1 INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES AND ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR The way individual differences affect behavior is an important topic in the discipline of interactional psychology. It vies behavior as a function of two main variables: the person and the environment: B=f(P,E). Person Skills ability; Personality Perception; Attribution; Attitudes; Values; Ethics Environment Organization Work groups Jobs, Personal Life Behavior Interactional psychology argues that in order to understand the person and his behavior we must be able to assess the person itself and the situation in which his behavior is engaged. There four fundamental propositions in this analysis: 1 Behavior is a result of interaction between the person and the situation 2The person is both affected by and at the same time affects the situation 3 People vary in their characteristics (cognitive, emotional, motivational) 4 The objective (outside) and the subjective (from the person’s viewpoint) should both be considered when evaluating the situation ____________________________ 2SKILLS AND ABILITIES Two types of abilities are considered best predictors of performance and behavior: Cognitive abilities, or General Mental Ability (GMA) Emotional Intelligence (EI) ____________________________ 3PERSONALITY Personality makes an individual behave in a consistent way in different situations Determinants of personality: Heredity Environment (bringing up, culture etc) 5-Trait Model When analyzing behavior, various personality theories break down behavioral patterns in major observable traits. One such widely used personality model is the 5-Trait model which associate behavior with 5 basic traits: 1 Extraversion assertive sociable communicative Introversion reserved timid quiet 2 Agreeable warm cooperative Disagreeable cold antagonistic 3 Conscientiousness organized hardworking dependable Nonlazy disorganized unreliable 5 Openness creative curious Resistance narrow practical Another approach to 4 Emotional stability Emotional instability calm anxious self-confident depressed 1 understanding and explaining behavior is the integrative approach. It views personality as a composite of individual psychological processes, particularly dispositions. Disposition is the tendency of a person to respond in a particular way to a situation. Types of dispositions include emotions, expectations, congitions. The integrative approach takes into account dispositions and situational variables. Personality Characteristics in Organizations Many personality characteristics determine a person’s behavior in organizations. Among them, three core personality characteristics include 1 core self-evaluations, 2 self-monitoring, and 2 positive– negative affect. 1 core self-evaluation is a set of personality traits that define a person’s self-concept Three such traits are locus of control, self-esteem, and self-efficacy Locus types include: the internal (believe that control over a situation resides within a person); and external locus of control (control is outside the person) . Internal: like to control work environment; want part in decision-making; do not like close supervision External: like structured work environment; relctant to participate in decision-making Self-efficacy reflects a person’s view of him/herself as being able to perform a certain task High self-efficacy types: confident, influence over others; attempt difficult tasks, value the opportunity to participate Low self-efficacy types: timid, feel ineffective Previous success and performance is a major determinant of self-efficacy Self-esteem: reflects a person’s general feeling of self-worth High: have positive feeling about themselves; believe strengths are more important than weaknesses; perform better; seek out higher status jobs; may brag inappropriately when in difficult situations; may be overconfident; may engage in conflict with others Los: strongly affected by the opinion of others; complement those who give them positive feedback and cut down people who give them negative feedback The self-esteem indicator can predict to a great extent behavior and performance in organizations ---What is the effect of success and failure on self-esteem? ---How does the opinion of others affect our self-esteem? What is better being liked ”for who you are” or “for achievement”? ---What should managers do to encourage high self-esteem among employees? Self Monitoring: the extent to which people base their responses and behavior on cues from other people High self-monitors: pay attention to what is appropriate in specific situations; pay attention to other people’s reactions and adjust their behavior accordingly; considered unpredictable, less consistent; accomplish tasks by fulfilling the expectations of others; seek central positions in social 2 networks; more likely to get promoted; point to others their skills and accomplishments; flexibility may not be suited to every job; tendency to move may not fit every organization; because of their ability to take cues from other, high-self monitors demonstrate higher levels of managerial selfawareness; as managers, they assess the workplace behavior accurately; as managers, they read and assess accurately employee needs; adjust their interaction with employees depending on the situations; respond more readily to work norms, organizational culture and supervisory feedback; can participate in different work-teams; can assume flexible roles Low self-monitors: act from internal state rather than paying attention to the situation; consistent across situations; considered more predictable, consistent; respond in a more reserved way to organizational culture, norms and feedback; follows internal guidelines of behavior ---Would you define yourself as a high or low self monitor? ---Organize a pro and con chart for high and low self-monitors (from your perspective) Positive-Negative Effect: trait that reflects focusing on the positive/negative aspects of oneself Positive: focus on the positive aspects of themselves; more often in a positive mood; more willing to help others; less absent from work; engage in organizational citizenship more often Negative: Report more work stress; When discussing a situation within wich behavior is engages, we should also consider if this is a strong situation or weak situation. Strong situation is a situation that overrides the effects of individual personality traits and tend to be interpreted in a similar way by different individuals; provides clear cues to appropriate behavior and obvious rewards to certain types of behavior Weak situation is a situation may be open to many different interpretations: provides few cues to appropriate behavior and no obvious rewards for one type of behavior or another ________________________________________________________________________ 2 APPLICATIONS OF PERSONALITY THEORY. THE MAYER-BRIGGS TYPE INDICATOR One personality and behavior model was developed This personality and behavior model is used extensively in a research that studies and attempts to understand behavior. It is based on 4 scale dichotomies : 3 Extraversion Outgoing Publicly expressive Interacting Speaks, then thinks Gregarious Introversion Quiet Reserved Concentrating Thinks, then speaks Reflective Thinking Analytical Clarity Head and reason Justice Rules Feeling Subjective Harmony focused Heart and feeling Mercy Sensing Practical Specific Feet on ground Details Concrete Intuition General Abstract Head in clouds Possibilities Theoretical Judging Structures Time oriented Decisive Makes lists/uses them Organized Perceiving Flexible Open minded Exploring Makes lists/loses them Spontaneous Extraversion/introversion: Pro situations: Con situations: ___________________ Sensing/intuition: Pro situations: Con situations: ____________________ Thinking/feeling: Pro situations: Con situations: ___________________ Judging/Perceiving: Pro situations: Con situations: 4 The Sixteen Types ESTJ-type style ______________________ ______________________ ______________________ ST-type ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ NT-type ______________________ ______________________ ______________________ IIFP-type style ______________________ ______________________ ______________________ I-type ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ F-type ______________________ ______________________ ______________________ ____________________________________________________________________ 3SOCIAL PERCEPTION Social perception is the process of interpreting the information about another person. Perception is a key factor in management activities, particularly appraising and selection. Question for discussion Interview situation: what kind of information is included in perception From the interviewer’s point of view From the interviewee’s point of view What affects the process of perception? Target -Appearance -Verbal communication -Nonverbal signs -Intentions Perceiver -Familiarity -Attitudes - Mood -Self-concept -Cognitive structure Barrier: Stereotyping First-impression error PERCEPTION Barrier: Selective perception, self-fulfilling prophesy Characteristics of the situation -Context of interaction -Strength of situation cues Perceiver Familiarity: Attitude Mood Self-concept (positive/negative) Cognitive patterns Target Appearance (clothing, height etc) Verbal signs Non-verbal signs Inferred intentions 5 Situation Strong situations Weak situations Discounting principle Impression (Perception) Management Name-dropping Self-enhancing Other-enhancing Barriers Discussion Question: Selective perception Describe a situation in which Stereotypes: accurate and impression management can be effective inaccurate, validated and shared; contrast Describe a situation in which of stereotypes impression management can be ineffective Projection Self-fulfilling prophesy ____________________________________________________________________ 4ATTRIBUTION Attribution is the psychological pattern that attributes (pinpoints) the causes to one’s own behavior and that of others. Attribution theory is the theory how we pinpoint to the causes of behavior. Attribution is concerned with our inference of explaining the types of behavior we observe, identify the reasons for performance, good or poor. Attribution patters: External Internal Attribution is so important because the way we explain our behavior directly affects our motivation. Attribution theory also explains how judgment on performance results in different patters of evaluation, praise and reward. Internal attribution as a motivator External attribution as a non-motivator Attribution Biases (US strictly) The fundamental attribution error The Self-serving bias Affect of culture on attribution Chinese and Indian perceptions Discussion Question How does your culture affect your pattern of attribution at home/the workplace? What may be some negative consequences of a serious mis-attribution on the part of management? From an ethical viewpoint, how do manager’s attribution errors affect employees’ performance and motivation? 6