National Academies Summer Institutes for Undergraduate Education in Biology Teachable Unit Framework Title of Unit Date and Location of SI Unit Developers & Contact Information Move Me July 23, 2013 Mountain West Summer Institute, Boulder, Colorado David Aguilar, dcaguilar@ucsd.edu, University of California San Diego Lisa Gallegos,lisa.gallegos@ojc.edu, Otero Junior College Richard Gomer, rgomer@tamu.edu Texas A&M University Warren McClure,warren.mcclure@ojc.edu, Otero Junior College Kathryn Ryan, kryan@tamu.edu, Texas A&M University What kind of course is unit designed for? Introductory Biology, Cell Biology, or Human Anatomy and Physiology How long is unit? 1 to 2 week unit When will the unit be used in the course? This activity can be used during a unit on Context cytoskeleton and motors in a biology class, or more specifically in a Mucle tissue unit in Anatomy and Physiology. Students should have prior knowledge of the three main types of cytoskeletal proteins, have a basic understanding of ATP as an energy source, and be able to sketch the arrangement of the major sarcomere proteins. After this activity, additional examples of actin/myosin, microtuble/kinesin, and microtubule/dynein based movements can be explored. Abstract Molecular motors are responsible for diverse functions including the movement of (< 200 words) vesicles and organelles within cells, cell division and migration, and gross motor movement caused by muscle contraction. Because these are dynamic processes, students must know not only the basic structures of the cytoskeletal filaments (actin and microtubules) and the motors (myosins, kinesins, and dyneins), but they must also understand how ATP provides both the energy and regulation required for the directional movement of the motors along their respective filaments. Muscle contraction is familiar to all students and provides a strong conceptual framework on which students can build their knowledge of molecular motors. This unit activity is intended for use after an introduction to the cytoskeleton and sarcomere structure. It emphasizes the role of ATP hydrolysis in transferring chemical energy from ATP to a high-energy conformation of myosin (both forms of potential energy) followed by the conversion of the potential energy to kinetic energy as myosin and actin interact to result in movement. Rationale Cytoskeletal motors based movements are required for many essential processes in biology. Students are already familiar with muscle movement. Therefore, beginning the discussion of molecular motors with muscle contraction allows the students to add to their existing framework of knowledge. Teachable Unit Framework 1 National Academies Summer Institutes for Undergraduate Education in Biology Teachable Unit Framework Learning Goals: what students will know, understand, and be able to do; includes content knowledge, attitudes, & skills Learning Outcomes: Student behaviors or performances that will indicate they have successfully accomplished the goals 1. Describe how motor proteins interact with cytoskeleton components to direct movement. 2. Understand how actin and myosin interact to have a muscle cell contract. 3. Know the physical movement of the myosin and how it functions as a motor. 4. Know how ATP binding and hydrolysis regulate the interaction of actin and myosin. 1. Describe the molecular structure and functional features of a myosin molecule. 2. Dramatize the physical movement of the myosin head. 3. Discuss how the physical features of myosin allow it to function as a motor protein. 4. Sketch or arrange the interaction of myosin and actin during the ATP cycle. 5. Explain how actin and myosin interact to cause movement and muscle contraction. 6. Predict what happens if there is no ATP. Incorporation of Scientific Teaching Themes Active Learning How students will engage actively in learning the concepts Activities outside of class: Students will be expected to have read the section on myosin from their textbook or other appropriate source before coming to class. Activities during tidbit: 1. Students will order the series of events between actin and myosin during a round of ATP hydrolysis and ADP+Pi release using a strip sequence. 2. Students will dramatize the movement of myosin along actin using one arm as actin and the other as myosin. 3. Students will predict what happened during rigor. Teachable Unit Framework Assessment How teachers will measure learning; how students will selfevaluate learning Diversity How the unit is designed to include participants with a variety of experiences, abilities, and characteristics In class assessments: Formative: All students participate in the Students will use strip activity. There is a diversity of sequences to order the learning styles: visual, auditory, interactions between actin and kinesthetic. and myosin as they occur during the ATP hydrolysis cycle. Correct placement of ATP or ADP at each step will also be assessed. Clicker questions will be used to assess and correct strip sequence exercise. Students will predict what happens during rigor. Post-tidbit assessments: Summative as homework or exam What is the consequence of taking cyanide which disrupts cell respiration? 2 National Academies Summer Institutes for Undergraduate Education in Biology Teachable Unit Framework Explain in terms of molecular motors. Sketch or arrange the interaction of myosin and actin during the ATP cycle. Predict properties of various non-functional myosins- ie one with a mutated ATP binding site. Sample Presentation Plan (general schedule with approximate timing for unit) Time (min) Learning Outcome(s) Activity/assessment Preclass: (15 min) Copy worksheet and strip sequences, and label ATP and ADP stickers. Prepreportory material presentation: (3 min) Briefly introduce the structure of myosin. Activity 1: Strip sequence of interactions (7-10 min) Explanation, notes, suggestions, tips If possible, the 4 strips of the strip sequence should be printed on different colors to aide assessment. Students should have covered this material in their readings, but a review will help emphasize correct vocabulary. 1. Sketch or arrange the interaction of myosin and actin during the ATP cycle. 2. Explain how actin and myosin interact to cause Teachable Unit Framework Working in pairs or small groups, students will label the diagram of the actin / myosin cycle and identify where in the cycle ATP is hydrolyzed and ADP released. Afterwards, the instructor guides the class 3 National Academies Summer Institutes for Undergraduate Education in Biology Teachable Unit Framework movement and muclse contraction. in coming to the correct answer. Activity 2: Dramatization of actin myosin movement. (3 min) 1. Describe the molecular structure and functional features of a myosin molecule. 2. Dramatize the physical movement of the myosin head. 3. Explain how actin and myosin interact to cause movement and muscle contraction. The instructor will use one are as myosin and clearly define the HEAD (fist), NECK (wrist), HINGE (lower arm), and TAIL (upper arm). Using the other arm as actin, physically perform the movements of the cycle emphasizing when the ATP binds, is hydrolyzed and ADP released. After an initial demonstration, have the students join in performing several cycles of this process. Activity 3: Students will predict what happened during rigor. (5min) 1. Predict what happens if there is no ATP. A series of clicker and Think-Pair-Share questions lead the students through this activity. Practice beforehand is key. It is easiest to start with ATP bound to myosin and not attached to actin. 1. In this first step the fist should be closed and arm folded so that the fist is toward the shoulder. 2 and 3. Step 2 is ATP hydrolysis, which causes the myosin to adopt a high-energy conformation moving the head forward. Unfold the arm (but keep the fist closed), and bring the fist (myosin head) into contact with their other outstretched arm (actin) somewhere between the wrist and elbow (Step 3). 4. As the powerstroke occurs have the myosin “head” remain in contact with the “actin” as the arms come back. The powerstroke occurs as Pi and ADP are released, so open the fist. The myosin head remains attached until a new ATP binds. Resources for Teaching the Unit 1. Worksheet for strip sequence and individual files for generating the strips. Effectiveness of unit (if you have used it in your own teaching) Teachable Unit Framework 4 National Academies Summer Institutes for Undergraduate Education in Biology Teachable Unit Framework Acknowledgements We would like to thank Aimee Bernard, our facilitator, and other attendees at the 2013 MWSI for critical feedback on this tidbit. Teachable Unit Framework 5