Dusit International Assignment III ICTM 401 Strategic Management for Travel Industry Amica Rangnoktai ID- 5080579 Sumandeep Thakral ID- 5180657 Naval Thakral ID- 5180658 Vethida Sithichaiudom ID- 5180832 Shivanshai Sethichaiyen ID- 5280510 Table of Contents 1. Strategic Acquisition and Restructuring 1.2 Mergers and Acquisitions Mergers DusitSindhorn Co., Ltd. with Kempinski Hotels At first seemed unlikely match,Dusit Sindhorn Co., Ltd., connected to the Dusit Thani Public Company, Limited and owner of Dusit Hotels and Resorts has taken over German Based Kempinski Hotels. The Kempinski is in 12 different countries own 18 branches of prime hotels. After all the fuss of closing down the German headquarters was over and opening new hotels. They immerged as Dusit-Kempinski. This strategy was implemented as an access to other markets as hotels from Japan and Hong Kong were proving to be a threat(Institutional Investor, 1995). This so-called acquisition happened in late 1994. Dusit Thani senior vice president KhampiSuwanarat said after the merger. “We plan to have 35 deluxe hotels under Dusit-Kempinski by the end of next year. Also, they feel that, to make the company viable, they must have 50 hotels. The target is to accomplish this within three years.” However later during the year that A Kempinski spokeswoman said. “Dusit Thani and the Siam Commercial Bank each owned 50% of the Bangkok-based Siam Sindhorn company, which owns 83% percent of Kempinski Hotels. Kempinski operates the Campton Place Hotel in San Francisco as well as hotels in Argentina, Bulgaria, Canada, China, France, Germany, Hungary, India, Japan, Russia, Switzerland and Turkey. Dusit Hotels and Resorts operate 13 hotels.” Dusit Thani has been meaning to sell the Kempinski shares since the Kempinski spokesmen said that Dusit International is not willing to fund the expansion of Kempinski. This shows that the acquisition was not as successful as expected. Dusit Hotels and Resorts Co., Ltd. and Royal Princess PCL. Dusit Thani Hotels and Resorts Company Limited completed the merger with Royal Princess Public Company Limited. They passed this resolution on 29th of April in 2008, transferring all their operation licenses of such subsidiary to this new merger calling it Dusit Princess. Dusit princess was created with a meeting between the two company’s shareholders agreeing to merge to enhance their power against competitors as well as creating a corporate level strategy. This merger was created to assist each other in recourses management as well as knowledge and guests information sharing to compete on the corporate level. Royal Princess gains the strong Brand Name of Dusit Thani as well as the affiliation with their training center like Dusit Thani College and La- Cordon bluer to enhance their staff abilities. The Dusit Thani reputation will help them draw in customers. Dusit Thani on the other hand will benefit from more resources and save cost from opening and reconstructing a brand new hotel as far as diversity is concerned they can achieve it through this merger. (Merger, 2008) Acquisition Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket For the past 23 years Dusit Thani has been managing one of their most successful Branches in Phuket. Dusit Thani announced that branch over 2 decades ago that seem to show promise on its performance after the acquisition. Laguna Resorts & Hotels Public Limited Company, part of the Banyan Tree Group, previously owned this. Now as Dusit Thani acquired it and it is now called Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket. Dusit Thani emerged supreme as the highest bidder and was delighted to beat their competitions to achieve this acquisition. “Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket has been one of our best managed hotels for over two decades, and has never dropped its performance, even despite the many challenges over this period.” The destination was eyed and studies by Dusit International for a while before the decision to bid on it. They believe in diversity of having a resort as they believe in the charm of Laguna’s destination and brand. By acquiring the resort Dusit Thani learned more about the operations of the resort and with their strength in staff management they are able to deliver service quality and maintain their standards. Dusit Thani also shows appreciation of their affiliations with Banyan Tree and Laguna Resorts & Hotels by still keeping the brand name “Laguna”. The brand relationships strengthen as this proves to enhance the growth curve of their Phuket customers as well as their performance. Dusit Thani has faith in this resort in its potential to yield profit for their company in the future. This acquisition will prove a greater strength in Dusit Thani’s variety to guests and enhancement of company’s assets, shifting them to a greater position in the market at they are growing rapidly internationally. Another purpose of this acquisition is also to enhance their presence in Thailand. This is one of the strategies Dusit Thani use as a means of expansion in Thailand; by searching for potential deals in acquiring key strategic destinations in Thailand as assistance to their brand growth. The latest report STR Global on Strong Recovery in Southeast Asia identified Phuket as one of the most prosperous cities in South East Asia with a RevPAR growth of up to 36.7% for 2010 and 2009; this ranked them as the second highest in South East Asia. The Latest Dusit Thani’s Laguna Phuket’s RevPAR amounted up to 16% growth compared to the competition’s average of just around 9%. Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket is also well known in an award winning environmental project in Bang Tao Bay, Phuket. Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket has also built its reputation to be one of the leading specialists in the MICE events providing excellent conventional as well as conference facilities. The Latitude venue in Dusit Thani Laguna that can accommodate 1,000 guests in a theatre style setting with 226 rooms and suites, 6 Pool Villas, and 22 Laguna Pool Villas (Dusit Successfully Acquire Laguna Phuket, n.d.). Hotel Nikko Manila, Philippines Dusit International purchased shares in the holding company of Philippine Hoteliers Inc. (PHI) from Japan Airlines Development Company Limited and JAL Trading Inc. This led them to acquire Hotel Nikko Manila in 1995. They were renamed as Dusit Thani Nikko, Manila. This acquisition was on the bases of expansion by acquisition. The main purpose was to move into Philippines initially. This was also to introduce the Dusit Thani Thai hospitality and standard of service to impose them in the Philippines Market. The reason was that it would cost lesser than creating a new business from scratch as well as by acquiring a hotel locally they can still gain control of the operations in the organization. Several years later in 2008 they underwent a major renovation to enhance their existence. They renamed as Dusit Thani, Manila in April 2008. They now are one of the most technologically advanced of Dusit Thani hotel chains. 1.3 Restructuring Joint ventures Bird group Bird Hospitality Services or BHS is a subsidiary of the Bird Group has launched its first project with Dusit Hotels and Resort one of Thailand’s most famous hotel companies. Under such joint venture Bird Hospitality Services are on their way to develop six, 4 to 5 star hotels in India. This provides Dusit Thani to franchise their branches across one of the up and coming BRIC Countries like India. The first’s three hotels were said to be launching within 2010 but due to some financial difficulties due to the 2008 economical crisis it hasn’t fall in to place. The targeted sites are Delhi, Goa and Rishikesh in 2010 and Pune, Amritsar and Jaipur in 2013 respectively. The Bird Hospitality Services has invested up to 200 million U.S. Dollars in this project(Deimezi, 2007). The Bird Group has been a strong entity in the travel industry for more than forty years. Due to the stupendous demand and promising growth in the tourism industry the Bird Group had deemed it logical to join the Tourism and Hospitality industry (Deimezi, 2007). India is experiencing an exceptional growth in inbound travellers rising up to 4.43 Million people in 2006 alone. The Bird Group is thrilled to work with one of the most well-known brand of Thai hotels as a joint venture to enhance their business. Claiming that the number of tourists will grow by double the size within 2020. Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Culinary School Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Culinary School was established in 2007 as a joint venture between Le Cordon Bleu International and Dusit International one of the leading Thai Hotel Brands. This famous culinary school is located in Silom district. This is located adjacent to the Dusit Thani Hotel for convenience of management as well as training. It is also easily accessible by MRT subway as well as the BTS sky train, which are only a few blocks away. Both these brands have high reputation as they joint together to assist each other in their prospers. The School is a modern and made up of state of the art training facilities and programs as well as the brand standard Chefs to train the trainees in both Le Cordon Bleu style menus as well as Thai Cuisines which are unique to the brand with Dusit. All classes are thought in English. Le Cordon Bleu Dusit accepts students both locally as well as internationally. This special joint culinary training course is established to enhance their students as well as potential staffs to be a master of food both locally and international with high standard. This is also a diversification as they move to provision of education rather than Hotel operation. 2. Re –Branding Recently in 2007 Dusit International had started processing Re-Branding of their Hotels. Creating new trademarks that would show more depth in their provision of services and thus redefining their brand standard to become more divers in order to compete with their competitors at both Business as well as corporate level. They also try to ensure the standard of satisfaction level after the introduction of Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Culinary School and the Dusit Thani College. The aim is to add value to their brand that spells “the Truly Contemporary Thai” with excellence in service that will exceed customers’ expectations will be advertise and their public relations through the year 2008. (An International Marketing Strategy analysis, n.d.) Dusit Thani’s sub brands have their own trademark as of this moment to enhance the variety as well as the differentiation and uniqueness of each of their brands. They have registered 5 main trademarks, which are Dusit Thani, Dusit Princess, D2, Dusit Devarana and Dusit Residence. Each trademark has different shareholders. 3. Down Scoping Due to changes like expansion, acquisitions and mergers Dusit International needed to down scope through restructurings. By expanding their sales office to monitor company maintenance in Shang-hai, China and Dubai, UAE. They also had to implement changes in their regional sales offices in Singapore and Hong Kong by hiring sales team from Dusit International company instead of having their own local sales team to maintain standards of Dusit Thani due to lack of performance. They had to go as far as down scoping their national sales office as well. This was due to the decrease in standards to achieve satisfactory objectives. For this reason Staffs who had lesser experience are switched to be supervised within the hotels in Dusit group and those who hold higher reputation to the sales offices (Product and Service Supplies, 2011). 4. Other restructuring Dusit Princess Branches terminated. Dusit Thani Koh Chang and Dusit princess Dubai were terminated due to slow performance and failure to draw in customers plus the high expenses in accordance to the Dubai soil and its cost of living with leasing the land. Dusit International now has only few Dusit Princess in existence, namely areDusit princess Srinakarin Bangkok and Dusit princess Korat. Royal princess LarnLuang, Royal princess Chiangmai, Grand China princess China town and Belaire princess sukhumvit(under Dusit International management team). Expansion of Global Sales Offices As one of the leading Asian hospitality groups Dusit International has issued an order of consolidation of the regional sales offices in Germany and United Kingdom to form a large European based sales headquarters and to further boost their sales operations in the key emerging markets in Asia Pacific. Due to such changes that are modified to improve sales management and performance specializations were needed. For this Dusit International as included two new positions within the Global Sales office in Bangkok. One of them include the newly formed Director of sales through Russia and Commonwealth of Independent States – CIS they also made an unusual move in contradiction of their philosophy of hiring internally from Dusit. Instead they appointed a Korean senior sales manager to provide treatment for such important markets. To add to their restructuring movements Dusit Thani has appointed Hotel Representation Australia or HRA to operate their regional sales activities in Australia. Australia with New Zealand and Oceana together has shown promising growth with 10% year on year increase in arrivals to Thailand in the first half of the year 2012. They also showed 23% growth in arrivals to Maldives over the same period. By the forth quarter of 2012 Dusit International opened a regional sales office in Tokyo, Japan, as Japanese are one of the most important business travellers to Thailand as well as a well-known business destination itself and is expected to boom with recovery after the Nuclear incident. They currently generate 11% of revenue for Dusit Group worldwide. Dusit International has also made their move to operate regional sales office in China by appointing their own Director of Sales overseas to northern China. The base is located in Shanghai. In addition the Hong Kong Sales Branch will employ another sales manager to coordinate deeper coverage for the southern part of china as well as Taiwan. Dusit Thani decided to hire local sales directors due to their own country familiarity and experience to extinguish language barriers and ease their operations abroad by hiring minds that are knowledgeable in those regions. New Sub Branches Dusit International has announced their merger with Birdgroup as an initiation of their project to fast track expansion into India in 2013. Through this they will make their moves into New Delhi, Jaipur, Rishikesh and Goa by the end of this respective year. Through this expansion they plan to launch their first ever Dusit Devarana. This is said to be a differentiation, as they will blend Indian architecture with Thai hospitality services creating the most luxurious brand of Dusit International. This project will also land the first D2 oversees. Dusit Devarana New Delhi was first scheduled to open in May 2010 however due to political problems as well as the economical shockwave in 2008 it was postponed. It will be the first Dusit Luxury Hotel in India. As far as location is concern it will be located in the center of New Delhi. This will be the fifth sub brand in the Dusit International Empire after the rebranding of their branches. Dusit Devarana, which means, “Garden in Heaven” in Sanskrit. This will be a multi-domestic strategy as they use the Indian architecture as a link to the local cultural taste of atmosphere for comfort to maintain the image of staying in India. Through this to maintain their global standard they will provide Thai style Hospitality of their brand. “The brand culture will be manifested through its people; a devoted group of professionals inspired to understand the needs of each guest, delivering highly personalized experiences and create the elusive DusitDevarana to be the world of one between Indian and Thai”. The opening of the first Dusit D2 outside Thailand will follow this. DusitD2 New Delhi, DusitDevarana Jaipur, Dusit DevaranaRishikesh, and the Goa project (Dynamic Expansion into India, n.d.). 2. Global Strategy Global strategy as defined in business terms is an organization's strategic guide to globalization.'Global Strategy' basically covers three areas: global, multinational and international strategies. Essentially, these three areas refer to those strategies designed to enable an organization to achieve its objective of international expansion (Lynch, 2012). Implications of the three definitions within global strategy: 1. International strategy: the organization’s objectives relate primarily to the home market. However, we have some objectives with regard to overseas activity and therefore need an international strategy. Importantly, the competitive advantage - important in strategy development - is developed mainly for the home market. 2. Multinational strategy: the organization is involved in a number of markets beyond its home country. But it needs distinctive strategies for each of these markets because customer demand and, perhaps competition, are different in each country. Importantly, competitive advantage is determined separately for each country. 3. Global strategy: the organization treats the world as largely one market and one source of supply with little local variation. Importantly, competitive advantage is developed largely on a global basis. During the last half of the twentieth century, many barriers to international trade fell and a wave of firms began pursuing global strategies to gain a competitive advantage. However, some industries benefit more from globalization than do others, and some nations have a comparative advantage over other nations in certain industries. To create a successful global strategy, managers first must understand the nature of global industries and the dynamics of global competition. Sources of Competitive Advantage from a Global Strategy A well-designed global strategy can help a firm to gain a competitive advantage. This advantage can arise from the flowing sources: Efficiency - Economies of scale from access to more customers and markets - Exploit another country’s resources in terms of labor, raw materials - Extend the product life cycle- older products can be sold in lesser developed countries - Operational flexibility that is the shift in production such as costs, exchange rates, changes over time. Strategic - First mover advantage and only provider of a product to a market - Cross subsidization between countries - Transfer price Risk - Diversify macroeconomics risks (business cycles not perfectly correlated among countries) - Diversify operational risks (labor problems, earthquakes, wars) Learning - Broaden learning opportunities due to diversity of operating environments Reputation - Crossover customers between markets in terms of reputation and brand identification. However, this is a framework comprising of three categories of strategic objectives and three sources of advantage that can be used to achieve them. 2.1 Domestic Market Domestic marketing basically means selling within one's own country. Typically, this is the first area where companies seek to market their goods or services. Because the market, customer needs, tastes, geography, demographics, and distribution methods are likely familiar, it's often the easiest place for companies to launch a product. The four P's of marketing - product, price, place and promotion - are often easier for companies to determine within the domestic market. In addition, it is the supply and demand for a good, service, or security in a particular country. Many companies cater to the domestic market because they know applicable laws and regulations the best. There also may be a unique demand for a certain product in the domestic market. For example, an American flag supplier will likely sell more flags in the United States than in Canada. The size of the domestic market is calculated in the gross domestic product (Grunert, 2013). Dusit Thani uses domestic strategy only for its hotels in Thailand. By using the domestic strategy, it give the company a more specific and accurate details on how to reach their target customers most effectively at a specific region. Dusit Thani College Dusit Thani College was established in June 1993. Students from this college will receive extensive theoretical and practical training from Asia’s newest and most advanced educational institute. In addition, Dusit Thani College sustainably develops and offers high quality education with highly competent graduates who acquire first-rate professional skills, creativity and innovative outlook. Dusit Thani College provides education, covering Bachelor’s Degree Programmes, which consisted of five major programmes in both Thai and International Programme Moreover, the college is also set up to educate for bachelor’s degree and master’s degree in culinary arts, tourism, hotel management, and other modules related to hotel business such as MICE and Event business. The purpose of the college is to produce human resources who are good at hotel business so as to work for Dusit and support the industry’s growth in Thailand. Students from Dusit Thani College will not only have skills, but also have a truly understanding about Dusit Company. As they believe that human talents are the fundamental elements of hospitality services, and it is the college priority to develop their talents in order to help the company strive for achieving excellence (Dusit International, 2013). From these courses provided to the students which will enable them to have a strong foundation and knowledge about Dusit culture and organizational structure and to keep themselves and the company competitive. Strategies to stimulate travel business in Thailand Thailand used to be one of the world’s most famous holiday destinations, but recently tourists have been hesitant to enter the kingdom of Thailand resulting from the devastation of yellow and red shirt riots which is political unrest and due to flood crisis which have led to tremendous losses to the travel and tourism industry and the economy as a whole. As a result, travellers lost confidence due to safety and security reason (Travel and Tourism, 2012). Therefore, in order to regain back the confidence and to draw tourist back in Thailand Tourism and Hospitality Industry, Dusit Thani has launched a marketing campaign under the name of “Dusit Together for Thailand”. In other words, as for the company’s rebuilding strategy to stimulate Thailand’s tourism, Dusit International has launched ‘Dusit Together for Thailand’ as part of its sales and marketing strategy to restore confidence and bring back the dynamic market environment for tourism. Additionally, with support and encouragement from all around the world, Dusit International, announces Dusit Together for Thailand. All Dusit International’s hotels and resorts from around the country are joining together to help restore confidence in Thailand’s hotel industry. Under ‘Dusit Together for Thailand’, Dusit Sales teams visit over 300 Bangkok-based companies in order to show appreciation to their clients and business partners for the continued support for Dusit and all Thais. The mission of ‘Dusit Together for Thailand is to show that if we work together, we can restore confidence and bring back the dynamic market environment for tourism in Thailand (Mok, 2010). Also, the activity will be extended to Hong Kong and Singapore in the coming few months. Dusit is continuing its active Public Relations programmes with domestic and international media throughout the year. Dusit International which is one of Asia’s leading hotel groups introduces"Dusit Take 2" offering special privileges for guests to enhance their summer experience with extra value at all Dusit's hotels and resorts (Dusit International, n.d.). Furthermore, Dusit International continues its rebuilding strategy under ‘Dusit Together for Thailand’ by launching Dusit’s Appreciation Gift Voucher for all dining guests With every THB 1,000 spent at any Dusit’s restaurants throughout the month of June and July, and guests will receive a THB 500 accomodations gift voucher to spend and enjoy their getaway at any of our participating hotels and resorts across Thailand (Dusit International, 2013). The ‘Dusit Together for Thailand’ programme will also help to encourage our guests to travel in Thailand, and stimulate domestic tourism during summer months. Dusit also released its first TV advertising for Dusit Thani Bangkok and Dusit Thani Pattaya on BBC and Star Channels (Kasemsuk, n.d.). 2.2 Global Market Global marketing is a firm’s ability to offer one’s goods or services worldwide. Most companies begin marketing their goods or services within their country, and expand to the global market to capture greater market share and open up new avenues for sales. With extensive reach, the need for a firm's product or services is established. The global firm retains the capability, reach, knowledge, staff, skills, insights, and expertise to deliver value to customers worldwide. The firm understands the requirement to service customers locally with global standard solutions or products, and localizes that product as required to maintain an optimal balance of cost, efficiency, customization and localization in a controlcustomization range to best meet local, national and global requirements to position itself against or with competitors, partners, alliances, substitutes and defend against new global and local market entrants per country, region or city.The firm will price its products appropriately worldwide, nationally and locally, and promote, deliver access and information to its customers in the most cost-effective way. The firm also needs to understand, research, measure and develop loyalty for its brand and global brand equity (stay on brand) for the long term (Grunert, 2013). Global market is concerning on what strategy does Dusit Thani apply to its hotels, both in Thailand and overseas unlike domestic market. Branding In the increasingly competitive hotel industry, recent trends indicate that brand is fast becoming the most important ingredient for success. In other words, hotel branding is an important aspect in business especially in terms of generating revenues. It is a process that helps a product stand apart from others that have similar physical features. In the world of competition, different companies of the same product/service try to lure the same prey you are luring. The only thing that sets you apart is the branding you have done for your business so that customers remember you the next time they need to book a reservation (Ira, 2010). Likewise, Dusit Thani International has its own brand as one of the main marketing strategies.This strategy is being applied to all of Dusit’s branches. The company can use its brand name for marketing purposes which is the same as selling the reputation. Even though there are some people who have never experienced staying with Dusit, but the reason they choose to stay at Dusit is because they have heard about the brand name and, therefore, the purpose of branding is to help ensure customers will return again and even recommend your business to others. In short brand has something known as “equity”. Brand equity is when customers associate that brand with positive and favorable feelings. A brand’s reputation and goodwill adds value to the company (Shoemaker, 2012). Alike other hotels, Dusit will be striving to ensure that the experience of staying at the hotel and the interaction with the staff is of the highest possible standard so that the next time they would most likely choose to stay at Dusit. Consequently, if customers have a pleasant experience during their stay at Dusit, this could lead them to spread positive word of mouth about their great experience at Dusit to others which definitely could bring in new customers to Dusit. Thus, this can create brand loyalty. Brand loyalty is when a consumer insists on continuously buying one particular brand of a product. They stick with that brand for a long period of time and will choose it over any other similar brands even if the unknown brand cost less. As a result, this helps Dusit to generate revenue for the company and hence profitability. However, Dusit is trying to sell its Thai hospitality which is quite cultural, therefore, expanding the brand into another country can be sensitive. In such case, the hotel must be really careful about how to present the product in order to match with certain cultures as in some places culture can be very sensitive (Vickers, 2012). Thus it can be extremely difficult in terms of maintaining the same standard for managing the brand in many other countries. Spa Devarana Spa is owned by Dusit Thani and it excites the senses and makes guests feel truly special, luxurious pampering and healing treatments are offered in a soothing stress- relieving environment. The name has a special meaning, “Garden in Heaven”. The contemporary Thai design and décor invites guests to transcend the everyday world and provides a relaxing and welcoming atmosphere in which to enjoy premium spa treatments with traditional Thai service and hospitality. Additionally, Devarana Spa is one of the products are being known and popular for Dusit Thani loyal customers. Since Thai spa has been recognized as one of the top five services in the world. However, Devarana Spa is considered as global market because it has its branches in Manila and Maldives, therefore, expanding Devarana Spa to the overseas could be an effective tool to present Thainess and at the same time representing excellence service of Dusit Thani. As a result, Thailand has a good reputation when it comes to spa service (Dusit Thani, 2010). Entry Strategy For any business, before entering new market the firm needs to analyze the market carefully in order to know its potential. Likewise, Dusit conduct research and analyze the market in order to know who will be their target customers which will also involve dividing a broad target market into subsets of consumers who have common needs and desires as well as common applications for the relevant goods and services which is called market segmentation. Once Dusit know about their target customers then the company need to analyze further in depth to find out about their needs, wants, their lifestyles, expectation, preferences etc. Therefore, market research is imperative for Dusit to know what type of products or services would be profitable to introduce in the market. Also with respect to its existing products in the market, good market research enables a company to know if it has been able to satisfy customer needs and whether any changes need to be made in terms of delivery of services to customer, the way staff present themselves in front of customers etc. This enables a company to formulate a viable marketing plan or measure the success of its existing plan. In order to minimize risk and seek for more opportunities, these areas such as HR, financial, culture clash and legal issues should be taken into consideration before entering the new markets (Day, 2005). Alliance Dusit Thani has become alliance with many of the organizations in a number of countries all around the world and not only in Thailand. Some of Dusit major alliances are Ringzero Network Thailand,Bird Group, Le Cordon Bleu, Preferred Hotel Group, Ecole Hoteliere Lausanne, GHA, AHA and Ruyi Company Limited. Consequently, these major alliances could help Dusit to differentiate the products and services, strengthen Dusit’s capability, create competitive advantage and generate trust as all of the mentioned organizations are very well-known in their work field. For example, Ringzero network is expertise in IT, therefore, Ringzero create a new fantastic website for Dusit Group. As a result, the new website renovated by Ringzero can meet the customer’s needs and wants (Ringzero Network, n.d.). Loyalty Programs In the hotel industry, all the major hotel companies have created their own version of the hotel loyalty program and are constantly striving to present their program as offering the best value. Throughout the travel and retail industries, consumers have been bombarded with countless loyalty programs, the aim to which is to retain customers and increase their loyalty to a specific brand or company (Hotel Marketing.com, 2009). Likewise, Dusit Thani provides a list of loyalty programs for their customers to offer privilege and exclusive promotions and services. This strategy is used to show appreciation to customers for choosing to stay at Dusit as their preferred hotel. It is also used to attract customers to frequently stay with Dusit Thani. There are various types of loyalty programs which are provided for customers which are Dusit Gold Card, Dusit Wine & Dine, DTCPF Prestige and Frequent Flyer. However, these programs can be used at any of Dusit hotels all around the world (Dusit International, n.d.). 2.3 International Strategy An International strategy is a strategy through which the firm sells its good or services outside its domestic market. One of the primary reasons for implanting an international strategy is that international markets yield potential new opportunities. Firm can derive four basic benefits from using international strategies which are increased market size, greater returns on major capital investments or on investments in new products and processes, greater economies of scale, scope or learning and a competitive advantage through location. However, Dusit Thani International implements the transnational strategy, which is the combination of multidomestic and global strategy. Multidomestic strategy: A multidomestic strategy is a type of marketing approach that seeks to focus attention on the needs of a local market rather than taking a more universal or global approach to the advertising effort. This means that companies employing this marketing strategy will seek to understand the culture of various local markets and tailor their entry into those markets based on the demographics of that area. With this approach, a great deal of effort is made to adapt advertising and presentation to appeal to local sensibilities, rather than using a mass market approach. In order for a multidomestic strategy to be successful, is it important to invest a great deal of research into the various localities where the products are actively marketed. This can often provide valuable insights into the nuances of the prevailing culture in an area, which leads to inspiration on how to present the products to best advantage (Clark, 2013). The sub-brands under the Dusit umbrella has been expanded to the overseas markets consisting of India (opened 2013), China, Egypt, Maldives and Philippine (coming projects). INDIA Dusit International took this opportunity to announce Dusit Devarana New Delhi India, which is planned to open this year in 2013.The Devarana brand reflects the ultimate in luxury and refinement, providing an enriching experience through intellectual and artistic touch points, and a modern yet timeless aesthetic (Dusit International, 2012). With personalized discreet, flawless service, Dusit Devarana provides an escape from the everyday world which is a sense of renewal, a renaissance of the mind. Additionally, the architecture of the hotel will reflect to the Indian culture since the hotel will be located in India. Dusit Devarana leverages Dusit International's rich cultural heritage and history of service excellence to offer an intimacy sanctuary experience. In addition, the hotel also provides the signature service, which is the Spa treatment under the Devarana Spa (Dusit Devarana: New Delhi, n.d). Moreover, Dusit International has appointed Mrs Mahema Bhutia as its new Director of Sales & Marketing for Dusit Devarana New Delhi, the first hotel to appear under its nascent Dusit Devarana brand. In her new role, Mrs Bhutia is responsible for the efficiency of the Sales and Marketing Department in terms of sales, profitability and image. Therefore, with her great professional experience who had worked in many big hotels likeDirector of Sales & Marketing for Hyatt Regency Pune; Associate Director of Sales at Hyatt Regency Mumbai; Senior Sales Manager for Marriott Executive Apartment and Renaissance Mumbai Hotel and Convention Center; and Manager of Banquet Sales for the Oberoi Group in Mumbai. Since Mrs Mahema Bhutia is very skilful and is an Indian, the hotel has appointed her to work in this position and thus she must already be familiar with the Indian culture (Director of Sales & Marketing, 2012).This can show that the hotel tried to adapt into new environment and culture in order to be part of them. As a result, The Dusit Devarana New Delhi is the first of many properties to open in India under the joint venture agreement with India based Bird Hospitality Services and Dusit International. China Dusit International has confirmed that Dusit Devarana Hainan will be open in China by this year which is 2013. The resort is located on the ZhiangShui bay. The resort will feature more than a dozen crafted spring-water bathing pools of varying sizes and temperatures. The hotel has blended Thai and China art together in building the hotels featuring Devarana Spa. Dusit Devarana Hainan is being designed as a low-rise complex of villas and deluxe rooms. The resort will offer a choice of two restaurants including Western and Chinese cuisines while a natural mountain river cuts through the complex, adding aesthetic appeal (Dusit Devarana Hainan, 2012). Moreover, Mr. Dennis is the director of sale who is the Hong-Kong citizen. Thus this can benefits the hotel since he would be familiar with the culture and easily help the hotel to survive in the long run and also to be able to compete against other hotel in the particular area (Dusit Thani International Showcase: China, 2012). Egypt The Dusit Thani Lakeview at Egypt is strategically located at the new Cairo district where the landscape and design of the hotel make it a real oasis in the heart of the developing district of New Cairo. Also, they came up with a great idea by featuring two fabulous outdoor swimming pools in a serene surrounding of lavish greenery. The roofs of the building are triangle in shape, which also represent the pyramids. Therefore, this is the great way to create uniqueness for the hotel. Additionally, there are varieties of dining options at Dusit Thani Lakeview Cairo which includes Ruen Thai the hotel Thai Restaurant, the international all day dining Branzino Restaurant and the Blue Rose Lounge which are set to delight every Dusit guest culinary desire (Dusit Thani, 2010). Maldives Dusit Thani Maldives blends graceful Thai hospitality with the unparalleled luxury setting of destination Maldives. Dusit Thani Maldives is said to blend Maldivian architecture with Thai artistry. The resorts also features Dusit’s signature Devarana Spa. Moreover, the hotel provides great dining experience for all its guests which include Benjarong serving Thai and Maldivian food mostly are grill-seafood (Dusit Thani Maldives, 2012). Philippine Dusit Thani Manila which is situated in the heart of the Philippines’s premiere financial district offers luxurious sights and sprawling urban hubs that offer reliable access to city splendours, historic sites, meeting and convention centres. Additionally, for repainting the state –of-art monochromatic beige-colored façade to reflect the Philippine culture, Dusit Thani in Manila has invested around US$20 on the renovation the management continues to endeavour in creating new reinventions for its guests. Moreover, the hotel provides variety of cuisine such as Thai, Italian, Japanese and Philippine. Also, Dusit Thani Manila hotel offers two of Asia’s best recreational activities that both represent internationally-renowned brands which are Devarana Spa and DFit Fitness Centre that are provided for customers. Furthermore, the hotel held the event on the Celebration of 112th independence so as to become part of the Philippine culture. The event was about the Philippine culinary art, which the hotel had brought a good chef to create the exceptional Philippine dishes. This shows that the company want to become part of the country (Dusit Thani Manila, 2010). Global Strategy Facilities/ Services Firstly, Dusit Thani and Dusit Devarana are the only two brands under Dusit International that provides the signature services which is the Devarana Spa that promises a revitalizing experience giving guests a new lease of life right at heaven gate. Additionally, Dusit Thani has expanded its branches in a number of countries like India, China and Philippines. However, all of Dusit branches still maintain the same standard of offering outstanding spa services to all its guests. Moreover, all the branches of Dusit Thani International need to provide D-Fit which is the fitness center to its entire guest as one of the facilities or services in the hotel. The equipment’s within the center are full-options ranging from weights to running machines For example, Dusit Thani Manila have the DFit Fitness Centre which provides a 973-square meter of cutting edge fitness facilities. Therefore, customers can seek a variety of new experiences for staying there. The last facilities that all the branches of Dusit International should provide is extensive pool of the hotel like Dusit Thani Manila that provides a 750 square meter swimming pool which is the largest in Maldives. Secondly, the official webpage of Dusit International is created for both local and international. For example, Dusit Thani website is designed in a very Thai traditional way where the guests can see on the Dusit Thani homepage is the Thai traditional dressing worn by Dusit staff which gives customers a sense of Thai culture. Dusit Thani tends to remove all language barriers for all the people. Therefore, when entering Dusit website there are five main languages which are provided for the people which are Arabic, English, Thai, Chinese and Japanese. Each language is well translated and therefore makes it easy for the foreign people to read and understand the information provided on the website and those who are interested in staying or using the hotel services. To illustrate, usually Chinese people face difficulty and cannot communicate and read well in English and thus they are languages for Chinese people as well as after changing to Chinese language, every title such as accomodations or services will be in Chinese fonts and thus these people will find it much easier and comfortable to read and also they are chances they will stay at Dusit (Dusit International, n.d.). Thirdly, as we have already mentioned early that Dusit also has Frequent Flyer Programs. Dusit Thani has alliance with more than five airlines such as Japan Airlines, American Airlines, Alaska Airlines, Thai Airways, Bangkok Airways, Jet Airways and Singapore Airlines etc. Customers will receive award miles per qualified stay after participating with any of the branches of Dusit International which include local and oversea. For example, customers will receive 500 miles per stay at Dusit International hotels and resorts. Consequently, the program from the hotel can create guest satisfaction since customers can easily gain the benefits from being hotel guests in local or overseas branches (Dusit International 2013). Lastly, for the service part, customers that receive a Dusit Gold Card can be recognizes as one of our most valued guests that are entitled to Dusit Golden Privileges and Benefits. Customers are able to use the Gold card with 20 hotels and resorts of Dusit International in both local (Thailand) and overseas. The guest will receive priority including best room rate, services discount or the complimentary. This give privileges for the guests as whenever they stay with the Dusit International, they are able to get 10% percent discount for the accommodation. The card can also be used for the all the restaurants under Dusit, which is for 10% off. Moreover, the hotel see the importance of creating the Dusit Thani Gold card, which can lead to customer loyalty and once customers become loyal this can create retained customers and hence generate revenue for the company. Also, fitness lovers can enjoy the high promotion, if they are interested in DFIT. Thus, being a gold card holder will give him privileges to choose when he would like to use the Dusit International services in Thailand or overseas(Dusit Gold Benefits, 2012) International Entry Mode 1. Licensing Licensing is an increasingly common form of organizational network, particularly among smaller firms. A licensing arrangement follows a foreign country to purchase the right to manufacture and sell the firm’s products within a host country or set of countries. The licensor is normally paid a royalty on each unit produced and sold. The licensee takes the risks and makes the monetary investments in facilities for manufacturing, marketing, and distributing the goods or services. As a result licensing is possibly the least costly form of international expansion. In addition, licensing is also a way to expand returns based on prior innovations. Even if product life cycles are short, licensing may be a useful tool. On the other hand, licensing also has disadvantages. For example, it gives the firm little control over the manufacture and marketing of its products in other countries. Thus, license deals must be structured properly. Moreover, licensing provides the least potential returns, because returns must be shared between the licensor and the licensee. Also, the international firm may learn the technology and produce and sell a similar competitive product after the license expires. To illustrate like most global hotel chains, Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide uses a franchise licensing arrangement and does not own most of its hotels. While focusing on other brands, it has let its Sheraton brand slip in quality. Given the current economic downturn, it is going to be difficult to get the owners to incest in needed design improvements and upgrades, especially given the owner differences in varying geographic markets. Thus licensing can also lead to inflexibilities, and as such it is important that a firm think ahead and consider the consequences of each entry, especially in international markets (Cockburn, n.d). However, for Dusit to bring in new knowledge so as to improve the products and processes of the company, Dusit has Sign licensing agreement. Dusit has mostly signed the agreement in terms of its educational business that is aiming to improve the curriculum of its courses and enhancing the future growth of the company. Tsuji culinary institution Osaka, Japan In 2013, Dusit International has made an agreement with Japan’s most prestigious culinary institute; the Tsuji Culinary institute of Osaka has offered an ‘Authentic Japanese Cuisine Courses” to the general public and its students. Additionally, the Japanese Cuisine Courses has been designed by a professional chef from the Tsuji Culinary Institute who is originally from Japan. Also, the brand new suitable kitchen facilities, designed exclusively for preparing Japanese Cuisine have been carefully designed in order to cater to the market needs in Thailand (Bangkok Post, 2013). Analysis Dusit International and also Dusit Thani College could result in various positive impacts after being partner with Tsuji Culinary Institution, this is because students and other staffs will have the chance to learn and acquire new knowledge as well as to take a journey into the heart of great Japanese culinary traditions and explore various cooking techniques. Moreover, Dusit can gain a lot of benefits from this program especially for the kitchen department as they will be given a great opportunity to learn and develop new Japanese cooking skills. Consequently, once they are developed and improved on their cooking skills, the taste, texture, smell at the same time will be improves as well which could definitely lead to guest satisfaction. Hence if the guests are satisfied with the quality of food, they tend to be retained customers and help hotel generate revenue even more than before. Ecole Hoteliere Lausanne In 2012, Dusit International’s subsidiary, Dusit Thani College has signed an agreement with Ecole Hôtelière de Lausanne (EHL) which is first successful and leading hospitality school in Switzerland, located in Lausanne. Dusit Thani College and Ecole Hôtelière de Lausannetogether has launched a new international Bachelor programme (B.B.A.) on Hotel and Resort Management. Additionally, both Thai and foreign students will be accepted in the programme and courses will be conducted in English. This partnership is in line with Dusit International’s preparations to further develop hospitality talent in the wake of the Asean Economic Community (AEC) in 2015 (Dusit Thani, 2012). Analysis From signing an agreement with ECL, the hotel as well as Dusit Thani College can gain benefits in terms of developing its human assets. This is because people can be more productivity in management skills, and thus when they are productive, they tend to work harder and faster and thus this can lead to the growth of the hotel. Hence this program will be suitable for the management since the course will provide both Thai and Switzerland hospitality value and management. For Dusit to be more competitive in the hotel industry, the company can easily learn and adopt more about the strengths of EHL. Lyceum University in Philippines On December 3, 2008, Dusit Thani Public Limited Company has signed a licensing and consults agreement with Lyceum University in Philippines University so as to offer Dusit Thani College's popular curriculum in Hospitality Management at the 4 campuses of LPU located in Manila, Batangas, Laguna and Cavite and also to obtain academic cooperation and provide a course for bachelor’s degree by using the courses of Dusit Thani College which include (i) hotel management (ii) cooking and restaurant management arts and (iii) tourism. Moreover, Dusit Thani hotels also have a branch in Philippines, so the company allowed trainees from LPU to do internship there as well. Analysis From having this agreement Dusit could get various positive impacts. Dusit can reduce its expense in terms of training and recruitment process as the company is able to produce its manpower working in the future properties in other branches of Dusit. Moreover, Dusit can enhance its brand awareness among Philippines market and, therefore, make it easier for future investment in the country. 2. Strategic alliance Strategic alliances have become a popular means of international expansion. Strategic alliances allow firms to share the risks and resources required to enter international markets. Moreover, strategic alliances can facilitate the development of new core competencies that contribute to the firm’s future strategic competitiveness. Additionally, each partner in an alliance brings knowledge or resources to the partnership. Indeed, partners often enter an alliance with the purpose of learning new capabilities. Common among these desired capabilities are technological skills. However, for technological knowledge to be transferred in an alliance usually requires trust between the partners. Managing these expectations can facilitate improved performance. However, not all alliance is successful, in fact many has fail. The primary reasons for failure include incompatible partners and conflict between the partners. International strategic alliances are especially difficult to manage. Several factors may cause a relationship to sour. Trust between the partners is critical and is affected by at least four fundamental issues: the initial condition of the relationship, the negotiation process to arrive at an agreement, partner interactions and external events. Trust is also influenced by the country cultures involved in the alliance (Strategic alliances, n.d.). For hotel industry company to enter into an international market, having strategic alliance is one of the most significant strategies. Therefore, for Dusit International to achieve its goals, it has found this strategy to be an important tool so the company has joined with various groups which are related to its business. There are four mains strategic alliances of Dusit which are as follows: Le Cordon Bleu Dusit and Le Cordon Bleu, one of the world’s largest culinary arts institutes, have set up a joint venture to offer a comprehensive range of quality culinary arts education courses in order to establish academy of World Cuisines which will be located at Dusit Thani Bangkok hotel. Also, they are offering degree in Business Administration in Professional Chef and Restaurant Management at Dusit Thani College. Moreover, it is modern state-of-the-art facility offering all the standard of Le Cordon Bleu programmes as well as a Professional Thai Cuisine programme unique to Le Cordon Bleu Dusit. All classes are taught in English and they accept both Thai and international students from all over the world since 2007 (Asia Travel Tip.com, 2013). Analysis Le Cordon Bleu company has help Dusit to better manage the school by sharing some of its essential resources and by creating recipe for the company. An example is sharing in terms of human resources such as equipment’s, uniform and instructors. As a result, the brand of Le Cordon Bleu can strengthen the education business of Dusit Thani. Preferred Hotel Group Preferred Hotel Group is an international hospitality company which provides sales, marketing, and technological solutions. Its services include integrated marketing and communications, loyalty programs, tradeshows and events, sales support, quality assurance, group purchasing and a solution for reservation management that connects various reservation channels. In 2009, Dusit Thani was announced to do partnership with Preferred Hotel Group. Under this agreement, Preferred Hotel Group will provide Dusit International with access to its established sales network, global marketing program and leading-edge distribution system. However, this partnership marks the beginning of a new business strategy for Preferred Hotel Group (Preferred Hotel Group, 2009). Analysis Dusit International will benefits from having global partnerships with members of Preferred Hotel Group as it will allow Dusit International to maintain its properties brand identity while benefiting from Preferred Hotel Group’s 28 worldwide sales offices, preferential global partnerships with key travel management companies and MICE planners, select marketing programs, airline flyer partnerships and distribution networks. Also, it can help Dusit to extend its network in many regions as the company has desired and to become global player in hospitality industry around the world. Bird Group Bird Group is India’s fastest growing business conglomerates with interests in Travel Technology, Aviation Services, Hospitality, Luxury Retail and Education. Also, bird group is one of India’s most trusted brands as such this trust extends to a series of products and services that cover diverse businesses from service industry to cutting-edge technology solutions. Today Bird Group’s core business includes Travel Technology, Aviation Services, Hospitality, Luxury Retail and Education. Bird Hospitality Services (BHS) is the subsidiary owned by Bird Group. Additionally, in March 2007, Bird Hospitality Services (BHS) and Dusit Hotels & Resorts are joint venture as they began to do hospitality business with Dusit Hotels and Resorts. Moreover, Bird Hospitality Services is committed to develop six, 4 to 5 star hotels, which will provide Dusit the possibility to manage or franchise several hotels in India (Deimezi, 2007). Presently, there is only one Dusit Devarana in New Delhi India. According to Sunil Mathur, Regional Vice President said that Dusit Devarana will ‘stand out’ not only for its unique architectural designs, but also for its ‘high level of genuine Asian hospitality’. “In a crowded market place like Delhi where there is hardly any ‘differentiator’ in terms of product design or offerings, Dusit Devarana will stand out for its world class design and genuine caring service (Kumar, 2007). However, other four properties which are DusitD2 New Delhi India, DusitD2 Goa India, Dusit Devarana Rishikesh India, and Dusit Devarana Jaipur India are under development which will be opened in the next few years. Analysis: Dusit could get various positive impacts from the joint venture with Bird Group. This is because India is the potential market for Dusit Thani especially in Rishikesh, Delhi and Goa as India is now witnessing a tremendous boom with inbound travel of 4.43 million in 2006 with a double digit growth forecast year on year till 2020. As Rishikesh is growing on demand of leisure and MICE segment, Delhi is already facing in short supply of business and leisure hotels and Goa has demand of in leisure both domestic and oversea segment. As a result, in order to give India hotels and resorts to redefine the standards of hospitality in the country, the hospitality expertise of Dusit International and local knowledge and network of Bird Hospitality will be combined together. Asia Hotel Alliance (AHA) and Global Hotel Alliance (GHA) Dusit and other four leading hotels in Asia has joined together to form AHA including Landis Hotels & Resorts in Taiwan, the Marco Polo Hotel Group in Hong Kong, Meritus Hotels & Resorts in Singapore and New Otani Hotels in Japan. This powerful marketing association is being established so as to better serve existing clients and future customers of the over 70 AHA affiliated hotels. The group’s main aim is to expand its market internationally by creating efficient distribution channel system through the group. However, in January 2007, the Asian Hotels Alliance (AHA) will merge withGHA, immediately bringing Dusit Hotels & Resorts, Landis Hotels & Resorts andMarco Polo Hotels as new members of GHA, while Meritus Hotels & Resorts. GHA thus further consolidates its position as the world’s largest hotel alliance of independentand individual brands. The Global Hotel Alliance (GHA) partners Kempinski,Omni, Pan Pacific and Rydges are delighted to welcome three new Members tothe GHA. Furthermore, GHA today launches its new web-site (www.globalhotelalliance.com), the gateway to a truly global travel experience. The new site offers not only attractive prices and ease of booking at all GHA hotels, but also enables customers and travel agents to book flights Lastly, GHA is also partner with many airlines such as Air France, British Airways, Emirates, and Thai Airways (Hsyndicate, 2012). Analysis Dusit would have a great opportunity to take a step of international hotel company as by forming an alliance will help strengthen the power of Dusit to compete with other big hotel chains such as Accor and Starwood. Moreover, AHA and GHA will allow customers to easily search for room availability and confirm room reservations and thus it enhance the sales volume of Dusit. Dusit would be able to diversify its market size around the world by promoting distribution channel through AHA and GHA. Especially, the hotels who are members of GHA can get benefit to expand market in other regions. 3. Acquisition Acquisitions can provide quick access to a new market. Acquisitions often provide the fastest and the largest initial international expansion of any of the alternatives. Thus, entry is much quicker than by other modes. Additionally, as free trade has continued to expand in global markets, cross-border acquisitions have also been increasing significantly. Although acquisitions have become a popular mode of entering international markets they are not without costs. International acquisitions carry some of the disadvantages of domestic acquisitions. Moreover, they can be expensive and also often require debt financing, which carries an extra cost. International negotiations for acquisitions can be exceedingly complex and are generally more complicated than domestic acquisitions. Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket Dusit International announces the acquisition of one of its most successful properties which it has managed for the past 23 years, and one of the best performing hotels is in Phuket- Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket, which was previously owned by Laguna Resorts & Hotels Public Limited Company. Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket has been one of our best managed hotels for over two decades, and has never dropped its performance, even despite the many challenges over this period. However, for this acquisition, Dusit has spent THB 2.62 BILLION (USD82 million) (Dusit International, 2013). Analysis: This successful acquisition will put Dusit in an even stronger position in the market, as well as strengthening its existing portfolio of hotel assets as the hotel continues to grow internationally. Additionally, the company will continue to enhance their presence in Thailand, and will consider some of the high potential deals in the key strategic destinations in Thailand to expand its portfolio. The latest report from STR Global on the “Strong Recovery in Southeast Asia’, Phuket is identified with a RevPAR growth of 36.7% for the first half of 2010 versus 2009, ranked second in Southeast Asia, which shows it’s phenomenal potential. Furthermore, Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket has shown growth in RevPAR over the last 12 months of 16.5%versus the market average of luxury and upscale properties in Phuket, which averages just 9.8% (Dusit International, 2013). The hotel Nikko Manila In 1995, Dusit International has acquired the Hotel Nikko Manila by purchasing shares in the holding company, Philippine Hoteliers Inc. (PHI), from Japan Airlines Development Company Limited and JAL Trading Inc. In addition, the Hotel Nikko Manila came under the management of Dusit Thani Hotels & Resorts, and was renamed the Dusit Hotel Nikko, Manila. Moreover, in April 2008, the Manila hotel also underwent a major renovation programme and became Dusit Thani Manila in order to meet the high Dusit standards (Ollie Quiniquini, 2008). Analysis Dusit is able to enter into the new market easier which is the Philippines market as it has acquired the Nikko Manila. This is a fastest and the best way to emerge into the country. As a result, Dusit is able to develop various projects in the destination and also it has become better well-known in Philippines. 4. New Wholly Owned Subsidiary The establishment of a new wholly owned subsidiary is referred to as a Greenfield venture. The process of creating such ventures is often complex and potentially costly, but it affords maximum control to the firm and has the most potential to provide above-average returns. This potential is especially true of firms with strong intangible capabilities that might be leveraged through a greenfield venture. A firm maintains full control of its operation with a greenfield venture. More control is especially advantageous if the firm has proprietary technology. Research also suggests that “wholly owned subsidiaries and expatriate staff are preferred’’ in service industries where “close contacts with end customers” and “high levels of professional skills, specialized know-how, and customization” are required. Additionally, the risks are also high, however, because of the costs of establishing a new business operation in a new country. The firm may have to acquire the knowledge and expertise of the existing market by hiring either host-country nationals, possibly from competitors, or through consultants, which can be costly. Still, the firm maintains control over the technology, marketing, and distribution of its products. Moreover, the company must build new manufacturing facilities, establish distribution networks, and learn and implement appropriate marketing strategies to compete in the new market. Furthermore, research suggests that when the country risk is high, firm prefer to enter with joint ventures instead of Greenfield investments in order to manage the risk. However, if they have previous experience in a country, they prefer to use a wholly owned Greenfield venture rather than a joint venture. Presently, Dusit is now aiming to expand even more in global markets, thus it has been coming up with new projects in different countries. However, not all projects are started from scratch. The following is the property that is wholly owned by Dusit and just open last year in 2012. Dusit Thani Maldive Dusit Thani Maldive is the second foreign property after the Philippines and is wholly owned by company. Dusit has spent for 2.5 Billion Baht to invest in 100-villa resort melds Thai and Maldivian architecture and services. In addition, Dusit aim is to expand its business and thus it mainly focuses is on seeking more opportunities outside the country. The reason that Dusit want to expand its business is to diversify risk, build a global brand, and increase awareness of the brand in the international market amongst people and to boost up its revenue. Moreover, the company spent at least three years looking for the right location and then it acquired a hotel on Mudhdhoo Island on Baa Atoll, near the country's first Unesco World Biosphere Reserve which is a home to marine life in order to operate at its best, even though Dusit took a lot of time to expand its branch to Maldives compared to any other Thai hotel operators such as Minor and Central (Dusit Thani Maldives, 2010). Analysis Since Dusit Thani Maldive is wholly owned by Dusit International, the company can manage independently resulting in flexible for restructuring management. The company can gain maximum control and can protect commercial secrets in order to avoid losing to the competitors. They put higher investment and can get highest potential returns. However, the company could have a chance to learn and gain new experience from scratch so as to adapt the lesson learnt for future investment in order to avoid high risk and high cost. We cannot yet see Dusit Thani Maldive whether the company will succeed from its investment as the hotel just open last year in 2012. Consequently, Dusit need more time to proof itself whether it can succeed from its investments and that it is the leading Asian’s hotels company in Maldives. There are many upcoming projects of Dusit which will be opened this year in 2013 and in the next few years. The company will have to make decisions on the projects whether it will be joint venture with another company or the company will wholly own project. Therefore, to conclude its strategic plan we have limited information. Dusit Thani Abudabi (2013) Dusit Devarana Hainan China (2013) dusitD2 Pasadena, California, USA (2013) Dusit Thani Dilmunia Bahrain (2013) Dusit Thani Jeddah (2014) However, all properties in India is owned by Dusit Bird Hotel under the management contract which is a joint venture between Dusit and Bird Group and are not wholly owned subsidiaries of Dusit. Moreover, Bird Group is devoted to establish six hotels and resorts in India under the JV agreement. The followings are the coming projects in India, which will be opened soon. dusitD2 New Delhi India (opened 2013) dusitD2 Goa India (opened 2013) Dusit Devarana Rishikesh India (2014) Dusit Devarana Jaipur India (2014) Dusit Devarana New Delhi 3.1 Type of Cooperative Strategy Strategic alliances Joint Venture - Bird group Bird Group is India's fastest growing company with interests in Travel Technology, Aviation Services, Hospitality, Luxury Retail as well as Education. This company is one of India's most trusted brands and this trust extends to a series of products and services that cover other numerous businesses. Bird Group has pioneered many innovations in the areas of IT, GDS and BPO services and presently, Bird Group's core business includes Travel Technology, Aviation Services, Hospitality, Retail and Education. In March 2007, Bird Hospitality Services (BHS), began to do hospitality businesses with Dusit Hotels and Resorts. Under this joint venture, Bird Hospitality Services is committed to develop six 4 - 5 star hotels, which will provide Dusit with the opportunity to manage or franchise several hotels in India. The first three properties, which opened in 2010, are in Delhi, Goa and Rishikesh. The next three which will be open by 2013 will be in Pune, Amritsar and Jaipur. Dusit Bird hotel private company limited manages Dusit Thani Goa, Dusit D2 Goa, Dusit D2 New Delhi, Dusit Devarana New Delhi, Dusit Devarana Jaipur and Dusit Devarana Rishikesh. The total investment in the hotels from Bird Hospitality Services is approximately over 200 million Dollars. With this joint venture, Bird group and Dusit Thani will combine the hospitality proficiency of Dusit International and the local network and knowledge of Bird Hospitality to give India’s hotels and resorts the highest standards of hospitality in the country. India is the potential market for Dusit Thani especially in Delhi, Goa and Rishikesh. Lastly, Goa is gaining demand in leisure travel, both domestic and oversea segment, and Rishikesh has a demand within the leisure and MICE segment. - Le Cordon Bleu To provide the best standards in the education business, Dusit and Le Cordon Bleu have come to an agreement to establish an Academy of World Cuisines located in the Dusit Thani Bangkok hotel, along with the introduction of an international Bachelors of Business Administration in Kitchen and Restaurant Management program. Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Co., Ltd is a joint venture between Dusit Thani Plc and Le Cordon Bleu international company. The Culinary school has been opened since 2007, and the brand name of Le Cordon Bleu can strengthen the education business of Dusit Thani. Moreover, the culinary school of FrenchThai Joint venture can differentiate their hospitality education from others because both cultures can share knowledge and expertise and know the market better. The new partnership will increase the demand in Thailand for people who are professionals as well as nonprofessionals in the culinary industry. Moreover, Le Cordon Bleu company will help Dusit to manage the school for by doing certain activities such as creating a curriculum and recipes, while Le Cordon Bleu will share resources such as human resources that include instructors, equipment and uniform. This will save costs for both parties. Non-equity strategic Alliance 1. Licensing agreement - Tsuji culinary institution Osaka, Japan Dusit Thani College signed an educational cooperation agreement with Japan’s most prestigious culinary institution called the Tsuji culinary institution in Osaka, Japan. The institution agreed to share the traditional Japanese cuisine with Dusit Thani College and the company will open a new curriculum as a culinary art major starting in this year 2013. Moreover, this Japanese institution will send their teachers to conduct the classes, and they also train the instructors from Dusit Thani College to be able to run the program. Both of the institutions guarantees on the highest quality of program. The curriculum is designed to suit with the market demand in Thailand. Brand new kitchens and equipment that are suitable for the course are already bought and set up by the college. - Lyceum University in Philippines Lyceum University Philippines currently has the largest student enrollment of more than 10,000 students in the Hotel & Restaurant Management and Tourism majors. Moreover, The University also provides training hotels for students in a full service hotel of 54 rooms with all facilities required for high level training. This training will be connected to this new learning center in Manila. In 2008, Dusit Thani Public Company Limited has signed a licensing and consulting agreement with Lyceum of the Philippines University to offer Dusit Thani College a popular curriculum in Hospitality Management at the 4 campuses of LPU in the Philippines. Under this agreement, Dusit Thani College will provide the curriculum and academic resource materials for Bachelor of Science in International Hospitality Administration, which is specialized in Hotel and Restaurant Management, Culinary Arts, Restaurant Management, Tourism Management as well as various intensive professional courses in Hotel Management. These courses will also include Dusit Thani College's famous Professional Chef and Culinary Arts programs, at LPU's four campuses located in Manila, Batangas, Laguna and Cavite. Moreover, Dusit Thani hotels also have a branch in the Philippines, so the company allows trainees from LPU to do internship there. - Ecole Hoteliere Lausanne Ecole Hoteliere Lausanne is the world’s first hotel school that became the leader in the hospitality sector in Switzerland and provides the management education of a top business school, while basing its program on its own unique educational philosophy, hospitality management in both science and art. In 2012, Dusit International and Ecole Hôtelière de Lausanne (EHL) launched a new bachelor program (B.B.A) in Thailand. After the agreement was signed, the course was conducted at Dusit Thani College, and targeted both Thai and international students. Dusit Thani College wants to raise the bar for hospitality education in Thailand therefore, In this program, both Thai and International students are accepted and it will be conducted in English. Also, Dusit College wants to prepare to develop a hospitality program in order to compete with the ASEAN community. 2. Distribution Agreement - Asian Hotels Alliance (AHA) Five of Asia’s hotel operators which include Dusit Hotels & Resorts in Thailand, Landis Hotels & Resorts in Taiwan, the Marco Polo Hotel Group in Hong Kong, Meritus Hotels & Resorts in Singapore and New Otani Hotels in Japan joined together to form AHA. The alliance acts as an effective marketing association where all AHA member hotels share a philosophy of Oriental service that distinguishes them from others. Each of the brands under AHA has their own strength. However, the ability of each brand to power its strength through marketing cooperation will make smaller regional companies effectively compete with the larger international brands. AHA launched a web base reservation technology through www.asianhotelsalliance.comwhere customers can search for room availabilities on members’ hotels, and they can also take advantage of special offers and confirm room reservations. As each member of AHA is a well-known brand in each popular destination in Asian region, they can help each other expand their market size in Asia. - Global hotel alliance (GHA) GHA is the world’s largest Alliance of independent luxury hotel brands and it was established since 2004. There are many world-class hotel brands that joined the organization, for example- Kempenski hotels, Marco Polo hotels, Anantara hotels and resorts, Pan Pacific Hotels and Resorts and so on. Moreover, GHA also has a partnership with many airlines such as Air France, British Airways, Cathay Pacific Airways, Lufthansa, Emirates, China eastern, Singapore Airlines, Thai Airways and more. In addition to this, Global hotel alliance has merged with the Asian Hotel Alliance therefore, Dusit Thani also enjoys all the benefits since it is also a member of GHA. For now, members of GHA include more than 200 hotels. The strategy of GHA is that they try to find hotel brands which represent regions and they aim to cover all the regions in the world. For example, for now GHA do not have any hotel members in Paris, so they want to fulfill this spot with the hotels that represent Paris. Therefore, the hotels that are members of GHA can get benefits to expand the market in other regions as well. - Hotel Representation Australia (HRA) Hotel Representation Australia (HRA) is an Australian foremost hospitality agency and is greatly experienced in understanding the needs of hotels and resorts while also seeking to expand their market share in Australia. Moreover, the company offers tourism research reports, marketing strategies and plan formulations, brand strategies, development, product as well as service appraisals. The range of creative marketing services is included traditional advertising and campaigns and design of campaign where they also offer web design and strategy, brochure and newsletter productions and so on. In 2012, Dusit Thani signed an agreement with HRA so the company will support Dusit regional sales representation in Australia and New Zealand. The partnership assists Dusit to have a stronger regional presence throughout Thailand and other destinations. The collaboration with HRA will be the key strength to support expansion in many regions such as Australia and New Zealand, which is the key target growth market of Dusit due to the increasing number of Oceania travelers. According to statistics from the Ministry of Tourism and Sports, Thailand welcomed 477894 travelers from Australia and New Zealand during January to June in 2012. The figure goes up to 10% from 436,617 arrivals during the same period in 2011. Therefore, expanding regional sales in Australia can attract Oceania to come to Dusit more. In addition, Dusit also looks forward to expand their properties to the Australia region and want to develop loyal customers from this region. Therefore, HRA can be one of the effective collaborations to penetrate the Australian market (Dusit News, 2012) - Preferred Hotel Group Preferred Hotel Group is an international hospitality company which provides sales & marketing as well as technology solutions to hotels and resorts around the world. In other word, Preferred hotel group is sale centric organization. Its services include integrated marketing and communications, loyalty programs, trade shows and events, sales support, a solution for reservation management that connects various reservation channels and much more. In 2009, Dusit Thani was announced to create a partnership with Preferred Hotel Group. Under this agreement, Preferred Hotel Group will provide Dusit International with access to its established sales network, global marketing program and leading-edge distribution system, while Dusit Thani will offer a larger portfolio in Asia and middle east to the company. Dusit Thani also benefits from preferred hotel group’s 28 sales regional offices worldwide while the regional sales office of Dusit Thani has only five places including Hongkong, UK, German, Singapore and Bangkok. Furthermore, the partnership will provide Dusit International the benefits of global partnerships with members of Preferred Hotel Group which are more than 700 members including travel management companies, MICE planners, select marketing programs, airline frequent flyer airline partnerships and distribution networks. Dusit will also gain Preferred Hotel Groups’ promotional channels. In the past, Dusit tried to expand their properties in the Asia market. However, presently Dusit wants to reach the global market by expanding to major business and tourism destinations like Europe, the Middle East, India, Indonesia, Philippines and China. Therefore, partnership with Preferred hotel group can bring Dusit to become a global player in the hospitality industry around the world and will also help to extend networks in many regions. 3. Supply Contract - Airlines Dusit Thani has a partnership with 17 airlines which are: Thai airways, Alaska airlines, flying blue (Air France), American Airline, Japan airlines, Korean air, Singapore Airline, etc. Dusit Thani developed a frequent flyers program for customers so when customers stayed at Dusit Thani hotels and resorts, they will get miles to fly with partner airlines. 4. Outsource Commitments - Ruyi Company Limited Ruyi Company limited is a media, branding and marketing agency. The company helps to market, advertise and deal with media for other companies. Dusit Thani has also outsourced Ruyi to do marketing where the company helps to produce media for Dusit Thani products such as Dusit Thani college, Dusit executive and development centre, Devarana Spa and Dusit Thani hotels. In addition to this, Ruyi Company Limited communications agency provides branding, marketing, custom events and creative design services to Dusit International in Bangkok Thailand. Moreover, the company also assists with the re-branding for Dusit Thani hotels and resorts, Dusit D2 and Dusit Princess and Dusit residence in terms of creating a logo, print advertising, online advertising, calendars, newsletters, global directories, mice brochures, brands credo, folder, print banner, print poster, trophy, VDO presentation, screensaver, wallpaper, media consultation, media buying & planning, brand manual, hotels collaterals, hotels brochure and so on. - Ringzero network Thailand RingZero is a company that combines strategic thinking, creativity and technological expertise in order to design, develop and deliver powerful Internet technology and new media business solutions. The company offers software development, game studio and professional service to customers. In 2011, Dusit Thani outsourced Ringzero network Thailand to develop the Dusit official website. Dusit Thani wanted to develop online marketing in order to compete with global competition therefore Dusit's online marketing strategy will play a key role in the long term marketing activities of all Dusit International hotels and resorts. The website has a new design, easy navigation, ability to track guest booking patterns, guest historical records, greater search engine optimization, Multi language, rates and availability display, etc. In addition, the new Dusit website will also help us understand our customer's behavior better with guest history, web statistics, conversion rates and Google analytics features. With an investment of almost $335,000, Dusit aimed to increase the overall online bookings through Dusit.com from 12% in 2010 to 25% in 2011 as minimum. 3.2 Business-Level Cooperative Strategies Joint ventures - Bird Group One of the joint ventures that are in process of development and implementation is the joint venture between Dusit International and Bird Group. Together they form a venture company called Dusit Bird hotel private company limited. The project shared between them is the movement of Dusit Thani Branches through Indian states. This aim is to inject Dusit Thani into the prosperous Indian market. The examples are Dusit Thani Goa and Dusit Devarana New Delhi. By becoming joint ventures with Bird Group they will be able to save cost of marketing activities and operation research and development since Bird Group is a local agency. The investment in Dusit Thani by Bird Group amounted up to 200 Million US Dollars this will add more capital funds to Dusit Thani, creating convenience in funding. They are a 50:50% venture. The Bird Group holds expertise of Hospitality in India. They also have work with related businesses like Aviation and Travel technologies. This also takes care of technological resources acquisition for Dusit International creating an advantage for them over their competitors. Sharing of Information and resources between the Bird Group and Dusit Thani will be an aid to both the companies in finding the most effective strategies as well marketing tactics and product modification to best fit the needs of the Indian Market. Bird Group is considered as a complimentary strategic alliance to Dusit International. They share knowledge of the market and resources to develop competitive advantage in the Indian market. For Example Dusit Thani in India will be a blend between Indian and Thai Hospitality. Bird Group, as an Indian company they have extensive knowledge about the legal requirements and the law of India. They are also comprehensive with the other external environments, which will be able to help Dusit Thani Reduce risks. - Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Thani also moved into the Education Business. With Dusit Thani College they were able to generate popularity in their diversification. To push it further they decided to differentiate themselves from their competitors. To show their quality they moved into a joint venture with one of the most culinary institutions from France. In 2007 they shook hands with Le Cordon Bleu to form Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Company Limited. This makes a difference in their value chain activities, as there is an addition of quality, standard and culture of food and education. This also shifts their marketing mix as its ads more value to their brand name. They decided to add value to their culinary courses hence the decision of collaboration with Le Cordon Bleu. It is now one of the most promising and well-known culinary schools in Thailand. This course opened the first LCB Classic Cycle, which educates about master class French cooking techniques of cuisines and pastries. They also provide short courses at the academy. Because of its popularity more Bachelor degree programs and culinary arts will also be offered to Dusit Thani College. To push it even more and help the Dusit educational institutions this course is not offered to only Thais but throughout the Southeast Asian regions. This course standard of culinary arts provide highest of cooking technologies and equipments that will allow students to use and experiment as well as having the standard of culinary techniques which innovates them above competition and can provide synergy as it is one of the most well-known culinary courses in Thailand. Non- Equity alliance - Airlines Dusit Thani has created partnership with many airlines. This is also one of their strategies to retain customers by using Dusit Frequent flyer programs. Customers who stay at Dusit Thani will be allowed to receive miles exchange from those who are partners with Dusit and use them to achieve certain privilege in the hotel. In addition if the customers can collect mileage from airline companies with affiliation with Dusit they will receive free stays at Dusit Thani Hotel For example if the customers of Thai Airways traveled for more than 12000 miles, they will receive a one night free stay at the hotel. If they traveled 22 miles or more they will receive 2 consecutive night stays and 32000 miles would mean 3 consecutive nights. Joining an airline industry can mean a lot of change therefore they seem to have trouble with orientations. Partners with alliance leads to reduction of their advertising cost as well as distribution costs. Dusit Thani can also promote and advertise through airplanes about their value and experience of stay to their competitor. This will recue their promotion activities and as well as the cost that come with it for PR. Dusit Thani is partner with many airlines with their idea of access to markets all around the world. These airlines are American Airlines, Japan Airlines, Korean airlines and British Airways. This will draw in potential customers for Dusit Thani with many nationalities this can be seen as trying to achieve cost leadership in their value chain activities, as there is a reduction in promotion necessity. - Ecole Hoteliere Lausanne Dusit International is in license with EHL School from Switzerland. Swiss Hospitality schools are world rebound and well certified as quality education in Hospitality management. To develop a new and improved bachelors program on management of hotels and resort Dusit International decided to have affiliations with EHL. This course will cover both Thai and European style hospitality to better develop their students from this college. They desire to differentiate in their marketing mix in terms of services that are compatible to both cultures. This strategy of alliance is to differentiate and increase the quality of their education against other Universities in Thailand. They have implemented a new four years course that offers 2 years in Thailand and 2 years at EHL with degree certifying for both Universities it can lead to a different level in management of Hospitality and tourism in Thailand. Dusit Thani wishes to lift their standard of their institution by adding significant value of their standard with an addition of Swiss Hospitality trainings. - Ruyi Company Limited Dusit Thani outsourced their marketing and media relations to Ruyi Company Limited. This is a vertical complimentary strategic alliance. This outsourcing is to rely on their expertise in the field of marketing to create a competitive advantage in their speed of operations in the marketing aspect of their value chain. One example could be during the rebranding of Dusit International. Dusit Thani wish o rebrand overall image of hotel business, one of such activities was outsourced to Ruyi Company Limited. They are in charge of media, new ads, and advertisement, brochures and article printings. They outsourced these activities to the specialists like Ruyi to save cost and time to improve in their other activities in their value chain accordance to their rebranding. Advertisements are very important during the rebranding procedures because it represents the identity of the company. Using expertise other than their own Ruyi with this alliance also created the design and the idea of Dusit Gold Card as well as the Devarana Spa ads. This will enhance their effectiveness in marketing and promotion as well as create efficiency in production. - Ringzero Network Ringzero Network Company is one of the most effective website creators in Thailand. They are outsourced by Dusit Thani to forge and update their company website and their online booking systems. Dusit Thani spent 335000 U.S. Dollars to develop this website with copy rite included. The website was handmade to be easy to navigate, constant rate updates using automatic system, Multilanguage to operate as well as live booking a high speed. Dusit Thani not only wants to differentiate from their customers with their hotels and other products but also through websites. This is now the matter of distribution chain. By creating comfortable, fast attractive new website that has new features it will attract customers who book through the Internet. The reason for such an expensive website is due to their rebranding decision. The renovation and the redesigning of their brand name as well as the addition of trademarks and issues of copy rites took the website to change its design and its software architecture all together to show the new and improved Dusit Thani. To conclude these strategic alliance strategies of Dusit International that supports their value chain activities. The Bird Group through their expansions to India supports them. The company also helps Dusit Thani to reduce cost of research and development and market survey in operations. They also have strong aids in their distribution channels through The RingZero Company Limited. Their educational institutions value is added through collaborations with Le Cordon Bleu and EHL. Both these institutions can bring education of Dusit Thani College to another level all together. Moreover with their marketing aspect Ruyi Company is aiding them in their marketing mix in terms of promotion. Finally by being partners with Airline companies they can reduce cost of promotion as well as use that fact to create new promotional ideas and packages. 3.3 Corporate-Level Cooperative Strategies GHA Recently Global Hotel Alliance (GHA) has already merged with Asian Hotel Alliance (AHA). The aim was to increase performance and enhances an even bigger network within these two alliances. This automatically makes Dusit International a member of GHA. Members of GHA are highly prestigious with high luxury and service standard provides. This characteristic is similar to Dusit Thani. The initial plan for Dusit International to expand their market through AHA has amplified to global proportions after this merger. Dusit Thani has the Micros Fidelio OPERA system which is how information flow through GHA and how they are linked. Dusit is able to expand its network even further. Diversification was definitely in their book as they aim to distribute their special promotions and offerings through the GHA. E.g. distributing their Gold Card. Their Gold Card Holders are entitled to receive benefits from attending GHA programs they visit. They will feel the enhancement of benefits from the special offerings made by the members (Dusit Loyalty Program, 2008). GHA has also formed Partnership with British Airways Launching their loyalty programs to customers on board. “GHA allows guests to earn 500 miles per stay at all participating GHA hotels, with double miles bonus offer” (Caswell, 2009). Hotel Representation Australia HRA is one of the most reputable tourism agencies in Australia. Hotel Representation Australia is very skilled in aiding those hotels and resorts who have the desire to explore the Australian market. They have extensive experience and understand the needs and wishes of the hotels and Resort groups well. The HRA are very unique as they offer research reports, strategic planning and implementations and they also do product evaluation and brand development. They also implement creative marketing with design of campaign and advertisement for the hotel’s products and services. In addition they also design websites, create brochures and articles for the tourism industries. They are all together a firm of an all rounded talent to help aid Hotel groups in whatever parts they need. Dusit Thani found this efficient and diverse group so, they decided to sign an agreement with the HRA company in 2012 for them to aid in regional sales and promotion in Australia and New Zealand. This partnership will assist Dusit Thani to a strong regional presence though out Thailand and other destinations. This smart collaboration with HRA will push Dusit Thani to ease in their expansion within Australia and New Zealand. This can become their key strength to achieve synergy. During the first Half of 2012 Thailand had successfully drawn in 477,894travellers from Australia and New Zealand according to statistics from the Ministry of Tourism and Sports. This is shows an increase of 10% compared to 2011 during the same period, which was 436617 arrivals during the first Half as well. This figure proves that the collaboration is working as after the implementation of collaboration with HRA there has been an increase in Oceana travelers to Dusit Thani. “Moreover, HRA will be one of the key strengths in supporting the new expansion of Dusit in Maldives, Delhi, Abu Dhabi and Hainan during 2012-2013”. (Koumelis, 2012) AHA Dusit Thani is one of the 5 most respected groups in the Asian Hotel Alliance (AHA). Joining this alliance is one of Dusit Thani’s Corporate-level Cooperative strategies. By joining this alliance Dusit is enabled to branch out their market shares. AHA is a strong association that holds the power to stabilize there individual as well as collective market shares. AHA aims to aid each other in what others lack in for example Dusit Thani is considerably smaller compared to a few big hotel chains in this case AHA will come to Dusit’s aid in terms of international market additional recourses and network building. All the hotels in this alliance will join forces to confront with other multinational competitors. One of the ways they are connected is the joint reservation system this will strengthen their marketing profile and increase chances of profitability through customer network and information flow. Members of AHA also help each other in joint loyalty programs for e.g. if one of their members are over booked the customers will be escorted to another member of AHA nearby. They also participate in trade shows together. In 2001 the AHA brochure was funded entirely by Dusit International with joint promotion distributing more than 80,000 copies of the first AHA joint brochure (Muqbil, 2001). This group also has their joint website where customers can make their reservations with any of the members in one single website for convenience. AHA intern is the fastest way for Local Hotels like Dusit Thani to reach the international market. Contract with PHG The partnership agreement between Dusit international and the Preferred Hotel group in a selective service agreement certifies a new beginning of a strategy implementation. This will provide Dusit International with the ability to access the PHG sales networks thus expanding their distribution channels and promotional with the ability to access a cutting-edge distribution planning systems. They offer PHG a larger portfolio of prestigious properties that Dusit International has been building in UAE and India This strategic partnership targets Dusit Thani’s major expansion with 50 hotels Across Middle East, Asia and European Regions. This is considered an aggressive expansion plan as Dusit Thani priorities to achieve higher returns for their stakeholders on their assets, facilities, services, technology and strategic alliance. This specific agreement between the two firms allows Dusit to sustain their brand name and identity with the access to PHG’s 28 sales offices worldwide. This adds to Dusit Thani’s 6 regional sales offices in Australia, Britain, Singapore, Germany, Hong Kong and Bangkok. In addition, this partnership provides Dusit International access to certain benefits in the global partnerships that PHG has negotiated with their 700 member’s hotels and resorts including corporate account managements with some of largest multinational organizations travel management companies, Event Planners, marketing specialists, airlines and Distribution networks. They will gain exposure through PHG promotional channels to gain their target market’s attention. For example, Dusit Thani is the primary Asian hotel organization who is able to utilize the private label chain code called BC in the GDS or Global Distribution system through SynXis Central Reservation system or CRS in January 2010. This has significantly broadened Dusit Thani’s reach in the market. This connection to SynXis of CRS is provided by Sabre Hospitality Solutions through PHG. (Dusit International goes strength, 2010). Educational Cooperation agreement with Tsuji Culinary Institute. At their Educational institution corporate level business Dusit International’s Dusit Thani College has recently signed an educational cooperate agreement with Tsuji Culinary Institute. This is one of the best culinary schools in Japan. Other than Le Cordon Bleu, Tsuji Culinary will provide diversification in Dusit Thani’s culinary institutions. This will provide the students with an opportunity to learn the art of Japanese cuisine. This strategy and the courses were designed to meet the market trend of Japanese food domination in the Thai market. This will speak to the demands of the trend towards Japanese cuisines. With this brand new facilities and state of the art kitchen equipment’s are installed in the institution for specific Japanese cooking in Dusit Thani College. Tsuji will provide Japanese chefs to the Dusit Thani College as well for the culinary courses that they will implement to be the Japanese cuisine instructor at the college (Citrinot, 2012). This provides the variety of course choices as well as a diversification towards Japanese cuisine cooking, which not many universities provide. This is a product differentiation. Students who graduate from this program will have extensive skill and knowledge of the trend in Japanese cuisines. As Dusit Thani implement internal recruitment from their college its self it is likely that they will become work forces of Dusit International. By being able to produce Japanese tastes quinines as well as courses they will be able to enhance their ability to target Japanese customers around the world in both long and short run. Licensing Agreement with Lyceum of the Philippines University ("LPU") Dusit Thani has signed an agreement with Lyceum of the Philippines University or LPU the Dusit curriculum Thani of to offer popular Hospitality Management at all the 4 campuses Philippines of LPU itself. in Dusit International will also provide academic resources and materials important for Hospitality management courses in 4 of LPU campuses in Manila, Laguna, Batangas and Cavite with training courses to all students in Philippines (Dusit Thani Ties up, 2008). This action will enhance their brand awareness even further in the Philippines market by diversifying towards education institutions and training provisions. So for they have only Dusit Thai Manila in Philippines which is their only branch there. They decided to follow through with this agreement to enhance their existence in the Philippines to show their competency in Hospitality management. This is also a step to Move the Dusit Thani College oversees. The aim of expanding their educational institution is a long-term goal this is one of their strategies. This is also to diversify their work force variety in the future. This is a step towards global expansion to become an international company. 3.4 International Cooperative Strategy According to Dusit International Annual report from the past 5 years Dusit International shows no signs of such kind of strategic alliance. There is no cross border activity that spells international strategies in the report. So far Dusit International has joined AHA, GHA and Preferred Hotel group to aid them through their expansions in the international market. Dusit Thani is still in the Phase of expansion and these alliances have aided them to such objectives. From the analysis of Dusit International Annual report Dusit Thani is not strong enough yet to manage a complex international alliance strategy. 3.5 Network Cooperative Strategy Dusit International, in their network cooperative strategy, has partnered with two major hotel alliances which is the preferred hotel group and global hotel alliances. These are the two alliance networks that work together to obtain economies of scale as well as build long term relationships for future growth. The members of this alliance have the same objective because they’re all in the tourism industry. Below are the details of the operation of this alliance as well as the benefits that Dusit International can obtain from them. Preferred Hotel Group (PHG) Preferred Hotel group is a global collection of independent hotels, destination resorts, city center hotels, luxury residences, and unique hotel groups. They have built their reputation as a global leader in the hospitality industry since 1968. They consist of more than 850 hotels across its eight worldwide brands which are Preferred Hotels and Resorts, Summit Serviced Residences, Sterling Hotels, Sterling Design, Historic Hotels of America, and Historic Hotels worldwide. They provide integrated marketing and communications, loyalty programs, trade shows and events, sales support, quality assurance and group purchasing, total branded connectivity and a solution for reservation management that connects various reservation channels. (preferredhotelgroup.com) Therefore, Dusit could take advantage of these benefits by developing sales relationships between its partners; have a thorough understanding of distribution technologies, the dynamics of the market place and also the access of consumers. PHG has 5 travel partners: Historic Hotels of America, Earn Airline Miles, American Express, Sixt Rent a Car and Dusit. - Historic Hotels of America Their purpose is to identify quality hotels that have faithfully maintained their historic integrity, architecture and ambiance. Historic Hotels of America preserves the authencity of America’s most prominent lodging addresses and offer visitors a remarkable travel experience to savor, celebrate and share. Members (hotels) are promoted nationally and internationally to those who prefer historic settings for their leisure and business travel. - Earn Airline Miles When staying at more than 500 participating PHG around the world, customers will earn airline miles. They will have 16 airline partners to choose from. - American Express American Express is a global services company, providing access to products, insights and experiences. They are the world’s largest card issuer by purchase volume, with over 70 million card members and 2200 travel services locations worldwide. They have partnered with Preferred Hotels and Resorts and Summit Hotels and Resorts to offer promotions and special offerings, all their properties accept the American Express cards making it convenient for customers. - Sixt Rent a Car PHG has partnered with Sixt, the oldest, most prestigious car rental company in all of Europe and the world. They currently have 220,000 rental vehicles in 105 countries around the globe. PHG offer a complimentary sixt gold card membership where members obtain benefits such as mobile check in, preferred customer service and up to 10% discount on best available online rates. This can help increase revenue in member hotels because PHG provides a large selection of marketing services such as monthly e-newsletters, travel agent promotions and co-operative advertising programs. Therefore, Dusit is able to enter the international market due to a larger network and better cooperative relationships between partner companies. Global Hotel Alliance (GHA) GHA is the world’s largest alliance of independent luxury hotel brands and offer of the industry’s best hotel loyalty and reward programmes. They bring together reputable hotel brands from across the globe including Anantara Hotels and Resorts, Kempinski Hotels, The Leela Hotels, Palaces and Resorts, The Doyle Collection, First Hotels, Lungarno Collection, Marco Polo Hotels, Mokara Hotels and Spas, Pan Pacific, Shaza Hotels, Tangram Hotels, Omni and Tivoli Hotels and Resorts surrounding 160 luxury hotels with more than 46,000 rooms in 41 different countries. Dusit could gain an advantage of expanding to these regions around the world that is full of diversity. Apart from hotel partners, GHA is also partnered with airlines frequent flyer programmes with Air France, British Airways, All Nippon Airways, Cathay Pacific Airways, China Eastern, Emirates, Etihad Airways, Jet Airways, Kingfisher, Lufthansa, Qatar Airways, SAS, Singapore Airlines, South African Airways and Thai Airways. Moreover, they are also partnered with two car rental companies which are Avis Rent-a-Car and Sixt Rent-a-Car (gha.com) GHA provides a lot of opportunities for Dusit by partnering with many companies. First, sales can be maximized since partners could share their products, for example, GHA could cooperate with their partner airlines to come up with a promotional campaign s that tourists who travel with those airlines could also use the accommodation provided by the member hotels worldwide as a package. Second, GHA acts as the most effective online distribution channels for Dusit International, through the website; customers could promptly access the website and book a room. This can save costs for Dusit in terms of operations through GHA such as advertising costs and costs of distribution. 3.6 Managing Cooperative Strategies Cost Minimization - Bird Group The Bird Group is amongst the largest and most diversified entities within the industry. They have pioneered many innovations in the areas of IT, GDS and BPO services. Their core businesses include Travel Technology, Aviation Services, Hospitality, Retail and Education. Since India is one of the fastest growing countries, the joint venture between Dusit and Bird group would give Dusit many advantages. Dusit International has development plans all over the country, which means there will be a high level of competition in India’s hospitality industry. By joining the Bird group, it was help Dusit in terms of cost reduction by: 1. The funds that Dusit receives from the Bird group can help in covering costs for the marketing campaign and other expenses. This means they share their costs by half. As a result, Dusit only needs to invest 50% while in return; they get the same amount of income. 2. Bird group has many businesses in terms of diversification under its brand. Dusit can use this to its advantage in their operations. For instance, since the Bird group is the largest technology provider to the Indian travel industry. Dusit could use their technology to create a software program on their computer system in all their hotels around India for reservations, customer management, accounting and ecommerce. They will be able to cover all the industry segments including airlines, online travel agencies, corporate and hospitality. 3. It is quite difficult for a foreign company to run a business in an unfamiliar country. They have limited information on the potential market and the culture of the region. To run a successful business, the foreign company needs to understand the customer’s lifestyle, culture, personal preference, legality, and political issues. Any clashes in the two countries in terms of these can result in a huge loss of investment. Since the Bird Group is an Indian based company, the can help Dusit International avoid problems and meet the customers requirement very well. Marketing will be easier, and Dusit can avoid legal problems therefore reducing their risk of failing. (bird.in) Airlines Another way to reduce Dusit International’s marketing cost is partnering with the 17 airlines around the world. Dusit International provides customers with the ‘frequent flyer program’ where customers can collect mileages in exchange for accommodation at Dusit hotels. Moreover, when staying at Dusit Thani, customers will receive a miles per qualified stay. This helps Dusit in terms of cost leadership of value chain activities. We can also say that this acts as a free advertising technique for Dusit International because its alliance with airlines automatically acts as a distribution channel. Brand expansion occurs as well since more customers will be aware of it. Therefore, once the customers experience their stay with Dusit, it will lead to brand loyalty as well.(dusit.com) Opportunity Maximization - AHA Since Dusit International is one of the five members of AHA, it can compete with larger international companies. It can help Dusit International grow its customer base, by reaching customers outside Thailand, such as Japan and Taiwan who are also part of AHA. Their brand reputation and awareness can also be created and improved. Since AHA gives its members the credibility they deserve, trust can be gained from customers as well as employees. In addition, Dusit International can obtain market information from other companies under AHA, it saves time and research costs, and marketing can be done more efficiently. As a result, Dusit can reduce marketing costs while gaining new markets and customers. - GHA Since AHA is a part of GHA, Dusit International is a part of GHA too. Their excellent reputation for being the world’s largest alliance of independent luxury hotel brands makes the alliance with them beneficial to compete with big chain hotels (gha.com). Dusit International can build their reputation as a high end brand. Customers will also trust them with the quality and value for money. They will also gain an advantage through GHA’s airline partnership. The benefits they receive from AHA and GHA is very similar except with GHA, they gain global benefits. AHA helps Dusit in the Asian market and GHA helps Dusit in the international market (larger base). Dusit International can also avoid mistakes or learn new things from other companies under GHA. They can do benchmarking, where they compare themselves to other companies and adopt some of their strategies, this can reduce their risk for failure tremendously. - PHG Dusit can gain many opportunities here. PHG and its expanded network can bring more customers to the hotels. When Dusit International has an alliance with other companies under PHG, their marketing opportunities are generated automatically. Dusit International could choose to offer sales offices to PHG in different regions to cover a larger market base. These offices provide any support relating to sales which can boost their performance. Since PHG has partners with businesses in the MICE industry, airline industry and the travel industry, Dusit International can use this opportunity to work with companies in these industries. They also provide a marketing solution service which eliminates Dusit’s risks and weaknesses. - Lyceum of the Philippines University In 2009, the Dusit Thani College initiated a programme with the Lyceum of the Philippines University (LPU) to prepare young people for a future career in the hospitality industry. This gives an opportunity for people in the Philippines to be aware of the Dusit International brand. It also gives them the opportunity produce quality employees for their brand. The exchange of students between Dusit Thani College and LPU help exchange cultures and company structures. Graduates from these two establishments will have a thorough knowledge, skill, and ability to deal with customers. Dusit will also be able to obtain a diversified workforce, giving them the opportunity to enter the international market quickly and easily.(dusit.com) - Tsuji Culinary Institute On August 10, 2012, Dusit Thani College entered into a landmark agreement with Japan’s most prestigious culinary institute, the Tsuji Culinary Institute of Osaka to offer authentic Japanese cuisine courses to its students as well as the general public. Japanese cuisine courses and learning materials are carefully designed to suit the market needs in Thailand. Since the Japanese cuisine is one of the healthiest and most unique cuisines, skills developed from this program can help Dusit gain customers who appreciate this cuisine. Their products can be diversified and maybe in the future, Dusit Thani can start projects in the culinary aspect abroad. (dusit.com) - Hotel Representation Australia (HRA) On August 9, 2012, Dusit International announced its new representation agreement with HRA, which is recognized as one of Australia’s foremost hospitality agencies. Under their agreement, HRA will support Dusit International as one of its regional sales representative in Australia and New Zealand, which are among the company’s key emerging source markets. According to statistics from the ministry of tourism and sports, Thailand welcomed 477,894 travelers from Australia during January to June 2012. Joining HRA will provide Dusit with information about the travelers from Oceania to help the market segmentation. It is vital to know the customers wants, needs, preferences, behaviors as well as culture to be successful in the hospitality industry. Since HRA is an expert in many areas such as the business strategies, research and marketing services, having a sales representative in other regions can help Dusit collect reliable data, and lead Dusit in the right direction while taking lesser risks.(dusit.com) - Le Cordon Bleu Dusit and Le Cordon Bleu established an Academy of world cuisines located next to Dusit Thani Bangkok and the introduction of an international Bachelor’s of Business Administration in Kitchen and Restaurant Management program at Dusit Thani college. These educational programs are not only opened to Thais, but for the entire South East Asian region. They will have the chance to recruit students from Le Cordon Bleu to add to their human resources in Dusit International. They can ensure that students that graduate have the right skills to work for their hotels, moreover, there won’t be extra coaching needed and the recruitment process will be easy, there will be a stable flow of employees. They can save time and money because they don’t need to search for the right candidate; this is their advantage over many hotels. There is also a higher chance for expansion in France because their reputation will be formed. Having a partnership with a reputable institute can increase their credibility in Thailand and other countries that are aware of Le Cordon Bleu to provide the best service to their customers. (dusit.com) - Ecole Hoteliere Lausanne (EHL) On January 19, 2012, Dusit Thani College and EHL signed an agreement to launch a new international Bachelor Programme (B.B.A) on hotel and resort management. This is the first step for the exclusive relationship which brought together Dusit Thani and EHL to raise the bar for hospitality education in Thailand. The programme is available for both Thai and international students which will be conducted in English. This program was established to prepare and to further develop the hospitality talent in the wake of the Asean Economic Community (SEC) 2015 agreement. Since EHL is the first hotel school in Switzerland, where the art of being a hotelier is from, Dusit will gain an opportunity to be known in the foreign market since there will be an exchange of students between the two institutes. Quality employees can also be obtained through this partnership. Moreover, Dusit can use EHL as a source of learning and developing for its current employees where lecturers from EHL can train hotel staff or the hotel staff can attend the program. This will improve the employee’s skills and motivation to be better, leading to better service within the hospitality industry.(dusit.com) - Ruyi Company Limited Ruyi Company Limited is a creative media, design, branding and communication solutions agency based in Bangkok. Whether it is for branding, market penetration, or just getting a simple message across, they have the ability to deliver concept, construct and comprehension for the client’s various markets. As an expert, Ruyi would definitely know the current trends in the market, which is why they would be able to advise Dusit on the time to enter the market and which market they need to enter. This way, potential customers can be reached effectively and quickly without any time and resources wasted. They can ensure higher revenue and an increase in brand image. (ruyi-company.com) - Ringzero Network Thailand Ringzero is a company that combines strategic thinking, creativity and technological expertise in order to design, develop and deliver powerful end-to-end internet technology and new media business solutions. Since the internet is an extremely powerful tool to reach customers quickly and easily, Dusit should hire the expertise of Ringzero to help. One of the main works of Ringzero is to create websites; Dusit can hire them to create and attractive and easily accessible website to make it easier for customers to find information and book rooms online using their hi-tech gadgets. They can target more markets by offering their website in different languages. It’s a good opportunity to expand their customer base (rznet.com). 3.7Leadership Style A leadership style is a leader’s style of providing direction, implementing plans, and motivating people. Leadership is less about your needs, and more about the needs of the people and the organization you are leading. Leadership styles are not something to be tried on like so many suits, to see which fits. Rather, they should be adapted to the particular demands of the situation, the particular requirements of the people involved and the particular challenges facing the organization. “Leaders are shaped and defined by character. Leaders inspire and enable others to do excellent work and realize their potential. As a result, they build successful, enduring organizations. As I have conducted an interview with the front office manager of Dusit Club, Khun Wanchai Paksee, said that according to him the leadership style should be a clear leader in terms of understanding, coaching, training, and even controlling in order to make sure that the operations will run smoothly. Also, assigning the right person to the right job will ensure that the task will be accomplished successfully. In addition, he said that the staffs are empowered and encouraged to make decisions by themselves only within the scope. For example, if the walk in guest comes in and ask for the room rate and if they find it too expensive or even asking for discounts then the staffs can’t just make their own decision but they have to consult the manager at first. Moreover, he emphasized a lot on coaching staff of how to deal with the guest efficiently and effectively that is the win-win situation. This is because if the staffs are not trained well or if they are being treated unfairly, then eventually staffs won’t be happy and they won’t treat customers well and when customers are not satisfied or happy with the services they received from the staff then they will not come back to stay at the hotel and thus loss of profitability for the company. However, to prevent this from occurring, the leaders inspire enthusiasm to all its staffs and are energetic in motivating others to move forward. The excitement and commitment from teams is an enormous benefit. Furthermore, they empower and encourage their staffs in the decision making process, they encourage creativity, and all the members are often highly engaged in projects and decisions. As a result, the members tend to have high job satisfaction and are productive because they are more involved in decisions. This also helps develop people’s skills. Consequently, members feel in control of their destiny, so they are motivate to work hard by more than just a financial reward. Khun Wanchai said that even though participation takes times as it slows down the decision making, but the result is often good, but the downside is that some members might not have the knowledge or expertise to provide high quality input. Also, I have conducted another interview with front office manager of Dusit front desk, Khun Veerapol Poungvarin, he said that transformation leadership is often the best leadership style to use in business situations. To illustrate, Dusit Thani have transformational leaders as they are inspiring because they expect the best from everyone on their team as well as themselves. This leads to high productivity and engagement from everyone in their team such that to exceed the expectations others have of them, to continuously enrich their capabilities, and to place the interests of the organization above their own. Moreover, transformational leaders develop and communicate a vision for the organization and formulate a strategy to achieve the vision. They make the followers aware of the needs to achieve valued organizational outcomes and encourage them to continuously strive for higher levels of achievement. Also, transformational leaders have emotional intelligence. Emotionally intelligent leaders understand themselves well, have strong motivation, are empathetic with others and have effective interpersonal skills. As a result of these characteristics, transformational leaders are especially effective in promoting and nurturing innovations in the company. 3.8Organizational Structure & Culture Management Mr.ChaninDonavanik, Chief Executive Officer Mr. Giovanni Angelini, Vice Chairman Mr. David Shakelton, Chief Operating Officer Sales and Marketing Ms. Catherine McNabb, Vice President Sales and Marketing Education Mr.KhampiSuwanarat, Managing Director – Education Mr. Gary Cromie , Joint- Venture Director of Le Cordon Bleu Dusit Culinary School Human Resources Mr. Tan Eng Leong, Vice President – Human Resources Development Operations Mr. Jiri Kobos, Vice President – Operations This is the big picture of Dusit International’s chain of comand from all its operationg companies For the complete company’s organisational structure it is considerable normal that it will be a massive chain of command as it is not possible to attend to each outlets or personnel directly at all times. Dusit Thani choose to use Matrix structure to show the direct chains of command between all outlets and departments of each organisation. This groups Dusit Thani employees by product that they deliver and their function in such product. This is a combination of functional structure branching into divisional structure Companies with more than 1 product mainly use this kind of structure or more than one corporate level services in the case of Dusit Thani. This kind of structure shows organisational structures within the organisational structures such as Dusit Thani hotels and Resorts will have another organisational structure within it with a Hotel management division governing all branches. This is the case where only the Directors of each product line will report to the Board of Directors. Other communications will be passed on. This might create a slow flow of communications from head of organisation to the rest as each of there products also has many branches. However this is an unusual structure as their corporate level businesses such as culinary school is not clearly mentioned as well as their Deverana spa is under the command of Hotel division Thisisanintegratedgeneralorganisationalstructureof Dusit Hoteloperations. As we can see this is a closer look into one of the divisions in the whole organisational structure from big picture to a smaller picture. This is an example of a general guideline Dusit Thani Hotel’s organisational chart. They tend to specify their work place as a warm and friendly environment to work in. this also shows in their organisational structure, as it is a functional structure. The functional structure is basically an organisational structure where such divisions or departments in hotels are categorised by their functions for example Front Office departments come under the rooms division which I a team of Front office and Housekeeping for those whose function is to coordinate to provide expectable standardised clean rooms for guest. To go into even more detail Dusit Thani tries to create a homely environment for staffs to work in. this also show in their organisational structure as it shows that it is quite flat in accordance to today’s trend. We can see that the pink level and the blue levels are the same. It might look like a different level but Rooms Department comprises of front office manager and housekeeping manger together as a team that becomes the room division. Accordingly the F&B comprises of the front of the house and the kitchen again to work as a team. Basically when the information flows to the pink level it means that the blue all the blue level had already received it. Dusit Thani makes sure that their management levels are close to their working level personals to create an environment that is fit to work in. this is to create a since of responsibility and closeness between the staff which can improve their quality of work as working evaluation and feedback is easier with a flatter organisational structure. “Dusit Thani has six main formal report structures of the company including Annual Report, Financial Statement, Annual Registration Statement, Notice, Performance Report and Minutes. In addition, Dusit Thani organizational reports are always up-to-date in its website and have issued various formal organizational reports to public. Dusit is very open to the public about showing their performance and can easily create trust from the customers “(Dusit International, 2012). Culture Ravasi and Schultz (2006) state that organizational culture is a set of shared mental assumptions that guide interpretation and action in organizations by defining appropriate behavior for various situations. Every organization has their own culture and so does Dusit Thani. Dusit Thani means “town in heaven” this does not apply to only customers but their staffs as well. Dusit Thani is well known for resembling and amplifying “Thainess”. They are one of the first Hotels of Thai origin that has made their mark in the world by expanding. Inside their working culture the organization shows a Thai style service. They will always do the “Wai” while greeting customers and address them by “Sawasdekha/khrap”. They try to bring in all the Thai culture in their atmosphere as well as behaviours. For example Thailand is known as the land of smiles. It is one of their main focus that they shall smile at their customers at all times to make them feel warm and welcomed just like when they enter in to Thailand when the customers enter Dusit Thani Hotels anywhere in the world the aim is to make them feel as if they have come to Thailand. “For over 60 years it has been our inspiration for the experience we aim to create for our guests at every moment of every day. Seizing on this inspiration it has become a guiding light for our founder Thanpuying Chanut Piyaoui. From a dream conceived in Thailand, Dusit International has grown into a leading collection of luxury hotels and resorts. In doing so, we have taken our unique and distinctive Thai heritage and service standards, throughout the world.” (Dusit International, n.d.) They focus on Thai heritage as we can see that their rooms are designed using Thai architecture to create a Thai atmosphere of stay to their customers. This can also be seen on their costume policy for their staff. They wear a traditional Thai silk dress, which depicts the olden days of Siam in today’s world. As said above on their website their main focus is bringing old traditional Thai heritage feeling to this modernize world. This is clearly shown in their room designs that they have renovated to fit today’s trend of simple designs with a blend with the old traditional Thai designs. This is also shown in their resort designs, which shows similarities to the Thai Salaa. It is not only shown in their presence for customer’s perception but also in their working environment. From source inside the company as Dusit Thani is a Thai company they tend to follow the Thai behaviour of co-dependency (Hofstede, 2013). This is shown very clearly in their Organizational structure above that their F&B and kitchen department are blend together as one team. The same does with their housekeeping and their front office department. However this will benefit them as it creates a flatter structure and more efficient and speed of communication will be practiced from the higher authorities. As their workforce also comprise of foreigners they tend to blend their organizational culture to be flatter to answer to today’s trends. They also train their staff to be behaving according to their theme, which is “Thainess”, which is Dusit Thani’s trademark. Dusit Thani’s aim is to bring the feeling of Thai hospitality to their customers as one of the pioneers they are well competent for such capability. This however also shows in their working environment. To follow their theme and to be consistent with this to their customers they also practice on themselves as they have staff parties with Thai theme and everything is done within the Hotel. The staffs are also trained to serve the traditional Thai way which is shown mostly towards their VIP with the action of bending while walking pass the VIP customers. This also adds to Hofstede study of Thai culture, which shows a significant difference in power between those with power and those without and in Dusit culture the customers are always the priority. Their organizational culture is shown both to customer’s perception as well as between their working colleagues Dusit Thani’s organizational culture revolves around the idea of being Thai. The Balanced Scorecard The balanced scorecard is a framework firms can use to verify that they have established both strategic and financial controls to assess their performance. This technique is most appropriate for use when dealing with business-level strategies; however, it can also be used with the other strategies firms may choose to implement e.g. corporate level, international and cooperative. The underlying premise of the balanced scorecard is that firms jeopardize their future performance possibilities when financial controls are emphasized at the expense of strategic controls, in that financial controls provide feedback about outcomes achieved from past actions, but do not communicate the drivers of future performance. Thus an overemphasis on financial control has the potential to promote managerial behavior that sacrifices the firm’s long-term, value creating potential for short-term performance gains. An appropriate balance of strategic controls and financial controls, rather an overemphasis on either, allows firms to effectively monitor their performance (Balanced Scorecard, 2013). There are four perspective that are integrated to form the balanced scorecard framework: financial (concerned with growth, profitability, and risk from the shareholders perspective), customer (concerned with the amount of value customers perceive was created by the firm’s products), internal business processes (with a focus on the priorities for various business processes that create customer and shareholder satisfaction), and learning and growth (concerned with the firm’s effort to create a climate that supports change, innovation and growth). Consequently, using the balanced scorecard framework allows the firm to understand how it looks to shareholders (financial perspective), how customers view it (customer perspective), the processes it must emphasize to successfully use its competitive advantage (internal perspective), and what it can do to improve its performance in order to grow (learning and growth perspective). Moreover, firms use different criteria to measure their standing relative to the scorecard’s four perspectives. The firm should select the number of criteria that will allow it to have both a strategic understanding and a financial understanding of its performance without becoming immersed in too many details. For example, we know from research that a firm’s innovation, quality of its goods and services, growth of its sales, and its profitability are all interrelated. 1. Financial Control Financial control focuses on financial outcome of the organization in the short-term. We look at ability of the firm in managing funds including spending incurred and revenues earned. If the firm is lack of effective financial control it may cause the firm in loss of profit making or in bankruptcy risk. However, as financial controls focus on historical outcomes and do not measure creation or destruction of future economic value. Therefore, manager should focus on appropriate balance of financial controlas well as strategic controls in order to achieve high levels of performance. Financial performance comparison between Dusit Thani and Shangri-La Measures of liquidity 1. Current ratio Current ration indicates the liquidity of a company in paying short-term debt 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 0.743x 0.721x Shangri-la 0.945x 0.568x From this ratio, it shows that Dusit Thani had current ratio of 0.721x in year 2011. In the next year 2012, it reveals that the current ratio is 0.743x (DTC, 2012). This indicates that Dusit Thani had performed slightly better in liquidity since the hotel has higher ability to pay back the short-term debts by the increase of 0.02x. In contrast, Shangri-La perform better in 2012 which is 0.945x meaning they have better ability to cover short-term debt than Dusit Thani so far (SHANG, 2012). However, both hotels had current ratios which are less than 1. It means that the hotels have total current assets less than total current liabilities. Therefore, the company still has a problem of paying short-term debts because of its inadequate current ratio. 2. Quick ratio Quick ratio or Acid test is a ratio that develops from current ratio. In calculation, we don’t bring inventory to calculate with other current assets such as cash and account receivables due to the fact that inventory convert itself into cash slowly than other ones 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 0.694x 0.682x Shangri-la 0.911x 0.526x From this ratio, it shows that Dusit Thani had quick ratio of 0.682x in year 2011. In the next year 2012, it reveals that the quick ratio is 0.694x (DTC, 2012). This indicates that Dusit Thani performs slightly better in liquidity since the hotel has higher ability to pay back the short-term debts with the increase of 0.012x. In contrast, Shangri-La perform better in 2012 which is 0.911x (SHANG, 2012). However, both hotels quick ratios are less than 1. It means that the hotels have total current assets less than total current liabilities. Therefore, both companies still has problem in paying short-term debts. Asset Management Ratio 1. Inventory Turnover Inventory Turnover indicates how many times that a business has an ability to sell inventory 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 49.4x 47.07x Shangri-la 54.1x 35.9x The inventory turnover of Dusit Thani for year 2011was at 47.07x. While in 2012 it turnover rate has increased to 49.4x (DTC, 2012). This indicates that Dusit Thani has performed better inventory management to generate sales. In contrast, Shangri-La’s inventory turnover for 2012 has increased a lot from 35.9x in 2011 to 54.1x in 2012 (SHANG, 2012). This shows that Shangri-La has a lot improvement in their inventory management. As you can see that the inventory turnover of Dusit Thani for 2012 was at 49.4x while Shangri-La was at 54.1x. This can be concluded that the performance of inventory management of Shangri-La become better than Dusit Thani. This indicates that Dusit Thani might carry too many inventory or managing inventory not as efficient as Shangri-La. 2. Days Sales Outstanding A measure of the average number of days that a company takes to collect revenue after a sale has been made. 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 34 days 55 days Shangri-la 34 days 25 days From the ratio shown, in 2011 Dusit Thani’s days sales outstanding ratio was at 55 which means Dusit Thani had to wait 55 days to receive cash after they made sales. While in 2012 the ratio decreased to 34 (DTC, 2012). This indicates that Dusit Thani wait shorter in the next year from 55 days in 2011 to 34 days in 2012. Meaning, Dusit Thani had improved its performance comparing to previous year. In contrast, Shangri-La’s DSO was at 25 days in 2011 and increased to 34 days in 2012 (SHANG, 2012). This shows that after comparing to previous year Shangri-La had waited longer while Dusit Thani had waited shorter which is a good sign for Dusit. However, after comparing both companies’ DSO of 2012 we will see that both hotels had waited for 34 days which means they has ability to collect cash back at the same length of time. 3. Fixed Assets Turnover A financial ratio of net sales to fixed assets. The fixed-asset turnover ratio measures a company's ability to generate net sales from fixed-asset investments - specifically property, plant and equipment (PP&E) - net of depreciation. 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 0.6 0.5 Shangri-la 0.418 0.296 The fixed asset turnover of Dusit Thani in 2011 was at 0.5. While in 2012 the turnover rate increased to 0.6 (DTC, 2012). This indicates that Dusit Thani’s performance in managing their fixed asset to generate sales has slightly improved from previous year. Whereas,Shangrila-La’s fixed asset turnover in 2011 was at 0.296 and increased to 0.418 in 2012 (SHANG, 2012). However, the higher ratio of Dusit’s turnover rate shows that Dusit Thani has more potential in using fixed asset in order to generate more sales to the company than Shangri-La. 4. Total Assets Turnover The total asset turnover ratio measures the ability of a company to use its assets to generate sales. The total asset turnover ratio considers all assets including fixed assets, like plant and equipment, as well as inventory and accounts receivable. 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 0.5 0.419 Shangri-la 0.344 0.267 In 2011, the total asset turnover of Dusit Thani was shown at 0.419 while in 2012 the ratio increased to 0.5 (DTC, 2012). This can be said that comparing to previous year Dusit had more capability to use its total asset to generate sales. On the other hand, Shangri-La’s total asset in 2011 was at 0.267 while increased to 0.344 in 2012 (SHANG, 2012). It displays that Shangri-La had also improved its potential in utilizing its total assets to generate more sales. However, the higher ratio of Dusit Thani indicates that DusitThani utilized their total asset to generate sales more effective than Asia hotel. Debt Management Ratio 1. Debt ratio Debt ratio is a financial ratio that indicates the percentage of a company's assets that are provided via debt. It is the ratio of total debt (the sum of current liabilities and long-term liabilities) and total assets (the sum of current assets, fixed assets, and other assets such as 'goodwill'). 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 45.8% 45.2% Shangri-la 19.7% 20.6% From this table, it shows that Shangri-La debt ratio of 20.6% in year 2011. In the next year 2012, it reveals that the debt ratio is 45.8% (SHANG, 2012). This indicates that the hotel perform better since the lower the ratio the lower the bankruptcy risk. In contrast, Dusit debt ratio increases from 45.2% to 45.8% (DTC, 2012), this indicates that the higher the debt ratio the higher the bankruptcy risk and it also means Dusit have more financial obligations. However, the debt ratio of Shangri-La is better than Dusit debt ratio it indicates that more risk Dusit is considered to have taken. 2. Debt/Equity A measure of a company's financial leverage calculated by dividing its total liabilities by shareholders' equity. It indicates what proportion of equity and debt the company is using to finance its assets 2012 2011 Dusit Thani 84.5% 82.4% Shangri-la 24.5% 25.9% From the table, it shows that Shangri-La debt/ equity ratio of 25.9% in year 2011. In the next year 2012, it reveals that the debt/equity ratio is 24.5% (SHANG, 2012).The lower the ratio indicates that the hotel is less dependent on its leverage. In contrast, Dusitdebt/equity has increased from 82.4% in 2011 to 84.5%in 2012 (DTC, 2012). It means that the hotel is being financed by creditors rather than from its own financial sources which may be a dangerous trend. The hotel with high debt-to-equity ratio may not be able to attract additional lending capital. Therefore, the higher the ratio, the more risk that Dusit is considered to have taken on. Profitability Ratio 1. Profit Margin We cannot deny that a company's profit margin, the so-called bottom line is the most often mentioned when discussing a company's profitability. While undeniably an important number, investors can easily see from a complete profit margin analysis that there are several income and expense operating elements in an income statement that determine a net profit margin. Moreover, it is a factor that investors will take a comprehensive look at a company's profit margins on a systematic basis. A ratio of profitability calculated as net income divided by revenues, or net profits divided by sales. It measures how much out of every dollar of sales a company actually keeps in earnings. 2012 2011 2010 Dusit Thani 3.5% 0.79% 3.00% Shangri-la 4.71% -13.67% -11.21% From the given calculation, it reveals that after both Dusit and Shangri-La profit margin had dropped down in 2011, profit margin of Dusit Thani has increased from 0.79% in 2011 to 3.5% in 2012 (DTC, 2012). While Shangri-La’s profit margin has increased a lot from -13.67% in 2011 to 4.71% in 2012 (SHANG, 2012). Even though Shangri-La made loss in 2011 but they has higher profit margin than Dusit in the following year. This may due to too much expense Dusit had incurred or its sales price was too low. 2. Return on Assets An indicator of how profitable a company is relative to its total assets. ROA gives an idea as to how efficient management is at using its assets to generate earnings. The higher the return, the more efficient management is in utilizing its asset base. The ROA ratio is calculated by comparing net income to average total assets, and is expressed as a percentage. 2012 2011 2010 Dusit Thani 1.78% 0.89% 4.35% Shangri-la 2.20% -2.68% -2.99% From the ratio, it indicates that Dusit’s ROA has slightly increased from 0.89% in 2011 to 1.78% in 2012. (DTC, 2012). This means that Dusit has managed its use of assets both current assets and non-current assets more efficiently than last year, but still not as efficient as in 2010. However, comparing to Shangri-La in 2012 ROA of Shangri-La is at 2.20% (SHANG, 2012), meaning Shangri-La has better ability to manage its total assets to generate profit than Dusit this year. Shangri-La seems to have better performance in managing it total assets over 3 years, after they had made loss in 2010 and 2011.Since the ratio can also display the ability of management team whether they make efficient use of all resources they have or not. Therefore, Dusit should always improve its management on how can the hotels utilize more of its total assets to gain higher percentages of ROA. 3. Return on Equity This ratio indicates how profitable a company is by comparing its net income to its average shareholders' equity. The amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholders equity. Return on equity measures a corporation's profitability by revealing how much profit a company generates with the money shareholders have invested. The higher the ratio percentage, the more efficient management is in utilizing its equity base and the better return is to investors. 2012 2011 2010 Dusit Thani 3.81% 0.79% 2.78% Shangri-la 2.09% -4.49% -2.75% From the table, it shows that ROE of Dusit has increased from 0.79% in 2011 to 3.8% in 2012 (DTC, 2012).Meaning, in 2012 the shareholders got higher profit from the money they invested than last year. Although, Shangri-La has increased its ROE to 2.09% in 2012 after they made loss in 2011 and 2010 but comparing to Dusit, Shangri-La’s shareholder still got fewer dividends than Dusit (SHANG, 2012). As a result, it is more likely that investors may interest to invest in Dusit more than Shangri-La. After the comparison of the financial ratio of Dusit Thani and Shangri-La hotel we can conclude that in 2012 in terms of liquidity both Dusit and Shangri-La have both current ratio and quick ratio less than 1 which means that both hotels have total current assets less than total current liabilities. Therefore, both companies still has problem in paying short-term debt. While the calculation in terms of asset management shows that the lower inventory turnover rate of Dusit indicates that Dusit’s inventory management is not as efficient as Shangri-La’s. While both Dusit and Shangri-La seem to take same number of days to collect cash from debtors after sale has been made which is 34 days in average. Moreover Dusit Thani tends to have more potential in utilizing both fixed assets and total assets to generate sales than Shangri-La. And in terms of debt management Dusit seems to have more financial obligation and therefore more financial risk to be taken as seen by the high percentage of debt ratio and debt/equity ratio. Lastly, in terms of profitability ratio Shangri-La seems to have better performance in terms of profit margin and return on asset but in terms of return on equity Dusit shareholder seems to satisfy more with its result. 2. Customer Customers are the most important people for any organization because without the customer most businesses would not exist. They are the resource upon which the success of the business depends. For the hospitality industry, there are dependent upon their customers. If they do not develop customer loyalty and satisfaction, they could lose their customers. In addition, potential customers often have many choices for places and services on which to spend their hard-earned money, and they will reward a good experience by both returning as well as, hopefully, telling their friends and associates about it, thus bringing the business more customers. The purpose of the organization is to fulfill the needs of the customers because it is the customers that will it make it possible to achieve business aims. Moreover, customer service is a mind-set where the hotel guest’s needs and wants come first. Customer service is series of activities which are designed to increase the level of satisfaction for the customers and that a product or service has to meet up with the customer’s expectation. It is also a provision of service to customers which are done before, during and after sale. Therefore, most of the five star hotel customer service is a business skill where hotel employees, management and hotel owners constantly provide service to their guests in a professional and pleasant manner. In addition, the importance of customer service may vary by product or service, customer and industry. The perception of success depends on the employees who can adjust themselves to the personality of the guest. Also, it plays an important role in the company’s ability to generate income and revenue (Titus, 2013). A customer service experience can change the entire perception a customer has of the organization. Most of the five star hotels challenge in working with customer service is to ensure that they have focused fully on their attention on the right key areas, which are measured by the right Key Performance Indicator (Reh, 2013). Key Performance Indicators which is also known as KPI, help an organization define and measure progress toward organizational goals. Once an organization has analyzed its mission, identified all its stakeholders, and defined its goals, it needs a way to measure progress toward those goals. Key Performance Indicators are those measurements. To illustrate, Dusit Thani Hotel know that in order to survive they need to attract and retain guests. Therefore, key operational and performance indicators are needed to improve satisfaction and presents evidence that satisfying hotel guests yields a measurable financial return on investment. Based on the Dusit Thani hotel survey, it determined that customer satisfaction directly bears on repeat purchases and on the likelihood of making recommendations. However, there are four key performance indicators particularly affected Dusit’s guest’s evaluation: reservation was accurate, check-in was completed within five minutes, no problems were experienced during their stay, and no billing errors occurred. Guests who experienced all four of these performance indicators were most likely to grant the hotel a top satisfaction rating. Also, Dusit Thani employees have built a strong relationship with their customers who are crucial for return business and positive hotel reviews. Hotel customer service begins with a positive relationship between the guest and the hotel employee. Therefore, for the employee to build a relationship with the guest is by using listening skills and paying attention to what the guest says. Customer service is not only about listening to the customers but it also about body language. Good hotel customer service body language consists of eye contact, which let the guest know that they are being listened to. For example, Dusit Thani employees greet a guest with a warm smile which help the guest feel more comfortable and the hotel employee are more approachable towards customers. Also, speaking clearly and confidently with the guests demonstrates professionalism. Furthermore, it is the service quality that is basically meeting or exceeding customer satisfaction. To meet or exceed customer satisfaction and expectation, Dusit Thani must fully understand all service attributes that contribute to customer vale and can lead to customer satisfaction and building customer loyalty. The success of any hotel industry is all about providing high quality services that meet up to customer satisfaction and reach up to their expectation and eventually this can create customer loyalty. Therefore, every hotel main goal is to build a customer loyalty because customer loyalty is the only proven way to compete with rivals without having to forfeit revenue. For example, the percentage of repeat business for Dusit Thani Hotel is 30 percent. Also, gathering constant customer feedback to make sure the needs of the customers are being met will ensure loyalty remains strong. In addition, in the area of hospitality, Total Quality Management (TQM) is a participatory process that empowers all levels of work in groups in order to establish guest service expectations and determine the best way to meet or exceed these expectations. Moreover, the concept of service quality is widely discussed in the hospitality management. Quality in the hospitality industry is defined as “the consistent delivery of products and guest services according to expected standards”. As a result guests are willing to pay more when they visit hospitality properties offering them with services that meets or exceeds their expectations (Kapiki, 2012). Furthermore, SERVQUAL is the most often used approach for measuring service quality in order to improve the quality of service as experienced by means of comparison between expected and perceived quality after the customer has received the service The SERVQUAL has been efficient method used to measure consumers’ perceptions of service quality. It is a technique that attempts to measure the five main characteristics of tangibility, reliability, responsiveness, assurance and empathy. First is the tangibility are modern equipment, visually appealing facilities and materials associated with the service, and employees who have a neat, professional appearance. Second is the reliability is performing services right the first time, providing services at the promised time and keeping customers informed about when services will be performed. Third is responsiveness is providing prompt service to customers and readiness to respond to customers’ requests. Fourth is assurance is making customers feel safe in their transactions, employees who are consistently courteous and employees who have the knowledge to answer customer questions. Fifth is empathy which means giving customers individual attention, employees who deal with customers in a caring fashion, employees who understand the needs of their customers and having the customers’ best interest at heart (Kumar, n.d.). Analysis Dusit Thani use Market Matrix which is a customer satisfaction online survey that helps company to measure the level of customer satisfaction. In this report, we will look at the customer’s attitudes towards Quality Service.This part presents the 300 respondents’ attitude toward each aspect of qualityservice of Dusit Thani Hotel. This Attitude Profile toward the QualityService of Dusit Thani covers both of the services of Front operation andaccommodation provided by the Hotel. Service Quality which includes Reliability, Responsiveness, Friendship and Assurance. Respondents were asked torate the following statement about their attitude toward quality service of Dusit Thani Hotel. The meanings of the scores are “1” equal to strongly disagree and “5”equal to strongly agree. Therefore the statement which had the means score to “5”will be favorably preferred. The findings of the Quality Service of each attributes were as follows: Customers’ attitude toward the reliability in hotel accommodation Average means score for Reliability in Hotel Accommodation = 3.1473 Analysis: The customers expressed their agreement that guestrooms weremaintained with high cleanliness with the highest means scores of 3.28 comparingamong other questions within the same construct. The second attribute in qualityservice in term of accommodation was the customers’ attitude toward the fullfacilities provided in guestroom with high standard perceptions with means score of3.25. The third highest means was 3.21 concerned the billing process of all outletswhich were very accurate, timely and understandable. However, the least mean rating was attribute for quality service in the Accommodation Service was thecheck-in process with a low means score of 2.92 means score, which was below theneutral point. This rating could be the factor that pulled the means scores for thereliability in hotel accommodation down to 3.1473, which was just above the neutralpoint. This means their impression on the hotel accommodation is mainly acceptable. Customers’ attitude toward the responsiveness in hotel accommodation Analysis: There were two attributes which got the highest means scores of 3.17concerned the quality service in term of responsiveness in Accommodation with thestaff manners was very welcome and readiness of the service provided as well as the24 hours room service which was provided with good quality. The others twoattributes also got the same means scores of 3.15 concerned the staff’s prompt servicewhenever there was a problem with the accommodation and the consistentlycourteous of the staffs. Therefore, the means score for the responsiveness inhotel accommodation were 3.1592 which was little above the neutral point. Thismeans that the customers were not so impressed with the quality service in term of theresponsiveness in hotel accommodation. Customers’ attitude toward the friendship in hotel accommodation Analysis The first attribute received 3.13 means scores concerning the hotel providedthe above average level in decoration and experience, which made the customers feltlike they were in Exclusive 6 star hotel. For the second attribute, which was asked aboutthe experience whether they felt warm and felt like they were in luxury hotel or not,the mean of this statement was equal to 3.15. This means that the customers were notfully impressed with the warmth and luxurious of the hotel rather than the feeling ofbeing in Exclusive 6 star hotel. The means score for the friendship inhotel accommodation was only 3.1367 which was above the neutral point. It is likelythat these customers have been to many luxurious hotels in other business trips but what Dusit Thani Hotel provided was just average or not extraordinary orimpressive. Customers’ attitude toward the assurance in hotel accommodation Analysis The assurance factor consisted of two attributes. The first attribute receivedthe means score of 3.32, Dusit Thani Hotel was able to provide highprivilege in the guestroom to all 300 customers. The second statement also receivedthe good feedback, which had the means scores of 3.29. The average means scoresfor the quality service in term of assurance in accommodations were 3.3067. Thismeant that customers felt that they were in privilege rather than in satisfaction whilethey were in the guestroom. Therefore, the means score for the assurance in hotelaccommodation were 3.3067. It was above the neutral point, which could meanacceptable at the minimum level. Customers’ reference in hotel to others 1) Dusit Thani Hotel is one of the hotels 300 that I will recommend my friends and family to stay Valid N (listwise) 300 5 3.24 Analysis From this statement, it means that the customers would likely recommendtheir friends and family to stay in Dusit Thani Hotel. The meansscore for the reference in hotel were 3.24. It was above the neutral point. Customers’ attitude toward the responsiveness in the hotel Front operation Analysis 300 customers rated their attitude toward the quality service in terms of responsiveness in the Front operation. The highest score was focus to thecustomers thought that Pre-arrival and Arrival segment insisted on error free recordsas the means scores equal to 3.21. The second attribute got means score of 3.18concerned the fast responses to hotel staff problem. The last attribute was askedabout the staffs’ providing of good quality of service with consistently courteous, themeans score for this factor was 3.17. The average means score for the quality servicein term of responsiveness at the Front operation equal to 3.1833, it’s above the neutralpoint. Customers’ attitude toward the assurance in hotel Front operation Analysis The second attribute which was the customers’ feeling of confident in thequality of service and support at the Front operation provided with means score of 3.27. While the least agreed attribute rated by the customers were the feeling of high privilege while they were at the Front operation with the means score of 3.20. So for this quality service in term of assurance at Front operation, they average means score was 3.2544, which are above the neutral point. Customers’ attitude toward the friendship at the hotel Front operation This meant that the customers were impressed with the experience at the Frontoperation rather than the decoration of the Front operation. Therefore, the meansscore for the friendship at Front operation were above the neutral point, which havegot the mean score of 3.1533. Customer Satisfaction toward Hotel both at Front operation and accommodation The means score for the overall customer satisfaction toward DusitThani both at the Front operations and accommodations were 3.20 whichwas above the neutral point. For the market segmentation, Dusit Thani has divided their target market into many groups as they are various groups of customers that the company wants to focus. But in this report we will only be analyzing on the demographic factors of the 300 respondents. Finally according to the research respondents’ profile, there are 2 groups ofrespondents which are male and female, and I found that the male customers aremore than female customers but female shows more level of customer satisfactionthan male if hotel provides good quality service in term of responsiveness, assurance,reliability and friendship for both at the Front operation and accommodation. Mostly the age of male and female customers are 31-40 years old and for thosewho age between 20-40 years old exhibits more level of customer satisfaction thanany other level while those who aged above 50 or as they are older they will not be satisfy much though hotel provides them with the good experience Front operationservice and accommodation. Single, married, and divorced respondentsused Dusit Thani hotel for their leisure trip. Customers who are married are morelikely satisfied if the hotel provides them the good experience at the Front operationand accommodation in every term of quality service than any other type of customers.Dusit Thani Hotel seemed to be popular to those who are Japanese,American, and Europe, respectively, and also, it’s very popular to high-income peoplewho earn more than 100,000 Baht per month. For those who have monthly income higher than 80,000 Baht are more likely to satisfy with the hotel Front operation andaccommodation than any others. Most customers who are using service at DusitThani Hotel are educated, receiving Bachelor Degree certified but those who will be satisfy with hotel quality service are those who have higher than bachelor degree. In addition, one important factor that has relationship between quality serviceand customer’s satisfaction is reliability in hotel staff. Customer satisfied that theguestroom was maintained with high cleanliness, also there was full facilitiesprovided in the guestroom with high standard perceptions, and the billing process ofall outlets is very accurate, timely and understandable. Additionally, customers aresatisfied with the various services which hotel Front desk offered with very goodquality and good perception. This point impressed customers to feel like they are inan Exclusive 6 star hotels. However, the pre check-in process does not run smoothlythat reduce the level of customer satisfaction. Responsiveness in hotel staff is the third factor, which has some relationshipbetween quality service and customers’ satisfaction towards Dusit Thani hotel. The staff’s manners are of very welcome and always ready to service are thereason why customers are satisfied. Customers are satisfied with the promptly serviceof staff and consistently courteous of the staff. Moreover, the responsiveness of the front operations service are also important, for example pre-arrival and arrivalsegment insists on error free records making customers satisfied to the quality service, and if the customers have problems in Front desk, hotel staffs can solve the problemwith high speed. Furthermore, the last finding is the relationship between quality service interms of assurance in hotel staff and customer satisfaction towards Dusit Thani Hotel. Customers preferred Dusit Thani Hotel because of having highprivilege in the guestroom, and also feel very satisfied when they stay inguestroom at the hotel. Additionally, customers satisfied with the satisfaction of theFront operation and feel confident with quality of service and support, including highprivilege. Customers express some attitudes that Dusit Thani Hotel is one of thehotels that they will recommend friends or family to stay since its received ratingabove the mean score. The worth factors, which have relationship between qualityservice and reference towards Dusit Thani Hotels, are in terms of friendshipin hotel staff, then reliability in hotel staff, responsiveness in hotel staff, and assurancein hotel staff, respectively. This can imply that customers will refer Dusit Thani Hotel to their friends or family, if customers feel that they are satisfied to the hotelbecause of the experience and decoration of the hotel make them feel warm and feellike they are in luxury hotel. In combination with the Front operation’s experienceand decoration, it makes customers feel like they are at the Front operation receptionof Exclusive 6 star hotels. To conclude, the level of quality service of Dusit Thani Hotel is slightly above theaverage mean to good score. The factors in both accommodation and Front operationswhich were rated as the highest means score is assurance, while the lowest meansscore but still above the average mean is friendship. Although the friendship receivedthe lowest means score, there were connected or have some relationship betweenquality service in terms of friendship in both accommodation / the Front operationsand customer satisfaction towards Dusit Thani Hotel. I have conducted an interview with the front office manager, Khun Wanchai Paksee about the quality of communications with customers. Khun Wanchai said that the most effective way to communicate with their customers of Dusit Thani Hotel is via email. He said that emails has been a very essential communication tool in this age of technology, and with the growing number of businesses doing transactions online, the email is indeed a great tool in managing the business. To illustrate, Dusit Thani use email to communicate with their employees, clients as well as their potential customers. He said that it has become very convenient for them as they could send the same information via email to large number of customer situated in different locations as email have a wide reach. Aside from its convenience in sending information, they are able to keep a record of the transactions of their hotel business. Keeping an archive of the mails was useful in terms of rechecking past information and transactions of Dusit Thani. In addition, for Dusit Thani Hotel the one useful way of getting potential customers is by email and they are able to introduce their new product online. Dusit Thani website has got contact information like email to build credibility and trust for their clients and customers. Also, it is a good tool to deal with customer queries and feedback. Moreover, emails are also a great storage of Dusit’s client’s addresses, potential customers, friends, employees and people that work together. The database of contact information can also be conveniently retrieved anytime in the address book. 3. Internal Business Process Internal Business Process Strong CSR - Earthcheck - DSD Internship Internal control system - Customers give good response - Staff give good response Shares from 0.5-1 baht Lack revenue management skills Profitability unstable at the moment. Internal Business process perspective The internal business process perspective is one of the most comfortable areas for the operational managers to work with because it is where they are most compatible. Measurement in such area takes place on processes done by them on a daily basis. The main aspect to this measurement is that it is where foundations are formed to drive the Business forward to the satisfaction of customers. There are certain aspects that cover the Internal Business process measurement. To complete the balance scorecard for Dusit Thani their internal process must be evaluated. And to evaluate their internal business process in respect to balance scorecard we need to look at Dusit Thani’s Corporate Social Responsibilities, Direct business process and indirect support business process. Corporate Social Responsibilities Corporate social responsibilities for Hotel companies like Dusit International is not just about the compliance or requirements to be supplier but it is a positive message showing their performance in playing their part to preserve this world which intern is a common trend today. This might also lead to increase in appreciation by customers. CSR main measurements include Health, Safety & Wellbeing, Environmental impact and Ethics. All of this area covers Safety and security of employees, contractors, visitors, customers and the planet. The board of director said in the annual report that they take their CSR process very seriously as one of its internal process management and it is measured for its efficiency every year in the annual report. Dusit Thani also encourages their business partners, suppliers and customers to follow the same value by implementing new CSR activities with analysis for its effectiveness. Those campaigns include: EarthCheck Programme Dusit International knows that contribution to the well-being of the communities in which it operates would be one of their primary priorities. Since hotel industry is one to be very vulnerable to such judgement towards their care for environment by customers the more Dusit Thani does for the environment the better. To advance their commitment to the protection of the environment they have decided to undergo benchmarking by EarthCheck programme in 2009 in order to receive independent and comprehensive proof of such actions. Dusit Thani operates under the checklist of EarthCheck environmental actions if it is satisfactory they will become one of the members of EarthCheck. However, if they can provide good pollution control and power management they will be awarded Bronze, silver or gold level certificate, which is certified by EarthCheck. So far Dusit Thani Dubai has reached bronze level of EarthCheck’s certificate in 2009. - Dusit and DSD (Department of Skill Development) internship in hospitality studies. Tourism and hospitality industry has been a pillar for source of income in Thailand. However, there seems to be slack in the adequacy of supply of such skilled workers. Dusit International is well aware of this and its role and responsibility to come to an aid to this aspect. Thus, Dusit International and Department of Skill Development or DSD under Thai ministry of labor have found a common ground and start to implement this with the objective of offering High school or diploma graduates who lack opportunities in self-development as well as aid their country in strengthening the tourism and hospitality industry in Thailand. The program is set to have durationof 12 months, which will provide knowledge in F&B management, Kitchen management and housekeeping operations. In measurement of success this program has produced 88 graduates all together from 2007-2010 and 70 more students till 2012. - Internal Control systems and internal audit To assess the internal process for the balance scorecard and determine its performance some kind of evaluation of the staff performance is required to do so. This is to measure the satisfaction of the staffs at work as well as the productivity they can achieve. Even though Dusit International has disclosed no real information, there is evidence of measurements with in the company to assess such attributes of the organization. Dusit International focuses its utmost attention on their internal control system to make sure they are operating efficiently. Within these duties, responsibilities and authorities of management will be well defined there are also implementations of the use of the companies’ assets in the most efficient way possible. This assessment will clearly separate staffs in their operation, supervision and performance and will be evaluated individually to crosscheck with each other and therefore balance the process of staff. This obligation is delegated to the Internal Audit Department to examine their operations to ensure that their core operations and significant financial activities of the companies by the employees are in line with the directions of the management. After this assessment they are required to send this directly to the Audit Committee and then to the Board of Directors. In addition the internal audit head will be assessed directly by the Audit Committee. According to the board of directors Dusit Thani excels in being a service provider. They are believed to have quality staffs and services, which is one of the pioneers of Thai Hospitality, which is in trend today. There have been good reviews from the customers on Dusit Thani’s services and the comfort of their stay. With 60 years of experience in hospitality they can provide a well standardized experience that can be trusted. We can also see that because of such experience an educational institute has been forged to create new Dusit Thani standard employees from scratch, imprinting in their blood the art of service in Thai heritage style. However as of today Dusit Thani lacks in their revenue management. This can be seen in the high fluctuation of revenue and costs that are drastically different almost every year with no definite high and low. This is shown in their financial statement, as this is also a cause to which the shareholders do not receive sometimes dividends. Is said earlier there hasn’t been disclosed information about Dusit International’s staff performance and efficiency other than the ROA calculated in the financial perspective. However, the Board of Directors will assess this assessment. They said in their Annual report of 2011 that. “The board of directors has performed self-assessments checklist to evaluate the internal performance. The assessment results were satisfactory. The Audit Committee has also performed self-assessment checklist which was also satisfactory to the chairman.” - Shareholders Dusit Thani’s Dividend policy is to pay dividends amounting up to 50% of their consolidated net income by considering the result of operation according to their consolidated financial statements including the result of their statement of retained earnings presented in the company’s financial statement is to ensure that the shareholders receive the promised dividend amount and their actual ability to pay such dividend and not oppose to the Public Limited Company act of law. In 2009 the company has paid their annual dividend operating at 0.50 Baht per share. They paid in total 42.50 million Baht. This makes it difficult to calculate the rate of dividend comparing to their net profit. However the company dissatisfied their shareholders in 2010 due to the flood situation in Thailand Dusit Thani ran into a loss. However now according to their financial statement of 2012 their paid up share capital is 850 million Baht which is a tremendous increase however the par value as of then was 1 Baht per share which also showed promise. Their net profit margin has also increased from -3.54 to 3.15% today, which is almost double. (Dusit International annual report, 2011). However the company’s net profit has dropped from 18104 million in 2012 to 31042 million in 2011. According to the chairman this was because of the expenses that went into the developmental activities and promotions of Dusit Thani’s expansion. - Internal Development Dusit International has relocated their General Managers as a part of their company’s longterm strategy to develop key talents and executives. Dusit Thani Dubai GM James Wilson has replaced general manager of the Dusit Thani Bangkok Alex Willat. Willet also replaced Dusit Thani Manila GM Prateek Kumar mean while Kumar takes over for Wilson in Dusit Thani Dubai. “It is essential that we have a ready pool of Dusit International general managers ready to take on assignments at any of our properties globally. This move is part of our overall succession planning and an essential process in building internal excellence. I congratulate all the concerned executives and look forward to working with them in their new roles,” said Dusit International managing director and CEO Chanin Donavanik. This is believed to enhance managerial experience between Dusit Thani’s general managers. This change also showed high satisfaction and corporation from the General Managers as well as add to employee’s belief that their currier path will be the same. (Edgumber, 2012) - Awards One of the main performance indicators is an award. Dusit Thani Bangkok has won first prize in the category of Asia’s Leading City Hotel’s in the World Travel Awards of 2012, at an award ceremony held in Singapore on the 18th of October 2012. General Manager Alex Willats said, "We're delighted to have won this award for the second year in succession. We've been a leading hotel in Asia for many years and to receive the award is testament to all the hard work and service that staff has put in and is good recognition of what the hotel and company have achieved over the past 60 years since they’ve been in existence." (Dusit Thani Bangkok, 2012) DusitD2 and Royal Princess in Chiang Mai recognized by EarthCheck DusitD2 Chiang Mai and Royal Princess Chiang Mai hotels have received Silver star benchmark status from the world’s leading sustainable travel and tourism certification organization for their strong for their persistent commitment in implementing environmental conservation practices. Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket received “The Smoke-Free and Health Promotions Hotel Golden Star Award 2011-2013” Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket received the Smoke-Free and Health Promotions Hotel Golden Star Award of 2011-2013, from Green Leaf Foundation in cooperation with the Thai Health Promotion Foundation for a strong dedication towards environmental preservation and health promotion. 4. Learning and Growth Since tourism is one of the vital parts of the Thai economy, and the future of tourism depends greatly on hospitality education in order to meet the growing demands of tourists and the tourism industry. Thailand represents the warmth and charm of hospitality. The Dusit International operates the Dusit Thani College which is the premier institution that brings these concepts through superior service and excellence in South East Asia. As part of Thailand’s leading five-star hospitality group for over 40 years, the programs offered at Dusit Thani College enable students to enter employment with the potential of making an immediate positive contribution. Dusit Thani College has developed strong relationships with international institutions. The institutions that are collaborating partners with Dusit Thani College are ASO College Group, Japan, Ecole Hôtelière de Lausanne, Switzerland, Le Cordon Bleu, France, Lyceum of the Philippines University (Manila, Cavite, Batangas and Laguna), The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, Tsuji Culinary Institute, Japan, University College Birmingham, England, William Angliss Institute, Melbourne, Australia. Partnering with these institutions gives Dusit Thani a chance to recruit international as well as local employees that have been professionally trained. It also gives them a chance for cultural exchange between potential consumer markets. Dusit International treat their people as their most valuable asset, so they will be offered the Compensation and Benefit Plan including : competitive pay and benefits, well-tailored uniforms, career development programmes, career advancement job training, job rotation, complimentary meals and more. They offer a management trainee program for high-achieving graduates. The program takes an ambitious graduate to a management role through intensive on-the-job training, field practices, and industrial placement within Dusit International’s hotels across the region. Through a strict process, they have to attend a year long program, comprising 17 intensive training units such as Sales & Marketing, Public Relations, Food & Beverage, Reservations, Human Resources, Finance, Front Office, Operations and others. The trainees will be inducted to the company’s business, strategy, and learn about the finer points of Thai hospitality and service as epitomized in our Dusit Brand Promise. After finishing the program, the trainees will have the opportunity for placements in a position that best suits their interests and competencies at their designated hotels. Dusit International plans to expand its wings in the Middle East to operate 15 properties by 2015. Although the brand currently operates five properties in the region, including Dusit Thani Dubai, Dusit Princess City Centre Dubai, Dusit Residence Dubai Marina, Pearl Coast Premier Hotel Apartments, as well as the Dusit Thani Lake View Cairo in Egypt, but they also have future plans to open hotels and resorts in Abu Dhabi, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Oman, and Qatar within the next three years. The success of their expansion into the Middle East will help pave the way for Dusit’s future expansion in the rest of the world and provide the drive to pursue new growth opportunities in other markets. Dusit Thani Manila launched the state-of-the-art monochromatic beige-colored repainting of Dusit Thani Manila’s façade to complete its extensive US$20 million renovation; they continue to endeavor in creating new reinventions for its guests. This time, with a Patrick Blanc-inspired vertical garden that does not only bring an artistic beauty to the surroundings of the hotel but most importantly, has a significant impact on environment and atmosphere. This Vertical Garden design specifically lowers the temperature at the driveway of Dusit Thani Manila especially when the afternoon sun rays hit the entrance. At the same time, the water feature helps cool the air that passes through the open spaces between walls. They also took into consideration the healing capabilities of plants, the ones that emit more oxygen, take away pollution and reduce carbon monoxide in the air. Having recently received a Silver certification for 2012 by EarthCheck, a globally renowned organization that grades environmental standards, Dusit Thani Manila continuously thrives to save Mother Earth through its green initiatives. This shows that they are taking initiative to be innovative for the target market. FINANCIAL RETURN ON ASSETS (ROA) Dusit’s ROA has slightly increased from 0.89% in 2011 to 1.78% in 2012. Shangri-La’s ROA in 2012 is at 2.20% RETURN ON EQUITY (ROE) ROE of Dusit has increased from 0.79% in 2011 to 3.8% in 2012 Shangri-La has increased its ROE To 2.09% in 2012 after they INTERNAL BUSINESS PROCESS made a loss in 2010 and 2011. CUSTOMER Dusit Thani use Market Matrix which is a customer satisfaction online survey that helps company to measure the level of customer satisfaction Average mean score for TRANSLATING VISSION AND STRATEGY: FOUR PERSPECTIVES Reliability in Hotel Accomodation = 3.1473 Average mean score for Responsiveness in Accomodation = 3.1592 Average mean score for Friendship in Accommodation = 3.1367 Average mean score for Assurance in Accomodation = 3.3067 Customers reference in hotel to others = 3.24 To evaluate their Internal business process in respect to balance scorecard we need to look at Dusit Thani’s Corporate Social Responsibilities, Direct business process and indirect support business process LEARNING & GROWTH • The operation of the Dusit Thani College • Strong relationships with international institutions in Japan, Switzerland, France, Philippines, Hong Kong, England and Australia. • Compensation and benefit plan for employees • Management trainee program- a year long in 17 training units Strong CSR - Earthcheck - DSD Internship Internal control system - Customers give good response - Staff give good response Shares from 0.5-1 baht Lack revenue management skills Profitability unstable at the moment. References About.americanexpress.com (2013).Our Company. Retrieved on 5th, March, 2013, from http://about.americanexpress.com/ An international marketing strategy analysis.(n.d.) Retrieved on 5th, March, 2013, from http://www.davideberle.com/files/university/MarketingStrategyPolicy%20Dusit%20P aper.pdf AsiaTravelTips.com (2013). Dusit and Le Cordon Bleu in joint venture to establish culinary arts education in Bangkok. Retrieved on 5th, March, 2013, from http://www.asiatravelt ips.com/news05/239-CordonBleu.shtml Balanced Scorecard(2013). What is a Balanced Scorecard? Retrieved on 5th, March, 2013, from http://www.balancedscorecard.org/bscresources/aboutthebalancedscorecard/tabi d/55/default.asp Bangkok Post (2013).DTC to launch “AUTHENTIC JAPANESE CUISINE COURSES”. Retrieved on 5th, March, 2013, from http://www.bangkokpost.com/forum/viewtopic. Php?f=69&t=8001 Bird.in (n.d.) About us. Retrieved on 5th, March, 2013, from http://www.bird.in/aboutus.asp Caswell, M. (2009). Focus: Global Hotel Alliance. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.businesstraveller.com/news/focus-global-hotel-alliance Citrinot, L. (2012). Dusit Thani goes Japanese with Tsuji Culinary Institute of Osaka. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.traveldailynews.asia/news/article/501 64/dusit-thani-goes-japanese-withDusit%20Paper.pdf Clark, W. (2013). What is Multidomestic Strategy? Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-a-multidomestic-strategy.htm Day, M. (2005). Why is Market Research Important? Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.webpronews.com/why-is-market-research-important-2005-08 Deimei, R. (2007). The Bird Group launches joint venture with Dusit Hotels and Resorts. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.traveldailynews.asia/ news/article/ 17508/the-bird-group-launches-joint Director of Sales & Marketing (2012) New Director of Sales & Marketing for Dusit Devarana New Delhi. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.breakingtravel news.com/news/article/new-director-of-sales-marketing-for-dusit-devarana-newdelhi/ DTC: Dusit Thani Public Company Limited. (n.d.).Stock Exchange of Thailand. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.set.or.th/set/companyhighlight. do?symbol=DT C&language=en&country=US DTC. (2012) Latest financial statement. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.set.or.th/set/companyfinance.do?type=balance&symbol=DTC&language= en&country=US Dusit CEO reaffirms confidence in Thailand’s hospitality industry. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.travelweeklyweb.com/dusit-ceo-reaffirms-confidence-inthailands-hospitality-industry/35542 Dusit.com (2013) Dusit Thani College. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/en/dusit-thani-college.html Dusit International (2013).Dusit Thani College. Retrieved on 6th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/dusit-thani-college.html Dusit International (2013). Dusit International launches an Appreciation Gift Voucher to Mobilize Loyal Diners to Holiday in Thailand. Retrieved on 7th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/en/press-centre/press2/68-dusit-international-launches-anappreciation-gift-voucher-to-mobilise-loyal-diners-to-holiday-inthailand.html?catid=21%3Apress-centre-2010 Dusit International (n.d). Dusit International Celebrates Summer with Dusit Take 2. Retrieved on 7th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/ar/press-centre/69-dusitinternational-celebrates-summer-with-dusit-take-2.html Dusit International (2013). Dusit International announces successful Acquisition of Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket. Retrieved on 7th, March, 2013, from https://www.dusit.com/ar/ press-centre/66-dusit-international-announces-successful-acquisition-of-dusit-thanilaguna-phuket.html Dusit International goes from strength to strength in sales distribution. (2010). Retrieved on 8th, March, 2013, from http://archive.malaya.com.ph/2010/ March/03172010/trav3.ht ml Dusit International announces successful Acquisition of Dusit Thani Laguna Phuket (n.d.). Retrieved on 8th, March, 2013, from https://www.dusit.com/en/press-centre/press2/66dusit-international-announces-successful-acquisition-of-dusit-thani-lagunaphuket.html?catid=21%3Apress-centre-2010 Dusit International (n.d). Loyalty Programs. Retrieved on 8th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/en/loyalty.html Dusit International, (n.d.). Retrieved on 8th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/dusit-international.html Dusit International (2012).Dusit International Showcases Thai Hotels and Resorts in India. Retrieved on 9th, March, 2013, from http://www.odysseymediagroup com/apn/Editorial -. Hotels-And-Resorts.asp?ReportID=545156 Dusit International Annual Report. (2011). Annual Report Dusit Thani Public company limited. Pages 24-107. Dusit Loyalty Program. (2008). Retrieved on 9th, March, 2013, from http://coolcinderella.blo gspot.com/2008/03/dusit-loyalty-programs.html Dusit Thani (2010). Devarana Spa. Retrieved on 9th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.co m/dusit-thani/en/dusit-thani-pattaya-hotel-facilities-a-services/devarana-spa.html Dusit Thani Maldives (2010). Dusit Thani Maldives: a true gift from the Sea. Retrieved on 9th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/dusit-thani/en/dusit-thani-maldiveslatest-news/1117-dusit-thani-maldives-a-true-gift-from-thesea.html?catid=128%3Alatest-news-2012 Dusit Thani (2012). Dusit’s Dusit Thani College Partners with Ecole Hôtelière de Lausanne. Retrieved on 9th, March, 2013, from http://www.pata.org/news/dusit-s-dusit-thani college-partners-with-ecole-h-teli-re-de-lausanne Dusit Thani Bangkok (2012).Dusit Thani Hotels & resorts. World travel awards 2012. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, fromhttp://www.dusit.com/dusit-thani/th/latestnews/1602-world-travel-awards-2012.html Dynamic Expansion into India, (n.d.). Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/ar/press-centre/87-dusit-internationals-dynamic-expansion-intoindia.html. Edgcumbe, D (2012). Dusit reassigns GMs as part of development scheme. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, fromhttp://www.hoteliermiddleeast.com/15966-dusit-reassignsgms-as-part-of-development-scheme/ Forming Asian Hotels Alliance (AHA). Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://www.hsyndicate.org/news/4008663.html Gha.com (n.d.) About GHA. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://www.gha.com/About-GHA Grunert, J (2013) Global and Domestic Marketing. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://business.lovetoknow.com/wiki/Global_and_Domestic_Marketing Hotel Marketing.com (2009).Hotel loyalty programs: An overview and how they benefit Hotel. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://www.hotelmarketing.com/index.ph p/article/hotel_loyalty_programs_an_overview_and_how_they_benefit_hotels/ Historichotels.org (2013).About Historic Hotels of America.Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013 from http://www.historichotels.org/about-historic-hotels/ Hofstede, G. (2013). The Hofstede Center Thailand. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://geert-hofstede.com/thailand.html Institutional Investor. (1995). The Dusit Thani Public Co. Ltd.: a hotel merger made in Heaven. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://business.highbeam.com/435607/ Article-1G1-17869749/dusit-thani-public-co-ltd-hotel-merger-made-heaven Ira, J. (2010). Why is branding important for a hotel? Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://www.exebit.org/wp/why-is-branding-important-for-a-hotel/ Kapiki, S. (2012). Quality Management in Tourism and Hospitality: an Exploratory Study Among Tourism Stakeholders. Retrieved on 10th, March, 2013, from http://www.academia.edu/1160667/Quality_Management_in_Tourism_and_Hospitalit y_an_Exploratory_Study_among_Tourism_Stakeholders Kasemsuk, C. (n.d.). Dusit International Welcomes a New Strategic Partnership. Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http://www.dusit.com/ar/press-centre/96-dusit-internationalwelcomes-a-new-strategic-partnership.html Koumelis, T. (2012). Dusit International joins forces with Hotel Representation Australia (HRA). Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http://www.traveldailynews.asia/news/article/50204/dusit-international-joins-forceswith Kumar, K. (2007). Dusit Bird Hotels to launch Dusit Devarana, New Delhi by end 2012. Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, fromhttp://www.travelbizmonitor.com/dusit-birdhotels-to-launch-dusit-devarana-new-delhi-by-end-2012-17144 Kumar, M. (n.d.).Managing Service Quality. Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm?articleid=1779125&show=abstract Lynch, R. (2012). What is Global Strategy? Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http://www.global-strategy.net/categories/Whatisglobalstrategy Ollie Quiniquini (2008). Dusit Hotel Nikko to become Dusit Thani Manila. Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http://www.ttgasia.com/article.php?article_id=15264 Preferred Hotel Group (2009).Preferred Hotel Group announces strategic partnership with to Dusit International. Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http:// www.traveldailynew s.com/news/article/29775/preferred-hotel-group-announces-strategic Preferredhotelgroup.com (n.d.) About Preferred Hotel Group. Retrieved on 11th, March, 2013, from http://preferredhotelgroup.com/about Products and Services Supplies. (2011). Retrieved on 12th, March, 2013, from capital.sec.or.th/webapp/.../200110007T06.DOC Reh, J. (2013). How an organization defines and measures progress toward its goals. Retrieved on 12th, March, 2013, from http://management.about.com/cs/generalmana gement/a/keyperfindic.htm RingZero Network (n.d.). Ring Zero Networks (Thailand) Co,, Ltd. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from from http://old.jobbkk.com/eng/job_express/extra_bkk.php?com_id=35 147 Ruyi-company.com ( n.d.) Ruyi Company Limited. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from http://www.ruyi-company.com/ Rznet.com (2011).About Ringzero Networks Thailand. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from http://www.rznet.com/ SHANG. (2012) Latest financial statement. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from http://www.set.or.th/set/companyfinance.do?type=balance&symbol=SHANG&langua ge=en&country=US Shoemaker, D. (2010). The Importance of Branding and Marketing in Hospitality. Retrieved On 13th, March, 2013, from http://ezinearticles.com/?The-Importance-of-Brandingand-Marketing-in-Hospitality&id=4283392 Sixt.com (n.d.) About Sixt rent a car. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from http://www.sixt.com/further-information/about-us/ Strategic alliances (n.d).Strategic alliance and joint ventures. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, fromhttp://www.nzte.govt.nz/develop-knowledge-expertise/export-guide/ways-ofentering-a-new-market/pages/strategic-alliances-and-joint-ventures.aspx The Merger.(2008). Dusit Thani Public Company Limited and its Subsidiaries. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from http://doc.morningstar.com/document/33226d03044b9d7b.m sdoc/?clientid= morningstareurope&key=b05d173f8e969ca1 Titus, M. (2013).Importance of Customer Service in the Hospitality Industry. Retrieved on 13th, March, 2013, from http://www.ehow.com/facts_6727902_importance-customerservice-hospitality-industry.html Travel and Tourism (2012).Travel and Tourism in Thailand. Retrieved on 14th, March, 2013 fromhttp://www.euromonitor.com/travel-and-tourism-in-thailand/report Vickers, R. (2012). Q&A: Dusit International on adapting to different cities. Retrieved on 14th, March, 2013, from http://www.marketingweek.co.uk/trends/qa-dusitinternational-on-adapting-to-different-cities/4004769.article