DRAFT PROGRAM
ANALYTICAL COMMUNITIES IN POLICY ADVISORY SYSTEMS AT GLOBAL AND LOCAL LEVEL:
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF POLICY IMPACT
HSE – IPSA, MOSCOW, 27 – 29, MAY 2014
The conference will be held at HSE Moscow Campus at the 20 Myasnitskaya Str, Acad. Council Conf. Hall
TUESDAY, MAY 27TH. PRECONFERENCE DAY
11th JCPA and ICPA-Forum International Workshop: «Concepts and Methods of Comparative
Policy Analysis: applicability to different “policy contexts”», organized by Public Policy
Department of National Research University Higher School of Economics together with
International Comparative Policy Analysis – Forum (ICPA – Forum).
By invitation only. If you are interested to take part please approach Conference Organizing
Committee (politanaliz@gmail.com)
WEDNESDAY, MAY 28TH
10h00
11h00 to 11h30
Registration of Conference Participants
WELCOMING SESSION


11h30 to 13h00
Welcoming Address by HSE First Vice-Rector Vadim Radaev
Welcoming Remarks from Program Committee Co-Chairs Nina Belyaeva and
Michael Howlett
 Welcoming Remarks by RPSA
 Introduction on Higher School of Economics as Research Community and its
Impact on Policy Making by HSE Vice-Rector
MORNING SESSION :
INTELLECTUAL COMMUNITIES AS POLICY MAKERS AT
NATIONAL AND GLOBAL LEVELS


11h30 to 12h00
12h00 to 12h15
12h15 to 12h30
12h30 to 13h00
13h00 to 14h00
14h00 to 15h00
15h00 to 18h00
Moderator : Nina Belyaeva, Professor, Chair of HSE Public Policy Department
Discussant : Frank Fischer, Professor of Politics and Global Affairs, Political
Science Dept. and E.J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, Rutgers
University, Newark and New Brunswick, NJ USA
Keynote speaker:
Jack Goldstone, Professor of Public Policy and Eminent Scholar School
of Public Policy, George Mason University, USA, jgoldsto@gmu.edu
Q & A Session
Reaction to Presentation and discussion by Session Discussant
Coffee – Break
Presentation of International Research Journals.
“Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis” (ed. Iris Geva-May)
“Policy and Society” (ed. Michael Howlett)
“Critical Policy Studies” (ed. Frank Fisher)
“The Journal of Policy Analysis and Management” (ed. Kenneth Couch)
Lunch
EVENING SESSION :
INTELLECTUAL COMMUNITIES AS POLICY MAKERS AT
1
NATIONAL AND GLOBAL LEVELS


Moderator : Nina Belyaeva, Professor, Chair of HSE Public Policy Department
Discussant : Frank Fischer, Professor of Politics and Global Affairs, Political
Science Dept. and E.J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, Rutgers
University, Newark and New Brunswick, NJ USA
15h00 to 17h00
Paper presenters:
1. “Analytical communities’ location in the process of public policymaking” Kieke G.H. Okma, New York University, USA,
kiekeokma781@gmail.com; Theodore Marmor, Yale School of
Management, USA, theodore.marmor@yale.edu
2. “Comparative Practice of Elaboration of UN Convention on
Regulation of Private Military and Security Companies and of Model
Laws in CIS Inter-Parliamentary Assembly: Role of Analytical
Communities”
Alexander
Nikitin,
MGIMO,
Russia,
an@inno.mgimo.ru
3. “Does Oil Promote or Prevent Coup d'etat? Experts' Assessments
and Impact of Experts on Coup d'etat” Frode Martin Nordvik, Bi
business school, Norway, Frode.M.Nordvik@bi.no
4. “Strategy 2020: Experts’ Impact on Russian Education Policy” Isaac
Froumin, Higher School of Economics, Russia, ifroumin@hse.ru
Case presenters:
5. “Analytical Communities’ Policy Impact on G20: the Case of
Think20” Mark Rakhmangulov, Higher School of Economics, Russia,
MRakhmangulov@hse.ru
6. “Analytical Communities in Singapore: serving National and Global
Interests” M Ramesh, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy,
National University of Singapore, mramesh@nus.edu.sg
7. “Advising Russian Government on East-Asian Policy” Aleksey
Maslov, Higher School of Economics, Russia, amaslov@hse.ru
8. “The expert discourse on geopolitics promoted by the analysts and
researchers affiliated with the Academy of Geopolitical Problems”
Natalia Morozova, Higher School of Economics, Russia,
nnmorozova@hse.ru
9. “Experience of Heinrich Boell Foundation work in Russia:
opportunities and limits of political participation and impact upon the
public policy” Irina Kosterina, Higher School of Economics, Russia,
ira.kosterina@gmail.com
17h00 to 17h30
17h30 to 18h00
18h00
Q & A Session
Reaction to Presentation and discussion by Session Discussant
Reception (HSE Campus, Professors Club)
THURSDAY, MAY 29TH
10h00 to 13h00
MORNING SESSION :
COMPARING POLICY ADVISORY SYSTEMS AND ROLES
ANALYSTS PLAY IN THEM. EXISTING EXPLANATORY
MODELS AND N EW TRENDS

Moderator : Philippe Zittoun, LET-ENTPE, University of Lyon
 Discussant : Michael Ramesh, Professor Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy
at the National University of Singapore
2
10h00 to 10h30
10h30 to 10h45
10h45 to 11h00
11h00 to 11h30
11h30 to 13h00
Keynote speaker : Michael Howlett, Professor at Simon Fraser
University, Canada; Policy Design Lab Project Director at the National
University of Singapore, howlett@sfu.ca
Q & A Session
Reaction to Presentations by Session Discussant
Coffee – Break ( in the same discussion hall)
Paper presenters:
1. “The collaboration between government and academics (representing
the U.S. viewpoint)” Kenneth Couch, The University of Connecticut,
USA, kenneth.couch@uconn.edu
2. “Policy Advisory Systems in Saratov region, Tatarstan and Karelia:
determining factors” Nina Belyaeva, Higher School of Economics,
Russia, politanaliz@gmail.com
3. “Politisation of Experts in Education Policy. Policy Advisory Systems
in Machiavellian country (case of Italy)” Giliberto Capano, Bologna
University, Italy, giliberto.capano@unibo.it
4. “Media Policy Making in current Russia: Administrative Competition
and Advisory Markets” Iliya Kiria, Higher School of Economics,
Russia, ikiria@hse.ru
Case presenters:
5. “Analysts in France as bureaucrats: opposing policy advisory system
framework” Philippe Zittoun, Science Po Lyon, France,
pzittoun@gmail.com
6. “Analytical communities in Russia and Kirgizia at National and
Local levels: Comparative analysis of Policy Impact" Anna Potsar,
potsar@gmail.com; Dmitry Zaytsev, Higher School of Economics,
Russia, zaycevdi2@gmail.com
7. “Role of Expert Community as one of Political Actors in Kyrgyzstan”
Baktykan Torogeldieva, Academy of Public Administration under the
President of the Kyrgyz Republic, baktoro_aukg@mail.ru
8. “The experience of civil experts` involving to preparing the Strategy
for Socio-Economic Development of the Yaroslavl region until 2025”
Alexander Sokolov, Demidov Yaroslavl State University, Russia,
alex8119@mail.ru
9. “Who governs? Analytical community and the political process of
development of Russian city strategy: case of Vladimir” Roman
Evstifeev, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and
Public Administration, Vladimir branch, roman_66@list.ru
10. “Measuring the State of the Political Advisory Systems” Mikhail
Mizulin, Irina Lozhnikova, Russian Academy of National Economy
and Public Administration under the President of the Russian
Federation, Russia, lozhnikova@yandex.ru
11. “Putting Inequality Issue at the Center of Russian Policy Agenda”
Sergey Kosaretsky
13h00 to 13h30
13h30 to 14h00
14h00 to 15h00
Q & A Session
Reaction to Presentations by Session Discussant
Lunch
3
15h00 to 19h00
15h00 – 15h30
15h30 to 15h45
15h45 to 16h00
16h30 to 17h00
17h00 to 18h30
EVENING SESSION :
CO-PRODUCTION OF POLICY ADVISE: BOUNDARY
ORGANIZATIONS, BOUNDARY WORK AND HYBRID
MANAGEMENT
 Moderator : Dmitry Zaitsev, Vice-Chair of HSE Public Policy Department
 Discussant : Giliberto Capano, Professor of Bologna University
Keynote speaker :
Robert Hoppe, Professor of Policy and Knowledge at University of
Twente, Netherlands, r.hoppe@utwente.nl
Q & A Session
Reaction to Presentations by Session Discussant
Coffee – Break
Paper presenters:
1. “Participatory Governance, Policy Communities, and the
Community Forest Movement in Nepal: Working the Boundary
Between Technical and Deliberative Expertise” Frank Fischer,
Rutgers University, USA, FrankFischer24@aol.com
2. “Experts and policy-making under uncertainty. The case of sweden’s
first multicultural provisions”. Manama Tawat, Cameroon
3. “The government, civil society and experts in Kyrgyzstan: has the
governmental decision making changed after April 2010?” Medet
Tiulegenov, American University of Central Asia, Kyrgyzstan,
tiulegenov@gmail.com
4. “Pathways to impact in local government: the mini-Stern review as
evidence in policy making in the Leeds City Region” Anna
Wesselink,
University
of
Twente,
Netherlands,
a.j.wesselink@utwente.nl
Case presenters:
5. “Searching for Ways to Better Assist the Victims of Human
Trafficking in Kazakhstan: The Role of Epistemic Communities,
Government and NGOs” Elena Maltseva, Nazarbayev University,
Kazakhstan, yelena.maltseva@nu.edu.kz
6. “Do intellectual communities need own media: case of Otkrytoe
mnenie” Vyacheslav Danilov, Moscow State University,
ivangog@mail.ru; Anna Potsar, Higher School of Economics, Russia,
potsar@gmail.com
7. “Civil initiative and policy advice in Russia” Artem Uldanov,
Higher School of Economics, Russia, art.uldanov@gmail.com
8. “Excluding independent analytical centers from policy advisory
system (case of police reform)” Vladimir Rimskiy, INDEM
Foundation, Russia, vlrim@yandex.ru
9. “Boundary organization and mediator structures: Russian
experience” Alexander Sungurov, Higher School of Economics,
Russia, asungurov@hse.spb.ru
10. “Boundaries of responsibilities participants of Strategic planning
process” Evgenia Ribina, Higher School of Economics, Russia,
ribina.evgenia@hse.ru
11. “Are transport infrastructure investments’ decision-making
4
18h30 to 18h45
18h45 to 19h00
19h00
comparable? A cross-countries study” Joseph Berechman, City
University of New York, USA, jberechman@ccny.cuny.edu
12. “Collaborative destination marketing planning: A case study of 2014
Sochi Olympic Games” Marina Predvoditeleva, Hyunjeong Han,
Anastasiia Salina, Higher School of Economics, Russia,
anastasia.salina@gmail.com
13. “Knowledge about the Internet as policy factor” Polina Kolozaridi,
Higher School of Economics, Russia, poli.kolozaridi@gmail.com
Q & A Session
Reaction to Presentations by Session Discussant
Dinner for Speakers & Presenters (HSE Campus, Professors Club)
5