PART 1 – PUBLIC DOCUMENT AGENDA ITEM NO. 19 TITLE OF REPORT: HEALTH AND SAFETY ENFORCEMENT PLAN REPORT OF THE HEAD OF HOUSING AND PUBLIC PROTECTION PORTFOLIO HOLDER: COUNCILLOR BERNARD LOVEWELL 1. SUMMARY 1.1 This report seeks agreement to an update of the Council’s Health and Safety Enforcement Plan. The original Enforcement Plan was endorsed by the Cabinet on the 19th October 2004. 2. FORWARD PLAN 2.1 This report does not contain a recommendation on a key decision and has not been referred to in the Forward Plan. 3. BACKGROUND 3.1 Responsibility for health and safety law enforcement is shared between the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and local authorities. The HSE is a statutory body, established by the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (HSWA). It is a national independent watchdog for work-related health, safety and illness and an independent regulator, acting in the public interest to reduce work-related death and serious injury across Great Britain’s workplaces. 3.2 The division of responsibilities between local authorities and the HSE is laid down in regulations but local authority responsibilities include the regulation of occupational safety in premises such as offices, shops, warehouses, catering establishments, residential care homes, sports and leisure activities and tyre/exhaust bays. 3.3 Amongst the duties that the HSE is charged with delivering is the provision of guidance to local authorities on the way they discharge their duties under the HSWA. 3.4 The HSE adopted a revised national strategy for health and safety in June 2009 entitled ‘The Health and Safety of Great Britain’. At the same time, the HSE and Local Authority Representative Bodies published a Statement of Commitment which set out a joint commitment to ensure provision of adequate standards of partnership working in order to prevent death, injury and ill health of those at work and affected by work activities. 3.5 Section 18 of the HSWA puts a duty on the HSE and local authorities to make adequate arrangements for enforcement. The 'Standard' sets out the arrangements that local authorities and the HSE should put in place to meet this duty. Enforcing Authorities (EA) have been legally required, from 1st April 2008, to work towards compliance with these principles and standards. From 31st March 2011, compliance is mandatory. CABINET (22.3.11) 4. NORTH HERTFORDSHIRE’S HEALTH AND SAFETY ENFORCEMENT PLAN 4.1 The Health and Safety Enforcement Plan might better be considered as a strategy setting out how the Authority will fulfil the nationally set duties and requirements for health and safety enforcing authorities, taking on board local circumstances and priorities. The context of the Enforcement Plan is used in developing the Commercial Team’s input into the annual Housing and Public Protection Service Plan. 4.2 The revised guidance or Section 18 Standard issued by the HSE sets a framework of principles that local authorities are expected to meet. The principles are as follows: To “make it happen” every EA shall …… set out its commitment, priorities and planned interventions. put into place the capacity, management infrastructure, performance management and information systems required to deliver an effective service and to comply with their statutory duties. operate systems to train, appoint, authorise, monitor, and maintain a competent inspectorate. To “do it right” every EA shall …… use interventions, including enforcement action, in accordance with their enforcement policy and within the principles of proportionality, accountability, consistency, transparency and targeting. To “work together” every EA shall …… work within their own organisation, in partnership with other EAs, other regulators and stakeholders to make best use of joint resources and to maximise their impact on local, regional and national priorities. actively contribute to liaison, policy and governance arrangements at a local, regional and national level. To “sell the story” every EA shall …… promote sensible risk management 4.3 The draft Enforcement Plan for North Hertfordshire, which is attached at Appendix 1, follows this approach. 4.4 Section 1 of the Plan is the introduction, setting the context for the plan. 4.5 Section 2 sets out the Service aims and objectives and links this with the vision for the district and the Council’s priorities. The aim of the Service is to secure the health, safety and welfare of persons at work, and members of the public who may be affected by work activities within North Hertfordshire. CABINET (22.3.11) 4.6 Section 3 gives a short profile of the district and the organisational structure of the Council. A profile of the type of premises in the district that the Council is responsible for regulating is provided. 4.7 Section 4 deals with service delivery. It sets out the Council’s approach to the delivery of its regulatory responsibilities having regard to the Section 18 Standard. 4.8 Section 5 deals with resources. The Commercial Team consists of four environmental health officers, including the Team Manager. The health and safety enforcement function accounts for approximately 17% of the Team’s work, which equates to a net budget in 2010/11 of £77,670. 4.9 Section 6 sets out the approach to quality assessment and the procedures in place to ensure delivery of a satisfactory service. 4.10 Section 7 sets out the review process. It proposes that there should be an annual report to the Portfolio Holder reporting on performance against the Service Plan. The Plan will be formally reviewed every five years or sooner if there are any significant changes required. 5. LEGAL IMPLICATIONS 5.1 Cabinet within its terms of reference must agree to implement policies and strategies other than those reserved to Council. 5.2 The Council has a statutory duty to deliver its health and safety responsibilities in line with the Section 18 Standard. This Enforcement Plan fulfils this mandatory commitment. Other legal implications are set out within the body of the report. 6. FINANCIAL AND RISK IMPLICATIONS 6.1 There are no financial issues arising from the preparation or implementation of the Plan, as the costs are covered by the core funding for the Housing and Public Protection Service. 6.2 Failure to deliver the health and safety enforcement function in line with the Section 18 Standard could result in criticism of the Authority or legal challenge. 7. HUMAN RESOURCE AND EQUALITIES IMPLICATIONS 7.1 The Commercial Team is expected to be at full establishment by the beginning of 2011/12. Delivery of the health and safety function is dependent on the retention of suitably trained environmental health officers or other suitably qualified staff. 7.2 The Council incorporates the statutory equalities duties which apply to all its activities into policies and services as appropriate, as set out in the Council's Corporate Equality Strategy. We also recognise that in our society, groups and individuals continue to be unfairly discriminated against and we acknowledge our responsibilities to actively promote good community relations, equality of opportunity and combat discrimination in all its forms. CABINET (22.3.11) 7.3 During the development and consideration of service and budget planning options the impact of equality of access and outcomes should be considered. 8. CONSULTATION 8.1 The Portfolio Holder for Housing and Environmental Health has been consulted during the update of the service plan and preparation of this report. 9. RECOMMENDATIONS 9.1 That the Health and Safety Enforcement Plan as set out in Appendix 1 to this report be approved. 10. REASONS FOR RECOMMENDATIONS 10.1 Local authorities have a duty from the 31st March 2011 to undertake their health and safety enforcement duties in line with the Section 18 Standard. Approval of the Enforcement Plan will demonstrate the Authority’s commitment to complying with this requirement. 11. ALTERNATIVE OPTIONS CONSIDERED 11.1 There are no alternative options for the reason set out in paragraph 10.1 12. APPENDICES 12.1 Appendix 1 – Draft Health and Safety Enforcement Plan 13. CONTACT OFFICERS 13.1 Andy Godman Head of Housing and Public Protection (T) 01462 474293 (E) andy.godman@north-herts.gov.uk 13.2 Peter Carey (report author) Environmental Health Manager (T) 01462 474861 (E) peter.carey@north-herts.gov.uk 13.3 Alan Sills (report author) Commercial Team Manager (T) 01462 474414 (E) alan.sills@north-herts.gov.uk 13.4 Jodie Penfold Group Accountant (T) 01462 474332 (E) jodie.penfold@north-herts.gov.uk 13.5 Kerry Shorrocks Corporate Human Resources Manager (T) 01462 474224 (E) kerry.shorrocks@north-herts.gov.uk CABINET (22.3.11) 13.6 Anthony Roche Senior Lawyer (Legal Services) Tel: 01462 474588 Email: anthony.roche@north-herts.gov.uk CABINET (22.3.11) THIS PAGE IS BLANK CABINET (22.3.11) APPENDIX 1 North Hertfordshire District Council Housing and Public Protection Service Draft Health and Safety Enforcement Plan March 2011 CABINET (22.3.11) 1.0 Introduction 1.1 North Hertfordshire District Council is a designated enforcing authority under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (HSWA) and as such has a statutory duty to make adequate arrangements for the enforcement within the district of the relevant statutory provisions for which it has been given responsibility. 1.2 This Health and Safety Enforcement Plan has been drawn up in accordance with guidance under S18 HSWA and is an expression of the commitment of North Hertfordshire District Council to the development and delivery of the Council’s health and safety service. 1.3 The Government commissioned a report, the Rogers Review, which was published in 2007 into the setting of national enforcement priorities. One of the priorities identified was ‘Improving health in the workplace’. The concept of enforcement prioritisation is now enshrined in the Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Act 2008. 1.4 The duties imposed on the Authority to act as an enforcement authority under the HSWA are discharged by the Commercial Team within the Council’s Housing and Public Protection Service. 1.5 This Enforcement Plan deals with the following issues: 1.5.1 It sets out the Council’s commitment to the Health and Safety Executive’s strategy towards health and safety; 1.5.2 It sets out the aims and objectives of the Service in order to meet the Council’s statutory responsibilities and to improving health, safety and welfare outcomes; 1.5.3 It describes the Council’s service planning process and how work programmes relating to health and safety enforcement fit into this; 1.5.4 It sets out the Authority’s policies and procedures relating to the delivery of its health and safety work programmes and related work. 1.6 This Enforcement Plan forms part of the Housing and Public Protection Service Plan, which is reviewed annually. The Housing and Public Protection Service Plan sets out the Service’s contribution towards the Authority’s Corporate Plan, linking in with those of other Council services. 1.7 This Plan has been approved by the Cabinet of North Hertfordshire District Council. 2.0 Service Aims And Objectives Aims 2.1 The North Hertfordshire Local Strategic Partnership (LSP) has set a vision of ‘Making North Hertfordshire a vibrant place for people to live, work and prosper’. 2.2 The aim of the Council in delivering the health and safety enforcing authority function is to secure the health, safety and welfare of persons at work, and members of the public who may be affected by work activities within North Hertfordshire. This aim links closely with the LSP’s vision for the district. CABINET (22.3.11) 2.3 The Council has identified three priorities: town centres green issues sustainable development 2.4 The Housing and Public Protection Service’s Service Plan, including the health and safety function, is developed to support and deliver the Council’s Strategic Objectives. 2.5 The Council is committed to supporting the Health and Safety Executive’s Strategy ‘The Health and Safety of Great Britain’, adopted by the Executive in 2009 (http://www.hse.gov.uk/strategy/strategy09.pdf) Objectives 2.6 To fulfil the Council’s health and safety enforcing authority responsibilities as effectively as possible. 2.7 To fulfil the Council’s public safety function under the Licensing Act 2003. 2.8 To ensure that there are sufficient and suitably qualified staff to fulfil the Council’s enforcing authority responsibilities. 2.9 To plan and deliver an annual inspection programme relating to businesses and business activities in North Hertfordshire. 2.10 To respond to all complaints, reports under the Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations 1995 (RIDDOR) and other referrals and service requests in an appropriately timely manner. 2.11 To maintain a database of businesses within the district for which the Council has health and safety enforcement responsibility. 2.12 To work in partnership with the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) as required to deliver the best possible health, safety and welfare outcomes. 2.13 To work in partnership with other districts and agencies across Hertfordshire, the East of England region and nationally to deliver the best possible health, safety and welfare outcomes. 2.14 To provide information and advice to local businesses to increase their knowledge of their legal obligations under health, safety and welfare legislation. 2.15 To seek a balance between the need for appropriate regulatory enforcement procedures and educational/advisory actions in order to remove risks to health and safety at work. 3.0. Background 3.1. The District of North Hertfordshire covers 37,500 hectares and is situated approximately 40 miles north of London. It is an area of mixed urban and rural communities taking in the towns of Hitchin, Letchworth, Baldock and CABINET (22.3.11) Royston with over 30 villages set in the countryside of the Eastern Chilterns. The District has a population of 125,000. 3.2. The organisational structure of the Council is attached in Appendix 1. 3.3 The Commercial Team within the Housing and Public Protection Service is responsible for delivering the Council’s health and safety enforcement responsibilities. The team also has responsibility for food safety, infectious disease matters and other miscellaneous public health related functions. 3.4 There are four full time Environmental Health Officers (EHO) posts in the Commercial Team, including the Team Manager. All Officers undertaking inspections meet the requirements of S.18 Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 guidance and are authorised through the Council’s Scheme of Delegation in accordance with their qualifications and experience. 3.5 There are approximately 2000 commercial premises in North Hertfordshire that the Council is responsible for regulating under the HSWA, including 800 retail shops, 575 offices and 1000 catering premises. The majority of employers in North Hertfordshire are small or medium size enterprises (SMEs); there are approximately 25 businesses with 50 or more employees. There are 28 premises registered for the practice of acupuncture and the business of tattooing, cosmetic piercing, semi-permanent skin colouring and electrolysis. 3.6 The Commercial Team is based in the Council Offices, Gernon Road, Letchworth Garden City, SG6 3JF; these offices are open from 9.00 a.m. to 5.00 p.m. Monday to Friday. 3.7 The enforcement of health and safety is shared between local authorities and the HSE depending upon the type of premises and the major activity on site. Allocation of enforcement is through the Health and Safety (Enforcing Authority) Regulations 1998. In general, local authorities are responsible for offices, shops, warehouses, catering establishments, residential care homes, sports and leisure activities and tyre and exhaust bays. The HSE is responsible for factories, education establishments, hospitals, construction, agriculture and motor vehicle repairers. 4.0 Service Delivery “Making It Happen” 4.1 The Commercial Team’s has an annual health and safety work plan that is reviewed at the end of each year in conjunction with the development of the following year’s plan. In developing the plan, regard is had to guidance issued by the HSE. The health and safety work that is undertaken can be broken down into two main areas, targeted project work and reactive/routine work. 4.2 The targeted project work has three main elements: 4.2.1 National priorities as set by the HSE 4.2.2 Regional priorities developed by the Herts and Beds Health and Safety Group, which is also attended by staff from the regional offices of the HSE 4.2.3 Local priorities CABINET (22.3.11) 4.3 Reactive/routine work is made up of the following elements 4.3.1 Inspections selected in accordance with the HSE priority planning guidance (LAC 67/2). This rating system scores premises based on four factors: confidence in management, health performance, safety performance, and welfare standards. 4.3.2 RIDDOR notifications and complaints selected in accordance with HSE incident selection criteria guidance (LAC 22/13), which aims to provide a proportionate, transparent and targeted to the selection and investigation of accidents. 4.3.3 Undertaking the public safety responsible authority role in relation to premises and events licensed under the Licensing Act 2003 4.4 The Team also carries out other health and safety related duties such as the registration of skin piercing activities under the Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1982 and local bye-laws. 4.5 The Council maintains a database of premises for which it is responsible for regulating. The database is called Acolaid. Relevant data is recorded in order for the Council to fulfil its duties and facilitate reporting. 4.6 On completion of a health and safety inspection, officers are required to enter details of the inspection on the Council’s database, complete the risk rating, make any amendments to the premises record from information obtained during the visit and take such action as they feel necessary to ensure that business proprietors can comply with health and safety legislative requirements. Details of any action taken by the officer are also logged on the database. Reference should be made to the Council’s Premises Inspection Procedure – Health and Safety. 4.7 The HSE Priority Planning Guidance LAC 67/2 categorises premises in four risk categories. The North Hertfordshire premises profile at the 31st January 2011 was as follows: Category A B1 B2 C Unrated No. of premises 3 8 163 1631 188 Category A premises are required to be inspected at least annually. Category B1 premises should be inspected every 1-2 years, possibly as part of other inspection programmes. 4.8 Revisits to premises are confined to checking that any improvements previously required / requested have been carried out to a satisfactory standard. Planned revisits should be made within 10 days of the timescale agreed with the proprietor. Revisits to check compliance with an Improvement Notice are made on expiry, or within 5 days of the expiry of the Notice. 4.9 The number and type of inspections are monitored through local performance indicators, reported to Members and through statutory returns. CABINET (22.3.11) 4.10 Provision is made within the annual budget for the appointment of specialist advice / consultancy in circumstances where it is felt that expert knowledge is needed to deal with matters beyond the capabilities of the Council’s health and safety enforcement officers. 4.11 Approximately 30 complaints are received annually either from people working within the District about working conditions, or from members of the public affected by work activities. All of these complaints are investigated in accordance with the Council’s adopted standards. The purpose of the investigation is to secure health and safety, to address the cause of the complaint and ensure that any necessary steps are taken to address issues identified. 4.12 Approximately 200 incidents are notified each year under RIDDOR - the majority of these relate to accidents involving the elderly in residential care homes. Incident/accidents are investigated in accordance with the Council’s Accident Investigation Policy. The purpose of an investigation is to understand the cause of an accident, ensuring that all parties are fulfilling their health and safety obligations, and prevent further accidents from occurring 4.13 The Commercial Team has prioritised all the activities that it is required to undertake having regard to national guidance and local priorities. The Team’s service priorities are set out in Appendix 2. “Doing It Right” 4.14 The Housing and Public Protection Service has an Enforcement Policy that sets out the approach to enforcement across the Service, including health and safety at work. This takes on board guidance from the HSE and other agencies about enforcement principles. This Enforcement Policy is periodically revised, the most recent revision being approved by Cabinet in December 2010. The Enforcement Policy is published on the Council’s website. 4.15 The Council operates a formal complaints system, the “3Cs”, to allow anyone who is dissatisfied with the Council’s services to challenge any actions taken. “Working Together” 4.16 It is the policy of this Council to encourage businesses within the District to encompass partnership working either under the Lead Authority Principle or the Primary Authority scheme. However, no formal agreements exist at present. 4.17 The Council is committed to working with other service areas within the Council, neighbouring authorities and other agencies in order to deliver its duties as effectively as possible. A key means of fulfilling this commitment is participation in the Herts and Beds Health and Safety Group, which seeks to share best practice, undertake joint enforcement projects and improve consistency of deliver of regulatory functions. 4.18 The Council will also endeavour to minimise the burden placed on businesses in seeking information about their organisations and will seek feedback on from businesses with the aim of ensuring that the way the regulatory function is delivered is as fair and as helpful to businesses as possible. CABINET (22.3.11) “Selling The Story” 4.19 The Council is committed to promoting sensible risk assessment in line with the HSE’s Sensible Risk Assessment Campaign and will use suitable opportunities during interventions, when responding to complaints, or as part of promotional activities, to do so. 4.20 It is the policy of this Council to support local businesses by providing information and advice on matters relating to health, safety and welfare. The profile of businesses in the District, mainly small offices and retail outlets, means that demands on the service can be met by the existing resources. 5.0. Resources 5.1 The health and safety enforcement function is integrated into the work programme of the Commercial Team, within the Housing and Public Protection Service. The health and safety responsibilities are approximately 17% of the Team’s workload, equating to £77,670 of the net budget of the Team. 5.2 The Commercial Team consists of four Environmental Health Officer posts, one of whom is the manager of the Team. Administrative support to the Team amounts to 0.5 full time equivalent posts. 5.3 Environmental Health Officers must complete a minimum of 20 hours training a year as part of the Continuing Professional Development programme of the Chartered Institute of Environmental Health. North Hertfordshire District Council operates a learning and development programme which is integrated with the annual appraisal process for all staff, with the aim of ensuring that staff have the skills and knowledge required to undertake the tasks required of them and fulfil the Council’s service objectives. The Regulators’ Development Needs Analysis tool, developed by the HSE, will also be used as part of this process. 6.0 Quality Assessment 6.1 The Commercial Team maintains a suite of procedures to ensure the effective delivery of this Enforcement Plan and the statutory duties regarding the regulation of occupational health, safety and welfare in North Hertfordshire. 6.2 The following documents have been prepared and implemented: The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 – Enforcement Policy The Health and Safety Enforcement Strategy The Document Control Procedure The Document List The Quality Management System The Procedure for the Authorisation of Enforcement Officers The Premises Inspection Procedure The Procedure for Ensuring the Accuracy of the Premises Database The Accident Investigation Policy The Accident Investigation Procedure CABINET (22.3.11) 7.0 Review 7.1 This Health and Safety Enforcement Plan will be formally updated and presented for Member approval every five years or earlier if significant changes are required to the plan. 7.2 The annual health and safety work plan will be reviewed on an annual basis. A report will be prepared for submission to the Portfolio Holder responsible for this area of work, which will include: Information on the previous year’s performance Relevant national and local performance indicators Any variance from the service plan Proposed areas for improvement CABINET (22.3.11) APPENDIX 1 North Hertfordshire District Council SENIOR MANAGEMENT ARRANGEMENTS/FUNCTIONS June 2009 Chief Executive Strategic Director Customer Services HOS Leisure & Env Serv Leisure Services Parking Enfor Public Conv Projects Markets Client Parks & Countryside Allotments Grounds Main Cemeteries Waste Manag Street Cleansing Emergency Planning CABINET (22.3.11) HOS Com & Cultural Ser (New) HOS Customer Serv & IT Children’s IT BPI Information Services Sports Dev Leisure Dir Halls & Centres Unit FOI/DPA Customer Museums Services Careline Reprog raphics Business Dev Policy Dev Comms Consultation PR Member Services Strategic Director Finance, Policy and Governance Strategic Director of Planning, Housing and Enterprise Corp Human Resources Manager Employee Relations Learning & Dev Shared Services HOS Dev & Building Control Building Control Planning Control & Conservation Technical Support Quality, Compliance and Monitoring HOS Housing & Env Health Commercial Team EH Env Protection Licensing & Enforcement Housing Needs Strategy, Dev & Renewal Community Safety Electoral Services Committee and Democratic Services Manager Corp Strat. Planning & Enterprise Manager Economic Development Regional and Strategic Planning LDF Projects Parking Strategy HOS Fin, Perf & Asset Manag Accountancy Treasury Mgt Property Services Asset Mgt Audit and Consultancy Risk Mgt & Insurances Performance & Quality Programme Mgt HOS Revenues & Benefits Revs and Benefits Systems & Technical Investigation MSU inc. Land Charges HOS Pol, Part’ships & Com Dev (New) Area Committees Com Dev Corporate Policy Comm strategy Scrutiny Grants Parish Challenge 50+ Corporate Legal Manager Legal Services Monitoring Officer role APPENDIX 2 COMMERCIAL TEAM SERVICE PRIORITIES 2010/11 Priority 1 Food safety inspections - Category A premises 1 Food safety inspections - Category B premises 1 Health & safety inspections – Category A premises 2 Non broadly compliant food premises Accident investigations – mandatory 3 Infectious disease high priority 4 Drainage in commercial premises Public burials Sonisphere Registration of skin piercers Complaints - high priority 5 Priority 2 Food safety new premises inspections Food safety inspections - Category C SOTD premises 1 Food safety inspections - Category D SOTD premises 1 Health & safety inspections – Category B1 premises 2 Infectious disease medium priority 3 ROTW LA2003 Responsible Authority applications Priority 3 Food safety inspections - Category C non SOTD premises 1 Food safety inspections - Category D non SOTD premises 1 Health & safety inspections – Category B2 premises 2 Accident investigations discretionary (medium priority) 3 Infectious disease low priority 4 Inspection of skin piercers Planning consultations Advice visits to businesses Sunbed establishments Smoke free enforcement Complaints – low priority 5 Priority 4 Notes 1 2 3 4 5 Food safety inspections - Category E premises Health & safety inspections – Category C premises Accident investigations discretionary (low priority) 3 Food Law Code of Practice (England) HSE LAC 67/2 (rev2) 10 March 2010 HSE LAC 22/13 24 September 2009 EoE GI Group draft guidance 22/3/10 NHDC criteria CABINET (22.3.11)