All the King’s Men by Robert Penn Warren Created for: Christian Classics October 1, 2008 1 Dear Rod, Thank you so much for ordering the All the King’s Men book club kit from www.BookClubClassics.com. I sincerely hope this guide adds to your enjoyment of the novel! Please feel free to email any questions or concerns before your club meets or any feedback afterwards: (kgalles@msn.com or BookClubClassics@q.com). I promise that any suggestions will be used to strengthen future kits, and I would love to use any positive quotes on my web site. By the way, all citations refer to the 1996 Harvest by Harcourt Books edition (the cover is on the title page of this kit). Again, thank you for your support and feel free to order another kit in the future!! Sincerely, Kristen Galles Book Club Classics LitGuides.com 2 Table of Contents Fast Facts 4 Allusions 5 Chapter Summaries 6 Author Information 7 Menu Ideas 8 Warm-up Activity 12 Character Sketches 13 Bookmark – All Characters 15 Bookmark – Main Characters 19 Discussion Questions 20 Review 26 Films 27 What to Read Next 28 3 All the King’s Men – Fast Facts Author – Robert Penn Warren Pages – 661 (Harvest by Harcourt Books edition) Date Published – 1946 Setting – Mason City; Burden’s Landing; Tyree; Upton (widely believed to be set in Louisiana) Point of view – First person (Jack Burden) Genre – Historical Fiction (novel) Issues/Conflicts – Politics / Power / Greed / Betrayal / Identity _____________________________________________________________ Excellent resources: Website on Huey Long: http://www.hueylong.com/: “Huey Long is one of the most significant, yet misunderstood political figures in American history. More than 70 years after his assassination at age 42, the story of Louisiana’s legendary governor, U.S. Senator, and favorite son remains more myth than fact. Best remembered for his ‘Share Our Wealth’ platform, which swept the nation during the Great Depression, Huey Long was demonized by the powerful as a dangerous revolutionary, yet revered by the masses as a champion of the common man. In a land of plenty, Huey Long believed that no American should be without an education, a home, an automobile, and a job that paid a decent living wage. Learn more about Huey Long's Share Our Wealth program. Huey Long implemented an unprecedented program of modernization and reform in Louisiana – building roads and bridges, providing free public education, expanding voting rights to all citizens, and creating economic opportunity for a majority trapped in poverty. Huey Long believed that government should protect and uplift its most vulnerable citizens and provide opportunity for everyone, regardless of race or class. Our most cherished government institutions – from social security to veterans benefits, student financial aid and public works – were causes first championed by Huey Long.” 1947 Pulitzer Prize: http://www.pulitzer.org/bycat/Novel Time Magazine’s All Time 100 Novels: http://www.time.com/time/2005/100books/0,24459,all_the_kings_men,00.html 4 All the King’s Men – Allusions Billiken – good luck doll or charm Barney Oldfield – racer and pioneer from early 1900’s General Forrest – Confederate general Nell Gwyn – English actress from 1600’s Kubla Khan – poem by Samuel Taylor Coleridge: http://www.onlineliterature.com/coleridge/640/ the benzene ring – molecular structure in organic chemistry Caedmon’s song – 7th century English poet: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caedmon's_Song Paul on the road to Damascus – refers to Paul’s conversion: http://www.beliefnet.com/story/142/story_14252_1.html Queequeg – Cannibal befriended by Ishmael in Moby Dick Luna moths: lime green Silk moth: http://www.earthsbirthday.org/butterflies/bflys/activitykit/lunamoths.html Judas – apostle who betrayed Jesus Samson’s parable w/ the bees -http://www.swedenborgdigitallibrary.org/sower/jj12/judg22.htm 5 All the King’s Men – Chapter Overviews Chapter 1 – Jack, Willie, Sugar Boy, Lucy, Tiny Duffy are introduced; photo shoot w/ Willie’s father and dog; Willie chats w/ townspeople of Mason City and promises to help friend’s imprisoned son; flashback to Jack’s first meeting w/ “Cousin” Willie; Sadie discovers that Judge Irwin has endorsed Callahan, so Willie and Jack pay him a visit and threaten to blackmail him. Chapter 2 – Flashback to Willie’s rise to power (schoolhouse tragedy); Willie becomes lawyer; Willie unknowingly set up to split the vote, but learns truth from Sadie and stumps for other candidate: MacMurfee; successful at law; runs for office and becomes governor; Jack hired by Willie. Chapter 3 – Jack visits his mother and reminisces about his childhood and mother’s three marriages; reminisces about Anne and Adam and of his decision to go to the state university and not Harvard; dinner party: all guests are against Willie; Jack returns to capitol to discover White controversy and impeachment attempt; Hugh Miller resigns and Lucy almost leaves Willie; Jack reminisces about Willie’s affairs and reveals that Sadie is Willie’s mistress; due to White scandal, Lucy leaves Willie to live w/ sister; Tom, Willie’s son, is revealed to be an arrogant college football star. Chapter 4 – Jack reveals his first “great sleep” or depression was caused by his thesis on ancestors: Cass Mastern had affair w/ friend, Duncan’s, wife, Annabelle; Duncan committed suicide when he discovered affair; Phebe, Annabelle’s slave, knows truth of suicide so Annabelle sells her; Cass tries to free Phebe, but fails; Cass farms plantation and frees slaves, but joins army on Confederate side, vowing not to kill anyone; Jack deserts thesis because he doesn’t understand Cass’s motives or feeling of responsibility for Duncan and Phebe. Chapter 5 – Jack tries to find dirt on Judge Irwin; Anne meets Willie in order to fund her charity; Willie begins to build hospital; Jack discovers that Judge received stock and position at American Electric Company in exchange for dismissing court case brought against Southern Belle Fuel Company (same parent company); Littlepaugh, former attorney for American Electric, appealed to Governor Stanton to intervene, but he protected his friend the Judge (who did not know this); Littlepaugh commits suicide, yet Governor Stanton still protects Judge Irwin and threatens Littlepaugh’s sister, who remains silent. Chapter 6 – Tom Stark is in drunk driving accident, gravely injuring his passenger whose father is very upset but is soon quieted by Willie; Lucy is upset and wants Tom to stop playing football; Willie refuses to let Tiny Duffy soil hospital by giving contract to Gummy Larson; Jack convinces Adam to head hospital by revealing his father’s former cover-up; Jack also tells Anne, who decides to have an affair with Willie; Jack flees West upon learning of affair. Chapter 7 – Jack drives West, reminiscing about his childhood relationship and inability to sleep w/ Anne, who refused to marry Jack due to his lack of ambition; he then remembers how his marriage w/ Lois was based on sexual compatibility; Jack fears that the news about her father drove Anne to Willie. Chapter 8 – Jack heads home and picks up old man with a twitch which leads to his Great Twitch theory that life is random and without cause (his “secret knowledge”); Jack watches Adam perform lobotomy; Jack learns about Coffee trying to bribe Adam and Adam’s reaction; Marvin Frey’s brings paternity suit against Tom, who may or may not have impregnated daughter Sibyl; in reaction, Willie begrudgingly gives hospital contract to Gummy; Jack reveals blackmail information to Judge Irwin who then commits suicide; Jack discovers his true paternity and becomes the sole heir to Judge’s estate; due to the inter-related nature of these events, Jack decides he must discard his Great Twitch theory. Chapter 9 – After the Judge’s death, Jack refuses to do any more blackmail for Willie and works on a tax bill instead; Tom is injured in a football accident and becomes paralyzed (and eventually dies); Willie cancels Gummy’s contract and recommits to wife and to doing good; Adam discovers Anne’s affair w/ Willie and kills Willie before Sugar Boy kills Adam. Chapter 10 – Jack learns from Sadie that she told Tiny Duffy about Willie’s affair with Anne, who told Adam about Anne; Jack confronts Tiny, who offers him a job; Jack visits Lucy and sees Tom’s son, named Willie; Jack sees Sugar Boy at the library and contemplates revealing that Tiny was behind Willie’s murder, but decides not to; Jack visits mother who is leaving her husband; Jack now respects his mother since she loved Judge Irwin, his father, and lies to her about why the Judge killed himself, citing poor health; Jack marries Anne and the Scholarly Attorney moves in w/ them at Judge Irwin’s house; Jack decides to continue thesis on Cass Mastern. 6 All the King’s Men -- Author Information Robert Penn Warren was born in Guthrie, Kentucky on April 24, 1905, but spent much of his youth in Tennessee. He graduated from Vanderbilt University in 1925. He also attended University of Berkeley and Yale University, and was a Rhodes Scholar in 1930. He taught at Vanderbilt, LSU, The University of Minnesota, and Rhodes College. He married Emma Brescia in 1930 and divorced in 1951. He then married Eleanor Clarck in 1952 and fathered two children, a daughter and a son. He eventually lived in Fairfield, CT and Stratton, VT before succumbing to bone cancer on September 15, 1989. Warren’s most famous work was All the King’s Men, which won the Pulitzer Prize. Warren won two more Pulitzers for his poetry and remains the only writer to win multiple Pulitzers in literature and poetry. He was also the Poet Laureate from 1944 – 1945. In addition, he was very influential in the field of literary criticism, co-authoring Understanding Poetry with Cleanth Brooks. He is considered to be one of the founders of New Criticism, an approach to interpreting literature that seeks to gain meaning from a close reading of the text, rather than any biographical significance or authorial intent. A review in the New York Times described Warren: “Robert Penn Warren, Kentucky born and Tennessee educated, poet, professor, critic and novelist, is a Southerner who hates the shortcomings of the South, as do so many Southern writers. But he writes about such shortcomings with an eloquence and an elemental rage worlds apart form the sordid bitterness of some of his literary colleagues.” For biography and further background info: Poets.org: http://www.poets.org/poet.php/prmPID/17 “No Kentucky author comes close to being as distinguished as Robert Penn Warren”: http://www.english.eku.edu/SERVICES/KYLIT/WARREN.HTM RobertPennWarren.com: http://www.robertpennwarren.com/ 7 All the King’s Men – Menu Ideas Here are a few menu ideas from the state of Louisiana, courtesy of VernaLisa and http://www.classbrain.com/artstate/publish/louisiana_recipes.shtml SIMPLE CHICKEN AND SAUSAGE GUMBO Perhaps the simplest of the gumbos, but a hearty one and a classic combination. If you can't find andouille, use a local smoked sausage or kielbasa or whatever smoked sausage you like. This one's easy to knock off quickly for a great evening's meal. 1 cup oil 1 cup flour 2 large onions, chopped 2 bell peppers, chopped 4 ribs celery, chopped 4 - 6 cloves garlic, minced 4 quarts chicken stock 2 bay leaves 2 teaspoons Creole seasoning, or to taste 1 teaspoon dried thyme leaves Salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste 1 large chicken (young hen preferred), cut into pieces 2 pounds andouille or smoked sausage, cut into 1/2" pieces 1 bunch scallions (green onions), tops only, chopped 2/3 cup fresh chopped parsley Filé powder to taste Season the chicken with salt, pepper and Creole seasoning and brown quickly. Brown the sausage, pour off fat and reserve meats. In a large, heavy pot, heat the oil and cook the flour in the oil over medium to high heat (depending on your roux-making skill), stirring constantly, until the roux reaches a dark reddish-brown color, almost the color of coffee or milk chocolate for a Cajun-style roux. If you want to save time, or prefer a more New Orleans-style roux, cook it to a medium, peanut-butter color, over lower heat if you're nervous about burning it. Add the vegetables and stir quickly. This cooks the vegetables and also stops the roux from cooking further. Continue to cook, stirring constantly, for about 4 minutes. Add the stock, seasonings, chicken and sausage. Bring to a boil, then cook for about one hour, skimming fat off the top as needed. Add the chopped scallion tops and parsley, and heat for 5 minutes. Serve over rice in large shallow bowls. Accompany with a good beer and lots of hot, crispy French bread. 8 NEW ORLEANS BEIGNET DOUGHNUTS 1 pk active dry yeast 1 1/2 c warm water (105 deg. f.) 1/2 c sugar 1 ts salt 2 ea eggs 1 c evaporated milk 7 c sifted all-purpose flour 1/4 c soft shortening 1 x oil for frying In large bowl, sprinkle yeast over water; stir to dissolve. Add sugar, salt, eggs and milk. Blend with rotary beater. Add 4 cups of the flour; beat smooth. Add shortening; beat in remaining flour. Cover and chill several hours. Deep fry at 360 degrees 2 to 3 minutes or until lightly browned on each side. (If beignets don't rise to the top immediately when you drop them into the oil, the oil isn't hot enough.) Drain on paper towels. Sprinkle heavily with confectioner’s sugar. Serve hot. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Cajun Meatloaf Ingredients 2 whole bay leaves 1 tablespoon salt 1 teaspoon ground red pepper( cayenne) 1 teaspoon black pepper 1/2 teaspoon ground cumin 1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg 4 tablespoons unsalted butter cup finely chopped celery 1/2 cup of celery finely chopped 1/2 cup finely chopped bell pepper 1/4 cup chopped greens onions 12 teaspoon of minced garlic 1 tablespoon tabasco sauce 1 tablespoon worcestershire sauce 1/2 cup milk 2 pounds ground beef 1/2 pound of ground pork 2 eggs lightly beaten 1 cup very fine dry bread crumbs 9 Cooking Instructions 1. combine the seasoning mix ingredients in a small bowl and set aside. 2. melt the butter in 1 quart saucepan over medium heat. 3. add the onions, celery, bell pepper, green onions, garlic, tabasco, worcestershire and seasoning mix. 4. saute until mixture starts sticking excessively, about 6 mins, stirring occasionally and scraping the pan bottom well. 5. stir in the milk and 1/2 cup catsup. 6. continue cooking for about 2 mins, stirring occasionally. 7. remove from the heat and allow mixture to cool to room temperature. 8. place the ground beef and pork in an ungreased 13 x 9 inch baking pan. 9. add the eggs, the cooked vegetable mixture removing the bay leaves, the bread crumbs. 10. mix by hand until thoroughly combined in the center of the pan ... shape the mixture into a loaf that is about 1 1/2 inches high x 6 inches wide and 12 inches long. 11. bake uncovered at 350 for 25 minutes, then raise heat to 400 and continue cooking until done, about 35 minutes longer. 12. serve immediately, Enjoy the taste of New Orleans! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ BAKED BRISKET FROM NORTH LOUISIANA 1 TB garlic powder 2 TB celery seed 2 TB black pepper 1 TB Mrs. Dash (any flavor) 1 TB seasoned salt 2 TB liquid smoke 2 TB worcestershire sauce 1 large brisket Mix in a small bowl until you make a paste. With a pastry brush pat on large brisket. Wrap in foil tightly, then cook for five hours at 300 degrees. ~~~~~~~~ 10 LOUISIANA ROLLED STUFFED MEAT LOAF 2 cups herb seasoned stuffing mix, crushed 1/2 cut shredded carrot 2 TB parsley 1/4 cup water 2 pounds ground chuck 2 cans cream of mushroom soup, undiluted and divided 1 egg beaten 1/3 cup finely chopped onion, optional 1 tsp salt 1/2 cup milk Combine 1 1/2 cups stuffing mix, carrot, parsley and water, stir well and set mixture aside. Combine beef, 1/2 cup soup, egg, onion, salt and remaining 1/2 cup stuffing mix. Shape into a 9 x 12 inch rectangle on a sheet of waxed paper. Spread reserved stuffing mixture on top, leaving a one inch margin around edges. Begin at long end and roll jelly-roll fashion, lifting waxed paper to help roll. Press edges and ends to seal. Place roll, seam side down in a lightly greased baking dish. Let loaf stand 10 minutes before serving. Combine remaining soup and milk in a saucepan. Cook over low heat and serve sauce over meat loaf. Bake for one hour or until done at 350 degrees. Serves 8 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ BEST EVER CHICKEN 'N DUMPLINS' - NORTH LOUISIANA 6 boneless chicken breasts 3 cups flour 1 1/2 cup milk little salt 1/4 cup butter 6 cups of water Boil chicken breasts. Save the broth and cool and cube chicken. Put the chicken aside. Mix flour, salt and butter together and slowly add the milk to the flour mixture. Blend well. This dough will be thick but roll out thinly on well floured board. Cut into squares with pizza cutter. Drop each square single into water and broth to keep the dumplings from sticking together. Cook the dumplings and chicken together for 15 to 20 minutes (covered). 11 All the King’s Men – Activities Throughout the novel, Warren occasionally uses animal imagery to bring out different qualities of the characters, especially Willie Stark: “Willie stopped pacing and swung his head at her with the forelock down over his eyes to give him the look of a mean horse when he’s cornered in the angle of the pasture fence with his head down a little and the mane shagged forward between the ears, and the eyes both wild and shrewd, watching you step up with the bridle, and getting ready to bolt” (93-4). Jack’s mother: “She sank down on the couch with an easy motion, vaguely suggestive of a flutter and preening as when a bird touches a bough, and took a sip, and lifted her head as if to let the liquor trickle into her throat” (166). He does not associate an animal with Jack Burden, Adam or Anne Stanton, Tiny Duffy, or Judge Irwin. What animal would fit each of them? Which animal would you choose to describe the experience of reading the novel? What type of animal would best describe the perfect reader of this novel? 12 All the King’s Men – Character Sketches Jack Burden – Born in Burden’s Landing to wealthy parents; childhood friends w/ Anne and Adam Stanton; father, Ellis Burden, abruptly leaves his mother when young; endures several step-fathers; Judge Irwin is his neighbor and surrogate father-figure; his childhood love is Anne, but when he proposes she thinks he has no ambition; he drops out of law school and becomes a student of history, but abandons research paper on his ancestors, the Masterns; invents nihilistic theory of “Great Twitch” after learning about Willie and Anne’s affair; blackmails Judge Irwin, which leads to the Judge’s suicide; discovers Judge was his father and inherits his estate; marries Anne at end and decides to complete thesis on the Masterns. Willie Stark – Raised poor on a pig farm; becomes successful lawyer; manipulated into running for governor in order to split the vote after he fights a corrupt building contract that results in disaster; after Sadie tells him about his role in splitting the vote, he stumps for McMurfee, the other candidate; eventually becomes governor himself; married to Lucy, but has many affairs; father of, and very proud of, Tom; hero to the masses for standing up to the old guard; uses blackmail to do good; desires to build hospital honestly. Tiny Duffy – Former tax assessor; “city hall slob”; sets up Willie to split vote for candidate Joe Harrison; hired by Willie and abused by him; becomes lieutenant governor; tries to get Willie into corrupt bargain with Gummy Larson for kick-back; uses info from Sadie about affair w/ Anne to facilitate Willie’s murder; becomes governor and offers Jack a job. Lucy Stark – Willie’s wife; former schoolteacher who lost her job when Willie stood up to corrupt builders and politicians; criticized Willie’s methods; disagreed about Tom’s behavior and whether he should play football; eventually moves to sister’s place, but reconciles with Willie after Tom’s accident; after Tom dies, she adopts Tom’s alleged lovechild and names him “Willie” who she must believe was a great man. Tom Stark – Willie and Lucy’s son; talented, but arrogant college football player; drunk driving results in grave injury of passenger; alleged to be father of child of Sibyl; disdainful of father; paralyzed in a football accident and eventually dies. Sadie Burke – Grew up in poverty; face is scarred by smallpox; Willie’s secretary and mistress after she tells Willie that he was being used to split the vote; only woman in Willie’s inner circle; reveals affair with Anne to Tiny Duffy out of jealousy; checks herself into a sanitarium afterwards, then leaves state. 13 Sugar-Boy O’Sheean – Young Irishman with a love of sugar who stutters; serves as Willie’s loyal driver and bodyguard; kills Adam after he shoots Willie. Adam Stanton – Childhood friend to Jack and brother of Anne; son of former governor; becomes renowned surgeon; chooses to live in poverty; agrees to head Willie’s hospital after learning about own father’s bad deeds; kills Willie after learning about affair with Anne. Anne Stanton – Childhood sweetheart of Jack who refused to marry him due to his lack of ambition; volunteers at children’s home; begins affair with Willie after learning of her father’s bad deed; marries Jack at end. Judge Irwin – Jack’s childhood neighbor and surrogate father; disdainful of Willie’s politics; while Attorney General under Governor Stanton, in need of money, he took a bribe from American Electric Power Company, which caused the suicide of their current attorney; Governor Stanton protected Judge Irwin, without his knowledge; he commits suicide when information is revealed and leaves estate to Jack, his biological son. Ellis Burden – Jack calls him “The Scholarly Attorney;” Jack is raised to believe he is his father; after learning of wife’s affair, he leaves her and Jack commits himself to helping poor and writing Christian tracts; eventually moves in with Jack at end. Jack’s mother – Unnamed mother of narrator; grew up poor in Arkansas where she met and married Ellis Burden and moved to Burden’s Landing; had an affair w/ Judge Irwin that resulted in Jack; upon learning this, Ellis leaves her; she subsequently marries “The Tycoon,” “The Count,” and “The Young Executive;” raises Jack in wealth and privilege; leaves “Young Executive” after death of Judge, and never learns Judge’s true motivation for suicide, believing it was due to his failing health. Cass Mastern – Jack’s great uncle; brother of Gilbert; sleeps with friend’s wife, Annabelle; when friend, Duncan, finds out he kills himself and leaves his ring under his pillow which Phebe, a slave, discovers; Annabelle sells Phebe out of embarrassment; Cass tries to free her, but is unsuccessful; becomes an abolitionist; runs a plantation without the use of slaves; volunteers to serve the South in Civil War in non-combat role; dies of gunshot wound. 14 All the King’s Men – Bookmark: Characters Printable Bookmark! Please print and then cut to use as a reference as you read!! When possible, only basic information has been provided to avoid “spoilers.” “Ch.” Refers to the chapter in which the character was first introduced. Character Jack Burden Willie Stark Tiny Duffy Lucy Stark Tom Stark Sugar-Boy O’Sheean Sadie Burke Malaciah Wynn Doc Slade Alex Michel Albert Evans Callahan Masters Theodore Murrell Adam Stanton Anne Stanton Joel Stanton Ellis Burden “The Scholarly Attorney” Jack’s mother Judge Montague M. Irwin Jim Madison Description Ch. Narrator and protagonist; Stark’s right-hand man “The Boss;” governor of state Former tax assessor who convinces Willie to run for governor and eventually becomes his lt. governor Willie’s wife; former school teacher 18 year old son of Starks Willie’s driver and bodyguard Willie’s secretary and mistress Friend of Willie whose son is in jail Runs soda fountain Owns The Crescent Cove Deputy sheriff; dies Attorney Senate candidate endorsed by Judge Irwin Senate candidate endorsed by Stark Jack’s current stepfather; the “Young Executive” Jack’s childhood friend; famous surgeon Jack’s childhood sweetheart; Adam’s sister Former governor; father of Anne and Adam Jack’s absent father who left Jack’s mother; now a missionary of sorts Raised in poverty; beautiful; marries four men Father-figure to Jack; friend of the Stantons and Burdens; former Attorney General Managing editor of Chronicle newspaper 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 15 Dolph Pillsbury J.H. Moore Jeffers Construction Mr. Sandeen Joe Harrison Sam MacMurfee Sen-Sen Puckett Hugh Miller Daddy Ross Chairman of county commissioners who opposes Willie on school house Bid on school house Low bid on school house 2 Father of boy killed in school house accident Former governor who uses Willie to split the vote Former two-term governor and Willie’s political rival Friend of Harrison’s; has affair with Sadie Willie’s Attorney General; quits after White scandal Jack’s first step-father 2 Jack’s second step-father Neighbors of Jack’s mother Woman Jack’s mother sets him up with Judges appointed by Willie 2 2 State auditor caught in scandal that leads to impeachment attempt Tax Lands Bureau administrator caught in scandal Chicago businessman Sugar Boy’s pals 2 One of MacMurfee’s boys Jack’s great-uncle Jack’s grandmother; Cass’s sister Cass’s brother; wealthy landowner Cass’s mistress Annabelle’s husband Gilbert’s neighbor; suggests Cass go to college; president of Confederacy Jefferson’s father Lavinia’s husband Annabelle’s slave who knows about affair and is therefore sold 3 4 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 “The Tycoon” Count Covelli Pattons Dumonde Armstrong and Talbott Byram B. White Hamill Josh Conklin Henry Harris and Al Perkins Lowdan Cass Mastern Lavinia Mastern Gilbert Mastern Annabelle Trice Duncan Trice Jefferson Davis Samuel Davis Willis Burden Phebe 2 2 2 3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 16 Mr. Robards and Mr. Simms Fielding L. Turner Caroline Turner Richard Albert Calloway Gummy Larson Cousin Mathilde Mabel Carruthers Le Moyne Carruthers Mr. Percy Poindexter Mr. Charles Pettis Wilbur Satterfield and Alex Cantor Mortimer Lonzo Littlepaugh Miss Lily Mae Littlepaugh Mrs. Dalzell Cavesse Jones Lois Seager Aunt Sophonisba Hubert Coffee Marvin Frey Sibyl Frey Dr. Bland Mrs. Daniell Mr. Pettus Billie Martin Thad Mellon Gup Lawson Slave traders 4 Wealthy lawyer from Lexington Fielding’s wife; from Boston; abused servants Abused servant who kills Caroline Kept Cass’s papers Wealthy businessman; MacMurfee supporter Anne’s cousin 4 Judge Irwin’s first wife 5 Mabel’s father 5 President of Seaboard bank Percy’s son-in-law 5 Officials of American Electric Power Co. 5 Lawyer for American Electric who commits suicide 5 Mortimer’s sister; clairvoyant Leads Jack to Miss Littlepaugh Involved in car wreck with Tom Jack’s ex-wife 5 Nanny 7 Gummy’s man who tries to bribe Adam Sibyl’s father Possibly impregnated by Tom Doctor at Burden’s Landing Judge Irwin’s neighbor Judge Irwin’s lawyer Tom’s football coach Substitute tackle on football team Regular guard on football 8 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 6 7 8 8 8 8 9 9 9 17 Jimmy Hardwich Axton Mr. Burnham Calvin Sperling Morrisey Dr. Simmons Katy Maynard Mrs. Sill Larkin Jo-Belle team 2nd string end Backup quarterback Special doctor brought in for Tom Commissioner of Agriculture Attorney General Fellow doctor and friend of Adam Old friend of Anne Sadie’s cousin Burdens’ cook 9 9 9 9 9 10 10 10 10 18 All the King’s Men –Bookmark: Main Characters Character Jack Burden Willie Stark Tiny Duffy Lucy Stark Tom Stark Sugar-Boy O’Sheean Sadie Burke Theodore Murrell Adam Stanton Anne Stanton Joel Stanton Ellis Burden “The Scholarly Attorney” Jack’s Mother Judge Montague M. Irwin Joe Harrison Sam MacMurfee Mr. Byram B. White Gummy Larson Mortimer Littlepaugh Miss Lily Mae Littlepaugh Lois Seager Hubert Coffee Marvin Frey Sibyl Frey Description Ch. Narrator and protagonist; Stark’s right-hand man “The Boss;” governor Former tax assessor; Willie’s lt. governor Willie’s wife; former school teacher 18 year old son of Starks Willie’s driver and bodyguard Willie’s secretary Jack’s current stepfather; the “Young Executive” Jack’s childhood friend; famous surgeon Jack’s childhood sweetheart; Adam’s sister Former governor; father of Anne and Adam Jack’s absent father who left Jack’s mother and is now a missionary Beautiful; raised in poverty; marries four men Father-figure to Jack; friend of the Stantons and Burdens; former Attorney General Former governor who uses Willie to split the vote Former governor and Willie’s political rival State auditor caught in scandal that leads to impeachment attempt Wealthy businessman; MacMurfee supporter Former lawyer for American Electric Mortimer’s sister; clairvoyant Jack’s ex-wife Gummy’s man; tries to bribe Adam Sibyl’s father Possibly impregnated by Tom 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 5 5 5 7 8 8 8 19 All the King’s Men Discussion Questions The following questions approach the novel from a number of different angles, i.e., how the novel functions as a work of art, how it reflects the time period, how it addresses fundamental questions of humanity, and how it engages the reader. A good discussion tends to start with our “heads” and end with our “hearts.” Therefore, you may want to save subjective opinions of taste until after you have discussed the more objective elements of the work’s merits. (It is tempting to begin with, “What did everyone think?” But if a number of people really didn’t like the novel, their opinions may derail a discussion of the novel’s merits). On the other hand, I recommend starting with a few accessible questions and asking every member to respond to ensure that all voices are present and heard from the beginning. Just a few suggestions! Enjoy… Warm up questions: 1)Reread the epigraph, a quote from Dante’s Divine Comedy: “Mentre che la speranza ha fior del verde” (As long as hope still has its bit of green). Now that you have finished the novel, what understanding do you have of this quote? Why do you think Warren chose this quote to be our first impression of his novel? What is hope’s bit of green at the end of the novel? 2) Thinking back, what were your first impressions of the novel? Had you read a summary or seen a movie version before beginning the actual novel? In what ways did the novel fulfill your expectations? In what ways did it disappoint? 3) Reread the first few sentences: “Mason City. To get there you follow Highway 58, going northeast out of the city, and it is a good highway and new. Or was new, that day we went up it. You look up the highway and it is straight for miles, coming at you, with the black line down the center coming at and at you, black and slick and tarry-shining against the white of the slab, and the heat dazzles up from the white slab so that only the black line is clear, coming at you with the whine of the tires, and if you don’t quit staring at that line and don’t take a few deep breaths and slap yourself hard on the back of the neck you’ll hypnotize yourself and you’ll come to just at the moment when the right front wheel hooks over into the black dirt shoulder off the slab, and you’ll try to jerk her back on but you can’t because the slab is high like a curb, and maybe you’ll try to reach to turn off the ignition just as she starts the dive. But you won’t make it, of course. Then a nigger chopping cotton a mile away, he’ll look up and see the little column of black smoke standing up above the vitriolic, arsenical green of the cotton rows, and up against the violent, metallic, throbbing blue of the sky, and he’ll say, ‘Lawd God, hit’s a-nudder one done done hit!’” 20 Many important elements that continue throughout the novel are present in this first paragraph – rich imagery, a definite sense of time and place, a feeling of speed and carelessness, a sense of “luck,” an awareness of mortality, a sense of foreshadowing and foreboding. What is the effect of beginning this novel with the juxtaposition of the jarring scenery, the sense of being out of control and the horrifying potential of violence? Why does Warren begin his novel by asking the reader to imagine his/her own death? With the use of “nigger” on the first page we are jarred into noticing the time and place of the setting. How did you react to the use of this word throughout the novel? 4) Soon after the above passage, we meet Jack Burden, our narrator: “That was the way it was the last time I saw Mason City, nearly three years ago, back in the summer of 1936. I was in the first car, the Cadillac, with the Boss and Mr. Duffy and the Boss’s wife and son and Sugar Boy.” (4) What were your first impressions of Jack and how did these impressions change? We are conditioned, as readers, to empathize with and “like” narrators, especially when they address us directly like Jack does. Did you “like” Jack? In what ways was he a credible narrator – and in what ways was he not? Notice his last name (Burden) – what where Jack’s burdens throughout the novel? He tells us his story in a circuitous manner, spiraling through the past and the present. How was this effective? 5) If the author is speaking through Jack, what do his values seem to be? If there is a “call to action” in this novel, what would it be? What aspects of human nature and politics does Warren seem to celebrate? What aspects does he criticize? 6) Throughout the novel, Jack struggles with how much responsibility people should feel for their actions. He discards his thesis on Mastern when he cannot understand Cass’s sense of guilt over Duncan’s death and Phebe’s fate. After he learns about Willie and Anne’s affair, he embraces what he describes as the “Great Twitch” theory: “The twitch was simply an independent phenomenon, unrelated to the face or to what was behind the face or to anything in the whole tissue of phenomena which is the world we are lost in… it occurred to me, as I reflected upon the thing which made him remarkable, that if the twitch was all, what was it that could know that the twitch was all? …And if I was all twitch how did the twitch which was me know that the twitch was all? Ah, I decided, that is the mystery That is the secret knowledge… the twitch can know that the twitch is all Then, having found that out, in the mystic vision, you feel clean and free. You are at one with the Great Twitch…” (473) Do you believe that Jack is responsible for his father’s death? Is Jane responsible for Adam’s death? Who is responsible for Willie’s death? Jack also believes “meaning is never in the event but in the motion through the event” (407) and considers himself an “Idealist”: “If you are an Idealist it does not matter what you do or 21 what goes on around you because it isn’t real anyway.” (45). What does being an Idealist mean to Jack? Do you agree? 7) Jack is scornful of his stepfather’s religion throughout most of the novel. He states: “For God and Nothing have a lot in common. You look either one of Them straight in the eye for a second and the immediate effect on the human constitution is always the same.” (150) “For Life is a fire burning along a piece of string – or is it a fuse to a powder keg which we call God? – and the string is what we don’t know, our Ignorance, and the trail of ash, which, if a gust of wind does not come, keeps the structure of the string, is History, man’s Knowledge, but it is dead, and when the fire has burned up all the string, then man’s Knowledge will be equal to God’s Knowledge and there won’t be any fire, which is Life. Or if the string leads to a powder keg, then there will be a terrific blast of fire, and even the trail of ash will be blown completely away…” (226) How would you describe Jack’s spirituality? What effect does Jack believe God / Nothingness has on humans? 8) Jack has a number of father-figures in his life, including Willie, and struggles with his identity throughout the novel. At one point Jack believes: “They say you are not you except in terms of relation to other people. If there weren’t any other people there wouldn’t be any you because what you do, which is what you are, only has meaning in relation to other people.” (192) Eventually he decides: “Perhaps the only answer, I thought then, was that by the time we understand the pattern we are in, the definition we are making for ourselves, it is too late to break out of the box. We can only live in terms of the definition…” (529) How does Jack define himself? Do you agree with either of the above theories? 9) Other than Sadie and Lucy, Jack struggles with his relationships with women: “I had loved Lois the machine, the way you love the filet mignon or the Georgia peach, but I definitely was not in love with Lois the person… But the paradox is that as long as Lois was merely the machine-Lois, as long as she was simply a welldressed animal, as long as she was really a part of innocent nonhuman nature, as long as I hadn’t begun to notice that the sounds she made were words, there was no harm in her and n o harm in the really extraordinary pleasure she could provide.” (457) 22 “It was always the same way when I came home and saw my mother. I would be surprised that it was the way it was but I knew at the same time that I had known it would be this way. I would come home with the firm conviction that she didn’t really care a thing about me, that I was just another man whom she wanted to have around because she was the kind of woman who had to have men around and had to make them dance to her tune…” (164) “There is nothing women love so much as the drunkard, the hellion, the roarer, the reprobate. They love him because they – women, I mean – are like the bees in Samson’s parable in the Bible: they like to build their honeycomb in the carcass of a dead lion.” (550) Is Jack misogynistic? 10) If the climax of any novel is the turning point of the action, which all major conflicts lead up to, what do you consider to be the climax of this novel? Who do you consider to be the protagonist of the novel: Jack or Willie? If "the story of Willie Stark and the story of Jack Burden are, in one sense, one story," then what is that story? 11) Revisit Jack’s first impressions of Willie Stark: “Willie is the fellow from the country with the Christmas tie… He is Cousin Willie from the country. He is Willie Stark, the teacher’s pet, and I met him in the back room of Slade’s… and he told me Lucy didn’t favor drinking.” (77) “He [Willie] became a martyr, not through ignorance, not only for the right but also for some knowledge of himself deeper than right or wrong… He knew something about human nature, but something now came between him and that knowledge…” (104) How does Willie change throughout the course of Jack’s acquaintance of him? Willie’s motto was My study is the heart of the people (9); what do you believe Willie discovered or believed about the heart of the people? 12) Robert Penn Warren stated: “Willie Stark was not Huey Long. Willie was only himself….” Would it affect your enjoyment of the novel if Willie was completely fictional? 13) Just before Adam agrees to head Willie’s hospital, Willie tells him: “Goodness. Yeah, just plain, simple goodness. Well you can’t inherit that from anybody. You got to make it, Doc. If you want it. And you got to make it out of badness. Badness. And you know why, Doc? …Because there isn’t anything else to make it out of.” 23 Adam answers: “If, as you say, there is only the bad to start with, and the good must be made from the bad, then how do you ever know what the good is? How do you even recognize the good?” Willie answers: “You just make it up as you go along.” (386-7) How did you react to this concept of “making up the good out of the bad as you go along”? What seems to be Willie’s motivation for staying in politics? Why does Adam agree to head the hospital? 14) In chapter one, Willie tells Jack that he has spent his life pouring swill: “And… by God, I’m still doing it. Pouring swill.” Later, Jack explains politics to his stepfather in the following passage: “… Politics is action and all action is but a flaw in the perfections of inaction, which is peace, just as all being is but a flaw in the perfection of nonbeing. Which is God. For if God is perfection and the only perfection is in nonbeing, then God is nonbeing. Then God is nothing. Nothing can give no basis for the criticism of Thing in its thingness…” (303) Why do people feel so strongly about politics? How do you define “politics”? 15) At the very end of the novel, Lucy tells Jack, “He [Willie] was a great man… You see, Jack… I have to believe that.” (643) In what ways is Willie a “great man”? 16) Jim considers Willie’s greatness in the following passage: “…it is possible that fellows like Willie Stark are born outside of luck, good or bad, and luck, which is what about makes you and me what we are, doesn’t have anything to do with them, for they are what they are from the time they first kick in the womb until the end. And if that is the case, then their life history is a process of discovering what they really are, and not, as for you and me, sons of luck, a process of becoming what luck makes us.” (94) Do you agree that Willie was simply following his destiny? 17) Beyond Adam’s gun, what is Willie’s death caused by? Arrogance? Naïveté? Lust? Tiny’s treachery? Adam’s principles? 24 18) In many respects, Jack and Adam are foils. “…what we students of history always learn is that the human being is a very complicated contraption and that they are not good or bad but are good and bad and the good comes out of bad and the bad out of good, and the devil take the hindmost. But Adam, he is a scientist, and everything is tidy for him, and one molecule of oxygen always behaves the same way when it gets around two molecules of hydrogen… All tidy. All neat. The molecule of good always behaves the same way…” (373) At the end, Jack states “As a student of history, Jack Burden could see that Adam Stanton, whom he came to call the man of idea, and Willie Stark, whom he came to call the man of fact, were doomed to destroy each other, just as each was doomed to try to use the other and to yearn toward and try to become the other, because each was incomplete with the terrible division of their age.”(656) Do you agree with this conclusion? 19) Was it believable that Anne would have an affair with Willie? Why does this affair prompt Adam to kill Willie? Was it believable that Jack and Anne would marry at the end? Why don’t they marry initially? How would each have been different if they had married young? 20) After Jack inherits the Judge’s money he states “…that particular money, which would have made [leaving] possible, was at the same time, paradoxically enough, a bond that held me here [with Willie].” (541). Why does he believe his inheritance ties him to Willie? 21) At the end, Jack believes the Judge’s death saves his mother’s soul: “So I went back down and stood in the garden among the black magnolia trees and the myrtles, and thought how by killing my father I had saved my mother’s soul. Then I thought how maybe I had saved my father’s soul, too. Both of them had found out what they needed to know to be saved. Then I ghouth how all knowledge that is worth anything is maybe paid for by blood” (647). Why does he believe this and do you agree? Wrap up Questions! 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Would you recommend the book to others? (Why/not) If you could change anything, what would it be? Would you read a sequel of this novel (about Jack and Anne’s life)? Should this novel be taught in political science or literature courses? Does it seem to deserve the Pulitzer Prize? 25 All the King’s Men -- Review From the New York Times: All the King's Men By ORVILLE PRESCOTT Books of the Times he summer fiction doldrums are over. An exciting new novel is published today. It isn't a great novel or a completely finished work of art. It is as bumpy and uneven as a corduroy road, somewhat irresolute and confused in its approach to vital problems and not always convincing. Nevertheless, Robert Penn Warren's "All the King's Men" is magnificently vital reading, a book so charged with dramatic tension it almost crackles with blue sparks, a book so drenched with fierce emotion, narrative pace and poetic imagery that its stature as a "readin' book," as some of its characters would call it, dwarfs that of most current publications. Here, my lords and ladies, is no book to curl up with in a hammock, but a book to read until 3 o'clock in the morning, a book to read on trains and subways, while waiting for street cars and appointments, while riding elevators or elephants… This review was published the year the novel was published. How would today’s reviewers treat it? Do you agree with the above review? Did you find the novel to be a “page turner”? 26 All the King’s Men – Films A couple of film versions have been made of All the King’s Men, including an Academy award-winning version from 1949 and a Hollywood version from 2006. Your group could watch a version of the movie together and discuss your impressions, or group members could watch a version before the meeting and then discuss impressions as a group. Time permitting, both versions could be viewed and then compared. Here are a few possible movie questions: While viewing the movie, which characters were most unlike how you pictured them while reading the novel? Which characters seemed “right on” in their portrayal? What plot elements were left out or changed in the movie? How was your enjoyment affected by what was left out/changed? Was the film able to recreate Warren’s tone and Jack’s sense of irony? The 1949 version, starring Judi Densch, Rufus Sewell, and Juliet Aubrey won Best Picture, Best Actor and Best Supporting Actress. If you viewed this version, did these awards seemed well earned? More information on the film(s): Here is a list of movie versions: 1949 version: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0041113/ 2006 version: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0405676/ 27 All the King’s Men – Further reading! If you enjoyed learning about history through fiction, consider checking out: Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck From Amazon.com: When The Grapes of Wrath was published in 1939, America, still recovering from the Great Depression, came face to face with itself in a startling, lyrical way. John Steinbeck gathered the country's recent shames and devastations--the Hoovervilles, the desperate, dirty children, the dissolution of kin, the oppressive labor conditions--in the Joad family. Then he set them down on a westward-running road, local dialect and all, for the world to acknowledge. For this marvel of observation and perception, he won the Pulitzer in 1940. The prize must have come, at least in part, because alongside the poverty and dispossession, Steinbeck chronicled the Joads' refusal, even inability, to let go of their faltering but unmistakable hold on human dignity. Witnessing their degeneration from Oklahoma farmers to a diminished band of migrant workers is nothing short of crushing. The Joads lose family members to death and cowardice as they go, and are challenged by everything from weather to the authorities to the California locals themselves. As Tom Joad puts it: "They're aworkin' away at our spirits. They're a tryin' to make us cringe an' crawl like a whipped bitch. They tryin' to break us. Why, Jesus Christ, Ma, they comes a time when the on'y way a fella can keep his decency is by takin' a sock at a cop. They're workin' on our decency." The point, though, is that decency remains intact, if somewhat battle-scarred, and this, as much as the depression and the plight of the "Okies," is a part of American history. Book Club Kit Available! 28 29