ARTIFICIAL SATELLITES, Journal of Planetary Geodesy
THE CHECKLIST FOR REVIEWERS
The author(s) and the paper’s title:
The reviewer:
The checklist below will help the editor in the evaluation of the material submitted for
publication:
yes
no
1. Does the paper significantly contribute to the progress
in the field of concern?
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
2. Is the paper correct, is it written logically and clearly?
3. Do the title and abstract correctly express the contents of the paper?
4. Did you do any correction or remark on the enclosed text of the paper?
5. Do you recommend publication of this paper in the present form?
6. Do you recommend publication of this paper after revision?
7. Do you recommend repeating the review procedure after revision?
8. Do you recommend outright rejection?
9. Do you agree to disclose your name?
Please attach your additional comments and remarks on a separate, unsigned sheet of paper.
.................
....................
Date
Signature