Volkswagen Brand Audit 1 Brand Overview Volkswagen originally began under orders from Hitler to build a cheap car for the people of Germany, hence the name Volkswagen which means “the people’s car.” After WWII, the factory in Wolfsburg produced cars for the occupying British government (“History,” n.d.). During this time they also introduced the Beetle, still popular today. The company began to sell cars overseas in 1947. In 1949, the “Volkswagen-Finanzierungsgesellschaft mbH” or VFG company was founded (“History,” n.d.). During the 1950s, Volkswagen continued to expand overseas, and obtained a global market share of 50%. The iconic Volkswagen van, officially called the Transporter model but nicknamed the Bully, was created in 1950 (“History,” n.d.). The 1960s marked a period of crisis where Volkswagen’s business model of mass-producing one model of car began to fail as other car companies diversified their offerings. In response, Volkswagen shifted more investment into research and development (“History,” n.d.). During this time Volkswagen became a public company, selling off 60% of shares to the German people with the remaining 40% divided between the government and Lower Saxony state (“History,” n.d.). Volkswagen’s first acquisition is the Auto Union group. The Passat and Golf are created in 1973 and 1974, respectively (“History,” n.d.). Meanwhile, the Beetle has passed the Ford Model T in production. Volkswagen opens a bank sector in 1973 to help its customers receive credit and financing to buy their vehicles (“History,” n.d.). By the 1980s, Volkswagen had a factory on four continents. Volkswagen acquired the Spanish company SEAT SA in 1991 after a long period of working together in a sales alliance (“History,” n.d.). The same year, they also acquired Czech brand Skoda, thus gaining further access to Central and Eastern European markets. The 90s marked a period of increase productivity, quality, and environmental efficiency (“History,” n.d.). Interestingly, Volkswagen adopted a four-day workweek in its German worksites. Clearly Volkswagen was comfortable with doing things differently than other car companies. The luxury brands Bentley, Bugatti, and Lamborghini are added in the late 90s, and the commercial vehicle division becomes its own separate brand (“History,” n.d.). The 2000s mark growth into developing economies, such as Russia and India. Today Volkswagen is venturing into new environmentally friendly technologies, including its newest car, the up! (“History,” n.d.). As always, the Volkswagen group will focus on research and development to maintain its status as an innovative, quality car maker. Brand Planning Assessment: How would you characterize the positioning of your brand? Volkswagen Automotive Group is the largest carmaker in Europe with several different brands such as Audi, Bentley, Bugatti, Lamborghini, Porsche, SEAT, Skoda and the Volkswagen passenger car. Their commercial vehicles include MAN, and Scania and their motorcycle line, Ducati. We could divide these into four categories: low-end automotive cars, high-end automotive cars, commercial vehicles, and motorcycles. Volkswagen Automotive Group high-end cars include Audi, Bentley, Bugatti, Lamborghini and the Porsche. Since the brand images of these cars are high, Volkswagen Automotive Group has positioned these brands to make these cars less common in the United States. For example, to keep up the image that they are more prestigious, car enthusiast must obtain their car by importing them to the United States. Although there are dealerships throughout the United States, they are scarce compared to Toyota or Ford dealerships. Volkswagen Automotive Group has also limited the amount of cars that they send overseas. This creates a more personalized high-end car for a more of a “wow” statement for the owner when they are driving down the street. The low-end of Volkswagen Automotive Group cars include the SEAT, Skoda and Volkswagen passenger car. SEAT and Skoda positioning of these care are unknown in the United States because they are mainly located in South America, Europe, and Africa. The Volkswagen passenger car is most commonly known in the United States which is because of the way they advertise on television to compete with other cars companies such as Toyota, Honda, Ford, Volvo, and GM. Volkswagen Automotive Group also has their commercial vehicles MAN and Scania. Like the SEAT and Skoda, MAN and Scania are only located in Europe, because of the little profit they would Volkswagen Brand Audit 2 make trying to compete with the American made commercial vehicles. Ducati motorcycles are commonly used as a racing motorcycle and possess a high-end brand image in the motorcycle community. It is mostly advertised within the United States within motorcycle magazines, racetracks, and celebrity endorsements. What have been the key marketing activities that have most contributed to the success of that positioning? Volkswagen Automotive Group key marketing activities have contributed to the success of the positioning in many ways. For their high-end cars by making them uncommon and almost unavailable in North America they have been able to maintain a prestigious image. For their low-end cars they have effectively integrated similar marketing channels to help them compete with other local and foreign distributors. Their Ducati racing bike has been successful in marketing in the motorcycle community making it one of the most sought after racing bike in the North America. What are the greatest opportunities to enhance that positioning? Volkswagen Automotive Group greatest opportunity to enhance their positioning would be advertising their pricing values on their Volkswagen passenger car for the people who have lower income. I wouldn’t change the positioning on their high-end cars. The element of a foreign car, expensive, and hard to find makes their high-end car more desired and prestigious than other luxury cars. Also, the position that Ducati uses to marketing their racing bikes is what makes it a luxury bike. They highly market it in motorcycle magazines and on race tracks. Brand Valuation Assessment: How has your brand built resonance? Established since 1937, Volkswagen has a long time to invest in and build the brand resonance. Volkswagen’s brand resonance is reflected in the following categories: 1. Brand salience: It is not difficult to think of Volkswagen when a person wants to purchase a car. Volkswagen is one the most popular car brand along with Toyota, Ford, and BMW... American and European people will mostly likely to recognize a Volkswagen car or its sub-brand one or even when just look at their logos. However, customers will not think of individual brands of Volkswagen such as Bentley, Audi, and Lamborghini… These brands are luxurious ones which target at only wealthy class. So the breadth of the German Corporate is still very limited. Nevertheless, Volkswagen recently applies its slogan “Das Auto” which means “the car” in most language. With “Das Auto”, Volkswagen wants to make it name corresponding to car in general. People will perceive Volkswagen as a word for car, as Hoover for vacuum. The purpose of this is to make increase both the breadth and depth of the brand so that whenever anyone mentions a car, they would think of Volkswagen immediately. 2. Brand imagery: Each brand of Volkswagen has different ways to define its image: Audi: In the premium segment, Audi has become one of the strongest car brands worldwide under the motif “Vorsprung durch Technik” – Head start through technology. The brand aims to take over market leadership in this segment and relies heavily on its sporty, high quality and progressive image. The success of Audi’s four rings in all markets around the world, coupled with the numerous honors and awards conferred on Audi models, is impressive proof of the fact that Audi has evolved into a premium, high prestige brand. This success is primarily attributable to a consistent marketing strategy with innovative engineering solutions and an emotional design language (Volkswagen Annual Report 2012). SKODA: With its “Simply clever” slogan ŠKODA has become one of the fastest emerging brands, particularly in Europe and China. The brand relies on delivering a strong value proposition and an attractive design, coupled with intelligent ideas for the use of space that are technically simple but offer refined and practical solutions. The high recognition for the Volkswagen Brand Audit 3 brand concept is reflected in its numerous awards for ambitious, innovative and sophisticated vehicle design. SEAT: Models that regularly win awards for their outstanding design are representative of the SEAT brand image. By sharpening the brand profile and placing additional focus on the most important brand values of “dynamic”, “young” and “design-oriented”, SEAT is aiming for stronger growth, particularly in Europe. The new brand claim “Enjoyneering” suitably expresses the character of the brand as a passionate perfectionist and emotional technology leader. Bentley, Bugatti and Lamborghini round off the brand diversity of the Volkswagen Group in a refined manner. They reside in the luxury vehicle segments and distinguish themselves by their exclusivity, power and elegance. Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles stands for superior mobility with its three core values of reliability, economy and partnership. It offers a range of different transport solutions at the highest levels of engineering for different customer groups. The light commercial vehicles in the Caddy, Multivan/Transporter, Crafter and Amarok ranges are tailored to meet the individual transportation needs of customers in retail and craft businesses, as well as civil authorities and service providers. Family-friendly MPVs and leisure-oriented motor homes are valued by private customers as derivatives of our light commercial vehicles. Scania: The success of the Swedish Scania brand is based on the core values of “customer first”, “respect for the individual” and “quality”. For over 100 years, the company has been manufacturing high-performance trucks and buses with highly innovative technology and offering customers efficient transport solutions in combination with a variety of service packages, including financial services. 3. Brand feelings: Volkswagen has built up its brand feelings from different levels. Some products make users feel warm; some fun, and some secure. Nevertheless, most of Volkswagen cars focus more on excitement, social approval, and self-respect – more gravity feelings rather than the intensity. These private feelings create a stable stand for Volkswagen in the market. Excitement: Volkswagen commercials attempt to invoke happiness and excitement from audiences. Slogan or tag line “Get in. Get Happy”. Social approval: In 2010, Volkswagen equipped Africa with infrastructures to organized World Cup 2010. The Corporate feels its social responsibilities and an urge to support Africa. Volkswagen built infrastructures, provided education, enhanced living standards, and relentlessly fought HIV in Africa. These are just a part of what Volkswagen did to give back to community. This helps to build Volkswagen as a corporate with a cause, gaining social agreement. The impact of charity in Africa will blur the side of environment-unfriendly of car engines. People will look at Volkswagen with a great amount of good will after accomplishment is Africa is broadcasted. Self-respect: With the sleek designs and powerful engines, any of Volkswagen cars is a symbol of delicacy. In addition, the cash value of a Lamborghini, Bentley, or Audi always dictates the class of the owner. Customers could feel the taste of accomplishment when they own a Volkswagen. 4. Brand resonance: Loyalty: Volkswagen owns a large amount of loyal customers. Since each brand of Volkswagen has distinctive characteristic and values, customers rarely change the brand. For example, a person who loves Lamborghini would never buy a Toyota or BMW. The car brand is the customer’ brand. It is consistent with their style, which the rate of repeated purchase is high. Interestingly, the brand that has most loyalty is Volkswagen passenger cars. Customers are satisfied with not only the values of the brand but also the outstanding quality of the product. Volkswagen Brand Audit 4 Community: There are many communities of Volkswagen both online and offline. Some communities share the experience of owning a Volkswagen and others want to know more about Volkswagen’s car feature. Moreover, there are clubs for people who love Volkswagen. They even have t-shirts and souvenir for their own groups, which demonstrate the spirit of the community. Some communities include: o http://www.communityvw.net/ o http://vwcommunity.ca/ o http://www.ivdub.com/groups/ These communities are concrete evidences of engagement of customers in Volkswagen. People who own a Volkswagen share some certain relationship and feel connected, which will connect them to the brand. The relationship between customer and the Corporate is really enhanced. They attempt to better understand the brand and contribute to the development of the products. Engagement: o Commitment in sport and culture: Volkswagen Arena: Volkswagen Arena is a multipurpose stadium in Wolfsburg, Lower Saxony, Germany and serves as the home stadium of the 2008–09 Bundesliga champions VfL Wolfsburg. When people went to the Volkswagen Arena, they can feel the spirit of Volkswagen, and really engaged in brand. Moreover, reputation from sponsoring numerous sport events is a precious source of brand equity to Volkswagen (13Ap). o Volkswagen Junior Master: The football program in 20 countries with 800 teams. Juniors participate in the game to show their passion and commitment to soccer. The program is a good chance for juniors to learn a play. At the same time, Volkswagen can build up brand image to juniors and their parents. o Museum of Modern of Art: Volkswagen cooperates with Museum of Modern Art in New York to promote Think Blue – innovative solutions to efficiency and green ecosystem. This partnership improved Volkswagen’s reputation as a friendly partner in environment reservation, in contrary to the pollution that cars usually cause. o Motor Sport: Volkswagen participated in Formula 3 races in Dakar. The team is always the forerun and takes advantages of technology to conquer challenging races. Customers can support Volkswagen team as a football team, with all of their heartedness and enthusiast. The relationship between customers and Volkswagen is elevated to a new level (13Ap). 5. Summary of brand resonance: Volkswagen has focused on brand salience, brand feelings, brand judgment, and brand resonance to define its name. In each area, Volkswagen Groups has done variety of activities to promote it names. Therefore, customers can perceive Volkswagen as an outstanding brand with a wide range of brand salience, outstanding images, positive feelings with social responsibilities, and high engagement. How would you assess the value of your brand to the company? Volkswagen’s brand value can be assessed from 3 areas: sale number, it competitors, and brand resonance. 1. Brand resonance: Based on what the Group has attempted since it was founded, Volkswagen has built up concrete and consistent brand names. Each brand has different values due to different target markets and customers. Through history of expansion, the enormous value of Volkswagen makes it easy to expand, spin-off, or acquire any other product line. All of this influence confirms Volkswagen as a highly valuable brand. 2. Brand value numbers: Volkswagen Brand Audit 5 In general, Volkswagen brand value is $17,758m in 2012, and increases to $23,666m in 2013. And among 100 global brands, Volkswagen’s rank is 55. All of this number reflects the gargantuan value of Volkswagen (Brandirectory ). The following table shows how much each brand contributes to Volkswagen Group, which reflects how much each brand values. (Source: http://annualreport2011.volkswagenag.com/divisions/brandsandbusinessfields.html) 3. Competitors: Among the 7 most popular luxurious car brands (BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, Lexus, Porsche, Bentley Motors and Rolls-Royce Motor Cars), three of them belong to Volkswagen Group. Volkswagen brands have taken over a large market share in luxurious car. However, to fully understand Volkswagen’s value, we should look at its strongest competitor, BMW and how it is doing. Both gigantic car brands come from Germany and share several similarities. But BMW has surpassed Volkswagen a little in the past. BMW’s brand value in 2012 is 21,282 million and is 23,236 million in 2013 (Brandirectory). The acceleration rate of BMW is slower than Volkswagen’s. High acceleration demonstrates that Volkswagen is speeding up and equals with BMW. In addition, BMW also constructs a very strong brand name by sponsoring variety of sport events as well as investing in 360-degree campaigns. To compete with BMW, Volkswagen must have Volkswagen Brand Audit 6 been equipped carefully and very confident in its brand name. BMW is a very effective projection toward Volkswagen’s brand value since they are compatible in the car industry. In short, brand resonance, brand value numbers, and the strongest competitor, BMW, has clarified the colossal value of potential of Volkswagen. Brand Growth Analysis: Source: http://www.volkswagenag.com/content/vwcorp/ What is your brand’s architecture? The brand architecture is a marketing tool used to show which brand elements should be used to represent a company’s products (Keller, 2013). Volkswagen Group’s brand architecture consists primarily of one corporate brand that oversees twelve individual brands including SEAT, Skoda, Volkswagen, Audi, Bentley, Bugatti, Lamborghini, and Porsche (Volkswagen Group Brands and Products). The corporate brand is divided into two divisions: Automotive and Financial Services. From the Automotive division, Volkswagen Group incorporates a branding strategy that creates individual umbrella branding for each of its eight family brands.Analyzing Volkswagen Group’s overall architecture and hierarchy, the corporation has implemented a vertical line extension, extending into premium, or prestige brands like Audi, Bentley, Bugatti, Lamborghini, and Porsche; however, the corporation also maintains market coverage with entry-level brands such as SEAT, Skoda, and Volkswagen (Volkswagen Group Brands and Products). How would you critique it? The current architecture allows each individual brand to maintain its own identity; as a result, the positive associations, feelings, and judgments of each individual brand is separate than that of Volkswagen Group’s. The Group implements a “House of Brands” approach and the broad architecture allows for a diverse market coverage as well as consumers’ perception of each brand’s credibility. The umbrella branding strategy can be positive for Volkswagen Group in cases of negative associations, where these associations might not necessarily affect the public’s feelings and judgments about the Group specifically, but only the individual brand. Volkswagen Brand Audit 7 For example, Volkswagen is one of the brands existing in the Low Consumption Small Cars product category. As depicted in the brand hierarchy chart above, Volkswagen acts as the family brand and can be divided into three categories: Compacts, Sedans, and Wagons. Compact cars consist of four individual brands: Golf, GTI, Beetle, and EOS; SUVS consist of Touareg and Tiguan; Sedans consist of Passat, Jetta, CC, and EOS; and Jetta SportsWagen maintains its own category in the wagon category (Volkswagen Group Brands and Products). Each individual brand also maintains different modifiers to further create points-of-differences between different makes. What is good or bad about its hierarchy? Volkswagen Group’s overall architecture currently reaches into both family-oriented or middleclass markets and extends into luxury, prestige markets. The hierarchy effectively establishes points-ofdifferences from both entry-level brands and prestige brands; however, opportunities remain in the lowend or value-conscious markets, where Volkswagen group has yet to extend into. Though SEAT, Skoda, and Volkswagen are valued as high quality in markets, an extension into a value-conscious brand, possibly costly, would allow taps into new markets. This low-end brand extension would also benefit from Volkswagen Group’s established equity. In establishing differentiated family brand images (provide examples like Volkswagen is family oriented, Porsche as sports, Bentley as high-class, etc), the brand extension should also inherit a new brand name, as to establish itself from other family brands, for example, Toyota’s Scion brand. How does it fit into a broader brand portfolio? Volkswagen group has a strategic manner of placing their products to tailor the needs of every customer in mind. The Volkswagen Group corporate brand is divided into the Automotive and Financial divisions, which separates the products the Group produces and financial services affiliated with those products. The strength that the Volkswagen Group has is that alongside offering variety of products, each brand maintains its own character and operates as their own independent entity on the market. Volkswagen Group’s broader brand portfolio executes a line extension that appeals to a variety of markets. For example, Porsche maintains a strong presence in the Sports Luxury category, Audi in the Luxury category, and Volkswagen in the Low Consumption Small Car category. Since Volkswagen Group has such a large brand portfolio they own the largest amount of car companies such as Bentley, Audi, and Lamborghini. Their company is recognized for taking modern German Engineering and producing vehicles that were safe, reliable, and comfortable at an affordable price. How well has the Brand expanded into new markets or channels? As Volkswagen Group maintains a prominent presence in the passenger car market through their umbrella branding strategy, they’ve been able to expand into new markets by following the latest trends and technology and implementing features into their higher-end vehicles. For example, the implementation of Apple products in the back seats of a Bentley incorporates a co-branding strategy where Bentley’s overall equity is improved and further establishes them in the luxury car market. Judging Volkswagen Group’s growth strategy, they tend to follow the current market trends and make adjustments to their current products by following the market trends such as making eco-friendly and hybrid vehicles for most of their models, abiding by their company goal of offering “attractive, safe and environmentally sound vehicles which can compete in an increasingly tough market and set world standards in their respective class” (Volkswagen Group: The Group). How would you judge its growth strategy? Volkswagen Group is constantly following trends and by doing this they are successful in the growth of their company and its overall strategy. They use their most sold models and create a “revamped” newer version of classic models from time to time. For example, in 2001 they sold 100,000 Passat’s from the 80,000 vehicles sold in 2000. In 2002, they released this same model with a more Volkswagen Brand Audit 8 refined look and included technology up to date, which attracted customers to purchase this vehicle for the amenities and retail price. (Wards Auto) By being able to introduce vehicles other than the Beetle that they are known for, selling vehicles for every style whether it be commercial or sport or simply due to price and prestige, Volkswagen has a vehicle marketing specific audiences in which they grow in reputation with their prestigious and luxury brands such as Audi and Lamborghini to their economical and compact cars such as the Jetta and Beetle. Recommendations Volkswagen has several opportunities for growth and maintaining brand equity: 1. Expand lower price brands SEAT and Skoda into the United States. Alternatively, Volkswagen could manufacture a low cost vehicle under the Volkswagen brand, though this would risk lowering the prestige of its current Volkswagen brand cars. Using a co-branding strategy might prove most effective. For example, Volkswagen could market a low price vehicle under the brand SEAT by Volkswagen or Skoda by Volkswagen, since Americans are unfamiliar with those brands and would look more favorably on the car if it were connected to the well-respected Volkswagen brand name. A lower price car could also be successful in the US market by using the Volkswagen name to advertise attributes not normally touted in cheaper cars, such as quality German engineering and excellent safety features. Such a vertical brand extension would allow Volkswagen to increase market share and cater to a new market segment that has previously been under-utilized. 2. Create a point of difference with other car companies by emphasizing green/environmentallyfriendly technology in all of its cars. Volkswagen cars are already some of the most fuel efficient and lowest in carbon emissions, so Volkswagen should capitalize on this in advertising and positioning. Demand for green technology in cars is increasing, and Volkswagen can only benefit by shifting its brand offerings and image to address this demand. Volkswagen has already begun to act on this growth opportunity by increasing the number of environmentally friendly cars in its offerings. These include the TDI Clean Diesel and hybrid versions of many of their popular models. Their new slogan, “Think Blue,” refers to the BlueMotion technology used in these models (“TDI diesel & hybrid cars,” n.d.). By not using a variation of green in the slogan, they have set themselves apart from other car brands’ advertising of their environmentally friendly cars. In addition, they claim a point of parity by saying that their eco-friendly cars are also highperformance. In other words, these cars perform just as well as non-eco-friendly cars from other brands, but are also good for the environment. Volkswagen can also expand into the electric car category. 3. Volkswagen could bring back the Transporter, more commonly known as the classic VW van. Many customers, when asked to recall the Volkswagen brand, think of this iconic vehicle, despite it not having been in production for decades now. Volkswagen should utilize this high level of recall, and benefit from the imagery associations of coolness, nostalgia, and adventure the vehicle already enjoys. The Transporter would essentially be a cash cow for Volkswagen; besides modernizing the engine, few other modifications from the original would be needed, since customers desire the van as it used to exist. This vehicle would especially appeal to younger age segments, which view it as a great car for traveling and spending time with friends. In addition, the van is already so well known that minimal marketing would be needed to facilitate sales. 4. Emphasize safety features to create a favorable brand response amongst customers with families and expand brand meaning. Volkswagen is already known for having quality cars in terms of engine performance, etc., and for making practical cars. Touting safety features will be important in the future not only to establish a point of parity with other carmakers who are seen as safetyconscious brands (such as Volvo), but also to expand brand response to include judgments of superiority in terms of safety features and feelings of security. The market segment of adults with small children is highly coveted in the car market, and Volkswagen has already begun to tailor their advertising to reflect this focus. Recent ads have shown parents with babies in their arms as Volkswagen Brand Audit 9 they go car shopping, asking the car salesperson if their cars are safe. Slogans such as “the safety of a Jetta” and “safety happens” suggest that safety should be a key performance element of Volkswagen’s brand meaning. Solidifying this brand meaning is important not only for family cars like the Jetta, but also for the Tiguan and Touareg SUVs, since SUVs have a reputation for rolling over. Volkswagen’s existing brand association of “quality German engineering” will facilitate this brand meaning and response expansion. Volkswagen Brand Audit 10 References (n.d.). Retrieved from http://brandirectory.com/profile/volkswagen (n.d.). Retrieved April 13, 2013, from http://en.volkswagen.com/en/volkswagen-live/engagement-andevents.html Brandirectory. (n.d.). Retrieved April 13, 2013, from http://brandirectory.com/profile/bmw Brandirectory . (n.d.). Retrieved April 7, 2013, from http://brandirectory.com/profile/volkswagen Volkswagen Annual Report 2012. (n.d.). Retrieved April 12, 2013, from http://annualreport2012.volkswagenag.com/managementreport/valueenhancingfactors/salesandmarketing.html?cat=i History. (n.d.). Volkswagen International. Retrieved April 20, 2013, from http://en.volkswagen.com/en/company/history.html#/flash=a131b52740bcdf23fb9a35d8d d360605@inspiration%2F1940%2Finformation%2FCompany%20history%2F0 Keller, K. L. (2013). Strategic Brand Management (4 ed.). Boston: Pearson. TDI clean diesel & hybrid cars. (n.d.).Volkswagen of America. Retrieved April 23, 2013, from http://web.vw.com/tdi-clean-diesel-and-hybrid/?sem=google Volkswagen group brands and products. (2012, December 31). Volkswagen Konzern Startseite. Retrieved April 23, 2013, from http://www.volkswagenag.com/content/vwcorp/ Volkswagen group: The group. (2012, December 31). Volkswagen Konzern Startseite. 23, 2013, from http://www.volkswagenag.com/content/vwc Retrieved April