Companies Taking Over Other Business 1 Introduction Limited companies often expand their businesses by taking over another business as a going concern Business taking over may be in the form of an acquisition or an exchange of shares 2 Acquisition 3 Acquisition Sole proprietorship, partnership or Limited company Liquidation Asset+ liabilities Purchasing company Shares, debentures or cash Business purchase account Realization account 4 Seller’s book 5 Acquisition Seller’s Book Transfer of assets to the realization account Dr. Realization Cr. Assets (at net book values) Expenses paid for realization Dr. Realization Cr. Cash Sale proceeds from disposing of those assets which are not taken over Dr. Cash Cr. Realization Transfer of liabilities to the realization account Dr. Liabilities Cr. Realization Liabilities settled by the company itself Dr. Liabilities Cr. Cash 6 Acquisition Seller’s Book Discounts received on the settlement of creditors by the company itself Dr. Creditors Cr. Realization Purchase consideration agreed upon Dr. Purchasing company Cr. Realization Profit on realization (Reverse the entries for any loss on realization) For Sole Trader Dr. Realization Cr. Capital For Partnership Dr. Realization Cr. Partners’ Capital For Limited Company Dr. Realization Cr. Sundry Shareholders 7 Acquisition Seller’s Book Transfer of balances from partners’ current accounts to the capital accounts Dr. Partners’ Current Cr. Partners’ Capital (for partnership only) Transfer of balances from the profit and loss account and reserve accounts to the sundry shareholders account Dr. Profit and Loss/Reserves Cr. Sundry Shareholders (for limited company only) Receipt of cash, shares or debentures from the purchasing company for the settlement of the purchase consideration Dr. Cash/Shares/Debentures in purchasing company Cr. Purchasing company 8 Acquisition Seller’s Book Distribution of cash, shares or debentures between the partners or shareholders For Sole Trader Dr. Capital Cr. Cash/Shares/Debentures in purchasing company For partnership Dr. Partners’ Capital Cr. Cash/Shares/Debentures in purchasing company For Limited Company Dr. Sundry Shareholders Cr. Cash/Shares/Debentures in purchasing company 9 Buyer’s book 10 Acquisition Buyer’s Book Assets taken over at their revised values Dr. Assets Cr. Business Purchase Liabilities taken over Dr. Business Purchase Cr. Liabilities Purchase consideration agreed upon Dr. Business Purchase Cr. Vendor Profit on the acquisition Dr. Business Purchase Cr. Capital Reserve Loss on the acquisition Dr. Goodwill Cr. Business Purchase Settlement of the purchase consideration by cash and/or issuing shares and debentures Dr. Vendor Cr. Cash/Share Capital/Debentures 11 Example 1 Taking over a sole traders 12 On 31 Dec 1997 Sino Trading Company Ltd. Acquired the business of K. Chan The purchase consideration was $350000 cash. The company revalued the assets taken over as follows: Machinery $180000 Motor vehicles $70000 Stock $40000 Debtors $50000 Balance Sheet as at 31 Dec 1997 (before takeover) Sino trading co. K. Chan Land & Buildings $300000 Machinery 260000 $185000 Furniture & Fittings 70000 Motor Vehicles 130000 68000 Stock 84000 43000 Debtors 98000 52000 Cash 420000 7000 1362000 355000 Share capital/capital 1000000 352000 Profit and loss 320000 Creditors 42000 3000 13 1362000 355000 In K. Chan’s Book (Seller) Machinery Motor Vehicles Stock Debtors All assets and liabilities taken over should be stated At book value before the takeover in the realization account Realization 185,000 Creditors – taken over 68,000 Sino Trading – purchase 43,000 consideration Bal b/ f Sino trading co. Cash 350,000 52,000 Capital – Profit on Realization 5,000 353,000 (bal. fig.) Realization 3,000 353,000 Sino Trading Company Ltd. 350,000 Cash Cash 7000 Capital 350000 357,000 350,000 357000 357000 Capital 357000 357000 Bal b/f Realization –profit 352000 14 5000 357000 In Sino Trading Company Ltd.’s Book (Buyer’s Book) Business Purchase Creditors Cash – purchase consideration 3,000 Machinery Motor Vehicles Stock 350,000 Debtors Goodwill (bal. fig.) 353,000 180,000 70,000 40,000 50,000 13,000 353000 Assets and liabilities taken over should be Stated at their revised values in the business Purchases account 15 In Sino Trading Company Ltd.’s Book (Buyer’s Book) Sino Trading Company Ltd. Balance Sheet as at 1 January 1998 (after acquisition) Fixed Assets Goodwill Land and Buildings Furniture and Fittings Machinery (260,000 + 180,000) Motor Vehicles (130,000 + 70,000) Current Assets Stock (84,000 + 40,000) Debtors (98,000 + 50,000) Cash (420,000 – 350,000) Less: Current Liabilities Creditors (42,000 + 3,000) Working Capital Share Capital Profit and Loss 13,000 300,000 70,000 440,000 200,000 1,023,000 124,000 148,000 70,000 342,000 45,000 297,000 1,320,000 1,000,000 320,000 1,320,00016 Example 2 Settlement by shares The facts are the same as those in Example 1, except that the purchase consideration was settled by issuing share capital of $350000 instead of paying cash 17 In Sino Trading Company Ltd’s Book (Buyer’s Book) Sino Trading Company Ltd. Balance Sheet as at 1 January 1998 (after acquisition) Fixed Assets Goodwill Land and Buildings Furniture and Fittings Machinery (260,000 + 180,000) Motor Vehicles (130,000 + 70,000) Current Assets Stock (84,000 + 40,000) Debtors (98,000 + 50,000) Cash 13,000 300,000 70,000 440,000 200,000 1,023,000 124,000 148,000 420,000 692,000 Less: Current Liabilities Creditors (42,000 + 3,000) Working Capital Share Capital (1,000,000 + 350,000) Profit and Loss 45,000 647,000 1,670,000 1,350,000 320,000 1,670,00018 Example 3 Taking over a limited company 19 The following trial balances are extracted from Astin Ltd. And cathay Ltd. On 31 Dec 1997 Astin Ltd. Cathay Ltd. Dr Cr Dr Cr Goodwill $3000 Premises 250000 80000 Plant & Machinery 370000 46000 Stock 120000 72000 Debtors 65000 28000 Bank 53000 14000 Share capital-ord. shares of $1@ 560000 200000 Share premium 1000 20000 Profit and loss 130000 5000 5% debentures 100000 13000 Creditors 70000 2000 861000 861000 240000 240000 20 Astin Ltd. Took over Cathay Ltd. ( all the assets and liabilities ) on 31 Dec 1997. Additional information: 1. The debentures in Cathay Ltd. were to be exchanged for a new issue of 5% debentures in Astin Ltd. Of the same nominal value. 2. The purchase consideration was discharged by the issue of 230000 $1 shares at a premium of 10%. 3. The assets were taken over at their book values except premises, stock and debtors, which were revalued at $10000, $70000 and 24000 respectively. 21 In Cathy Ltd.’s Book (Seller) Premises Plant and Machinery Stock Debtors Bank Realization 80,000 Debentures 46,000 Creditors 72,000 28,000 Astin Ltd. – purchase consideration 14,000 (230,000 X 1.1) Sundry Shareholders (profit on realization) (bal .fig.)28,000 268,000 13,000 2,000 253,000 268000 Sundry Shareholders Shares in Astin Ltd.-purchase Share capital Consideration 253000 Share premium Profit and loss Realization-profit 253000 200000 20000 5000 28000 253000 22 All shares capital and reserves should be closed to the sundry shareholders’ account In Cathy Ltd.’s Book (Seller) Business purchase Debentures 13,000 Premises Creditors Astin Ltd. – purchase consideration (230,000 X 1.1) 2,000 Plant and Machinery Stock Debtors Bank 253,000 Goodwill (bal. Fig.) 268,000 100000 46,000 70,000 24,000 14,000 14000 268000 23 In Astin Ltd.’s Book (Buyer’s Book) Astin Ltd. Balance Sheet as at 1 January 1998 (after acquisition) Fixed Assets Goodwill (3,000 + 14,000) Premises (250,000 + 100,000) Plant and Machinery (370,000 + 46,000) Current Assets Stock (120,000 + 70,000) Debtors (65,000 +24,000) Bank (53,000 + 14,000) Less: Current Liabilities Creditors (70,000 + 2,000) Working Capital Share Capital Share Capital (560,000 + 230,000) Share Premium (1,000 + 23,000) Profit and Loss Long-term Liabilities 5% Debentures (100,000 + 13,000) 17,000 350,000 416,000 783,000 190,000 89,000 67,000 346,000 72,000 274,000 1,057,000 790,000 24,000 130,000 944,000 113,00024 1,057,000 Share Exchanges 25 Share exchange A limited company may take over another limited company by exchanging shares with the shareholders of the selling company. The selling company will not be liquidated. It becomes the subsidiary of the purchasing company. No entry is necessary in the books of the selling company,as it is only a change in the identity of the shareholders. The shareholders of the selling company now become shareholders of the purchasing company The purchasing company now becomes a holding company, In the books of the holding company, the subsidiary is regarded as an investment, 26 Share exchange Shares Limited company Holding company Shares Subsidiary company Issue of shares or debentures to Subsidiary company’s shareholders No entry in accounts 27 Share Exchange Accounting Entries Dr. Investment Cr. Share Capital Cr. Share Premium With the total cost of investment With the par value of the issue of exchange With the premium on the new issue 28 Example 4 29 The following balance sheets reflect the situation of Joyce Ltd and Anna Ltd. On 31 Dec 1997 Joyce Ltd. Goodwill Land & building Plant & machinery Office equipment Stock Debtors Bank 1300000 750000 80000 150000 180000 65000 2525000 Share capital- ord. Shares of $1@ Profit and loss account General reserve Creditors 2000000 400000 50000 75000 2525000 Anna Ltd. $20000 1000000 450000 50000 97000 110000 34000 1761000 1000000 600000 60000 101000 1761000 30 Joyce Ltd. took over Anna Ltd. By exchanging with the shareholders of Anna Ltd. Three shares of Joyce Ltd. Were exchanged at a premium of 20% for every two shares of Anna Ltd. There is no accounting entry required in the books of Anna Ltd. as there is no liquidation of Anna Ltd. The only changes is that the shareholders of Anna Ltd. Become shareholders of Joyce Ltd. 31 In Joyce Ltd.’s Book (Buyer’s Book) Joyce Ltd. Balance Sheet as at 1 January 1998 (after acquisition) Fixed Assets Land and Premises Plant and Machinery Office Equipment Investment in Anna Ltd., at cost Current Assets Stock Debtors Bank Less: Current Liabilities Creditors Working Capital Share Capital Ordinary Shares of $1 each (2000000+150000) Reserves Share Premium [(1000000*3/2)*20%] General Reserve Profit and Loss Account 1300,000 750,000 80,000 2,130,000 1,800,000 150,000 180,000 65,000 395,000 75,000 320,000 4,250,000 3,500,000 300,000 50,000 400,000 32 4250000 Pre-incorporation Profit 33 Pre-incorporation profit Limited Co. take over other businesses. It takes p period of time before they can be incorporated. A company cannot earn profits before it legally comes into existence through incorporation. The profits generated after the takeover and before the incorporation are knows as pre-incorporation profits Pre-incorporation profits are capital in nature. They must be transferred to a capital reserve account which is not available for dividend distribution. 34 Pre-incorporation Profits Accounting entries Dr. Profit and Loss Cr. Capital Reserve/Goodwill With the pre-incorporation profits earned Dr. Goodwill Cr. Profit and Loss With the pre-incorporation loss After incorporation, the company legally comes into existence. The profits generated after incorporation are known post-incorporation profits The profits which can be transferred to the profit and loss appropriation account and is also available for the distribution of dividends. 35 Allocation of profits between different parties 36 Allocation of Profits between Different Parties Case 1 A partnership was taken over by a limited company on 1 April. The company was incorporated on 1 June. Date of takeover 1/1 1/4 Date of incorporation Financial year end 1/6 31/12 Apportionment of profits: 1/1 to 31/3 Partnership 1/4 to 31/5 Pre-incorporation Profits 1/6 to 31/12 Limited company(Post-incorporation profits) 37 Allocation of Profits between Different Parties Case 2 A partnership was taken over by a limited company on 1 January. The company was incorporated on 1 April. Date of takeover 1/1 Date of incorporation Financial year end 1/4 31/12 Apportionment of profits: 1/1 to 31/3 Pre-incorporation Profits 1/4 to 31/12 Limited company (Post-incorporation profits) 38 Allocation of Profits between Different Parties Case 3 A partnership was taken over by a limited company on 1 April. The company was incorporated on the same date. Date of takeover of incorporation 1/1 Financial year end 1/4 31/12 Apportionment of profits: 1/1 to 31/3 Partnership 1/4 to 31/12 Limited company (Post-incorporation profits) 39 Apportionment of revenues and expenses Theoretically, a separate set of records should be dept for each period. However, a business may not have stock-take or may not close the accounts when there is a change in ownership of the business Therefore the income and expenditures must be apportioned over different periods in order to compute the pre-incorporation profits and the postincorporation profits The income and expenditures of the business should each be apportioned on a different basis 40 Basis of Apportionment Examples Sales Variable expenses and Revenues - They would increase proportionally to the increase in turnover - e.g. gross profit, selling and distribution expenses, carriage outwards, cost of goods sold, bad debts, discounts allowed, etc. Time Fixed expenses and revenues - They would increase proportionally to time - e.g. rent and rates, interest, administrative exp., office salaries, depreciation, etc. Actual - There is no need to apportion these expenses and revenues as they are incurred in a particular period. 41 Apportionment of Revenues and Expenses Basis of Apportionment Actual Examples - Partnership e.g. Interest on drawings, interest on capital, partners’ salaries, etc. - Pre-incorporation period e.g. interest on purchase consideration - Post-incorporation period e.g. preliminary expenses, interest on purchase consideration, debenture interest, directors’ remuneration, etc. 42 Example 5 Refer to textbook P.191-192 43 Example 5 Sales Cost of Sales Gross Profit Less: Expenses Rent Sales Comm. Preliminary Exp. Debenture Int. on Purchase Consideration Directors’ Fees Disc. Allowed Depreciation Office Salaries Net Profit Apportionment basis Partnership (Jan to Mar.) Pre-incrop. (Apr. to Sept) Post-incorp. (Oct. to Dec.) Turnover (3:8:4) Turnover (3:8:4) 360,000 90,000 270,000 960,000 240,000 720,000 480,000 120,000 360,000 Time (3:6:3) Turnover (3:8:4) Actual Actual 30,000 8,400 60,000 22,400 30,000 11,200 10,000 15,000 30,000 5,000 18,000 7,200 12,000 24,000 227,600 Time (6:1) Actual Turnover (3:8:4) Time (3:6:3) Time (3:6:3) 5,400 12,000 24,000 190,200 14,400 24,000 48,000 521,200 44