Based on part of the GeotechniCAL reference package by Prof. John Atkinson, City University, London http://environment.uwe.ac.uk/geocal/quiz_frame.htm Soil description and classification Soils consist of grains (mineral grains, rock fragments, etc.) with water and air in the voids between grains. The water and air contents are readily changed by changes in conditions and location: soils can be perfectly dry (have no water content) or be fully saturated (have no air content) or be partly saturated (with both air and water present). Although the size and shape of the solid (granular) content rarely changes at a given point, they can vary considerably from point to point. First of all, consider soil as a engineering material - it is not a coherent solid material like steel and concrete, but is a particulate material. It is important to understand the significance of particle size, shape and composition, and of a soil's internal structure or fabric. Soil as an engineering material The term "soil" means different things to different people: To a geologist it represents the products of past surface processes. To a pedologist it represents currently occurring physical and chemical processes. To an engineer it is a material that can be: built on: foundations to buildings, bridges. built in: tunnels, culverts, basements. built with: roads, runways, embankments, dams. supported: retaining walls, quays. Soils may be described in different ways by different people for their different purposes. Engineers' descriptions give engineering terms that will convey some sense of a soil's current state and probable susceptibility to future changes (e.g. in loading, drainage, structure, surface level). Engineers are primarily interested in a soil's mechanical properties: strength, stiffness, permeability. These depend primarily on the nature of the soil grains, the current stress, the water content and unit weight. Size range of grains The range of particle sizes encountered in soil is very large: from boulders with a controlling dimension of over 200mm down to clay particles less th in size which behave as colloids, i.e. do not settle in water due solely to gravity. In theBritish Soil Classification System, soils are classified into named Basic Soil Type groups according to size, and the groups further divided into coarse, medium and fine sub-groups: Very coarse BOULDERS soils COBBLES Coarse soils 60 - 200 mm coarse 20 - 60 mm G medium 6 - 20 mm GRAVEL fine 2 - 6 mm coarse S SAND Fine soils > 200 mm M SILT 0.6 - 2.0 mm medium 0.2 - 0.6 mm fine 0.06 - 0.2 mm coarse 0.02 - 0.06 mm medium 0.006 - 0.02 mm fine C CLAY 0.002 - 0.006 mm < 0.002 mm Aids to size identification Soils possess a number of physical characteristics which can be used as aids to size identification in the field. A handful of soil rubbed through the fingers can yield the following: SAND (and coarser) particles are visible to the naked eye. SILT particles become dusty when dry and are easily brushed off hands and boots. CLAY particles are greasy and sticky when wet and hard when dry, and have to be scraped or washed off hands and boots. Shape of grains The majority of soils may be regarded as either SANDS or CLAYS: SANDS include gravelly sands and gravel-sands. Sand grains are generally broken rock particles that have been formed by physical weathering, or they are the resistant components of rocks broken down by chemical weathering. Sand grains generally have a rotund shape. CLAYS include silty clays and clay-silts; there are few pure silts (e.g. areas formed by windblown Löess). Clay grains are usually the product of chemical weathering or rocks and soils. Clay particles have a flaky shape. There are major differences in engineering behaviour between SANDS and CLAYS (e.g. in permeability, compressibility, shrinking/swelling potential). The shape and size of the soil grains has an important bearing on these differences. Shape characteristics of SAND grains SAND and larger-sized grains are rotund. Coarse soil grains (silt-sized, sand-sized and larger) have different shape characteristics and surface roughness depending on the amount of wear during transportation (by water, wind or ice), or after crushing in manufactured aggregates. They have a relatively low specific surface (surface area). Click on a link below to see the shape Rounded: Water- or air-worn; transported sediments Irregular: Irregular shape with round edges; glacial sediments (sometimes sub-divided into 'sub-rounded' and 'sub-angular') Angular: Flat faces and sharp edges; residual soils, grits Flaky: Thickness small compared to length/breadth; clays Elongated: Length larger than breadth/thickness; scree, broken flagstone Flaky & Elongated: Length>Breadth>Thickness; broken schists and slates Shape characteristics of CLAY grains CLAY particles are flaky. Their thickness is very small relative to their length & breadth, in some cases as thin as 1/100th of the length. They therefore have high to very high specific surface values. These surfaces carry a small negative electrical charge, that will attract the positive end of water molecules. This charge depends on the soil mineral and may be affected by an electrolite in the pore water. This causes some additional forces between the soil grains which are proportional to the specific surface. Thus a lot of water may be held asadsorbed water within a clay mass. Specific surface Specific surface is the ratio of surface area per unit weight. Surface forces are proportional to surface area (i.e. to d²). Self-weight forces are proportional to volume (i.e. to d³). Surface force 1 Therefore self weight forces d area 1 Also, specific surface = d * volume Hence, specific surface is a measure of the relative contributions of surface forces and self-weight forces. The specific surface of a 1mm cube of quartz ( = 2.65gm/cm³) is 0.00023 m²/N SAND grains (size 2.0 - 0.06mm) are close to cubes or spheres in shape, and have specific surfaces near the minimum value. CLAY particles are flaky and have much greater specific surface values. Examples of specific surface The more elongated or flaky a particle is the greater will be its specific surface. Click on the following examples: cubes, rods, sheets Examples of mineral grain specific surfaces: Mineral/Soil Thickness Grain width Specific Surface m²/N Quartz grain 100 d 0.0023 Quartz sand 2.0 - 0.06 d 0.0001 - 0.004 Kaolinite 2.0 - 0.3 0.2d 2 Illite 2.0 - 0.2 0.1d 8 Montmorillonite 1.0 - 0.01 0.01d 80 Structure or fabric Natural soils are rarely the same from one point in the ground to another. The content and nature of grains varies, but more importantly, so does the arrangement of these. The arrangement and organisation of particles and other features within a soil mass is termed its structure or fabric. This includes bedding orientation, stratification, layer thickness, the occurrence of joints and fissures, the occurrence of voids, artefacts, tree roots and nodules, the presence of cementing or bonding agents between grains. Structural features can have a major influence on in situ properties. Vertical and horizontal permeabilities will be different in alternating layers of fine and coarse soils. The presence of fissures affects some aspects of strength. The presence of layers or lenses of different stiffness can affect stability. The presence of cementing or bonding influences strength and stiffness. Origins, formation and mineralogy Soils are the results of geological events (except for the very small amount produced by man). The nature and structure of a given soil depends on the geological processes that formed it: breakdown of parent rock: weathering, decomposition, erosion. transportation to site of final deposition: gravity, flowing water, ice, wind. environment of final deposition: flood plain, river terrace, glacial moraine, lacustrine or marine. subsequent conditions of loading and drainage - little or no surcharge, heavy surcharge due to ice or overlying deposits, change from saline to freshwater, leaching, contamination. Origins of soils from rocks All soils originate, directly or indirectly, from solid rocks in the Earth's crust: igneous rocks crystalline bodies of cooled magma, e.g. granite, basalt, dolerite, gabbro, syenite, porphyry sedimentary rocks layers of consolidated and cemented sediments, mostly formed in bodies of water (seas, lakes, etc.) e.g. limestone, sandstones, mudstone, shale, conglomerate metamorphic rocks formed by the alteration of existing rocks due to heat from igneous intrusions (e.g. marble, quartzite, hornfels) or pressure due to crustal movement (e.g. slate, schist, gneiss). Weathering of rocks Physical weathering Physical or mechanical processes taking place on the Earth's surface, including the actions of water, frost, temperature changes, wind and ice; cause disintegration and wearing. The products are mainly coarse soils (silts, sands and gravels). Physical weathering produces Very Coarse soils and Gravels consisting of broken rock particles, but Sands and Silts will be mainly consists of mineral grains. Chemical weathering Chemical weathering occurs in wet and warm conditions and consists of degradation by decomposition and/or alteration. The results of chemical weathering are generally fine soils with separate mineral grains, such as Clays and Clay-Silts. The type of clay mineral depends on the parent rock and on local drainage. Some minerals, such as quartz, are resistant to the chemical weathering and remain unchanged. quartz A resistant and enduring mineral found in many rocks (e.g. granite, sandstone). It is the principal constituent of sands and silts, and the most abundant soil mineral. It occurs as equidimensional hard grains. haematite A red iron (ferric) oxide: resistant to change, results from extreme weathering. It is responsible for the widespread red or pink colouration in rocks and soils. It can form a cement in rocks, or a duricrust in soils in arid climates. micas Flaky minerals present in many igneous rocks. Some are resistant, e.g. muscovite; some are broken down, e.g. biotite. clay minerals These result mainly from the breakdown of feldspar minerals. They are very flaky and therefore have very large surface areas. They are major constituents of clay soils, although clay soil also contains silt sized particles. Clay minerals Clay minerals are produced mainly from the chemical weathering and decomposition of feldspars, such as orthoclase and plagioclase, and some micas. They are small in size and very flaky in shape. The key to some of the properties of clay soils, e.g. plasticity, compressibility, swelling/shrinkage potential, lies in the structure of clay minerals. There are three main groups of clay minerals: kaolinites (include kaolinite, dickite and nacrite) formed by the decomposition of orthoclase feldspar (e.g. in granite); kaolin is the principal constituent in china clay and ball clay. illites (include illite and glauconite) are the commonest clay minerals; formed by the decomposition of some micas and feldspars; predominant in marine clays and shales (e.g. London clay, Oxford clay). montmorillonites (also called smectites or fullers' earth minerals) (include calcium and sodium momtmorillonites, bentonite and vermiculite) formed by the alteration of basic igneous rocks containing silicates rich in Ca and Mg; weak linkage by cations (e.g. Na+, Ca++) results in high swelling/shrinking potential Transportation and deposition The effects of weathering and transportation largely determine the basic nature of the soil (i.e. the size, shape, composition and distribution of the grains). The environment into which deposition takes place, and subsequent geological events that take place there, largely determine the state of the soil, (i.e. density, moisture content) and the structure or fabric of the soil (i.e. bedding, stratification, occurrence of joints or fissures, tree roots, voids, etc.) Transportation Due to combinations of gravity, flowing water or air, and moving ice. In water or air: grains become subrounded or rounded, grain sizes are sorted, producing poorly-graded deposits. In moving ice: grinding and crushing occur, size distribution becomes wider, deposits are well-graded, ranging from rock flour to boulders. Deposition In flowing water, larger particles are deposited as velocity drops, e.g. gravels in river terraces, sands in floodplains and estuaries, silts and clays in lakes and seas. In still water: horizontal layers of successive sediments are formed, which may change with time, even seasonally or daily. Deltaic & shelf deposits: often vary both horizontally and vertically. From glaciers, deposition varies from well-graded basal tills and boulder clays to poorly-graded deposits in moraines and outwash fans. In arid conditions: scree material is usually poorly-graded and lies on slopes. Wind-blown Löess is generally uniformly-graded and false-bedded. Loading and drainage history The current state (i.e. density and consistency) of a soil will have been profoundly influenced by the history of loading and unloading since it was deposited. Changes in drainage conditions may also have occurred which may have brought about changes in water content. Loading /unloading history Initial loading During deposition the load applied to a layer of soil increases as more layers are deposited over it; thus, it is compressed and water is squeezed out; as deposition continues, the soil becomes stiffer and stronger. Unloading The principal natural mechanism of unloading is erosion of overlying layers. Unloading can also occur as overlying ice-sheets and glaciers retreat, or due to large excavations made by man. Soil expands when it is unloaded, but not as much as it was initially compressed; thus it stays compressed - and is said to be overconsolidated. The degree of overconsolidation depends on the history of loading and unloading. Drainage history Chemical changes Some soils initially deposited loosely in saline water and then inundated with fresh water develop weak collapsing structure. In arid climates with intermittent rainy periods, cycles of wetting and drying can bring minerals to the surface to form a cemented soil. Climate changes Some clays (e.g. montmorillonite clays) are prone to large volume changes due to wetting and drying; thus, seasonal changes in surface level occur, often causing foundation damage, especially after exceptionally dry summers. Trees extract water from soil in the process of evapotranspiration; The soil near to trees can therefore either shrink as trees grow larger, or expand following the removal of large trees. Grading and composition The recommended standard for soil classification is the British Soil Classification System, and this is detailed in BS 5930 Site Investigation. Coarse soils Coarse soils are classified principally on the basis of particle size and grading. > 200 mm Very coarse BOULDERS soils COBBLES 60 - 200 mm Coarse soils coarse 20 - 60 mm G medium 6 - 20 mm GRAVEL fine 2 - 6 mm S coarse 0.6 - 2.0 mm medium 0.2 - 0.6 mm SAND fine 0.06 - 0.2 mm Particle size tests The aim is to measure the distribution of particle sizes in the sample. When a wide range of sizes is present, the sample will be sub-divided, and separate tests carried out on each sub-sample. Full details of tests are given in BS 1377: "Methods of test for soil for civil engineering purposes". Particle-size tests Wet sieving to separate fine grains from coarse grains is carried out by washing the soil specimen on a Dry sieving and shaken through a nest of sieves of descending size. Sedimentation is used only for fine soils. Soil particles are allowed to settle from a suspension. The decreasing density of the suspension is measured at time intervals. Sizes are determined from the settling velocity and times recorded. Percentages between sizes are determined from density differences. Particle-size analysis The cumulative percentage quantities finer than certain sizes (e.g. passing a given size sieve mesh) are determined by weighing. Points are then plotted of % finer (passing) against log size. A smooth S-shaped curve drawn through these points is called a grading curve. The position and shape of the grading curve determines the soil class. Geometrical grading characteristics can be determined also from the grading curve. Typical grading curves Both the position and the shape of the grading curve for a soil can aid its identity and description. Some typical grading curves are shown in the figure: A - a poorly-graded medium SAND (probably estuarine or flood-plain alluvium) B - a well-graded GRAVEL-SAND (i.e. equal amounts of gravel and sand) C - a gap-graded COBBLES-SAND D - a sandy SILT (perhaps a deltaic or estuarine silt) E - a typical silty CLAY (e.g. London clay, Oxford clay) Grading characteristics A grading curve is a useful aid to soil description. Grading curves are often included in ground investigation reports. Results of grading tests can be tabulated using geometric properties of the grading curve. These properties are called grading characteristics First of all, three points are located on the grading curve: d10 = the maximum size of the smallest 10% of the sample d30 = the maximum size of the smallest 30% of the sample d60 = the maximum size of the smallest 60% of the sample From these the grading characteristics are calculated: Effective size d10 Uniformity coefficient Cu = d60 / d10 Coefficient of gradation Ck = d30² / d60 d10 Both Cu and Ck will be 1 for a single-sized soil Cu > 5 indicates a well-graded soil Cu < 3 indicates a uniform soil Ck between 0.5 and 2.0 indicates a well-graded soil Ck < 0.1 indicates a possible gap-graded soil Sieve analysis example The results of a dry-sieving test are given below, together with the grading analysis and grading curve. Note carefully how the tabulated results are set out and calculated. The grading curve has been plotted on special semi-logarithmic paper; you can also do this analysis using a spreadsheet. Sieve mesh size (mm) Mass Percentage retained (g) retained Percentage finer (passing) 14.0 0 0 100.0 10.0 3.5 1.2 98.8 6.3 7.6 2.6 86.2 5.0 7.0 2.4 93.8 3.35 14.3 4.9 88.9 2.0 21.1 7.2 81.7 1.18 56.7 19.4 62.3 0.600 73.4 25.1 37.2 0.425 22.2 7.6 29.6 0.300 26.9 9.2 20.4 0.212 18.4 6.3 14.1 0.150 15.2 5.2 8.9 0.063 17.5 6.0 2.9 Pan 8.5 2.9 TOTAL 292.3 100.0 The soil comprises: 18% gravel, 45% coarse sand, 24% medium sand, 10% fine sand, 3% silt, and is classified therefore as: a well-graded gravelly SAND Fine soils In the case of fine soils (e.g. CLAYS and SILTS), it is the shape of the particles rather than their size that has the greater influence on engineering properties. Clay soils have flaky particles to which water adheres, thus imparting the property of plasticity. Consistency limits and plasticity Consistency varies with the water content of the soil. The consistency of a soil can range from (dry) solid to semi-solid to plastic to liquid (wet). The water contents at which the consistency changes from one state to the next are called consistency limits (or Atterberg limits). Two of these are utilised in the classification of fine soils: Liquid limit (wL) - change of consistency from plastic to liquid Plastic limit (wP) - change of consistency from brittle/crumbly to plastic Measures of liquid and plastic limit values can be obtained from laboratory tests. Plasticity index The consistency of most soils in the ground will be plastic or semi-solid. Soil strength and stiffness behaviour are related to the range of plastic consistency. The range of water content over which a soil has a plastic consistency is termed the Plasticity Index (IP or PI). IP = liquid limit - plastic limit = wL - wP The plasticity chart and classification In the BSCS fine soils are divided into ten classes based on their measured plasticity index and liquid limit values: CLAYS are distinguished from SILTS, and five divisions of plasticity are defined: Low plasticity wL = < 35% Intermediate plasticity wL = 35 - 50% High plasticity wL = 50 - 70% Very high plasticity wL = 70 - 90% Extremely high plasticity wL = > 90% Activity So-called 'clay' soils are not 100% clay. The proportion of clay mineral flakes (< 2 affects its current state, particularly its tendency to swell and shrink with changes in water content. The degree of plasticity related to the clay content is called the activity of the soil. Activity P / (% clay particles) Some typical values are: Mineral Activity Soil Activity Muscovite 0.25 Kaolin clay 0.4-0.5 Kaolinite 0.40 Glacial clay and loess 0.5-0.75 Illite 0.90 Most British clays Montmorillonite > 1.25 0.75-1.25 Organic estuarine clay > 1.25 Specific gravity Specific gravity (Gs) is a property of the mineral or rock material forming soil grains. It is defined as Method of measurement For fine soils a 50 ml density bottle may be used; for coarse soils a 500 ml or 1000 ml jar. The jar is weighed empty (M1). A quantity of dry soil is placed in the jar and the jar weighed (M2). The jar is filled with water, air removed by stirring, and weighed again (M3). The jar is emptied, cleaned and refilled with water - and weighed again (M4). [The range of Gs for common soils is 2.64 to 2.72] Volume-weight properties The volume-weight properties of a soil define its state. Measures of the amount of void space, amount of water and the weight of a unit volume of soil are required in engineering analysis and design. Soil comprises three constituent phases: Solid: rock fragments, mineral grains or flakes, organic matter. Liquid: water, with some dissolved compounds (e.g. salts). Gas: air or water vapour. In natural soils the three phases are intermixed. To aid analysis it is convenient to consider a soil model in which the three phases are seen as separate, but still in their correct proportions. Volumes of solid, water and air: the soil model The soil model is given dimensional values for the solid, water and air components: Total volume, V = Vs + Vw + Va Since the amounts of both water and air are variable, the volume of solids present is taken as the reference quantity. Thus, the following relational volumetric quantities may be defined: Note also that: n = e / (1 + e) e = n / (1 - n) v = 1 / (1 - n) Typical void ratios might be 0.3 (e.g. for a dense, well graded granular soil) or 1.5 (e.g. for a soft clay). Degree of saturation The volume of water in a soil can only vary between zero (i.e. a dry soil) and the volume of voids; this can be expressed as a ratio: For a perfectly dry soil: Sr = 0 For a saturated soil: Sr = 1 Note: In clay soils as the amount water increases the volume and therefore the volume of voids will also increase, and so the degree of saturation may remain at Sr = 1 while the actual volume of water is increasing. Air-voids content The air-voids volume, Va , is that part of the void space not occupied by water. Va = Vv - Vw = e - e.Sr = e.(1 - Sr) Air-voids content, Av Av = (air-voids volume) / (total volume) = Va / V = e.(1 - Sr) / (1+e) = n.(1 - Sr) For a perfectly dry soil: Av = n For a saturated soil: Av = 0 Masses of solid and water: water content The mass of air may be ignored. The mass of solid particles is usually expressed in terms of their particle density or grain specific gravity. Grain specific gravity Hence the mass of solid particles in a soil Ms = Vs .Gs .w (w = density of water = 1.00Mg/m³) [Range of Gs for common soils: 2.64-2.72] Particle density s = mass per unit volume of particles = Gs .w The ratio of the mass of water present to the mass of solid particles is called the water content, or sometimes the moisture content. From the soil model it can be seen that w = (Sr .e .w) / (Gs .w) Giving the useful relationship: w .Gs = Sr .e Densities and unit weights Density is a measure of the quantity of mass in a unit volume of material. Unit weight is a measure of the weight of a unit volume of material. There are two basic measures of density or unit weight applied to soils: Dry density is a measure of the amount of solid particles per unit volume. Bulk density is a measure of the amount of solid + water per unit volume. The preferred units of density are: Mg/m³, kg/m³ or g/ml. The corresponding unit weights are: Also, it can be shown that = d(1 + w) and = gd(1 + w) Laboratory measurements It is important to quantify the state of a soil immediately it is received in the testing laboratory and just prior to commencing other tests (e.g. shear tests, compression tests, etc.). The water content and unit weight are particularly important, since these could change during transportation and storage. Some physical state properties are calculated following the practical measurement of others; e.g. void ratio from porosity, dry unit weight from unit weight & water content. Water content The most usual method of determining the water content of soil is to weigh a small representative specimen, drying it to constant weight and then weighing it again. Drying can be carried out using an electric oven set at 104-105° Celsius or using a microwave oven. Example: A sample of soil was placed in a tin container and weighed, after which it was dried in an oven and then weighed again. Calculate the water content of the soil. Weight of tin empty = 16.16 g Weight of tin + moist soil = 37.82 g Weight of tin + dry soil = 34.68 g Water content, w = (mass of water) / (mass of dry soil) = (37.82 - 34.68) / (34.68 - 16.16) = 0.169 Percentage water content = 16.9 % Unit weight Clay soils: Specimens are usually prepared in the form of regular geometric shapes, (e.g. prisms, cylinders) of which the volume is easily computed. Sands and gravels: Specimens have to be placed in a container to determine volume (e.g. a cylindrical can). Example A soil specimen had a volume of 89.13 ml, a mass before drying of 174.45 g and after drying of 158.73 g; the water content was 9.9 %. Determine the bulk and dry densities and unit weights. Bulk density = (mass of specimen) / (volume of specimen) = 174.45 / 89.13 g/ml = 1.957 Mg/m³ [1 g/ml = 1 Mg/m³] Unit weight = 9.81m/s² x Mg/m³ = 19.20 kN/m³ Dry density d = (mass after drying) / (volume) = 158.73 / 89.13 = 1.781 Mg/m³ d = / (1 + w) = 1.957 / (1+0.099) = 1.781 Mg/m³ Dry unit weight d = / (1 + w) = 19.20 / (1+0.099) = 17.47 kN/m³ Field measurements Measurements taken in the field are mostly to determine density/unit weight. The most common application is the determination of the density of rolled and compacted fill, e.g. in road bases, embankments, etc. Note: These methods are covered in detail by BS1377. You should understand the general principle that density is calculated from the mass and volume of a sample. How a sample of known volume is obtained depends on the nature of the soil. You are not expected to remember the details of each method. The core cutter method This method is suitable for soft fine grained soils. A steel cylinder is driven into the ground, dug out and the soil shaved off level. The mass of soil is found by weighing and deducting the mass of the cylinder. Small samples are taken from both ends and the water content determined. The sand-pouring cylinder method This method is suitable for stony soils Using a special tray with a hole in the centre, a hole is formed in the soil and the mass of soil removed is weighed. The volume of the hole is calculated from the mass of clean dry running sand required to fill the hole. The sand-pouring cylinder is used to fill the hole in a controlled manner. The mass of sand required to fill the hole is equal to the difference in the weight of the cylinder before and after filling the hole, less an allowance for the sand left in the cone above the hole. Bulk density = (mass of soil) / (volume of core cutter or hole) Current state of soil The state of soil is essentially the closeness of packing of the grains in the range: Closely packed Loosely packed Dense Loose Low water content High water content Strong and stiff Weak and soft The important indicators of the current state of a soil are: current stresses: vertical and horizontal effective stresses current water content: effecting strength and stiffness in fine soils liquidity index: indicates state in fine soils density index: indicates state of compaction in coarse soils history of loading and unloading: degree of overconsolidation. Eng. operations (e.g. excavation, loading, unloading, compaction, etc.) on soil bring about changes in its state. Its initial state is the result of processes of erosion and deposition. It is possible for the engineer to predict changes that could result from a proposed eng .operation: changes from the soil's current state to a new future state. Soil history: deposition and erosion Original deposition Most soils are formed in layers or lenses by deposition from moving water, ice or wind. One-dimensional compression occurs as overlying layers are added. Vertical and horizontal stresses increase with deposition. Erosion Erosion causes unloading; stresses decrease; some vertical expansion occurs. Plastic strain has occurred; the soil remains compressed, i.e. overconsolidated. Subsequent changes Subsequent changes may occur in the depositional environment: further loading/unloading due to glaciation, land movement, engineering; and ageing processes. Soil history: ageing The term ageing includes processes that occur with time, except loading and unloading. Ageing processes are independent of changes in loading. Vibration and compaction Coarse soils can be made more dense by vibration or compaction at essentially constant effective stress Creep Fine soils creep and continue to compress and distort at constant effective stress after primary consolidation is complete. Cementing and bonding Intergranular cementing and bonding occurs due to deposition of minerals from groundwater, e.g. calcium carbonate; disturbance due to excavation fractures the bonding and reduces strength. Weathering Physical and chemical changes take place in soils near the ground surface due to the influence of changes in rainfall and temperature. Changes in salinity Changes in the salinity of groundwater are due to changes in relative sea and land levels, thus soil originally deposited in sea water may later have fresh water in its pores, such soils may be prone to sudden collapse. Density index (relative density) The void ratio of coarse soils (sands and gravels) varies with the state of packing between the loosest practical state in which it can exist and the densest. Some engineering properties are affected by this, e.g.shear strength, compressibility, permeability. It is therefore useful to measure the in situ state and this can be done by comparing the in situ void ratio (e) with the minimum and maximum practical values (emin and emax) to give a density index D emin is determined with soil compacted densely in a metal mould emax is determined with soil poured loosely into a metal mould Density index is also known as relative density Relative states of compaction are defined: Density index State of compaction 0-15% Very loose 15-35 Loose 35-65 Medium 65-85 Dense 85-100% Very dense Liquidity index In fine soils, especially clays, the current state is dependent on the water content with respect to the consistency limits (or Atterberg limits). The L or LI) provides a quantitative measure of the current state: where wP = plastic limit and wL = liquid limit Significant values of IL indicating the consistency of the soil are: IL -plastic solid or solid 0 < IL < 1 1 < IL Predicting stiffness and strength from index properties Preliminary estimates of strength and stiffness can provide a useful basis for early design and feasibility studies, and also the planning of more detailed testing programmes. The following suggestions have been made; they are simple, but not necessarily reliable, and should be not be used in final design calculations. Undrained shear strength su = 170 exp(-4.6 L) kN/m² [Schofield and Wroth (1968)] su = (0.11 + 0.37 P) 'vo kN/m² where 'vo = vertical effective stress in situ [Skempton and Bjerrum (1957)] Stiffness The slope of the critical state line may be estimated from: = P .Gs / 461 [After Skempton and Northey (1953)] The compressibility index may be estimated from: Cc = ln10 = P Gs / 200 (where P is in percentage units) BS system for description and classification BS 5930 Site Investigation recommends the terminology and a system for describing and classifying soils for engineering purposes. Without the use of a satisfactory system of description and classification, the description of materials found on a site would be meaningless or even misleading, and it would be difficult to apply experience to future projects. BS description system A recommended protocol for describing a soil deposit uses ninecharacteristics; these should be written in the following order: compactness e.g. loose, dense, slightly cemented bedding structure e.g. homogeneous or stratified; dip, orientation discontinuities spacing of beds, joints, fissures weathered state degree of weathering colour main body colour, mottling grading or consistency e.g. well-graded, poorly-graded; soft, firm, hard SOIL NAME e.g. GRAVEL, SAND, SILT, CLAY; (upper case letters) plus silty-, gravelly-, with-fines, etc. as appropriate soil class (BSCS) designation (for roads & airfields) e.g. SW = well-graded sand geological stratigraphic name (when known) e.g. London clay Not all characteristics are necessarily applicable in every case. Example: (i) Loose homogeneous reddish-yellow poorly-graded medium SAND (SP), Flood plain alluvium (ii) Dense fissured unweathered greyish-blue firm CLAY. Oxford clay. Definitions of terms used in description A table is given in BS 5930 Site Investigation setting out a recommended field indentification and description system. The following are some of the terms listed for use in soil descriptions: Particle shape angular, sub-angular, sub-rounded, rounded, flat, elongate Compactness loose, medium dense, dense (use a pick or driven peg, or density index ) Bedding structure homogeneous, stratified, inter-stratified Bedding spacing massive(>2m), thickly bedded (2000-600 mm), medium bedded (600-200 mm), thinly bedded (200-60 mm), very thinly bedded (60-20 mm), laminated (20-6 mm), thinly laminated (<6 mm). Discontinuities i.e. spacing of joints and fissure: very widely spaced(>2m), widely spaced (2000-600 mm), medium spaced (600-200 mm), closely spaced (200-60 mm), very closely spaced (60-20 mm), extremely closely spaced (<20 mm). Colours red, pink, yellow, brown, olive, green, blue, white, grey, black Consistency very soft (exudes between fingers), soft (easily mouldable), firm (strong finger pressure required), stiff (can be indented with fingers, but not moulded) very stiff (indented by sharp object), hard (difficult to indent). Grading well graded (wide size range), uniform (very narrow size range), poorly graded (narrow or uneven size range). Composite soils In SANDS and GRAVELS: slightly clayey or silty (<5%), clayey or silty (5-15%), very clayey or silty(>15%) In CLAYS and SILTS: sandy or gravelly (35-65%) British Soil Classification System The recommended standard for soil classification is the British Soil Classification System, and this is detailed in BS 5930 Site Investigation. Its essential structure is as follows: Soil group Symbol Coarse soils Fines % G GRAVEL Recommended name GW 0-5 Well-graded GRAVEL GPu/GPg 0-5 Uniform/poorly-graded GRAVEL G-F GWM/GWC 5 - 15 GPM/GPC 5 - 15 GF GML, GMI... 15 - 35 S SAND SILT M Very silty GRAVEL [plasticity sub-group...] 15 - 35 Very clayey GRAVEL [..symbols as below] SW 0-5 Well-graded SAND SPu/SPg 0-5 Uniform/poorly-graded SAND 5 - 15 Well-graded silty/clayey SAND 5 - 15 Poorly graded silty/clayey SAND GPM/GPC Fine soils Poorly graded silty/clayey GRAVEL GCL, GCI... S-F SWM/SWC SF Well-graded silty/clayey GRAVEL SML, SMI... 15 - 35 Very silty SAND [plasticity sub-group...] SCL, SCI... 15 - 35 Very clayey SAND [..symbols as below] >35% fines Liquid limit% MG Gravelly SILT MS Sandy SILT CLAY C ML, MI... [Plasticity subdivisions as for CLAY] CG Gravelly CLAY CS Sandy CLAY CL <35 CLAY of low plasticity CI 35 - 50 CLAY of intermediate plasticity CH 50 - 70 CLAY of high plasticity CV 70 - 90 CLAY of very high plasticity CE >90 CLAY of extremely high plasticity Organic soils O Peat [Add letter 'O' to group symbol] Pt [Soil predominantly fibrous and organic] Basic mechanics of soils Loads from foundations and walls apply stresses in the ground. Settlements are caused by strains in the ground. To analyse the conditions within a material under loading, we must consider the stress-strain behaviour. The relationship between a strain and stress is termed stiffness. The maximum value of stress that may be sustained is termed strength. Analysis of stress and strain Stresses and strains occur in all directions and to do settlement and stability analyses it is often necessary to relate the stresses in a particular direction to those in other directions. normal stress n/ A normal strain shear stress s/ A shear strain o o Note that compressive stresses and strains are positive, counter-clockwise shear stress and strain are positive, and that these are total stresses (see effective stress). Special stress and strain states Analysis of stress and strain In general, the stresses and strains in the three dimensions will all be different. There are three special cases which are important in ground engineering: General case princpal stresses Axially symmetric or triaxial states Stresses and strains in two dorections are equal. x y x y Relevant to conditions near relatively small foundations, piles, anchors and other concentrated loads. Plane strain: Strain in one direction = 0 y=0 Relevant to conditions near long foundations, embankments, retaining walls and other long structures. One-dimensional compression: Strain in two directions = 0 x y=0 Relevant to conditions below wide foundations or relatively thin compressible soil layers. Uniaxial compression x y=0 This is an artifical case which is only possible for soil is there are negative pore water pressures. Mohr circle construction Values of normal stress and shear stress must relate to a particular plane within an element of soil. In general, the stresses on another plane will be different. To visualise the stresses on all the possible planes, a graph called the Mohr circle is drawn by plotting a (normal stress, shear stress) point for a plane at every possible angle. There are special planes on which the shear stress is zero (i.e. the circle crosses the normal stress axis), and the state of stress (i.e. the circle) can be described by the normal stresses acting on these planes; these are called the principal stresses 1 3. Parameters for stress and strain In common soil tests, cylindrical samples are used in which the axial and radial stresses and strains are principal stresses and strains. For analysis of test data, and to develop soil mechanics theories, it is usual to combine these into mean (or normal) components which influence volume changes, and deviator (or shearing) components which influence shape changes. stress mean deviator p' = s' = strain a a t' = r) / 3 ev ) r / 2 n a a - r) r) es = /2 a r) r) a a a - r) /3 r) In the Mohr circle construction t' is the radius of the circle and s' defines its centre. Note: Total and effective stresses are related to pore pressure u: p' = p - u s' = s - u q' = q t' = t Strength The shear strength of a material is most simply described as the maximum shear stress it can sustain: l be a limiting condition at f is then the shear strength of the material. The simple type of failure shown here is associated with ductile or plastic materials. If the material is brittle (like a piece of chalk), the failure may be sudden and catastrophic with loss of strength after failure. Types of failure Materials can ‘fail’ under different loading conditions. In each case, however, failure is associated with the limiting radius of the Mohr circle, i.e. the maximum shear stress. The following common examples are shown in terms of total stresses: Shearing Shea f nf = normal stress at failure Uniaxial extension tf f Uniaxial compression cf f Note: f = 0. Hence vertical and horizontal stresses are equal and the Mohr circle becomes a point. Strength criteria A strength criterion is a formula which relates the strength of a material to some other parameters: these are material parameters and may include other stresses. For soils there are three important strength criteria: the correct criterion depends on the nature of the soil and on whether the loading is drained or undrained. In General, course grained soils will "drain" very quickly (in engineering terms) following loading. Thefore development of excess pore pressure will not occur; volume change associated with increments of effective stress will control the behaviour and the MohrCoulomb criteria will be valid. Fine grained saturated soils will respond to loading initially by generating excess pore water pressures and remaining at constant volume. At this stage the Tresca criteria, which uses total stress to represent undrained behaviour, should be used. This is the short term or immediate loading response. Once the pore pressure has dissapated, after a certain time, the effective stresses have incresed and the Mohr-Coulomb criterion will describe the strength mobilised. This is the long term loading response. Tresca criterion Mohr-Coulomb (c’=0) criterion Mohr-Coulomb (c’>0) criterion Tresca criterion The strength is independent of the normal stress since the response to loading simple increases the pore water pressure and not the effective stress. The shear strength f is a material parameter which is known as the undrained shear strength su. f ar) = constant Mohr-Coulomb (c'=0) criterion The strength increases linearly with increasing normal stress and is zero when the normal stress is zero. f n In the Mohrthis criterion are known as frictional. In soils, the Mohr-Coulomb criterion applies when the normal stress is an effective normal stress. >Mohr-Coulomb (c'>0) criterion The strength increases linearly with increasing normal stress and is positive when the normal stress is zero. f n c' is the 'cohesion' intercept In soils, the Mohr-Coulomb criterion applies when the normal stress is an effective normal stress. In soils, the cohesion in the effective stress Mohr-Coulomb criterion is not the same as the cohesion (or undrained strength su) in the Tresca criterion. Typical values of shear strength Undrained shear strength su (kPa) Hard soil su > 150 kPa Stiff soil su = 75 ~ 150 kPa Firm soil su = 40 ~ 75 kPa Soft soil su = 20 ~ 40kPa Very soft soil su < 20 kPa Drained shear strength c´ (kPa) Compact sands 0 35° - 45° Loose sands 0 30° - 35° (deg) Unweathered overconsolidated clay critical state 0 18° ~ 25° peak state 10 ~ 25 kPa 20° ~ 28° residual 0 ~ 5 kPa 8° ~ 15° Often the value of c' deduced from laboratory test results (in the shear testing apperatus) may appear to Often this is due to fitting a due to suction or dilatancy. line to the experimental data and an 'apparent' cohesion may be deduced Stress in the ground When a load is applied to soil, it is carried by the water in the pores as well as the solid grains. The increase in pressure within the porewater causes drainage (flow out of the soil), and the load is transferred to the solid grains. The rate of drainage depends on the permeabilityof the soil. The strength and compressibility of the soil depend on the stresses within the solid granular fabric. These are called effective stresses. Total stress The total vertical stress acting at a point below the ground surface is due to the weight of everythinglying above: soil, water, and surface loading. Total stresses are calculated from the unit weight of the soil. Unit weight ranges are: dry soil d 14 - 20 kN/m³ (average 17kN/m³) saturated soil g 18 - 23 kN/m³ (average 20kN/m³) water w 9.81 kN/m³ v) may also result in a change in the horizontal total stress h) at the same point. The relationships between vertical and horizontal stress are complex. total stress Total stress in homogeneous soil Total stress increases with depth and with unit weight: Vertical total stress at depth z, v Simple total stress calculator z v 20 3 60 z, i.e. related to depth z. The unit weight, , will vary with the water content of the soil. d g total stress Total stress below a river or lake The total stress is the sum of the weight of the soil up to the surface and the weight of water above this: Vertical total stress at depth z, v w .zw where weight of the saturated soil, i.e. the total weight of soil grains and water weight of water w = unit The vertical total stress will change with changes in water level and with excavation. Note that free water (i.e. water outside the soil) applies a total stress to a soil surface. Simple total stress calculator z zw v 20 3 1 69.81 total stress Total stress in multi-layered soil The total stress at depth z is the sum of the weights of soil in each layer thickness above. Vertical total stress at depth z, 1d1 v 2d2 3(z - d1 - d2) where 1 2 3, etc. = unit weights of soil layers 1, 2 , 3, etc. respectively If a new layer is placed on the surface the total stresses at all points below will increase. Layer 1 2 3 Thickness 1.5 2 5 Unit weight 16 19 20 0 stress 0 @ m= kPa Enter a value in any box (except the last) then click outside the box to see the effect Total stress in unsaturated soil total stress Just above the water table the soil will remain saturated due to capillarity, but at some distance above the water table the soil will become unsaturated, with a consequent reduction in unit weight u) v w . zw g(z - zw) The height above the water table up to which the soil will remain saturated depends on the grain size. See Negative pore pressure (suction). Total stress with a surface surcharge load The addition of a surface surcharge load will increase the total stresses below it. If the surcharge loading is extensively wide, the increase in vertical total stress below it may be considered constant with depth and equal to the magnitude of the surcharge. Vertical total stress at depth z, v For narrow surcharges, e.g. under strip and pad foundations, the induced vertical total stresses will decrease both with depth and horizontal distance from the load. In such cases, it is necessary to use a suitable stress distribution theory - an example is Boussinesq's theory. Pore pressure The water in the pores of a soil is called porewater. The pressure within this porewater is called pore pressure (u). The magnitude of pore pressure depends on: the depth below the water table the conditions of seepage flow Groundwater and hydrostatic pressure Pore pressure Under hydrostatic conditions (no water flow) the pore pressure at a given point is given by the hydrostatic pressure: w .hw where hw = depth below water table or overlying water surface It is convenient to think of pore pressure represented by the column of water in an imaginary standpipe; the pressure just outside being equal to that inside. Water table, phreatic surface Pore pressure The natural static level of water in the ground is called the water table or the phreatic surface (or sometimes the groundwater level). Under conditions of no seepage flow, the water table will be horizontal, as in the surface of a lake. The magnitude of the pore pressure at the water table is zero. Below the water table, pore pressures are positive. w .hw In conditions of steady-state or variable seepage flow, the calculation of pore pressures becomes more complex. See Groundwater Negative pore pressure (suction) Below the water table, pore pressures are positive. In dry soil, the pore pressure is zero. Above the water table, when the soil is saturated, pore pressure will be negative. u = - w .hw The height above the water table to which the soil is saturated is called the capillary rise, and this depends on the grain size and type (and thus the size of pores): · in coarse soils capillary rise is very small · in silts it may be up to 2m · in clays it can be over 20m Pore water and pore air pressure Between the ground surface and the top of the saturated zone, the soil will often be partially saturated, i.e. the pores contain a mixture of water and air. The pore pressure in a partially saturated soil consists of two components: · porewater pressure = uw · pore-air pressure = ua Note that water is incompressible, but air is compressible. The combined effect is a complex relationship involving partial pressures and the degree of saturation of the soil. In Europe and other temperate climate countries most design states are associated with saturated conditions, and the study of partially saturated soils is considered to be a specialist subject. Pore pressure in steady state seepage conditions In conditions of seepage in the ground there is a change in pore pressure. Consider seepage occurring between two points P and Q. The hydralic gradient, i, between two points is the head drop per unit length between these points. It can be thougth of as the "potential" driving the water flow. Hydralic gradient P-Q, i = - = . 1w Thus w But in steady-state seepage, i = constant Therefore the change in pore pressure due to seepage alone, For seepage flow vertically downward, i is negative For seepage flow vertically upward, i is positive. s = w .s Effective stress Ground movements and instabilities can be caused by changes in total stress (such as loading due to foundations or unloading due to excavations), but they can also be caused by changes in pore pressures (slopes can fail after rainfall increases the pore pressures). In fact, it is the combined effect of total stress and pore pressure that controls soil behaviour such as shear strength, compression and distortion. The difference between the total stress and the pore pressure is called the effective stress: effective stress = total stress - pore pressure -u Note that the prime (dash mark ´ ) indicates effective stress. Terzaghi's principle and equation Karl Terzaghi was born in Vienna and subsequently became a professor of soil mechanics in the USA. He was the first person to propose the relationship for effective stress (in 1936): All measurable effects of a change of stress, such as compression, distortion and a change of related to total stress and pore pressure by The adjective 'effective' is particularly apt, because it is effective stress that is effective in causing important changes: changes in strength, changes in volume, changes in shape. It does not represent the exact contact stress between particles but the distribution of load carried by the soil over the area considered. Mohr circles for total and effective stress Mohr circles can be drawn for both total and effective stress. The points E and T represent the total and effective stresses on the same plane. The two circles are displaced along the normal stress axis by the amount of pore pressure n n' + u), and their diameters are the same. The total and effective shear stresses are equal . The importance of effective stress The principle of effective stress is fundamentally important in soil mechanics. It must be treated as the basic axiom, since soil behaviour is governed by it. Total and effective stresses must be distinguishable in all calculations: algebraically the prime Changes in water level below ground (water table changes) result in changes in effective stresses below the water table. Changes in water level above ground (e.g. in lakes, rivers, etc.) do not cause changes in effective stresses in the ground below. Changes in effective stress In some analyses it is better to work in changes of quantity, rather than in absolute quantities; the effective stress expression then becomes: If both total stress and pore pressure change by the same amount, the effective stress remains constant. A change in effective stress will cause: a change in strength and a change in volume. Changes in strength The critical shear strength of soil is proportional to the effective normal stress; thus, a change in effective stress brings about a change in strength. Therefore, if the pore pressure in a soil slope increases, effective stresses will be reduced by - sometimes leading to failure. A seaside sandcastle will remain intact while damp, because the pore pressure is negative; as it dries, this pore pressure suction is lost and it collapses. Note: Sometimes a sandcastle will remain intact even when nearly dry because salt deposited as seawater evaporates slightly and cements the grains together. Changes in volume Immediately after the construction of a foundation on a fine soil, the pore pressure increases, but immediately begins to drop as drainage occurs. The rate of change of effective stress under a loaded foundation, once it is constructed, will be the same as the rate of change of pore pressure, and this is controlled by the permeability of the soil. Settlement occurs as the volume (and therefore thickness) of the soil layers change. Thus, settlement occurs rapidly in coarse soils with high permeabilities and slowly in fine soils with low permeabilities. Calculating vertical stress in the ground The worked examples here are designed to illustrate the principles and methods dealt with in Pore pressure, effective stress and stresses in the ground. The examples chosen are typical and simple. Simple total and effective stresses The figure shows soil layers on a site. Unit weights are: d = 16 kN/m³ g = 20 kN/m³ (a) At the top of saturated sand (z = 2.0 m) Vertical total stress v = 16.0 x 2.0 Pore pressure u=0 Vertical effective stress v v-u (b) At the top of the clay (z = 5.0 m) Vertical total stress v = 32.0 + 20.0 x 3.0 = 32.0 kPa = 32.0 kPa = 92.0 kPa Pore pressure Vertical effective stress u = 9.81 x 3.0 v v - u = 92.0 29.4 = 29.4 kPa = 62.6 kPa Effect of changing water table The figure shows soil layers on a site. The unit weight of the silty sand is 19.0 kN/m³ both above and below the water table. The water level is presently at the surface of the silty sand, it may drop or it may rise. The following calculations show the effects of this: Water table Stresses under foundations From an initial state, the stresses under a foundation are first changed by excavation, i.e. vertical stresses are reduced. After construction the foundation loading increases stresses. Other changes could result if the water table level changed. The figure shows the elevation of a foundation to be constructed in a homogeneous soil. The change in thickness of the clay layer is to be calculated and so the initial and final effective stresses are required at the mid-depth of the clay. Unit weights: sand above WT = 16 kN/m³, sand below WT = 20 kN/m³, clay = 18 kN/m³. Calculations for Short-term and long-term stresses The figure shows how an extensive layer of fill will be placed on a certain site. The unit weights are: clay and sand = 20kN/m³ , rolled fill 18kN/m³ , assume water = 10 kN/m³. Calculations are made for the total and effective stress at the mid-depth of the sand and the middepth of the clay for the following conditions: initially, before construction; immediately after construction; many years after construction. Initially, before construction Initial stresses at mid-depth of clay (z = 2.0m) Vertical total stress v = 20.0 x 2.0 = 40.0kPa Pore pressure u = 10 x 2.0 = 20.0kPa Vertical effective stress v v - u = 20.0kPa Immediately after construction The construction of the embankment applies a surface surcharge: q = 18 x 4 = 72.0 kPa. The sand is drained (either horizontally or into the rock below) and so there is no increase in pore pressure. The clay is undrained and the pore pressure increases by 72.0 kPa. Initial stresses at mid-depth of clay (z = 2.0m) Vertical total stress v = 20.0 x 2.0 + 72.0 = 112.0kPa Pore pressure u = 10 x 2.0 + 72.0 = 92.0 kPa Vertical effective stress - u = 20.0kPa (i.e. no change immediately) Initial stresses at mid-depth of sand (z = 5.0m) Vertical total stress v = 20.0 x 5.0 + 72.0 = 172.0kPa Pore pressure u = 10 x 5.0 = 50.0 kPa Vertical effective stress v v - u = 122.0kPa (i.e. an immediate increase) v v Many years after construction After many years, the excess pore pressures in the clay will have dissipated. The pore pressures will now be the same as they were initially. Initial stresses at mid-depth of clay (z = 2.0 m) Vertical total stress v = 20.0 x 2.0 + 72.0 = 112.0 kPa Pore pressure u = 10 x 2.0 = 20.0 kPa Vertical effective stress v v - u = 92.0 kPa (i.e. a long-term increase) Initial stresses at mid-depth of sand (z = 5.0 m) Vertical total stress v = 20.0 x 5.0 + 72.0 = 172.0 kPa Pore pressure u = 10 x 5.0 = 50.0 kPa Vertical effective stress v v - u = 122.0 kPa (i.e. no further change) Steady-state seepage conditions The figure shows seepage occurring around embedded sheet piling. In steady state, the hydraulic gradient, Then the effective stresses are: A = 20 x 3 - 2 x 10 + 0.4 x 10 = 44 kPa B = 20 x 3 - 2 x 10 - 0.4 x 10 = 36 kPa Drainage and volume change Solid soil grains are very stiff: their volume change under load can be ignored. Water or air can be squeezed out of soil under load. The loss of water from the soil is called drainage. The grains are rearranged and the volume of voids reduced. Volume compressibility under load Consider a volume (V) of soil in equilibrium under a constant total stress: o and the pore pressure is uo: o o - uo, Click the hypertext links to change the diagram Immediately after loading the total stress is increased by Howeve - Some time after loading drainage will have occurred: w) d the volume of the soil has Finally then: Drainage under load If drainage cannot take place when a soil is loaded the volume cannot change. In the oedometer test porous stones are placed above and below the sample, so that drainage is two-way: upward and downward. Under a concrete foundation drainage may only take place downward. In an embankment layers of sand can be placed to speed up drainage and thus changes in volume. The installation of vertical sand drains, called sandwicks, can further speed up volume change in embankments by allowing horizontal radial drainage. Click the hypertext links to change the diagram Permeability and time The rate of drainage of water from soil depends on the permeability. Volume change under load takes place quickly in sands and gravels, and very slowly in clays. Seepage is driven by the excess pore pressure and as this is dissipated the rate of seepage slows down. Thus, the rate of volume change is fast to begin with, but slows down with time. The volume-change/time curve is exponential. A simple approximate rule is: "half the total volume change occurs in one-tenth of the total time". Volume change under constant effective stress In saturated soil volume changes can only occur as drainage occurs and as effective stresses change. In unsaturated soils volume change is due to changes in water and air volume; both of which can change without change in effective stress. Compaction, in which air is expelled, can occur due to vibration (e.g. from traffic, machinery, piling, etc..); also, loosely-placed fill can compact under its own weight. Shrinking and swelling can occur in some clays near the surface due to climatic changes (shrinking in summer, swelling in winter). Creep occurs in some clay soils due to gradual changes in fabric. Drained and undrained loading The relative rates of the increase of total stress and drainage are of critical importance in determining soil behaviour and predicting future conditions and changes. If the rate of drainage is quicker than the rate of loading, effective stress and volume changes occur quickly - these are called drained loading conditions. In drained loading the pore pressures are always in equilibrium - if construction stops the pore pressures will remain constant and there are no more volume changes. If the rate of drainage is slower than the rate of loading, the pore pressure increases and the effective stress and volume remain unchanged - these are undrained loading conditions. In undrained loading of saturated soil there is no volume change - if construction stops the excess pore pressures dissipate, consolidation occurs then the volume changes. Drained loading conditions Under fully drained conditions the pore pressure does not change, Thus, volume decrease will follow loading increase, i.e. increase in total stress. Drained loading conditions may be assumed to occur when either the soil has a high permeability (e.g. in sands and gravels), or the loading rate is slow (e.g. natural erosion). drained or undrained conditions. Undrained loading conditions Under undrained conditions there can be no volume change, since water cannot escape. From a practical point of view undrained loading occurs: in a laboratory test (e.g. triaxial) when drainage is prevented; and in field situations where loading changes occur quickly on soils of low permeability. In a saturated soil, the increase in total stress produces an equal increase in pore pressure: u = uo As drainage occurs, u decreases and so does the volume. At an elapsed time t: ut = uo t, - Dut and t Vt = Vo t Eventually, when all of the excess pore pressure has dissipated, equilibrium is regained and steady-state pore pressure conditions prevail: u = uo and o Consolidation The dissipation of excess pore pressure, accompanied by volume change is called consolidation. Usually (but not always) the total stress remains constant (e.g. under a foundation) and the pore pressure and volume slowly change. The rate of consolidation (volume change with seepage) is dependent on the permeability of the soil and the size of the consolidating layer. Transient undrained conditions prevail during consolidation, but eventually, when all of the excess pore pressure has been dissipated, conditions are the same as those for drained loading. Swelling will occur during unloading as water is sucked back into the soil. Rates of loading and seepage In any geotechnical calculation (analysis or design) it is important to distinguish between drained and undrained loading - soils behave quite differently in the two sets of conditions. In making this distinction it is the relative rates of loading and seepage that must be considered. Seepage rates depend on the coefficient of permeability which is related mainly to grain size: For design purposes it is common to assume quick seepage in coarse soils and slow seepage in fine soils. soil type coeff. of permeability (k) seepage rate gravel > 10-2 sand -2 10 ~ 10 silt 10-5 ~ 10-8 -8 very quick -5 quick slow clay < 10 very slow Different rates of loading arise from different natural events or construction operations. Very rapid loading rates may occur in earthquakes, due to piling and due to wave action. Event/Operation Duration Shock wave - piling <1 s Shock wave - earthquake 1-2 s Wave breaking against wall 5 - 10 s Trench excavation 1 - 3 hours Small building foundation 5 - 20 days Large excavation or building 1 - 6 months Construction of dam or embankment 1 - 3 years Filling of reservoir 2 - 5 years Natural erosion > 50 years Volume change Saturated soil contains only mineral grains and water. Both are relatively incompressible so the volume can only change if water can drain out. In unsaturated soil volume changes can occur as air compresses or bleeds out. In both cases loading will bring the grains closer together and the specific volume will reduce. 1. 2. 3. 4. Reduction in volume leads to increase in strength increase in stiffness settlement of foundations If soil is unloaded it will swell as the grains move apart. Swelling leads to reduction in strength and stiffness and heave of excavations. Compression and swelling The relationship between volume change and effective stress is called compression and swelling. (Consolidation and compaction are different.) The volume of soil grains remains constant, so change in volume is due to change in volume of water. Compression and swelling results from drained loading and the pore pressure remains constant. If saturated soil is loaded undrained there will be no volume change. Mechanisms of compression Compression of soil is due to a number of mechanisms: rearrangement of grains fracture and rearrangement of grains distortion or bending of grains On unloading, grains will not unfracture or un-rearrange, so volume change on unloading and reloading (swelling and recompression) will be much less than volume change on first loading (compression). In compression, soil behaviour is: non-linear mostly irrecoverable Common cases of compression and swelling In practice, the state of stress in the ground will be complex. These are simple theories for two special cases. Isotropic: Equal stress in all directions. Applicable to triaxial test before shearing. a r) / 3 = mean stress v o = volumetric strain One-dimensional: Horizontal strains are zero. Applicable to oedometer test and in the ground below wide foundations, embankments and excavations. z = vertical stress / Vo v o o) = volumetric strain Isotropic compression and swelling Equations Overconsolidation State Isotropic compression and swelling is applied at the start of a triaxial test. a r) / 3 = mean stress V = Vo w = volume v o o = volumetric strain v = V / Vs = specific volume As the mean stress p' is raised and lowered there are volumetric strains and the specific volume changes. p'o = initial mean stress vo = initial specific volume Note the paths of compression, swelling and re-loading. Equations For isotropic compression and swelling there are simple relationships between specific volume v and (the natural logarithm of) the mean stress p'. First loading normal compression line OAD on the graph v=NUnloading and reloading swelling line BC on the graph v = vk vk and p'y locate the particular swelling line. p'y is referred to as the yield stress. If the current stress and the history of loading/unloading are known, the current specific volume can be calculated. Bulk modulus Isotropic compression can be represented by a bulk modulus K' or by the slope of the normal ted. v v=Ndv / v = Bulk modulus K' depends on v and p'. Both of these will change during compression or swelling and so K' is not a soil constant. Typical values for isotropic compression parameters the nature of the soil. Typical values very high plasticity clay high plasticity clay intermediate plasticity clay low plasticity clay quartz sand carbonate sand For clays p / 170. wL 80 60 42 30 Ip 50 34 23 12 l 0.29 0.20 0.14 0.07 0.15 0.34 - 0.35) because clay particles can bend and distort. For sands pressure). compression. Overconsolidation If the current state of soil is on the normal compression line it is said to be normally consolidated. If the soil is unloaded it becomes overconsolidated. (Soil cannot usually be at a state outside the normal compression line unless it is bonded or structured). At a state A the overconsolidation ratio is Rp = p'y / p'a (on NCL Rp = 1.0 and soil is normally consolidated). Note: p'y is the point of intersection of the swelling line through A and the NCL. This is usually close to the maximum past stress. State The current state of a soil is described by the stress p', the specific volume v and the overconsolidation ratio Rp (for a complete description the shear stress q' is required). The state at A is given by any two of va , p'a , Rp = p'y / p'a All states with the same Rp fall on the lines parallel with the NCL. ln Rp = ln ( p'y / p'a ) = ln p'y - ln p'a Many features of soil behaviour, especially shear modulus and peak strength, increase with increasing overconsolidation. Back to Isotropic compression: state Change of state Loading and unloading (relevant to all soils) Change of state A to B can only be achieved by normal compression along CD followed by swelling along DB. Note that the yield stress corresponding to B is larger than the yield stress corresponding to A. Vibration or compaction (relevant to sands) or creep (relevant to clays) Change of state can occur directly from A to B. Note that the yield stress corresponding to B is larger than the yield stress corresponding to A. Critical state There is a critical overconsolidation ratio which separates states in which the soil will either compress or dilate during shear. This corresponds to the critical state line CSL. Look at the possible specific volumes (v) that can occur at a mean effective stress p'. wet side of critical (W on the graph) vw > vc at stress p' water content ww is larger than critical wc · loose · normally consolidated or lightly overconsolidated · compress during drained shear dry side of critical (D on the graph) vd < vc at stress p' water content wd is smaller than critical wc · dense · heavily overconsolidated · dilate during drained shear Back to Isotropic compression: state Normalising parameters Normalising parameters change the current state to a normalised state so that all states with the same overconsolidation ratio have the same value. Equivalent specific volume vl = va + ln p'a Equivalent pressure ln p'e = ( N - va ) / Critical pressure ln p'c = ( - va ) / If A is on the wet side of critical ve p'a / p'c > 1 If A is on the dry side of critical ve p'a / p'c < 1 One-dimensional compression and swelling One-dimensional loading is applied in an oedometer and occurs in the ground beneath wide foundations, embankments or excavations. z = vertical effective stress H = height or thickness vertical strain = volumetric strain v o o) where Ho, eo o are initial values. z is raised and lowered the top of the sample settles or heaves, or the layer contracts or expands. Note that the compression-swelling-recompression curve is similar to that for isotropic z, e) rather than (p', v). Equations For one-dimensional compression and swelling there are simple relationships between the void z. First loading: normal compression line (NCL) OAD on the graph e = eN - Cc z Unloading and reloading: swelling-recompression line (SRL) BC on the graph e = ek - Cs z · eN, Cc and Cs are soil parameters · ek y locate a particular swelling line o and the history of loading and unloading are known, the current void ratio can be calculated. e.g. eo = eN - Cc 'o ) y + Cs y- One-dimensional modulus and compressibility The one-dimensional stiffness modulus is the slope of the stress/strain curve: z v or E'o z z h = 0) The reciprocal of stiffness is compressibility. The one-dimensional coefficient of compressibility is the slope of the strain/stress curve: mv z (1+e)) = 1 / E'o E'o and mv apply for the normal compression line and for swelling and recompression lines, and depend on the current state, on the history and on the increment of loading, so they are not soil constants. Since mv z z = 100kPa. Overconsolidation If the current state of soil is on the normal compression line it is said to be normally consolidated. If the soil is unloaded it becomes overconsolidated. Soil cannot usually be at a state outside the normal compression line unless it is bonded or structured. At a state A the overconsolidation ratio is Ro y a soil is normally consolidated). intersection of the swelling line through A but not always, close to the maximum past (on NCL Ro = 1.0 and y is the point of and the NCL. This is usually, stress (see change of state). Horizontal stress in one-dimensional loading During one-dim h h will change since = 0) is imposed. The ratio Ko h z is known as the coefficient of earth pressure at rest. Ko depends on · the type of soil · the overconsolidation ratio (Ro) · the loading or unloading cycle Approximations normally consolidated soils: Konc » 1 c overconsolidated soils: Ko » Konc ÖRo State ratio Ro The state at A is given by any two of ea a , Ro y a All states with the same Ro fall on the lines parallel with the NCL. log Ro y a) ya Many features of soil behaviour, especially shear modulus and peak strength, increase with increasing overconsolidation. Change of state (relevant to all Loading and unloading soils) Change of state A to B can only be achieved by normal compression along CD followed by swelling along DB. Note that the yield stress corresponding to B is larger than the yield stress corresponding to A. Vibration or compaction (relevant to sands) or creep: (relevant to clays) Change of state can occur directly from A to B. Note that the yield stress corresponding to B is larger than the yield stress corresponding to A. Critical state There is a critical overconsolidation ratio which separates states in which the soil will either compress or dilate during shear. This corresponds to the critical state line CSL. Look at the possible voids ratios (e) that can o a. wet side of critical (W on the graph) ew > ec water content ww is larger than critical wc · loose · normally consolidated or lightly overconsolidated · compress during drained shear dry side of critical (D on the graph) ed < ec water content wd is smaller than critical wc · dense · heavily overconsolidated · dilate during drained shear Normalising parameters Normalising parameters change the current state to a normalised state so that all states with the same overconsolidation ratio have the same value. Equivalent void ratio el = ea + Cc a Equivalent stress e = ( eN - ea ) / Cc Critical stress c = ( eG - ea ) / Cc If A is on the wet side of critical el > eG >1 If A is on the dry side of critical el < eG a c<1 a c Wet and dry states State parameters Soils whose states lie on the normal compression line (NCL) are normally consolidated. There is a critical overconsolidation ratio that corresponds with the critical state line (CSL). A lightly overconsolidated soil has a state which lies above the CSL. A heavily overconsolidated soil has a state which lies below the CSL. States lying above the CSL are said to be on the wet side of critical. States lying below the CSL are said to be on the dry side of critical. In the diagrams: va > vb, and yet since the stress at B is greater, state B is on the wet side of critical, while state A is on the dry side of critical. Wet and dry states State parameters Soils whose states lie on the normal compression line (NCL) are normally consolidated. There is a critical overconsolidation ratio that corresponds with the critical state line (CSL). A lightly overconsolidated soil has a state which lies above the CSL. A heavily overconsolidated soil has a state which lies below the CSL. States lying above the CSL are said to be on the wet side of critical. States lying below the CSL are said to be on the dry side of critical. In the diagrams: va > vb, and yet since the stress at B is greater, state B is on the wet side of critical, while state A is on the dry side of critical. State parameters A measure of the initial state of a soil are the distances it lies at from the CSL, in terms of either volume or stress. These distances are expressed as state parameters: Stress state parameter Ss = pa' / pc' ln Ss = ln pa' - ln pc' Volume state parameter Sv = va - vc The state parameters are related: Sv = ln Ss Normally consolidated state: Sv s=0 States on the wet side of critical: Sv and ln Ss are positive States on the dry side of critical: Sv and ln Ss are negative Consolidation When soil is loaded undrained, the pore pressures increase. Then, under site conditions, the excess pore pressures dissipate and water leaves the soil, resulting in consolidation settlement. This process takes time, and the rate of settlement decreases over time. The amount of settlement which occurs in a given time depends on the 1. permeability of the soil 2. length of the drainage path 3. compressibility of the soil If soil is unloaded (e.g. by excavation) the excess pore pressures may be negative. The process of consolidation and settlement In coarse soils (sands and gravels) any volume change resulting from a change in loading occurs immediately; increases in pore pressures are dissipated rapidly due to high permeability. This is called drained loading. In fine soils (silts and clays) - with low permeabilities - the soil is undrained as the load is applied. Slow seepage occurs and the excess pore pressures dissipate slowly, consolidation settlement occurs. The rate of volume change diminishes with time; about one-half of the total consolidation settlement occurs in one-tenth of the total time. The basic consolidation process and terminology Consider a site on clay soil with initial steady-state groundwater conditions. An embankment is built, the loading is undrained: the pore pressure in the soil increases, seepage flow and therefore volume changes commences. As consolidation takes place, settlement occurs, and continues at a decreasing rate until steady-state conditions are regained. Click on the buttons to see the sequence of loading and pore pressure changes. Terms and symbols Seepage refers to the flow of groundwater in a saturated soil. q = rate of seepage flow Excess pore pressure ( ) is the difference between the current pore pressure (u) and the steady state pore pressure (uo). = u - uo Hydraulic gradient (i) is the difference in total head between two points in the soil. Permeability or the coefficient of permeability (k) relates to flow in a given direction, i.e. along a given drainage path. One-dimensional consolidation A general theory for consolidation, incorporating three-dimensional flow vectors is complicated and only applicable to a very limited range of problems in geotechnical engineering. For the vast majority of practical settlement problems, it is sufficient to consider that both seepage and strains take place in one direction only; this usually being vertical. One-dimensional consolidation specifically occurs when there is no lateral strain, e.g. in theoedometer test One-dimensional consolidation can be assumed to be occurring under wide foundations. One-dimensional consolidation theory A simple one-dimensional consolidation model consists of rectilinear element of soil subject to vertical changes in loading and through which vertical (only) seepage flow is taking place. There are three variables: 1. the excess pore pressure ( ) 2. the depth of the element in the layer (z) 3. the time elapsed since application of the loading (t) The total stress on the element is assumed to remain constant. The coefficient of volume compressibility (mv) is assumed to be constant. The coefficient of permeability (k) for vertical flow is assumed to be constant. Mathematical model and equation Consider the element of consolidating soil. In time : · the seepage flow is (q = A k i = A k · the change in excess pressure is · the thickness changes by = -mv ´ It can be shown that the basic equation for one-dimensional consolidation is: By defining the coefficient of consolidation as this can be written: Isochrones Solutions to the one-dimensional consolidation equation can be obtained by plotting the variation of with the depth in the layer at given elapsed times. The resulting curves are called isochrones. (Gk. iso = equal; kronos = time) The figure shows a set of supposed standpipes inserted into a consolidating layer. Before loading, the pore pressure in the drain is zero. At the base of each standpipe there is some initial pore pressure u= uo, the excess pore pressure = 0. Immediately after the loading is applied the standpipes will each show an initial excess pore pressure of i, thereafter the excess pore pressure will dissipate. Click on the following time intervals to observe the changes in across the thickness of the layer with time. 1. Before loading = 0 2. Initial (after loading) when time = 0 3. 0 < time < tc 4. time = tc (still no change at the bottom) 5. tc < time < t¥ 6. Finally at time = ¥ Adjacent to the drain (at the top) the excess pore pressure drops to zero almost immediately At the bottom of the layer the dissipation is quite slow. Some properties of isochrones The gradient of an isochrone is related to the hydraulic gradient (i): At the drainage surface, isochrones are steepest and = 0. At the impermeable (k = 0) base the seepage velocity is zero since V = ki; the isochrones will therefore be at 90° to the impermeable boundary. Between two isochrones the change in thickness in time -mv , 2 - t1 is the shaded area. Thus, the settlement at the surface of the layer is given by: v area OAB Terzaghi's solution The basic equation is (z,t) is excess pore pressure at depth z after time t. The solution depends on the boundary conditions: The general solution is obtained for an overall (average) degree of consolidation using nondimensional factors. General solution The following non-dimensional factors are used in order to obtain a solution: · Degree of consolidation at depth z · Time factor · Drainage path ratio The differential equation can now be written as: If the excess pore pressure is uniform with depth, the solution is: Putting Ut t Drainage path length During consolidation water escapes from the soil to the surface or to a permeable sub-surface layer above or below (where = 0). The rate of consolidation depends on the longest path taken by a drop of water. The length of this longest path is the drainage path length, d. Typical cases are: An open layer, a permeable layer both above and below (d = H/2) A half-closed layer, a permeable layer either above or below (d = H) Vertical sand drains, horizontal drainage (d = L/2) One-dimensional consolidation theory Solution using parabolic isochrones Isochrones can be approximated to parabolas, affording reasonably accurate solutions to the differential equation for one-dimensional consolidation. Solutions must be obtained for two separate, but adjoining, cases: · When the elapsed time (t) is less than the critical time (tc) · When the elapsed time (t) is greater than the critical time (tc) The critical time is the time that must elapse before the excess pore pressures at the impermeable base first begin to dissipate. Solution for t < tc case Putting time factor and average degree of consolidation, the general solution is This is valid for 0 < t < tc At t = tc, n = H = Giving and Ut = 0.3333 Solution for t > tc case Putting time factor and average degree of consolidation, the general solution is This is valid for tc < t < t¥ At t = tc, n = H = Giving and Ut = 0.3333 The oedometer test Apparatus and procedure The one-dimensional compression and swelling characteristics of a soil may be measured in the laboratory using the oedometer test (from the Greek: oidema = a swelling). A cylindrical specimen of soil enclosed in a metal ring is subjected to a series of increasing static loads, while changes in thickness are recorded against time. From the changes in thickness at the end of each load stage the compressibility of the soil may be observed, and parameters measured such as Compression Index (Cc) and Coefficient of Volume Compressibility (mv). From the changes in thickness recorded against time during a load stage the rate of consolidation may be observed and the coefficient of consolidation (cv) measured. The test is fully detailed in BS 1377. Apparatus and procedure The saturated specimen is usually 75 mm diameter and 15-20 mm thick, enclosed in a circular metal ring and sandwiched between porous stones. Vertical static load increments are applied at regular time intervals (e.g. 12, 24, 48 hr.). The load is doubled with each increment up to the required maximum (e.g. 25, 50, 100, 200, 400, 800 kPa). During each load stage thickness changes are recorded against time. After full consolidation is reached under the final load, the loads are removed (in one or several stages - to a low nominal value close to zero) and the specimen allowed to swell, after which the specimen is removed and its thickness and water content determined. With a porous stone both above and below the soil specimen the drainage will be two-way (i.e. an open layer in which the drainage path length, d = H/2) Determination of cv from test results The recorded thickness changes during one of the load stages in an oedometer test are used to evaluate the coefficient of consolidation (cv). The procedure involves plotting thickness changes (i.e. settlement) against a suitable function of time [either Ötime or log(time)] and then fitting to this the theoretical Tv:Ut curve. In this way known intercepts of Tv:Ut are located from which cv may be calculated. The Root-Time method The first portion of the curve of settlement against Ötime is approximately a straight line. The U0 (Ut = 0) point is located at the intercept with the Ut axis. A second point is required: suppose this is U90/Öt90 (point C). The location of this point depends on the equation for the curved portion [See curve fitting methods: Terzaghi or parabolic isochrones]. Once U90 has been located other values follow since the Ut axis scale is linear. The coefficient of consolidation is therefore: where d = drainage path length [d = H for one-way drainage, d = H/2 for two-way drainage] Other appropriate time-interval values could be used: e.g. U50, ÖT50, Öt50 , etc. Curve fitting based on Terzaghi's equation From Terzaghi’s analysis, the straight-line portion is: For 0 < Ut < 0.6, On the straight line: ÖT90 On the curved portion: ÖT90 = AC = Ö0.848 = 0.9209 Thus, a line drawn through points O and C has abscissae 1.15 times greater than those of the straight line (OB). [0.9209/0.7976 = 1.15] After the laboratory results curve has been plotted, line OB is drawn, followed by line OC: this crosses the laboratory curve at point (ÖT90,U90) and locates Öt90 The coefficient of consolidation is therefore: Curve fitting based on parabolic isochrones From the parabola equation the straight-line portion is: For 0 < Ut < 0.333, On the straight line: ÖT90 = AB = 0.9 x Ö(3/4) = 0.7794 On the curved portion: ÖT90 = AC = Ö0.716 = 0.8462 Thus, a line drawn through points O and C has abscissae 1.086 times greater than those of the straight line (OB). [0.8462/0.7794 = 1.086] After the laboratory results curve has been plotted, line OB is drawn, followed by line OC: this crosses the laboratory curve at point (ÖT90,U90) and locates Öt90 The coefficient of consolidation is therefore: The Log-Time method An alternative to the Root-Time method, that is particularly useful when there is significant secondary compression (creep). The Uo point is located by selected two points on the curve for which the times (t) are in the ratio 1:4, e.g. 1 min and 4 min; or 2 min and 8 min.; the vertical intervals AP and PQ will be equal. The U100 point can be located in the final part of the curve flattens sufficiently (i.e. no secondary compression). When there is significant secondary compression, U100 may be located at the intercept of straight line drawn through the middle and final portions of the curve. Now U50 and log t50 can be located. The coefficient of consolidation is therefore: Calculation of settlement times After the coefficient of consolidation (cv) has been determined from laboratory data calculations are possible for site settlements. It is important to note that cv is not a constant, but varies with both the level of stress and degree of consolidation. For practical site settlement calculations, however, it is sufficiently accurate to measure cv relative to the loading range applicable on site and then assume this value to be approximately constant for all degrees of consolidation (except for very low values). The basic equation used is: where d = drainage path length [d = H for one-way drainage, d = H/2 for two-way drainage] Tv and t are coupled to a given degree of consolidation Prediction of time for given settlement Example The final consolidation settlement of a layer of clay 5.0 m thick is calculated to be 280mm. The coefficient of consolidation for the loading range is 0.955 mm²/min. There is two-way drainage, upward and downward. Calculate the time required for (a) 90% consolidation settlement, (b) a settlement of 100 mm. (a) Drainage path length, d = 5.0/2 = 2.50 m = 2500 mm For U90, T90 = 0.848. Then (b) For 100 mm settlement, Ut = 100/280 = 0.357 and since Ut < 0.6, Tv = 0.357² x Then time for 100mm settlement Prediction of settlement amount at given time Example A layer of clay has a thickness of 4.0 m and drains both upward and downward. A laboratory test has yielded a coefficient of consolidation for the appropriate loading range of 0.675 mm²/min. The final consolidation settlement has been calculated to be 120mm. Provide estimates of the consolidation settlement that may be expected 1yr, 2yr, 5yr and 10yr after construction. Drainage path length, d = 2000 mm When Ut < 0.6, use Ut = Ö(4Tv/ When Ut > 0.6, cv = 0.645 mm²/min = 928.8 mm²/day time t time t Tv Ut Ut rc (mm) (years) (days) = cvt/d² (<0.6) (>0.6) at time t 1 365 0.0848 0.328 39 2 730 0.1965 0.465 56 5 1825 0.4238 0.735 0.715 86 10 3650 0.8475 0.900 108 23.6 8613 2.0 0.994 119 Reliability for design purposes Laboratory measurements of stress-strain parameters (Cc, Cs, mv) are generally acceptable, provided sampling quality is good, e.g. minimal disturbance, valid representation of strata, maintenance of structure and water content, careful preparation, etc. Measurements of strain/time relationships (cv) and permeability (k) are not so reliable. Observed rates of settlement are generally greater than values based on oedometer test results. Reliability is compromised by factors such anisotropy (e.g. silt/sand layers, varves, fissures, etc), presence of roots, organic matter and voids, and also the effects of secondary compression. Loads are not often applied instantaneously, and so due allowance should be for the gradual application of loading. Secondary compression or creep In some soils (especially recent organic soils) one-dimensional compression continues under constant loading after all of the excess pore pressure has dissipated, i.e. after primary consolidation has ceased - this is called secondary compression or creep. It is generally thought that creep is due to changes in soil structure, although no reliable theory has been proposed as yet. It is likely that some creep is occurring due primary consolidation, affecting the linearity of the r/Ötime curve and thus making the accurate prediction of settlement difficult and possibly unreliable. For practical purposes, the Log-Time plot (described elsewhere) can be used to estimate a . Coefficient of secondary compression The amount of secondary compression is the settlement occurring after t100, i.e. after full dissipation of excess pressures a (or sa). 100 can be approximated to a straight line, the slope of which gives the coefficient of secondary compression (Ca). The slope of the laboratory curve is measured over one log-time cycle, e.g.1000 to 10000 mins. Overconsolidation due to creep Creep (secondary compression) is basically similar to compaction, except it takes place slowly. The result of creep is a change in volume (also water content and void ratio). The soil is in effect further consolidated, and therefore if unloaded is left overconsolidated. The phenomenon of overconsolidation due to creep is noticeable in soft clays. Compaction Compaction is a process that brings about an increase in soil density or unit weight, accompanied by a decrease in air volume. There is usually no change in water content. The degree of compaction is measured by dry unit weight and depends on the water content and compactive effort (weight of hammer, number of impacts, weight of roller, number of passes). For a given compactive effort, the maximum dry unit weight occurs at an optimum water content. Compaction purposes and processes Compaction is a process of increasing soil density and removing air, usually by mechanical means. The size of the individual soil particles does not change, neither is water removed. Purposeful compaction is intended to improve the strength and stiffness of soil. Consequential (or accidental) compaction, and thus settlement, can occur due to vibration (piling, traffic, etc.) or selfweight of loose fill. Compaction as a construction process Compaction is employed in the construction of road bases, runways, earth dams, embankments and reinforced earth walls. In some cases, compaction may be used to prepare a level surface for building construction. Soil is placed in layers, typically 75 mm to 450 mm thick. Each layer is compacted to a specified standard using rollers, vibrators or rammers. Refer also to Types of compaction plant and Specification and quality control Objectives of compaction Compaction can be applied to improve the properties of an existing soil or in the process of placing fill. The main objectives are to: increase shear strength and therefore bearing capacity increase stiffness and therefore reduce future settlement decrease voids ratio and so permeability, thus reducing potential frost heave Factors affecting compaction A number of factors will affect the degree of compaction that can be achieved: Nature and type of soil, i.e. sand or clay, grading, plasticity Water content at the time of compaction Site conditions, e.g. weather, type of site, layer thickness Compactive effort: type of plant (weight, vibration, number of passes) Types of compaction plant Construction traffic, especially caterpillar-tracked vehicles, is also used. In the UK. further information can be obtained from the Department of Transport and handbooks on civil engineering construction methods. Smooth-wheeled roller Self-propelled or towed steel rollers ranging from 2 - 20 tonnes Suitable for: well-graded sands and gravels silts and clays of low plasticity Unsuitable for: uniform sands; silty sands; soft clays Grid roller Towed units with rolls of 30-50 mm bars, with spaces between of 90-100 mm Masses range from 5-12 tonnes Suitable for: well-graded sands; soft rocks; stony soils with fine fractions Unsuitable for: uniform sands; silty sands; very soft clays Sheepsfoot roller Also known as a 'tamping roller' Self propelled or towed units, with hollow drum fitted with projecting club-shaped 'feet' Mass range from 5-8 tonnes Suitable for: fine grained soils; sands and gravels, with >20% fines Unsuitable for: very coarse soils; uniform gravels Pneumatic-tyred roller Usually a container on two axles, with rubber-tyred wheels. Wheels aligned to give a full-width rolled track. Dead loads are added to give masses of 12-40 tonnes. Suitable for: most coarse and fine soils. Unsuitable for: very soft clay; highly variable soils. Vibrating plate Range from hand-guided machines to larger roller combinations Suitable for: most soils with low to moderate fines content Unsuitable for: large volume work; wet clayey soils Power rammer Also called a 'trench tamper' Hand-guided pneumatic tamper Suitable for: work in confined Unsuitable for: Laboratory trench back-fill; areas large volume work compaction tests The variation in compaction with water content and compactive effort is first established in the laboratory. Target values are then specified for the dry density and/or air-voids content to be achieved on site. Dry-density/water-content relationship The aim of the test is to establish the maximum dry density that may be attained for a given soil with a standard amount of compactive effort. When a series of samples of a soil are compacted at different water content the plot usually shows a distinct peak. The maximum dry density occurs at an optimum water content The curve is drawn with axes of dry density and water content and the controlling values are values read off: d(max) = maximum dry density wopt = optimum water content Different curves are obtained for different compactive efforts Explanation of the shape of the curve For clays Recently excavated and generally saturated lumps of clayey soil have a relatively high undrained shear strength at low water contents and are difficult to compact. As water content increases, the lumps weaken and soften and maybe compacted more easily. For coarse soils The material is unsaturated and derives strength from suction in pore water which collects at grain contacts. As the water content increases, suctions, and hence effective stresses decrease. The soil weaken, and is therefore more easily compacted. For both At relatively high water contents, the compacted soil is nearly saturated (nearly all of the air has been removed) and so the compactive effort is in effect applying undrained loading and so the void volume does not decrease; as the water content increases the compacted density achieved will decrease, with the air content remaining almost constant. Expressions for calculating density A compacted sample is weighed to determine its mass: M (grams) The volume of the mould is: V (ml) Sub-samples are taken to determine the water content: w The calculations are: Worked example A compacted soil sample has been weighed with the following results: Mass = 1821 g Volume = 950 ml Water content = 9.2% Determine the bulk and dry densities. Bulk density d = 1.917 / (1+0.092) = 1.754 Mg/m³ Dry density and air-voids content A fully saturated soil has zero air content. In practice, even quite wet soil will have a small air content The maximum dry density is controlled by both the water content and the air-voids content. Curves for different aird / w plot using this expression: The air-voids content corresponding to the maximum dry density and optimum water content can d/w plot or calculated from the expression (see the worked example). Worked example Determine the dry densities of a compacted soil sample at a water content of 12%, with air-voids contents of zero, 5% and 10%. (Gs = 2.68). Effect of increased compactive effort The compactive effort will be greater when using a heavier rammer in the compactive effort: heavier roller on site or a laboratory. With greater maximum dry optimum water content decreases air-voids content remains almost the same. density increases Effect of soil type Well-graded granular soils can be compacted to higher densities than uniform or silty soils. Clays of high plasticity may have water contents over 30% and achieve similar densities (and therefore strengths) to those of lower plasticity with water contents below 20%. As the % of fines and the plasticity of a soil increses, the compaction curve becomes flatter and therefore less sensitive to moisture content. Equally, the maximum dry density will be relatively low. Interpretation of laboratory data During the test, data is collected: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Volume of mould (V) Mass of mould (Mo) Specific gravity of the soil grain (Gs) Mass of mould + compacted soil - for each sample (M) Water content of each sample (w) d / w curve is plotted together with the air-voids curves. The maximum dry density and optimum water content are read off the plot. The air content at the optimum water content is either read off or calculated. Example data collected during test In a typical compaction test the following data might have been collected: Mass of mould, Mo = 1082 g d Volume of mould, V = 950 ml Specific gravity of soil grains, Gs = 2.70 Mass of mould + soil (g) 2833 2979 Water content (%) 3080 3092 3064 3027 8.41 10.62 12.88 14.41 16.59 18.62 Calculated densities and density curve The expressions used are: 1.84 Water content, w d (Mg/m³) 2.00 2.10 2.12 2.09 2.05 0.084 0.106 0.129 0.144 0.166 0.186 1.70 1.81 1.86 Air-voids curves The expression used is: Water content (%) 10 12 14 16 18 20 d when Av = 0% 2.13 2.04 1.96 1.89 1.82 1.75 d when Av = 5% 2.02 1.94 1.86 1.79 1.73 1.67 d when Av = 10% 1.91 1.84 1.76 1.70 1.64 1.58 1.851 1.79 1.73 The optimum air-voids content is the value corresponding to the maximum dry density (1.86 Mg/m³) and optimum water content (12.9%). Specification and quality control The degree of compaction achievable on site depends mainly on: Compactive effort: type of plant + No of passes -versa -graded soils; fine soils have higher water contents End-result specifications require predictable conditions Method specifications are preferred in UK. End-result specifications Target parameters are specified based on laboratory test results: Optimum water content working range, i.e. ± 2% Optimum air-voids content tolerance, i.e. ± 1.5% For soils wetter than wopt, the target Av can be used, e.g. 10% for bulk earthworks 5% for important work The end-result method is unsuitable for very wet or variable conditions. Method specifications A site procedure is specified giving: type of plant and its mass maximum layer thickness and number of passes. This type of specification is more suitable for soils wetter than wopt or where site conditions are variable - this is often the case in the UK. The Department of Transport publishes a widely used method specification for use in the UK. Moisture condition value This is a procedure developed by the Road Research Laboratory using only one sample, thus making laboratory compaction testing quicker and simpler. The minimum compactive effort to produce near-full compaction is determined. Soil placed in a mould is compacted by blows from a rammer dropping 250 mm; the penetration after each blow is measured. Apparatus and sizes Cylindrical mould, with permeable base plate: internal diameter = 100 mm, internal height at least 200 mm Rammer, with a flat face: face diam = 97 mm, mass = 7.5 kg, free-fall height = 250 mm Soil: 1.5 kg passing a 20 mm mesh sieve Test procedure and plot Firstly, the rammer is lowered on to the soil surface and allowed to penetrate under its own weight The rammer is then set to a height of 250 mm and dropped on to the soil The penetration is measured to 0.1 mm The rammer height is reset to 250 mm and the drop repeated until no further penetration occurs, or until 256 drops have occurred The change in penetration ) is recorded between that for a given number of blows (n) and that for 4n blows A graph is plotted of / n and a line drawn through the steepest part The moisture condition value (MCV) is give by the intercept of this line and a special scale Example plot and determination of MCV After plotting against the number of blows n, a line is drawn through the steepest part. The intercept of this line and the 5 mm penetration line give the MCV The defining equation is:MCV = 10 log B (where B = number of blows corresponding to 5 mm penetration) On the example plot here an MCV of 13 is indicated. Significance of MCV in earthworks The MCV test is rapid and gives reproducible results which correlate well with engineering properties. The relationship between MCV and water content for a soil is near to a straight line, except for heavily overconsolidated clays.A desired value of undrained strength or compressibility can be related to limiting water content, and so the MCV can be used as a control value after calibrating MCV vs w for the soil. An approximate correlation between MCV and undrained shear strength has been suggested by Parsons (1981). Log su = 0.75 + 0.11(MCV) Shear strength Near any geotechnical construction (e.g. slopes, excavations, tunnels and foundations) there will be both mean and normal stresses and shear stresses. The mean or normal stresses cause volume change due to compression or consolidation. The shear stresses prevent collapse and help to support the geotechnical structure. Shear stress may cause volume change. Failure will occur when the shear stress exceeds the limiting shear stress (strength). Common cases of shearing Back to Shear strength In practice, the state of stress in the ground will be complex. There are simple theories for two special cases. Triaxial (axial symmetry) Parameters used for analysis: · deviator stress · shear strain · normal stress · volumetric strain · specific volume Direct or simple shear Parameters used for analysis: · shear stress · shear strain · normal stress · volumetric (normal) strain · void ratio It is not possible to draw a Mohr circle for a shear test unless stresses on vertical planes are measured. Strength Back to Shear strength In very simple terms, the strength of soil is the maximum shear stress ( f) it can sustain, or the shear stress acting on a shear slip surface along which it is failing. There are three distinct strengths: peak, critical (or ultimate) and residual. Shearing may be simple or direct. Drained direct (ring) shear Drained simple shear We explore the relationship between the maximum shear stress and the effective normal stress ( f Some aspects of the behaviour show up more clearly if we normalise f Back to Strength Peak strength The peak strength is the maximum value of the shear stress or the maximum value of the ratio of shear stress to effective mean or normal stress. For drained tests these will occur simultaneously, for undrained tests they may occur at different points and the definition used here is the maximum stress ratio. Peak strengths can only occur at shear stresses above the critical state line and at water contents below the CSL. Peak states can occur anywhere in the regions above and below the CSL. Peak states at the same water content fall on unique smoth envelopes. The peak states can be represented on a graph in 3 dimensions. All peak states fall on a surface in this graph. Peak strength in shear tests The circle represent the results of a set of shear tests on samples at the same moisture content but different normal stresses. The squares represent the results of a second set of tests at a different moisture content. We normalise the data by plotti against / f/ The basic peak states, before normalisation, fall on different curves each for a particular water content or void ratio. After normalisation all the peak states fall on a single unique envelope. Equations At a given water content or void ratio, all the peak states fall on a single smooth envelope. This may be represented in one of two ways: As a power law p As a linear (Mohr-Coulomb) envelope if the curvature is relatively small over a given range. p = c'p p The parameters a, B and c'p p depend on the water content or void ratio. Even at a given water content or voids ratio, the parameters c'p depend on the range of stress for linear approximation. p Peak strength in triaxial tests The basic peak states, before normalisation, fall on different curves each for a particular water content or specific volume. After normalisation all the peak states fall on a single unique envelope. equations At a given water content or specific volume all the peak states fall on a single smooth envelope. This may be represented in one of two ways: As a power law As a linear envelope if the curvature is relatively small over a given range. q'p = Gp + Hp p' p, Hp depend on the water content or voids ratio. Even at a given water content or voids ratio, the parameters Gp and Hp depend on the range of stress for linear approximation. Peak strength and dilatancy Peak state and initial state Stresses and displacements in a shear sample are analagous to the forces and movements of a friction block on an inclined plane. At critical state c The additional stress ratio (above the critical state) is due to the rate of dilation Peak state and initial state The peak stress ratio depends on the initial state given by the initial overconsolidation ratio. The maximum rate of dilation increases with overconsolidation ratio. For the same initial overconsolidation ratio (i.e. A and A') the peak stress ratio is the same. Critical state strength At its critical state soil continues to distort at constant effective stress and at constant volume. This applies for turbulent flow of the particles: if the flow becomes laminar, as in clays at large strain, the strength falls to the residual. When soil is at its critical state there is a unique relationship between shear stress, effective normal stress and water content (or specific volume or void ratio). Critical states are unique and do not depend on initial state or stress path. Critical states correspond to shear strains typically 10% to 40%. Critical shear stress (critical state strength) increases with increasing effective normal stress and with decreasing water content. The critical state line can be represented as a graph in 3 dimensions. For isotropic compression, shear stresses are zero and the isotropic normal compression line can also be represented. Critical state strength in shear tests The graphs show the critical state line. If you know either c cc and eG are soil parameters. The one-dimensional normal compression line (NCL) for zero shear stress is also shown. c or the equivalent void ratio el. The critical state line and the isotropic normal compression line both reduce to single points. Critical state strength in triaxial tests The graphs show the critical state line. If you know either p' or v at the critical state you can calculate the critical state deviation stress q'. M We should really use subscripts c and e for compression and extension as the values are slightly different. The isotropic normal compression line corresponds to zero deviator stress c or the equivalent specific volume vl. The critical state line and the isotropic normal compression line both reduce to single points. Typical values of critical state strength parameters The critical state parameters are basic soil parameters and they depend principally on the nature of the soil grains. For fine grained soils the CS parameters are related to the Atterberg limits; for coarse-grained soils they are related to the mineralogy and shape of the grains. Typical values G M high plasticity clay 0.16 2.45 0.89 23º low plasticity clay 0.10 1.80 1.18 29º quartz sand 0.16 3.00 1.28 32º carbonate sand 0.34 4.35 1.65 40º For fineby Cc = (Ip x Gs) / 200 p x Gs) / 460 c of the critical state line is related to the Atterberg limits For many soils the critical state lines all pass v(W) = 1.25 p'(W) = 10MPa e(W W) = 15MPa. Undrained strength The critical state strength is uniquely related to the water content. If the soil is sheared without change of water content (i.e. undrained) its strength remains the same. This is called the undrained strength su. But if the soil is not undrained and the water content changes the strength will also change. The undrained strength is directly related to the liquidity index IL. Some authors give slightly different values for su but su at PL (i.e. IL=0) is always 100 times su at LL (i.e. IL=1) Residual strength This is the very lowest strength which occurs after very large displacements. For sands the residual strength is the same as the critical state strength. For clays the residual is about ½ the critical state strength. For clays the flat clay particles become aligned parallel to the direction of shear. The residual strength occurs after very large (>1m) movements and is not usually relevant for geotechnical engineering where generally ground movements must be small. However, on old landslides there may have already been very large movements and in such cases the strength may already be at the residual before construction starts. Residual strength: equations Residual strength applies to clays after very large shear displacements when clay particles have become aligned in well-defined shear zones or slip planes. Drained case r r = residual friction angle r c. For London Clay, c r»10º. r depends on the quantity of clay present. Undrained case ur sur = undrained residual strength (depends on water content) Groundwater Soils consist of mineral particles in contact surrounded by voids or pores. The voids contain fluid which may be liquid, gas or a mixture of the two. The relative volumes can be described by the void ratio e, specific volume v, or porosity n. In dry soils (Sr = 0) the single pore fluid is air. In saturated soils (Sr = 1) the single pore fluid is water. Discussion of groundwater is usually concerned with saturated soils. Pore water pressure Permeability Analytical solutions Flow nets Quick condition and piping Measurement Groundwater control Some case histories Pore water pressure Water table Elevation, pressure and total head Hydraulic gradient Effective stress In general, the water in the voids of an element of saturated soil will be under pressure, either due to the physical location of the soil or as a result of external forces. This pressure is the pore water pressure or pore pressure u. It is measured relative to atmospheric pressure. When there is no flow, the pore pressure at depth d below the water surface is: u = w d Water table Fine-grained soils Coarse-grained soils Perched water table The level in the ground at which the pore pressure is zero (equal to atmospheric) is defined as the water table or phreatic surface. When there is no flow, the water surface will be at exactly the same level in any stand pipe placed in the ground below the water table. This is called a hydrostatic pressure condition. The pore pressure at depth d below the water table is: : u = w d Fine-grained soils In fine grained soils, surface tension effects can cause capillary water to rise above the water table. It is reasonable to assume that the pore pressure varies linearly with depth, so the pore pressure above the water table will be negative. If the water table is at depth dw then the pore pressure at the ground surface is uo = and the pore pressure at depth z is w (z - dw) w.dw Where the water table is deeper, or where evaporation is taking place from the surface, saturation with capillary water may not occur. The height to which the soil remains saturated with negative pore pressures above the water table is called the capillary rise. Coarse-grained soils Below the water table the soil can be considered to be saturated. In coarse-grained soils, water will drain from the pores and air will therefore be present in the soil between the ground surface and the water table. Consequently, pore pressures above the water table can usually be ignored. Below the water table, hydrostatic water pressure increases linearly with depth. With the water table at depth dw u = 0 for z < dw u = w(z - dw) for z > dw Perched water table Where the ground contains layers of permeable soil (e.g. sands) interspersed with layers of much lower permeability (e.g. clays) one or more perched water tables may develop and the overall distribution of pore pressure with depth may not be exclusivelyly linear. Detection of perched water tables during site investigation is important, otherwise erroneous estimates of in-situ pore pressure distributions can arise. Pore pressure conditions below perched water tables may be affected by local infiltration of rainwater or localised seepage and therefore may not be in hydrostatic equilibrium. Elevation, pressure and total head Pore pressure at a given point (e.g. point A in the diagram) can be measured by the height of water in a standpipe located at that point. Pore pressures are often indicated in this way on diagrams. The height of the water column is the pressure head (hw) hw = u w To identify significant differences in pore pressure at different points, we need to eliminate the effect of the points' position. A height datum is required from which locations are measured. The elevation head (hz) of a point is its height above the datum line. The height above the datum of the water level in the standpipe is the total head (h). h = hz + hw Hydraulic gradient Flow of pore water in soils is driven from positions of higher total head towards positions of lower total head. The level of the datum is arbitrary. It is differences in total head that are important. The hydraulic gradient is the rate of change of total head along the direction of flow. hz1 and hz2 above datum. In the first diagram, the total heads are equal. The difference in pore pressure is entirely due to the difference in altitude of the two points and the pore water has no tendency to flow. In the second diagram, the total heads are different. The hydraulic gradient is i = (h2 - h1 and the pore water tends to flow. Effective stress All strength and stress:strain characteristics of soils can be linked to changes in effective stress Effective stress (') = total stress () - pore water pressure (u) u Groundwater Permeability Void ratio Stratified soil Seepage velocity Temperature The rate of flow of water Darcy's law q (volume/time) through cross-sectional area A is found to be proportional to hydraulic gradient i according to Darcy's law: v = q = k.i i= A where v is flow velocity and k is coefficient of permeability with dimensions of velocity (length/time). The coefficient of permeability of a soil is a measure of the conductance (i.e. the reciprocal of the resistance) that it provides to the flow of water through its pores. The value of the coefficient of permeability k depends on the average size of the pores and is related to the distribution of particle sizes, particle shape and soil structure. The ratio of permeabilities of typical sands/gravels to those of typical clays is of the order of 106. A small proportion of fine material in a coarsegrained soil can lead to a significant reduction in permeability. Void ratio and permeability Permeability of all soils is strongly influenced by the density of packing of the soil particles which can be simply desrcibed through void ratio e or porosity n. Sands 10)² m/s where d10 is the effective particle size in mm. This relationship was proposed by Hazen. The Kozeny-Carman equation suggests that, for laminar flow in saturated soils: where ko and kT are factors depending on the shape and tortuosity of the pores respectively, Ss is the surface area of the solid particles per unit volume of solid material, and w the pore water. The equation can be written simply as Clays The Kozeny-Carman equation does not work well for silts and clays. For clays it is typically found that where Ck is the permeability change index and ek is a reference void ratio. For many natural clays Ck is approximately equal to half the natural void ratio. Stratified soil and permeability Consider a stratified soil having horizontal layers of thickness t1, t2, t3, etc. with coefficients of permeability k1, k2 k3, etc. For vertical flow, the flow rate q through area A of each layer is the same. Hence the head drop across a series of layers is The average coefficient of permeability is For horizontal flow, the So i1 = i2 = i3 etc. The flow rate through a layered block of soil of breadth B is therefore The average coefficient of permeability is Seepage velocity Darcy's Law relates flow velocity (v) to hydraulic gradient (i). The volume flow rate q is calculated as the product of flow velocity v and total cross sectional area: q = v.A At the particulate level the water follows a tortuous path through the pores. The average velocity at which the water flows through the pores is the ratio of volume flow rate to the average area of voids Av on a cross section normal to the macroscopic direction of flow. This is the seepage velocity vs Porosity of soil is related to the volume fraction of voids Seepage velocity can be measured in laboratory models by injecting dye into the seeping pore water and timing its progress through the soil. Temperature and permeability The flow of water through confined spaces is controlled by its viscosity temperature. An alternative permeability K (dimensions: length² ) is sometimes used as a more absolute coefficient depending only on the characteristics of the soil skeleton. The values of k at 0°C and 10°C are 56% and 77% respectively of the value measured at 20°C. Analytical solutions Steady one-dimensional flow Darcy's Law indicates the link between flow rate and hydraulic gradient. For one-dimensional flow, constant flow rate implies constant hydraulic gradient. Steady downward flow occurs when water is pumped from an underground aquifer. Pore pressures are then lower than hydrostatic pressures. Steady upward flow occurs as a result of artesian pressure when a less permeable layer is underlain by a permeable layer which is connected through the ground to a water source providing pressures higher than local hydrostatic pressures. The fountains of London were originally driven by artesian pressure in the aquifers trapped beneath the London clay. Pumping from aquifers over the centuries has lowered the water pressures below artesian levels. Analytical solutions Quasi-one-dimensional and radial flow Cylindrical flow: confined aquifer Cylindrical flow: groundwater lowering Spherical flow Where flow occurs in a confined aquifer whose thickness varies gently with position the flow can be treated as being essentially one-dimensional. The horizontal flow rate q is constant. For an aquifer of width B and varying thickness t, the discharge velocity and Darcy's Law indicates that Hydraulic gradient varies inversely with aquifer thickness. Quasi-one-dimensional and radial flow Cylindrical flow: confined aquifer Steady-state pumping to a well which extends the full thickness of a confined aquifer is a one-dimensional problem which can be analysed in cylindrical coordinates: pore pressure or head varies only with radius r. Darcy's Law still applies, with hydraulic gradient dh/dr and area A varying with radius: where ro is the radius of the borehole and h0 the constant head in the borehole. Cylindrical flow: groundwater lowering Pumping from a borehole can be used for deliberate groundwater lowering in order to facilitate excavation. This is an example of quasi-one-dimensional radial flow with flow thickness t=h. Then Spherical flow Variation of pore pressure around a point source or side (for example, a piezometer being used for in-situ determination of permeability) is a one-dimensional problem which can be analysed in spherical coordinates: pore pressure or head varies only with radius r. Darcy's Law still applies, with hydraulic gradient dh/dr and area A varying with radius: A=4 where r0 is the radius of the piezometer and h0 the constant head in the piezometer. Two-dimensional flow, Laplace Anisotropic soil Two-dimensional steady flow of the incompressible pore fluid is governed by Laplace's equation which indicates simply that any imbalance in flows into and out of an element in the x direction must be compensated by a corresponding opposite imbalance in the y direction. Laplace's equation can be solved graphically, analytically, numerically, or analogically. For a rectangular element with dimensions into the element is x y and unit thickness, in the x direction the velocity of flow the negative sign being required because flow occurs down the hydraulic gradient. The velocity of flow out of the element is Similar expressions can be written for the y direction. Balance of flow requires that and this is Laplace's equation. In three dimensions, Laplace's equation becomes Anisotropic soil For a soil with permeability kx and ky in the x and y directions respectively, Laplace's equation for twodimensional seepage becomes This can be solved by applying a scale factor to the x dimensions so that transformed coordinates xt are used In the transformed coordinates the equation regains its simple form and flownet generation can proceed as usual. Calculations of flow are made using an equivalent permeability It may be preferable in some cases to transform the y coordinates using: The equivalent permeability remains unchanged. For many natural sedimentary soils seasonal variations in the depositional regime have resulted in horizontal macroscopic permeabilities significantly greater than vertical permeabilities. Transformation of to analysis of seepage in such situations. coordinates lends itself Transient flow, consolidation Since water may be regarded as being essentially incompressible, unsteady flow may arise when water is drawn into or expelled from pores as a result of changes in the size of pores. This can only occur as a result of changes volume associated with changes in effective stress. The time-dependent transient change in pore pressure that occurs as a result of some perturbation, and associated change in effective stress is called consolidation. One-dimensional compression tests in an oedometer define the relationship between vertical effective stress v and specific volume v or void ratio e from which a one-dimensional compliance mv can be defined Then, under conditions of constant total stress, consolidation is governed by a diffusion equation: where cv is the coefficient of consolidation having dimensions (length²/time). Solutions of the consolidation equation are typically presented as isochrones, i.e. variations of pore pressure with position at successive times, but can also be converted to curves linking settlement with time. Flow nets Calculation of flow Calculation of total flow Boundary between layers Boundary conditions Flow through embankments Solutions to Laplace's equation for two-dimensional seepage can be presented as flow nets. Two orthogonal sets of curves form a flow net: equipotentials connecting points of equal total head h flow lines indicating the direction of seepage down a hydraulic gradient If standpipe piezometers were inserted into the ground with their tips on a single equipotential then the water would rise to the same level in each standpipe. (The pore pressures would be different because of their different elevations.) There can be no flow along an equipotential, because there is no hydraulic gradient, so there can be no component of flow across a flow line. The flow lines define channels along which the volume flow rate is constant. Calculation of flow Consider an element from a flow channel of length L between equipotentials which indicate a fall in total head gradient is and for unit width of flow net the volume flow rate is There is an advantage in displaying or sketching flownets in the form of curvilinear 'squares' so that a circle can be insrcibed within each four-sided figure bounded by two equipotentials and two flow lines. Then b = L and q = k equipotentials. Calculation of total flow For a complete problem, the flownet has been drawn with the overall head drop h divided into Nd equal intervals: d with Nf flow channels. Then the total flow rate per unit width is It is usually convenient in sketching flownets to make Nd an integer. The number of flow channels Nf will then generally not be an integer. In the example shown, of flow under a sheet pile wall Nd ;= 10, Nf = 3.5 and q = 0.35kh per unit width. Boundary between layers Flow across a boundary between two layers of soil of different permeability produces a refraction effect. Consideration of continuity of flow and of continuity of velocity normal to the interface shows that It is not possible to construct a flow net with curvilinear squares on both sides of the interface unless the head drop between equipotentials is changed in inverse proportion to the permeability ratio. If the ratio of permeabilities is greater than about 10, e.g. at the boundary of a drainage layer then construction of the part of the flow net in the more permeable soil is unlikely to be necessary. Flow nets Boundary conditions A surface on which the total head is fixed (for example, from the level of a river, pool, reservoir) is an equipotential. A surface across which there is no flow (for example, an impermeable soil layer or an impermeable wall) is a flow line For the situation shown, with flow occurring under a sheet pile wall, the axis of symmetry must also be an equipotential. Flow through embankments Seepage through an embankment dam is an example of unconfined flow bounded at the upper surface by a phreatic surface which represents the top flow line and on which the pore pressure is everywhere zero (atmospheric). Total head changes and elevation changes thus match and for equal head intervals intervals between the points of intersection of equipotentials with the phreatic surface. Quick condition and piping If the flow is upward then the water pressure tends to lift the soil element. If the upward water pressure is high enough the effective stresses in the soil disappear, no frictional strength can be mobilised and the soil behaves as a fluid. This is the quick or quicksand condition and is associated with piping instabilities around excavations and with liquefaction events in or following earthquakes. Seepage force The viscous drag of water flowing through a soil imposes a seepage force on the soil in the direction of flow. Consider the actual distribution of pore water pressure around an element length L and thickness b taken from a flownet, bounded by two equipotentials with fall in wbL of water in the element and partly providing the seepage force. It is found that the seepage force is wbL equivalent to a seepage pressure (force per unit volume) in the direction of flow Critical hydraulic gradient The quick condition occurs at a critical upward hydraulic gradient ic, when the seepage force just balances the buoyant weight of an element of soil. (Shear stresses on the sides of the element are neglected.) The critical hydraulic gradient is typically around 1.0 for many soils. Fluidised beds in chemical engineering systems rely on deliberate generation of quick conditions to ensure that the chemical process can occur most efficiently. Measurement Laboratory measurement of pore pressure Laboratory measurements of pore pressure are required in undrained testing where soil properties are to be measured in terms of effective stresses and in model tests which involve the loading or unloading of beds of clay. Traditionally, pore pressures are measured in the drainage lines just outside a triaxial cell. It is essential that the pore pressure measurement system should be completely free of air and as stiff as possible so that minimal amounts of pore water flow are required in order to register the changes in pore pressure. In research testing, miniature pore-pressure transducers may be mounted directly on a soil sample in order to speed up the expected response time. Field measurement of pore pressure Pore pressures can be measured in the ground with different types of piezometer. The simplest piezometer consists of a open tube or standpipe with a porous tip. The change in measured head of water requires a large flow of water into the tube, so response is slow. A Casagrande piezometer comprises a porous tip in a filter zone at the base of a borehole, connected to a narrow tube. The cross sectional area of the tube is small by comparison with the surface area of the filter, so the flow required to register a change in pressure is smaller than in a standpipe, and the response is quicker. Closed circuit piezometer systems are read remotely by mechanical or electrical means and provide possibilities for de-airing the pore water circuit. The response time is dependent on the length of connecting tubing. Electrical transducers (using strain gauge or vibrating wire techniques) can be placed in the ground. These are stiff devices which respond rapidly, but can be difficult to keep de-aired particularly if there is a possibility of the surrounding soil becoming unsaturated. Laboratory measurement of permeability Laboratory measurements of the permeability of soils can be made using a permeameter. For fine-grained soils (clays), the coefficient of permeability can be estimated directly or indirectly during one-dimensional compression tests in an oedometer. Permeameter Constant head test Recommended for coarse-grained soils. steady total head drop L, as water flows through a sample of cross-section area A. Falling head test Recommended for fine-grained soils. Total head h in standpipe of area a is allowed to fall; heads h1 and h2 are measured at times t1 and t2. Oedometer Indirect measurement Transient consolidation phenomena are controlled by the coefficient of consolidation. With knowledge of one-dimensional compliance mv, coefficient of permeability k can be estimated from Direct measurement Direct measurement of permeability in oedometers is preferable. Flow pumps can be used to maintain a constant flow rate (q) across the sample and to measure the resultant constant head (h). The coefficient of permeability is then given by k = q.L / A.h Field measurement of permeability Field or in-situ measurement of permeability avoids the difficulties involved in obtaining and setting up undisturbed samples in a permeameter or oedometer and also provides information about bulk permeability, rather than merely the permeability of a small and possibly unrepresentative sample. Pumping test In a well-pumping test, the steady-state heads h1 and h2 in observation boreholes at radii r1 and r2 are monitored at flow rate q. If the pumping causes a drawdown in an unconfined (i.e. open surface) soil stratum then If the soil stratum is confined and of thickness t and remains saturated then Constant head and falling head tests with in-situ piezometers can also be used. Constant head and falling head tests Field tests equivalent to the laboratory constant head and falling head tests can be performed in which controlled heads or flows are applied to piezometer tips. In general, conditions around such piezometers are not ideally cylindrically symmetric or spherically symmetric and an intake factor F (with dimensions of length) is required for each particular geometry. Values of the intake factor may be deduced from analytical or numerical studies. For a borehole open to its base, of diameter D, and lined to the full depth F=2.75D. If the cased hole is through impermeable soil and the base of the casing is at the interface with a permeable stratum F=2D. For an intake formed by a cylindrical filter zone of diameter D and length L in an infinite isotropic stratum for L/D > 4 Then for a steady state, constant head test in which a flow q is required to maintain a head h: For a falling head test in which heads h1 and h2 are measured at times t1 and t2 in a borehole of area A: Groundwater control Failure to control groundwater adjacent to a construction project may result in flooding instability ground movement loss of bearing capacity The available techniques fall into 4 broad categories: control of surface water removal from within the works extraction from the surrounding ground exclusion Selection of the most appropriate method depends on cost, which depends on the nature of the ground the size of the works the duration of the works the level of acceptable risk Groundwater lowering Removal of water from the ground will cause the water level to fall. How quickly and by how much depends on the permeability of the soil and the distance between the adjacent wells. Drainage of clays is impractical. Silt particles may be removed along with the water causing the formation of voids in the ground and damage to pumps. The high yield in gravels may make the method impractical. Lowering the ground water will reduce the pore water pressure and hence increase stability. Removing water will tend to cause settlement although the effect is likely to be small for sandy soils in which the technique works well. Groundwater exclusion Exclusion methods involve the installation of an impermeable barrier. This may be structural (steel sheet piles or concrete diaphragm wall) and may form a part of the permanent work. Other methods include slurry trench with bentonite or native clay thin grouted membrane other forms of grouting ground freezing compressed air (for tunnels and shafts) Excluding water may cause a build up in pore water pressure. Heave is a particular problem where a thin layer of impermeable soil at the base of an excavation results in a high pore water pressure close to the base. SOIL MECHANICS LECTURE NOTES LECTURE # 1 SOIL AND SOIL ENGINEERING * The term Soil has various meanings, depending upon the general field in which it is being considered. *To a Pedologist ... Soil is the substance existing on the earth's surface, which grows and develops plant life. *To a Geologist ..... Soil is the material in the relative thin surface zone within which roots occur, and all the rest of the crust is grouped under the term ROCK irrespective of its hardness. *To an Engineer .... Soil is the un-aggregated or un-cemented deposits of mineral and/or organic particles or fragments covering large portion of the earth's crust. ** Soil Mechanics is one of the youngest disciplines of Civil Engineering involving the study of soil, its behavior and application as an engineering material. *According to Terzaghi (1948): "Soil Mechanics is the application of laws of mechanics and hydraulics to engineering problems dealing with sediments and other unconsolidated accumulations of solid particles produced by the mechanical and chemical disintegration of rocks regardless of whether or not they contain an admixture of organic constituent." * Geotechnical Engineering ..... Is a broader term for Soil Mechanics. * Geotechnical Engineering contains: - Soil Mechanics (Soil Properties and Behavior) - Soil Dynamics (Dynamic Properties of Soils, Earthquake Engineering, Machine Foundation) - Foundation Engineering (Deep & Shallow Foundation) - Pavement Engineering (Flexible & Rigid Pavement) - Rock Mechanics (Rock Stability and Tunneling) - Geosynthetics (Soil Improvement) Soil Formation * Soil material is the product of rock * The geological process that produce soil is WEATHERING (Chemical and Physical). * Variation in Particle size and shape depends on: - Weathering Process - Transportation Process * Variation in Soil Structure Depends on: - Soil Minerals - Deposition Process * Transportation and Deposition Four forces are usually cause the transportation and deposition of soils 1- Water ----- Alluvial Soil 1- Fluvial 2- Estuarine 3- Lacustrine 4- Coastal 5- Marine 2- Ice ---------- Glacial Soils 1- Hard Pan 2- Terminal Moraine 3- Esker 4- Kettles 3- Wind -------- Aeolin Soils 1- Sand Dunes 2- Loess 4- Gravity ----- Colluvial Soil 1- Talus What type of soils are usually produced by the different weathering & transportation process????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ??? - Boulders - Gravel Cohesionless - Sand (Physical) - Silt Cohesive - Clay (Chemical) * These soils can be - Dry - Saturated - Fully - Partially * Also they have different shapes and textures LECTURE # 2 SOIL PROPERTIES PHYSICAL AND INDEX PROPERTIES 1- Soil Composition - Solids - Water - Air 2- Soil Phases - Dry - Saturated * Fully Saturated * Partially Saturated - Submerged 3- Analytical Representation of Soil: For the purpose of defining the physical and index properties of soil it is more convenient to represent the soil skeleton by a block diagram or phase diagram. 4- Weight - Volume Relationships: Weight Wt = Ww + Ws Volume Vt = Vv + Vs = Va + Vw + Vs 1Unit Wei ght Density * Also known as - Bulk Density - Soil Density - Unit Weight - Wet Density Relationships Between Basic Properties: Examples: _____________________________________________________________________________ Index Properties Refers to those properties of a soil that indicate the type and conditions of the soil, and provide a relationship to structural properties such as strength, compressibility, per meability, swelling potential, etc. ______________________________________________________________________________ 1- PARTICLE SIZE DISTRIBUTION * It is a screening process in which coarse fractions of soil are separated by means of series of sieves. * Particle sizes larger than 0.074 mm (U.S. No. 200 sieve) are usually analyzed by means of sieving. Soil materials finer than 0.074 mm (-200 material) are analyzed by means of sedimentation of soil particles by gravity (hydrometer analysis). 1-1 MECHANICAL METHOD U.S. Standard Sieve: Sieve No. 4 10 20 40 60 100 140 200 -200 Opening in mm 4.76 2.00 0.84 0.42 0.25 0.149 0.105 0.074 Cumulative Curve: * A linear scale is not convenient to use to size all the soil particles (opening from 200 mm to 0.002 mm). * Logarithmic Scale is usually used to draw the relationship between the % Passing and the Particle size. Example: Parameters Obtained From Grain Size Distribution Curve: 1- Uniformity Coefficient Cu (measure of the particle size range) Cu is also called Hazen Coefficient Cu = D60/D10 Cu < 5 ----- Very Uniform Cu = 5 ----- Medium Uniform Cu > 5 ----- Nonuniform 2- Coefficient of Gradation or Coefficient of Curvature Cg (measure of the shape of the particle size curve) Cg = (D30)2/ D60 x D10 Cg from 1 to 3 ------- well graded 3- Coefficient of Permeability k = Ck (D10)2 m/sec Consistency Limits or Atterberg Limits: - State of Consistency of cohesive soil 1- Determination of Liquid Limit: 2- Determination of Plastic Limit: 3- Determination of Plasticity Index P.I. = L.L. - P.L. 4- Determination of Shrinkage Limit 5- Liquidity Index: 6- Activity: SOIL CLASSIFICATION SYSTEMS * Why do we need to classify soils ??????????? To describe various soil types encountered in the nature in a systematic way and gathering soils that have distinct physical properties in groups and units. * General Requirements of a soil Classification System: 1- Based on a scientific method 2- Simple 3- Permit classification by visual and manual tests. 4- Describe certain engineering properties 5- Should be accepted to all engineers * Various Soil Classification Systems: 1- Geologic Soil Classification System 2- Agronomic Soil Classification System 3- Textural Soil Classification System (USDA) 4-American Association of State Highway Transportation Officials System (AASHTO) 5- Unified Soil Classification System (USCS) 6- American Society for Testing and Materials System (ASTM) 7- Federal Aviation Agency System (FAA) 8- Others 1- Unified Soil Classification (USC) System: The main Groups: G = Gravel S = Sand ......................... M = Silt C = Clay ........................ O = Organic ........................ * For Cohesionless Soil (Gravel and Sand), the soil can be Poorly Graded or Well Graded Poorly Graded = P Well Graded = W * For Cohesive Soil (Silt & Clay), the soil can be Low Plastic or High Plastic Low Plastic = L High Plastic = H Therefore, we can have several combinations of soils such as: GW = Well Graded Gravel GP = Poorly Graded Gravel GM = Silty Gravel GC = Clayey Gravel Passing Sieve # 4 SW = Well Graded Sand SP = Poorly Graded Sand SM = Silty Sand SC = Clayey Sand Passing Sieve # 200 ML = Low Plastic Silt CL = Low Plastic Clay MH = High Plastic Silt CH = High Plastic Clay To conclud if the soil is low plastic or high plastic use Gassagrande's Chart _____________________________________________________________________________ 2- American Association of State Highway Transportation Officials System (AASHTO): - Soils are classified into 7 major groups A-1 to A-7 Granular A-1 {A-1-a - A-1-b} (Gravel & Sand) A-2 {A-2-4 - A-2-5 - A-2-6 - A-2-6} A-3 More than 35% pass # 200 A-4 Fine A-5 (Silt & Clay) A-6 A-7 Group Index: _____________________________________________________________________________ 3- Textural Soil Classification System (USDA) * USDA considers only: Sand Silt Clay No. Gravel in the System * If you encounter gravel in the soil ------- Subtract the % of gravel from the 100%. * 12 Subgroups in the system Example: ******** MOISTURE DENSITY RELATIONSHIPS (SOIL COMPACTION) INTRODUCTION: * In the construction of highway embankments, earth dams, and many other engineering projects, loose soils must be compacted to increase their unit weight. * Compaction improves characteristics of soils: 1- Increases Strength 2- Decreases permeability 3- Reduces settlement of foundation 4- Increases slope stability of embankments * Soil Compaction can be achieved either by static or dynamic loading: 1- Smooth-wheel rollers 2- Sheepfoot rollers 3- Rubber-tired rollers 4- Vibratory Rollers 5- Vibroflotation __________________________________________ _______________________________ ____________________ General Principles: * The degree of compaction of soil is measured by its unit weight, content, wc. , and optimum moisture * The process of soil compaction is simply expelling the air from the voids. or reducing air voids * Reducing the water from the voids means consolidation. Mechanism of Soil Compaction: * By reducing the air voids, more soil can be added to the block. When moisture is added to the block (water content, wc, is increasing) the soil particles will slip more on each other causing more reduction in the total volume, which will result in adding more soil and, hence, the dry density will increase, accordingly. * Increasing Wc will increase Up to a certain limit (Optimum moister Content, OMC)After this limit Increasing Wc will decrease Density-Moisture Relationship Knowing the wet unit weight and the moisture content, the dry unit weight can be determined from: The theoretical maximum dry unit weight assuming zero air voids is: I- Laboratory Compaction: * Two Tests are usually performed in the laboratory to determine the maximum dry unit weight and the OMC. 1- Standard Proctor Test 2- Modified Proctor Test In both tests the compaction energy is: 1Stan dard Proctor Test Factors Affecting Compaction: 1- Effect of Soil Type 2- Effect of Energy on Compaction 3- Effect of Compaction on Soil Structure 4- Effect of Compaction on Cohesive Soil Properties II- Field Compaction Flow of Water in Soils Permeability and Seepage * Soil is a three phase medium -------- solids, water, and air * Water in soils occur in various conditions * Water can flow through the voids in a soil from a point of high energy to a point of low energy. * Why studying flow of water in porous media ??????? 1- To estimate the quantity of underground seepage 2- To determine the quantity of water that can be discharged form a soil 3- To determine the pore water pressure/effective geostatic stresses, and to analyze earth structures subjected to water flow. 4- To determine the volume change in soil layers (soil consolidation) and settlement of foundation. * Flow of Water in Soils depends on: 1- Porosity of the soil 2- Type of the soil - particle size - particle shape - degree of packing 3- Viscosity of the fluid - Temperature - Chemical Components 4- Total head (difference in energy) - Pressure head - Velocity head - Elevation head The degree of soil is expressed by the compressibility of a coefficient of permeability of the soil "k." k cm/sec, ft/sec, m/sec, ........ Hydraulic Gradient Bernouli's Equation: For soils Flow of Water in Soils 1- Hydraulic Head in Soil Total Head = Pressure head + Elevation Head ht = hp + he - Elevation head at a point = Extent of that point from the datum - Pressure head at a point = Height of which the water rises in the piezometer above the point. - Pore Water pressure at a point = P.W.P. = gwater . hp *How to measure the Pressure Head or the Piezometric Head??????? Tips 1- Assume that you do not have seepage in the system (Before Seepage) 2- Assume that you have piezometer at the point under consideration 3- Get the measurement of the piezometric head (Water column in the Piezometer before seepage) = hp(Before Seepage) 4- Now consider the problem during seepage 5- Measure the amount of the head loss in the piezometer (Dh) or the drop in the piezometric head. 6- The piezometric head during seepage = hp(during seepage) = hp(Before Seepage) - Dh GEOSTATIC STRESSES & STRESS DISTRIBUTION Stresses at a point in a soil mass are divided into two main types: I- Geostatic Stresses ------ Due to the self weight of the soil mass. II- Excess Stresses ------ From structures I. Geostatic stresses I.A. Vertical Stress Vertical geostatic stresses increase with depth, There are three 3 types of geostatic stresses 1-a Total Stress, stotal 1-b. Effective Stress, seff, or s' 1-c Pore Water Pressure, u Total Stress = Effective stress + Pore Water Pressure stotal = seff + u Geos tatic Stres s with Seep age When the Seepage Force = H gsub -- Effective Stress seff = 0 This case is referred as Boiling or Quick Conditon I.B. Horizontal Stress or Lateral Stress sh = ko s'v ko = Lateral Earth Pressure Coefficient sh is always associated with the vertical effective stress, s'v. never use total vertical stress to determine sh. II. Stress Distribution in Soil Mass: When applying a load on a half space medium the excess stresses in the soil will decrease with depth. Like in the geostatic stresses, there are vertical and lateral excess stresses. 1. For Point Load The excess vertical stress is according to Boussinesq (1883): - Ip = Influence factor for - Knowing r/z ----- I1 can be the point load obtained from tables According to Westergaard (1938) where h = s (1-2m / 2-2m) m = Poisson's Ratio 2. For Line Load Using q/unit length on the surface of a semi infinite soil mass, the vertical stress is: 3. For a Strip Load (Finite Width and Infinite Length): The excess vertical stress due to load/unit area, q, is: Where Il = Influence factor for a line load 3. For a Circular Loaded Area: The excess vertical stress due to q is: The Field Vane Shear Web Page Dr. R. S. Olsen (www.liquefaction.com) Information on techniques for CPT estimation of field vane and triaxial strengths are at the bottom of this web. Web sites on Vane Shear Test (VST) are located at: http://www.pagani-geotechnical.com/ http://www.geonor.com/Soiltst.html http://www.envi.se/products.htm http://www.geotech.se/Vanes/evt-2000.html The above sites were provided by Prof Paul Mayne http://www.igeotest.com/tema5/vane.htm - in Spanish but good see below (Olsen, 1994) This above figure shows how the vane shear tries to cut a larger diameter cylinder because the blades are cutting the soil at a right angle. This effective cutting diameter is more pronounced for granular clays compared to pure clays. However, even clays exhibit this effect. This effect produces larger effective diameter with increased silt or sand content. (Olsen, 1994, 1995). Because the effective cutting diameter is larger than the vane shear cylinder diameter, the consequence is a calculated vane shear strength too large because the wrong diameter is used. This is why we must use the vane shear correction factor. {Rick Olsen, March-1999} If the rod is in contact with the soil then the "rod friction" must be accounted for (see the above figure) . The Olsen field vane shear - for verifying CPT estimated strengths. This system used a Torque wrench to measure an estimate of the peak field vane shear strength. A electro magnetic couple transmits the torque to a computer data acquisition system for a more accurate record. {Rick Olsen jan-1999} CPT based estimation of the normalized vane shear strength and normalized triaxial undrained strength (Olsen, 1994, 1995). The ratio of these two estimated strengths is equal to the classical vane shear reduction factor CPT estimation of field normalized vane shear strength (Olsen, 1994). Use this correlation to confirm that the CPT soil characterization technique can estimate strength. You must perform field vane shear measurement tests next to CPT soundings. CPT estimation of laboratory triaxial undrained strength (Olsen, 1994). After the CPT soil characterization techniqiue is confirmed (using the above correlation for field shear vane measurements) use this correlation to estimate triaxial strength for design. Remember, these estimated strengths are "best estimates" using high quality CPT data. Poor CPT without good controls can generate estimated strengths much higher than the true in situ strengths. Ratio of triaxial strength divided by the field vane shear measurement (Olsen, 1994) This chart is not for design purposes. It is only to show that the two CPT estimated strength trends above match historical trends See text for important discussion of this ratio (vane shear reduction factor) This ratio matches the trends and magnitude of the Bjerrum and NGI correction factor. The original correlation is shown below: Bjerrum correction factor for the Field vane shear test (Bjerrum, 1972) - NGI has improved this correlation NOTE: The information at this web site represents results from research and experience by Dr. Olsen. These correlations should only be used by experts in the field of in situ site characterization that understand the underlying data and know how to acquire quality CPT data. Dr. Rick Olsen This page was last updated on