Earthquakes 11 Earthquakes begins with a discussion of earthquakes, faults, and origination of earthquakes including elastic rebound. Following a detailed look at the San Andreas Fault, seismology is introduced with a presentation of the types of seismic waves, their propagation, and how they appear on a typical seismic traces. This is followed by a discussion of earthquake epicenters – how they are located and their worldwide distribution. Earthquake intensity and magnitude are also explained. The destruction caused by seismic vibrations and their associated perils introduces a discussion of earthquake prediction. The chapter closes with an examination of whether earthquakes can be predicted and the use of earthquakes as evidence for plate tectonics. Learning Objectives After reading, studying, and discussing the chapter, students should be able to: Explain the origin of earthquakes, including their relationship to faults. Briefly discuss elastic rebound and the accumulation of strain in rocks. Discuss seismology, including the characteristics and recording of earthquake waves. Explain how to locate the source of an earthquake. Compare and contrast shallow- versus deep-focus earthquakes. Discuss the measurement of earthquake intensity and magnitude. Explain the use and limitations of the modified Mercalli Intensity scale. Compare and contrast earthquake magnitude measurements using the Richter scale with the newer concept of moment magnitude. Discuss the various aspects of earthquake destruction, including some of the factors that determine the extent of damage produced by a given earthquake. Explain earthquake prediction in terms of both short-range and long-range forecasting. Understand the occurrence of earthquakes in relation to tectonic plate boundaries. Chapter Outline___________________________________________________________________ I. What is an earthquake? A. An earthquake is the vibration of Earth produced by the rapid release of energy 1. Energy released radiates in all directions from its source, the focus 2. Energy is in the form of waves 3. Sensitive instruments around the world record the event B. Earthquakes and faults 1. Movements that produce earthquakes are usually associated with large fractures in Earth’s crust called faults 2. Most of motion along faults can be explained by the plate tectonics theory C. Elastic rebound 1. Mechanism for earthquakes was first explained by H.F. Reid 89 90 CHAPTER 11 a. D. Rocks on both sides of an existing fault are deformed by tectonic forces b. Rocks bend and store elastic energy c. Frictional resistance holding the rocks together is overcome d. Slippage at the weakest point (the focus) occurs e. Earthquakes occur as the deformed rock “springs back” to its original shape (elastic rebound) f. Earthquakes most often occur along existing faults whenever the frictional forces on the fault surfaces are overcome Foreshocks and aftershocks 1. 2. II. Adjustments that follow a major earthquake often generate smaller earthquakes called aftershocks Small earthquakes, called foreshocks, often precede a major earthquake by days or, in some cases, by as much as several years San Andreas Fault: an active earthquake zone A. San Andreas is the most studied fault system in the world B. Displacement occurs along discrete segments 100 to 200 kilometers long 1. Some portions exhibit slow, gradual displacement known as fault creep 2. Other segments regularly slip producing small earthquakes 3. Still other segments store elastic energy for hundreds of years before rupturing in great earthquakes a. Process described as stick-slip motion b. Great earthquakes should occur about every 50 to 200 years along these sections III. Seismology A. The study of earthquake waves, seismology, dates back almost 2000 years to the Chinese B. Seismographs, instruments that record seismic waves 1. Records the movement of Earth in relation to a stationary mass on a rotating drum or magnetic tape 2. More than one type of seismograph is needed to record both vertical and horizontal ground motion 3. Records obtained are called seismographs C. Types of seismic waves 1. Surface waves a. Travel along outer part of Earth b. Complex motion c. Cause greatest destruction d. Waves exhibit greatest amplitude and slowest velocity e. Waves have the greatest periods (time interval between crests) f. Often referred to as long waves, or L waves 2. Body waves a. Travel through Earth’s interior b. Two types based on mode of travel 1. Primary (P) waves a. Push-pull (compress and expand) motion, changing the volume of the intervening material b. Travel through 1. Solids 2. Liquids 3. Gases c. Generally, in any solid material, P waves travel about 1.7 times faster than S waves 2. Secondary (S) waves a. "Shake" motion at right angles to their direction of travel Earthquakes b. c. d. e. IV. Temporarily change the shape of the material that transmits them Travel only through solids Slower velocity than P waves Slightly greater amplitude than P waves Locating the source of earthquakes A. Terms 1. Focus – the place within Earth where earthquake waves originate 2. Epicenter – location on the surface directly above the focus B. Epicenter is located using the difference in velocities of P and S waves 1. Three station recordings are needed to locate an epicenter 2. Each station determines the time interval between the arrival of the first P wave and the first S wave at their location 3. A travel-time graph is used to determine each station’s distance to the epicenter 4. A circle with a radius equal to the distance to the epicenter is drawn around each station 5. The point where all three circles intersect is the earthquake epicenter C. Earthquake belts 1. About 95 percent of the energy released by earthquakes originates in a few relatively narrow zones that wind around the globe 2. Major earthquake zones include the a. Circum-Pacific belt b. Mediterranean Sea region, through Iran, and on past the Himalayan complex c. Oceanic ridge system D. Earthquake depths 91 1. Earthquakes originate at depths ranging from 5 to nearly 700 kilometers 2. Earthquake foci arbitrarily classified as a. Shallow – within 70 kilometers of the surface b. Intermediate – between 70 and 300 kilometers c. Deep – greater than 300 kilometers 3. Definite patterns exist a. Shallow focus occur along the oceanic ridge system b. Almost all deep-focus earthquakes occur in the circum-Pacific belt, particularly in regions situated landward of deep-ocean trenches 1. In the Tonga trench region, foci depths increase with distance from the trench 2. Called Wadati-Benioff zones V. Measuring the size of earthquakes A. Two measurements that describe the size of an earthquake are 1. Intensity – a measure of the degree of earthquake shaking at a given locale based on the amount of damage 2. Magnitude – estimates the amount of energy released at the source of the earthquake B. Intensity scales 1. Modified Mercalli Intensity Scale was developed using California buildings as its standard 2. The drawback of intensity scales is that destruction may not be a true measure of the earthquakes actual severity C. Magnitude scales 1. Richter magnitude a. Concept introduced by Charles Richter in 1935 b. Richter scale 1. 92 Based on the amplitude of the largest seismic wave recorded Accounts for the decrease in wave amplitude with increased distance CHAPTER 11 3. Largest magnitude recorded on a Wood-Anderson seismograph was 8.9 4. Magnitudes less than 2.0 are not felt by humans 5. Each unit of Richter magnitude increase corresponds to a. A tenfold increase in wave amplitude b. About a 32-fold energy increase 2. Other magnitude scales a. Several “Richter-like” magnitude scales have been developed b. Moment magnitude 1. Developed because none of the “Richter-like” magnitude scales adequately estimates the size of very large earthquakes 2. Derived from the amount of displacement that occurs along a fault 3. Calculated using a. Average amount of displacement along the fault b. Area of the rupture surface c. Shear strength of the faulted block 4. Has gained wide acceptance among seismologists and engineers VI. 2. Earthquake destruction A. Amount of structural damage attributable to earthquake vibrations depends on 1. Intensity and 2. Duration of the vibrations 3. Nature of the material upon which the structure rests 4. Design of the structure B. Destruction from seismic vibrations 1. Ground shaking a. Regions within 20 to 50 kilometers of the epicenter will experience about the same intensity of ground shaking b. However, destruction varies considerably mainly due to the nature of the ground on which the structures are built 1. Soft sediments generally amplify vibrations more than solid bedrock 2. Regions farther from the epicenter may experience more damage than near locations because of amplified ground motion attributed to soft sediments 2. Liquefaction of the ground a. Unconsolidated materials saturated with water turn into a mobile fluid b. Underground objects may float toward the surface 3. Seiches a. The rhythmic sloshing of water in lakes, reservoirs, and enclosed basins b. Waves can weaken reservoir walls and cause destruction C. Tsunamis, or seismic sea waves 1. Destructive waves that are often inappropriately called “tidal waves” 2. Result from a. Vertical displacement along a fault located on the ocean floor or b. From a large undersea landslide triggered by an earthquake 3. In the open ocean, height is usually less than 1 meter 4. In shallower coastal waters the water piles up to heights that occasionally exceed 30 meters 5. Can be very destructive D. E. Landslides and ground subsidence Fire VII. Can earthquakes be predicted? A. Short-range predictions Earthquakes 1. Goal is to provide a warning of the location and magnitude of a large earthquake within a narrow time frame 2. Research has concentrated on monitoring possible precursors – phenomena that precede a forthcoming earthquake such as measuring a. Uplift b. Subsidence c. Strain in the rocks 3. Currently, no reliable method exists for making short-range earthquake predictions B. Long-range forecasts 1. Give the probability of a certain magnitude earthquake occurring on a time scale of 30 to 100 years, or more 93 2. Based on the premise that earthquakes are repetitive or cyclical a. Using historical records or b. Paleoseismology 3. Are important because they provide information used to a. Develop the Uniform Building Code and b. Assist in land-use planning VIII. Earthquakes: Evidence for plate tectonics A. A good fit exists between the plate tectonics model and the global distribution of earthquakes B. The connection of deep-focus earthquakes and oceanic trenches is further evidence C. Only shallow-focus earthquakes occur along divergent and transform fault boundaries Answers to the Review Questions 1. An earthquake is ground shaking caused by a sudden cracking and rupturing of highly strained rock and quick, lateral and/or vertical movements of the blocks on either side of the rupture surface. Failure occurs when the cumulative strains finally exceed the internal, cohesive bonds that hold the rock together. Failure (rupture and block movements) is catastrophic, usually taking only a few tens of seconds to a minute, and a high percentage of the strain energy is converted to ground vibrations. Following the earthquake, strain begins gradually building again toward a future quake. 2. A fault is the plane or zone of fracture separating two blocks that are abruptly displaced during an earthquake. The focus is the point at depth, usually in a fault zone, where the displacement and sudden release of elastic energy initiate. It marks the initial rupture site associated with the earthquake. The epicenter is the point on the surface directly above the focus. These relationships are nicely shown in Figure 11.2. 3. H. F. Reid, a professor at Johns Hopkins University, based his elastic rebound idea on studies of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake. 4. Reid concluded that the quake was due to excess, elastic strain energy being suddenly (catastrophically) released as the highly overstrained rocks snapped back (rebounded) to a state of much lower strain. Cool lithospheric rocks have elastic limits large enough to support earthquake-causing, elastic strains. Hence, most earthquakes originate in the lithosphere. Because they are much warmer, asthenospheric rocks begin deforming by flowage (plastic deformation) at much lower stress magnitudes. Therefore, any stored, elastic strain energies in the asthenosphere are too small in magnitude to produce a strong earthquake. 94 CHAPTER 11 5. Creep movements should reduce the likelihood of an earthquake by reducing the level of strain accumulated in the fault-zone rocks. A fault without creep may reflect two fundamentally different conditions. First, the stresses may be too small to move the blocks and there is no accumulation of elastic strain. In this case the fault is clearly inactive. In the other case, the fault is active but locked; the blocks cannot respond to tectonic stresses by moving so elastic strain accumulates. A locked fault has a high probability for hosting a damaging future quake and such areas, known as seismic gaps, are of special interest in earthquake forecasting. 6. A seismograph produces scaled and timed records of ground motion, ground velocity, and ground acceleration that result from earthquake (seismic) waves moving through the instrument site. The sensing part of the instrument is usually placed underground in a rigid, concrete vault. The rigid structure vibrates in concert with the passing seismic waves and ground motions (displacement, velocity, and acceleration) are sensed by optical or electromagnetic sensors set in motion by the seismic vibrations. These variations are converted to electrical signals, amplified, and recorded as a function of time, giving an accurate record of the seismic wave patterns. 7. P waves (primary or compressional waves) travel though matter as particle vibrations along lines parallel to the ray path or to the path traced by a point traveling with the wave front. P waves move through solids, liquids, and gases, the “vibrations” being in the form of “push-pull” waves. S waves (secondary or shear waves) move by particle vibrations at right angles to the ray path and they are transmitted only by solids, not by liquids or gases. Also, P waves always travel faster than S waves in a given material. 8. Compressional waves (P waves) are transmitted through solids and fluids because the transmitting material need not have any shear strength. S waves are shear waves and can propagate only in materials with a finite, shear strength. Thus S waves are transmitted only by solids, not by liquids and gases. 9. Surface waves have much higher amplitudes than body waves (P and S waves) and account for nearly all of the dangerous ground displacements and accelerations associated with earthquakes. The horizontally vibrating surface waves generally present more danger to buildings and other structures than surface waves with vertical motion. Closer to the epicenter of a shallow-focus quake, the various waves more or less arrive at the same time giving a cumulative effect to the first strong ground motions. 10. The travel time versus distance curves for P and S waves are shown in the figure. To answer the question, you must find the point on the distance axis that corresponds to a difference in arrival times between the P and S waves of 3 minutes. On tracing paper make a line whose length is equal to a time interval of 3 minutes (0 to 3 minutes, 3 to 6 minutes, etc.) on the vertical or time axis. Then move the line onto the graph and find the distance on the horizontal axis where the time interval between the first P and S arrivals is 3 minutes. The correct distance is about 1900 kilometers. 11. This is the circum-Pacific belt. The earthquakes here are associated with active subduction zones around the rim of the Pacific Ocean (Fig. 11.13) where the oceanic crust is sinking into the mantle beneath island arcs or continental margins. 12. Deep-focus quakes occur below oceanic trenches and, like the trenches, are directly associated with subducting slabs of oceanic lithosphere. With increasing depth, the intermediate and deep-focus epicenters migrate farther toward the interior of the upper plate in correspondence to the dip of the Earthquakes 95 subduction zone. The earthquakes are thought to occur in the sunken oceanic plate. Long after sinking into the mantle, interior parts of the slab stay cool enough to maintain some rigidity and the minerals present may be “destabilized” and subjected to very fast phase changes. Mantle rocks surrounding the slab are too plastic to accumulate elastic strain energy and mineral phases there are more or less in equilibrium with respect to temperatures and pressures at those depths. Thus deep-focus earthquakes are associated only with subduction zones. 13. The Richter earthquake-magnitude scale is based on standardized measurements of ground vibration amplitudes and the total energy released during the earthquake. It is a logarithmic numerical scale and a theoretical consideration of rock strength suggests that 9 is about the highest magnitude possible. The Richter scale is quantitative because magnitudes are based on measured wave amplitudes and a physically valid relationship between amplitude and wave energy. The Mercalli earthquake-intensity scale is based on visual observations. It gives an estimate of the ground shaking intensity in terms of human perceptions, eyewitness accounts, and damage to buildings or other property. As such, it is a subjective scale and the ratings are strongly dependent on local site characteristics such as foundation stability and building design. The scale (from I to XII) utilizes Roman numerals. 14. For each increase of one on the Richter scale, wave amplitude increases (10) times. 15. An earthquake measuring 7 on the Richter scale releases about (30) times more energy than an earthquake with a magnitude of 6. 16. Moment magnitude has gained popularity among seismologists because: (1) it is the only magnitude scale that correctly estimates the size of very large earthquakes; (2) it is determined by the size of the rupture surface and the amount of displacement, thus it is a better reflection of the total energy released during a quake; and (3) it can be verified by both field studies (measurement of fault displacements) and by seismographic methods. 17. Many factors can be noted, particularly the amplitude of the ground displacement or acceleration, the length of time that shaking occurs, and the character of the ground shaking. In general, vertical ground motion is not so dangerous as lateral or horizontal shaking, and short period (high-frequency) vibrations are less dangerous than longer period vibrations. Stability of the foundation material, building design, and construction quality are also important factors. 18. Weak foundation material and poor building design both contributed to the unusually severe damage at a site over 200 miles from the epicenter. The city is built on old lakebeds and marshlands known to have existed when Cortez and the Spaniards were there early in the sixteenth century. Soft, unconsolidated, water-saturated sediments are extremely unstable with respect to vibrations; and ground shaking is greatly intensified over that in underlying solid rock. In the Mexico City case, intensified shaking caused slides, slumps, and liquefaction, leading to numerous foundation failures. 19. Two factors account for the greater loss of life from the Armenian earthquake. First, the damaged cities in Armenia were densely populated and very near the epicenter. Secondly, most people lived in large, multifamily, concrete slab apartment buildings that collapsed or were heavily damaged. A 5.8 magnitude aftershock finished off many of the damaged or weakened buildings. Although the Northridge, California 96 CHAPTER 11 earthquake was larger in terms of moment magnitude, poor construction practices in Armenia resulted in a much higher number of deaths. 20. Fires, such as those that followed the 1906 San Francisco quake, and secondary effects such as landslides, dam failures, and tsunamis can be more dangerous than the ground shaking. Damaged utilities, water and sewer systems, and waste disposal systems leave an earthquake-ravaged area without reliable communications and electricity and vulnerable to serious public health problems. In addition, hazardous materials, toxic chemicals, and radioactive substances may be released from broken pipelines, damaged storage facilities, and in truck and train accidents. 21. Tsunami are very long period, long wavelength surface waves in the oceans generated by sudden displacement of large volumes of seawater. Most tsunami are caused by sudden vertical motion of the seafloor during earthquakes. However, tsunami associated with the 1883 Krakatau volcanic eruption are known to have been triggered by high-volume, extremely fast moving pyroclastic flows entering the ocean. Sudden caldera collapse would also generate tsunami. At sea, tsunami are not noticeable; their long wavelengths (kilometers) and modest amplitudes (a few meters) are easily lost in the normal open-ocean swell. However, as they enter shallower waters along a coastline, the wave slows, amplitudes grow, and huge waves pile up at the shoreline and surge inland. Following the surge inland, the water then rushes back out to sea retracing the initial areas of destruction. Needless to say, tsunami can be very dangerous and destructive. Tsunami generation and characteristics are very sensitive to the amplitude, period, and duration of seabottom ground shaking, and to coastal bathymetry. Thus occasionally, localized, unusually destructive tsunami are associated with seemingly modest-magnitude earthquakes. 22. In addition to magnitude, earthquake casualties and damage depend on many other natural and cultural factors. Aftershocks can slow or stop rescue efforts and cause additional damage and casualties. Amplified ground shaking and liquefaction intensify damage to structures built on quick clay and soft, unconsolidated, and/or water-saturated foundation materials. Landslides, rockslides, and rolling boulders can account for far more deaths and injuries than are attributable directly to the ground shaking. A quake during the day when most people are out-of-doors results in far fewer injuries and fatalities than one at night when families are sleeping in their homes. The appalling death tolls associated with earthquakes in the magnitude 5 to 6 range in countries such as Iran, Afghanistan, India, and Morocco are mainly due to collapse of weakly bonded mud and rock homes. As in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, fire is a constant threat; gas lines and water mains break, streets, highways, and bridges may be impassable, and there may be no practicable way to fight the fires. Electrical power failures, damage to sewage plants, unsafe and/or unavailable drinking water, and other results of infrastructure damage all contribute to poor sanitation and increase the threat of sickness and epidemics. In more developed countries like the U.S., accidents involving toxic plants, etc., increase the chances of dangerous secondary effects following a quake. Finally a tsunami may be made more dangerous by some unusual combination of seafloor displacement, seafloor topography, and coastal configuration. Earthquakes 97 23. In recent years, seismologists have concluded that no reliable method exists for making short-range earthquake predictions. Long-range predictions have been more successful that involve forecasting magnitudes and locations on time scales of years or perhaps even decades. Such forecasts, while not always reliable for any short-range planning, are important because they provide information used to develop building codes and also to assist in land-use planning. Therefore, forecasting today is directed more toward identifying risks, increasing preparedness, and reducing casualties and damage. 24. Paleoseismicity studies, historical seismicity studies, geologic and geophysical studies, and high and lowtech strain monitoring enable earthquake risks and anticipated maximum ground accelerations to be determined in a general way. By educating the public, such studies enhance prospects for increased disaster preparedness and reduced fatalities, injuries, and property damages when the next powerful earthquake inevitably does strike. They also assist in long-term planning as discussed above in question number 23. 25. Earthquakes can be used as evidence to support the theory of plate tectonics in several ways. These include the fit between the plate tectonics model and the global distribution of earthquakes, the connection of deep-focus earthquakes and oceanic trenches, and the occurrence of only shallow-focus earthquakes along divergent and transform fault boundaries. Lecture outline, art-only, and animation PowerPoint presentations for each chapter of Earth, 9e are available on the Instructor’s Resource Center CD (0131566911). 98 NOTES: CHAPTER 11