Case study : Price pack architecture solution for a leading global CPG company Background Client witnessed an exceptional growth in the first year (March 11). 2012 saw a slowdown with the actual growth of 85% vs. target of 120%. The slowdown was primarily attributed to – Price increase through absolute price increase or pack downsizing – Cannibalization by the launch of more expensive in one of the variant variant Client was thus planning to develop a new pricing strategy to manage consumer value as well as profitability Objective Absolutdata recommended based pack price architecture solution with following objectives to address the business problem Price Change Impact: – Price sensitivity analysis – Optimal price points for biscuit packs – Estimate gain/loss to biscuit portfolio due to price change Pack downsizing impact: – Pack size sensitivity analysis – Impact of de-grammage on volume, value and transactions New pack introduction impact – Estimate the gain/loss to portfolio with new pack introduction – Optimal new pack dynamics (price, pack size, flavor) for introduction Portfolio Optimization – Build an optimal portfolio Impact Devised a new portfolio for client by introducing new packs and modifying the existing ones (in terms of number of cookies and price) The new portfolio helped to gain market share as well as increase consumption of existing biscuit consumers Optimal pricing and offering price incentive in larger packs helped boost volume sales © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 1 Case study : Absolutdata’s price pack architecture solution Price Pack Architecture is a powerful solution which enables you to create a market advantage through redesigning your product portfolio to fit with market needs Business Objective Business Solution Price Pack Architecture Technique Conjoint (choice based conjoint) + Calibration through Market Mix Modeling Built a pricing based strategy to increase revenues and profitability of biscuit portfolio 1. Increase price of the SKUs 2. Reduce the pack size for the SKUs with price constant 3. Introduce a new SKU in the portfolio 1. New SKU Introduction Analysis – Measures the impact of new SKU at various price points on portfolio 2. Price/Grammage sensitivity Analysis –Assess any leverage points in terms of price and grammage vis-à-vis competition brands 3. Competitive Strategy Impact Analysis – Assess the impact of changes made my competition on the portfolio 4. What-if Analysis – Conduct ‘what-if’ analysis leading to the optimal portfolio such as the impact of price change vs. pack size and new SKU introduction © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 2 Case study : Conjoint design - Translating design into a shelf display Out of the 10 packs that you plan to purchase in the next grocery shopping trips, please distribute them amongst the following cream biscuits or cookies product options. You can buy more or less than 10 packs if you feel that is what you would want to do in a given scenario, if the prices and products available seem attractive to you. Brand 1 Brand 2 Brand 2 Brand 3 Brand 4 Brand 5 Brand 6 Brand 7 Brand 8 Brand 9 Brand 10 Brand 11 Brand 12 Brand 13 Brand 14 Respondents were able to fill in the number of cookie packs they will buy for each brand © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential Hovering on a certain product enlarges the image and product details (price, pack size etc) None: Would reserve these purchases for another time or at other store 3 Case study : Sample key findings - Hierarchy of decision making by the consumers The hierarchy of decision making for the cream biscuits and cookie category shows that price is not the most powerful lever to influence the consumers’ purchase decision Order of attributes that buyers look at while purchasing a cream/cookie biscuits Brand & Flavor Pack Size Price © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 4 Case study : Absolutdata resolution - Calibration of conjoint results using MMM Calibration of results was done using actual MMM data. MMM data along with other control variables was used to build a model and its price elasticity value was used as a reference point Conjoint analysis, which gave us the flexibility to estimate demand at prices which are currently not offered in the market were then calibrated Calibration was done using common price points and getting a calibration factor Calibrated model Elasticity derived from conjoint data Pc1 Pc2 Demand Pc3 Ps1 Ps2 Ps3 Demand Elasticity derived from true sales data Price Price © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 5 Case study: Sample key findings - Price impact on individual SKU and biscuit portfolio Base price Base price Vanilla 6 cookie SKU has high price sensitivity as well as the highest price elasticity in the portfolio For Vanilla 6 cookie SKU, a decrease in price leads to gain in transactions and volume share in the portfolio but does not lead to any gain in revenue share An SKU level analysis was done in terms of looking at the impact of price increase decrease on SKU volumes and revenue. A portfolio level analysis was done in terms of looking at the impact on revenue, transaction and volumes of portfolio due to price change of an SKU Similarly, grammage elasticity were also analyzed to understand their impact on volume, packs and value. This enabled us to decide the product attributes that could be altered to get increased volumes/revenue © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 6 Case study: What changes needs to done to portfolio? Current Portfolio 2 cookies New Scenario Rs 5 6 cookies Rs 12 12 cookies Rs 25 6 cookies Rs 15 4 cookies Rs 10 A workshop was conducted with the client team to try out different scenarios and to measure its impact on portfolio. 12 cookies Rs 30 The portfolio mix with an addition of small pack (4 cookie) in Choco Crème leads to an overall 6% and 4% growth in volume and revenue respectively of the biscuit portfolio These scenarios were created using the excel based simulator and a recommendation was made based on feasibility of the portfolio existence and its impact on the portfolio © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 7 Case study: Using simulator for price sensitivity measurement analysis Price Sensitivity Price elasticity curve for Brand 60% Demand 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Base - 5 Base - 2 Base Price Base + 2 Banse + 5 Demand curves helped measure the price sensitivity of different packages In this case, we could calculate the impact of per unit increase/decrease in the package cost on the preference shares This helped client understand the optimum pricing curve/accepted price range © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 8 Case study: Impact Current Portfolio v 2 cookies a n 6 cookies i l l 12 cookies a 6 cookies Recommended Portfolio 2 cookies 5 25 0.15 10 10 cookies 0.1 20 15 cookies 27 15 6 cookies 12 cookies Growth due to increased consumption Growth drawn from competition 5 5 cookies 12 30 Growth over Current Portfolio 0.05 15 0 15 cookies 30 SKUs in the current portfolio 11% 3% 2% 3% 2% Packs Volume Revenue SKUs different from the current portfolio The recommended scenario shows a 14% volume growth and 5% revenue growth over the current portfolio Relatively low cannibalization as a significant proportion of volume growth is driven by increased consumption “client is doing quite well & did see a significant spike post new pricing, so you guys were quite right !” – AVP Marketing © Absolutdata 2014 Proprietary and Confidential 9