Name: Hour: AP American Government Unit 2 Assignments: Ch. 4 American Political Culture Ch. 7 Public Opinion Ch. 8 Political Participation 1 Chapter 4 (all) and 7 (158-end) overview: Political Beliefs and Behavior Vocabulary Political Culture Civic duty Civic competence Class consciousness Orthodox Progressive Political efficacy Internal efficacy External efficacy Political socialization Elite Gender gap Political ideology Political elites Chapter 4 1. What did Alexis de Tocqueville say about the United States? 2. Analyze American political culture. 3. Explain how Americans view the political system using the five italicized words on 77. 2 4. Since we have a common political culture, how does the author explain that we do things inconsistent with this culture? 5. Also, since we have a common political culture- why do we fight with each other? 6. Make a list of attributes to describe the American view of our economic system. 7. Fill in the table below to compare the political culture (political system, economic system and the civic role of religion) of the United States with other countries. You will have a lot in the US column, so write small!! The United States Sweden Japan Great Britain 8. How has religion been intertwined in American politics? 3 9. Where does American political culture come from? (page 84-86) 10. Below the terms “orthodox” and “progressive,” list where each stands on the issues as explained on pages 86-87. Orthodox Progressive 11. Analyze how each event below altered American faith in their government. A. Nixon resignation B. Clinton impeachment C. Eisenhower administration 4 D. 1960s and 1970s E. 9/11 12. Explain what political efficacy is and give examples. 13. Summarize the section on political tolerance. Why do you think this is an important aspect of American democracy? Chapter 7 (starting at page 158) 1. Define political socialization in your own words and then describe the ways Americans are socialized. a. family b. religion c. gender d. school/media 5 2. Explain what it means to have a cleavage in public opinion. 3. List some common political cleavages in the United States. 4. Compare and contrast the cleavage of social class in America with that of race and ethnicity. 5. Describe how region impacts political attitudes and cultures. 6. What is political ideology? How do we use it? 7. Explain the difference between a “liberal” and a “conservative” according to your book. 8. Explain what each of the following terms mean. a. Pure liberal b. Pure conservative 6 c. Libertarian d. Populists 9. What is a political elite? Who would be included in this group? 10. Summarize the section: Political Elites, Public Opinion and Public Policy 7 Practice Qs: The following Qs will look very similar to the Qs you’ll see on your quiz. See how you do! 1. Which of the following statements about the U.S. democratic republic is correct? a. It has never been tried elsewhere. b. It thrived in the United States despite the existence of a feudal aristocracy. c. It thrived in the United States despite the large number of legal restraints on it. d. It emphasizes social equality over personal liberty. e. It has been tried without great success by many other countries. 2. The text argues that the democratic political culture of Sweden differs from that of the United States because the Swedes a. integrate religion more successfully into their politics. b. insist on greater citizen participation in government. c. allow greater economic inequalities to exist. d. resist tendencies toward socialism. e. are more deferential than participatory in their politics. 3. Which of the following most accurately describes the orthodox view in the culture war? a. Morality is more important than self-expression and is based on unchanging rules from God. b. Personal freedom is more important than tradition, and the rules for morality vary with circumstances. c. Morality is more important than self-expression, and the rules vary with circumstances. d. Personal freedom is more important than tradition, and morality is based on unchanging rules from God. e. Morality is irrelevant to personal freedom, even when there are objective standards by which to judge. 4. A majority agrees that a moment of silence should be allowed in public schools if one examines the opinions of a. the general public. b. Catholics. c. Evangelicals. d. Jews. e. a, b, and c. 5. Which of the following statements is incorrect? a. From the mid-1920s to the mid-1960s, Americans went to college in record numbers. b. Much research indicates higher levels of liberalism are associated with higher levels of education. c. Higher levels of conservatism were more prominent among those from more prestigious colleges. d. Increased schooling has been associated with increased voting. e. Increased schooling has been associated with increased political activity. Answers: 1-E, 2-E, 3-A, 4-E, 5-C 8 QW: What is a political ideology? Why do you think ideology is so important in politics? Can they be misleading? Using your book, “Philosophical Differences,” class set of article on philosophies and Kaplan handout, fill out chart (4 total resources-not located in this packet). X=do not fill out this box. Ideology Textbook definition “Power and Choice” Classic liberalism Economic: Kaplan handout X Philosophical Differences Modern liberals: Social: American liberalism Economic: Social: Communism Economic: X X Social: Socialism Economic: X Social: Fascism Economic: X X X Social: Libertarianism Economic: X Social: Populism Economic: X Social: American conservatism Economic: Social: Classic conservatism Economic: Modern conservatives: X Social: Review QW: 9 Describe a typical American liberal (democrat): Describe a typical American conservative (republican): The Political Spectrum Power Point notes: Details, details, details The olden days John Locke, Adam Smith, Thomas Paine Classic liberalism: Born out of ____________________ Freedom and liberty ____________________________________________ Live to our fullest potential People are responsible for their own actions Little to no government involvement Think: _______________________________________ Early in republic: local control, independence Socialism Eugene Debs People aren’t individuals: ________________________ Responding to liberalism and the industrial revolution Oppressed workers are being ______________________ Government, controlled by workers, can control the economy, education _________________________________ Socialist-democracy Communism Socialism plus revolutionary Edmund Burke, Herbert Spencer Classic Conservatism: Responded to revolution Save _____________________________________ Support the state, the lower classes, aristocracy ____________________________________________ People should work as a group Order, common values, stable Powerful help the weak Unfamiliar to Americans!! ____________________________________________ Early in the republic: wanted a more centralized system Fascism _________________________________________ racism, nationalism Right wing? Large military Anti- intellectual State controls private industry (___________________) War based American political spectrum: Social Left (liberal) less government Social Right (conservative) more government Economic left (liberal) more government Economic right (conservative) less government American views Both are born out of classic liberalism 10 American Liberals (Democrats) • ___________________________ (liberal in economic and social policies) • Lots of ____________ • Lots of ____________ • Help EVERYONE • More economic equality • “People are good”? Stay out of social stuff? Young, college educated, nonreligious History: Democratic Party Began: local (Jefferson- Democratic Republicans) (small gov) Civil War: Supported States’ rights Adopted Populist sentiments (more government…) Progressivism New Deal (big gov) Civil Rights Act __________________________ American Conservatives (Republicans) • _________________________________ (conservative on economic and social policies) • Low taxes (keep what you earn) • People should ___________________ • Free market • ______________________________ • ”People are born bad”? Involved in social stuff? Older, white, higher incomes, Midwest History: Republican Party Began: national (Federalists, whigs) (big gov) Civil War: Supported national agenda Dixiecrats (shifting of the South) (small gov, more moral intervention) Barry Goldwater (1964) Conservative coalition Against the _______________________ Devolution Reagan’s policies Moral Majority Populism Liberal on economic matters Conservative on social matters United States based More likely to be: older, poorly educated, low income, religious, South or Midwest Libertarianism Conservative on economic matters Liberal on social matters Small, weak government Ideal republic: Freedom Privacy and free speech More likely to be: young, college educated, white, higher incomes, less religion, West AP Government Spectrum Assignment You, with others, are asked to do the following: Choose an issue from the list below (These are issues that society tries to deal with, but has conflicting viewpoints about how it should be handled…for example: abortion). Two people in the group will represent American conservatives, and the others will represent American liberals. (or one conservative and one liberal) Using your issue, create a skit or a debate that shows what each ideology would say about your issue (use attached notes for details). Create a script about what you will each say…one/group. Come and present your skit to the class. You may use your script, but you will hand it in when finished. You will earn 5 points individually for addressing your ideology and for participating. Extra points for creativity and flair. As others present, you will listen, and mark on your attached notes where you stand on the issue (comes in handy later). You can star/circle the side that you tend to be on for EACH issue presented. 11 My issue is_______________________________ Very important note-not every conservative or liberal fit perfectly into their “category”. We are all individuals with slightly different versions of the ideas listed below. Issue American Liberal beliefs/attitudes American Conservative beliefs/attitudes A fetus is not a human life. Human life begins at conception. Abortion is the murder of Abortion The decision to have an abortion is a personal choice of a woman regarding her own body and the government should stay out of it. Women should be guaranteed the right to a safe and legal abortion, including partial birth abortion. Affirmative Action Death Penalty The Economy The Environment Gun Control Healthcare Due to prevalent racism in the past, minorities were deprived of the same education and employment opportunities as whites. We need to make up for that. Support affirmative action based on the belief that America is still a racist society. Minorities still lag behind whites in all statistical measurements of success. Also, the presence of minorities creates diversity. We should abolish the death penalty. The death penalty is inhumane and is ‘cruel and unusual' punishment. It does not deter crime. Imprisonment is the appropriate punishment. Every execution risks killing an innocent person. Favor a market system in which government regulates the economy. We need government to protect us against big businesses. Unlike the private sector, the government is motivated by public interest. We need government regulation to level the playing field. a human being. Nobody has the right to murder a human being. Support legislation to prohibit partial birth abortions, called the "Partial Birth Abortion Ban" (partial birth abortion - the killing of an unborn baby of at least 20 weeks by pulling it out of the birth canal with forceps, but leaving the head inside. An incision is made in the back of the baby's neck and the brain tissue is suctioned out. The head is then removed from the uterus.) People should be admitted to schools and hired for jobs based on their ability. It is unfair to use race as a factor in the selection process. Reverse-discrimination is not a solution for racism. The death penalty is a punishment that fits the crime; it is neither ‘cruel' nor ‘unusual'. Executing a murderer is the appropriate punishment for taking an innocent life. The free market system, competitive capitalism, and private enterprise afford the widest opportunity and the highest standard of living for all. Free markets produce more economic growth, more jobs and higher standards of living than those systems burdened by excessive government regulation. Conservatives don't care about protecting the environment. Industrial growth harms the environment. Desire clean water, clean air and a clean planet, just like everyone else. However, extreme environmental policies destroy jobs and damage the economy. Global warming is caused by an increased production of carbon dioxide. The U.S. is a major contributor to global warming because it produces 25% of the world's carbon dioxide. The U.S. should enact laws to significantly reduce that amount. The Second Amendment gives no individual the right to own a gun, but allows the state to keep a militia (National Guard). Guns kill people. Guns kill children. Support universal government-supervised health care. There are millions of Americans who can't afford health insurance. They are being deprived of a basic right to healthcare. Changes in global temperatures are natural over long periods of time. So far, science has not shown that humans can affect permanent change to the earth's temperature. The Second Amendment gives the individual the right to keep and bear arms. Gun control laws do not thwart criminals. You have a right to defend yourself against criminals. More guns mean less crime. Free healthcare provided by the government (socialized medicine) means that everyone will get the same poorquality healthcare. The rich will continue to pay for superior healthcare, while all others will receive poor-quality free healthcare from the government. Health care should remain privatized. Support Healthcare Spending Accounts. 12 Immigration Support legal immigration and increasing the number of legal immigrants permitted to enter the U.S. each year. Support blanket amnesty for current illegal immigrants. Believe that regardless of how they came to the U.S., illegal immigrants deserve: - U.S. government financial aid for college tuition. - visas for spouse/children to come to the U.S. Families shouldn't be separated. Religion Illegal immigrants do the jobs that Americans do not want to do. Support the separation of church and state. Religious expression has no place in government. Support the removal of all references to God in public and government spaces. Support legal immigration at current numbers, but do not support illegal immigration. Government should enforce immigration laws. Oppose President Bush's amnesty plan for illegal immigrants. Those who break the law by entering the U.S. illegally should not have the same rights as those who obey the law by entering legally. If there were a decrease in cheap, illegal immigrant labor, employers would have to substitute higher-priced domestic employees, legal immigrants, or perhaps increase mechanization. The phrase "separation of church and state" is not in the Constitution. The First Amendment to the Constitution states "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." This prevents the government from establishing a national church. However, it does not prevent God from being acknowledged in schools and government buildings. Religion should not interfere with government. Oppose the removal of symbols of Christian heritage from public and government spaces. Same-sex marriage Marriage should be legal for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender couples to ensure equal rights for all. All individuals, regardless of their sex, have the right to marry. Taxes United Nations (UN) War on terror/terrori sm Welfare Believe that prohibiting same-sex citizens from marrying denies them of their civil rights. Opinions differ on whether this issue is equal to civil rights for African Americans. Support higher taxes and a larger government. High taxes enable the government to do good and create jobs. We need high taxes for social welfare programs, to provide for the poor. We can't afford to cut taxes. The United States has a moral and a legal obligation to support the United Nations (UN). The UN can be effective in promoting peace and human rights. The U.S. should not have acted in Iraq without UN approval. The U.S. should submit its national interests to the greater good (as defined by the UN). 9/11 was caused by America's arrogant foreign policy. America needs to stop angering other countries. The threat posed by terrorism was exaggerated by President Bush for his own political advantage. Support welfare. We need welfare to provide for the poor. Conservatives oppose welfare because they Government should not interfere with religion and religious freedom. Marriage is between one man and one woman. Opinions differ on support for the creation of a constitutional amendment establishing marriage as the union of one man and one woman. Believe that requiring citizens to sanction same-sex relationships violates moral and religious beliefs of millions of Christians, Jews, Muslims and others who believe marriage is the union of a man and a woman. Support lower taxes and a smaller government. Lower taxes create more incentive for people to work, save, invest, and engage in entrepreneurial endeavors. Money is best spent by those who earn it. The UN has repeatedly failed in its essential mission: to preserve world peace. The wars, genocide and human rights abuses of the majority of its member states (and the UN's failure to stop them) prove this point. History shows that the United States, not the UN, is the global force for spreading freedom, prosperity, tolerance and peace. The U.S. should never subvert its national interests to those of the UN. The world toward which the Militant Islamists strive cannot peacefully co-exist with the Western world. In the last decade, Militant Islamists have repeatedly attacked Americans and American interests here and abroad. The terrorists must be stopped and destroyed. Oppose long-term welfare. We need to provide opportunities to make it possible for poor and low-income workers to 13 are not compassionate toward the poor. We have welfare to bring fairness to American economic life. Without welfare, life below the poverty line would be intolerable. become self-reliant. It is far more compassionate and effective to encourage a person to become self-reliant, rather than keeping them dependent on the government for money. Copyright 2005 StudentNewsDaily.com Political Culture Reading Read Shively Qs 161-168: Answer these Qs below. (This reading is NOT found in this packet) 1. What is political culture according to Shively? 2. Why is it difficult to describe a country’s political culture? 3. Why does political culture change slowly? 4. How is the US different from Europe? 5. What role does religion play in US political culture? 6. Define political socialization. 7. How are people socialized? 8. What do we learn from parents? School? Peer groups? 14 Chapter 7 (pgs. 155-158) and chapter 8 (all) overview: Public Opinion and political Participation Vocabulary Public opinion Poll Random sample Sampling error Exit polls Voting Age population Registered voters Literacy test Poll tax Grandfather clause White primary Australian ballot Activists Chapter 7 1. Give some of the examples the book lists as to ways the government does not always act “for the people, by the people”. 2. Why is there this difference between what the people want and what the government does? 3. Analyze the role of public opinion in a democracy such as ours. 15 4. What have public opinions historically shown about Americans? 5. List and explain the steps in the polling process. 6. Use the following example to explain the importance of the margin of error/ sampling error: “Barack Obama leads Mitt Romney in polls, 47% to 42 %” (Margin of Error =/- 5%) 7. Compare and contrast: opinion saliency, opinion stability and opinion policy congruence. Chapter 8: Political Participation A Closer Look at Non-voting…. 1. What is the difference between a Voting Age population and a Voting Eligible population? 2. List some of the reasons that voter turnout in America is low. Why do you think Americans don’t vote in very high numbers? 3. Explain the Motor Voter law. Do you think it has helped with voter turnout? 16 4. How do people participate in politics BESIDES voting? The Rise of the American Electorate… 5. Using this section, explain how the states have used their power to run elections in the past. Include how the federal government has also tried to influence the election process. 6. In the space below, put at least 10 dates on the timeline that you feel are important regarding the history of voting in this country. 1800 1900 2000 7. Analyze the data given on page 183. What trends do you notice? 17 8. List the requirements to vote in most US states. Do you think there should be more or less requirements? Why or why not? 9. What are the two main reasons scholars think voter turnout has declined? (use pages 184-186 to answer this!!) 10. How did the Australian ballot change elections? 11. What is an argument that universal voter turnout might not be the best thing? Who Participates in Politics…. 12. Describe each of the following: a. Inactive citizens b. Activists c. Voting specialists d. Campaigners e. Communalists f. Parochial participants 18 13. Explain how each of the following impacts the way people vote. a. Education b. Religion c. Gender d. Age e. Income (pg 191) 14. Pages 189-190 list 5 more reasons people don’t vote. List them and then pick the one you think is most responsible for low voter turnout. 15. Read and summarize the section “the Meaning of Participation Rates”. Practice Qs: The following Qs will look very similar to the Qs you’ll see on your quiz. See how you do! 1. Only rarely, argues the text, does the general public have which of the following? a. A dominant opinion on an issue b. A chance to learn and examine the facts about an issue c. The opportunity to obtain formal power d. Problems with official decisions on issues e. The will to exercise power 2. One reason why public policy often differs from public opinion is that a. The U.S. Constitution places many checks on the influence of public opinion. b. public opinion polling tends to express the opinions of the political elite. c. public opinion is easy to gauge, while the effectiveness of public policy is not. d. public opinion tends to change much more slowly than public policy. e. public opinion is rarely informed at the beginning of the policy making process. 19 3. In U.S. presidential elections, voter turnout is typically a. less than 25 percent. b. less than 30 percent. c. less than 60 percent. d. more than 80 percent. e. nearly 100 percent. 4. Which of the following statements about the right to vote in the United States is correct? a. Not every U.S. citizen of voting age is allowed to vote. b. The original U.S. Constitution ensured women the right to vote. c. In 1880 a higher percentage of British than Americans could vote. d. The original U.S. Constitution specifically prohibited setting property restrictions on the right to vote. e. The states originally had little say as to who could and could not vote. 5. One explanation given by the text for the decline in U.S. voter participation in presidential elections after 1900 is that a. parties began functioning to mobilize mass voter turnout. b. fewer citizens were directly affected by the outcome of presidential elections. c. other forms of political participation became less accessible to citizens. d. election fraud was rampant in the nineteenth century. e. the Republican party began to attempt to mobilize individuals who were least likely to vote. Answers: 1-A, 2-A, 3-C, 4-A, 5-D Ideology, culture and socialization PP review notes How did we get this way? Ideology o Set of beliefs o Way to compare people politically o Not etched in stone o Left, right, social, economic o The role of the gov! Let’s review… Democrats (left wing, American liberals) Universal/gov healthcare More taxes/more programs Pro-choice More $ for the environment Increase minimum wage 20 Support social security Republicans (right wing, American conservatives) Private healthcare Fewer taxes, private enterprise Pro-life More $ for military/ research Let states/businesses decide on minimum wage Privatize social security What will AP ask? Unless specified, if AP asks about liberals and conservatives, assume they are referring to AMERICAN liberals and conservatives, both born out of ideals of liberty. Ideology can be seen in culture Economic and Political equality? Idea of liberty Political equality All about liberty Assertive, confident: religion, patriotism, capitalism, individualism High political efficacy comparatively General distrust in politics since the 60s More tolerant Socialization The process by which people acquire political values and attitudes Family Religion Gender Schooling Social Class Race and ethnicity Region Family Religion 21 The Gender Gap Men increasingly Republican Women remain unchanged Issues: – Gun control (women strongly for) – Spending on programs for the poor (somewhat for) – Gay marriage (less likely to strongly oppose) – Death penalty (women strongly against) Pg. 161 Schooling and Information Differences: social class We are all middle class? Blue vs. white collar Class voting has declined sharply Unskilled workers are more likely to vote Democrat Wealthy more likely to vote Race and Ethnicity Age Region Typical voters? Democrats: Republicans: Just remember…. we are ALL “middle class moderates” according to ourselves… 22 Polls: the measuring stick of modern politics By Eric Pryne Seattle Times staff reporter In 1936 Literary Digest magazine, citing its own poll, boldly predicted that Republican Alf Landon would defeat President Franklin D. Roosevelt. FDR, of course, was re-elected by a landslide. Oops. Literary Digest is long dead. Polls, still in their infancy in 1936, are thriving. It's hard to imagine modern American politics without them. The concept behind polling is simple: ask a question of a representative sample of the population, and you should get a pretty accurate sense of what the country as a whole is thinking. Candidates use polls to monitor how their campaigns are faring, and to find out which buttons they might push to win your vote. The news media conduct polls to find out what's on voters' minds, and to track the "horse race." Polls are controversial. Some people say they discourage good potential candidates with low name familiarity from running for office. Others say polls help obscure differences between candidates: they all read the polls and tailor their pitches accordingly. Others say polls may measure public opinion, but often don't measure the intensity of that opinion. And of course nobody knows how much those responding have thought about the candidate or issue. Reading polls intelligently Public-opinion researchers know much more about how to conduct a poll now than they did when the Literary Digest staged its spectacular bellyflop. Still, polls are imperfect tools, subject to manipulation and misinterpretation. Here are some questions you should ask whenever you're looking at poll results. Red flags should go up if the people behind the polls don't provide the answers. 1. Who sponsored the poll? Special-interest groups love to commission and release polls that support their points of view. If the National Rifle Association sponsors a poll that shows most Americans want to keep assault weapons under their beds, or if the Sierra Club sponsors a poll that shows people want the spotted owl to replace the bald eagle as the nation's symbol, you might well question the survey's objectivity. 2. How big was the sample? Obviously, it's impossible to poll every voter. But it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that the more people you poll, the more likely you are to obtain results that reflect the attitudes of the population as a whole. How far from reality the poll results can be expected to be is called the margin of error. The larger the sample polled, the smaller the margin. For example, 570 Washingtonians responded to a statewide Seattle Times/Front Porch Forum in April 1996, and 18 percent said they were very concerned about keeping their jobs. Statisticians calculate that the margin of error for a sample that size is 4 percentage points. That means that if every adult in the state were questioned, 23 between 14 and 22 percent would say they are very concerned about job security. A smaller sample would have a larger margin of error. 3. Who was sampled? Good pollsters strive for randomness. Theoretically, every person in the target population should have an equal chance of being surveyed. That's where the Literary Digest poll fell short. The magazine surveyed only owners of automobiles and telephones; in 1936, many poorer voters owned neither. So wealthier voters were over-represented in the sample, and the poll results were skewed. Today many pollsters dial phone numbers at random, so people with unlisted numbers will have as much chance of being sampled as people listed in phone books. 4. What methodology was used? Polls can be conducted in person, by telephone or by mail. Mail surveys, often employed by politicians to gauge voter opinion on issues, are the least accurate; the people who take the time to return the survey forms usually aren't a representative sample of all the people who receive them. 5. When was the poll conducted? Voters change their minds; an old poll may not reflect new developments or current attitudes. Pollsters expect a "bump" in a candidate's standing, for instance, at the end of a national convention with all its positive coverage. Pollsters incorrectly predicted Thomas Dewey would defeat President Harry Truman in 1948 partly because they didn't poll close enough to election day. 6. What was the exact wording of the question? Leading questions can produce biased results: An example: "For president, are you leaning toward voting for war hero Bob Dole, or that dope-smoking draft-dodger Bill Clinton?" Bias rarely is that obvious. Still, a look at the precise wording of a question allows you to make up your own mind. Some poll questions ask respondents to choose from a limited number of responses. Other questions are open-ended. Practice writing your own questions below: Invalid: Valid: Poll jargon: pushing, tracking and exit Finally, a brief word about three kinds of polls you may hear mentioned this election year. Exit polls are often conducted by news organizations, who question voters as they leave polling places on election day. The results are then used to "project" the winners of races long before the votes are counted. Candidates have complained when TV networks broadcast results of these polls before all voters have cast their ballots, and these days most exit polls aren't released until after the end of the voting day in the state where the polling was done. Tracking polls are small-sample surveys used by campaigns and others to track the standing of candidates on a regular basis, sometimes daily. Push polls aren't really polls at all, but campaign propaganda masquerading as research. They aim not to measure public opinion, but to manipulate it by planting negative impressions of an opposing candidate in the form of a question. An extreme example: "Would you be more or less likely to vote for Candidate X if you learned he frequents topless bars?" Makes no difference if that allegation is true; the purpose of a push poll is to plant that seed. Use the section above to summarize the six “red flags” in the polling process below. 24 QW: How do political elites use polls? How is that different from the citizenry? Polling Power Point Notes Types of polls Straw polls: Exit polls: Who do you poll? Random samples Stratified/quota samples (geographic distribution) 250 million= 1500 people How do you poll? Define the Construct a sample Create Select and control Analyze and report findings Why do you poll? Public opinion 25 National polling organizations tend to be pretty accurate Influence is not measurable What does a good poll need? Representative sample Carefully constructed Accurate statistical analysis Meticulous A stratified or quota sample is the best way to sample Common problems Room for error Margin of error (+/- 3%) Sampling error: difference between random samples taken at the same time See Gallup/Pew for examples: Practice Qs: 1. Which of the following statements about public opinion polling is TRUE? A) Straw polls are scientific polls usually conducted by newspapers. B) The larger the population in question, the larger the sample size must be to maintain the same sampling error. C) Requirements for randomness may be satisfied quite easily by having respondents phone answers in to a television station. E) Telephone surveys are generally unreliable because they target only those who can afford telephones. 2. A useful public opinion poll requires all of the following EXCEPT A) a representative sample B) carefully constructed questions C) an accurate statistical analysis D) meticulous planning E) face-to-face interviewing 26 3. Last minute polls often have results that are different from earlier polls. This is probably due to A) the use of large numbers of questions B) the use of different questions C) an increase in sampling errors D) the lack of proper questions E) the lack of random controls Every Eligible Voter Counts: Correctly Measuring American Turnout Rates Dr. Michael P. McDonald All signs point to 2004 as a vintage year for democracy in the United States. Interest in the campaign and candidates is up. More people are following the election. People see distinct differences between the candidates on the issues. The election is perceived to be close, not only nationally, but also in a greater number of battleground states than in 2000. Many people have already committed to voting, and absentee ballot applications are running at record levels. This year will undoubtedly set a record for the total number of Americans who vote. If the 2004 turnout rate matches the 1992 turnout rate, as many polling organizations predict when they define “likely voters,” then approximately 122 million Americans will vote, an 17 million increase from the record 2000 presidential turnout of 105 million. When measured correctly, voter turnout is not declining, as many people believe. This misunderstanding arises because the population ineligible to vote is increasing. Remarkably, the ineligible population commonly is included in the calculation of voter turnout rates, which creates false impressions about historical trends and inaccurate comparisons among the states. Looking back at turnout rates post-World War II, we can understand why observers have wrongly concluded that American voters are becoming more apathetic. If we calculate turnout rates for everyone of voting age in the United States, there is an unmistakable downward trend since the 1960s, interrupted only occasionally. If we instead base the rates on those eligible to vote, no decline is apparent since 1972. As I will explain, the way in which the turnout rate is calculated can have a substantial impact on our understanding of Americans’ level of electoral participation. Ideally, we would calculate the turnout rate as: Rate Turnout total ballots cast # of eligible voters But, due to the convenience of readily available numbers, the turnout rate is most often calculated as: Rate Turnout= total votes for president Total # of people 18 or older in the U.S. To correctly understand participation in American elections, we need to examine closely the underlying numbers in the denominator and numerator of the voter turnout rate. Several important demographic trends lurk in these data and have relevance beyond getting the turnout rate right. 27 The Denominator Let’s start with the denominator in the ideal turnout rate equation: those eligible to vote. Until recently, the Census Bureau calculated turnout rates based on what is known as the “voting-age population,” defined as an estimate of the domestic United States population age 18 and older. Many organizations and individuals continue to use this figure in place of a calculation of those eligible to vote, even though the Census Bureau instead uses citizen-voting-age population in its most recent reports. As the Census Bureau is careful to state, the voting-age population (VAP) is not equivalent to the voting-eligible population (VEP). The VAP includes persons ineligible to vote: persons residing in the United States who are not citizens, ineligible felons (depending upon state laws), persons who do not satisfy residency requirements, and the mentally incompetent. It also excludes persons who are eligible to vote, namely eligible voters living overseas. Remarkably, in 2004 an estimated 9.3% of the voting-age population is ineligible to vote. Non-citizens The increase in the non-citizen population accounts for much of the misperception of American voter turnout trends. In 1972, non-citizens constituted only about 1.5% of the VAP, yet their numbers have been steadily increasing. Today, non-citizens are estimated to be 7.9% of the voting-age population, thus constituting the largest portion of those ineligible to vote. Although one might incorrectly infer that these non-citizen immigrants are here illegally, the majority are legal residents. The Department of Homeland Security reports that as of 2000, legal permanent residents constituted 10.8 million and unauthorized immigrants 7.0 million of the total estimated 17.8 million noncitizens in the country. Felony Disfranchisement The voting rights of felons depend on state law. Forty-eight states (plus the District of Columbia) bar felony prisoners from voting, thirty-two states bar those on parole, and twenty-nine bar those on probation. Examining Department of Justice reports on the number of felons located in these states and in the federal prisons suggests that about 3.2 million persons cannot vote because of their felony status. The number of ineligible felons has trended upwards since the early 1980s when prison populations began expanding. The estimate of felony disfranchisement does not include figures for the fourteen states that restrict exfelon voting rights to some degree, though since 2000, five states have modified their laws to make it easier for ex-felons to vote. The statistics necessary to construct such an estimate with a high degree of accuracy are unavailable: recidivism, migration, and mortality rates of ex-felons. One estimate, compiled by the Sentencing Project, finds that 1.7 million ex-felons were unable to vote in the 2000 presidential election. Felony disfranchisement is not racially neutral, as African-American and Hispanic men, groups with larger percentages of felons than the national average, are more likely to be barred from voting than are whites or women. The Sentencing Report finds that 1.4 million black males (13%) are ineligible. In the states that permanently bar felons from voting, 25% are ineligible. Recent Movers 28 State law on residency requirements varies from state to state. Some states have an explicit requirement that an individual has maintained residency for a given period, while others are implicitly set with the registration deadline. Thirty-three states have a 28-day or more effective residency requirement. Statistics on the number of people who have moved following a state’s residency deadline is unknown. According to the 2000 census, 8.4% of all persons moved to another state within the past 5 years. If we evenly distribute these individuals by month, then 0.1% of all persons moved to a different state in the month prior to a presidential election, which equates into about 300,000 persons of voting-age. Unfortunately, we do not know how these persons are distributed among the states with varying residency requirements, so an adjustment to the VAP for movers cannot be made. The impact of moving on voter turnout is probably more pronounced than simple eligibility since persons who are most likely to vote are those who are connected to their community. Recent movers, until they feel a part of their community, do not vote at as high rates as long-time residents. The Mentally Incompetent Persons who are found mentally incompetent by a court of law are barred from voting in all states. No good statistics exist for the number of persons who are legally considered mentally incompetent. The number of occupied beds in high- level nursing homes, in which the mentally incompetent often receive care, is about 250,000 according to a recent National Institute of Health Statistics survey. Overseas Citizens Overseas citizens consist of private citizens living or traveling abroad; military persons and their dependents; and other government officials, such as those working for the State Department, and their dependents. Surprisingly, the Census Bureau reports that there is no reliable estimate of the number of overseas citizens. Moreover, the statistics that are available do not indicate how overseas citizens are apportioned to the states. The number of voting-eligible overseas citizens can be crudely estimated at 3.2 million, based on military deployment reports, State Department personnel reports, and reports of private citizens living overseas. The Numerator The number of people who voted in an election should be simple to measure. After all, we have to know the election results in order to declare a winner. Yet there are voters who cast a ballot but inadvertently did not record a vote for president or purposely skipped the presidential choice to vote for a different race on the ballot. Did these people vote? Perhaps we should calculate turnout rates for all those who cast a ballot, but remarkably we do not know how many people actually cast a ballot in a national election. Most states report the total number of ballots cast, but some do not. Instead of using total ballots cast, those who study participation rely on the number of presidential election votes to gauge participation. We can estimate the total number of ballots cast by using those states that report the number and inflating the presidential vote for those states that do not. Using this method, the total number of ballots cast is about 2.1% greater than the number of people who voted for president. The result is that we can show participation is even slightly higher than is widely believed. Correctly Measuring Turnout Rates 29 Turnout Rates in Presidential Elections, 1948-2000 There has been an increasing gap between VAP turnout rates for presidential voters and VEP turnout rates for total ballots cast as a consequence of an increase in immigration, larger prison populations, and a slight decrease in overseas citizens when troops returned to the United States at the end of the Cold War. Thirty years ago, it mattered only slightly which statistics one used. But in 2000, there was a 5.3 percentage point difference between the two turnout rates. Using the wrong statistics also creates misperceptions about differences in turnout rates between the states. For example, California has the nation’s largest non-citizen population. The 2000 turnout rate (based on voting-age population) was 44.1%, well below the national rate of 50.0%. In contrast, when using data on those eligible to vote and those who cast a ballot, California’s turnout rate is 56.6%, higher than the national rate of 55.3%. If we were to use the wrong numbers, we might conclude California’s turnout was in crisis, when in fact participation in California is slightly higher than in other states. As it turns out, much of the previously perceived variation in state turnout rates can be attributed to the presence of ineligible voters. If we drew a trend line for participation in American elections using the VAP turnout rate, we would come to the sad conclusion that in 240 years, no one would vote. Those concerned about turnout declines equate voting with other civic engagement activities and ominously warn that American democracy is teetering on the brink. Many well intentioned people promote various cures for a system they believe is on life support. The good news is that things are not as bad as they are made out to be, and perhaps people are looking for a cure to a nonexistent problem. A trend line drawn from 1972- 2000 shows no decline in turnout rates. Sure, American participation could be higher, but it is not in the midst of a deepening crisis. And as recently as 1992, participation broke 60% of those eligible to vote, equaling participation during the 1950s and 1960s. When academic polls and national and state elections are examined, it is clear that voter interest is the most important factor for higher voter turnout. We need more competition and more exciting elections to entice voters to the polls. Regrettably, we have an Electoral College that reduces competition to a few battleground states. Only ten percent of congressional districts are up for grabs due to gerrymandering. Reforming our antiquated electoral system to inject competition may have a greater impact on increasing participation than any initiative aimed directly at urging voters to the polls. 30 Every Eligible Voter counts Qs 1. What are the official requirements to vote? 2. What is the author’s argument about voter turnout? What does he say is really happening? 31 3. Contrast the formula the author says we should use with the formula we often use to calculate voter turnout. 4. List and describe the groups that are ineligible to vote according to this document. Do you agree that these groups should not vote, or are indeed “ineligible”? 5. What does the author say is the problem with calculating the numerator? 6. Why does the author think calculating incorrect voter turnout rates is dangerous? QW: Evaluate current laws about who gets to vote. Are they fair? Not fair? 32 33 Voting Rights Act 1965 video: http://www.nbcnews.com/video/nbc-news/8645974#8645974 QW: Describe why the VRA of 1965 was so significant (use the video clip and notes from book): Ballot Battles video questions 1. Briefly summarize the 2000 presidential election in Florida and the controversy surrounding it. 2. When is a recount used in elections? How does it work? 3. What is the Help America Vote Act? 4. Why was Ohio important in the 2004 election? 34 5. What did Diebold's opponents argue? 6. List the problem areas for computerized voting machines. 7. Explain how these issues are related to disabled voters 8. What group of people is not allowed to vote in 7 states? Do you agree with this? 9. Explain the racial component of the 2000 election 10. What do you predict to be the future of voting? Test: Chapters 4, 7, 8 Review Topics: You do not have to write anything on this. Please use your Barron’s book to study, as well as the practice Qs I have provided. Quizlet.com can be a handy resource as well! Political Spectrum Be able to define: liberal (American), conservative (American), classic conservatism, classic liberalism, populism, socialism, communism, libertarianism and fascism. For each of the above: be able to explain where they would stand on social and economic issues and why. Be able to analyze major turning points in how we use the words liberal and conservative (New Deal, Civil Rights, swapping of the Democrats and Republicans, etc.) 35 Political Socialization List the ways people are socialized politically. Which is often the most influential? Compare American political culture to that of other European countries and the Japanese. Analyze how party loyalty/identification has changed over the past several decades. Political Participation Be able to identify how each of the following groups are likely to vote in an election (which party)(remember, this is a generalization, it does not apply to everyone in these groups!!): African Americans, Latinos, the South, men, Jewish people, white collar workers, blue collar workers, rural vs. urban voters, Protestants, Catholics Review the idea of the gender gap/ identify issues there may be a difference between men and women. Know: the steps in the polling process, dangers of the polling process Contrast the ways voter turnout can be calculated. Compare “cannot voters” and “nonvoting voters.” What are some of the ways people can participate in politics BESIDES voting? Voting History and trends Identify the role of each of the following in voting: age, education, income Identify how voting requirements have changed in the United States since the creation of the Constitution. (Include: methods of denying the vote to some groups) Know: Voting Rights act and Civil Rights Act, methods used to being about changes for the voting rights of African Americans. Explain how the Australian ballot changed elections. 36