12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 1 of 16) Course prefix: SBS Course code: 2000 Title: Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences Class hours: 3 Lab hours: n/a Total contact hours: 45 Credits: 3 New York City College of Technology, CUNY CURRICULUM MODIFICATION PROPOSAL FOR NEW COURSE Please refer to the Curriculum Modification Guide before submitting a proposal. (One course per form) Date: December 17, 2012 Social Science Department: Proposers: Marco Castillo – Assistant Prof. of Government; Pa Her – Assistant Prof. of Psychology; Sean MacDonald – Associate Prof. of Economics; Maria Pagano – Associate Professor of Psychology Course Number: Title: SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences Hours: Class Hour, 3 Credits: Credits 3 Prerequisite(s): Corequisite(s): Lab Hours 0 Any Introductory ANTH, ECON, GEOG, GOV, HIS, PSY, SOC, or, any AFR or LTAM 1400 series course, or AFR 1501, 1502, 2402 or 3000, or COMM 2402, or 3401 and MAT 1180 or higher; ADGA students will also need the prerequisite of PSY 3407 Psychology of Perception. None Course Description: An introduction to the research methodologies utilized in the social and behavioral sciences, beginning with the fundamentals of research design, through data collection, analysis, interpretation, and the final reporting of results. Both quantitative and qualitative designs are examined using software to aid in inquiry and analysis. 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 2 of 16) Curriculum Modification Questions Y 1. Has the department approved the modification and recorded the approval in the minutes? Date of Meeting: March 1 2012 X 2. X 3. Has the department consulted with the academic dean? March 1, 2012 Will other departments be affected by this change? N X If so, which ones: Advertising Design and Graphic Arts 4. Does the content of this course overlap with other courses in the College? If so, which ones: 5. X HUS 3610 Research Methods Is this course is a(an): elective within the dept. X other _ required within the dept. free elective Required by ADGA for B.Tech. When approved, this course will also be submitted to the Interdisciplinary Committee for approval as an interdisciplinary course and as a Pathways “Scientific World.” 6. Will you submit this proposal for inclusion in Pathways? X 7. How many faculty members are qualified to teach this course? 14 8. When will this course be offered? X spring 9. 10. summer X fall X day X evening Are there minor changes to your Curriculum that will need to be made as a result of this new course? Has the Advisory Board recommended this change? If so, when? Signatures: ________________________________ ________________________________ Academic Dean Chairperson Please see attached letter of support Date Please see attached email confirming support DD Date Please attach: Course Outline Summary of Student Survey Results (optional): N/A Library Form Consultation with Affected Department(s): See appendix from HS department Letter of Support from ADGA Letter of Support from Liberal Arts and Sciences Dean Botchway Email of Support from Social Science Chair Chancellor’s Report X X 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 3 of 16) Rationale: Students are primarily consumers of research conducted by others. As students, they are typically assigned readings related to course material and asked to comment and/or critically analyze arguments presented in these readings. What is often lacking is an understanding of the research process that underlies the conclusions behind the arguments. The goal of this course is to shed light on the research process in the social and behavioral sciences and to provide students with the necessary foundation to conduct basic research studies. In doing so, they will develop skills in conducting independent research while expanding on their ability to understand and evaluate the findings of others. Because this course will develop students’ critical thinking skills, it has direct application across disciplines and fields of study. This course differs from the Human Services Research Methods (HUS 3610) course in that it will enable other students outside of Human Services to take a research methods course (a copy of the HS Syllabus can be provided upon request). City Tech is the only CUNY college that does not offer such a course and as such, this course was requested by ADGA and will be required in their program. Inclusion in Pathways: If this course is approved, a request will be made to have this course included in pathways under the “Scientific World” category. This course will also be submitted to the interdisciplinary committee if approved. Enrollment Expectation Survey: An enrollment expectation survey was not conducted for this course because: 1. This course fills a void in the current LAA/LAS course offerings. All CUNY 4-year and comprehensive colleges offer a course of this type 2. The creation of this course was requested by Professor MaryAnne Biehl, Chair of the Advertising Design and Graphic Arts Department (see attached for letter of support) 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 4 of 16) Catalogue description: An introduction to the research methodologies utilized in the social and behavioral sciences, beginning with the fundamentals of research design, through data collection, analysis, interpretation, and the final reporting of results. Both quantitative and qualitative designs are examined using software to aid in inquiry and analysis. Course pre-requisite (s): Any Introductory ANTH, ECON, GEOG, GOV, HIS, PSY, SOC, or, any AFR or LTAM 1400 series course, or AFR 1501, 1502, 2402 or 3000, or COMM 2402, or 3401 and MAT 1180 or higher; ADGA students will also need the prerequisite of PSY 3407 Psychology of Perception. Course co-requisite (s): n/a Recommended/required textbook (s) and/or materials 1 Title: Making Sense of the Social World: Methods of Investigation Edition: 4th edition Author: Chambliss, David F. and Schutt, Russell K. Publisher: Pine Forge Press, 2012 Materials: MS Excel or related data management software Course Intended Learning Outcomes and Methods of Assessment: Learning outcomes Assessment methods 1. Application of theoretical approaches underlying research methodology from a historical, cultural, and ethical context and the ability to choose the proper theoretical foundation for a research project. 2. Determining the difference between quantitative and qualitative designs and an understanding of how and when to apply each design using the scientific method. 1. Classroom discussion of theoretical approaches; quizzes and exams to identify factual material; in-class and online participation activities on the application of theory to practice when choosing a research project. 2. Class discussion surrounding current research articles and projects that use quantitative, and/or qualitative, research design; in-class or on-line group discussion and participation activities of the benefits/drawbacks of each; paper assignment on constructing a design outline for a research project. 3. Classroom discussion surrounding studies on ethics; in-class or on-line group discussion in response to conducting research with human subjects; creation of 3. Understanding the role and importance of ethics and the ability to critically analyze risks versus benefits when conducting research. 1 This text is only suggested. The final determination will be at the discretion of the instructor. 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 5 of 16) informed consent form to be included in with project; certification and conducting research with human subjects-Institutional Review board. 4. The ability to create and test a hypothesis, including the capacity to conduct a proper literature review and to logically apply past findings to the creation of an Introduction Section. 5. Analyzing observational methods with and without intervention, archival research and content analysis, and case study designs. The ability to apply this understanding to the proper creation of a method while considering the benefits and drawbacks of using each design. Determining proper sampling methods and avoiding selection bias. Students will be able to begin creation of Methods Section of poster/paper 6. Determining when and how to use quasiexperimental design including one group pretest/posttest design and ABAB design. The ability to apply this understanding to the proper creation of a method while considering the benefits and drawbacks of using each design. Continued application towards creation of Methods Section of poster/paper. 7. Creating survey/questionnaire designs using reliability and validity measures including appropriate data collection methods and analysis for mail surveys/questionnaires, telephone surveys/questionnaires, personal interviews, and internet surveys/questionnaires. The ability to apply this understanding to the proper creation of a method while considering the benefits and drawbacks of using each design. Continued application towards creation of Methods Section of poster/paper. 8. Appropriate application of univariate and bivariate distributions, including the ability to understand the appropriate use of correlational designs. The ability to read scatterplots. Application of univariate and bivariate distributions to the creation of a Results Section. 9. Using the logic behind the construction of experimental designs and the application of statistical analysis to confirm findings and to determine proper methodology and proper reporting of Results section. Continued application of material towards creation of Results Section. 4. Classroom discussions of testable versus non-testable questions; library class on available resources and inclass or on-line development of Introduction Section. Exam #1 5. Classroom discussions of the various observational studies used in research and proper sampling methods; quiz; in-class or on-line group discussion and participation activities demonstrating how to utilize observational methods and in-class or on-line outline construction of Methods Section. 6. Classroom discussions comparing different types of quasi-experimental designs; quiz; Continued preparation of Methods Section via in-class or on-line group discussions. 7. Classroom discussions of appropriate Likert scale construction, reliability and validity; in-class or on-line group discussion and participation to distinguish between different survey methodologies; In-class or online continued group discussion and work on refining of Introduction and Methods Sections; In-class or on-line preparation of Results Section. 8. Classroom discussion of appropriate application of univariate and bivariate data; in-class or on-line group discussion and in-class exercise/review examining the proper application of correlational designs. In-class or on-line continued preparation of Introduction, Methods, and Results Sections. 9. Classroom discussions on experimental designs; inclass participation activity conducting their own pilot experiment; participation activity reflecting on experiment; Classroom discussions about cause and effect; quiz; In-class or on-line continued preparation of Introduction, Methods, and Results Sections. 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 6 of 16) 10. The ability to logically draw conclusions based on research findings, and the ability to properly prepare, construct, and present an APA style poster or paper. 10. Classroom discussions; quiz; in-class or on-line group discussion and assignments throughout the semester on APA style; students will use paper assignment; in-class student poster presentations of research proposal; Group research project proposal due General education learning outcomes/assessment methods Learning outcomes Assessment methods 1. Knowledge: Using different methodological concepts students develop an understanding of the key concepts and varied forms of analysis used in conducting research on social problems 1. Discussion of theories and concepts with a focus on developing the ability to apply theory as a foundation for applied research; Students will be assessed as to how best they articulate these ideas and concepts through in-class and on-line discussions, in written assignments, group participation activities, and a group research project proposal and presentation. 2. Skills: Proficiency in applying the scientific method to research, report, and draw conclusions using data collected by the student and to comprehend the findings reported by others. 2. Students will demonstrate an understanding of the basic types of research methods and to assess which are best suited for particular research questions. Students will be assessed as to how best they articulate these ideas and concepts through class exams, class discussions, and research design projects. 3. Students will be able to formulate questions that are appropriate to different types of research projects in related disciplines; assessment of this ability will be measured via the final research project, on exams and in class discussions and participation activities focused on this learning outcome. 4. By the end of the course, students will demonstrate an understanding of the scientific method in the context of the term research proposal. This will involve identifying a problem and relevant variables so that the most appropriate method can be applied to the research proposal. 3. Integration: Development of student’s ability to formulate research questions based upon a critical appraisal of existing research across social and behavioral disciplines. 4. Values, Ethics and Relationships: Application of fundamental research concepts to understanding human behavior and social systems; awareness of the importance of creatively working with others to solve problems and appreciate diverse viewpoints when analyzing real-world problems. Sample sequence of topics and time allocations 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 7 of 16) Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Topic Introduction to Research in Social Science—Choosing a Project The Scientific Approach Ethics in Social Science, Institutional Review Board and certification Problem Formulation and Theory Development; Conducting a Literature Review; Hypothesis Testing and Operationalizing Variable; Writing an Introduction Sampling, Selection Bias; Observational Methods; Archival Research; Case Studies; Constructing a Methods Section; term exam #1 Quasi-Experimental Designs; term exam #2 Survey Research & Questionnaire Construction Introduction to Data Collection and Qualitative Analysis; Univariate and Bivariate Distributions; Writing a Results Section; Introduction to Research Design: True Experiments Writing the Full Research Report, Implications, Conclusions and Future Directions Draft Group Research Proposals Due and Student peer-review of research proposal; final exam Final Group Research Presentations/Papers Due Summary of assessment methods Exam 1 and 2: ☐ 30% Final Exam : ☐ 20% Lab: ☐n/a Homework: ☐ 10% Hours 3 3 3 3 6 3 3 6 3 6 3 3 Research/class proposal and ☐ 20% presentation: Class participation: ☐ 10% Quizzes: ☐10% Other: n/a TOTAL: 100% *Scope of Assignments and Method of Grading to be determined at discretion of the instructor METHOD OF GRADING – elements and weight of factors determining the students’ grade Two Term examinations @ 15% each 2. Final examination 3. Group Research Project Proposal + Presentation 4. Quizzes 5. Two Assignments 6. Participation 30% 20% 20% 10% 10% 10% __________________________________________________________________________________________ 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 8 of 16) Selected Bibliography: American Psychological Association (2009). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (6th Ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. Babbie, Earl. (2010). The Practice of Social Research (12th Edition). Stamford: Wadsworth. Chambliss, Daniel F., & Schutt, Russell K. (2012). Making Sense of the Social World (4th Edition). Washington D.C.: Pine Forge Publications Creswell (2007). Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Approaches (2nd ed). Thousand Oaks: Sage. Creswell (2009) Research Design: Qualitative & Quantitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches (3rd Ed). Thousand Oaks: Sage. Denzin & Lincoln (2000). Handbook of Qualitative Research (2nd Ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage Ethridge, D. (2004), Research Methodology in Applied Economics. Hoboken: Blackwell Publishing. Galvan, J.L. (1999). Writing Literature Reviews. Los Angeles: Pyrczak Publishing. 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 9 of 16) Library Form: LIBRARY RESOURCES & INFORMATION LITERACY: MAJOR CURRICULUM MODIFICATION CURRICULUM PROPOSAL – NEW COURSES AND PROGRAMS LIBRARY RESOURCES & INFORMATION LITERACY Please complete this form for all new courses/programs and major changes to existing courses/programs. The information you provide will assist the library in planning for new acquisitions; this information will not affect course or program proposals either positively or negatively. Consult with library faculty subject selectors early in the planning of course proposals. This will ensure enough time to allocate budgets if materials need to be purchased. Find the library faculty subject selector for your department here: http://library.citytech.cuny.edu/about/faculty/subject.php Course proposer: please complete boxes 1-5. Library faculty subject selector: please complete box 6. #1 Title of proposal: New Course Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences SBS 2000 Department Chairperson/Coordinator: Hugh McDonald Proposed by: Marco Castillo, ext. 4969 mcastillo@citytech.cuny.edu Pa Her, ext. 5741, pher@citytech.cuny.edu Sean MacDonald, ext. 5084, smacdonald@citytech.cuny.edu Maria Pagano, ext. 5096, mpagano@citytech.cuny.edu Department/Program: Social Science Expected date course(s) will be offered Each Fall and Spring semester beginning, Fall, 2014 # of students: 30 Date: February 11, 2012 #2 Brief description of course(s) and/or program: An introduction to the research methodologies utilized in the social and behavioral sciences, beginning with the fundamentals of research design, through data collection, analysis, interpretation, and the final reporting of results. Both quantitative and qualitative designs are examined using software to aid in inquiry and analysis. 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 10 of 16) #3 Are City Tech library resources sufficient for course assignments? Please elaborate. Yes. The library’s resources are more than adequate for students to conduct the required literature review for their final paper. Moreover, the library offers classes to assist students with finding reputable resources for their final group research project proposal. #4 Are additional resources needed for course assignments? Please elaborate. Books / electronic books Journals / electronic journals Databases and other electronic resources Multimedia (DVDs, CDs, CD-ROMs, etc.) Other A copy of the suggested course texts are not yet available at the NYCCT library and will need to be ordered. Upon approval of the course by College Council, a request will be made for a copy of each suggested text. Please include author, title, publisher, edition, date and price. Chambliss, Daniel F. and Schutt, Russell K. Making Sense of the Social World (4th Edition). Pine Forge Publications, 2012. ISBN 978-1-4522-1771-0. Price: $60.84 #5 Library faculty focus on strengthening students' information literacy skills in finding, evaluating, and ethically using information. We are available to collaborate with instructors regarding development of assignments, and to provide customized information literacy instruction and research guides for your course. Do you plan to consult with the library faculty subject specialist for your area? Please give details. Yes. It will be strongly suggested that faculty who teach this course should allocate at least one class meeting toward an information literacy workshop to be conducted by Keith Muchowski. #6 Library Faculty Subject Selector: Keith Muchowski I researched the CUNY library catalog to ensure that the Ursula C. Schwerin Library contained sufficient and appropriate materials for this course, which it does. The library holds a significant number of monographs on research methods in the Social and Behavioral Sciences. The databases contain a sizable collection of newspapers, magazine, and academic journal articles in this field as well. Comments and Recommendations I have no specific recommendations. I suggest the department inform the library of any future trends in the field to ensure the library’s collection continues to remain current. Date February 17, 2012 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 11 of 16) Consultation with Affected Department: Re: Re: Methods Course Trash x mpagano@citytech.cuny.edu x Christine Thorpe Oct 26 (10 days ago) to Maria Hi Maria, Our curriculum committee recently met to further discuss the methods course that you are proposing. Upon further discussion, we felt that the courses offered in both human services and health services administration currently satisfy the needs of our students. I will provide you with a copy of the Methods course syllabus to show the differences in the courses for the college council cmte. Regards, Christine Christine W. Thorpe, EdD, EdM, CHES Chairperson Human Services Department New York City College of Technology/CUNY >>> Maria Pagano 10/17/12 12:59 PM >>> Hi Christine, Thanks for the minutes, but they are from the wrong meeting. We met with Professors Cho and Negron on March 1, 2012, so the minutes should have been from the Curriculum Committee meeting in March, 2012. In addition, we could also need a copy of the syllabus for the Methods course to show the differences. While Professors Cho and Negron did agree that the courses differed in major ways we would like to show concrete evidence of this to the College Council Curriculum Committee. Sorry about all this. Regards, Maria On Wed, Oct 17, 2012 at 11:22 AM, Christine Thorpe <cthorpe@citytech.cuny.edu> wrote: Hi Maria, Sorry for the delay. Please see attached minutes. Please let me know if you need additional information. Thanks, Christine Christine W. Thorpe, EdD, EdM, CHES Chairperson Human Services Department 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 12 of 16) New York City College of Technology/CUNY ---------- Forwarded message ---------From: "Christine Thorpe" <CThorpe@CityTech.Cuny.Edu> To: "Maria Pagano" <MPagano@CityTech.Cuny.Edu> Cc: "Sean Macdonald" <SMacdonald@CityTech.Cuny.Edu>, "marco castillo" <marcocastillophd@gmail.com> Date: Tue, 09 Oct 2012 11:19:32 -0400 Subject: Re: Methods Course Hi Maria, Will do. Will send you a copy of the minutes this week. Best, Christine Christine W. Thorpe, EdD, EdM, CHES Chairperson Human Services Department New York City College of Technology/CUNY 718-260-5724 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 13 of 16) Consultation with Affected Department: New York City College of Technology The City University of New York 300 Jay Street Brooklyn, NY 11201 October 2nd, 2012 Dear Prof. MacDonald I am writing in support of SBS 2000—Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences, a new course proposed by your Department. On September 21 st, the ADGA Department voted unanimously in favor of the course. We believe the proposed course will benefit our students as they prepare for ADV 4830 - Senior Project - our capstone design course. In our discussions, we also noted the following: - Based on our current enrollment numbers, we suggest two sections be offered for ADGA students (one day, one evening) - Require that PSY 3407 be listed as a pre-requisite (for ADV students only), in order to encourage them to take the proposed new course in the 7th semester prior to registering for our Senior Project class which is offered to our upper-level students in the 8th semester. We look forward to the implementation of this new class for our students. Sincerely, Mary Ann Biehl Chairperson Department of Advertising Design & Graphic Arts New York City College of Technology 300 Jay Street, Namm 1126 Brooklyn, NY11201 mbiehl@citytech.cuny.edu 718-260-5175 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 14 of 16) NEW YORK CITY COLLEGE OF TECHNOLOGY The City University of New York Karl Botchway, PhD Interim Dean, School of Arts and Sciences 300 Jay Street, Namm 805 Brooklyn, NY 11201-2983 Ph: (718) 260 – 5008 Fax: (718) 260 – 5012 KBotchway@citytech.cuny.edu September 30th, 2012 To: Prof. Andrew Douglas, Chair of the Curriculum Committee From: Karl Botchway, Interim Dean, School of Arts and Sciences Subject: Letter of Support – Proposed New Course: Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences I am writing to support the decision of the Social Sciences Department to propose a new course: Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences. This new course which is an interdisciplinary course will complement and enrich the department’s course offerings. This course addresses a long overdue vacuum in the social science department and introduces students to the foundational elements of basic methods for social and behavioral science research. Among other course objectives, the course will enable students learn distinguish between quantitative and qualitative approaches to social science research and utilize computer software packages to aid in such inquiry and analysis. As the course proposers note, students taking this course will also be exposed to a core General Education objective at CityTech: that is, developing the “skills in conducting independent research while expanding on their ability to understand and evaluate the findings of others.” Sincerely, Karl Botchway __________________ Karl Botchway PhD Interim Dean of Arts and Sciences 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 15 of 16) Jean Kubeck Nov 15 (5 days ago) to Marco, Karl, Maria, Pa, Sean Dear All, I reviewed the attached proposal revisions, concur with Dean Botchway's comments, and approve this version. If you need a formal letter, let me know. Thank you, Jean Jean Kubeck Hillstrom, Ph.D. Chair, Department of Social Sciences CUNY University Integrated IRB Member New York City College of Technology, CUNY 300 Jay Street, N611 Brooklyn, NY 11201 1-718-260-5080/5079 >>> Maria Pagano <mpagano@citytech.cuny.edu> 11/14/2013 2:15 PM >>> 12-16 SBS 2000 Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences 12-19-2013 (Page 16 of 16) Chancellor’s Report: Section AIV: New Courses AIV.1.Social Sciences Course Number: SBS 2000 Title: Research Methods for the Social and Behavioral Sciences Hours: 3 Class Hour, 0 Lab Hours Credits: 3 Credits Prerequisite: Prerequisite(1): Any Introductory ANTH, ECON, GEOG, GOV, HIS, PSY, SOC, or, any AFR or LTAM 1400 series course, or AFR 1501, 1502, 2402 or 3000, or COMM 2402, or 3401 and MAT 1180 or higher; ADGA students will also need the prerequisite of PSY 3407 Psychology of Perception. Pre-requisite (3): PSY 3407 Psychology of Perception; prerequisite only applies to Advertising Design and Graphic Arts students Corequisites: None Course Description: An introduction to the research methodologies utilized in the social and behavioral sciences, beginning with the fundamentals of research design, through data collection, analysis, interpretation, and the final reporting of results. Both quantitative and qualitative designs are examined using software to aid in inquiry and analysis. Rationale: City Tech is the only CUNY College that does not offer such a course and as such, this course was requested by ADGA and will be required in their program.