Thinking toward my comprehensive exams…
Motivation, rationale/objectives
Beth Dempster, Ph.D. student
University of Waterloo
www.fes.uwaterloo.ca/u/mbldemps
METHODOLOGY READING LISTS
Research - Civics/consensus – Planning procedure - Learning
Ecosystem approaches – Systems Related
Potporri
From other areas of interest
Methodology: Motivation - Rationale/objectives
JUNE 17, 2001
 Degree of concentration:
1 = higher c = cursory
m = maybe, but yet uncertain
 References read:
< = less so > = more so
- = middling or read previously
and not yet reviewed
This set of reading lists is more tentative than most of the others. Rather than emerging from focused
intentional research on finding "appropriate methodologies," the list represents a gathering of references
over the years through intent and serendipity.
Research
1
c
m
c
c
m
c
c
c
m
m
c
c
c
m
c
<
<
-
<
<
Alvesson, Mats and Kaj
Sköldberg
Creswell, John W.
Cunningham, J. Barton
Firestone, W. A.
Fonow, M. M and J. A.
Cook
Gioia, D.A., Pitre, E.
Guba, Egon G., ed.
Harding, Sandra
Kirby and McKenna
Marcus, George E.
Marcus, George E., ed.
Morgan, Gareth, ed.
Morrow, R. A. with D. B.
Brown
Nelson, J. G.
Norgaard, R. B.
Palys, Ted
2000
1994
1993
1987
1991
1990
1990
1987
1998
1999
1983
1994
1991
1989
1997
Reflexive methodology: new vistas for qualitative
research
Research Design: Qualitative and Quantitative
Approaches
Action Research and Organizational Development
Meaning in methods: The rhetoric of quantitative and
qualitative
research Feminist Scholarship as Lived
Beyond
Methodology:
Research
Multiparadigm perspectives on theory building
The Paradigm Dialog
Introduction: Is There a Feminist Method?
Experience Research Social Science
Ethnography through thick and thin
Critical anthropology now: unexpected contexts,
shifting constituencies,
changing
agendas
Beyond
Method: Strategies
for Social
Research
Critical Theory and Methodology
Research in Human Ecology and Planning: An
Interactive,
Adaptive
Approach
The Case for
Methodological
Pluralism
Research Decisions: Quantitative and Qualitative
Perspectives, 2nd ed.
London : SAGE
Sage
Praeger,
Westport, Conn
Educational
Researcher
Indiana University
Press
Adademy of
Management
Sage
Review
in Feminism and
Reaching Agreement: Consensus Processes in
British
Columbia
Differences
of opinion: Round Tables, policy
networks,
and the failure for
of Canadian
environmental
Shared Decision-Making
British Columbia
strategy
(Orientation
Materials)
Finding
Common
Ground: A Shared Vision For Land
Use in British Columbia
Communications
Strategy Report - Georgian Bay
Islands
National
Park Ecosystem
Conservation
Plan
A framework
for scaling
and framing
policy problems
in
sustainability
Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving
In Directions in Mediation: Communication
New
Research andapproaches
Perspectives
Participatory
to sustainable urban
development:
reflections
on practice
in Seattle,
Anthropology as
cultural critique:
an experimental
Vancouver
and
Waitakere
moment
in
the
human
sciences
Towards a Sense of Civics: Sustainable
Development,
Civic
realism the Universities and Provincial
Renewal
Mediation, Citizen Empowerment, and
B.C. Round Table
on
Environment
Alternatives
and
Economy
CORE
CORE
Heritage
Resources
Ecological Centre
Economics
Houghton Miffin
Sage
Planning Practice
and
Research
University
of
Chicago Press,
Chicago
; London
MIT Press,
Civics/consensus
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
m
m
c
m
m
m
c
c
<
-
-
BCRTEE (B.C. Round
Table
on J.
Environment
Brunton,
and M.
and
Economy)
Howlelt
CORE (Commission On
Resources
and
CORE
(Commission
on
Environment)
Resources
and
Dakin,
Susan
Environment)
Dovers, Stephen R.
1991
1992
1992
1994
1996
1995
Fisher, R. and W. Ury
1981
Folger, J.P. and T.S.
1994
Jones, eds.
Malbert,
B.
1998
Marcus, George E. and 1999
Michael
M.J.
Nelson, J.
G. Fischer
1993
Rowe, Peter G.
1997
Schwerin, Edward W.
1995
Selin, S. and D. Chavez 1995
Susskind, L., ed.
1999
Swaffield, Simon
1998
Transformational
Politics model for environmental
Developing a collaborative
planning
and
management
Handbook on Consensus-Building
Frames of Reference: A metaphor for analyzing and
interpreting attitudes of environmental policy makers
and policy influencers
Methodology, S.
Harding,
Princetoned.
University
School of Press,
Princeton,
American N.J.
Sage
Research
Press,
Sage
Santa Fe, N.M.
The Canadian
Geographer
Ecological
Economics
Harcourt
Brace
and Company
Canada, Toronto
Cambridge,
Mass.
Environmental
Management
Sage, Beverly
Hills, CA
Environmental
Management
planning reading – beth dempster, uwaterloo – June 17, 2001 - 1
Alicja
Muszyn
Jaquie
ski
Newma
Jaquie
n
Newma
n
Woltjer
2000
Jaquie
ref list
Newma
n
japa
review
63
(2)
Foreste
r 1999
Planning procedure
c
m
c
c
c
1
m
c
m
c
-
-
Brown, Daryl W.
Cohen +
Commission on
Resources
Crossan, M.and
M., H. W.
Environment
Lane, R.A.E. White and
Etzioni,
L.
Klus John
Forester,
1996
1972
1992
1996
1967
1999
Mandelbaum, S.
1991
Throgmorton, J. A.
1992
Throgmorton, J. A.
1995
Throgmorton, James A. 1993
Learning
c
c
c
c
c
c
m
-
Argyris, C. and D.
Schon
Argyris, Chris
Argyris, Chris
Barrett, Frank J.
Krippendorff, K.
Schon, Donald A.
Schneider, B., A. P.
Brief and R. A. Guzzo
1996
1993
1993
1995
1987
1994
1996
Strategic Land Use Planning Source Book
Garbage Can Model of Organizational Choice
Report on a Land Use Strategy for British Columbia
The Improvising Organization: Where Planning Meets
Opportunity
Mixed-scanning:
A "third" approach to decisionmaking
The
Deliberative Practitioner: Encouraging
Participatory
Telling StoriesPlanning Processes
Planning as Persuasive Storytelling About the Future:
Negotiating
an Electric
Power
Rate Settlement
in
Ethics,
Passion,
Reason,
and Power:
The Rhetorics
Illinois
of Electircas
Power
Planning
in Chicago
Planning
a Rhetorical
Activity:
Survey Research as
a Trope in Arguments About Electric Power Planning
in Chicago
Commission on
Resources and
Administrative
Environment,
Science
CORE Quarterly
Victoria, B.C.
Organizational
Design
Public
Administration
MIT Press,
Review
Cambridge,
Journal of MA
allison'
Planning
s thesis
Education
In Planningand
Research
Ethics: AofReader
Journal
the
In Planning
American
Theory,
PlanningPractice
and Education
Association
Organizational Learning II: theory, method and
practice
Knowledge for action: a guide to overcoming barriers
to organizational
On
Organizationalchange
Learning
Creating Appreciative Learning Cultures
Paradigms for Communication and Development with
Emphasis
on Autopoiesis
Frame Reflection:
Toward the Resolution of
Intractable
Policy Controversies
Creating
a Climate
and Culture for Sustainable
Organizational Change
Jossey-Bass, San
Francisco
Jossey-Bass, San
Francisco
Blackwell
Business,
Organizational
imagini
Cambridge
Design
ng
In:
Communication
Basic Books, New possibil
Hempel
Theory:
Eastern ities
York
Organizational
and
and
Western
Design
generat
Perspectives,
Kincaid, D.L., ed. ing new
ways of
in National Parks looking
and
ProtectedJoint at the
International
Areas:
Their role world
Commission
Conservation
USFS
in
environmental Human
Biology
Lewis
Publishers,
mitchell
protection R. G.
Factors
Chelsea,
97
Berrett-Koehler,
from
Wright, ed.
Biblio
Michigan
San
Francisco
Capra
Island Press,
Washington,
D.C.
Conservation
ian
Biology
thornto
Conservation
n
Biology
Coastal
Management
John Wiley,
Chichester
in National Parks
and Protected
Futures
Areas:
Their role
Island Press,
in environmental
in
Public Issues:
protection,
R. G.
A
Geographical
in
Landscape
Wright,
ed.
Perspective,
Ecology
and J.
in
Ecosystem
Audrey
and
Management,
Health, R. J. G.
Ecological
Nelson,
eds.
Proceeding
the
Costanza,
B.ofG.
Economics
in
Conservation
of
First
symposium
Norton,
and
B. D.
Biodiversity
and
Landscape
and
P 675c
of
the
Canadian
Haskell,
eds.
the New
Regional
Urban
Planning
Society
for
Planning,
LandscapeR. E.
Ecology
Saunier
and
Ecology
and R. A.
Marine Policy
Meganack,
eds.
Management
St Lucie Press,
Delray, Florida
Human
Ecology USFS
Review
Human
Factors
Biblio
Ecosystem approaches, adaptive management, etc.
c
c
m
m
m
c
c
c
c
c
c
1
c
m
m
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
m
-
<
<
<
Agee, J. K.
Allen, T.F.H., B.L.
Bandurski,
Alpert, P. and A.W.
King
Cairns, J. and T. V.
Crawford, eds.
Callenbach,
E. F.
Capra,
L. Goldman,
Costanza,
R., B. G. S.
Marburg,
and
Norton,
and
D.Lutz
Grumbine,
R.B.R.
Edward
Haskell, eds.
Grumbine,
R. Edward
Hennessey, Timothy M.
Holling, C. S.
Jope, K. L. and J. C.
Dunstan
Kay,
J. J., H. A. Regier,
M. Boyle,
Lee,
Kai N.and G.
Francis
Nelson, J. G. and R.
1996
1993
1995
1991
1993
1992
1997
1994
1994
1978
1996
1999
1993
1993
Serafin
Nelson, J. G., P.
1988
Grigoriew,
P. G. R.
Norton,
B. G.
1992
Smith,
Savory,J.A.B. Theberge
1991
Slocombe, D. Scott
1995
Slocombe, D. Scott
1998
Walters
1986
Walters, C. J. and C. S. 1990
Holling
Wilson, J. A., J. M
1994
Acheson,
M. Metcalfe
Woodley, S.,
J.J. Kay
1993
and G.
P. Kleban
and
Francis
Young,
G. L.
1994
Ecosystem Management: An Appropriate Concept for
Parks?
The Ecosystem Approach: theory and ecosystem
integrity
Incarnating ecosystem management
Integrated Environmental Management
EcoManagement
Ecosystem Health: New Goals for Environmental
Management
Reflections on "What is Ecosystem Management?"
What Is Ecosystem Management?
Governance and Adaptive Management for Estuarine
Ecosystems:
The Case of
Chesapeake
Bay
Adaptive Environmental
Assessment
and
Management
Ecosystem-Based Management: Natural Processes
andecosystem
Systems Theory
An
approach for sustainability: addressing
the challenge
complexityIntegrating Science and
Compass
and of
Gyroscope:
Politics
for Monitoring
the Environment
Improving
and Assessment for
Environmental
Decision-Making
The ABC Resource
Survey Method, the ESA Concept
and
Comprehensive
Use Planning
and
A
New
Paradigm for Land
Environmental
Management
Management
Holistic resource management: a conceptual
framework
ecolotgically
sound
economic
Integrating for
Park
and Regional
Planning
Through an
modelling
Ecosystem
Approach
Lessons from experience with ecosystem-based
management
Adaptive
Management of Renewable Resources
Large-Scale Management Experiments and Learning
By
Doing
Chaos,
complexity and community management of
fisheries
Ecological Integrity and the Management of
Ecosystems
The
case for a 'catholic' ecology
planning reading – beth dempster, uwaterloo – June 17, 2001 - 2
Systems Related
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
1
c
c
1
c
c
m
<
<
<
-
<
-
Checkland, P. B. and J. 1990
Scholes
Checkland,
Peter
1986
Flood
1999
Flood, R. L. and N. R.
1996
A. Romm,G.
eds.
Gallopin,
1994
Jackson, M. C.
1999
Jackson, M. C.
1993
Lister, Nina-Marie E.
1998
Midgeley, G.
1996
Naughton, John
1?87
Ravetz, J. R.
1999
Rosenhead, Jonathan, 1989
ed.
Senge,
P. M.
1990
Ulrich, Werner
1994
Soft Systems Methodology in Action
Systems Thinking, Systems Practice
Rethinking the 5th Discipline
Critical Systems Thinking: Current Research and
Practice
Impoverishment
and Sustainable Development: A
Systemscoherent
Approach
Toward
pluralism in management science
Signposts to Critical Systems Thinking and Practice
A systems approach to biodiversity conservation
planning
The
Ideal of Unity and the Practice of Pluralism in
Systems
Science
Soft
Systems
Analysis: An Introductory Guide
What is Post-Normal Science
Rational Analysis For a Problematic World
The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the
Learning
??
FutureOrganization
Responsive Management through System
Thinking and Design?
John Wiley,
Chichester
John
Wiley,
Chichester
2000
1992
1994
1992
1991
1985
1994
1994
1983
1992
The Practice and Ethics of Design
Situating the Self
The origins and practice of participatory rural
appraisal
Our
Responsibility to the Seventh Generation:
Indigenous
Peoples and
Sustainable
Toward an Ecological
Ethic
of Care Development
Six Thinking Hats
Dis-stance and Other Stances: Negotiatios of Power
Inside Feminist
Research
Power
and Method:
Political Activism and Educational
Research
Quantum Soup
Decisions Without Hierarchy: Feminist Intervetions in
Organization
Theory and Practice
Tools
for Conviviality
Systems
Research
Routledge,and
Behavioural
London
World
Science
Development
International
Institute
Hypatia for
sustainable
Penguin Books,
Development
London
in Power and
Method, A. Gitlin,
Routledge
ed.
E.P. Dutton, New
1993
1990
1997
1995
1996
1994
1999
Traditional Ecological Knowledge: Concepts and
Cases
Reinscribing Otherwise: The Play of Values in the
Practices
the Human (2nd
Sciences
Images ofof
Organization
ed.)
Metaphors we might survive by
Community Research as Empowerment: Feminist
Links,
Postmodern
Interruptions
Narrative
Policy Analysis:
Theory and Practice
Improvisation for the Theater, 3rd ed.
Metapatterns
International
Development
in The Paradigm
Research
Centre
Dialog,
e. Guba,
Sage, Thousand
ed.
Oaks CA
Ecological
Economics
Oxford University
Press
Duke University
Press
Northwestern
University Press,
Evanston Illinois
james
Plenum Press
International
Institute of
frothe
Journal
Sustainable
Operational
Kybernetes
Development
Research
Society Dan's
Environmental
Monitoring
thesis
in
Critical and
Assessemnt
Systems
Open Univeristy
Thinking,
Press
Futures Flood
and Romm, eds.
John Wiley and
Sons, Chichester
Doubleday
Interfaces
Potporri
m
m
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
1
c
c
1
c
c
c
<
<
<
<
<
<
Bausch, Kenneth C.
Benhabib, Seyla
Chambers, R.
Clarkson, L., V.
Morrissette
Curtin, D. and G.
Regallet
de Bono, Edward
Fine, M.
Gitlin, Andrew, ed.
Huang, Chungliang Al
Iannello, K. P.
Illich, Ivan
Inglis, J. T. ed.
Lather, P. A.
Morgan, Gareth
Norgaard, Richard B.
Ristock, J. L. and J.
Pennell
Roe, Emery
Spolin, Viola
Volk
ejournal
Foreste
s,
uw
r 1999
shelf
York
Routledge
Methodology reading from other areas of interest
plan-thri
plan-dem
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-thri
plan-oth
plan-thri
plan-oth
plan-oth
plan-thri
1
c
c
c
c
1
c
1
1
1
1
1
c
1
m
<
-
-
Arnstein, S. R.
Bohman, J. and W.
Rehg,
eds.
Fischler,
Raphael
Forester, John
Forester, John
Healey, Patsy
Holling, C. S. and M. A.
Goldberg
Innes,
J. E.
Innes, Judith E.
Innes, Judith E.
Jones, Alice
Mandelbaum, Seymour
J.
Meppem,
T. and R. Gill
Michael, D.
Ulrich, Werner
1969
1997
1995
1980
1989
1997
1971
1996
1989
1995
1996
2000
1998
1993
1983
A Ladder of Citizen Participation
Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and
Politics
Planning Theory as Culture and Experience
(Teaching
Planning
Theory Symposium
Critical
Theory
and Planning
Practice )
American Institute
of
Planners
MIT
Press,
Journal
Cambridge,
Journal of Mass
Planning
JAPA
Education
and
Planning in the Face of Power
University of
Research
California
Press
Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in
Vancouver: UBC
Fragmented
Press
Ecology and Societies
Planning
Journal of
American Institute
Planning Through Consensus Building: A New View American
of
Planners
of the Comprehensive
PlanningPlanning
Ideal
Planning
Information
in Communicative
Journal
of the
Associaiton
American
Planning Theory's Emerging Paradigm:
Journal of
Journal
Communicative
and Interactive
Planning
The Psychology Action
of Sustainability:
WhatPractice
Planners Can Planning
Journal of
Association
(Teaching
Theory Symposium )
Education
Learn
fromPlanning
Attitude
Research
Planning
Open
Moral
Communities
MIT
Press and
Research and
Education
Planning for sustainability as a learning concept
Ecological
Research
Economics
Governing by learning: boundaries, myths and
Futures
metaphors
Critical Heuristics of Social Planning: A New
Verlag Paul
Approach to Practical Philosophy
Haupt, Bern
planning reading – beth dempster, uwaterloo – June 17, 2001 - 3