Republic of the Marshall Islands Economic Policy, Planning and Statistics Office Office of the President P.O. Box 7 Majuro, MH 96960 Proposal for Improving Solid Waste Reduction and Recycling for Majuro Atoll, Republic of the Marshall Islands 1. Overview of the Problem This proposal springs from an earlier OMIP project for the Marshall Islands that was tasked with assessing the solid waste situation in the Marshall Islands. Because of a number of issues and constraints the assessment dealt entirely with Majuro Atoll, which is the capital for the Marshall Islands. There are increasing population pressures and very limited land space available for solid waste activities. The population density of Majuro is over 6,500 people per square mile! The environment, public health and economic development are under different potential threats if a significant change of direction is not taken with the handling and processing of solid waste on Majuro. Many of the wastes disposed in Majuro have a high potential for recycling. From governmental, non-profit and community meetings and discussions, it was apparent that the interest in recycling is also high at this time. Two different types of recycling programs are feasible, commodity recycling and organic waste recycling. Commodity recycling includes food and beverage containers and organics recycling includes yard trimmings, food waste and wood waste. Paper and cardboard can be recycled either as a commodity or in an organics recycling program. During visits from a team of solid waste practitioners from the City of San Diego Department of Environmental Services (partially funded by OMIP), several trips were made to the current landfill to evaluate incoming loads of waste. Waste from the first four days of a visit was stockpiled and carefully reviewed and compared with waste composition information provided by the EPA in their 1996 report. It would appear based on an evaluation of the length of time being taken to fill up the current landfill, that the tonnage being generated may have been over estimated in the EPA report by up to 50%. However, with over 60% of the population reported to be fewer than 30, waste generation will continue to grow rapidly in the coming years. The composition analysis in the EPA report, which was based on projecting an analysis done by the World Health Organization in 1991, may have under-reported the miscellaneous component. It was reported as 6% but estimated to be closer to 30% during the visit. However, it was clear that 50% or more of the waste stream is compostable (including the cardboard and paper) and that there were very large quantities of aluminum cans and plastic Polyethylene terepthalate (PET) drinking bottles being disposed. There are very high relative percentages of cardboard in the waste because of the need to import almost all consumer and food products. The high percentage of plastic water bottles is a reflection of the water quality on the island. 1 At this time space in the landfill is very scarce and expansion of the landfill will be of a limited nature. Waste reduction and recycling assume a much more prominent role because of the space problems in the landfill. It is anticipated that with the purchase of a tub – grinder and trommel screen approximately 50% of the waste currently being deposited into the landfill can be diverted (yard waste, cardboard and wood). Additions of equipment to deal with aluminum cans, plastic bottles and glass could account for another 12% - 15% of the waste stream. This result of diverting up 65% waste from the landfill will extend its operational life. Another area to address will be general public education and awareness. Over the course of the last year there have been several meetings with the landowners of Majuro. There have also been smaller meetings with the Majuro Chamber of Commerce. The level of discussion and concern over this issue is much, much higher than the recent past. However, more will need to be done particularly if we are looking to people and businesses to begin separating some of their respective waste streams. Until this time, recycling efforts have been minimal and focused on sporadic aluminum can collection at a handful of locations and a brief effort by the RMIEPA in the mid 1990’s from which it was reported no cans were shipped off the island. Some small-scale organic waste recycling was noted at the Taiwanese experimental farm in Laura and, in the past, some research on trench composting had been done at College of the Marshall Islands (CMI) Laura campus. The Taiwanese farm primarily used chicken and pig wastes combined with crop residues but also occasionally added copra and fish waste from the processing facilities in Majuro. From these visits to Majuro, it appears that there is no infrastructure currently in place, which would be available to assist with the diversion of organic waste materials from landfill disposal. The current trash collection infrastructure consists of seventy 20-cubic yard roll offs placed strategically around the island from just east of the airport to the east end of Majuro which are serviced by two roll off trucks. The collection operates 14 hours a day six days a week and it was apparent from observations during the visit that, while the roll off sites were generally well maintained, there was little – if any – additional collection capacity with the existing trucks. The only chipper observed on the island was the very small-scale unit at the Taiwanese experimental farm. We were told that Kwajalein did have a large industrial grinder they used to chip and recycle their green wastes. 2. Proposed Solution During the course of calendar year 2002 the following events/items have occurred: January – MalGov sent the current head of the Sanitation Department to 1 month of basic MSW training in Samoa. The Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) sponsored this. March – OMIP proposal for Solid Waste Assessment was approved March – The first of many meetings between the Mayor of Majuro and President Note concerning solid waste took place. May, July, and September – The OMIP Solid Waste Assessment Proposal is carried out by a team of consultants from the Environmental Services Division from the City of San Diego. The team meets with members of the Cabinet, government officials, the local 2 government, Chamber of Commerce, traditional leaders and landowners. The team is interviewed by the local radio station and newspaper. May - Officials from MalGov visited the waste and recycling operations at the City of San Diego. June and August – RMIEPA and MalGov have a conduct a series of meetings with the landowners of Majuro concerning solid waste. These meeting were primarily basic education about the current problems and what they can do to help. There is a great level of interest and a demand to improve the situation as a result. The level of public pressure to deal with the problem has increased dramatically. June, July, and October – There are a number of editorials and stories in the local newspaper addressing the solid waste situation on Majuro. August – President Note and the FAS Presidents from FSM and Palau, during the regional FAS summit, agreed to support more regional efforts in the area of solid waste and the environment. October – President Note, in an effort to initiate regional action on solid waste and the environment, sent an official to Palau to discuss these issues. November – Officials from RMIEPA and the President’s Office traveled to Kwajalein to examine waste and recycling efforts on the base and discuss the possibility of training opportunities for solid waste and waste reduction activities. Environmental Officials from the base have responded favorably to this request and are awaiting more details from the RMI Government. The solution being proposed covers a fairly broad area, but this coverage is the result of lessons learned in the past, particularly over the last year. A. Waste Reduction/Recycling Activities In order to extend the life span of the landfill, waste reduction and recycling activities have to be implemented. At present about 50% of the waste currently heading into the landfill could be converted into compost. In addition recycling or reprocessing of other materials (aluminum, plastic drinking containers, glass and tires) could divert another 10% - 15% of the waste stream from the landfill. However in order for this to occur some equipment must be purchased. As part of the solution the national government will purchase a tub – grinder, this is the most essential and most expensive piece of equipment needed for this activity. It is proposed with the remaining pieces of this highly specialized equipment is purchased under a 50/50 arrangement between RMI (national government and MalGov) and OMIP. The goal will be to gradually reduce the amount of waste entering the landfill. At the end of three years it is anticipated that about 40% of the current waste stream will be diverted through these efforts, but a reduction of this magnitude can only occur if there is a purchase of relevant and necessary equipment. B. Construction Some construction needs to take place in order for this project to succeed. First MalGov will begin a modest expansion of the current landfill. This will relieve some of the pressure on the landfill as it is currently overflowing. This extra space will allow sections being used now to facilitate operation of the tub – grinder and trommel screen for composting operations. Second, in order to house the specialized recycling equipment 3 MalGov will begin construction of a metal frame building to house this equipment on the site of the old fill next to the bridge. C. Training/Capacity Building There are two major components to this area. The first is basic training and familiarization at Kwajalein MSW Operations. It is anticipated that over the next three years personnel from MalGov will spend about 6 weeks on the base. In the first year this will be 4 weeks. 3 weeks will be spent on the base before equipment arrives in Majuro. This will allow personnel from MalGov to be exposed to working MSW/Recycling/Composting operation. In addition, all the MSW/Recycling/Compost operators at the Kwajalein site are Marshallese, so this will be tremendous benefit in passing along information to MalGov personnel. The remaining periods will be for follow – up to ensure potential questions in areas surrounding collection schedules; organization issues, maintenance tips and public information can be asked and answered. Being able to work the base is a tremendous opportunity because of its close location to Majuro, helping to keep down cost of travel, Kwajalein faces many of the same waste issues as Majuro, and because almost all personnel from Kwajalein are Marshallese passing along information will be easily facilitated. Outcome will be that training will be provided for a total of 12 people over the course of this program. D. Public Information/Public Education Another major element will be an expansion of the available information covering solid waste/recycling and composting. These efforts will be tied into existing programs being implemented by RMIEPA under other international/regional environmental programs. The efforts made under this proposal will develop information separation of wastes, what is composting and recycling. MalGov has a weekly radio show and these topics are already a regular feature of the program. This information will be made available to all households on Majuro and to the Ministry of Education for distribution in the schools. The printing budget in this project will allow MalGov, along with RMI EPA and the Ministry of Education, to produce enough educational/public information material for every household on Majuro, as well as some information for people in Ebeye, Jaluit and Wotje. Information will also be distributed through the school system. E. Consulting There will also be a number of consulting activities to support the development of the above activities. It is envisaged that the same team of consultants from the City of San Diego will be used; this will help ensure continuity of information and direction. Areas of consultation will be MSW operations, primarily looking at landfill operations, collection schedules, recycling/composting activities and department organization. Another area will concentrate on the development of public information/education materials by MalGov. The last area of consultation will involve a review of existing national and local laws and ordinances relating to MSW and related environmental issues. The aim will be to make the laws and ordinances more relevant to the true 4 situation on the ground. Many laws and ordinances in this area have just been imported from the U.S. and bear little if any relevance to conditions found on Majuro. The major outcome in this area will be institutional development and strengthening, this will include advise on operations, planning and maintenance. At the end of the three-year period the Solid Waste Department should be able to stand on it own. 3. Benefits to be Derived - Outcomes A. Reduce Direct Landfill Disposal Approximately 60% of the waste currently being dumped into the landfill could be diverted with some changes in practices, purchase of equipment and capacity building. Because space is at such a premium in the landfill, a diversion of this much waste would be a significant positive development, adding to the lifespan of the current landfill until a more permanent landfill arrangement can be developed and implemented. The current thinking is that a goal of a 40% reduction over three years is feasible. B. Reduce Potential Public Health Hazards/Ease Environmental Strain Through the production of mulch and compost another source of cover for the landfill will be produced. This will reduce the potential public health hazed that now exists. In addition the production of mulch and compost will relieve the strain on the environment in the lagoon, particularly with dredging, which is the only way to currently provide covering material for the landfill. Dredging is a major cause of erosion along the lagoon. C. Better Control of Hazardous Waste There are no programs in place to deal with items such as used motor oil, batteries and tires. Since the completion of road paving on Majuro the number of vehicles on Majuro has increased from 1,800 in 1998 to over 3,100 vehicles in 2002. Controlling this waste stream is a function of the capacity and professional development not only of MSW operations but of RMIEPA as well. Examining both the national and local laws and ordinances associated with issue, MalGov and RMIEPA will be in a better position to enforce and monitor activities that contribute to the solid waste stream on Majuro. D. Increase Public Awareness Efforts at public education dealing with waste reduction and recycling have been, at best, haphazard in the past. There was little connection or coordination given to the fact there was almost no capacity or organizational infrastructure to deal with this area. With the establishment of a more comprehensive waste management program, there needs to be a corresponding increase and improvement in the quantity and quality of information given to the public and schools. Every house on Majuro and a significant number in the other urban areas (Ebeye, Jaluit and Wotje) will receive information concerning many aspects of solid waste management such as information on waste reduction, separation of waste, recycling. 5 E. More Professional and capable MSW operations While MalGov has been involved with solid waste collection for many years, it is only in the last 4 years that modern equipment has been used and a Sanitation Department created. There has also been little in the way of professional development or training. This proposal seeks to introduce improved opportunities for training and information for management and operators. For almost everyone working in the Sanitation Department at MalGov this program will provide the first elements of professional development and training they have received in this vital area of municipal services. There is a definite need to improve the professionalization of solid waste management, to network, attend training seminars and to be exposed directly to different and appropriate equipment vendors. Funding would allow for 2 people (MalGov Director of Sanitation and another rep from MalGov) to attend this important annual convention. Past experience has shown that unless we can dedicate funding for this activity directly, people have not been able to use Buddy System Funds to travel to these types of meetings. Given the nature and scope of this proposal it is seems to be appropriate to include this type of professional development as one element to be included, at least for the first two years. After this initial two years it would be up to the Buddy System to fund this type of activity. 4. Milestones A. April 03 – Tub Grinder and Trommel Screen Ordered B. April 03 – Landfill Expansion completed and current landfill prepped to support composting activities C. August 03 – Review of National/Local MSW legislation & ordinances completed D. July – April 03 – 1st trip to Kwajalein completed E. May – May 03 – Consultants arrive on Island F. July 03 – Tub grinder & Trommel screen arrive on island G. August – June 03 – 2nd trip to Kwajalein H. Aug – Sept 03 – Attend SWANA Conference I. Nov – Sept 03 – Consultants on Island J. October 03 – Recycling Equipment ordered K. October 03 – Site preparation for Recycling Center L. Jan 04 – 3rd trip to Kwaj M. Jan 04 – Recycling Equipment arrives on Island N. Feb – Mar 04 – Consultants on Island O. June – Apr 04 – 4th trip to Kwaj P. Aug – Sept 04 – Attend SWANA Conference Q. Sept 04 – 2nd year of Project Completed 5. Costs 6 Year 1 A. Equipment 1. Tub – Grinder - $270,000 CIF Majuro 2. Trommel Screen - $80,000 CIF Majuro 3. Computer Equipment - $9,000 B. Construction 1. Landfill Expansion Majuro Atoll Local Government (MalGov) will commence a modest expansion of the current Rairok landfill. A significant portion of this landfill will be prepared so the use of the tub – grinder, trommel screen and resultant composting operation can commence this location. 2. Recycling Center MalGov will begin preparing the old landfill at the bridge as the site for a recycling center. It is anticipated this will be an erector style metal frame building to house the recycling equipment planned under Year 2. C. Training/Capacity Building 1. Kwajalein It is envisioned that at least 4 personnel from Majuro Local Government will travel to Kwajalein and shadow counterparts in the Solid Waste Department. Specifically this will involve the recycling/composting activities as well as collection and basic management procedures. Before equipment is scheduled to arrive in Majuro, personnel will work with Kwajalein personnel for a period of 2 – 3 weeks. After the equipment has arrived personnel will again work with Kwajalein for a period of 1 – 2 weeks. 1St Trip to Kwajalein A. Hotel – The Kwaj Lodge - 21 days x $20 x 4 = $1,680 B. Per Diem – 21 days x $100 x 4 = $8,400 C. Air Fare – 4 trips x $250 = $1,000 Total = $11,080 2nd Trip to Kwajalein A. Hotel – Kwaj Lodge – 7 days x $20 x 4 = $560 B. Per Diem – 7 days x $100 x 4 = $2,800 C. Air Fare – 4 trips x $250 = $1,000 Total = $4,360 2. Majuro Under the RFP’s for the equipment, there will be a line item for a factory representative to assist with installation and initial operator training. In addition additional training, particularly with composting activities will be required. 7 3. Consultants This project will utilize the same Solid Waste consultants who were in Majuro last year working on a Solid Waste assessment report funded by OMIP. These consultants will focus on organizational and training issues for MalGov, particularly in landfill management, collection, waste reduction, public information and education. This budget includes, airfares and per diem. Year 2 A. Equipment 1. Aluminum Can/Plastic Container Baler - $28,000 – CIF Majuro 2. Glass Pulverizer - $80,000 CIF Majuro Total = $108,000 B. Training 1. Hotel – Kwaj Lodge – 14 days x $20 x 4 = $1,120 2. Per Diem – 14 days x $100 x 4 = $5,600 3. Air Fare – 8 trips x $250 = $2,000 Total = $8,720 C. Consultants Year 3. A. Equipment Tire Shredder - $75,000 CIF Majuro B. Training 1. Hotel – Kwaj Lodge – 14 days x $20 x 4 = $1,120 2. Per Diem – 14 days x $100 x 4 = $5,600 3. Air Fare – 8 trips x $250 = $2,000 Total = $8,720 C. Consultants – Follow – up on landfill, collection and other MSW management activities Proposed Project Budget Year 1 Item Equipment A. Tub Grinder B. Trommel Screen C. Computer, printer Digital camera, scanner and software RMI Share $270,000 $41,500 $4,500 MalGov Share OMIP Share Total $41,500 $4,500 $270,000 $83,000 $9,000 8 Construction A. Landfill Expansion Training/Capacity Building Travel to Kwajalein from Majuro MalGov MSW Training Public Information/Education A. Public Info Specialist A. Environmental Staff Trainer/Ed Specialist B. Printing Consulting A. Solid Waste System Management/Planning B. Collection/Waste Reduction &Recycling C. Review of National and Local Environmental Legislation Year 1 TOTALS $70,000 $70,000 $7,720 $7,720 $15,440 $5,000 $5,000 $10,000 $4,000 $4,000 $8,000 $3,585 $3,585 $7,170 $7,000 $7,000 $14,000 $5,000 $5,000 $10,000 $21,000 $21,000 $42,000 $99,305 $538,610 $369,305 $70,000 Year 2 Item Equipment A. Aluminum Can Baler B. Glass Pulverizer Construction Recycling Center Training/Capacity Building A. Travel to Kwajalein from Majuro for MalGov MSW Training RMI Share MalGov Share OMIP Share Total $14,000 $14,000 $28,000 $43,250 $43,250 $86,500 $80,000 $4,360 $80,000 $4,360 $8,720 9 Public Information/Education Printing Consulting MSW Operations/Composting Follow - up Year 2 TOTALS $2,585 $2,585 $5,170 $20,000 $20,000 $50,000 $84,195 RMI $84,360 MalGov $84,195 OMIP $252,750 Total RMI Share MalGov Share OMIP Share Total $35,000 $70,000 $4,360 $4,360 $8,720 $2,585 $2,585 $5,170 $20,000 $40,000 YEAR 3 Item Equipment A. Tire Shredder $35,000 Training/Capacity Building A. Travel to Kwajalein from Majuro Public Information/Education Printing Consulting MSW Operations/Composting Follow - up $20,000 Year 3 TOTALS $55,000 $6,945 $61,945 $133,890 GRAND TOTALS RMI $508,700 MalGov $161,305 OMIP $245,445 Total $915,450 Contact Persons 1. Carl S. Hacker – Director, Economic Policy, Planning and Statistics Office (EPPSO) EPPSO Office of the President P.O. Box 7 Majuro MH, 96960 10 Ph – (692) 625 – 3802 Fax – (692) 625 – 3805 E – Mail - planning @ ntamar.com 2. Russell Langrine – Assistant to the Mayor, Majuro Atoll Local Government (MalGov) Majuro Atoll Local Government P.O. Box 796 Majuro MH, 96960 Ph – (692) 625 – 8186 Fax – (692) 625 – 5714 E-Mail @ntamar.com 11