Differentiated Instruction Project Janna Reighard Johns Hopkins University May 5, 2011 Introduction Unit Topic Vocabulary: Using Synonyms, Antonyms, and Words with Multiple Meanings Classroom Environment This lesson is being taught in a second grade inclusive co-taught classroom. There are 18 students in the class, 10 boys and eight girls. Three students in the class are performing two quarters below grade level expectations in reading and writing. 10 students are performing right on grade level and five students are performing above grade level expectations. One student has an IEP due to a diagnosis of autism which impacts his behavior, reading comprehension, written expression, oral expression, and problem solving skills. He is currently on grade level in reading in both reading comprehension of text. However, his ability to read text far outweighs what he is able to comprehend. He also has significant sensory needs, specifically in the area of oral motor sensory needs. The occupational therapist has designed a therapy program in order to help satisfy his sensory needs in an appropriate manner. He is currently fully included for all academic instruction. He does receive pull-out services for speech and occupational therapy. This classroom also has two students are English Language Learners (ELL). One student is performing on grade level in reading and the second student is performing above grade level in reading. These students are removed from the class daily for 30 minutes in order to receive instruction from the ELL teacher. Lesson One Title: Adjectives Subject: Language Arts Grade Level: 2 MSDE Indicator(s): 1.2.D.1 Develop and apply vocabulary through exposure to a variety of texts 1.2.D.1.a Classify and categorize words into sets and groups, such as animals, adult/baby 3.2.A.7 Identify and describe the author’s use of language 3.2.A.7.d Identify language that appeals to the senses and feelings 5.2.A.1 Identify and use grammar concepts and skills that strengthen oral and written language 5.2.A.1.a Identify and use various parts of speech, such as nouns, pronouns, verbs, and adjectives Objectives: Students will explain vocabulary related to concepts in books read. Determine how the author’s word choice can help the student understand what is read. Students will use adjectives to make their writing more interesting. Materials needed: Chart or transparency with sample sentences Two markers of different colors A copy of a short, descriptive text for each student to write on A collection of pictures or objects for students to describe (suggested pictures: ice cream, a storm, animals, foods, rocks, a beach, flowers, toys) Chart paper Index cards large enough for students to write two sentences Teacher Preparation Select a text with strong adjectives, poetry for example. You may also write a short piece to use as a demonstration model. Possible samples you may use on chart paper or overhead transparency: o The cold, damp grass sparkled as the sun began to rise. o High above the misty, purple mountains you could see the golden globe peeking over the tree-filled mountaintops. o The crazed wind howled as it passed through the valley. Have two pictures to use for the demonstration. The pictures need to depict objects that can readily be described using sensory details (color, texture, size, shape, etc.). Lesson Ask, “What does an author do to help you become interested in what he/she has to say?” o Possible student responses: The pictures are interesting. It is about a topic I am interested in. The author uses special words, so I am able to picture what is happening in the story or what the character looks like. If students are having difficulty coming up with suggestions, you may want to share a short excerpt that contains descriptive language that uses sensory details. Once students have heard a couple of examples, ask the question again, and they may be better able to contribute. Read the sample sentences aloud as the students follow along. o Sample Sentences: The cold damp grass sparkled as the sun began to rise. High above the misty, purple mountains you could see the golden globe peeking over the tree-filled mountaintops. Ask students “Were you able to picture in your minds what this place looked like? Could I have a volunteer assist me with locating and underlining the nouns in these sentences?” (grass, sun, mountains, globe, mountaintops) Next, underline the words cold and damp in a different color marker. Ask, “What are these words describing?” (nouns) Ask, “Could I have a volunteer to assist me with locating and underlining the other words in these sentences that are used to describe the nouns?” (misty, purple, golden, tree-filled) Explain that the words the writer used to help them visualize the nouns or pronouns are called adjectives. Show a picture and describe it using complete sentences with sensory details so that students can see how you have given careful thought to word choice about the picture. Make your description come alive. Show students another picture and have them help you describe it. Using shared writing, record the description on a chart large enough for the students to see. Circle the nouns in the writing and underline the adjectives. Ask students to explain the difference between nouns and adjectives. (A noun names a person, a place, a thing, or an idea. An adjective is a word that describes a noun or a pronoun.) Repeat this procedure using two other pictures. Again, model the description first. Then, using shared writing, have the students help you with the description. Invite students to circle the nouns and underline the adjectives on the chart. Have students select a picture or object. Give them an index card and have them write two to three sentences about the picture or object. Students may work in small groups or independently. Provide time for students to share. Ask students if, after hearing the way one student wrote about his/her picture/object, there was another way he/she would have written about it. The purpose for this is to say that there really isn’t one way to describe a noun. It is sometimes based on a person’s experience with it. Checking for Understanding Provide students with a short passage to read and highlight the adjectives they find. This may be done independently or in pairs. Then have students share the adjectives they were able to find. Be sure to have them identify the noun that the adjective is describing. Have students circle the nouns on their index cards and underline the adjectives that were used to describe the nouns/pronouns. Differentiation In order to teach the lesson more effectively, the teacher will use small groups to reinforce the whole group lesson. While the students are working on their independent activity (describing the picture) the teacher will pull small groups (3-5 students) based on observation from whole group lesson to reteach adjectives. Each group will only last about five minutes. The teacher will review what and adjective using pre-made sentences that are clearer than the whole group lesson. The teacher will give each student a worksheet with these sentences and they will work together to determine the adjective and the noun. After completing the worksheet together, the students will verbally tell the teacher one sentence that describes the picture or object they choose to write about. They will then return to their seats to complete the independent work. During the small group lessons and independent work, the co-teacher will help students at their desks as needed. She may help students individually or in small groups. Accommodations For the student with autism, the co-teacher will employ strategies to help him remain focused on the whole group lesson. These strategies may include giving him gum to help with sensory needs, his own copy of the text and sentences so he can follow along and underline nouns and adjectives, and providing him with breaks as needed in order to help him remain focused. The co-teacher will also provide scribe for him as needed. For the ELL students, the teacher will preview the lesson with the students to make sure they understand what a noun and an adjective is. These students will also receive their own copy of the sentences. All students will have the opportunity to reference the chart paper as needed when completing their independent work. If desired these students may also have access to individual worksheets with the sentences on them to underline with the teacher. They may use these as reference during independent work. Rationale Using small group instruction to reinforce whole group instruction allows the teacher to tailor instructional needs to individual students. Using different sentences not in the guide allows for material to be at the group’s ability level. Having the students verbally tell the teacher what they plan to write about allows the teacher to quickly assess is the student is on target. If not, they teacher can meet with the student one on one to re-teach the concept. Lesson Two Title: Using Adjectives to Set a Mood Subject: Language Arts Grade Level: 2 MSDE Indicator(s): 4.2.A.4 Identify how language choices in writing and speaking affect thoughts and feelings 4.2.A.4.a Use colorful language to convey thoughts and feelings in formal and informal writing 5.2.A.1 Identify and use grammar concepts and skills that strengthen oral and written language Objectives Students will determine how an author’s word choice helps the reader understand what was read. Materials needed: Chart paper Teacher Preparation Write the following sentences on a chart or transparency: o I learned that the thick green muck that nearly clogged my throat had a name. They call it split pea soup. o This hearty, nutritious soup will warm you on a cold winter’s day. Write the following passage on chart paper or an overhead transparency: o Hanging upside down in a small, caged chair, I could hear the cling, cling, cling sounds of change falling from my pockets. My heart was racing, and my red face felt hot from the blood gathering in my head. There is a furious fight going on in my stomach. One second longer and I wouldn’t know if I would be able to keep my cotton candy, hotdog, and cheese fries down. All of a sudden the tight skin on my face was being pushed back. The pounding force of the rushing wind was making it hard for me to control my urge to react. We were moving again, but I was so fast that I didn’t have time to yell, “Slow down! We’re crashing to the ground!” Lesson Say, “We talked about how different writers may use different adjectives to describe the same person, place, or thing. Today we will look at how the words you choose to use in your writing can affect the reader’s mood. A writer’s use of adjectives can help to make a piece of writing come alive. In other words, it seems more believable. The words that the writer uses to describe not only help the reader see what or where he/she is writing about, but also, they can help the reader get into a certain mood. For example, let’s look at the way a fourth grade student wrote about split pea soup.” Show students the sentence: I learned that the thick green muck that nearly clogged my throat had a name. They call it split pea soup. Ask, “How does this student feel about split pea soup? How could you tell she felt that way about split pea soup?” Think aloud to show how your mood may have been changed by what was said. Say, “When I read clogged my throat, I remembered back to a time when I was told to eat something I didn’t want to eat and I almost gagged. Reading this made me feel sorry for her.” Say, “Her mother may have had this to say about split pea soup: This hearty, nutritious soup will warm you on a cold winter’s day. How does her mother feel about split pea soup? How could you tell she felt that way about split pea soup?” Think aloud to show how your mood may have been changed by what was said. Say, “I felt a warm feeling inside when I read this, because it made me think of a winter day when I had been out playing in the snow. I was so cold that the bowl of soup my mom had waiting for me just felt so warm and filling. So for me the mood was that of security and comfort.” Demonstrate how you would use writing to get students to connect to the feelings you had about an event that you experienced. Start by writing this sentence on chart paper: I went on a ride at the amusement park. Ask students to tell you the mood they feel when they think of an amusement park. Jot down students’ responses. Write the sentence: o You are going to the doctor to get a shot. Ask students to tell you the mood they feel when they think about going to the doctor for a shot. Jot down students’ responses. Say, “If I were to write about riding a roller coaster, and I wanted to get my reader excited, I might write the following.” (Use the prepared passage from teacher preparation.) Ask students what the mood of this piece is. Ask, “Is it sad, cheerful, and/or exciting?” Have them explain the words that were written in the piece to help create the mood. Checking for Understanding Have students write a sentence in which they express a feeling about something that happened to them. Have them share their sentences with a partner. Have each student write the mood they get from reading their partner’s sentence. Have students tell or write about an experience they had. Remind them that they are going to use words that will help their readers feel the same way about the event as they did. Allow time for students to share and discuss. Differentiation Provide students who are having difficulty coming up with a topic to write about several examples to choose from. Make sure these examples are something that most students have experienced. For example how they felt on the first day of school, going to the dentist, having or going to a birthday party. Provide visuals of those examples for the children to choose from if they are having difficulty thinking of ways to describe a situation. Instead of writing the scenario, students may type on the computer, word processor, or use word to text software. Students may choose to illustrate their example (if they did not use a picture to help them) and then present their example orally to the class instead of writing sentences. Accommodations The student with the IEP will receive extended time as per his IEP. He can also choose to be scribed for. He will also be given a word bank and printed copies of examples for reference. The co-teacher will provide support as needed, either one to one or in a small group with other students who are having similar difficulties. The ELL students will receive a word bank and copies of examples to take to their desk. The teacher or co-teacher will check in periodically to make sure they understand the concept. Re-teaching will be provided as needed. Rationale By giving students the option of several different ways to demonstrate learning, most likely you will be able to get a true picture of what the student has learned. By providing the students with examples, you are eliminating the change of a child not finishing the project because they were unable to think of a topic. Lesson Three Title: Using Synonyms Subject: Language Arts Grade Level: 2 MSDE Indicator(s): 1.2.D.2 Develop a conceptual understanding of new words 1.2.D.2.b Identify and explain common antonyms, synonyms, and homophones to increase vocabulary skills 5.2.A.1 Identify and use grammar concepts and skills that strengthen oral and written language 5.2.A.1.a Identify and use various parts of speech, such as nouns, pronouns, verbs, and adjectives Objectives Students will identify how learning new words helps them when they read and write. Materials needed: Chart paper Teacher Preparation Write the following questions on chart paper: o What is the message? o How did the writer help you to “see” what he or she was seeing? Write the following two writing samples on chart paper so they may be presented simultaneously: First writing sample: o Dr. Rodriguez wore a pretty dress to the party at the White House. She looked nice as she walked onto the dance floor with Mr. Rodriguez. The lights from the overhead chandelier made the buttons on her dress look great. Second writing sample: o Dr. Rodriguez wore a marvelous dress to the grand party at the White House. She looked radiant as she walked onto the dance floor with Mr. Rodriguez. The brilliant lights from the overhead chandelier made the buttons on her magnificent dress sparkle. Mini-lesson Say, “I’ve noticed in your writing that many of you are attempting to bring life to your work by using adjectives to explain your nouns and pronouns. I’m noticing words such as nice, good, and great being used a lot. When I see this use of adjectives, it signals to me that it’s time to help you take your writing to the next level. We are going to work together to move your writing to a level that will help your readers get a clearer picture of what you intend for them to see. I will use a word today that some of you may be familiar with and others will hear for the first time. Raise your hand if you’ve heard the word synonym before.” Write the word synonym on the board. Explain that synonyms are words that have the same or similar meanings. Do a few examples together with students. Say, “Let’s work out a few examples of synonyms together. What word has the same meaning as: o good = __________ o bad = ____________ o pretty = ___________ Say, “Writers make their writing rich and inviting to their readers by playing with words and always trying to find the perfect word to describe how they feel and what they see. I will read two paragraphs to you, and I want you to compare them. Think about these two questions when comparing the two paragraphs.” (Display the prepared questions.) o What is the message? o How did the writer help you to “see” what he or she was seeing? Read each paragraph aloud to students. Ask for volunteers to assist you in locating the adjectives, nouns, and pronouns. Give students time to reread the paragraphs and discuss with a partner the questions you posted. Have students share their observations. Record students’ responses on chart paper. Have students record what they’ve learned in their writer’s response books. Instruct students to keep precise, descriptive adjectives in mind when they reread their writing. When they revise, they should look at the adjectives they have used and think about whether other adjectives would be better. Checking for Understanding As you read students’ writing, observe their use of precise, descriptive adjectives. Differentiation Anchor Activities o Students will be given a choice of five activities to work on after they finish their independent activity. Students will be expected to complete at least three out of the five activities. Activity 1: Students can play the synonym games found at the following websites. They can play each game one time before letting another student have a turn. Students can work in pairs. http://pbskids.org/lions/games/synsam.html http://www.scholastic.com/wordgirl/synonym_toast.htm Activity 2: Synonym word search. Students will be given a word search. First they must find the matching pairs of synonyms, and then they will complete the word search. A word search can be created at: http://tools.atozteacherstuff.com/word-search-maker/wordsearch.php Activity 3: Students can complete the following worksheet. http://www.superteacherworksheets.com/synonymsantonyms/synonyms2.pdf Activity 4: Students can complete the synonym password game. Students play this fun game in pairs. One person chooses a word card from a bag. The person then gives their partner up to three synonym “passwords” one at a time, and challenges their partner to guess their word from these clues. Students will write down any other synonyms they discover along the way. Activity 5: Thesaurus Search. Students will have a worksheet with five adjectives. They must use the thesaurus to find three synonyms for each word. Accommodations For the student with the IEP, he only has to complete one anchor activity. However, he can complete more if he chooses or has time to complete more than one activity. He can have a teacher scribe for him. He will also be given extended time if needed. This student will also have time to access the anchor activities during other appropriate times during the school day. This student will have access to a thesaurus at all times if needed. The ELL students will also receive extended time and only need to complete two anchor activities. They can choose to complete more activities is time allows. These students will be given time outside of the language arts block to work on anchor activities if the need more time. These students will be provided with a thesaurus to help with vocabulary needs. All students can have access to a thesaurus if needed. Rationale It is important to provide students with meaningful activities to complete when they have finished assigned tasks. By providing students with meaningful extension activities they are continuing their learning rather than interrupting the teacher with the question “What should I do next?” These activities should also be fun and engaging. If they aren’t, the students will simply see them as extra work and won’t be motivated to complete them. Students are given the choice to only complete three of the activities. By doing this, they will not feel overwhelmed with the amount of work to be complete. They will also have the opportunity to pick the activities that are most appealing to them. Lesson Four Title: Using Antonyms Subject: Language Arts Grade Level: 2 MSDE Indicator(s): 1.2.D.2 Develop a conceptual understanding of new words 1.2.D.2.b Identify and explain common antonyms, synonyms, and homophones to increase vocabulary skills 5.2.A.1 Identify and use grammar concepts and skills that strengthen oral and written language 5.2.A.1.a Identify and use various parts of speech, such as nouns, pronouns, verbs, and adjectives Objectives Students will use antonyms to help them understand text. Materials needed: Dry erase boards for each student Chart paper with examples of words, their antonyms, and additional space for guided practice Teacher Preparation Prepare a chart with examples of words, their antonyms, and additional space for guided practice. Example: Word Antonym Happy Sad Courageous Cowardly Good Bad Love Hate Mini-lesson Review synonyms by asking students to define the word synonyms and give examples. (Synonyms are words with the same or close to the same meaning. For example, startled and shocked are synonyms for surprised.) Say, “Today we will explore antonyms. I will give you a few examples of antonyms and I would like for you to think about the definition of an antonym.” Say the first word in the column labeled Word and then the word directly across from it in the column labeled Antonym. Continue using the next three examples. Ask, “What connections do you see between the column labeled Word and the column directly across from it labeled Antonym?” Ask students to help you generate a definition of antonyms. (Antonyms are words that mean the opposite.) Ask students to share other antonyms for the words in the column labeled Word. For example, if the word is happy and the antonym is sad, what other word could have been used as the antonym for sad? Guided Practice Word Antonym(s) Happy Sad Courageous Cowardly Good Bad Love Hate Ceiling Sloppy Fast Opposite Old Have students use their dry erase boards to write an antonym for each of the words that don’t have a word in the antonym column located adjacent to it. Do one word at a time. Remember there may be more than one correct response, so you will need to record all of them. Provide an opportunity for students to share other examples of words and their antonyms in the lower sections of the chart. Say, “We study antonyms because they help us identify relationships between words and phrases. For example, when a writer writes the little puppy wasn’t happy, in our minds we may be thinking the puppy was sad because that makes sense to us.” Checking For Understanding Provide a few examples for students to show what they know about antonyms. Possible samples: 1. Susan’s mother wasn’t pleased with her when she saw that Susan had spilled paint on her new jacket. Say, “We know that pleased means (pause so that students can help with the definition) ________, so we know that the mother is _______. 2. The number eight is greater than the number seven, but not greater than the number nine. Say, “What is another way the italicized section could have been stated?” (Possible response: The number eight is less that the number nine.) 3. It wasn’t dark outside. Say, “If it isn’t dark outside, what could it look like outside? (Possible responses: light, bright, etc.) Differentiation Multiple Intelligences o Students will create a project of their choice that demonstrates understanding of antonyms. The project will highlight the child’s strength based on Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences. Students may create a song, poster, story, model, game, cheer, etc. that represents antonyms. Students must have their idea approved by the teacher. Students will be graded on understanding using a rubric. Students will then present their projects to the class. o Rubric: Name: Project: Demonstrates correct definition of antonym /5 Orally presented project /5 Demonstrated creativity /5 Total /15 Accommodations The student with the IEP and the ELL students will be given several examples of projects he could create if needed. The teacher will provide scribe if needed. This student will have extended time to complete his project. All students will have access to examples of projects if they have difficulty coming up with their own ideas. Rationale Not all students learn in the same way. By tapping into their strengths, a student can truly show you what they know. Also by giving the students the freedom to demonstrate their knowledge in a way that interests them will allow them to be completely engaged in the learning process. Lesson Five Title: Words with Multiple Meanings Subject: Language Arts Grade Level: 2 MSDE Indicator(s): 1.2.D.3 Understand, acquire, and use new vocabulary 1.2.D.3.a Determine the meanings of unknown words: Reread; use context clues; read on; use text features Objectives Students will identify examples of words with multiple meanings in text. Materials needed: Marker Chart paper Student Copies of “What Does It Mean?” organizer A variety of Amelia Bedelia books Eight Ate, A feast of Homonym Riddles Why the Banana Split A Chocolate Moose for Dinner The King Who Rained A Little Pigeon Toad On chart paper, write the following 3-column “What Does It Mean?” organizer. Word What the word means What clue helped me determine the meaning of the word? Before Reading Tell students that authors sometimes use words that can have several different meanings. For example, the word ring can mean the sound that a bell makes, or a circle, or a piece of jewelry that you wear on your finger. An author would use other words with the word ring to help us know which meaning she wanted us to have. The author might write: The bell had a loud ring to it; The students formed a ring in the center of the gym; The king placed the ring on his finger. We know the meanings of the word ring from the other words in the sentences. Introduce the story Teach Us, Amelia Bedelia by showing the cover of the book. Ask students to talk with a partner and think about what they know about Amelia Bedelia from reading or hearing about her. Ask for students’ ideas. (Bring out the fact that the meanings of words sometimes confuse her.) Give a brief book introduction stating what the author’s intent was for the book. Suggested book introduction: “Peggy Parish has written several humorous books about Amelia Bedelia, who seems always to get confused. Amelia Bedelia works for Mrs. Rogers by taking care of her house. In this book, Amelia Bedelia is substituting at school until the new teacher gets there. To confuse her character, Peggy Parish uses words that have multiple meanings. For example, Amelia Bedelia is told to call the roll. Instead of calling the names of the students from a class list or class roll, she borrows a roll made of dough from a student’s lunchbox and calls it! There are many other examples of words with multiple meanings. Today we will read the list that was given to Amelia Bedelia by Mr. Carter, the principal. Then, as we read the story, I want you to think about two things: The meanings of the words and how the author let you know what each word meant.” During Reading Display the 3-column What Does It Mean? organizer. Think aloud to demonstrate how you determine the meaning of the words. For example, say, “We talked about the first job- Call the roll. Let’s look at the next job- Plant a bulb. I know that a bulb that we would plant looks something like an onion. Let’s read to see what Amelia Bedelia did.” Open the book to the pages where Amelia Bedelia is reading this job and doing it in her own way (pages 24-28). Talk about how the word bulb can also mean the glass part of a lamp that gives off light when it is turned on. Say, “I am going to write the word bulb on the chart in the first column. In the second column, I am going to write the definition that goes with the meaning on the list—a plant bud that develops underground. In the third column I am going to write that the clue was the word plant because I know that you plant bulbs that grow underground.” Record the information on the 3-column chart. Involve the students in the other examples. Read each job on the list and point out the highlighted word. Discuss what it means in the context of the other words. Then read the book to see how Amelia Bedelia defined the word. Discuss the multiple meanings of the word, but return to the context of the word to determine the author’s definition. Record the students’ responses on the 3-column chart. After Reading Pose the following question to students: “In the story Amelia Bedelia, how did Peggy Parish help you know the correct meanings of the words?” Use the think-pair-share strategy. Establish that the context in which the words were used best determined the meanings of each word. Discuss how knowing the context would help students with future readings. Provide an example from a text that they may currently be reading or from a text that they have already read. Literature Circles (can be split into 2 days if needed) After the whole group lesson, student will participate in literature circles. The teacher will review 5 pre-selected texts that feature words with multiple meanings. o Eight Ate, A feast of Homonym Riddles o Why the Banana Split o A Chocolate Moose for Dinner, o The King Who Rained o A Little Pigeon Toad Students will then choose which book they would like to read with no more than 4 children per group. The teacher will allow the students in to chose their desired role. o Connector o Word Wizard o Questioner o Illustrator Students will then be given 30 minutes to read and discuss their books. After 30 minutes, students will be given 30 minutes to come up with a way to present the words with multiple meanings in the books. Students can act out the words, make a poster, etc. Allow each group 5 minutes to present the final product. Independent Practice Use other Amelia Bedelia stories to provide practice with determining the author’s meaning through the context of the story. Supply students (individually or pairs) with the attached graphic organizer Have the students make collections of words with multiple meanings. Point out that dictionaries are great sources for finding words with many definitions, such as the word spring that has as many as 36 definitions and the word play that has as many as 67 entries. Have them write as many definitions for each word as they can. Then have the students use the words in sentences. Have other students match the meanings of the words in sentences with the corresponding definitions. Closure/Evaluation Give students practice with vocabulary development using the following format: Select the sentence in which the word is used in the same way as the underlined word in the given sentence. Have you ever seen the play called The Secret Garden? 1. I made a great play in yesterday’s soccer game. 2. Who will play the part of the tricky fox? 3. We are all going to try out for the school play. 4. My dog likes to play catch with me. Accommodations For the student with the IEP, he will be given a chance to preview the books prior to the lesson and choose which book he would like to use for the literature circles in advance as well as what role he would like. During the whole group lesson he will be given first choice in order to ensure he receives the book and role he feels comfortable with. The ELL students will be given a chance to preview the books prior to the lesson. The teacher will also review the different roles with the students and the expectations of each role in order for the students to have a complete understand of the task. Rationale Literature circles are an excellent way to meet the needs of diverse students in the classroom. Literature circles meet the needs of students based on interests, ability level, and assessment needs. Literature circles can be grouped using homogenous and heterogeneous grouping. You can allow students to choose what type of product they would like to use to demonstrate their learning as well as showcasing the book they read. Since a literature circle is an ongoing project, students are not graded based on their ability to answer a comprehension question. Name:_______________________________ Date:_______________________________ What Does It Mean? Word What the word means What clue helped me determine the meaning of the word?