CHAPTER 17 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT CHAPTER 17 QUIZ CHAPTER ORGANIZATION The basic objective in cash management is to keep the investment in cash as low as possible while still operating the firm's activities efficiently and effectively. This goal usually reduces to the dictum “Collect early and pay late.” Accordingly, we discuss ways of accelerating collections and managing disbursements. In addition, firms must invest temporarily idle cash in short-term marketable securities. These securities can be bought and sold in the financial markets. As a group, they have very little default risk, and most are highly liquid. 17.1 Float and Cash Management Reasons for Holding Cash Speculative motive - The need to hold cash in order to be able to take advantage of, for example, bargain purchase opportunities that might arise, attractive interest rates, and (in the case of international firms) favorable exchange rate fluctuations. Precautionary motive - The need to hold cash as a safety margin to act as a financial reserve. is the need for a safety supply to act as a financial reserve. Transaction motive - The need to have cash on hand to pay bills. Transaction-related needs come from the normal disbursement and collection activities of the firm. The opportunity cost of holding cash is the return that could be earned by investing the cash in other assets. However, there is also a cost to convert between cash and other assets. The optimal cash balance will balance these costs to minimize the overall cost of holding cash. Understanding Float - The difference between the available balance and the ledger balance is called the float, and it represents the net effect of checks in the process of clearing (moving through the banking system). Book balance – the amount of cash recorded in the accounting records of the firm Available balance – the amount of cash the bank says is available to be withdrawn from the account (may not be the same as the amount of checks deposited minus amount of checks paid, because deposits are not normally available immediately) Prepared by Jim Keys 1 Float = Available balance – book balance Negative float implies that checks have been deposited that are not yet available. The firm needs to be careful that it does not write checks over the available balance, or the checks may bounce. Positive float implies that checks have been written that have not yet cleared. The company needs to make be sure to adjust the available balance so it does not think that there is more money to spend than there actually is. Disbursement float – generated by checks the firm has written that have not yet cleared the bank; arrangements can be made so that this money is invested in marketable securities until needed. Collection float – generated by checks that have been received by the firm but are not yet included in the available balance at the bank Have you ever written a check a day or two before receiving your paycheck, even though on the day you mailed the check, your checking account had insufficient funds to cover it? This is an example of using disbursement float. We recognize that the time for the check to travel through the mail and then be processed and cleared, should allow enough time for the paycheck to clear our bank. We do need to be careful about this process, however. The check we wrote may go through the system faster than anticipated and it may take the paycheck longer to become available than anticipated. In this case, our check may bounce or at the very least our credit line will be tapped and we end up paying some unexpected interest charges. Float management involves controlling the collection and disbursement of cash. The objective in cash collection is to speed up collections and reduce the lag between the time customers pay their bills and the time the cash becomes available. The objective in cash disbursement is to control payments and minimize the firm's costs associated with making payments. Managers need to be more concerned with net float and available balances than with the book balance. Total collection or disbursement times can be broken down into three parts: mailing time, processing delay, and availability delay: o Mailing time is the part of the collection and disbursement process during which checks are trapped in the postal system. o Processing delay is the time it takes the receiver of a check to process the payment and deposit it in a bank for collection. o Availability delay refers to the time required to clear a check through the banking system. The Institutional Investor (September 1985) provides a lengthy discussion of legal and ethical questions surrounding cash management. The article, “Cash management: Where do you draw the line,” by Barbara Donnelly, focuses on the E.F. Hutton check kiting scandal. In retrospect, it is clear that the value of lost reputation far exceeded the savings gained via the company’s cash management strategies. The Expedited Funds Availability Act (EFAA) governs the availability of funds deposited by firms. The following rules apply (based on US Code: Title 12 Section 4002 as of January 23, 2000): Cash or electronic payment and government checks are available the day after deposit. Local checks are available two days after deposit. Non-local checks are available five days after deposit. Prepared by Jim Keys 2 Note that these rules indicate the maximum time for availability. A bank may make funds available sooner. Also, deposits made at ATMs can have a different schedule due to the processing time required. Electronic Data Interchange and Check 21: The End of Float? 17.2 Cash Management: Collection, Disbursement, and Investment Cash Collection and Concentration Collection Time = mailing time + processing delay + availability delay Cash collection policies depend on the nature of the business. Firms can choose to have checks mailed to one location, or many locations (reduces mailing time), or allow preauthorized payments. Many firms also accept online payments either with a credit card or with authorization to request the funds directly from your bank. Prepared by Jim Keys 3 Lockboxes are special post office boxes that allow banks to process the incoming checks and then send the information on account payment to the firm; that reduces processing time and often reduces mail time because several regional lockboxes can be used. Prepared by Jim Keys 4 Cash concentration is the practice of moving cash from multiple banks into the firm’s main accounts. This is a common practice that is used in conjunction with lockboxes. Managing Cash Disbursements Increasing disbursement float – slowing payments by increasing mail delay, processing time, or collection time. May not want to do this from both an ethical standpoint and a valuation standpoint. Slowing payment could cause a company to forgo discounts on its accounts payable. As we will see later in the chapter, the cost of forgoing discounts can be extremely high. We make a point to emphasize the importance of ethical behavior in this area of cash management. Because transactions occur frequently and in large amounts, unscrupulous financial managers tend to “cut corners” in this area more often than in some others. Some corporations routinely pay late, or take discounts that have not been offered. This hurts the suppliers that the company does business with and may ultimately hurt the company through a loss of reputation or credit. Controlling disbursements – minimize liquidity needs by keeping a tight rein on disbursements through any ethical means possible. Zero-balance accounts – maintain several sub-accounts at regional banks and one master account. Funds are transferred from the master account when checks are presented for payment at one of the regional accounts. This reduces the firm’s liquidity needs. Prepared by Jim Keys 5 Controlled disbursement accounts – the firm is notified on a daily basis how much cash is required to meet that day’s disbursements and the firm wires the necessary funds. Investing Idle Cash If a firm has a temporary cash surplus, it can invest in short-term securities. As we have mentioned at various times, the market for short-term financial assets is called the money market. The maturity of short-term financial assets that trade in the money market is one year or less. Firms have temporary cash surpluses for various reasons. Two of the most important are the financing of seasonal or cyclical activities of the firm and the financing of planned or possible expenditures. Characteristics of Short-Term Securities - Given that a firm has some temporarily idle cash, there are a variety of short-term securities available for investing. The most important characteristics of these short-term marketable securities are their maturity, default risk, marketability, and taxability. o Maturity refers to the time period over which interest and principal payments are made. We know that for a given change in the level of interest rates, the prices of longer-maturity securities will change more than those of shorter-maturity securities. As a consequence, firms often limit their investments in marketable securities to those maturing in less than 90 days to avoid the risk of losses in value from changing interest rates. Prepared by Jim Keys 6 o Default risk refers to the probability that interest and principal will not be paid in the promised amounts on the due dates (or not paid at all). Of course, some securities have negligible default risk, such as U.S. Treasury bills. Given the purposes of investing idle corporate cash, firms typically avoid investing in marketable securities with significant default risk. o Marketability refers to how easy it is to convert an asset to cash; so, marketability and liquidity mean much the same thing. Some money market instruments are much more marketable than others. At the top of the list are U.S. Treasury bills, which can be bought and sold very cheaply and very quickly. “Marketability” suggests that large amounts of an asset can be bought or sold quickly with little effect on the current market price. This characteristic is usually associated with financial markets that are “broad” and “deep.” Broad markets have a large number of participants; deep markets have participants that are willing and able to engage in large transactions. The market for U.S. T-bills epitomizes these characteristics. There are millions of potential buyers and sellers world-wide and multi-million dollar transactions are common. o Taxability - Interest earned on money market securities that are not some kind of government obligation (either federal or state) is taxable at the local, state, and federal levels. U.S. Treasury obligations such as T-bills are exempt from state taxation, but other government-backed debt is not. Municipal securities are exempt from federal taxes, but they may be taxed at the state level. 17.3 Credit and Receivables - When credit is granted, an account receivable is created. These receivables include credit to other firms, called trade credit, and credit granted consumers, called consumer credit, and they represent a major investment of financial resources by U.S. businesses. Furthermore, trade credit is a very important source of financing for corporations. Components of Credit Policy - If a firm decides to grant credit to its customers, then it must establish procedures for extending credit and collecting. In particular, the firm will have to deal with the following components of credit policy: 1. Terms of sale. The terms of sale establish how the firm proposes to sell its goods and services. If the firm grants credit to a customer, the terms of sale will specify (perhaps implicitly) the credit period, the cash discount and discount period, and the type of credit instrument. 2. Credit analysis. In granting credit, a firm determines how much effort to expend trying to distinguish between customers who will pay and customers who will not pay. Firms use a number of devices and procedures to determine the probability that customers will not pay, and, put together, these are called credit analysis. 3. Collection policy. After credit has been granted, the firm has the potential problem of collecting the cash when it becomes due, for which it must establish a collection policy. Terms of the Sale Credit period – amount of time allowed for payment; Cash discount and discount period – percent of discount allowed if payment is made during the discount period; Type of credit instrument Basic form: 2/10 net 60 means 2% discount if paid in 10 days; total amount is due in 60 days if the discount is not taken. In this example, the 60 days is the net credit period, the 10 days is the discount period and the 2% is the cash discount amount. Prepared by Jim Keys 7 The invoice date is the date for which the credit period starts. This is normally the shipping date, but some companies may post-date the invoice to encourage customers to order early. Length of the credit period depends on: -Buyer’s inventory and credit cycle -Perishability and collateral value -Consumer demand -Cost, profitability, and standardization -Credit risk -Size of the account -Competition -Customer type Cash discounts – offered by sellers to induce early payment. Not taking the discount involves a cost of credit for the purchaser. Cost of credit – the cost of not taking discounts offered (this is a benefit to the company granting credit) Periodic rate = (discount %) / (100% – discount %) Number of periods per year = m = 365 / (net credit period – discount period) APR = m x (periodic rate) EAR = (1 + periodic rate)m – 1 Example: Consider terms of 1/15, net 45 (assume payment is made on time in 45 days when the discount is forgone) Periodic rate = 1 / (100 – 1) = 1 / 99 = .0101 Number of periods per year = m = 365 / (45 – 15) = 12.166667 APR = 12.166667(.0101) = 12.288% EAR = (1 + .0101)12.166667 – 1 = (1.0101)12.166667 – 1 = .130055 = 13.01% Offering discounts generally reduces the average collection period and thus the cash cycle. This reduces the amount of financing required, but the company loses sales in the amount of the discount taken. Consequently, the firm needs to look at the size and timing of the expected cash flows to determine what, if any, discount should be offered. Credit instruments – the basic evidence of indebtedness o Open account – invoice only o Promissory note – basic IOU, may be used when the order is large or the purchasing firm has a history of late payments o Commercial draft – request for funds sent directly to the purchaser’s bank o Sight draft – payable immediately o Time draft – payment required by some future date o Trade acceptance – buyer accepts draft with agreement to pay in the future o Bankers’ acceptance – bank accepts draft and guarantees payment Prepared by Jim Keys 8 Various investments have been developed to shift the risk of non-payment of receivables in international transactions from the seller to a financial institution. For example, a banker’s acceptance is an irrevocable letter of credit issued by a bank guaranteeing payment of the face amount. A letter of credit is simply a promise from the buyer’s bank to make payment upon receipt of the goods by the buyer. While these guarantee arrangements add to the cost of doing business, their existence greatly facilitates international trade. Optimal Credit Policy - An optimal credit policy is one in which the incremental cash flows from sales are equal to the incremental costs of carrying the increased investment in accounts receivable. The cost of granting credit is described by the total credit cost curve, which depicts the trade-off between two kinds of costs: Carrying costs – required return on receivables, losses from bad debts, costs of managing credit and collections Opportunity costs – potential profit from credit sales that is lost Credit Analysis - Once a firm decides to grant credit to its customers, it must then establish guidelines for determining who will and who will not be allowed to buy on credit. Credit analysis refers to the process of deciding whether or not to extend credit to a particular customer. It usually involves two steps: gathering relevant information and determining creditworthiness. Information sources commonly used to assess creditworthiness include the following: 1. Financial statements. A firm can ask a customer to supply financial statements such as balance sheets and income statements. Minimum standards and rules of thumb based on financial ratios can then be used as a basis for extending or refusing credit. 2. Credit reports on the customer's payment history with other firms. Quite a few organizations sell information on the credit strength and credit history of business firms. The best-known and largest firm of this type is Dun & Bradstreet, which provides subscribers with a credit reference book and credit reports on individual firms. Experian (formerly TRW) is another well-known credit-reporting firm. Ratings and information are available for a huge number of firms, including very small ones. Equifax, Trans Union, and Experian are the major suppliers of consumer credit information. 3. Banks. Banks will generally provide some assistance to their business customers in acquiring information on the creditworthiness of other firms. Prepared by Jim Keys 9 4. The customer's payment history with the firm. The most obvious way to obtain information about the likelihood of a customer's not paying is to examine whether they have settled past obligations and how quickly they have met these obligations. There are no magical formulas for assessing the probability that a customer will not pay. In very general terms, the classic five C’s of credit are the basic factors to be evaluated: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Character. The customer's willingness to meet credit obligations. Capacity. The customer's ability to meet credit obligations out of operating cash flows. Capital. The customer's financial reserves. Collateral. Assets pledged by the customer for security in case of default. Conditions. General economic conditions in the customer's line of business. Credit scoring – assigning a numerical rating to customers based on credit history. Credit scoring models were initially introduced in the 1940s and became widespread in the 1960s. Companies that use scoring models need to use great care to make sure that the factors that determine the credit score do not depend on race, gender, geographic location, or any other criteria that could be considered discriminatory. Failure to take the proper precautions is not only unethical; it can lead to substantial legal problems, customer ill will, and lost sales. Collection Policy - Collection policy involves monitoring receivables to spot trouble and obtaining payment on past-due accounts. Monitoring Receivables To keep track of payments by customers, most firms will monitor outstanding accounts. First, a firm will normally keep track of its average collection period, ACP, through time. If a firm is in a seasonal business, the ACP will fluctuate during the year, but unexpected increases in the ACP are a cause for concern. Either customers in general are taking longer to pay, or some percentage of accounts receivable is seriously overdue. The aging schedule is a second basic tool for monitoring receivables. To prepare one, the credit department classifies accounts by age. Suppose a firm has $100,000 in receivables. Some of these accounts are only a few days old, but others have been outstanding for quite some time. The following is an example of an aging schedule: Collection Effort A firm usually goes through the following sequence of procedures for customers whose payments are overdue: 1. It sends out a delinquency letter informing the customer of the past-due status of the account. 2. It makes a telephone call to the customer. Prepared by Jim Keys 10 3. It employs a collection agency. 4. It takes legal action against the customer. 17.4 Inventory Management The Financial Manager and Inventory Policy Despite the size of a typical firm's investment in inventories, the financial manager of a firm will not normally have primary control over inventory management. Instead, other functional areas such as purchasing, production, and marketing will usually share decision-making authority. Inventory management has become an increasingly important specialty in its own right, and financial management will often only have input into the decision. Financial managers see the results of inventory decisions in many places – ROA, inventory turnover, and Days’ Sales in Inventory ratios, to name a few. Inventory Types For a manufacturer, inventory is classified into one of three categories: - Raw materials - Work-in-progress - Finished goods Classification into one of these categories depends on the firm’s business; raw materials for one firm may be finished goods for another. Inventory types have different levels of liquidity. Demand for raw materials and work-in-progress depends on the demand for finished goods Inventory Costs There are two basic types of costs associated with current assets in general and with inventory in particular. The first of these are carrying costs. Here, carrying costs represent all of the direct and opportunity costs of keeping inventory on hand. These include: - Storage and tracking costs. - Insurance and taxes. - Losses due to obsolescence, deterioration, or theft. - The opportunity cost of capital for the invested amount. The sum of these costs can be substantial, roughly ranging from 20 to 40 percent of inventory value per year. The other types of costs associated with inventory are shortage costs. These are costs associated with having inadequate inventory on hand. The two components of shortage costs are restocking costs and costs related to safety reserves. Depending on the firm's business, order or restocking costs are either the costs of placing an order with suppliers or the cost of setting up a production run. The costs related to safety reserves are opportunity losses such as lost sales and loss of customer goodwill that result from having inadequate inventory. A basic trade-off in inventory management exists because carrying costs increase with inventory levels while shortage or restocking costs decline with inventory levels. The basic goal of inventory management is thus to minimize the sum of these two costs. Prepared by Jim Keys 11 17.5 Inventory Management Techniques The ABC Approach is a simple approach to inventory management where the basic idea is to divide inventory into three (or more) groups. The underlying rationale is that a small portion of inventory in terms of quantity might represent a large portion in terms of inventory value, and this group would be monitored closely. The Economic Order Quantity Model EOQ – the restocking quantity that minimizes total inventory costs based on the assumption that inventory is depleted at a steady pace. Total carrying costs = (average inventory)(carrying cost per unit) = (Q/2)(CC) Total restocking costs = (fixed cost per order)(number of orders) = F(T/Q) Prepared by Jim Keys 12 Total costs = carrying costs + restocking costs = (Q/2)(CC) + F(T/Q) EOQ 2TF CC The EOQ is the point where the total carrying costs equal the total restocking costs. This is the quantity that minimizes the cost function and can be found by taking the first derivative, setting it equal to zero, and solving for Q. The Trektronics store begins each month with 900 phasers in stock. This stock is depleted each month and reordered. If the carrying cost per phaser is $38 per year and the fixed order cost is $530, what is the total carrying cost? What is the restocking cost? Should the company increase or decrease its order size? Describe an optimal inventory policy for the company in terms of order size and order frequency. The carrying costs are the average inventory times the cost of carrying an individual unit, so: Carrying costs = (900/2)($38) = (450)($38) = $17,100 The economic order quantity is: EOQ = [(2T × F)/CC]1/2 EOQ = [2(12)(900)($530)/$38]1/2 EOQ = 548.87 phasers The order costs are the number of orders times the cost of an order, so: Restocking costs = 12($530) = $6,360 Prepared by Jim Keys 13 The optimal number of orders per year will be the total units sold per year divided by the EOQ, so: Number of orders per year = 12(900) / 548.87 = 10,800 / 548.87 = 19.68 The firm’s policy is not optimal, since the carrying costs and the order costs are not equal. The company should decrease the order size and increase the number of orders. Extensions to the EOQ Model Up to this point we have assumed that a company will let its inventory run down to zero and then reorder. In reality, a company will wish to reorder before its inventory goes to zero for two reasons. First, by always having at least some inventory on hand, the firm minimizes the risk of a stockout and the resulting losses of sales and customers. Second, when a firm does reorder, there will be some time lag before the inventory arrives. Safety stocks – minimum level of inventory that must be kept on hand. If a firm carries safety stock, then inventory won’t actually reach zero and the carrying cost component will be higher than what is predicted by the EOQ model. Reorder points – place orders before inventory reaches a critical level. Designed to account for delivery time. Prepared by Jim Keys 14 Managing Derived-Demand Inventories - Demand for some inventory types is derived from, or dependent on, other inventory needs. Materials requirements planning (MRP) and just-in-time inventory (JIT) management are two methods for managing demand-dependent inventories. Summary and Conclusions This chapter has covered cash, receivables, and inventory management. Along the way, we have touched on a large number of subjects. Some of the more important issues we examined are: 1. Firms seek to manage their cash by keeping no more than is needed on hand. The reason is that holding cash has an opportunity cost, namely, the returns that could be earned by investing the money. 2. Float is an important consideration in cash management, and firms seek to manage collections and disbursements in ways designed to optimize the firm's net float. 3. A firm's credit policy includes the terms of sale, credit analysis, and collection policy. The terms of sale cover three related subjects: the credit period, cash discount, and credit instrument. 4. The optimal credit policy for a firm depends on many specific factors, but generally involves trading off the costs of granting credit, such as the carrying costs of receivables and the possibility of nonpayment, against the benefits in terms of increased sales. 5. There are different types of inventories that differ greatly in their liquidity and management. The basic trade-off in inventory management is the cost of carrying inventory versus the cost of restocking. We developed the famous EOQ model, which explicitly balances these costs. 6. Firms use different inventory management techniques; we described a few of the better known, including the ABC approach and just-in-time, or JIT, inventory management. Link to Sample Exam questions: https://www.eztestonline.com/190704/13524091042391100.tp4 Prepared by Jim Keys 15