CHAPTER 4 A Tour of the Cell 1. Cells are the smallest entity that exhibits all the characteristics of life. 2. Cells are as fundamental to biology as atoms are to chemistry. 3. An understanding of cell structure and function is essential to understanding most human disease. Biology and Society: Drugs That Target Bacterial Cells 1. Explain how antibiotics specifically target bacteria while minimally harming the human host. The Microscopic World of Cells 2. Compare the following pairs of terms, noting the most significant differences: light microscopes versus electron microscopes, scanning electron microscopes versus transmission electron microscopes, magnification versus resolution, prokaryotic cells versus eukaryotic cells, plant cells versus animal cells. Membrane Structure 3. Describe the structure of the plasma membrane and other membranes of the cell. Explain why this structure is called a fluid mosaic. 4. Explain how MRSA bacteria disable human immune cells. 5. Compare the structures and functions of a plant cell wall and the extracellular matrix of an animal cell. The Nucleus and Ribosomes: Genetic Control of the Cell 6. Explain how the genetic information in the nucleus is used to direct the production of proteins in the cytoplasm. The Endomembrane System: Manufacturing and Distributing Cellular Products 7. Compare the structures and functions of the following components of the endomembrane system: rough endoplasmic reticulum, smooth endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi apparatus, lysosomes, and vacuoles. Chloroplasts and Mitochondria: Energy Conversion 8. Compare the structure and function of chloroplasts and mitochondria. Describe the adaptive advantages of extensive folds in the grana of chloroplasts and the inner membrane of mitochondria. The Cytoskeleton: Cell Shape and Movement 9. Describe the functions of the cytoskeleton. Compare the structures and functions of cilia and flagella. Evolution Connection: The Evolution of Antibiotic Resistance 10. Explain how and why antibiotic-resistant bacteria have evolved. Key Terms cell junctions cell theory central vacuole chloroplast chromatin chromosome cilia cristae cytoplasm cytoskeleton cytosol electron microscope (EM) endomembrane system endoplasmic reticulum (ER) eukaryotic cell extracellular matrix flagella fluid mosaic food vacuoles gene Golgi apparatus grana light microscope (LM) lysosomal storage disease lysosome magnification microtubule mitochondria nuclear envelope nucleolus nucleus organelles phospholipid phospholipid bilayer plasma membrane prokaryotic cell resolving power ribosome rough ER scanning electron microscope (SEM) smooth ER stroma transmission electron microscope (TEM) transport vesicles vacuole Word Roots chloro = green (chloroplast: the green organelle of photosynthesis) chromo = color (chromosome: a threadlike, darkly staining structure packaging DNA in the nucleus) cili = small hair (cilium: a short, hair like cellular appendage with a microtubule core) cyto = cell (cytoplasm: cell region between the nucleus and the plasma membrane) endo = inner (endomembrane system: an internal system of membranous organelles) eu = true (eukaryotic: cell type with a membrane-enclosed nucleus and other organelles) extra = outside (extracellular: the substance around animal cells) flagell = whip (flagellum: a long, whiplike cellular appendage that moves cells) micro = small (microtubule: microscopic tubular filaments contributing to the cytoskeleton) plasm = molded (plasma membrane: the thin layer that sets a cell apart from its surroundings) pro = before (prokaryotic: the first cells, lacking a membrane-enclosed nucleus and other organelles) reticul = network (endoplasmic reticulum: membranous network where proteins are produced) trans = across (transport vesicles: membranous spheres that move materials across a cell) vacu = empty (vacuole: sac that buds from the ER, Golgi apparatus, or plasma membrane) Student Media Activities Metric System Review Prokaryotic Cell Structure and Function Comparing Cells Build an Animal Cell and a Plant Cell Membrane Structure Role of the Nucleus and Ribosomes in Protein Synthesis The Endomembrane System Build a Chloroplast and a Mitochondrion Cilia and Flagella Review: Animal Cell Structure and Function Review: Plant Cell Structure and Function BioFlix Tour of an Animal Cell Tour of a Plant Cell BLAST Animations Animal Cell Overview Plant Cell Overview Vesicle Transport along Microtubules Vacuole Mitochondrion Plant Cell Wall MP3 Tutors Cell Organelles Process of Science What Is the Size and Scale of Our World? Videos Discovery Channel Video: Cells Prokaryotic Flagella Euglena Cytoplasmic Streaming Chlamydomonas Paramecium Cilia Paramecium Vacuole Relevant Current Issues in Biology Articles Current Issues in Biology, volume 6 (ISBN 0-321-59849-0) Your Cells Are My Cells Relevant Songs to Play in Class “Tainted Love,” Soft Cell “Golgi Apparatus,” Phish Chapter Guide to Teaching Resources The Microscopic World of Cells Student Misconceptions and Concerns 1. Students typically cannot distinguish between resolution and magnification. However, pixels and resolution of digital images can help “clarify” the distinction. Consider printing the same image at high and low resolution or enlarging the same image at two different levels of resolution. Teaching Tip 2 below suggests another related exercise. 2. Students frequently equate the functions of mitochondria and chloroplasts as alternative ways to acquire usable energy. This often leads to the conclusion that animal cells have mitochondria but not chloroplasts and that plant cells have chloroplasts but not mitochondria. Plant cells have both. Teaching Tips 1. Here is a chance to challenge students to identify technology that has extended our senses. Chemical probes can identify what we cannot taste, listening devices detect what we do not normally hear, night vision and ultraviolet (UV) cameras detect or magnify wavelengths beyond our vision, and so on. Students could be assigned the task of preparing a short report on one of these technologies. 2.Here is a way to demonstrate resolving power in the classroom. Use a marker and your classroom marker board to make several pairs of dots separated by shorter and shorter distances. Start out with two dots clearly separated apart—perhaps by 4–5 cm—and end with a pair of dots that touch. Label them a, b, c, and so on. Ask your students to indicate the letters of the pairs of points that they can distinguish as separate; this is the definition of resolution for their eyes. (They need not state their answers publicly, to avoid embarrassment.) 3.Most biology laboratories have two types of microscopes for student use: a dissection (or stereo-) microscope and a “compound” light microscope using microscope slides. The way these scopes function parallels the workings of EMs. Dissection microscopes are like an SEM—both rely on a beam reflected off a surface. As you explain this to your class, hold up an object, identify a light source in the room, and explain that our eyes see most images when our eyes detect light that has reflected off the surface of an object. Compound light microscopes are like TEMs, in which a beam is transmitted through a thin sheet of material. If you have an overhead or other strong light source, hold up a piece of paper between your eye and the light source. You will see the internal detail of the paper as light is transmitted through the paper to your eye—the way a compound light microscope or TEM works! 4.Even in college, students still struggle with the metric system. When discussing the scale of life, consider bringing a meterstick to class. The relationship between a meter and a millimeter is the same as a millimeter is to a micrometer. Each is a difference of 1,000. 5.This is a place where a visual image comparing a prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell can be very helpful. These cells are strikingly different in size and composition. A visual reference point instead of just abstract ideas and traits will be a continual reminder for your students during your discussion of these cells. 6.Students might wrongly conclude that prokaryotes are typically one-tenth the volume of eukaryotic cells. A difference in diameter by a factor of ten translates into a much greater difference in volume. Students might be challenged to recall enough geometry to calculate the difference in the volume of two cells with diameters that differ by a factor of ten. 7.Germs—here is a term that we learn early in our lives but that is rarely well defined. Students may appreciate a biological explanation. The general use of germs is a reference to anything that causes disease. This may be a good time to sort the major disease-causing agents into three categories: (1) bacteria (prokaryotes), (2) viruses (not yet addressed), and (3) single-celled and multicellular eukaryotes (athlete’s foot is a fungal infection; malaria is caused by a unicellular eukaryote). 8.Some instructors have reported great success by challenging their students to make analogies to the functions of the many organelles discussed. Students may wish to construct one inclusive analogy between a society or factory (used in the text) and a cell or to construct separate analogies for each organelle. As with any analogy, it is important to list the similarities and differences/exceptions. 9. This might be a good time to discuss the evolution of antibiotic resistance. Teaching tips and ideas for related lessons can be found at www.pbs.org/wgbh/evolution/educators/lessons/lesson6/act1.html. Membrane Structure Student Misconceptions and Concerns 1.Students often think of the function of cell membranes as mainly containment, like that of a plastic bag. Consider relating the functions of membranes to our human skin. (For example, both membranes and our skin detect stimuli, engage in gas exchange, and serve as sites of excretion and absorption.) Teaching Tips 1. The hydrophobic and hydrophilic ends of a phospholipid molecule naturally create a lipid bilayer. The hydrophobic edges of the layer will seal to other such edges, eventually wrapping a sheet into a sphere that can enclose water (a simple cell). Further, because of these hydrophobic properties, lipid bilayers are naturally self-healing. That all of this organization naturally emerges from the properties of phospholipids is worth sharing with your students. 2. You might wish to share a very simple analogy that seems to work with some students. A cell membrane is a little like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich with jellybeans poked into it. The bread represents the hydrophilic portions of the bilayer (and bread does indeed quickly absorb water). The peanut butter and jelly represent the hydrophobic regions (and peanut butter, containing plenty of oil, is generally hydrophobic). The jellybeans stuck into the sandwich represent proteins variously embedded partially into or completely through the membrane. Transport proteins would be like the jellybeans that poke completely through the sandwich. Analogies are rarely perfect. Challenge your students to critique this analogy to find exceptions. (For example, this analogy does not include a model of the carbohydrates on the cell surface.) The Nucleus and Ribosomes: Genetic Control of the Cell Student Misconceptions and Concerns 1. Noting the main flow of genetic information from DNA to RNA to protein on the board will provide a useful reference for students when explaining these processes. As a review, have students note where new molecules of DNA, RNA, and proteins are produced in a cell. 2. Consider challenging your students to explain how we can have four main types of organic molecules functioning in specific roles in our cells, yet DNA and RNA only specifically dictate the generation of proteins (and more copies of DNA and RNA). How is the production of specific types of carbohydrates and lipids in cells controlled? (Answer: primarily by the specific properties of enzymes.) Teaching Tips 1. Some of your more knowledgeable students may like to guess the exceptions to 46 chromosomes per human cell. These exceptions include gametes, some of the cells that produce them, and red blood cells in non-fetal mammals. 2.If you wish to continue the text’s factory analogy, nuclear pores might be said to function most like the doors to the boss’s office. 3. If you want to challenge your students further, ask them to consider the adaptive advantage of using mRNA to direct the production of proteins instead of using DNA directly. Some biologists suggest that DNA is better protected in the nucleus and that mRNA, exposed to more damaging cross-reactions in the cytosol, is the temporary “working copy” of the genetic material. In some ways, this is similar to making a working photocopy of an important document, keeping the original copy safely stored away. The Endomembrane System: Manufacturing and Distributing Cellular Products Student Misconceptions and Concerns 1. Students might have trouble connecting the diverse functions to the organelles. The pathway of secretory proteins is a good process to use to introduce the primary organelle functions. The movement of information and products extends generally from the central nucleus to the interconnected rough ER, to the more peripherally located Golgi, and finally to the outer plasma membrane. Introducing the steps of this process with the central to peripheral flow may help students better see the interrelationships and recall the sequence. 2. Conceptually, some students seem to benefit from the well-developed factory-like-a-cell analogy developed in the text. The use of this analogy in lecture might help to anchor these relationships. Teaching Tips 1. The endoplasmic reticulum is continuous with the outer nuclear membrane. This explains why the ER is usually found close to the nucleus. 2.Some people think the Golgi apparatus looks like a stack of pita bread. 3. If you continue the factory analogy, the addition of a molecular tag is like adding address labels in the shipping department of a factory. Chloroplasts and Mitochondria: Energy Conversion Student Misconceptions and Concerns 1. Students often mistakenly think that chloroplasts are a substitute for mitochondria in plant cells. They may falsely think that cells either have mitochondria or they have chloroplasts. You might wish to emphasize the presence and significance of mitochondria and chloroplasts in plant cells. 2. The evidence that mitochondria and chloroplasts evolved from free-living prokaryotes is further supported by the small prokaryote size of these organelles. Mitochondria and chloroplasts are therefore helpful in comparing the general size of eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells. Teaching Tips 1. ATP functions in cells much like money functions in modern societies. Each holds value that can be generated in one place and “spent” in another. This analogy has been very helpful for many students. 2.Mitochondria and chloroplasts are each wrapped by multiple membranes. In both organelles, the innermost membranes are the sites of greatest molecular activity and the outer membranes have fewer significant functions. These outer membranes best correspond to the plasma membrane of the eukaryotic cells that originally wrapped the free-living prokaryotes during endocytosis. 3. Mitochondria and chloroplasts are not cellular structures that are synthesized in a cell like ribosomes and lysosomes. Instead, mitochondria only come from other mitochondria and chloroplasts only come from other chloroplasts. This is further evidence of the independent evolution of these organelles from free-living ancestral forms. The Cytoskeleton: Cell Shape and Movement Student Misconceptions and Concerns 1. Students often regard the fluid of the cytoplasm as little more than a watery fluid, which suspends the organelles. The diverse functions of thin, thick, and intermediate filaments are rarely appreciated before college. 2.Students often think that the cilia on the cells lining our trachea function like a comb, removing debris from the air. Except in cases of disease or damage, these respiratory cilia are instead covered by mucus. Cilia lining our trachea do not reach the air to “comb” it. Instead, these cilia sweep the dirty mucus up our respiratory tracts. (See also Teaching Tip 2 below.) 3. The dynamic, weblike structure of the cytoskeleton is very different from the skeletons that students may already know. Their dynamic structures (see Teaching Tip 2 below) are quite unlike any human designs. Students have much to gain from vivid illustrations of cytoskeletal diversity. Consider sharing some impressive images from a Google image search or other resources. Teaching Tips 1. Students might enjoy this brief class activity. Have everyone in the class clear their throats at the same time. Wait a few seconds. Have them notice that after clearing, they swallowed. The mucus that trapped debris is swept up the trachea by cilia. When we clear our throats, this dirty mucus is disposed of down our esophagus and among the strong acids of our stomach! 2. Analogies between the infrastructure of human buildings and the cytoskeleton are limited by the dynamic nature of the cytoskeleton. Few human structures have their structural framework routinely constructed, deconstructed, and then reformed in a new configuration on a regular basis. (Tents are often constructed, deconstructed, and then reformed repeatedly but typically rely upon the same basic design.) Thus, caution is especially warranted in such analogies. Answers to End-of-Chapter Questions The Process of Science 11. Suggested answer: In the cell membrane, phospholipids are facing either the aqueous environment outside the cell or the aqueous environment inside the cell. Since the polar “heads” of the phospholipids are hydrophilic, they orient toward water. Therefore, two layers are necessary. The membranes that enclose oil droplets face only an aqueous environment on the exterior of the droplet. This means that one layer of phospholipids is sufficient. The polar heads point outward, whereas the hydrophobic fatty acids point inward toward the oil. 12. Suggested answer: Upon initial inspection, one would expect to see cells containing indigestible substances accumulated in the lysosomes. The symptoms of lysosomal storage diseases can be diverse, depending on the specific digestive enzyme that is not present or functioning correctly. A wide battery of blood tests and a physical exam might reveal some of these specific symptoms. In addition, some of the disease symptoms might also exist in one of the parents of the child. Biology and Society 13. Some issues and questions to consider: Were the cells Moore’s property, a gift, or just surplus? Was Moore asked to donate the cells? Was he informed about how the cells might be used? Is it important to ask permission or inform the patient in such a case? How much did the researchers modify the cells? What did they have to do to them to sell the product? Do the researchers and the university have a right to make money from Moore’s cells? Is the fact that they saved Moore’s life a factor here? Does Moore have the right to sell his cells? Would Moore have been able to sell the cells without the researchers’ help? Additional Critical Thinking Questions The Process of Science 1. You are comparing two cells. One cell is very small, and the other cell is huge. You are asked to determine which cell will be more successful based solely on size. What would your answer be? Give a specific explanation for your answer. Suggested answer: The smaller cell would be expected to be more successful. It will have a greater surface-to-volume ratio. This makes it easier for the cell to acquire nutrients, remove wastes, and communicate faster between the nucleus and cytoplasm. Larger cells do have a large surface area; however, they also have a larger volume and much greater distances for materials to diffuse. 2.Several lines of evidence support the hypothesis that mitochondria and chloroplasts evolved from parasitic prokaryotic cells living in the cytoplasm of primitive eukaryotic cells. What types of evidence would you look for to support or refute this hypothesis? Suggested answer: Prokaryotes, like eukaryotes, contain DNA. One would expect, therefore, to find DNA in mitochondria and chloroplasts. Such DNA is found. You would expect that genes found within mitochondrial or chloroplast DNA are more similar to prokaryotic genes than they are to equivalent eukaryotic genes. Prokaryotes carry out protein synthesis, as do mitochondria and chloroplasts, which have their own ribosomes. One curious feature of mitochondria and chloroplasts is their double membrane. Although prokaryotes do not have a double membrane, you might imagine how the envelopment of a prokaryote by a eukaryotic cell would wrap a second “outer membrane” around the cell. Thus, the inner membrane would represent the original prokaryotic membrane, and the outer membrane would represent the remains of the eukaryotic membrane. 3.The inside of lysosomes is acidic with a pH (5.0) significantly lower than the slightly basic pH of the cytoplasm. As you might expect, the hydrolytic enzymes stored inside the lysosome work best at this low pH. Can you think of a hypothesis to explain why such a pH difference was important in the evolution of the cell? How would you test your hypothesis? Suggested answer: Lysosomes are dangerous organelles because of their large arsenal of enzymes capable of digesting virtually any macromolecule produced by the cell. Were a lysosome to leak, the potential damage to the cell would be great. It is inevitable that a few lysosomes rupture, either because of accident or because of age. Because of the pH difference, leaked enzymes would be unable to work in the pH of the cytoplasm, and no damage would be done to the cell. To test your hypothesis, you could isolate enzymes from lysosomes and measure their activity at several different controlled pHs. If your hypothesis were correct, you would expect that the activity of the enzymes at the pH of the cytoplasm would be very low. 4. You have isolated a new prokaryotic organism, and now you want to determine whether it is photosynthetic. It is too small to visualize with the microscopes you have available. Design an experiment to determine whether the new cell actively uses photosynthesis. Suggested answer: You could provide this new cell with the ingredients needed for photosynthesis and see what happens. For example, you could provide the cells with water in which the oxygen has been radioactively labeled. If the cells photosynthesize, those water molecules will be split, and radioactive oxygen gas will be released. You could also provide the cells with radioactively labeled carbon dioxide. If the cells perform photosynthesis, the radioactivity should be found in glucose in the cells. Biology and Society 5. Panspermia is an old idea that living cells did not evolve on Earth, but instead came to Earth from space. The Greek philosopher Anaxagoras was the first to consider the possibility that living seeds arrived on Earth from another world. Several famous scientists have also held this view. The Swedish chemist Svante Arrhenius, a Nobel Prize winner, published a book in 1907 in which he argued that living spores escaped from the upper atmosphere of living planets and traveled to other planets through space. The astronomer Fred Hoyle, famous for the steady-state universe theory, argued that life originated in comets, which seeded the Earth on impact. Frances Crick, codiscoverer of the structure of DNA, argued in a 1981 book that life was sent to Earth on rocket ships by intelligent beings elsewhere in the universe, a process he termed directed pangenesis. What objections to this theory would its supporters have to consider? Do you consider this idea a reasonable explanation of how living cells evolved? How would such an idea change your view of your position in the universe? Some issues and questions to consider: Could living cells or spores survive the long journey through space? Would they be damaged by the intense radiation and extreme temperatures found in space? What force could eject cells from their home planet? Would the force of such an ejection damage the cells? Could cells survive passage through the earth’s atmosphere? Assuming cells survived this journey inside a protected environment (such as the center of a large comet), how would they exit this environment upon arrival? Could they survive the environment of their new home? If there are supportive data for each of these concerns, does the hypothesis merely push back the question of how life evolved? If it did not evolve on Earth, then how did it evolve in some other corner of the universe? If cells did evolve elsewhere in the universe, the most important conclusion would be that indeed we are not alone in the universe. Perhaps our universe is teeming with life. 6. Explain why animal cells would be unable to exist without the presence of plant cells. Is this relationship reciprocal? Some issues and questions to consider: What things do plants produce via photosynthesis that animal cells require? Do animals produce anything that plants need? What would happen to animals if plant cells all died? What would happen to plant cells if animal cells all died?