International Education Strategy for Victoria 2013-2018 Department of State Development Business and Innovation State Government of Victoria Contents Message from the Premier and Minister............................................................................................................................. 3 International Education Strategy at a Glance ..................................................................................................................... 4 Vision ................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Goals .................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Strategic Action Area ........................................................................................................................................... 4 Initiatives .............................................................................................................................................................. 4 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................. 5 Victoria’s International Education Sector at a Glance 2012 ................................................................................ 6 2. International education – Victoria’s largest single export ....................................................................................... 7 Transnational Education (TNE) – Towards Greater Internationalisation ............................................................. 8 3. The Global Opportunity & Challenges for Victoria ................................................................................................ 9 Opportunity ........................................................................................................................................................ 9 The global market for international students is expanding ................................................................................... 9 Victoria’s location and reputation ........................................................................................................................ 9 Challenge ........................................................................................................................................................... 10 On the domestic front ......................................................................................................................................... 10 Global competition ............................................................................................................................................. 12 Affordability ....................................................................................................................................................... 12 4. A Strategic Approach to Sustainable Growth ....................................................................................................... 14 Supporting strategic action ................................................................................................................................. 15 5. Market Development ............................................................................................................................................. 16 Supporting Victorian education providers in market.......................................................................................... 16 Victorian Government facilitation of new market opportunities – some examples ........................................... 19 6. Enhancing the Quality of International Education ................................................................................................ 21 7. Student Experience ............................................................................................................................................... 23 Student support................................................................................................................................................... 23 Public Transport Costs for International Students .............................................................................................. 24 Accommodation ................................................................................................................................................. 25 Towards a ‘premium’ student experience .......................................................................................................... 25 8. Marketing and Branding ....................................................................................................................................... 28 9. Implementation ..................................................................................................................................................... 30 Message from the Premier and Minister Skills and knowledge can transform a person’s life and open doors to a world of choice and a rich and rewarding career. Today’s student is tomorrow’s tradesperson or professional, embarking on a lifetime of personal and vocational achievement. The State of Victoria has a long and proud heritage of intellectual leadership, backed by world-class public and private educational institutions: schools, colleges, vocational training institutes, universities, and research centres. Victoria’s metropolitan and regional academic institutions are renowned globally for providing the highest quality educational outcomes. Melbourne also has the advantage of being rated the world’s most liveable city in the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Global Liveability Report again in 2013. In 2012, QS ranked Melbourne as one of the world’s four leading student cities along with Paris, London and Boston. The Victorian Government is committed to ensuring that Victoria’s reputation for academic excellence positions the state as a global destination for international students, and positions us as the preferred partner for research collaboration and skills development. Globally there is high demand from students wanting to study outside their own country and this is highly valued by employers. Most institutions also have a desire to internationalise their teaching and research, and governments want to develop their people and support economic growth. Many choose Victorian institutions because of our reputation. However, there is increasing competition. Demand across all aspects of international education is predicted to grow significantly, and this has caused other Australian States and countries to also increase their student attraction efforts, including new emerging economies. The International Education Strategy for Victoria 2013-2018 outlines the Victorian Government’s plan to assist Victoria’s education and training sector to capitalise on global education opportunities. The strategy will ensure Victoria continues to be a leading provider of international education in the Asia-Pacific region. The Victorian Government seeks to strengthen the State’s position as a globally competitive service-based economy. International education is Victoria’s largest single export industry. It brings allied benefits to local tourism, hospitality and retailing either directly from the students themselves or when overseas relatives and friends come to visit. Importantly, international education adds to our social and cultural vibrancy. It increases Victoria’s interaction with trading partners and deepens relationships between our state and the world. It helps build Melbourne’s brand as a global city. It contributes to Victoria’s research and development capacity through the attraction of postgraduate students and academics and encourages international partnerships with researchers offshore. International students return home with knowledge and understanding of Victoria’s capabilities and culture, opening doors for major export, trade and cultural opportunities in the future. This strategy outlines the Victorian Government’s plan for strengthening the State’s international education sector and promoting Victoria’s education services to the world. The International Education Strategy has been informed by consultation with education and training providers and feedback from international students. The Victorian Government looks forward to working with the sector to achieve sustainable growth in international education in Victoria. The Hon Denis Napthine MP Premier of Victoria The Hon Louise Asher MP Minister for Innovation, Services and Small Business Minister for Tourism and Major Events Minister for Employment and Trade International Education Strategy at a Glance Vision Victoria is the leading provider of international education in the Asia-Pacific region, strengthening the State’s position as a globally competitive services economy Goals Consolidate Victoria’s position as a global leader in international education Increase Victoria’s share of Australia’s international students, boosting student numbers and export revenue Moderate volatility in student demand in order to create a sustainable sector Capitalise on the broader cultural and economic benefits of international education Strategic Action Area Market Development o To support Victorian education and training providers to deepen their engagement in current overseas markets and to realised the opportunities in new markets for Victoria Quality o To drive the quality of Victoria’s international education services and delivery Student Experience o To enhance the overall experience of international students in Victoria Marketing and Branding o To build Victoria’s international education profile in a crowded and competitive global market Initiatives 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. International Education Advisory Body a. Supports implementation of the Strategy and provides advice and guidance as required Extend Education Service Managers (ESMs) Support Target onshore and offshore market development activities Support Collaborative Models Expand transnational partnerships in VET Review regulation of offshore delivery Fund Doctoral Scholarships Expand Asian language capabilities Showcase quality through events Establish Study Melbourne Student Centre A new public transport ticket scheme for international students Expand work experience opportunities Establish the Study Melbourne Experience Program Improve communication with international students Re-brand activities under one ‘Study Melbourne’ brand Enhance Study Melbourne website Develop B2B marketing strategy Increase awareness of Victoria’s education strengths Strengthen engagement with student alumni 1. Introduction The Victorian Government’s vision for the international education sector is that: Victoria is the leading provider of international education in the Asia-Pacific region, strengthening the State’s position as a globally competitive services economy. International education is Victoria’s largest single export industry. It generates enormous benefits to the State and has the potential to grow. As global demand for quality education increases, Victoria is well-placed to be a leader in international education in the Asia-Pacific region. Over the decade to 2009, Victoria’s international education sector grew to be one of the State’s most valuable and vibrant export sectors, with an estimated value of $5.74 billion. Driven by strong global demand, a desire to internationalise and migration settings that linked international education and skilled migration, Victoria’s education and training providers forged international partnerships and embraced opportunities to broaden their delivery to international students. For the last three years, several factors have led to a decline in international student numbers across Australia including changes to migration settings, student visa eligibility and the strength of the Australian dollar. In Victoria, international student enrolments were down about 28 per cent in 2012 from peak levels in 2009, accompanied by a comparable decline in export revenue. Intensifying global competition has also eroded Victoria’s share of global higher education enrolments. At the same time, worldwide demand for international education is growing. A forecast extra three million students globally by 2020 and increasing demand for transnational education provide great opportunity for Victoria. In an increasingly globalised economy, Victoria’s international education sector is a major strength. In the absence of significant tradeable mineral and energy resources compared with Western Australia and Queensland, a service industry such as international education is vital to Victoria’s economy. International education is also important because it strengthens our global relationships, especially with rapidly developing economies in our region such as China, India, and South East Asian countries, contributing to longer term trade, investment and tourism opportunities. Growing Victoria’s international markets is one of four central themes underpinning the Victorian Government’s economic statement, Securing Victoria’s Economy – Planning, Building, Delivering. This statement affirms the Government’s vision to secure Victoria’s position as Australia’s knowledge capital as well as the nation’s most globally-focused economy and most Asia-capable workforce. The Victorian International Engagement Strategy (VIES) represents a long-term strategic approach to positioning the Victorian economy for growth through strong engagement in priority international markets. The VIES will support Victoria to maximise trade and investment opportunities with priority international economic partners such as China, India and South East Asia. The Government has been investing heavily in building relationships in corporate, cultural and civic areas to broaden economic ties with these partners. Consistent with the rationale and approach of the VIES, this International Education Strategy outlines the Government’s approach to securing Victoria’s globally competitive position as a quality provider of international education and supporting the sector to take advantage of expanding opportunities in the global market. This strategy establishes four goals for sustainable growth and four strategic action areas – focused on market development, quality, the student experience and marketing. The strategy also outlines nineteen initiatives to achieve the goals. While a five-year implementation timeframe for the strategy is envisaged, the initiatives are intended to lay the foundation for international education in Victoria to 2023 and beyond. Victoria’s International Education Sector at a Glance 2012 Student numbers: On-shore student enrolments: 148,860 in 20121. Off-shore students: 80,400 in 2011 – Higher education & public VET only2. International student enrolments (on-shore), Victoria by sector, 2012 (AEI) Higher Education – 46% VET – 31% ELICOS – 14% Schools – 4% Other – 5% Market share: 1 In 2012 Victoria had 28.9 per cent of total Australian market share of on-shore enrolments (AEI). In 2011 Victoria had 75.3 per cent of Australia’s off-shore public VET students and 45.3 per cent of off-shore higher education students. Australian Education International (AEI). This data includes enrolments by students in Australia on student visas. It does not include students on visitor or working holiday visas who may undertake a short course (e.g. English language). 2 Department of Industry, Innovation, Climate Change, Science, Research and Tertiary Education, 2012. International education – Victoria’s largest single export 2. International education is Victoria’s largest single export industry. (Figure 1) Figure 1: Victoria’s Top Exports in 20123 Education-related travel - $4.365 billion Personal travel excluding education - $2.56 billion Dairy* - $1.869 billion Meat* - $1.412 billion Wool and animal hair - $1.371 billion Passenger motor vehicles – 1.312 billion Source: International Trade in Goods and Services, Australia (ABS cat. No 5368.0). *Note: “Dairy” is an aggregation of Milk products and cheese & curd export sectors; “Meat” is an aggregation of Meat (excl. beef) and Beef. The export value of Victoria’s international education sector from students studying onshore on a student visa was $4.365 billion in 2012. This includes tuition fees and expenditure on goods and services. Of this, fees account for just under half of total expenditure. The remaining expenditure by international students is on other goods and services such as food, accommodation and transport. The data in Figure 1 does not include students who are studying in Australia on non-student visas. Only 61 per cent of international students studying English language courses in 2012 held student visas; 20 per cent were visitor visa holders and 19 per cent held working holiday or other visas 4. Deloitte Access Economics estimates that every $145,000 spent by international students in Australia generates one full-time equivalent (FTE) job5. These jobs are created in the education and training sector as well as in service industries such as food, retail and accommodation. Based on the current student numbers and expenditure, it is estimated that over 30,000 FTE jobs are created by the presence of international students in Victoria. Additional revenue is earned through offshore or transnational operations and other educational activities in which Victorian education and training institutions lead the country. However data is currently not available on the extent of the economic value of these activities. Department of Education and Early Childhood Development (DEECD) estimates suggests that, in 2011, Victorian TAFE Institutes generated around $42 million through off-shore delivery representing 25 per cent of revenue derived from international students. Additionally, indirect economic benefits of international education are generated through family and friends of overseas students visiting Australia, contributing to tourism. Recent research estimates that, in the year ending December 2012, 49,700 international overnight visitors to Victoria were visiting international students studying in Australia 6. This represents 2.7 per cent of international visitors to Victoria. These visitors stayed for a cumulative 781,800 nights in Victoria. Based on average expenditure of visitors to Victoria per night, Tourism Victoria estimates that total expenditure of these visitors to Victoria was $62.77 million in the year ending December 2012. More difficult to quantify are the enormous benefits of international education in deepening trade and cultural links between Victoria and the home countries of students over the longer term. International education contributes to Victoria’s economy and culture well beyond the direct economic benefits it generates. International education increases 3 The ABS category for international education expenditure in Australia is “Education-related travel”; “Personal travel excluding education” is international tourism. 4 English Australia, Survey of major ELICOS regional markets in 2011, June 2012. 5 Unpublished advice to the then Department of Business and Innovation, October 2012. 6 Tourism Research Australia, International Visitor Survey 2012, unpublished data. our interaction with trading partners, creates and improves relationships between Victoria and the world, adds to our social and cultural vibrancy and contributes to Victoria’s research and development capacity through attraction of postgraduate students as well as academics. International students educated in Victoria carry home with them knowledge and understanding of Victoria’s capabilities and culture thereby opening doors for major export, trade and cultural opportunities in the future. International students also contribute to the economy through participation in the labour market while they pursue their education. With the commencement of post-study work visas for higher education graduates in 2013, there are increased opportunities to work in Australia, gain valuable work experience and contribute to the skills needs of the Australian economy. And, while most international students return home to contribute to their country’s economy and community, international graduates are a potential source of specialised skills to the Victorian economy through Australia’s skilled migration program. Victoria’s metropolitan and regional academic institutions are renowned globally for providing the highest quality educational outcomes. Melbourne also has the advantage of being rated the world’s most liveable city in the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Global Liveability Report again in 2013. In 2012, QS ranked Melbourne as one of the world’s four leading student cities along with Paris, London and Boston. Transnational Education (TNE) – Towards Greater Internationalisation Delivery of education services to international students by Australian providers off-shore (transnational education) has been a feature of international education for the last two decades but has grown significantly since 2006, especially in the vocational education and training (VET) sector. In the higher education sector, more than 80,000 international students were enrolled with Australian universities off-shore in 2011 (24.2 per cent of total higher education international students). In 2011, over 58,000 students were enrolled in off-shore VET courses delivered by public providers7. Victorian providers dominate Australian delivery of education off-shore, accounting for 75.3 per cent of Australia’s off-shore public VET students in 2011 (around 44,000 students) and 45.3 per cent of offshore higher education students (36,400 students). While small, growth of off-shore delivery of secondary school education is also expanding, with an increasing number of schools licensed to deliver the Victorian Certificate of Education overseas. Many Victorian providers have indicated a strong interest in further expansion of their international partnerships and operations and are looking to diverse countries across Asia, the Middle East and Latin America for new opportunities. These go beyond direct delivery of full Australian accredited courses or twinning arrangements and may include educational consultancy, licensing of curriculum, staff training, government advisory services, study tours, research collaborations and staff and student mobility programs. These varied arrangements not only educate current students but also build the host country’s capacity and provide long term benefits that support their economic development. Evident also is the increasing role that industry has in transnational bilateral and multilateral education partnerships. The demand for TNE is predicted to grow substantially, driven by burgeoning needs for education and training in growing economies, increasing global competition for students, cost pressures that make off-shore delivery more affordable in developing countries and a realisation of the non-financial benefits of international collaborations and knowledge exchange. Students can benefit from increased study options, broader experiences and better informed curriculum. Institutions benefit from expanding their global profile, broadening educational and research knowledge and increasing access to resources. Businesses benefit from a more highly skilled workforce and greater access to quality research and development. Governments and communities also benefit from shared expertise, economic support and increased cultural awareness. Increasingly, TNE is an integral and important element of international education programs. 7 Data on off-shore VET delivery by private providers is not currently available. 3. The Global Opportunity & Challenges for Victoria Opportunity The global market for international students is expanding The rate of growth in international higher education enrolments globally increased substantially from 2000 onwards, underpinned by significant growth in demand for education in China and India. In 2010, 4.2 million students studied at universities outside their home country, a 100 per cent increase since 2000 (Figure 2)8. This growth is projected to continue, with forecasts of around 7.2 million 9 to 8 million10 students seeking education outside their own country by 2025. Figure 2: Growth in higher education students enrolled outside their country of citizenship 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2025 0.8M 1.1M 1.1M 1.3M 1.7M 2.1M 3.0M 4.2M 7.0M Source: OECD and UNESCO Institute for Statistics. There are strong links between economic growth and demand for education. Government policy across most emerging economies also reflects realisation of the value of vocational education. Foreign investment in Asia and large scale aid and development programs by organisations such as the World Bank, Asian Development Bank and AusAID are also driving demand for increased training of local workforces. Other drivers of demand include demographic changes, particularly in the Asian region, the impact of technology, mass communications, global mobility, the evolving role of universities and the changing needs of industry. Forecasters are confident of significant growth in worldwide educational demand to meet population and economic growth. Victoria’s location and reputation Victoria is well-placed to take advantage of the growing demand for international education, especially in the AsiaPacific region. Australia’s proximity to growing Asian markets and historic relationships through migration, education and trade, have seen particularly strong performance in delivery of international education services to China, India, Vietnam, Malaysia and Singapore. Victoria’s performance in international education is underpinned by a strong education and training sector. Victoria boasts a concentration of education and research infrastructure that is unrivalled in the region. Specific strengths include: 8 five of Australia’s top 20 universities11; one of the world’s top 30 universities and two universities in the world’s top 100 12; a strong VET framework and extensive experience in offshore delivery; four of Australia’s five universities with TAFE operations (dual sector universities); a well-developed system of articulated pathways between education sectors; and Similar global statistics are not available for other international education sub-sectors. Bohm, Meares and Pearce (2002) The Global Student Mobility 2025 Report: Forecasts of the Global Demand for International Education, IDP quoted in UNESCO, Higher Education Crossing Borders, 2006. 10 Goddard, B. “Future Perspectives: Horizon 2025” in IEA, Making A Difference, 2011. 11 Excellence in Research for Australia 2012 rankings. 12 Times Higher Education World University Rankings 2012-13. 9 an extensive network of overseas partnerships supporting off-shore delivery, student and staff mobility and research collaborations. Melbourne also has the advantage of being rated the world’s most liveable city in the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Global Liveability Report. Further, in 2012, QS ranked Melbourne as one of the world’s four leading student cities along with Paris, London and Boston. The criteria included quality of living, reputation of the city’s universities, the student mix, employer activity and affordability. Victoria’s multicultural make up is one of the State’s greatest assets. Victoria is the most culturally and linguistically diverse State in Australia. ABS Census data indicates that: 26.2 per cent of Victorians were born overseas in more than 200 countries; 46.8 per cent of Victorians were either born overseas or have at least one parent born overseas; 74.6 per cent of Victoria’s overseas-born population came from non-English-speaking countries; 23.1 per cent of Victorians spoke languages other than English at home, with 260 different languages spoken in homes around the State; 67.7 per cent of Victorians followed 135 different religions; and the top ten countries of birth for Victorians born overseas are England, India, China, New Zealand, Italy, Vietnam, Greece, Sri Lanka, Malaysia and the Philippines. Victoria is unique in its approach to supporting and reaping the benefits of an active and vibrant multicultural population. Victoria’s strong and confident multicultural society attracts international students, skilled migrants, international tourists and global businesses, generating social, cultural and economic benefits. Victorians are proud of their harmonious and inclusive society which recognises and shares the various cultures and identities that make up Victoria. Strong support for multiculturalism in Victoria and Australia helps to create a welcoming and accepting society. Challenge On the domestic front Despite strong global demand for education, Victoria (and Australia) has experienced a decline in on-shore international student numbers over the last three years although the trend since 2002 shows overall growth (Figure 3). As highlighted in Figure 4 much of the growth between 2006 and 2009, and the subsequent fall in enrolments, was in the VET sector. Figure 3: Trend in international student numbers State 2002 Victoria 74029 84305 89099 94051 105973 131966 160934 190614 182563 161318 148292 Victoria Avg since 2002 74029 79167 82477.67 85371 89491.4 96570.5 105765.3 116371.4 123726 127485.2 129376.7 Australia 274133 307180 324618 344766 380384 450791 542232 630572 616111 554099 513887 Australia Avg since 2002 274133 290656.5 301977 312674.3 326216.2 346978.7 374872 406834.5 430087.4 442488.6 448979.4 Source: AEI 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Figure 4: Victoria’s international student enrolments, 2002-2012 enrolments by education sector, 2002-12 Sector 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Higher Education 39,022 46,485 51,631 54,669 56,650 59,273 62,680 69,432 72,270 71,966 68,886 VET 9,974 9,479 9,531 12,614 19,735 33,995 52,099 71,308 69,127 55,204 45,222 Schools 7,096 8,182 8,122 7,390 7,075 7,821 8,315 7,937 7,014 6,161 5,691 ELICOS 12,099 14,303 14,139 13,724 16,582 24,436 30,356 33,524 25,767 20,428 21,714 Other 5,838 5,856 5,676 5,654 5,931 6,441 7,484 8,413 8,385 7,559 6,779 Grand Total 74,029 84,305 89,099 94,051 105,973 131,966 160,934 190,614 182,563 161,318 148,292 Source: AEI Migration policy and student visa settings have had the biggest impact. Commonwealth migration policy settings led to a rapid expansion in successful applications from international students for permanent residence under Australia’s skilled migration program which favoured students undertaking VET qualifications recognised on Australia’s ’skills in demand‘ list. When these migration settings were changed, the decline in overseas students in VET courses and, to a lesser extent, in ELICOS courses, was dramatic. This trend was exacerbated by safety concerns in the Indian market, sub-optimal delivery by a small number of private vocational training colleges and a strong Australian currency that saw increasing costs relative to other countries. Further changes to Australia’s student visa requirements since late 2011, following the Knight Review of student visas, have had benefits for universities but have also created distinctions between parts of the sector. In March 2012, the Commonwealth introduced streamlined visa processing for universities through which most visa applications for university courses are processed within two weeks and require less documentation. Universities have derived a significant competitive advantage from this change and from the introduction of post-study work visas for higher education graduates from early 2013. The absence of streamlined visa processing beyond universities is not only delaying international student enrolments for TAFE institutes and private providers but also creates a negative perception that these other institutions are somehow “secondary” or of a lower quality than universities. Compounding this issue, education and training providers have concerns about inconsistent and subjective application of the Genuine Temporary Entrant (GTE) criterion by the Department of Immigration and Citizenship in its assessment of student visa applications. Victoria also faces competition from other States. Victoria is the Australian destination of choice for students from some major markets, notably India, Vietnam, Malaysia, Pakistan and Sri Lanka, but NSW continues as the overall market leader with 37.6 per cent share in 2012 compared to Victoria’s 28.9 per cent. NSW currently outperforms other States in important markets such as China, Korea, Thailand, Brazil, Indonesia, Nepal and the Philippines. Other States and Territories generally have lower market shares than NSW and Victoria but dominate in some areas. For example, Queensland attracts more Korean, Brazilian, Saudi Arabian and Colombian students than Victoria and Western Australia attracts more Brazilian and Kenyan students. Victorian providers lead the way in offshore education delivery with TAFE Institutes holding a 75.3 per cent share of off-shore VET enrolments with public providers and Victorian universities accounting for 45.3 per cent of off-shore higher education students. However other States are intensifying their efforts in relation to offshore delivery and the Report of the International Education Advisory Council (IEAC) in early 201313 makes a number of recommendations to support growth of offshore delivery by Australian providers. Global competition Competition is increasing on multiple fronts. Recent estimates suggest that Victoria’s share of global higher education enrolments has fallen from around 2.0 per cent in 2009 to 1.5 per cent in 201214. Global mobility, technological advances and improved education systems in many nations mean prospective international students now have more options when choosing a study destination. Competition for international students is intensifying, with countries such as the United Kingdom (UK), Canada and New Zealand establishing ambitious targets to increase the number of international students. Institutions in the United States of America (USA) have recently increased promotion aimed at overseas students. Given the historical reputation of the USA for education and the ability to absorb many more international students (on average USA universities had only 3.7 per cent international students in 2011-1215), the USA will continue to be Victoria’s competitor. The numbers of foreign students in the USA grew by 5.7 per cent in 2011-12 (from 723,270 to 764,495)16. New international student commencements into Canada in 2012 were up 32 per cent from 2008 levels, buoyed by favourable student visa policies, more aggressive marketing and easy access to permanent residency after graduation. By contrast, international student enrolments in the UK have declined due to recent changes to migration and student visa conditions. Also of significance, several of Victoria’s traditional student source countries are now repositioning as competitors. This includes Malaysia, Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, Singapore and China which are attracting increased numbers of international students in the Asian region. The recent emergence of free web-based education modules delivered by well-respected universities such as MIT, Harvard, Princeton and Stanford Universities (e.g. edX, Coursera and Udacity) also presents competitive challenges. Victorian institutions are already responding to the challenge and examples include the recent partnership of the University of Melbourne with Coursera and the long standing expertise exhibited by universities such as Monash, Deakin and La Trobe for online delivery of qualifications either directly or through Open Universities Australia17. The capacity to deliver education in this way challenges the current models for international education and education in general but also offers the opportunity for institutions to be innovative in educational delivery and provide more options for prospective students with varied needs to access courses. Affordability While cost and affordability are not the top determinants of student choice, there is no doubt that the high Australian dollar relative to other key currencies and the consequent increase in relative costs of tuition and living in Australia, are having an impact on Australia’s competitiveness as a study destination. The 2012 International Student Survey suggests that international students have relatively low levels of satisfaction18 with living costs in Australia. 13 Times Higher Education World University Rankings 2012-13 Times Higher Education World University Rankings 2012-13 15 Institute of International Education Open Doors Data, 2012. 16 Institute of International Education, November 2012. 17 The Grattan Institute’s report “The online evolution: when technology meets tradition in higher education” (April 2013), provides example of online delivery as well as an overview of models and trends. 18 AEI, International Student Survey 2012 – Overview Report, April 2013. Fifty-one per cent of higher education students and 63 per cent of VET students were satisfied with living costs, compared to overall satisfaction with living in Australia of around 88 per cent. 14 Analysis undertaken for the International Education Advisory Council suggests the average cost of an international education in Australia increased by 166 per cent between 2002 and 2011, compared with a 55 per cent increase for international students in the United States and a 78 per cent increase for students in the UK 19. This competitive disadvantage provides an imperative for Australia and Victoria to demonstrate that it provides superior value through a high quality, well-regarded study and living experience for international students. These developments reinforce the need for Victoria to compete on its educational merits for international students – that is, as a location offering quality education and high quality student experiences (both on campus and off, in the classroom and extracurricular). They also signal the need for Victorian providers to be flexible and innovative in course content and delivery. Victorian institutions must be nimble in responding to the changing global environment to take advantage of the opportunities that present. We have the necessary capabilities and are well placed to meet the challenges. 19 The Boston Consulting Group, Analysis of Strategic Trends, February 2013, prepared for the IEAC. 4. A Strategic Approach to Sustainable Growth Victoria’s vision to be the leading provider of international education in the Asia-Pacific region will be achieved by a proactive and strategic approach that supports the education and training sector to capitalise on the opportunities presented by global demand for education, while minimising the barriers that providers face in a highly competitive global market. This strategy identifies four goals which together will support achievement of the vision for Victoria’s international education sector over the next five years. These goals are: Goal 1: Consolidate Victoria’s position as a global leader in international education. Goal 2: Increase Victoria’s share of Australia’s international students, boosting student numbers and export revenue. Goal 3: Moderate volatility in student demand in order to create a sustainable sector. Goal 4: Capitalise on the broader cultural and economic benefits of international education. While migration settings and the relatively high Australian dollar are factors outside the control of the Victorian Government, the Government can support Victorian institutions and enterprises to access and capitalise on global opportunities by addressing these and other barriers. Key challenges to competitiveness of and growth of international education in Victoria include: the need for up-to-date knowledge of key markets and opportunities for providers, especially in new and emerging markets; access to contacts in source markets, and a need for government facilitation of contacts in some markets with centralised decision-making (e.g. China); the need for mechanisms that support collaborative responses to market needs (e.g. in new markets with diverse needs); positive student experience that goes beyond the study experience and relies on broader government and community action to welcome and support students; and the need for unified and consistent marketing to increase recognition (and take-up) of Victoria’s international education offerings because marketing efforts by individual providers alone may be insufficient to highlight the value of Victoria’s education and training attributes. The International Education Advisory Council (IEAC) Report – 2013 recognises the value and potential of international education to “drive economic, cultural and social outcomes for Australia in the Asian century” and to “be a significant export opportunity for Australia’s education institutions”. The Council made 35 recommendations designed to position Australia as a sustainable and quality provider of international education, with an emphasis on the Asian region. Victoria is a relatively small State that has performed very strongly in the global market for education over the last ten years. As is recognised by the IEAC, the global market for education is not only growing but is increasingly complex with intensifying competition and changing patterns of supply and demand. Victoria needs to ‘play to its strengths’, focusing on markets in which the State has a competitive advantage and where international education delivery/activity will complement and leverage other aspects of Victoria’s international engagement such as tourism and trade. Victoria’s other strengths include the quality of its educational institutions, its liveability, multicultural make up and Melbourne’s standing as a top student city. This document identifies four strategic action areas which will support sustainable growth of Victoria’s international education sector: Market Development – to support Victorian education and training providers to deepen their engagement in current overseas markets and to realise the opportunities in new markets for Victoria (see section 5); Quality – to drive the quality of Victoria’s international education services and delivery (see section 6); Student Experience – to enhance the overall experience of international students in Victoria (see section 7); and Marketing and Branding – to build Victoria’s international education profile in a crowded and competitive global market (see section 8). Initiatives under each of these strategic action areas, outlined in the following sections, form a cohesive and complementary program to position Victoria as the leading provider of international education in the Asia-Pacific region. Supporting strategic action A coordinated and strategic approach to achieving sustainable growth in Victoria’s international education sector will require greater collaboration between the Government and the sector. Accordingly, the Government announced in December 2012, as part of Securing Victoria’s Economy, that it would establish an industry advisory body to facilitate greater collaboration among Victorian education institutions and to provide a clear line of access to Government on strategic issues affecting the sector. The establishment of an advisory body will help ensure that international education receives the strategic focus and support it needs as Victoria’s largest single export industry. The advisory body will also enable stronger advocacy to the Commonwealth on issues such as migration policy and regulation of education quality and standards. INITIATIVE 1 Establish a Victorian international education advisory body, with representation from all education sub-sectors, to provide advice to the Minister for Innovation, Services and Small Business on issues impacting on the sector and its growth. 5. Market Development The sustainable growth of Victoria’s international education sector requires a multi-pronged approach to market development, comprising: consolidating and deepening delivery in markets in which Victorian providers are well-established such as eastern China, India, Malaysia and Singapore; expanding delivery in markets with growth potential for Victorian providers such as Vietnam, Indonesia, South Korea and the Gulf States; developing and building delivery in newer and emerging markets for Victorian providers such as western China, western and central Asia (including Turkey), some South East Asian countries (e.g. Thailand) and Latin America. Victoria has a strong base from which to deepen and expand delivery in its two key markets from which almost 50 per cent of international students are drawn (China and India) as well as in a number of key South East Asian countries (Malaysia, Vietnam and Indonesia). Figure 5: International student enrolments (on-shore), Victoria, by source country, 2012 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. China – 30% India – 17% Vietnam – 7% Malaysia – 5% Indonesia – 4% Pakistan – 3% Thailand – 3% South Korea – 3% Sri Lanka – 3% Nepal – 2% Other – 23% Source: AEI A goal of this strategy is to moderate volatility in student demand in order to create a sustainable sector. A key contributor to achievement of this goal is ensuring diverse source markets for international students, reducing reliance on one or two countries. Diversification of markets also supports efforts to increase Victoria’s share of students and to globalise the education experience for international and domestic students. Opportunity exists for Victoria’s education providers in countries with growing demand for education services such as in the Middle East and Latin America. Victorian providers are well-established in some Gulf States (mainly Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates) but there is potential for a stronger presence. A number of higher education providers have begun exploring opportunities in Latin America. Advice on the opportunities in Latin America 20 indicates the greatest opportunities for Victoria lie in Colombia, Chile and Brazil. This targeted approach to market development will differentiate between education sectors (higher education, VET, ELICOS and schools) while fostering greater synergy and pathways between the sectors. Victoria’s market development activities will also reflect the diversity of Victoria’s international education services, encompassing delivery to overseas students in Victoria, off-shore delivery, commercial contracts for overseas skills development/training, sale of curriculum and expertise and research partnerships. Supporting Victorian education providers in market 20 Tony Crooks, A Latin America Education Engagement Strategy for Victoria: A report for the Department of Industry, Innovation and Regional Development, December 2010. In new and emerging markets for Victoria, there is a role for Government in supporting Victorian providers to identify emerging opportunities. Exploration of new markets is expensive and involves significant up-front cost. Further there is often a lack of in-market intelligence to support market exploration which can combine to make it unattractive for individual providers. Consultation with the sector indicates that most providers see a role for Government in facilitating linkages, particularly in new markets (e.g. Latin America) and in markets with centralised decision-making and/or planned economies (e.g. China). Providers also see a valuable role for government in connecting them to companies with off-shore operations, especially Australian companies that may have local (off-shore) training needs. Austrade assists Australian education providers with information on international markets and the Victorian Government works collaboratively with Austrade to identify specific opportunities relevant to Victorian providers. A key mechanism that the Victorian Government has to support access to market opportunities in international education is the location of its Education Services Managers (ESMs) in key source markets. ESMs are currently operating in China (based in Shanghai), Japan and Korea (based in Tokyo), South East Asia (based in Kuala Lumpur), India (based in Bangalore) and the Middle East and North Africa (based in Dubai). With China expected to remain Victoria’s top source market over the next five years, maintaining an ESM in eastern China to concentrate on the attraction of students and servicing of partnerships in the eastern regions of the country is critical. The Victorian Government recently announced plans to establish a Victorian Government presence in Chengdu, the capital of Sichuan Province and part of the economic hub of south-west China. Sichuan Airlines, one of China’s fastest-growing airlines, is now offering direct flights three times a week from Chengdu to Melbourne. The Government’s 2012 Super Trade Mission to China saw Box Hill Institute sign three separate memoranda of understanding (MOU) with tertiary education providers in Chengdu. Victoria will build on these developments to expand partnerships with industry, particularly VET providers, in Chengdu and south-west China more broadly. A new ESM position based in Western China will support these efforts. Expanding activity in Victoria’s second significant source market – India – is also imperative. India has a young and increasingly urbanised population and a growing middle class – all attributes that are driving increased demand for education and training. The Indian Government has established clear goals for education and training including an additional 10 million people enrolled in higher education by 2016-1721 and training of 500 million people by 202222. While India boasts a well-developed education system, it faces challenges in meeting the vast demand for education and skills development. These circumstances are expected to further drive demand for international education by Indian students. British Council forecasts23 indicate that the highest growth in outward mobility will be among higher education students from India, providing opportunities for Victorian universities to expand their enrolment of students from India. Further opportunities are provided by Victoria’s strong VET system and capacity, particularly in provision of off-shore education and training services. The ESM in India will support Victorian providers to access opportunities for delivery to Indian students and to further develop partnerships with India. After China and India, South East Asian countries are Victoria’s top source countries for international students. Victoria has a long history of delivery of higher education to students from Malaysia and Victoria’s ESM covering South East Asia is based in Malaysia. More recently economic growth in Vietnam and Indonesia has increased demand for international education. Vietnam is now Victoria’s third largest source of international students. Indonesia currently has a relatively low student global mobility rate but its population of around 244 million and Government plans for economic development in priority industry areas point to opportunities for Victoria to expand delivery across higher education and VET, including in-market delivery and industry training. 21 Ernst & Young, Federation of Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Government of India Planning Commission; Higher Education in India: Twelfth Five Year Plan (2012-2017) and Beyond. 22 AEI, Policy Overview of Vocational Education and Training in India, September 2011. 23 British Council, Going Global 2012. The Victorian International Education Cluster is pursuing targeted opportunities in the Indonesian market (see Initiative 4). With Victoria re-opening a Victorian Government Business Office in Jakarta, the location of a dedicated ESM in Indonesia will enable strengthening of education links between Victoria and Indonesia and lay the foundations for further growth of international education services to Indonesians as its economy further develops. As a region, the Middle East and Western Asia is diverse, comprising many countries. There is strong growth in demand for international education across the region and there is a strong presence of foreign universities located in countries such as Saudi Arabia. Victoria currently attracts only 26 per cent of international student enrolments to Australia from this region, although the share is higher for UAE and Oman. Government scholarship programs in countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan provide opportunities for Victoria, as does growing demand for vocational education and training. Victorian providers are keen to explore opportunities in Turkey. South Korea has the third highest number of internationally outbound tertiary students (behind China and India) and a significant number of students from South Korea study in Australia. However, Victoria’s share of these students is relatively low. Increased engagement with Korea is warranted. Japan is a mature market for Victorian education providers and student numbers have declined over the last seven years. However there is an opportunity for Victorian providers to respond to increasing demand by Japanese businesses for employees, not only with English language skills but also with international experience, consistent with the Japanese Government’s policy to further develop the country’s Global Human Capital. Latin America is a vast geographical area with diverse markets and opportunities. Victoria is a late entrant to the market, with Canada, New Zealand, NSW and Queensland already well-established in these markets. Victoria’s share of Latin American student enrolments in Australia remains low at around 17 per cent. However the number of students from Latin American countries studying in Victoria, particularly from Colombia, has increased significantly over recent years. With a relatively young population and increasing economic prosperity, demand for education is exceeding supply across Latin America. A number of countries in the region provide significant funding to encourage internationalisation of their education institutions through two-way flow of staff, students and researchers. Major global events such as the 2016 Olympics in Brazil are also increasing demand for training. Given the range of opportunities available across Latin America, serious exploration is warranted. A number of Victorian education institutions have established education and research partnerships in the region and there is strong interest to pursue further opportunities. At present, awareness of Australia is generally low across the region and subsequently Victoria’s profile is almost non-existent in some parts. The presence of an ESM in a Latin American country such as Chile or Colombia would allow Victoria to increase promotion of Victoria as a study destination and to support the establishment of education partnerships/alliances. INITIATIVE 2 Extend the support provided by Victoria’s network of Education Services Managers (ESMs) in key markets (eastern China, India, South East Asia, the Middle East and Western Asia, Japan and South Korea) with the placement of additional ESMs in western China, Indonesia and Latin America, to target future growth opportunities. Development of market engagement plans is essential for stronger and more consistent outcomes and will inform the priorities of ESMs. Detailed plans will be based on strong market intelligence and research and will include analysis of market conditions and assessment of future trends. Marketing activities in the region will target both onshore and offshore business development across all sectors. Activities will include industry, government and institutional outreach by the ESMs, brand strengthening initiatives and targeted inbound and outbound delegations and trade missions. Outbound trade missions and incoming familiarisation visits for stakeholders or potential partners will be linked to industry and education priorities of key markets and provide access to new opportunities in service delivery, skills training, and research development. INITIATIVE 3 Establish a strategically-focused program of onshore and offshore market development activity including targeted trade missions to support growth in identified priority, established and emerging markets. In expanding and newer markets, there are often diverse education and training needs and under-developed systems for meeting these needs. In such markets, there are often multiple stakeholders/clients including government agencies, aid agencies and businesses seeking to access international education services as well as individual students and their families. The Victorian Government will enhance opportunities available to the Victorian international education sector by profiling capabilities and strengths of the Victorian education providers and by facilitating access to key international government and industry bodies. The Department of State Development, Business and Innovation (DSDBI) and ESMs will support the work of Victorian Government Commissioners to develop government to government partnerships and agreements in key markets. A valuable mechanism in this context is the export cluster model. In 2011, the Government established the Victorian International Education Cluster (VIEC) which focuses on strengthening government-to-government, industry and institutional linkages in South East Asia by providing collaborative solutions. INITIATIVE 4 Continue to support collaborative models for Victorian providers such as the Victorian International Education Cluster to leverage commercial opportunities in new markets. INITIATIVE 5 Work with Victorian VET providers and key stakeholders to explore the potential and plan for transnational partnerships in VET program and skills development Cluster members include universities, TAFE institutes and private education and training providers. An advantage of the cluster approach is that it provides a platform for Victorian education providers to work in a collaborative manner and to bid for large projects with multiple requirements. The scale of demand for skills development in emerging economies, coupled with Victoria’s strong VET system and capacity, provide a strategic opportunity for Victoria. Demand is also escalating for long term capacity building arrangements and Victoria’s VET providers have the expertise to guide development of systems, processes and curriculum. These enormous opportunities often require a collaborative approach with industry and State Government as well as vocational education and training providers. Victorian Government facilitation of new market opportunities – some examples Training opportunities in Indonesia: In mid-2011, the Victorian Government established an international education cluster for South East Asia to explore and respond to emerging opportunities in that region. As part of the work of the cluster, Victoria’s Education Services Manager for South East Asia led a small group of Victorian VET providers on a mission to Java in early 2012, meeting with representatives of Indonesia’s Bappenas (Ministry of Planning) and the Indonesian Ministry of Home Affairs, and a delegation of 35 Indonesian Government decision makers participated in an inbound mission to Melbourne later that year. A range of projects have been identified including potential delivery of World Bank scholarships to Indonesian recipients, customised leadership programs (also funded by the World Bank), an internship program for Indonesian Government agencies and a consultancy opportunity to develop a national approach to public sector staff training for the Indonesian Ministry of Home Affairs. Strategic linkages with the Iraqi Government: In 2013 the Victorian Government facilitated a meeting between an Iraqi delegation and representatives from Victoria’s nine generalist universities to discuss Victoria’s capacity to deliver education to Iraqi citizens under scholarships fully funded by the Iraqi Government. The Iraqi delegation, which also visited NSW and Queensland, provided positive feedback on Victoria’s professionalism and effectiveness in facilitating the discussions. The Iraqi Government requested that the DSDBI coordinate the allocation of scholarships to Victorian universities and has now directed to Victoria 60 per cent of the first tranche of scholarships allocated to Australia. 6. Enhancing the Quality of International Education The key to Victoria’s success in international education is the inherent quality of its educational services. The quality of the education experience is critical to student choice and essential to “backing up” the brand to support future growth. The 2012 International Student Survey24 confirmed the importance of quality and reputation in student choice. The top factors influencing the choice of where to study in Australia reported by international higher education and VET students in Australia, were quality of teaching, reputation of a qualification and institution, quality of research and reputation of the Australian education system. In 2011 the Commonwealth assumed responsibility for regulation of the quality of all post-secondary international education. In this context, the Victorian Government has only a limited role in relation to quality of international education delivery (currently relating only to secondary school education). While it does not coordinate or control the delivery of international education, the Victorian Government is committed to taking action where possible to safeguard, enhance and promote the quality of Victoria’s international education services. Of particular significance to Victoria is safeguarding the quality of off-shore delivery (or transnational education). The National Quality Council identified significant risks to Australia’s education “brand” and reputation as a result of limited regulatory oversight of transnational education (TNE). As the State with the dominant share of TNE, Victoria’s risk is higher than that of other States. It is in Victoria’s interests to work with the sector to ensure high quality delivery of offshore education and training. It is also important that regulation of offshore delivery is appropriate – for example, that Australian standards are not enforced where Australian qualifications are not delivered. A policy review of the regulation of offshore delivery, drawing on the expertise of Victorian providers who have extensive experience in offshore delivery, would strengthen Victoria’s capacity to advocate for effective regulation of TNE. INITIATIVE 6 Support Victoria’s leading position in offshore delivery of education and training by undertaking a policy review of the regulation of offshore education to enable Victoria to advocate to the Commonwealth for regulation that protects the integrity of education standards without impeding Victoria’s competitive position. However, the focus on quality needs to go beyond ‘quality assurance’ measures. The global market for international education is dynamic and competitive and Victoria needs to be at the forefront of education and research. Victoria has already established itself as a leader in research and innovation as epitomised in its world-recognised research facilities and institutes such as the Australian Synchrotron, the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute (Australia’ largest medical research institute) and the AgriBio Centre for AgriBioscience based at La Trobe University. This provides a strong incentive for international students and researchers to come to Victoria and is a competitive advantage for Victoria that needs to be fostered and promoted. Victoria’s two Ph.D. scholarship programs – the Victoria India Doctoral Scholarships (VIDS) and the Victorian International Research Scholarships (VIRS) – are valuable instruments in building Victoria’s brand as a high quality research and academic centre. An additional benefit of these programs is the development of a ‘cadre’ of ambassadors who can promote the quality of Victoria’s education and research institutions in their home countries and help build education exchange and research partnerships. INITIATIVE 7 Continue to attract high quality international research scholars to Victoria through funding for international doctoral scholarships. 24 AEI, International Student Survey 2012 – Overview Report, April 2013. The position of Victoria as a high quality, globally-focused education and training destination will be further strengthened by expansion of opportunities for Victorians to undertake studies overseas. Student exchange programs are an effective vehicle for developing greater language proficiency and intercultural understanding. Increasing the number of Victorian secondary students who are proficient in Asian language skills by supporting them to study abroad will further boost Victoria’s ‘Asian literacy’ and strengthen our economic and cultural ties with Asia. The Victorian Government recognises the importance of two-way exchange for all Victorians, not just students, for increasing our Asian cultural and language proficiency and understanding of appropriate behaviour for business engagement. Broadening Victorians’ cultural competence will improve the competitiveness of Victorian businesses and increase the global readiness of local graduates. The Hamer Scholarships program was established in March 2012 to provide opportunities for Victorians to undertake intensive Chinese language study in Jiangsu Province, Victoria’s Sister State. As part of its Victorian International Engagement Strategy, the Government is expanding the Hamer Scholarships to other countries in the region. INITIATIVE 8 Expand opportunities for Victorians to build their Asian language capabilities and encourage two-way cultural exchange, including: establishment of a China Immersion Program for Year 9 students which will enable 1,500 Victorian secondary school students to participate in a language and cultural immersion program in China for up to one school term; and expansion of the Hamer Scholarships program to Indonesia, Korea and Japan, offering scholarships for Victorian professionals to increase their Asian language and cultural skills through study in the region. Promotion of the quality of the sector through significant events also contributes to Victoria’s profile in a competitive market. The inaugural Victorian Government International Education Awards to recognise best practice in international education, including outstanding international education providers and students in Victoria, will be held in late 2013. These awards will complement the Awards for International Students in Victorian schools and highlight excellence in the provision of international education in Victoria and the achievements of outstanding international students. The Government will explore opportunities for significant events that attract global attention to Victoria’s education sector. INITIATIVE 9 Showcase Victoria’s quality international education through events such as the annual Victorian Government International Education Awards to commence in late 2013. 7. Student Experience Student experience affects the attractiveness of an education destination and word of mouth is an important source of information in the decision making process of potential international students. There is a strong correlation between a positive student experience and the likelihood of recommending Victoria as a place to study 25. In 2008 nearly 80 per cent of Victoria’s international students had family and/or friends from home currently studying in Australia 26. Melbourne is the world’s most liveable city27 and is ranked the fourth student city in the world (after Paris, London and Boston). Recent surveys of international students have found that overall international students’ experience in Australia (and Victoria) is positive. In 2012, 85.7 per cent of international students in Victoria were either satisfied or very satisfied with their overall living experience in Victoria 28. However the experience of international students can be improved. Research suggests that international students are seeking more positive living experiences in Australia including better opportunities for social interaction and work experience29. Victoria recognises the mutual long term benefits of ensuring international students have a unique, rewarding experience and are encouraged to connect with the local community. A positive living experience can relieve some of the pressures of being a young adult in unfamiliar surroundings without the usual support structures of family and friends. It can also support the transition to the new cultural and learning environment. International students then return home with positive thoughts of Victoria and a cultural and social awareness that can provide long term benefits to Victoria. At the same time the presence of international students enriches the experience of Victorians – in the classroom, in communities and in workplaces. The lifelong relationships that develop can open doors to trade, social and cultural exchanges that are vital to a growing, outwardly-focused economy. Victoria’s excellent educational institutions have existing dedicated support structures for international students and the Victorian Government has worked in partnership with them to enhance the service that is collectively provided to the students. In addition to maximising the safety and well-being of all residents and visitors, the Victorian Government supports a range of programs to improve the living experience of international students to the State. The International Student Care Service, Welcome Desk and the Culture Card are examples of additional services provided by Victoria which establish the State as a leader in its support of international students. Student support The International Student Care Service (ISCS) provides vital support, advice and assistance to international students 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The ISCS complements the student support services provided through educational institutions and works closely with a broad range of service providers such as Consumer Affairs Victoria and legal services, referring students as required. The ISCS provides crisis intervention and support in emergency situations as well as information and assistance with accommodation, legal issues, health services and other personal support services. The service is staffed by multilingual, professionally trained staff who are culturally aware, and can personally respond to the student’s needs or refer students as required. As other States introduce similar student support programs, it is important for Victoria to enhance the reach and depth of its programs if Victoria’s significant advantage in this field is to be preserved. There is capacity to use the ISCS as 25 The Nous Group, Priorities for Improving the International Student Experience and Support Services, November 2011 Lawrence, R. The 2008 Futurecast Study, Prospect Research, Delivered at the AIEC conference 2009 27 Melbourne was named the most livable city in the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Liveability Ranking Report, August 2012 28 AEI, International Student Survey 2012 29 The Nous Group, Priorities for Improving the International Student Experience and Support Services, commissioned by DBI, 2011 26 the core of a range of student services provided from a facility at the heart of the student precinct of Melbourne and to better promote the service. Recognising that for many international students their time in Victoria represents their first experience of independent living, there is a need to strengthen provision of educative and preventative information, especially in relation to health and wellbeing. It is also essential international students intending to study in Victoria have clear and unambiguous information on the need for comprehensive health insurance (including the limitations of health insurance cover relating to waiting periods for health cover) as they are not covered by Australia’s Medicare system. While it is primarily a Commonwealth responsibility, Victoria can support information provision in this area to minimise negative experiences for international students in Victoria. Other issues on which students need better information include financial management, safety and accommodation issues. Victoria’s student care services can be enhanced through more wide-reaching, proactive and preventative information provision on these matters, working collaboratively with education and service providers. The enhancement of these support services is consistent with the principles to promote and protect the human rights of international students recently released by the Australian Human Rights Commission30. INITIATIVE 10 Establish the Study Melbourne Student Centre by: relocating the International Student Care Service to a visible location in the informal student precinct in central Melbourne to improve its accessibility; augmenting the services of the Centre by strengthening health promotion and prevention advice including clearer information to students about eligibility for health services and insurance requirements as well as legal services; and exploring opportunities for partnerships with other student service providers. Public Transport Costs for International Students The Government will introduce a new public transport ticket scheme for international students from 2015 in partnership with education providers. The scheme will reduce transport costs for eligible students in metropolitan and regional institutions. Recognising that public transport costs for many international students are significant, the Government will be providing some extra help. Accordingly, the Government will provide a discount on annual full fare myki passes to eligible students. Unlike NSW, Victoria’s scheme will be available in all travel zones including Zone 1 covering Inner Melbourne. Metropolitan and regional providers will be able to opt in to the scheme and will be required to contribute towards its cost if they want their students to have access to the scheme. The new public transport ticket scheme will help make international students feel more welcome when they come to study in Victoria. The Government will undertake commercial discussions with public transport operators before being able to announce details. Details of the scheme will be announced in 2014 to commence in 2015. Initiative 11 The Government will trial a new public transport ticket scheme for eligible international students from 2015 for three years in partnership with education providers. 30 Australian Human Rights Commission, October 2012 Accommodation On moving to Victoria, international students are faced with the challenge of finding somewhere to live. Access to affordable accommodation is an issue for many students who have relocated to Melbourne to study but international students in particular generally lack an understanding of the housing market and lack an extended network of friends and family to fall back on. Institutions provide a range of support to assist international students to find accommodation – including on-campus housing, support to find accommodation in the private rental market and advice on housing issues. Supporting the efforts of education and training providers, the Victorian Government provides information to students about renting in the private market through its Study Melbourne website and information provided on arrival at Melbourne Airport. The ISCS is also available to assist students with accommodation issues as required. Complementing its general information to Victorians on residential tenancy issues, Consumer Affairs Victoria provides information on renting in Victoria in English and other languages and their services are promoted through educational institutions. The 2012 International Student Survey31 found generally high levels of satisfaction with the quality and safety of accommodation but lower satisfaction with the cost of accommodation. Access to affordable accommodation also remains an issue. The International Education Advisory Council report recommends a sample stocktake of “off-campus” accommodation with a view to developing a national standards and quality ratings model for accommodation. It is proposed that the issue of accommodation be a matter for consideration of the new Victorian International Education Advisory Body (Initiative 1). Towards a ‘premium’ student experience To remain a top provider of international education, Victoria needs to go beyond offering a safe and ‘liveable’ destination to offering international students a ‘premium’ experience. In addition to lifestyle and quality of education, international students are most concerned with their employability once they have completed their studies. This reflects the expectation of a ‘return on investment’ made in international education and is a consistent theme in research about students’ needs. Employability skills may be gained through work placements and work experience during studies, either integrated with learning or arranged independent of their studies, and through post-study employment. Most international students also look for part time employment during their studies to supplement their living expenses. Barriers to greater participation of international students in work placements include: 31 lack of clarity and confusion about rules governing participation in work placements under the Education Services to Overseas Students (ESOS) Act and about visa conditions; lack of awareness among employers of the availability and potential benefits of work placements for international students; perceived English language deficiencies and cultural barriers by employers; lack of networks and industry knowledge of international students which can impede their ability to organise their own work placements32. AEI (2013), International Higher Education Student Satisfaction with Accommodation in Australia, pending publication. The issues around international student work placements and opportunities to increase work placements are explored in an internal report prepared for DSDBI by the International Education Association of Australia. 32 Government can assist employers through the provision of clear and accurate information about the work entitlements of international students and their potential contribution to business. The establishment of post-study work visas for international higher education graduates from early 2013 provides a platform for further action. As an example, through the overseas skills registry project, the Victorian Government is working with two Victorian education institutions to match international students with employers who have skill needs that they have been unable to meet. This preliminary work to expand professional work opportunities for international students can inform a more substantial work experience program for international students. An internship program – particularly one that focuses on placement with employers with international operations – will enhance the reputation of Victorian education institutions as providing international students with employment-ready qualifications. INITIATIVE 12 Expand work experience opportunities for international students including the establishment of a Study Melbourne Internship Program, offering up to 150 international student internships per annum in the private and public sectors and work with employers to build awareness of the benefits of engaging international students. Another recurrent theme in research into the experience of international students in Australia and Victoria is the desire for more opportunities for social interaction and engagement with local communities 33. Students are attracted to the lifestyle offered in Melbourne and seek a genuine local experience whilst studying in Australia. The strong focus on sport in Victoria offers a valuable mechanism to link international students with the local community. Programs such as GloBALL offer opportunities for international students to attend sporting events at the elite level (AFL, cricket and netball games) and encourage participation at the local level. The opportunity to interact with players, staff and supporters also benefits local communities by increasing interaction with people from different cultures. There is also evidence that some international students experience social isolation, increasing risks associated with lack of social support. Efforts to increase the connection of international students to other students, their communities and to support services will all enhance the overall experience of international students in Victoria. At the same time, Victoria remains a cohesive multicultural, multilingual and multifaith society. Our multicultural communities make a significant contribution to Victoria’s development – both culturally and economically. Victoria will continue to encourage and support activities that connect established communities with international students, further strengthening and uniting the community for the benefit of all Victorians. INITIATIVE 13 Establish the Study Melbourne Experience Program, providing a comprehensive program of activities and programs that will connect international students with the broader community including: redevelopment of the Culture Card into the Study Melbourne Card and expansion of the range of activities available through the Card; support for student initiatives to facilitate greater connection between international students and the community; continued support for the International Student Welcome Desk at the Melbourne Airport; delivery of events to welcome international students to the State such as the annual welcome event for international school students; and celebration of the contribution of international students in Victoria through established Government programs such as Cultural Diversity Week. In international education, as in any market, the voice of the consumer needs to be heard to ensure that their needs are understood, considered and, where possible, addressed. Students also want to “have a say” in decisions that affect them. 33 Australian Education International, Student Voices: Enhancing the experience of international students in Australia, June 2012; The Nous Group, 2011, op cit. There is also great value in increasing opportunities for dialogue between government representatives and international students to support greater understanding of issues of importance to students. The establishment of social media functionality on the Study Melbourne website (Initiative 15) will provide further opportunities for international students to share their experiences. INITIATIVE 14 Improve channels for communication with, and feedback from, international students on their experience in Victoria. 8. Marketing and Branding Effective and sustained marketing of Melbourne/Victoria as a study destination is fundamental to supporting sustainable growth of the sector. Under the “Australia Unlimited” brand promoted by Austrade, Victoria needs to establish and maintain its identity and to differentiate its products in the face of strong global competition. ‘Brand’ awareness and brand value are critical drivers of student decisions about where to study. The Study Melbourne website is the primary mechanism for provision of information to potential students. As with tourism, the Government has a key role in ensuring a unified and consistent message about the attractiveness and quality of Victoria’s international education sector through marketing activities. The Study Melbourne brand is well-supported by providers who consider that Victoria should position itself as a ‘highquality’ choice for education. Research undertaken for Tourism Victoria consistently demonstrates the advantage of using ‘Melbourne’ as the primary brand, due to confusion of ‘Victoria’ with other locations (e.g. Canada) 34. Regionallybased providers will be assisted to leverage the impact of Study Melbourne for their regions. INITIATIVE 15 Broaden the reach of the Study Melbourne brand to integrate all Victoria’s international education activities under the one brand (e.g. the International Student Care Service becomes the Study Melbourne Student Centre; the Culture Card program becomes the Study Melbourne Card). Through the website, Study Melbourne has asserted itself as a trusted government brand for potential students. Website statistics, combined with feedback from students and institutions, support the continued use and development of this premium tool. Over 108,000 people (unique visitors) used the Study Melbourne website in the twelve months to 1 March 2013; 80 per cent of them were new visitors to the site. It is critical that this tool continues to grow and develop along with the technological usage and expectations of the student cohort. The first stage of redevelopment of the Study Melbourne website was completed in early 2013, including the establishment of nine new in-language sites (Arabic, Bahasa Indonesia, Chinese (simplified), Hindi, Japanese, Korean, Portuguese, Spanish and Vietnamese) and five Study Melbourne mobile sites (in Arabic, Chinese, English, Japanese and Korean). These sites offer a condensed version of the full Study Melbourne website showcasing content specifically designed for use on mobile devices (e.g. mobile phones, electronic tablets). The inclusion of a social media component (e.g. Twitter, Facebook, Weibo) is essential to lift the profile and impact of the Study Melbourne website. Given the high use of social media by students, the next stage of development of the Study Melbourne website will include integration of social media. INITIATIVE 16 Ensure that the Study Melbourne website is a top global international student website, by adding, supporting and utilising the marketing opportunities of a social media component. The main focus of Victoria’s marketing efforts to date is on students. The Study Melbourne site is a consumer-facing website and much of the marketing collateral focuses on Melbourne as a student destination. Promotion of Victoria’s education and training sector to overseas businesses, governments and educational institutions would be strengthened by a business-to-business (B2B) marketing strategy including web-based information to support B2B engagement and assist in disseminating industry-oriented communications. INITIATIVE 17 Develop a business-to-business (B2B) marketing strategy to promote Victoria’s education and training capacity/providers to overseas businesses, institutions, governments and agents including: 34 Tourism Research Australia, International Visitor Survey December 2012, unpublished an online tool which facilitates B2B and government-to-business interaction; and development of high quality marketing collateral specifically designed for off-shore marketing to key decisionmakers and decision influencers such as governments, businesses and education agents. Renewed marketing efforts are required that take account of different drivers of demand in different overseas markets (for example, marketing of VET in India or Colombia will require a different approach to marketing higher education in Malaysia or Eastern China). To support a redeveloped brand strategy and support market development activities outlined in section 5, additional work is needed to ensure maximum resonance with target markets. INITIATIVE 18 Increase awareness of Victoria’s strengths in international education and training, including awareness of the Study Melbourne brand, through stronger marketing efforts including: detailed and differentiated marketing plans for key growth markets; targeted client focused marketing of Victoria’s educational capacity; utilisation of other related branding of Melbourne as an “intellectual” and culture centre (i.e. Melbourne as a Knowledge City and a UNESCO City of Literature) and as an engaging liveable tourist destination through Tourism Victoria; and working with Tourism Victoria to welcome friends and relatives of international students to Victoria. Finally, maintaining on-going connections with international alumni of Victoria’s educational institutions provides an opportunity to promote Victoria as a welcoming student city and to forge stronger links to cultural and business activities. Anecdotally, the Government knows that many international students who study in Victoria go on to develop business and trade links with Victoria, underpinned by the knowledge of Victoria gained while studying here. The Victoria Connection program, with over 2,500 members, provides a mechanism for networking between professional Victorian expatriates, repatriates, alumni and those interested in doing business with Victoria who live outside of Australia. However greater engagement with Victoria’s international alumni provides a valuable mechanism to maximise the benefits of international education to Victoria. INITIATIVE 19 Strengthen engagement with Victoria’s international student alumni through: greater utilisation of the Victoria Connection initiative to leverage existing contacts and networks; organisation of alumni events overseas, coinciding with trade missions and industry events, to promote Victoria’s international education sectors and build business ties; and partnering with educational institutions to offer a broader range of activities to their international alumni. 9. Implementation The Victorian Government allocated $17.5 million over four years in the 2013-14 Budget to support implementation of the International Education Strategy. Initiatives will be implemented progressively from the first quarter of 2013-14. The last four years have demonstrated that the international education sector is dynamic. It is important therefore to review the effectiveness of the Strategy as it proceeds. An evaluation framework will be established and a mid-point review conducted. The international education advisory body will support implementation of the Strategy, providing advice and guidance as required.