School-Wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (SWPBIS) Northeast PBIS (NEPBIS) School-Wide Team Training Day 8 INSERT TRAINER NAMES with support from Brandi Simonsen, Jen Freeman, Susannah Everett, & George Sugai Advance Organizer • Quick Recap of Day 7 Training • Celebrate Accomplishments • Tier 1: Class-Wide PBIS – Focus on practices – Focus on Systems • Action Planning TIER 1 LEADERSHIP TEAM & COACHES MEETINGS • 3 days Coaches Meetings 2 Coaches • 2 days of TA per district Admin, Coach, Data Entry • 3 days of Team Training Same above • 3 days Coaches Meetings Same above • 2 days of TA per district Same above • 2 days of Team Training Same above • 3 days Coaches Meetings Same above • 2 days of TA per district Same above YEAR 1 • 6 days of Team Training Minimum membership: administrator, grade level representatives, support staff YEAR 2 WHO YEAR 3+ WHAT Tier 2 Training will also be offered to schools implementing Tier 1 with fidelity. MAIN TRAINING OBJECTIVES in YEAR 2 • Enhance leadership team • Maintain staff agreements • Enhance knowledge of SWPBIS outcomes, data, practices, and systems • Refine individualized action plan for SWPBIS • Enhance and sustain implementation in future years TRAINING EXPECTATIONS: RESPECT… SELF • Self-monitor (Are you participating? Engaged as a learner? Talking during allotted times?) • Stretch, break, stand as needed OTHERS • Cell phones (inaudible): Converse in lobbies and breaks • Work as a team: Room for every voice, reinforce participation ENVIRONMENT • Recycle • Maintain neat working area Tools! nepbis.org pbis.org Ca Pur pa cit pos Dis y Bu e ild tric in tL eve g— l DIS TR M ICT S/S CH OO Dis eas ure As trict ses C sm apac en t (D ity CA ) LS IN TR AIN IN Fid G ple elity Co Bu menta of m ild the plete ing tion Pro — PB Le ass supp d by Fu gre vel IS ess ort dis ncti Tie P —B ss M tr o lan o d re Inv o uil nin istric f a tra ict lea n ento d Fid din nito g. t ca ine d Lea ri ry (T elity gL pac d fa ership eve ng FI) c sup dersh ity l Pro and ilitato team criti port ip te gre to g r) to (wit a o Se s h and cal fe f exte m se uid lf-A —T s Mo lf a eA rn -e III. ture eam nit ctio Su sses s o al coa valua rve s n Le oring fP y (S ment ve l Us BIS ch) to tion (w e AS acro ass ith ass d by ) ss ess sys essm scho Sc T th iers o ho e Pla tems ent o l staff ol I, II Imp Team Cli nnin in th f eff fo , ma lem eir ecti r init g. Ch te As ia sch ve eck entati e ool beh l and list o mu lf-as and avio ann (TIC n Ge PB lti-lev sessm o to g r su ual ) IS el g ent Cli rgia p A u s tatu cti u ide port ma S to Ac te S choo s o on P ide fo ol th ti f im r l la a on urv ple ns a creati t serv eys An n me n nta d eva g Sc es as (gra annu ho tion lu a perc des al surv acti ating ol-W 3 vitie the ide and eptio -12), ey th s. abo high ns o teac at as f h s self ut ad scho scho er, a esse n o o o Stu dro -harm lesc l surv l clim d pa s stud de X e e nt nt surv pout, idea nt dru eys ate. rent Ou T a tco tra ey p and p tion a g/alc lso in he m me climining rovide aren nd be ohol/ clud iddle s e s ta to h s ate upp , sa ort informl invo aviors bacc items o Sc lv fe , n u e a s e hoo Info ty, and eds re tion to ment. choo se, lrm atio wide vio late dete The l Off len ic (SW n Sys ce d to s rmin data e dis tem pre cho e IS) ven ol dec for ciplin tion m adm ision-m onth e refe . rra a ly pre inis ven trato king team ls (O tion rs, by te rev DR) pro X ac iew effo and rts oth hers s and vide and er s , Ac taff tion to Pla guid nnin e g. Im Ye ar Win ter 1T rain ED UL E Ye ar Fa ll X 2T Win te X X X X X X X X X We ekly We ekly We ekly We ekly We ekly Action Plan SC H ing Sp ring Legend New Content Guidelines Training Organization Review +Ex -Ex Activity Legend Section Header (I.A) Chapter Header (e.g., I) Review of Day 7 We reviewed guidelines, examples, Critical Features of PBISand did a self-check for critical implementation steps Supporting Culturally Equitable Social Competence & Academic Achievement OUTCOMES Supporting Culturally Knowledgeable Staff Behavior (Vincent, Randal, Cartledge, Tobin, & SwainBradway, 2011; Sugai, O’Keefe, & Fallon 2012 ab) Supporting Culturally Valid Decision Making PRACTICES I.C Supporting Culturally Relevant Evidence-based Interventions We Previewed Two New Tier 1 Topics: • • Equity Integrating Initiatives: Bully Prevention Equity (adapted from Kent McIntosh) Disproportionality in School Discipline (Losen & Skiba, 2010) Definitions • Overt Bias – Conscious belief in superiority of a group • Explicit Bias – Conscious belief that some groups aspire to desirable traits more than others • Implicit Bias – Unconscious associations regarding some groups A 5-point Intervention to Enhance Equity in School Discipline http://www.pbis.org/school/equity-pbis 5-point Intervention to Enhance Equity in School Discipline 1. Use effective instruction to reduce the achievement gap 2. Implement SWPBIS to build a foundation of prevention 3. Collect, use, and report disaggregated student discipline data 4. Develop policies with accountability for disciplinary equity 5. Teach neutralizing routines for vulnerable decision points http://www.pbis.org/school/equity-pbis Integrating Initiatives: Bully Prevention in PBIS (adapted from George Sugai, Aug 2010) Doesn’t Work • Label student • Exclude student • Blame family • Punish student • Assign restitution • Ask for apology Works • Teach targeted social skills • Reward social skills • Teach all • Individual for nonresponsive behavior • Invest in positive school-wide culture PBIS Prevention Goals & Bullying Behavior •Establish positive, predictable, consistent, Goal 1 rewarding school culture for all across all settings •Teach social skills that work at least as well as or Goal 2 better than problem behavior •Respond to nonresponsive behavior proactively & Goal 3 differently, rather than reactively & more of same •Actively supervise & precorrect for problem Goal 4 behaviors & settings, especially nonclassroom School “Show and Tell” Activity: Show, Tell, and Ask • Work as team for 10 min • Review your action plan and identify – 1-2 accomplishments since last time we met – 1-2 questions or concerns shared by most members of team • You’ll have 3-5 min to show, tell, and ask! Class-Wide PBIS: Focus on Practices Critical Features of Evidence-based Classroom Management Acknowledgements for this portion: Other Members of Research Team: Sarah Fairbanks, Amy Briesch, Diane Myers, & George Sugai www.pbis.org www.cber.org SWPBS Systems Classroom Non-classroom Student Family What “kind” of students can display problematic behavior? All students. Students with/without labels who are served in general/special education can display problematic behavior. This is not a special education issue. It is an education issue. We need to learn more about the 5 critical features of effective classroom management to be able to help all students. Evidence Based Practices in Classroom Management 1. Maximize structure in your classroom. 2. Post, teach, review, monitor, and reinforce a small number of positively stated expectations. 3. Actively engage students in observable ways. 4. Establish a continuum of strategies to acknowledge appropriate behavior. 5. Establish a continuum of strategies to respond to inappropriate behavior. (Simonsen, Fairbanks, Briesch, Myers, & Sugai, 2008) 1. Maximize structure in your classroom. • Develop Predictable Routines – Teacher routines – Student routines • Design environment to (a) elicit appropriate behavior and (b) minimize crowding and distraction: – – – – Arrange furniture to allow easy traffic flow. Ensure adequate supervision of all areas. Designate staff & student areas. Seating arrangements (groups, carpet, etc.) 2. Post, Teach, Review, Monitor, and reinforce a small number of positively stated expectations. Establish Evaluate Monitor Teach Prompt Establish Behavioral expectations/Rules • Operationally define what the rules look like across all the routines and settings in your school. • One way to do this is in a matrix format. • This matrix should compliment your school-wide matrix, but be specific to your classroom setting. Rules within Routines Matrix Routines Rules Respect Responsibility Safety Entering Classroom Seat Work Small Group Activity Leaving Classroom Teach rules in the context of routines • Teach expectations directly. – Define rule in operational terms—tell students what the rule looks like within routine. – Provide students with examples and non-examples of rulefollowing within routine. • Actively involve students in lesson—game, role-play, etc. to check for their understanding. • Provide opportunities to practice rule following behavior in the natural setting. Prompt or remind students of the rule • Provide students with visual prompts (e.g., posters, illustrations, etc). • Use pre-corrections, which include “verbal reminders, behavioral rehearsals, or demonstrations of rule-following or socially appropriate behaviors that are presented in or before settings were problem behavior is likely” (Colvin, Sugai, Good, Lee, 1997). Percent of Intervals What happens when we prompt a student ONE time at the beginning of class? 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Baseline Student 1 Alternating Treatments No Prompt Prompt 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Observation Sessions (Faul, Stepensky, & Simonsen, under review) It worked for the next student too! Student 2 Percent of Intervals No Prompt 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Baseline Alternating Treatments Prompt 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Observation Sessions (Faul, Stepensky, & Simonsen, under review) Monitor students’ behavior in natural context • Active Supervision (Colvin, Sugai, Good, Lee, 1997): » Move around » Look around (Scan) » Interact with students » Reinforce » Correct Evaluate the effect of instruction • Collect data – Are rules being followed? – If there are errors, •who is making them? •where are the errors occurring? •what kind of errors are being made? • Summarize data (look for patterns) • Use data to make decisions Simonsen, Myers, Everett, Sugai, Spencer, & A lesson plan that prompts the critical features just described: 2. RECAP: Post, Teach, Review, Monitor, and reinforce a small number of positively stated expectations. Establish Evaluate Monitor Teach Prompt 3. Actively engage students in observable ways. Provide high rates of opportunities to respond Consider various observable ways to engage students Link engagement with outcome objectives Range of evidence based practices that promote active engagement Direct Instruction Computer Assisted Instruction Class-wide Peer Tutoring Guided notes Response Cards 4. Establish a continuum of strategies to acknowledge appropriate behavior. • Specific and Contingent Praise • Group Contingencies • Behavior Contracts • Token Economies Specific and Contingent Praise • Praise should be… – …contingent: occur immediately following desired behavior – …specific: tell learner exactly what they are doing correctly and continue to do in the future •“Good job” (not very specific) •“I like how you are showing me active listening by having quiet hands and feet and eyes on me” (specific) Group Contingencies • Three types: – “All for one” (Interdependent Group Contingency) – “One for all” (Dependent Group Contingency – “To each his/her own” (Independent Group Contingency) Behavioral Contracts • A written document that specifies a contingency for an individual student or in this case…whole class • Contains the following elements: – Operational definition of BEHAVIOR – Clear descriptions of REINFORCERS – OUTCOMES if student fails to meet expectations. – Special BONUSES that may be used to increase motivation or participation. (Wolery, Bailey, & Sugai, 1988) Class Constitution In Mrs. Gaines’ class, we are respectful to others, responsible for our selves, and create a safe environment. We will be recognized (with kind words and points) by Mrs. Gaines when we demonstrate these behaviors. When we forget, we will be reminded. If the whole class demonstrates these behaviors most of the time (earns X% of points) for X days, we will be able to choose a fun activity for Friday Fun. My signature shows that I understand and agree. Mrs. Gaines Luis Abby Jacob Roisin Caleb Establishing a Token Economy • • • • • • • Determine and teach the target skills Select tokens Identify what will be back-up reinforcers Identify the number of tokens required to receive back-up reinforcers Define and teach the exchange and token delivery system Define decision rules to change/fade the plan Determine how the plan will be monitored (Guidelines from Sulzer-Azaroff & Mayer, 1991) Considerations for Token Economies • A token can easily provide immediate feedback about student behavior, while delaying the presentation of the back-up reinforcer. • Allows you to avoid satiation of reinforcers. • Beware of counterfeiters. • Do you plan on only giving tokens for appropriate behavior? Or, will you implement a response cost procedure? 5. Establish a continuum of strategies to respond to inappropriate behavior. • Error Corrections • Differential Reinforcement • Planned ignoring • Response Cost • Time out from reinforcement Quick Error Corrections • Error corrections should be… – …contingent: occur immediately after the undesired behavior – …specific: tell learner exactly what they are doing incorrectly and what they should do differently in the future – …brief: after redirecting back to appropriate behavior, move on Types of Differential Reinforcement • DR…of lower rates of behavior (DRL) • DR…of other behaviors (DRO) • DR…of alternative behavior (DRA) • DR…of incompatible behavior (DRI) Planned Ignoring Definition: • If a behavior is maintained by adult attention …consider planned ignoring (e.g., ignore behavior of interest) Examples: • Taylor talks out in class and his teacher currently responds to him approximately 60% in the time (either + or -). • The teacher decides to ignore all talk outs and instead only call on him when his hand is raised. Response Cost Definition: • The withdrawal of specific amounts of a reinforcer contingent upon inappropriate behavior. Examples: • A wrong answer results in a loss of points. • Come to class without a pencil, buy one for 5 points. Response Cost Cont’d • Response cost procedures fit best within a token economy. • Generally, better to stick to the positives... – What happens if you continue to take away points? – How do you retrieve tokens once they have been given? • REMEMBER we always want a higher ratio of positives to negatives!!!!! : Time-out Definition: • A child (or class) is removed from a previously reinforcing environment or setting, to one that is not reinforcing Example: • Child throws a rock at another child on the playground. The child is removed to the office…. • REMEMBER the environment the child is removed to cannot be reinforcing!!! So, if the child receives adult attention in the office, which they find reinforcing, YOU have NOT put the child on time out RECAP: Evidence Based Practices in Classroom Management 1. Maximize structure in your classroom. 2. Post, teach, review, monitor, and reinforce a small number of positively stated expectations. 3. Actively engage students in observable ways. 4. Establish a continuum of strategies to acknowledge appropriate behavior. 5. Establish a continuum of strategies to respond to inappropriate behavior. Does this remind you of anything you’ve (Simonsen, Fairbanks, Briesch,seen Myers, &before? Sugai, 2008) Evidence-Based Practices in Classroom Management 1. 2. 3. IV.B Minimize crowding & distraction Maximize structure & predictability State, review, & reinforce positively stated expectations. 4. Provide more acknowledgement for appropriate than inappropriate behaviors. 5. Maximize varied opportunities to respond. 6. Maximize active engagement. 7. Actively & continuously supervise. 8. Respond to inappropriate behaviors quickly, positively, & directly. 9. Establish multiple strategies for acknowledging appropriate behavior. 10. Generally provide specific feedback for errors & corrects. Another useful resource from OSEP and pbis.org Interactive!Map!of!Core!Features! Interactive Map of Core " " Classroom"Interventions"and"Supports Foundations"(Table"1) 1.1"Settings The!physical!layout!of!the! classroom!is!designed!to!be! effective 1.2"Routines Predictable!classroom! ! routines!are!developed!and! taught 1.3"Expectations Three!to!five!classroom!rules! are!clearly!posted,!defined,! and!explicitly!taught Features Practices"(Table"2) Data"Systems"(Table"3) Prevention Response 2.1"Supervision Provide!reminders! (prompts),!and!actively! scan,!move,!and!interact! with!students 2.5"Error"Corrections Use!brief,!contingent,!and! specific!statements!when! misbehavior!occurs 2.2"Opportunity Provide!high!rates!and! varied!opportunities!for!all! students!to!respond! 2.3"Acknowledgment ! Using!specific!praise!and! other!strategies,!let! students!know!when!they! meet!classroom! expectations 2.4"Prompts"and" Precorrections Provide!reminders,!before! a!behavior!is!expected,! that!clearly!describe!the! expectation 2.6"Other"Strategies Use!other!strategies!that! preempt!escalation,! minimize!inadvertent! reward!of!the!problem! ! behavior,!create!a! learning!opportunity!for! emphasizing!desired! behavior,!and!maintain! optimal!instructional!time! 2.7"Additional"Tools" More!tips!for!teachers!! 3.1"Counting Record!how!often!or!how! many!times!a!behavior! occurs!(also!called! frequency) 3.2"Timing Record!how!long!a!behavior! lasts!(also!called!duration). 3.3"Sampling Estimate!how!often!a! ! behavior!occurs!during!part! of!an!interval,!the!entire! interval,!or!at!the!end!of!an! interval! 3.4"ABC"Cards,"Incident" Reports,"or"Office" Discipline"Referrals Record!information!about! the!events!that!occurred! before,!during,!and!after!a! behavior!incident Self-Assessment Decision Making Chart Tables with Definitions, Examples, Non-Examples, and Resources Additional Tools Scenarios to illustrate implementation Activity: Discussion on Class-Wide PBIS • Work as team for 15 min • Review “Supporting and Responding to Behavior” on pbis.org • Discuss the extent to which you believe all/most teachers are implementing all/most of the evidence-based critical features of classroom management. • What are biggest challenges? • Prepare to present 1 “big idea” from your group. Class-Wide PBIS: Focus on Systems To Support Implementation What is implementation? • Implementation is “…specified set of activities designed to put into practice an activity or program of known dimensions” (Fixsen, Naoom, Blasé, Friedman, & Wallace, 2005, p. 5) • It’s what we do. • Implementation outcomes include “changes in… – “…adult professional behavior” – “…organizational structures and cultures…to support the changes in adult professional behavior” – “…relationships to consumers, stakeholders, …and systems partners” (Fixsen et al., 2005, p. 12) Isn’t there science to guide implementation? Translated into our language (based on theirs)… • Begin with an “it” (evidence-based practice [EBP] or program; aka “source” or “best example”) • Identify the “who” (individuals who work to implement with fidelity; aka “purveyors”) • Identify the “where” (individuals and organizations that will adopt the EBP; aka “destination”) • Determine “how”: train, prompt, and use data (performance feedback; aka “feedback mechanism” or information flow) • Consider context (aka “influence”) (Fixsen, Naoom, Blasé, Friedman, & Wallace, Isn’t there science to guide implementation? “New “Old Way” It: EBP Where: Teacher / Classroom Context Who: Implementation “Supporters” How: Train, prompt, use data (Fixsen, Naoom, Blasé, Friedman, & Wallace, This is one way to start organizing our implementation supports It: EBP We know what these are! Where: Teacher / Classroom We know where! But… Who:? Implementation “Supporters” Expert Peer How SelfContext often? How:? Train, prompt, use data Who On what? needs what? (Adapted from Fixsen, Naoom, Blasé, Friedman, & We can’t afford to do everything, but we can’t afford to do nothing... We think there’s a lot in between! NOTHING BUT, how do we organize all of this? No Training or Support Provided “Sit and Get” training delivered in isolation Didactic training + email reminders Didactic training + email reminders + periodic check-ins PLUS Self-management supports EVERYTHING Every teacher receives coaching and performance feedback Multi-tiered Framework of Professional Development Support Progress Monitoring Walk-through, Student Data Review, Teacher Collected Data Universal Screening Walk-through & Student Data Review Tier 3 Intensive PD: Data-driven Consultation Tier 2 Targeted PD: Self-Management with Peer or Coaching Supports Tier 1 Universal PD: Training & SelfManagement (adapted from Simonsen, MasSuga, Briere, Freeman, Myers, Scott, & Sugai, 2013) Bottom line… “training by itself does not result in positive implementation…or intervention outcomes” (Fixen, Naoom, Blasé, Friedman, & Wallace, 2005, pp. 40-41) So, what do we do? 74 One approach: Self-Management • Across multiple studies, we’ve found that selfmanagement with email coaching prompts resulted in desired initial increases in specific classroom management skills across teachers. We are still working Teachers… and generalization of effects. to enhance maintenance (Simonsen, Freeman, Dooley, Maddock, & Kern, under review; • Set a goal (criterion for selfSimonsen Freeman, Dooley, Kern, & Maddock, in preparation) reinforcement) • Self-monitored daily • Entered data into an Excel Spreadsheet, which automatically graphed daily skillrates relative to goal • Self-evaluated and self-reinforced • Received weekly email prompts to use skill and submit data Strategies…What do you do? • One shot in-service? • On-going training? • Mentoring? • Coaching? • Performance feedback? • _____________________ • _____________________ • _____________________ 76 Examples from schools… • Principal reviews 1 strategy per faculty meeting and gives grade-level (or content-specific) teams time to action plan around incorporating the strategy into their classrooms. • Dean of Students has teachers read a book on classroom management (e.g., Colvin’s book) and provides explicit training on each strategy (with CEUs). • School arranges peer mentors for all new or struggling teachers. Mentors model and then provide coaching and feedback. 77 Other examples… • Principal teaches one strategy (e.g., praise) and asks teachers to self-monitor their use of that strategy during 1 instructional activity per day for a week. Teachers turn in their praise rates with a plan to improve or maintain their levels. • PBS team members present content on classroom management (e.g., matrix, lesson plans, etc.). Then, they hold “workshop” drop in hours—when teachers can come get assistance with creating their products. 78 Activity: Jigsaw Class-Wide PBIS Systems • Work as team for 15 min • Brainstorm ideas for improving classroom management at your school • Jigsaw for 15-20 min • Count off and share ideas with individuals from other schools to refine/expand your ideas. • Return to school team and share 10 min • Return to your school team, debrief, and add relevant action steps to your action plan. • Prepare to present 1 “big idea” from your group. SWPBIS Action Planning Activity: Action Planning • Work as team for 75 min • Complete the Team Implementation Checklist • Return to your Action Plan • Focus on classroom practices and systems discussed today, and review classroom data summarized by your coach. • Identify relevant resources and steps to help move your school forward. • Present 2-3 “big ideas” from your group (1 min. reports) Review of SWPBIS Critical Features of PBIS Supporting Culturally Equitable Social Competence & Academic Achievement OUTCOMES Supporting Culturally Knowledgeable Staff Behavior (Vincent, Randal, Cartledge, Tobin, & SwainBradway, 2011; Sugai, O’Keefe, & Fallon 2012 ab) Supporting Culturally Valid Decision Making PRACTICES I.C Supporting Culturally Relevant Evidence-based Interventions Evidence Based Practices in Classroom Management 1. Maximize structure in your classroom. 2. Post, teach, review, monitor, and reinforce a small number of positively stated expectations. 3. Actively engage students in observable ways. 4. Establish a continuum of strategies to acknowledge appropriate behavior. 5. Establish a continuum of strategies to respond to inappropriate behavior. (Simonsen, Fairbanks, Briesch, Myers, & Sugai, 2008) Another useful resource from OSEP and pbis.org Multi-tiered Framework of Professional Development Support Progress Monitoring Walk-through, Student Data Review, Teacher Collected Data Universal Screening Walk-through & Student Data Review Tier 3 Intensive PD: Data-driven Consultation Tier 2 Targeted PD: Self-Management with Peer or Coaching Supports Tier 1 Universal PD: Training & SelfManagement (adapted from Simonsen, MasSuga, Briere, Freeman, Myers, Consider Tattoos! 4 PBIS Elements School Systems Supporting Social Competence & Academic Achievement OUTCOMES Classroom Supporting Decision Making Supporting Staff Behavior SWPBIS Non-classroom PRACTICES ~5% Supporting Student Behavior Primary Prevention: School-/ClassroomWide Systems for All Students, Staff, & Settings Tertiary Prevention: Specialized Individualized Systems for Students with High-Risk Behavior ~15% Secondary Prevention: Specialized Group Systems for Students with At-Risk Behavior ~80% of Students Family Student