CFAspace Provided by APF Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 CFA Level I FIXED INCOME: Yield Measures, Spot Rates and Forward Rates Lecturer: Nan Chen Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 1. Sources of Return Source 1 Periodic coupon interest payments; Source 2 Recovery of principal, along with any capital gain or loss Source 3 Reinvestment income Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.1 Current Yield *Current yield=Annual Cash Coupon Payment/Bond Price *EX1: Consider a 10-year, $1000 par value, 6% coupon, semiannual-pay bond that is currently trading at $894.5. Calculate the current yield. Annual cash coupon payment = 1000 * 6%= 60 current yield = 60/894.5=6.71% For an annual-pay bond and a semiannual-pay bond with the same coupon rate and price, they have the same current yield. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.2 Yield to Maturity (YTM) Semiannual-pay Coupon Bond *YTM: an annualized internal rate of return, based on a bond’s price and its promised cash flows. *Bond Price C C C Par ... YTM YTM 2 YTM 2 N 1 (1 ) (1 ) 2 2 2 C=Semiannual coupon payment; 2N=Number of semiannual periods. *EX2: Consider a 10-year, $1000 par value, 6% coupon semiannualpay bond that is currently trading at $894.5. Calculate the YTM. -894.5 [PV] [FV] [N] 30 [PMT] [CPT] [1/Y] 得到3.76 30 30 1000 30 $894.5 ... 1000 YTM YTM 2 YTM 210 (1 ) (1 ) 1 20 2 2 2 Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 YTM=1/Y ×2=7.52 Copyright © CFAspace.com Bond Equivalent Yield and Annual Pay Yield EX3: The yield of a 3-year bond issue quoted on an annual-pay basis is 84%. The yield-to-maturity on a bond-equivalent basis is closest to: A. 3.85% B. 7.69% C. 7.84% (1+bond-equivalent yield/2) 2 =1+annual-pay yield In this case, (1+bond-equivalent yield/2) 2 =1+0.0784 Therefore, bond-equivalent yield=7.69% B is the correct answer. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.2 Yield to Maturity (YTM) Annual-pay Coupon Bond EX4: Consider a 10-year, $1000 par value, 6% coupon annual-pay bond that is currently trading at $894.5. Calculate the YTM. -894.5 [PV] 1000 [FV] 10 [N] 60 [PMT] [CPT] [1/Y] 得到7.54 Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 YTM=1/Y =7.54 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.2 Yield to Maturity (YTM) *Coupon Rate and YTM Trade at par Coupon Rate= YTM Trade at premium Coupon Rate> YTM Trade at discount Coupon Rate < YTM *Coupon Rate, Current Yield and YTM Bond selling at par Coupon Rate =Current Yield= YTM Bond selling at premium Coupon Rate >Current Yield >YTM Bond selling at discount Coupon Rate <Current Yield <YTM Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.3 Yield to Call (YTC) *YTC: used to calculate the yield on callable bonds that are selling at a premium to par. In this case, YTC < YTM ; call price < current market price *Bond Price C C C Call Pr ice ... YTC YTC 2 YTC 2YearstoCallDate 1 (1 ) (1 ) 2 2 2 YTC YTM [FV] Call Price Par Value [N] Number of Periods to Call Date Number of Periods to Maturity *EX5:A semiannual-pay bond is callable in five years at $106. The bond has an 8% upon and 15 years to maturity. If the bond is currently trading at $98 today, the yield call is closest to: Time to call is 5 years and semi-annual pay=> number of periods till call date N=10, A. 8.22% Call Price = $106 => FV=106, B. 8.49% 8% coupon and semi-annual pay=> PMT=4, C. 9.48% PV=-98 CPT -> 1/Y=4.7386 YTC=4.7386*2=9.48 Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.3 Yield to Call (YTC) Yield to Par Call Yield to Par Call YTM [FV] Par Value (call at par value) Par Value [N] Number of Periods to Par Call Date Number of Periods to Maturity Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Yield to Worst (YTW) *YTW: the lowest yield of any that are possible given the call provisions of the bond. *EX6: A 10% annual coupon bond with 3 years to maturity is currently trading at $1,010. The bond is callable in one year at a call price of $1,008 and in two years at a call price of $1,005. The bond’s yield to worst most likely occurs when the bond is: A. held until maturity in 3 years. B. called in year 1. C. called in year 2. The yield to worst for a callable bond is the lowest of the YTCs for each possible call date and YTM YTC if the bond is called in 1 year is 10.45%, because 1,005=(100+1,010)/1.1045 YTC if the bond is called in 2 years is 10.09% , because 1,005=100/1.1009+(100+1,008)/1.10092 YTM of the bond is 9.80%, because 1,005=100/1.0980+100/1.0980 2+(100+1,000)/1.09803 => YTW=the lowest yield of the three = YTM =9.80% Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.4 Yield to Put (YTP) YTP YTM [FV] Put Price Par Value [N] Number of Periods to Put Date Number of Periods to Maturity Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.5 Yield to Refunding Yield to Refunding: refers to a specific situation where a bond is currently callable but not refundable. Yield to Refunding YTM [FV] Call Price Par Value [N] Number of Periods till refund protection ends Number of Periods to Maturity Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 2.6 Cash Flow Yield (CFY) *CFY: the IRR that will make the present value of projected cash flows equal to the market price of the security. *Calculated for mortgage-backed securities and asset-backed securities CF1 CF 2 CFn ... SecurityMarket Pr ice 2 1 CFY (1 CFY ) (1 CFY ) N *Convert a Monthly CFY to a Bond Equivalent CFY: Bond Equivalent CFY= 2 × Semiannual Yield= 2 ×[(1+monthly CFY)6-1]] Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Limitations of Traditional Yield Measures Yield Measures Limitations Current Yield Considers only coupon payment; does not consider capital gains/losses or reinvestment income. YTM Assumes: 1). Reinvestment rate= YTM Cash flows of each period are reinvested at YTM Cash flows of each period are discounted at the same rate of YTM Yield curve is flat 2). The bond will be held until maturity YTC, YTP, YTRefunding, CFY Similar measure to YTM; Same issue as YTM except that the bond will be held until maturity. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Limitations of Traditional Yield Measures EX7: Elaine Wong has purchased an 8% coupon bond for $1,034.88 ith 3 years to maturity. At what rate must the coupon payments be einvested to produce a 5% yield-to-maturity rate? A. 8% B. 6.5% C. 5% C is the correct answer. Yield-to-maturity measure assumes that the oupon payments can be reinvested at YTM. In this case, it’s 5%. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 3.1 Reinvestment Income *Reinvestment Rate, YTM and Realized Yield: When: Reinvestment Rate< YTM Reinvestment rate<Realized Yield < YTM Reinvestment Rate> YTM Reinvestment rate>Realized Yield > YTM Realized yield is always between YTM and reinvestment rate. *Required Reinvestment Income to achieve the target yield: EX8:To provide an investor with a compound return of 6.5% on a semiannual basis, how much reinvestment income must be generated for a bond with 6% coupon, 10- year Treasury bond purchased at $96? -To achieve the 6% return, the total value that must be generated 10 years (20 semiannual periods) from now=96×(1+6.5%/2)20=$182.00 -20 coupon payments of $3 each: $3 ×20=$60 -Payment of $100 of principal at maturity The required reinvestment income to achieve the target yield= 182.00-60-100=$22 Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 3.2 Reinvestment Risk *Reinvestment Risk: the possibility that cash flows prior to stated maturity will be reinvested at a lower yield than pre-specified yield. *Factors that contribute to a higher reinvestment risk: Characteristic Reinvestment Risk Higher coupon rate Higher Longer maturities Higher Has a call feature Higher An amortizing security Higher Contains a prepayment option Higher Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 3.2 Reinvestment Risk EX9: Consider the three bonds in the following table. Which of the three bonds is most likely to have the greatest reinvestment risk? Bond YTM Time to Maturity Current Price A 8% 15 $980 B 8% 15 $1,000 C 8% 15 $1,098 A. Bond A B. Bond B C. Bond C Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve *Spot Rate: the yield of a default-free zero-coupon bond. *Treasury securities are considered default-free. => YTM of treasury securities of different maturities are spot rates. *The US government issues zero-coupon bonds at maturities under 1 year. => We need to calculate the spot rates for periods longer than 1 year. => Spot rates calculated by ourselves are theoretical spot rates. *Bootstrapping: we will solve for the spot rates by knowing the prices of the coupon bonds. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Bootstrapping Annual-pay Bond Prices and Yield of Two Annual-pay Bonds Maturity Coupon Yield Price 1 year 3% 3% $1,000 2 years 4% 4% $1,000 =>2-year spot rate = 4.019% Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Bootstrapping Semiannual-Pay Bond Prices and Yields of Two Semiannual-pay Bonds Maturity Coupon Yield Price 6 months 5% 5% $100 1 year 6% 6% $100 =>1-year Bond Equivalent spot rate S1.0= 2×0.030076=6.0152% Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve EX10: Tina Mo, a fixed income analyst, is asked to value a single, default-free cash flow of $60,000. She is given the information in the following table: Period Years Annual Par Yield to Maturity BEY Theoretical Spot Rate BEY 6‐month Forward Rates BEY 1 0.5 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2 1.0 2.40 % 2.40% 2.71% 3 1.5 2.70% 2.71% 3.12% 4 2.0 3.20% 3.23% 4.55% The value of this single cash flow at the end of Period 4 is closest to: A. $56,427 B. $56,309 C. $56,276 The theoretical spot rate for Treasury securities represent the appropriate set of interest rates that should be used to value single, default-free cash flows. Therefore, the current value of the$60,000 at the end of Period 4 should be discounted at the Period 4 spot rate= $60,000/(1+0.0323/2)4=$56,276 Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 5.1 Nominal Spread *Nominal Spread = YTM of an issue - YTM of a treasury security of similar maturity *Nominal Spread ignores the shape of the spot yield curve. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 5.2 Zero-volatility Spread Maturity Coupon Nominal Spread The equal amount added to the Treasury YTM that produces a bond value equal to the market price of the bond Z-Spread The equal amount added to each rate on the Treasury spot yield curve that makes the PV of a risky bond’s cash flows equal to its market price EX11:Consider a 3-year, 9% annual coupon corporate bond trading at $89.464. 1-, 2-, 3- year spot rates on Treasuries are 4%, 8.167%, and 12.377%. Compute the zero-volatility spread of the corporate bond. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 5.2 Zero-volatility Spread EX12:The zero-volatility spread is a measure of the spread off: A. one point on the Treasury yield curve. B. all points on the Treasury yield curve. C. all points on the Treasury spot curve. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Nominal Spread an Z-Spread Three factors that influence the difference between nominal spread and Z-spread: * The steeper the benchmark spot rate curve, the greater the difference between the two spread measures. A flat spot yield curve Z-Spread = Nominal Spread An upward sloping spot yield curve Z- Spread > Nominal Spread A downward sloping spot yield curve Z- Spread < Nominal Spread * The earlier the bond principal is paid, the greater the difference between the two spread measures. An upward sloping spot yield curve The difference between the two spread measures is greater for an amortizing security than for a bullet security. * The longer the maturity, the greater the difference between the two spread measures. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Nominal Spread an Z-Spread EX13: The difference between Z-spread and nominal spread will most likely be the most significant for a: A. Treasury security with short maturity in a flat yield curve environment B. zero coupon Treasury security. C. mortgage-backed security in a steep upward-sloping yield curve environment The difference between the two spread measures grows with the maturity of the security. => A is incorrect. The difference between the two spread measures is greater for issues in which the principal is repaid over time rather than only at maturity. =>B is incorrect and C is the correct answer. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 5.3. Option-adjusted Spread(OAS) *OAS is used when a bond has embedded options. *OAS takes the option yield component out of the Z-spread measure. OAS= Z-spread - option cost in percent For callable bonds and MBS, option cost >0, OAS < Z-spread For putable bonds, option cost <0, OAS > Z-spread *OAS is the spread for non-option characteristics like credit risk, liquidity risk and interest rate risk. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 5.3. Option-adjusted Spread(OAS) EX14: Which of the following statement is correct about the option adjusted spread ( OAS ): A. OAS is Z-Spread minus the option cost. B. OAS is the value of the embedded option. C. OAS is Z-spread plus the option cost. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 6.1 Relationship between Forward Rates and Spot Rates Measure: Definition Forward Rate The borrowing/lending rate of a loan to be made at some future date. Spot Rate The borrowing/lending rate of a loan to be made today. 1f2: the one-year forward rate, two years from now. 2-year bond (today): S2 1-year bond (today): S1=1f0 (1+S2)=(1+0f1)(1+1f1) 1-year bond (one year from today): 1f1 forward rate => spot rate spot rate Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 => forward rate Copyright © CFAspace.com 6.1 Relationship between Forward Rates and Spot Rates EX15: Using the BEY (bond-equivalent yield) spot rates for U.S. Treasury yields provided in the following table, the 6-month forward rate one year from now on a bond-equivalent yield basis is closest to: Period Years Spot Rate 1 0.5 1.40% 2 1.0 2.30 % 3 1.5 3.00% 4 2.0 3.50% A. 4.41% B. 2.20% C. 2.30% Answer: xfy represents x-period forward rate y periods from now; Z x+y represents (x+y)-period spot rate; Z y represents y-period spot rate. We have (1+Z x+y)x+y=(1+Zy)y (1+xfy)x 6-month forward rate one year from now in this case is 1 period forward rate 2 periods from now. All spot rates are given on a BEY basis and must be divided by 2 in the calculation: (1+0.03/2)3= (1+0.023/2)2 (1+1f 2)1 1f 2=0.022038 On a BEY basis, the forward rate is 0.022038*2=4.41% Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com 6.2 Valuing a Bond using Forward Rates EX16: The current 1-year rate is 4%, the 1-year forward rate for lending from time=1 to time=2 is 1f1=5%, and the 1-year forward rate for lending from time=2 to time=3 is 1f2=6%. Value a 3- year annual-pay bond with a 5% coupon and a par value of $1,000. Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com Framework Coupon Interest Payments 1. Sources of Return Capital Gains or Losses Reinvestment Income Current Yield Yield to Maturity 2. Traditional Yield Measures Yield to Call Yield to Put Yield to Refunding Cash Flow Yield 3. Reinvestment Income and Reinvestment Risk 4. Theoretical Spot Rate Curve 5. Nominal Spread, Z-Spread, and Option-adjusted Spread 6. Spot Rates, Forward Rates and Value of Bonds Academy of Professional Finance 专业金融学院 Copyright © CFAspace.com