LESSON 6 Suggested solutions Question 1 (30 marks) Multiple choice (1 mark each) a. 3) Although 1 and 2 are important parts of an internal control system for cash, the segregation of the duties of cash handling from cash accounting is the most important internal control over cash. b. 3) The cash held in the sinking fund is not available for current use. Therefore, it would be recorded as a non-current asset on the balance sheet. Note that while petty cash normally has its own G/L account, it would usually be part of cash reported on the balance sheet. c. 4) The direct write-off method of accounting for bad debts expense violates the matching principle because the expense is recorded in the period when the account is written off, which may not be in the period the related sale was made. d. 2) Both assignment of accounts receivable and factoring of accounts receivable mean that accounts receivable are converted to cash prior to their normal collection time. e. 1) When accounts receivable are sold to a factor without recourse it means that the factor is responsible for any uncollectible accounts. f. 2) The cost of the first computer will be €4,000. Since the note payable carries the market rate of interest, no discounting is required. To get the cost of the second computer, the cash payments must be discounted at 8%. The only cash payment is the payment of €4,320 at the end of one year. The present value factor for a single sum to be paid at the end of one period, discounted at 8% is 0.9259. €4,320 0.9259 = €4,000. g. 3) The fact that the maker of the note is experiencing financial difficulty does not necessarily mean that payment won’t be made as scheduled. When the payee determines it is probable that the recoverable value of the note is less than its carrying value, impairment has occurred. Financial Accounting: Assets Suggested solutions 6 1 h. 2) The bank account and the petty cash fund are two separate cash accounts and should be added together to get the total cash to be reported on the balance sheet. i. 4) The bank balance is too low compared to the cash general ledger balance because of deposits in transit. Therefore, deposits in transit need to be added to the balance per bank. j. 3) The bank reconciliation is designed to reconcile both the unadjusted cash balance per the books and the unadjusted cash balance per the bank to the correct cash balance that should be reported on the balance sheet. (2 marks each) k. 3) €40,000 + €20,000 – €4,000 Or, you might notice that both reconciling items are adjustments to the bank balance. That means the general ledger balance for cash is the correct final balance. l. 2) €164 + €34 = €198 This means that cash is short by €2. Since there is only €34 of cash left, €166 of cash must be added to the petty cash box. m. 2) €97,850 + €10,000 – €13,000 n. 3) €1,840 + €36,750 – €36,200 o. 3) €1,000 – €200 p. 1) X + €3,800 + €160 – €3,000 = €2,500 X = €2,500 – €3,800 – €160 + €3,000 q. 2) €800,000 – €62,500 r. 4) €40,000 – €3,400 Financial Accounting: Assets Suggested solutions 6 2 s. 1) €30,000 + (€30,000 4.3553) 4.3553 is the present value factor for a six-period annuity at a discount rate of 10%. t. 4) You could calculate the carrying value at December 31, year 2 (€120,000) and compare it with the recoverable amount. However, since annual interest payments are expected to be made each year to maturity, and the stated interest rate is equal to the market rate of interest, it should be obvious that the present value of the future payments is still equal to €120,000. If you are not sure, calculate it! Question 2 (6 marks) Requirement 1 (3 marks) Factoring without recourse means that when Desperado sells its receivables to the factor, it is the factor that assumes the risk for any accounts receivable that cannot be collected in the future. If the factor is unable to collect certain accounts receivable, it has no recourse to Desperado. Factoring with recourse means that when Desperado sells it receivables to the factor, it is Desperado who retains some (or all) of the risk of uncollectible accounts. If the factor is unable to collect a particular receivable, it has the right to come back to Desperado for payment of that amount. Desperado will likely get more cash if it sells its accounts receivables on a with recourse basis. Since the risk of non-payment remains with Desperado under a with recourse agreement, the factor will be willing to pay more. Requirement 2 (3 marks) When receivables are sold without recourse, the transaction is normally recorded as a sale. The accounts receivable are removed from the books of Desperado and an expense equal to the difference between the price paid by the factor and the book value of the receivables is recognized. When receivables are sold with recourse, the funds received from the factor are normally recorded as a loan from the factor rather than as sales proceeds. This is because there really has not been a transfer of risk from the seller to the factor. As the customers make payments and funds are collected by the factor, the loan is reduced. Question 3 (14 marks) Requirement 1 (4 marks) Deposits in transit, November 30 Plus Deposits made by Rutnip in December (€11,820 – €90 error correction) Deposits that could have been received by bank in December Deposits actually recorded by bank in December Deposits in transit at December 31 (deposit recorded by the company but not yet recorded by the bank) Financial Accounting: Assets € 3,080 11,730 14,810 10,000 € 4,810 Suggested solutions 6 3 € 4,000 6,400 10,400 8,200 Outstanding cheques, November 30 Plus cheques written by Rutnip in December Cheques that could have cleared bank in December Cheques actually cleared by bank in December Outstanding cheques at December 31 (cheques written by the company but not yet recorded by the bank) € 2,200 Requirement 2 (5 marks) RUTNIP INC. Bank Reconciliation December 31, 20X5 Cash balance per books, December 31, 20X5 Add: Note receivable collected by bank Deduct: NSF cheque December bank charge December interest on bank loan Error correction on deposit (€320 – €230) Adjusted cash balance per books, December 31 € 18,770 1,800 € 270 30 470 90 (860) € 19,710 € 17,100 Cash balance per bank statement, December 31, 20X5 Add: Deposits in transit (from Requirement 1) Deduct: Outstanding cheques (from Requirement 1) Adjusted cash balance per bank statement, December 31 4,810 (2,200) € 19,710 Requirement 3 (5 marks) Journal entries from bank reconciliation: a. Cash ................................................................................ 1,800 Notes receivable......................................................... 1,800 To record collection of note receivable made by bank on behalf of Rutnip. b. Accounts receivable, Smythe........................................... 270 Cash ........................................................................... 270 To re-establish the account receivable from Smythe since their cheque was no good. c. Bank service charge expense ........................................... Cash ........................................................................... To record the monthly bank charge. 30 d. Interest expense ............................................................... Cash ........................................................................... To record monthly interest on bank loan. 470 Financial Accounting: Assets 30 470 Suggested solutions 6 4 e. Accounts receivable ......................................................... 90 Cash ........................................................................... 90 To correct error on cash deposit originally recorded as €320, which should have been €230. Question 4 (20 marks) Requirement 1 (4 marks) Allowance for doubtful accounts ........................................... 2,400 Accounts receivable ......................................................... 2,400 There is no effect on total current assets as a result of the accounts receivable write off entry because both accounts receivable and the related contra account are reduced by the same amount. Requirement 2 (4 marks) Accounts receivable ............................................................... 5,000 Allowance for doubtful accounts ..................................... To re-establish the account receivable that was previously written off. 5,000 Note: the collection of this €5,000 is included in the €210,000 of customer payments for the year. Requirement 3 (4 marks) The balance in the accounts receivable account at December 31, 20X6, before the recording of the 20X6 bad debt expense is €194,600 as derived below: Bal. January 1 Sales on account Accounts receivable 162,000 Cash collected 240,000 AR written off Re-establish AR previously written off Bal. December 31 210,000 2,400 5,000 194,600 The balance in the Allowance for doubtful accounts at December 31, 20X6 before the recording of the 20X6 bad debt expense is €6,000 as derived below: Allowance for doubtful accounts AR written off 2,400 Bal. January 1 Reestablish AR previously written off Bal. Dec. 31 Financial Accounting: Assets 3,400 5,000 6,000 Suggested solutions 6 5 Requirement 4 (4 marks) a. To calculate bad debt expense based on the credit sales method, the expected uncollectible rate of 2% is applied to the credit sales for the period of €240,000. 2% of €240,000 = €4,800 The journal entry would be Bad debt expense ............................................................. 4,800 Allowance for doubtful accounts ............................... 4,800 b. To calculate bad debt expense based on the accounts receivable method, the required allowance at December 31, 20X6 (€5,400) is compared to the balance in the Allowance for doubtful accounts prior to the adjustment for bad debts (€6,000) and an entry is made to adjust to the required amount (€5,400 – €6,000 = (€600)). The journal entry would be Allowance for doubtful accounts ..................................... Bad debt expense ....................................................... 600 600 The reason for the negative bad debt expense is that there must have been an overestimation of the expense in prior periods. Requirement 5 (4 marks) Credit sales method Current assets Accounts receivable Less: Allowance for doubtful accounts Accounts receivable method € 194,600 € 194,600 (1) 10,800 € 183,800 (2) 5,400 € 189,200 (1) €6,000 + €4,800 (2) €6,000 – €600 Question 5 (10 marks) Requirement 1 (4 marks) The present value of the €750,000 non-interest bearing note would be €250,000 2.48691 = €621,725 1 The present value factor of an annuity for three periods at 10% (Table 2, Appendix A Lesson 5) Therefore, the €750,000 face value note would be recorded as Face value of note Less: Discount on note receivable Present value of note receivable Financial Accounting: Assets € 750,000 128,275 € 621,275 Suggested solutions 6 6 The entry to record the sale of the equipment by XTL on January 1, 20X5 would be Cash ...................................................................................... 250,000 Note receivable ...................................................................... 750,000 Discount on notes receivable ........................................... 128,725 Equipment ........................................................................ 600,000 Gain on sale of equipment ............................................... 271,275 Requirement 2 (2 marks) The entries to record the interest revenue and the first repayment of the note at December 31, 20X6 would be as follows: Discount on notes receivable ................................................. Interest revenue ................................................................ 1 (€750,000 – €128,725) 0.10 62,1271 62,127 Cash ...................................................................................... 250,000 Notes receivable............................................................... 250,000 Requirement 3 (4 marks) At December 31, 20X6, it is necessary to compare the carrying value of the note receivable to its recoverable amount to determine if there is an impairment that requires a write-down. Carrying value of note receivable at December 31, 20X6 Present value of €500,000 to be received in three years Amount of impairment 1 2 € 433,8521 375,6502 € 58,202 €500,000 – (€128,275 – €62,127) €500,000 0.7513 (the present value of a single sum to be received in three years, discounted at 10%) Note: there would be no recognition of interest revenue in 20X6 because of the impairment of the loan. Once a loan becomes impaired, accrual of interest ceases. If interest had been accrued to December 31, 20X6, it would just make the amount of the write-off larger, to offset the interest that had been accrued. The entry to record the impairment of the loan would be Charge for loan impairment ................................................... Allowance for loan impairment ....................................... Financial Accounting: Assets 58,202 52,202 Suggested solutions 6 7 Question 6 (20 marks) Requirement 1 (12 marks) The present value of the three year, 4%, €240,000 note payable would be Present value of €240,000 to be received in three years, discounted at 8% is Present value of €9,600 annuity for three years, discounted at 8% €240,000 0.7938 € 190,512 €9,600 2.5771 24,740 € 215,252 The journal entries to record the purchase of the land and the subsequent interest expense and principal repayment would be as follows: January 1, 20X5 Land ...................................................................................... 215,252 Discount on notes payable ..................................................... 24,748 Notes payable................................................................... To record purchase of land and issuance of note payable. 240,000 December 31, 20X5 Interest expense ..................................................................... 17,2201 Discount on notes payable ............................................... 7,6203 Cash ................................................................................. 9,6002 To record annual interest payment, interest expense, and amortization of discount on notes payable. 1 2 3 €215,252 0.08 €240,000 0.04 €17,220 – €9,600 December 31, 20X6 Interest expense ..................................................................... 17,8301 Discount on notes payable ............................................... 8,2303 Cash ................................................................................. 9,6002 To record annual interest payment, interest expense, and amortization of discount on notes payable. 1 2 3 (€215,252 + €7,620) 0.08 €240,000 0.04 €17,830 – €9,600 Financial Accounting: Assets Suggested solutions 6 8 December 31, 20X7 Interest expense ..................................................................... 18,4881 Discount on notes payable ............................................... 8,8883 Cash ................................................................................. 9,6002 To record annual interest payment, interest expense, and amortization of discount on notes payable. 1 2 3 (€215,252 + €7,620 + €8,230) 0.08 €240,000 0.04 €18,488 – €9,600 Note that, due to rounding, there is still a €10 balance (€24,748 – €7,620 – €8,230 – €8,888) in the Discount on notes payable account. To get rid of this balance, we make the following entry: Interest expense ..................................................................... Discount on notes payable ............................................... To bring balance in Discount account to zero. 10 10 December 31, 20X7 Notes payable......................................................................... 240,000 Cash ................................................................................. To record repayment of principal amount of note payable. 240,000 Requirement 2 (8 marks) The present value of the two-year, non-interest bearing €14,000 note receivable would be Present value of €140,000 to be received in two years, discounted at 8% is €14,000 0.8573 € 12,002 The journal entries to record the sale of the goods, the recognition of interest revenue and the subsequent collection of the note receivable would be as follows: January 1, 20X5 Note receivable ...................................................................... Discount on notes receivable ........................................... Sales ................................................................................ To record sale of goods. 14,000 1,998 12,002 December 31, 20X5 Discount on notes receivable ................................................. 9611 Interest revenue ................................................................ 961 To record interest revenue and amortization of discount on note receivable. 1 €12,002 0.08 December 31, 20X6 Financial Accounting: Assets Suggested solutions 6 9 Discount on notes receivable ................................................. 1,0371 Cash ....................................................................................... 14,000 Notes receivable............................................................... 14,000 Interest revenue ................................................................ 1,037 To record interest revenue and amortization of discount on note receivable and collection of note receivable. 1 [(€12,002 + €961) 0.08] 100 Financial Accounting: Assets Suggested solutions 6 10