Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs Research Study on International Recycling Experience Annex A A2 FRANCE - NIORT A2.1 OVERVIEW A summary description of Niort and key recycling data are presented in Table A2.1. Table AA2.1 Overview of Niort City Background Details Population 59 663 Density 631/km2 Type of area Urban Type of housing Houses: 65% Apartments: 35% (5% of these are concentrated in the city centre). Definition of MSW All domestic waste and commercial waste similar to domestic & parks and gardens waste. Recycling target 50% of MSW must be recovered (energy recovery, re-use, recycling) Recycling achievement 36% (1998/99) Principal recycling drivers producer responsibility; good separate collection facilities (organic waste); public information activities. Niort was one of the first municipalities in France to introduce composting of organic waste. Many municipalities across France are currently introducing recycling systems for other waste materials, amongst these is Niort. A2.2 RECYCLING TRENDS Figure AA2.1 Quantities of waste collected for recycling (household and commercial sectors) Note: The column representing packaging waste reflects the packaging collected over the six month pilot phase. The column representing packaging waste in Figure A2.1 reflects the results of the pilot collection of packaging waste. Table A2.2 breaks down this figure into the components of packaging collected: Table A2.A2.2 Results of selective collection test for packaging waste Material Tonnage Total waste delivered Steel 291.46 Materials recovered 6.05 Aluminium 0.33 Cardboard 26.98 Carton 3.9 Plastic 22.78 Newspaper and magazines 50.94 23.43 per cent of the packaging waste delivered from yellow bins was residual waste. A2.3 MSW MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE The municipality has overall responsibility for the collection and treatment of all MSW. Collection activities are carried out by the municipality. The municipality considers that this allows costs and quality to be controlled more effectively. Waste sorting of paper and card, and of plastics and metals has been contracted to a private company. The contract is for one year and renewable. A three year contract has been organised for the supply of recycling containers. The municipality plans to build its own sorting centre within two to three years. The municipality is responsible for the composting of organic waste, but all other collected materials are processed by private companies. Separated materials are delivered to these companies, under the national system of financing for packaging waste, see Section A2.5. A2.4 COLLECTION MECHANISMS AND ACCESSIBILITY The testing phase for organic waste took place from 1992 to 1994. This test phase involved 1500 households. From 1994 to 1997, the pilot scheme was extended to the rest of the houses in the area. Up until 1999, recycling points throughout the city were provided for paper and card, and glass. The testing phase for door to door separate collection of these materials ran from May 1999 to December 1999. The testing phase was set up for houses in the urban centre, estate housing and a mix of the two, each area covering around 1800 households. The pilot scheme is being extended to around 4000 households every month in 2000. By June 2000, it is expected that all houses should be covered by separate collection. A yellow bin of 120 litres is provided for newspaper and packaging (paper, plastics and metals). One green bin is provided for glass collection. A dark green bin is provided for organic wastes. A final bin is provided for general refuse collection. A member of the municipality visits each household and commercial premise to discuss problems related to lack of space for the bins. As much as possible, the municipality encourages the person to participate in door to door collection schemes. Where several households have space problems, a collective solution is looked for. Approximately 95 per cent of the households have accepted the four bins. As households receive new bins for glass and packaging, city recycling containers are being removed. Underground containers are used in the historic city centre, where there is not always enough room for the additional bins above ground. It is expected that a container will be made available at a maximum of 100 metres of each household. Collection of all waste materials on the same days was complicated by the difference in density between the various types of wastes. This idea was abandoned. Refuse is collected twice a week. Collection frequencies recyclable materials is as follows: packaging: once a week; glass: once a month; organic: once a week. Textiles, oils, batteries, household toxic wastes and bulky waste must be delivered directly by households to civic amenity sites. Residents of flats must use city recycling containers. There are expected to be around 15 to 20 such containers around the city. This gives a density of 1187 to 890 people per container for packaging and glass. Separate collection of packaging, glass and organic waste is expected to be introduced for flats in the future. It is expected that stakeholder consultation will take place with householders to discuss the appropriate level of separate collection facilities needed. A2.4.1 Participation Rate There is no data on participation rates in recycling, but opinions of some staff within the municipality indicate that the vast majority of the population recycles to some degree. A2.5 COSTS AND REVENUES Companies, under the packaging obligation, finance the collection of packaging waste through Eco-Emballages, a private company that facilitates the compliance of the national packaging target. Companies which join EcoEmballages can use a special label (two green arrows) on their packaging.[1] Each partner commits itself to take back the corresponding materials once collected and sorted by the local authorities. The partners nominate the companies which will be responsible for recycling. The prices that the companies pay for collected materials, through Eco-Emballages are as follows: Table AA2.3 Prices of collected materials Material Plastics Price paid (£/ tonne) 137.55 - 555, depending on quantities of sorted materials. Glass 4.50 - 6.40 Metal 18 Aluminium 149 Paper 26 - 51 Cardboard 4.50 The municipality processes organic waste itself, at a cost of FF120 per tonne (£11).[2] The compost is given away for free to residents. The average cost of collection, including costs relating to administration, provision of containers and maintenance is around FF426 (£39) per tonne for all types of waste. However, this hides a large variance, ranging from FF268 (£25) per tonne of glass collected through recycling containers, FF516 (£47) per tonne of glass collected door to door, to FF 1707 ( £157) per tonne of packaging waste. The prices paid by EcoEmballages do not cover these costs entirely. Other forms are support are as follows: general waste taxes; Eco-emballages: grants financial support for the employment of young unemployed people (one person per 10 000 inhabitants up to a maximum of FF 60 000 (£5 500) per year for three employees); ADEME: up to 40 to 50 per cent of the investment. ADEME also provides support for public information activities; The Region government provides match funding with ADEME. A2.6 CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS Composting of organic waste is the most significant recycling activity in Niort. This is largely due to a good separate collection services and public information activities. The way in which the message is put across, as well as the tools used to promote the collection schemes, have been critical. Niort has found that households respond much better if they are encouraged to think of the collection scheme as a service, rather than a responsibility to sort. The national recycling target is a strong push to consider waste management options other than disposal. Producer responsibility has provided a strong incentive to collect and recycling packaging waste. Tying this responsibility to an agreement to take back recycled materials provides a market for the recycled materials. A2.7 LEGAL AND REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS The Decree of the Ministry of Environment, April 1998, states that 50 per cent of municipal wastes must be recovered (energy recovery, re-use and recycling). This Decree is commonly known as the Decree Voynet. The national packaging recycling target is 75 per cent. A2.8 FISCAL INCENTIVES The VAT on collection, sorting and treatment operations has been reduced from 20.6 per cent to 5.5 per cent for local authorities which have put into place a system of separate collection. A2.8.1 Waste Disposal Costs Landfilling is charged at FF 400 (£37) per tonne. No incineration of MSW takes place. A2.8.2 Charging Systems for Waste Management Households pay an annual waste charge as a percentage of the estimated rented value of their housing. In Niort, this tax varies between FF 700 to FF 800 (£64 to £73). Commercial or industrial generators are charged on the same basis, up to a maximum of 1 200 litres per week. Above this limit, the company is charged a tax calculated on the basis of the number of bins. A2.9 PUBLIC AWARENESS Composting: The Municipality of Niort commune has conducted an active information and promotional campaign for composting activities. The following tools and mechanisms have been used to increase public participation: the media have been used for promotional purposes. A press conference was organised at the start of the scheme, followed by regular press conferences and press releases; public information campaigns; public meetings in all the city districts; information distributed through letter boxes; stickers; a letter of information twice a year; guided tours of the composting site; free helplines. Separate collection of glass and paper A letter is sent from the municipality introducing the scheme, as well as a schedule of the different collections, a leaflet explaining the new system and instructions on how to participate. Posters are displayed around the city. The operation has also been advertised in the newspapers. Separate collection begins two weeks after the bins have been distributed and the initial educational campaign is delivered. Training is also given to municipality personnel involved in waste management. The total costs of public information and promotion were £53 745 in 1999. A2.10 MARKET DEVELOPMENT There are no market development initiatives. The packaging agreement between members of EcoEmballages and the Municipality provides sufficient markets for recycled products. See Section A2.5 for more information. A2.11 FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS The following actions will be taken to develop recycling activity: set up a municipally run sorting centre in order to improve sorting operations (for example, to incorporate dirty paper to composting raw material) and promote jobs amongst the unemployed; extension of separate collection to cover apartments in the next two years; increasing of the treatment capacity of the composting station. The treatment surface will be doubled so as to compost 15,000 tonnes of wastes per year. The municipality intends to label the final product. [1] Eco-Emballages works with 5 partners: Sollac (steel), France Aluminuim Recyclage (aluminium), Valorplast (plastics) and the Chambre Syndicale des verreries mecaniques de France (glass). [2] FT 19/04/00 £1 = FF 0.0917 [ Previous ] [ Contents ] [ Next ] Published 26 April 2001 Waste Index Environmental Protection Index Defra Home Page