VCE CHEMISTRY Summary of proposed changes to the study design

advertisement

VCE CHEMISTRY

Summary of proposed changes to the study design

This table provides detailed information about proposed changes to the VCE Chemistry study design.

Section Current study design Proposal for revised study design

Scope of study A single Rationale covers both proposed Scope of study and Rationale

Rationale

Aims

Explains aspects of the broad discipline of chemistry that is included in VCE Chemistry

Explains the importance of studying VCE

Chemistry, including post-secondary pathways

Includes a set of eleven VCE

Chemistry aims

Proposes a set of two VCE Chemistry-specific aims and a set of eleven generic aims which apply to all VCE sciences (Biology, Chemistry,

Environmental Science, Physics and Psychology)

Key science skills

A set of key skills is described under three general headings

A set of key science skills is described under seven general headings which apply to all VCE sciences, with contextualised elaborations specific to VCE Chemistry

Unit questions Unit titles

Unit 1: The big ideas of

Chemistry

Unit 2: Environmental chemistry

Unit 3: Chemical pathways

Unit 4: Chemistry at work

Unit questions designed to link concepts and ideas across the unit and to reflect the inquiry nature of science

Unit 1: What makes materials different?

Unit 2: Why is water precious?

Unit 3: How can energy and materials be produced efficiently?

Unit 4: Why is carbon useful?

Area of study questions

Area of study has short phrases as titles

Area of study has questions as titles which are designed to enable exploration of the concepts and ideas related to the topics within the area of study

Key knowledge sub-headings

Key knowledge listed as a set of dot points

Key knowledge dot points listed under sets of sub-headings

©VCAA, August 2014

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Section Current study design Proposal for revised study design

Unit 1

Area of Study 1

Current content from Unit 1

Area of Study 1 (The Periodic

Table) includes:

the Periodic Table

atomic theory

mole concept

mass spectrometry

Why do elements matter?

Topics:

origin, distribution and structure of the elements

Periodic Table and properties of elements

metals

materials containing metal compounds

quantifying atoms and compounds

Content is similar to current Unit 1 Area of

Study 1 except that:

new content includes nuclear genesis, abundance of elements in the Universe and on Earth, metallic nanomaterials and glass

historical development of the Periodic Table is deleted

historical development of models of atomic structure is deleted

Content from current Unit 1 Area of Study 2 includes metallic and ionic bonding

Unit 1

Area of Study 2

Current Unit 1 Area of

Study 2 (Materials) includes:

models of bonding

alkanes and alkenes up to C6

structural isomers of butane

surface chemistry

addition polymers

Why are non-metals so versatile?

Topics:

materials made of molecules

carbon lattices and carbon nanomaterials

organic compounds

customised polymers

Content is similar to current Unit 1 Area of

Study 2 except that:

alkanes and alkenes up to C10 are included

new content includes graphenes, fullerenes, polymer additives, composite materials, fractional distillation of crude oil

surface chemistry is deleted from this area of study

Unit 1

Area of Study 3

Not included Research investigation into a useful material and its life cycle

new area of study with a skills focus

investigation question relates to content in

Unit 1 Areas of Study 1 and/or 2

includes new content of green chemistry principles as applied to production of new materials

©VCAA, August 2014 2

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Section Current study design Proposal for revised study design

Unit 2

Area of Study 1

Current content in Unit 2

Area of Study 1 (Water) includes:

role of water in maintaining life in the environment

acids and bases

stoichiometry

redox reactions in solution

green chemistry principles related to water processes

What makes water unique?

Topics:

 density

 specific heat capacity and latent heat of vaporization

 solvent properties

 measurement of solubility and concentration

 acid-base reactions in water

 redox reactions in water

 environmental issues

Content is similar to current Unit 2 Area of Study

1 except that:

new content includes specific heat capacity, solubility curves and ocean solubility of oxygen and carbon dioxide

green chemistry principles related to solution chemistry is deleted

Unit 2

Area of Study 2

Current content in Unit 2

Area of Study 1 (The atmosphere) includes:

role of the atmosphere in maintaining life in the environment

greenhouse effect gases and protocols

kinetic molecular theory of gases

calculations involving gas laws

What is in water?

Topics:

 water sample analysis

 analysis for salts

 analysis for organic compounds

 analysis for acids and bases

 water treatment

Content relates to aspects of current Unit 2 Area of Study 1 in terms of stoichiometry, acid-base reactions and the role of water in maintaining life in the environment

Relevant content from current Unit 4 Area of

Study 1 includes pH as a measure of the strength of acids and bases

New content includes chromatography, instrumental analysis, analysis of contaminants, acid-base titrations, standards in water treatment

Unit 2

Area of Study 3

Not included Practical investigation into an aspect of water quality

new area of study with a laboratory skills focus

investigation question relates to content in

Unit 2 Areas of Study 1 and/or 2

©VCAA, August 2014 3

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Section Current study design Proposal for revised study design

Unit 3

Area of Study 1

Current content in Unit 3

Area of Study 1 (Chemical analysis) includes:

volumetric analysis

gravimetric analysis

calculations involving solids, liquids and gases

balanced chemical equations for redox reactions

chromatography

spectroscopy

matching analytical technique/s to a particular task

What are our energy options?

Topics:

energy from fuels

fuel choices

storage of energy in galvanic cells

energy possibilities

Content is similar to current Unit 4 Area of

Study 2 except that:

calorimetry is included in Unit 4 Area of

Study 2, although specific heat capacity is used to determine energy released in combustion reactions

 electrolytic cells and Faraday’s laws are included in Unit 3 Area of Study 2

fossil fuels and bio-fuels have been specified

new content includes energy efficiency and environmental impacts of fuel choices, stoichiometry (mass-mass, mass-volume and volume-volume)

Relevant content from current Unit 3 Area of

Study 2 with reference to bio-fuel production is included

Unit 3

Area of Study 2

Current content in Unit 3

Area of Study 2 (Organic chemical pathways) includes:

organic nomenclature and structural formula of alkanes, alkenes, amines, haloalkanes, alkanols and esters up to C10

reactions and equations for organic reactions

chemical bonding

organic reaction pathways

How can the production of chemicals be optimised?

Topics:

rate of chemical reactions

extent of chemical reactions

chemical production by electrolysis

rechargeable batteries

Content includes a large part of the current Unit 4

Area of Study 2 except that:

pH as a measure of acid-base strength has been included in the proposed Unit 2 Area of

Study 1

industrial production of a specific chemical has been deleted

electrolytic cells, rechargeable batteries and

Faraday’s laws (from current Unit 4 Area of

Study 1) are included in this area of study

new content includes competing equilibria associated with carbon monoxide poisoning, selection of pyrolysis or electrolysis in metal extraction

©VCAA, August 2014 4

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Section Current study design

Unit 4

Area of Study 1

Current content in Unit 4

Area of Study 1 (Industrial chemistry) includes:

collision theory and rates of reaction

energy profile diagrams and ΔH notation

equilibrium

pH as a measure of strength of acids and bases

industrial production of a chemical

Unit 4

Area of Study 2

Current content in Unit 4

Area of Study 2 (Supplying and using energy) includes:

renewability of energy resources

calorimetry

electrochemical series predictions

primary and secondary galvanic cells

fuel cells

electrolytic cells

 Faraday’s laws

Proposal for revised study design

Why is carbon useful?

Topics:

organic compounds

properties and reactions of simple organic families

analysis of organic chemicals

Content is similar to current content in Unit 3 Area of Study 2 except that:

added nomenclature and structures for alkynes, amides, aldehydes, ketones

chemical bonding moved to Unit 4 Area of

Study 2 in the context of food chemistry

organic reaction pathways

new content includes comparison of silicon and carbon in terms of ability to form a range of compounds, catalytic cracking and catalytic reforming, distinction between structures of benzene and cyclohexane

Content includes parts of the current Unit 3 Area of Study 1:

spectroscopy: mass; IR, NMR

volumetric analysis (redox)

chromatography

titrations, including back titration

What is food?

Topics:

roles of food

metabolism of food in the human body

carbohydrates

proteins

lipids

Food chemistry is a new topic in the proposed study design. It draws on content related to organic chemistry (from Unit 3 Area of Study 2) and calorimetry (from Unit 4 Area of Study 2) as a field of applied chemistry.

©VCAA, August 2014 5

VCE CHEMISTRY

Section Current study design

Unit 4

Area of Study 3

Not included

Units 3 and/or 4 scientific poster template

Practical logbook

Units 3 and 4

Schoolassessed

Coursework

Not included

Practical logbook not mandated

School-assessed

Coursework is evenly weighted across four outcomes

SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Proposal for revised study design

Experimental investigation related to energy and/or food production

new area of study with a laboratory skills focus

investigation question relates to content in

Units 3 and/or 4

results presented as a scientific poster

may be undertaken in either Unit 3, Unit 4 or across both Units 3 and 4

Scientific poster template provided which includes identified sections and suggested marking scheme

Students are required to maintain a practical logbook for record, authentication and assessment purposes

Proposed School-assessed Coursework is equally weighted across 5 outcomes

©VCAA, August 2014 6

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

ASSESSMENT

Units 1 and 2

Assessment tasks in the current and proposed study designs are similar although some have been updated to reflect current assessment practice and the nature of the discipline.

Current Unit 1 assessment tasks Proposed Unit 1 assessment tasks

Assessment tasks for this unit are:

• An extended experimental investigation. This could be student designed and/or planned or teacher directed and would require between three and five hours of laboratory/ practical work. Results could be presented in a variety of formats. Students should complete a Risk

Assessment and Risk Management as part of this task. Students could work in small groups or individually.

Or

• A summary report including annotations of three practical activities. This task would require between three and five hours of laboratory time. The annotations would illustrate the links between the practical activities (for example, data, techniques, concepts, problems faced and recommendations for future practical activities). Teachers may provide students with prompts to assist them with the annotations.

If the extended experimental investigation is completed in Unit 1, the summary report including annotations of three practical activities must be completed in Unit 2. If the summary report including annotations of three practical activities is completed in Unit 1, the extended experimental investigation must be completed in

Unit 2.

And

At least one of the following:

• a response to stimulus material in written, oral, visual, or multimedia format

• an analysis of first and/or second-hand data using structured questions

• a written, oral, visual or multimedia presentation of a new material/s, or new use/s of an existing material.

Assessment tasks for this unit are:

For Outcomes 1 and 2:

A selection from the following:

annotations of a practical work folio of activities or investigations

report of a practical activity or investigation

modelling activity

media response

problem solving involving chemical concepts, skills and/or issues

reflective learning journal/blog related to selected activities or in response to an issue

data analysis

test comprising multiple choice and/or short answer and/or extended response.

The assessment tasks may be written, oral or multi-modal.

And

For Outcome 3:

report of an investigation of a new product or material using an appropriate format, for example, digital presentation, oral communication, or written report.

©VCAA, August 2014 7

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Current Unit 2 assessment tasks Proposed Unit 2 assessment tasks

Assessment tasks for this unit are:

An extended experimental investigation. This could be student designed and/or planned or teacher directed and would require between three and five hours of laboratory/ practical work. Results could be presented in a variety of formats. Students should complete a Risk

Assessment and Risk Management as part of this task. Students could work in pairs, small groups or individually.

Or

A summary report including annotations of three practical activities. This task would require between three and five hours of laboratory time. The annotations would illustrate the links between the practical activities (for example, data, techniques, concepts, problems faced and recommendations for future practical activities). Teachers may decide to provide students with prompts to assist them with the annotations.

Assessment tasks for this unit are:

For Outcomes 1 and 2:

A selection from the following:

annotations of a practical work folio of activities or investigations

report of a practical activity or investigation

modelling activity

media response

problem solving involving chemical concepts, skills and/or issues

reflective learning journal/blog related to selected activities or in response to an issue

data analysis

test comprising multiple choice and/or short answer and/or extended response.

The assessment tasks may be written, oral or multi-modal.

And

If the extended experimental investigation is completed in Unit 1, the summary report including annotations of three practical activities must be completed in Unit 2. If the summary report including annotations of three practical activities is completed in Unit 1, the extended experimental investigation must be completed in

Unit 2.

For Outcome 3:

a report of a student-designed quantitative laboratory investigation using an appropriate format, for example, digital presentation, oral communication, scientific poster or written report.

And

At least one of the following:

a response to stimulus material in written, oral, visual, or multimedia format

an analysis of first and/or second-hand data using structured questions

a written, oral, annotated, visual or multimedia presentation related to green chemistry.

©VCAA, August 2014 8

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Proposed Unit 3 Assessment

The nature of assessment tasks in the current and proposed study designs is similar. Some assessment tasks have been updated to reflect current assessment practice and the nature of the discipline. An indication of time for the task is intended to provide greater comparability in the scope of the tasks across classes and schools, and to reduce School-assessed Coursework load for teachers and students.

Outcomes

Outcome 1

Compare fuels quantitatively with specific reference to energy and greenhouse gas production, apply knowledge of the electrochemical series to design, construct and test a galvanic cell, and evaluate energy resources based on energy efficiency, renewability and environmental impact.

Marks allocated*

30

Assessment tasks

Analysis and evaluation of two or more media articles related to energy options

OR

Report on a laboratory investigation of the design, construction and testing of a galvanic cell that meets a specified set of criteria

(approximately 50 minutes)

©VCAA, August 2014 9

VCE CHEMISTRY SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES

Proposed Unit 4 Assessment

Assessment tasks in the current and proposed study designs are similar for Outcomes 1 and 2 although some have been updated to reflect current assessment practice and the nature of the discipline. An indication of time for the task is intended to provide greater comparability in the scope of the task across classes and schools, and to reduce School-assessed Coursework load for teachers and students.

The proposed Outcome 3 task may be undertaken in Unit 3, Unit 4, or across Unit 3 and Unit 4, but will be reported as part of Unit 4 School-assessed Coursework. A template has been constructed for production of the associated scientific poster task to assist in staged completion and authentication of student work.

Outcomes

Outcome 1

Compare general structures and reactions of major organic families, deduce structures of organic compounds using instrumental analysis data, and design reaction pathways for the synthesis of organic molecules.

Marks allocated*

30

Assessment tasks

At least one task selected from:

• annotations of at least two practical activities from a practical logbook

• report of a student investigation

• analysis of data including generalisations and conclusions

• media analysis/response

• extended response questions

• reflective learning journal/blog related to comparison of organic structures or pathways.

(approximately 50 minutes)

30

Outcome 2

Compare general structures and reactions of major organic families, deduce structures of organic compounds using instrumental analysis data, and design reaction pathways for the synthesis of organic molecules.

Response to an issue related to food and diet

OR

Report of a laboratory investigation involving calorimetry.

(approximately 50 minutes)

Outcome 3

Design and undertake a practical investigation related to energy and/or food resources, and present methodologies, findings and conclusions as a scientific poster.

30 Structured scientific poster according to

VCAA template.

Total marks 90

*School-assessed Coursework for Unit 4 contributes 24 per cent.

©VCAA, August 2014 10

Download