FORENSIC SCIENCE INTRODUCTION Crime Scene Investigation Forensic Science Definition: The application of science to those criminal and civil laws that are enforced by police agencies in a criminal justice system. The business of providing timely, accurate, and thorough information to all levels of decision makers in our criminal justice system. 2 Complex Reasoning In Forensic Science Deductive and Inductive Reasoning Classifying Comparing and contrasting Problem Solving Analyzing Perspectives Constructing Support Error Analysis CRIME Why Did It Happened? What Happened? Crime Scene Evidence Collection Witness, Suspect and Motive Development Post Scene + Investigative Stage Profiling Means Motive Opportunity Who Did It? = Identification and Arrest of Suspect Evidence Processing Cause, manner, time of death 4 CORPUS DELICTI You must prove: “Body of the Crime” that a crime occurred that the person charged with the crime was responsible for the crime Top Reasons for Committing a Crime Money Revenge Sex Emotion--love, hate, anger Source of Evidence Body Primary and/or Secondary Crime Scene Suspect(s) 5 Crime Scene Team A group of professionals investigators, each trained in a variety of special disciplines. Team Members First Police Officer on the scene Medics (if necessary) Investigator(s) Medical Examiner (if necessary) Photographer and/or Field Evidence Technician Lab Experts: pathologist DNA expert forensic odontologist forensic psychologist firearm examiner document and handwriting experts serologist toxicologist forensic anthropologist forensic entomologist bomb and arson expert fingerprint expert 6 First Officer at the Scene A Assess the crime scene D Detain the witness A Arrest the perpetrator P Protect the crime scene T Take notes for CSI team 7 Eye Witness Faces Composite Program by InterQuest Will explain their part of the scene Give enough information to lead the team to a conclusion about what happened at this crime scene “Perception is reality.” As a result an eye witness may not be the best source of crime scene information. A police composite may be developed from the witness testimony by a computer program or forensic artist. 8 Basic Stages in a Search These are the responsibility of the 1st Officer at the scene. Approach, secure and protect the scene Initiate preliminary survey/determine scene boundaries Only authorized personnel should be allowed on the scene (Every person who enters the scene is a potential contaminator of viable physical evidence) Once a scene is secured, the lead investigator duties: Evaluate physical evidence possibilities Prepare narrative description Depict scene photographically Prepare diagram/sketch of scene Conduct detailed search Record and collect physical evidence Conduct final survey Release scene 9 Photography Scene should be photographed in an unaltered condition. Unless someone is injured, everything should be left in its unaltered condition. Close-up of phys. evidence should include a ruler or something to show size/scale Videotaping/digital cameras Still photography is still the best for its detail WHAT to photograph? Area of crime Adjacent areas Entrance/exit Body if present -- area under body after removal injuries/ weapons 10 ROUGH Sketches After photos, sketch… first rough sketch is made at the scene Accurate depiction of the dimensions at the scene Location of important objects to the case TRIANGULATION METHOD – measured accurately Each object is given a letter and a legend or list will correlate the letter to the item Designate north on the sketch ( The finished sketch is drawn to scale using the measurements provided in the rough sketch and is used as court evidence) 11 HOW do you do a proper sketch? Lay out basic perimeter Windows, doors, etc… Set forth fixed objects, furniture, etc… Record position of evidence Appropriate measurements – double check Key/legend, compass orientation, etc… NOTES: Constant activity throughout the processing of the scene Detailed description of the scene with location of evidence recovered Must id the time the evidence was discovered, whom, how, and then packaged, marked after collected Tape recording notes is helpful, but would need to be transcribed. 12 Typical material found on rough sketch Specific location Date Time Case identifier Preparer Weather conditions Lighting conditions Scale or disclaimer Compass orientation Evidence Measurement Key or legend 13 Crime Scene Sketch Date: August 14, 2001 Time: 11:35 Criminalist: Ann Wilson Location: 4358 Rockledge Dr St. Louis, Mo. A. Couch/sofa E c B. Female body D C. Knife D. Over turned Lamp E. Chairs E F. Table G. Fireplace G A F E E E 14 TRIANGULATION Measure from A to B and then to the evidence in a triangular shape. A+B need to be fixed points, something that will not change! Examples of a fixed point: - windows - doors - trees - buildings MAPPING TECHNOLOGY The latest technology includes this Nikon Tsunami with computer. The exact location of all crime evidence can be determined and directly loaded into a computer to produce a crime scene map. (Cost = $35,000 for the set) 16 Can we search for evidence now? Edmond Locard - French professor Considered the Father of Criminalistics Built the world’s first forensic laboratory in France in 1910 Locard Exchange Postulate: Whenever two objects come into contact with each other, traces of each are exchanged. 17 FOUR BASIC PREMISES The best search options are typically the most difficult and time consuming You can not “over document” the physical evidence. There is only one chance to perform the job properly There are two basic search approaches: A “cautious” search of visible areas, taking steps to avoid evidence loss or contamination After the “cautious” search, a vigorous search for hidden/concealed areas. 18 The Search…. • A search must always be thorough and systematic (even if a suspect is guilty!) • Methods of search are always customized to suit the crime. (Ex. Large open area uses a line search with a few people) • Here are some factors that help determine the type of search method: - Locale and size of area - # of techs available - size/type of evidence 19 Crime Scene Search Patterns TWO of FOUR PATTERNS Strip or Line Quadrant or Zone 20 Crime Scene Search Patterns TWO of FOUR PATTERNS Spiral Grid 21 Collection… • The collection of evidence starts with the most fragile or most easily lost evidence. • Photographs are continually taken. • Most items are placed in paper envelopes or bags. • Any liquid, arson evidence, or moist evidence are packaged differently, not in paper bags. • Items are always packaged separately to eliminate cross-contamination. • Proper labeling must always be place on ALL packages! 22 WHAT GOES TO THE LAB? Physical evidence must be collected in such a way that prevents any change between the crime scene and the crime lab. Victim’s clothing- never in an airtight container. Fingernail scrapings Hairs- leave on the article and send entire article to lab, where they will remove the hair Blood- leave on the article and send entire article to lab, where they will remove the blood Never in an airtight container, because the condensation could cause mold growth which could destroy the evidence. Fibers- leave on the article and send entire article to lab, where they will remove the fibers Swabs of secretions Charred debris- should be packaged in an air-tight container, so the petroleum residues do not evaporate. (paint cans) Bullets Hand swabs if needed NOTE: Each different item must be packaged separately! (prevent cross contamination) 23 Just A Thought… It’s not what you know that hurts you, its what you think you know and it’s not so . . . . .Mark Twain How does this apply to forensic science and crime investigations? 24