Chapter 2: Conducting Research

advertisement

Chapter 2: Conducting

Research

Psychology is an experimental science. Theories of behavior must be supported by evidence.

5 Steps of Scientific Research

• Form a Question

• Form a Hypothesis

• Test the Hypothesis

• Analyze the Results of the Test

• Draw Conclusions

Form a Question

• Do people learn by observing others?

• Do people learn better in small groups or alone?

• Do clients prefer counselor self-disclosure?

• Do older children (birth order) do better in school?

• Are the babies of the family spoiled?

QUESTION MUST BE MEASUREABLE!

Are athletes nicer, prettier? (How do you measure this?)

Form a Hypothesis

• Make an educated guess

• A child who watches Power Rangers will be more aggressive

• A child who plays Medal of Honor will most likely go into the military

• Students who sit in the front of the class get better grades

• Kids will buy the candy closest to them at the camp store window

• Grandpa’s and Grandma’s drive slower

Test the Hypothesis

• CAREFULLY EXAMINE THE BEHAVIOR IN A NATURAL OR CONTROLLED

ENVIRONMENT

• Decide what information is needed to test the hypothesis (What is the best way to gather information?)

• If you want to see if fat people eat bad foods, survey their carts at the grocery store before checkout

• If you want to see if skinny people eat slower, observe them in a café

• Survey questions DO NOT always work…people often tell you what they think you want to hear

Test the Hypothesis Continued

• GATHER THE INFORMATION: This could take weeks, months, or even YEARS

• Conduct a survey

• Take a survey

• Observations

Analyze the Results of the Test

• SUMMARIZE THE DATA STATISTICALLY

• Look for patterns and relationships in the data

• Use complex statistical tests to see if results are better than chance

Draw Conclusions

• DID THE OBSERVATIONS SUPPORT THE HYPOTHESIS?

• Were there predicted results?

• Were there unpredicted results?

• Do you have any predictions for future results?

• How can you adjust or refine the original hypothesis?

Replication

• For findings to be confirmed, they must be

REPLICATED with a different sample of subjects or else results may be a random occurrence.

• If you repeat your findings with different people (gender, socioeconomic status, age, education, geographic region) and get similar results, your findings are more robust.

New Questions

• Perhaps your research methods will lead you to formulate new hypothesis tests, methods of information gathering, and results for further discussion.

Research Methods: Selecting Samples

• Important to carefully consider what group of people you will examine (ex: if you are interested in behaviors in the parking lot…don’t ask freshmen)

• To accurately predict an outcome, your sample must be representative of the target population.

Selecting Samples: Two Ways

• Random Sample

• Individuals are selected by chance from the target population

• Everyone has an equal chance of being chosen

• If it is big enough, it will accurately represent the entire target population

• Stratified Sample

• Subgroups in target population are represented proportionally

• U.S. by race

• 74% non-Hispanic white

• 10% Eskimo / Native Americans

• 3% Asian

• 10% Hispanic

• 12% African American

• U.S. by sex, by grade, by age, by race…you can’t always account for all these

• The bigger your sample, the more likely it will be stratified

Selecting Samples

• Generalizing Results: researchers are careful not to generalize their findings to groups not represented in their sample

• Can be bias because of gender, race, geographic location, socioeconomic status or volunteer bias

• People who volunteer to participate in research studies often differ from people who do not

• More willing to disclose personal information

• More interested in research

• More spare time

• People who complete magazine studies

• Read magazines

• Have time to fill out the surveys

• Different leisure preferences

Survey Method

• Gathering information by asking people directly

• Through a questionnaire

• Through interviews in person or over the phone or e-mail

• Advantages

• Questionnaire – people can be more anonymous

• Interviews – more likely to do it and not throw it away

• Issues of confidentiality or honesty in all methods

• People will sometimes say what they think you want to hear

• People may not always tell the truth

• People are not always comfortable sharing their thoughts

Methods of Observation

• Learn a lot from watching people

• Psychologists use careful methods of observation to investigate behavior

Testing Method

• Psychologists use tests (I.Q. tests, personality tests, aptitude tests, vocational tests, etc.)

• Give us information about the persons (learning ability, temperament, character, special skills, career interests, etc.)

Case Study Method

• In depth investigation of an individual or small group

• Use what they learn to generalize to a larger population

• EX: Genie at 20 months was locked in a small room by her dad until 13. Mom fed her, Dad beat her, no one spoke to her. She herself did not say a word.

She eventually learned language, but not as well as most people. Case study conclusion: the critical period for language development is between 20 months and 13 years.

• Problems with case studies:

• Difficult to REPLICATE

• Often biased with interview format

• People don’t always remember

• Some people distort the past

• Researchers subtly bias respondents to answer how they want to hear

Longitudinal Method

• Looks at how people change over time (often years or decades)

• Information collected at intervals

• Tend to take long, be expensive, risky – no guarantee that people will want to continue to participate

Cross-Sectional Method

• Includes and compares different people of different ages

• Less reliable than longitudinal

• Cannot be certain that age alone is responsible for differences in behavior

Naturalistic Observation

• Observe people in actual environment

• Homes

• Schools

• Offices

• restaurants

• Do not interfere with the organism while observing

• EX: people’s eating habits, grocery store carts, fast-slow chewers

Laboratory Observation Method

• Observe people and animals in a laboratory setting (more often animals)

• Can sometimes control variables in a lab setting (does light or noise influence behavior?)

• TV Violence: observe kids’ behavior after watching a violent TV show

Analyzing Observations

• Correlations

• How closely is one thing related to another?

• The stronger the correlation, the more likely they are to be related

• Ex: Tall = basketball player

• EX: Talk = teacher

Correlations

• Positive Correlation: as one goes up, so does the other

• EX: Education and salary; height and basketball player; money and happiness (?)

• Negative Correlation: as one goes up the other goes down

• EX: stress and health; age and height; involvement in extracurricular activities and grades (?)

Correlations

• Correlations are limited. They describe the relationship but they do not reveal cause and effect. One thing does not necessarily cause the other.

Experimental Method

• Used to establish cause and effect in research.

• One group of subjects gets treatment (experimental group)

• One group of subjects does not get treatment (control group)

• Randomly assign subjects to each group. Assume other differencs balance out with randomization

• Behavior is observed or measured

• All other conditions are held constant

• If different – cause = treatment

Variables

• Independent Variable: factor that researchers manipulate so that they can determine its effect

• Dependent Variable: behavior being measured or thought to be influenced by independent variable

• Example: Hypothesis: Children watching violent TV are more likely to be violent

• Independent Variables

• Power Rangers TV show, Barney TV show (Experimental

Groups)

• No TV show (control group)

• Dependent Variable: behavior after watching the show

Variables

• EX: Hypothesis: Review helps students perform better on tests

• Class 1 gets a review game before a test

• Class 2 does not get a review game before the test

• Independent variable = review game

• Dependent Variable = test scores

Placebo Effect

• Substance or treatment that has no effect apart from a person’s belief in it

• Doctors find this to be true with certain hypochondria patients and medication

Blind Studies

Single Blind Study: participants unaware of whether they are receiving treatment or a placebo

Double Blind Study: participants and researchers are unaware of who is in which group. Researchers remain less bias.

Experimental Method

Advantages: researchers are able to manipulate variables to determine cause and effect. Laboratory setting enables researchers to monitor and record all stages of the experiment.

Disadvantages: conditions created in the lab may not accurately reflect the conditions of real life. Experiments may be subject to volunteer bias, researcher bias and the placebo effect.

Ethical Issues

• Ethics: standards for proper and responsible behavior. Psychologists promote dignity of the individual, foster human welfare, maintain scientific integrity.

• Psychological research should NOT be harmful

(consider the experimentation in Nazi concentration camps)

• Animal experimentation: need to present all findings (controversial)

Confidentiality and Informed Consent

• Information is private (subjects more likely to disclose true information and feelings)

• People agree to participate in a research study after they know what its about and choose to participate

• Deception can only take place if the potential benefits outweigh the potential harm

• When the participants receive an explanation of the study after it occurred.

Download