A brief history of migration to Chapeltown

advertisement

Table of Contents, Foreword by Stuart Hall and Preface to

The Struggle for “Community” in a

British Multi-Ethnic Inner City Area –

Paradise in the Making

Llampeter and New York: The Edwin Mellen (Publication date November

2002)

CONTENTS

List of maps and tables

Foreword

Preface

Chapter 1

Chapter 2

Introduction: the aims of this study

Chapeltown: maps and demographics

Introduction: maps and impressions

Buildings and open space: a brief history

Leeds: ethnic population statistics

Chapeltown: population statistics

Occupation and lifestyle

Ethnic segmentation and ‘community’ institutions in Chapeltown

Caribbean groups

South Asians

White populations

Conclusion

Chapter 3

‘We did not come alive in Britain’:

A brief history of migration to Chapeltown

Introduction

The migration from the Caribbean

The migrations from South Asia and East Africa xi

xiii xv

1

9

47

iv

Indian (Sikh) settlement

Pakistani (Muslim) settlement

Bangladeshi (Muslim) settlement

Conclusion

Chapter 4

The concept of community

Three dimensions of ‘actual community’

1) Territory and its (non) representation

2) Theorising the social: conceptualising social relationships

Marx: alienation and the social

Weber: types of social relationship

Modern sociology: relationships in ‘mass society’

3) The politics of ‘community’: values and goals

Community as a social imaginary

Beyond ‘community studies’: a typology of subjective orientations

Chapter 5

Chapeltown: territory and the social construction of space

Introduction

Maps and the sociology of space

79

127

The discursive construction of space and territory in Chapeltown

Early modern settlers

Jewish settlers: discourses of the (white) Other

Black settlers: the sexualised and racialised discourse of hell

The economic construction of Chapeltown’s social space

Conclusion

Chapter 6

Constructing ‘community’: forming social movements, 1972-75

The urban social movement thesis

161

Caribbean-led mobilisations in the early 1970s

The Chapeltown Parents Action Group: ‘community’ as racialised reform

The West Indian Afro Brotherhood: ‘community’ as racialised reform

Indian-led action in the early 197 0s. The Sikhs: ‘community’ as religious reform

White and multi-cultural politics in Chapeltown in the 1970s

The Chapeltown Community Association 1971 - 3: ‘community’ as reform (interethnic)

The CCA 1973 - 5: ‘community’ as anti-racist socialism

The CCA: an urban social movement?

Ethnic identities

Conclusion: the complexities of ‘community’ action

Chapter 7

Violence and the competing politics of ‘community’, 1975-81

Introduction

Reggae and Rastafarianism: violence and redemption

The proto-politics of Bonfire Night 1975

207

v

The 1981 rebellion: social movements and the politics of violence

Conclusion

Chapter 8

Segmenting ‘community’: the decline of the social movements, 1981-97

241

Introduction

The 1980s: processes of individualisation and ethnic segmentation

The Harehills and Chapeltown Liaison Committee

Professionalisation and individualisation

Arguing for ethnic unity

Ethnic segmentation

‘Community’ building(s)

‘The Rushdie Affair’: consolidating Muslim ‘difference’

Partial social movements, 1986 - 1994: ‘community’ deconstructed

Changes in identification: ‘community’ politics, careers and ethnicities

Conclusion

Chapter 9

Crime, social relations and the deconstruction of ‘community’

Introduction

Crime and its impact on ‘community’ in Chapeltown

Racialising street crime

Young people, unemployment and education

Attempting to mobilise ‘the community’ against hard drugs

Crime, everyday life and the breakdown of trust

Trust and social control: some personal accounts

Migration and ontological security: more personal accounts

Conclusion

297

343 Chapter 10

Conclusion: constructing and de-constructing

‘community’ in Chapeltown

Appendix

Epistemology and methodology

Epistemology and methodology

Participant observation in Chapeltown

Six problems with participant observation

Documentary sources

Conclusion

Primary sources and bibliography

Index

359

381

399

vi

vii

LIST OF MAPS AND TABLES

Map 2.1

Map 2.2

General map situating Chapeltown

Chapeltown around 1840

Map 2.3

Map 2.4

Chapeltown around 1890

Chapeltown around 1950

Table 2.1 Ethnic minority settlement in Leeds, 1951-1991

Map 2.5 Enumeration district map (Chapeltown)

Table 2.2 Ethnic minorities: figures for the author’s map

10

12

13

15

19

22 of Chapeltown, 1991

Table 2.3 Male unemployment rates in 1991 for author’s map

23 of Chapeltown

Table 2.4

Occupational structure of Chapeltown (author’s map)

25 and Leeds, 1991 26

Table 2.5 Lifestyles: Chapeltown (author’s map) and Leeds, 199128

Map 2.6 The Caribbean 32

Map 2.7

Map 2.8

The Indian sub-continent

The Punjab

Table 4.1 A typology of subjective orientations

Map 5.1 Chapeltown: the Ordinance Survey map compared to the ‘local knowledge’ map

34

36

119

131

Map 5.2 Circa 1580 map of Chapel Allerton and the territory now known as Chapeltown 137

Map 5.3 Pattern of land ownership in and around Chapeltown in the mid-nineteenth century 140

Table 8.1 Provision of built facilities in Chapeltown, 1972 – 1997 263

Table 9.1 Numbers of selected crimes recorded by the West Yorkshire

Police Force, Chapeltown South policing area, 1986-96

302

Figure 9.1 Graph of selected crimes recorded by the West Yorkshire

Police Force, Chapeltown South policing area, 1986-1996

303

Table 9.2 Unemployment and educational participation among

313 16-19 year olds in Chapeltown and Leeds

Table 9.3 Unemployment and educational participation among

20-24 year olds in Chapeltown and Leeds 313

viii

FOREWORD

Stuart Hall

Despite the voluminous literature on post-war migration to Britain, there are few, serious, in-depth studies of how the politics of race plays out at local level in particular communities. This book is such a study, based on

Chapeltown, a multi-ethnic inner-city area of Leeds. Using the muchinvoked, but slippery and contested concept of ‘community’–one of the principal code-words of race politics in Britain –Max Farrar undertakes a meticulous and critical analysis which unpacks the complexities of racial and ethnic politics in Chapeltown from the 1970s to the present. He sets the social and demographic scene and outlines the pattern of migration and the way urban space was constructed and transformed by the changing composition of the population. He then traces the birth of antiracist politics and the formation of social movements across the different communities; the social unrest and proto-rebellions of the early 1980s; the growing ethn ic segmentation and the strengthening of ‘difference’ of the 1990s; and the fragmentation of community through the criminalisation of disadvantage which characterises Chapeltown today.

This is a trajectory which, with variations, can be traced in many other places over the same period. The period of high activism is not idealised: there is a vivid sense of what he calls ‘the competing and violent politics of community’ in the 1970s and 1980s. However, the consequences of fragmentation along ethnic lines for the utopian dream of an imagined community grounded in a radical, anti-racist politics –the ‘paradise’ signalled in the book –is soberly, even stoically, confronted.

Max Farrar brings to this task a life-long engagement with inner-city politics in Chapeltown, a well-substantiated and detailed grasp of the history and changing shape and fortunes of the area. The account is framed by a developed sociological perspective, which critically review the existing literature on ‘community’, adding a significant dimension of its own –the idea of ‘community’ itself as a social, even as a utopian, imaginary. The ethnographic account of community politics in action not only stands in its own rich detail, but also gives substance to the wider, macro-political trends to which Chapeltown narrative is constantly related.

It is out of the analytic narratives like this that the history of the post-war black and Asian diasporas in Britain will ultimately be written. Above all,

ix the book speaks eloquently to a passionate commitment to the cause of racial justice and social equality, which enriches rather than diminishes its scholarly value, and to courage and hope tenaciously sustained in the face of the remorselessness of historical change.

Stuart Hall

Emeritus Professor of Sociology

The Open University

U.K.

x

PREFACE

This book represents a labour of love and this Preface is a thank-you to all those who have made it possible. It started in 1970 when I moved to

Spencer Place, in Chapeltown, while a third-year student at Leeds

University. Alan Dawe, Bob Towler and Dennis Warwick made sociology seem worthwhile, and almost commensurate with my revolutionary aspirations. John Rex’s work, and his kind words, inspired me to engage in a study of a multi-ethnic inner city. Bob got me a SSRC grant (1972-4) during which I started research

 and he smiled indulgently when I gave it up, having concluded that sociology was a bourgeois deviation. I had realised, as well, that I could learn little that was worth saying about

Chapeltown within the period of a research grant.

As this book shows, a notion like ‘the people of Chapeltown’ is too woolly for sociology

 but the Preface claims the privileges of everyday life.

It is ‘the people of Chapeltown’ who have to be thanked most of all: without the affection and help from innumerable people this book would never have materialised. Many of those who have criticised me have contributed to my self-knowledge and sociological understanding, and I thank them, too. People who were kind enough to allow me to record interviews are named in the list of primary sources. Some of them, and many others to whom I am indebted, are referred to in the text.

Pseudonyms have been used where the material is personally sensitive. I hope that this book

 despite its jargon and its fairly neutral tone of voice

 betrays my personal, political support for the extraordinary struggles of ordinary people to realise their dream of a better life for all, to attain an earthly paradise. I also hope that it is used by those who wish to develop and extend those struggles in Chapeltown, and elsewhere. That, for me, would justify this enterprise.

Some time in the early 1990s I became a born-again sociologist.

Zygmunt Bauman’s books made the job seem worthwhile again. His work, and that of Paul Gilroy and Stuart Hall confirmed the possibility of a politically relevant sociology. Leeds Polytechnic employed me in

Community Education. Sharing an office with Cal Clothier showed me that there was a zest for life, love, shopping and writing inside the concrete towers, so I began to feel at home. I miss him dearly. We turned into a University and a School of Cultural Studies. A Ph.D. became necessary and, as Chapeltown’s social movements seemed to be disintegrating, I wanted to find a way of summarising my own observation and commitment. For its financial support in fees and grants I offer

xi sincere thanks to the Leeds Metropolitan University Faculty of Cultural and Education Studies. Considering the under-resourcing of the modern universities, its staff development programme has been extremely generous. So this book started life as a Ph.D. thesis. Simon Gunn and

Gordon Johnston were stimulating and supportive as supervisors;

Simon’s detailed notes have made a valued contribution. Without

Zygmun t Bauman’s enthusiastic responses to various articles and chapters I would never have had the confidence to continue. None, of course, can be blamed for the outcome. The penetrating questions and discussion raised at the viva for the Ph.D. by Paul Bagguley, Stuart Hall and Graham Haughton were much appreciated.

My friends Ruth Bundey, Graham Frost, Miranda Miller and Jane Storr did me a huge service by proof-reading early versions of this tome. Joan

Dearnley did the final proofing, and produced the detailed index. Phillipa

Boyce in Leeds Metropolitan University’s Learning Technology Services produced the maps, and Lee Walsh designed the cover. Rachel Evans helped me with the complexities of book-style headers and the admin staff in the School of Cultural Studies helped me keep calm as I grappled with the mysteries of camera-ready page lay-out. Further detailed advice on page lay-out came from Iona Williams at the Edwin Mellen Press. I am very grateful to them all.

My parents, Betty and Don, my brother and sister, Guy and Lucy, and my out-of-laws, Mary, Robert and Athaliah have been more help than they realise. Our children, Rose and John, have watched over this work from the womb, and it provided them with endless ripostes whenever I complained that they hadn’t finished their essays on time. My partner

Jane has been there since before the beginning. Her love and unflagging support at every painstaking stage of its development is the main reason why I have finally been able to draw this work to a (temporary) close.

Leeds

November 2001

Download