3 things I might change: University of Lethbridge 9 Exit slips are used to gain understanding for the teacher so that if anyone were to be very off the mark you could check in with them in the first few minutes of the next class. Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan 10 Scenarios 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. You are a new company providing a mat cleaning service to businesses around Calgary. You are a pen manufacture, specializing in personalized pens that can be printed with any logo or company name on them. They are also great gifts for wedding favours or for school spirit sales. You are a local apple farm located near Airdrie. Your customers come pick their own apples. You are a sneaker manufactuer. Your shoes are a hit with younger kids and come in sizes 5 (small kids) to 6 (big kids, almost adults) You are a toy manufacture specializing in Lego type blocks. You are a new computer company specializing in personal computers for home use. Your ad must contain: A photo of your product (1 mark) 2 types of font (serif and sans serif) (2 marks) 2 different font sizes (2 marks) 3 different features of your product (3 marks) Total (8 marks) Be creative with this assignment. Think of who your target market is and what would draw that consumer in and make them what to buy your product. What are the features of your product? Make sure you use the elements of design that you learned about in COM 1005 to enhance your advertisement. University of Lethbridge Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Lesson Plan 3/4 Name: Mary Elizabeth Telfer Grade/Subject: Grade 11 Entrepreneurship Unit: MAM2090 – Print Advertising Topic: Class Work Period Date: Length of Lesson: 52 mins Alberta Program of Studies Outcomes General Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 2. Evaluate print advertisements 4. Demonstrate basic competencies Specific Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 2.1 Provide examples that illustrate a variety of target markets for the following types of advertisements, e.g., consumer products, consumer services, business products, business services, advocacy (institutional) advertising 2.2 Describe a variety of objectives that marketers use when developing advertising campaigns 2.3 Provide specific examples of geographical promotional strategies e.g. local, regional, national, international 2.4 Identify and provide examples of various print and broadcast media and describe the advantages and disadvantages of each Students will: Select ads to show an understanding of the various types of media (print, tv, online, ect) and geographical location Distinguish between ads that are shown in different types (consumer product, service, business service, ect) and levels of advertising (geographical consideration, local, vs national) Recognize and classify the tactics and objectives that marketers use to successfully market products to their consumers Learning Objectives: Materials and Resources Teacher Resources Learning Resources Scenarios – cut up Rubric (version 1) AdMongo - from the Federal Trade Commission: http://www.admongo.gov www.Calgarycoop.com www.virginmobile.ca www.covergirl.com YouTube: http://youtu.be/tOSHxSCE udY http://youtu.be/6ykhvL45th4 Technology Students – Students will be using photoshop and possibly a search engine to research various ad elements. If the student desires they may use another software but it must be teacher approved. Modification/ Differentiation Classroom Management Considerations Lesson Plan Procedure Introduction (10 min.) Recap of Last Class Types of Advertising There are three main types of advertising – Print, Broadcast (radio/ TV) and Online Print advertising is what you see in magazines, billboards and in your local newspaper. Broadcast is what you see on your tv and hear on radio Online are usually interactive ads that you click on and they then bring you to a website or to a specific area of a page Levels of Advertising There are also three levels of advertising o Local – only advertising in one area, small businesses, single stores or local grocery stores o National – Advertising that is seen nation wide, but is specific to one country o International – Advertising that is seen world wide Target Audience Who are you selling to ? Consumers University of Lethbridge Assessment Methods Recall Questioning 11 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Business to Business ads Advocacy ads Effective Advertising Strategies (Videos) Colour, humor, using bold fonts, call to action, creativity Students will have access to all videos and presentations given in class through moodle or a class website. Body of Lesson (35 min.) Class Assignment Students will group themselves with the people who have the same scenario as them Students will have to create a PRINT ad for that scenario and provide a 1 minute presentation about their product, their target market and what level of advertising this would be rolled out as. Students will use Photoshop (or another electronic medium) to create their ads, and each student will create their own ad using elements discussed in the group time. Students will be creating ads for their scenarios given to them last class. I will walk around helping students when need it. This assignment is meant to be a formative assessment, on the students understanding of basic print ad elements. Although it does have some marks assigned with it for guidance, it will only be worth 5 %, It is also designed to give them a chance to work with photoshop which they may not have at home. Students in this class will have taken the COM 1005 which is standard for any computer lab classes in many high schools (At least in Calgary or Lethbridge). COM 1005 is a basic comm tech course that goes through the basics of photoshop, premier and other digital software that gives students a basic understanding of these technologies so they can be used in an effective way in other classes. It is assumed for this module that students have taken COM 1005, and other INFO Pro classes to prepare them for this business course and that students are in the grade 11/12 range. Students will have 2 class to complete this assignment and 1 class to present their advertisements. Being that technology or CTS courses are usually seen as “options” it has been my experience that many students will not complete their assigned tasks as home work in a CTS computer/business course. In this case I am assigning students to use Photoshop which many of them will not have a home so ample time is given in order to ensure that students are able to create and present their work before the final assignment is taken in for marks. Once the students are finished they will upload their advertisements to their Weebly web blog. They will also present their advertisements to the class. Closure (2 min.) Exit Poll What elements of advertising are you using to entice your target market? Sponge Activity Reflection Students who finish their ads early will be able to crate a second ad with either a second scenario (traded with another group) or create a different level of ad (local vs. national). 3 things that worked: 3 things I might change: University of Lethbridge 12 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Advertising Rubric (Scenarios Version 1) After the presentation please assign marks to the group using the rubric listed below. Creativity: Colour, well designed ads, effort. The ads were well developed and displayed a high degree of creativity and understanding of the target market. The ads were well laid out and appeared organised and clear. Creativity was present but not exemplary. 8 Points 7 – 8 points 5 – 6 Points The ads were either plain or lacking essential target market elements to draw in the specified market. Elements appear to be inconsistent. 3 – 4 Points Presentation There were only one or to word whiskers (um, uh, well…). The students spoke well and clearly. 8 Points There were at least three word whiskers. The presenters tapered off or did not consistently speak clearly to the audience. There were many word whiskers. The presenters were inconsistent in there voice. They were unheard in spots. 5 – 6 Points 3 – 4 Points There was a degree of effort and thought put into the ad. The ads showed an understanding of relevant advertising strategies. The pitch was generally clear and could be explained to the audience with some assistance from the presenters. The ads show an attempt at advertising strategies. 7 – 8 points Effectiveness: Ads integrated clearly defined advertising strategies / techniques 8 Points Clearly identified market (market segmentation) well thought through idea directed at target consumer. 8 Points The ad shows a high degree of sophistication in terms of advertising strategies. The idea / pitch is clear / simple and imaginative. They presented the 7 – 8 Points Ad demonstrated that they knew exactly who their customers will be and what would draw their specific consumer in to buy the product 7-8 points 5 – 6 Points Ad demonstrated elements of who the customer maybe but was lacking a strong hook to pull the consumer in. The ads were incomplete or lacked essential advertising elements at all. The ad was thin in terms of detail offered and lacked imagination. 1 – 2 Points There were frequent and repeated word whiskers. The presenters seemed to stumble though the presentation and little organisation. Their voices were too soft to be heard more than once 1 – 2 Points The ads show little or no clear marketing / advertising strategies.. 1 – 2 Points 3 – 4 Points Ad showed an attempt to define the targeted consumer but it was hidden or not strongly presented The ads did not identify a clear market / customers. They were unsure of what they were selling or how it was to be marketed 3- 4 points 1-2 Points 5-6 points University of Lethbridge 13 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Being that this is a CTS course and it would be made up of 5 modules I would take the time now to move on to another module, either direct marketing or possibly business planning. The overview of this course was to be a Entrepreneurship course so the students would work through a variety of CTS courses that would be essential to running a business. At this time the students would begin the planning of their business, choose a product, and then revisit the topic of print advertising at the end of the class. I like the flexibility of the CTS courses and the fact that a lot of their outcomes do overlap so it allows you to structure the class in a unique way, such as I have done. University of Lethbridge 14 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Lesson Plan 5 Name: Mary Elizabeth Telfer Grade/Subject: Grade 11 Entreprenuership Unit: MAM2090 – Print Advertising Topic: FINAL ASSIGNMENT Class Date: Length of Lesson: 52 mins Alberta Program of Studies Outcomes General Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 3. Design and create an effective print advertisement 4. Demonstrate basic competencies Specific Learning Outcomes (P.O.S.) 3.1 Explain the steps in planning a print advertisement including: 3.1.1 determining the form of print media; eg billboard, flyer, poster 3.1.2 state the objectives 3.1.3 define the target audience 3.1.4 select the buying motive eg. Use of unique selling proposition (USP) 3.2Demonstrate the use of effective layout arrangements such as: 3.2.1 use of borders 3.2.2 use of white space 3.2.3 use of different fonts 3.2.4 placement of various components Students will: Demonstrate their understand of essential print ad elements through a final assignment which is an ad for the specific product that the class has chosen Prepare a written document to accompany their ad detailing thetarget market, essential elements they used as well as Learning Objectives: Materials and Resources Teacher Resources Assignment sheet Rubric (version 2) Teaching Strategies Learning Resources Modification/ Differentiation Classroom Management Considerations Lesson Plan Procedure Introduction (5 min.) Body of Lesson (35 min.) Recap of last class Hand back advertisements with critiques This was a formative assessment to ensure that students are aware of the levels of advertising, the target market, how to create an effective ad using font, size, colour, images ect. Introduce final assignment See final assignment sheet and rubric. Students will have 2 full classes to create an ad that reflects the product that they have chosen for their overall entrepreneurship class. Each student will have their ad printed and displayed around the school as part of the marketing plan for the product. Students are not required to present this assignment as it is a final assignment and will be used in the marketing for the product that has been chosen by the class for their product to sell. Students who are head or need a challenge in the class will be asked to make a video commercial using the same parameters of the rubric for the print ad. This is only for students who are advanced in the software and marketing aspects of this class o I have this in this particular lesson because when I taught at LCI there was a group of students who were advanced in their studies and an assignment like this would have been boring for them and this could create class room management issues. o To combat this, these students were asked to make videos or websites while others were University of Lethbridge Assessment Methods Recall Questioning 15 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan working on photoshop to challenge them in a way that could still be related to the class subject. Closure (5min.) Exit Poll What is your main “hook” for your advertisement to grab the attention of students in the school? Sponge Activity Reflection 3 things that worked: 3 things I might change: University of Lethbridge 16 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Final Print Advertising Assignment Assignment: You are tasked to create one (1) print ad for the product that was chosen by the class to be sold this year in the school “store”. Your ad will be targeted to our school (adolescents 15 – 18 years old). Your ad must have An image of the product 2 fonts (possibly in different sizes) 1 heading A description of the product The price of the product A creative use of colour It must fit on a standard piece of paper (8 ½ x 11) Accompanying your ad you must also write a short explanation of why you chose the elements that you did (use of colour, font size, image placing ect.). You must also in detail describe your target market and relate how your elements used in your ad will draw that target market into buying your product. You will use photoshop to create this ad and may use inspiration from outside of this classroom to help your creativity. Any images used from the internet must be sourced in your written document. You will be graded using the same rubric as the scenario assignment, but instead of being graded on your presentation in front of the class you will be graded on your written communication document. University of Lethbridge 17 Mary Elizabeth Telfer MAM 2090 Module Plan Advertising Rubric (Version 2) After the presentation please assign marks to the group using the rubric listed below. Creativity: Colour, well designed ads, effort. The ads were well developed and displayed a high degree of creativity and understanding of the target market. The ads were well laid out and appeared organised and clear. Creativity was present but not exemplary. 8 Points 7 – 8 points 5 – 6 Points The ads were either plain or lacking essential target market elements to draw in the specified market. Elements appear to be inconsistent. 3 – 4 Points Written Document 8 Points Effectiveness: Ads integrated clearly defined advertising strategies / techniques 8 Points Clearly identified market (market segmentation) well thought through idea directed at target consumer. 8 Points Document clearly stated the target market and effectively explained why the elements were used as they were. There were little to no grammatical or spelling errors 7 – 8 points The ad shows a high degree of sophistication in terms of advertising strategies. The idea / pitch is clear / simple and imaginative. They presented the 7 – 8 Points Ad demonstrated that they knew exactly who their customers will be and what would draw their specific consumer in to buy the product The ideas were stated but not effectively explained. There were few spelling and grammatical errors. The ideas behind the ad were stated were lacking explanation or reasoning. Many spelling errors. 5 – 6 Points 3 – 4 Points There was a degree of effort and thought put into the ad. The ads showed an understanding of relevant advertising strategies. The pitch was generally clear and could be explained to the audience with some assistance from the presenters. 5 – 6 Points Ad demonstrated elements of who the customer maybe but was lacking a strong hook to pull the consumer in. The ads show an attempt at advertising strategies. The ads were incomplete or lacked essential advertising elements at all. The ad was thin in terms of detail offered and lacked imagination. 1 – 2 Points The document was a simple list, the ideas were stated but not explained at all. The was incomplete. 1 – 2 Points The ads show little or no clear marketing / advertising strategies.. 1 – 2 Points 3 – 4 Points Ad showed an attempt to define the targeted consumer but it was hidden or not strongly presented The ads did not identify a clear market / customers. They were unsure of what they were selling or how it was to be marketed 3- 4 points 1-2 Points 5-6 points 7-8 points University of Lethbridge 18