Agenda Item No. HERTFORDSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL HIGHWAYS AND WASTE MANAGEMENT CABINET PANEL TUESDAY 13 MAY 2014 AT 10.00 A.M. 5 FLOODING IN HERTFORDSHIRE 2013/14 – RESPONSIBILITIES AND RESPONSE Report of the Chief Executive and Director of Environment Author: John Rumble, Head of Environmental Resource Planning (Tel: 01992 556296) Executive Member: Terry Douris, Highways and Waste Management 1. Purpose of report 1.1 To inform the Panel of the flooding responsibilities of the various agencies involved in responding to flooding incidents and to update on the progress in investigating the most severe flooding incidents at Christmas 2013 and February 2014 in the county. 1.2 To inform the Panel of a publicity campaign to help residents and businesses prepare for incidents, such as extreme weather, as well as raise awareness of different roles and responsibilities during flooding incidents, both internally and externally. 2. Summary 2.1 The winter of 2013/14 was the wettest in England since records began in 1766. Although Hertfordshire was not as badly affected as parts of the south west and south east of England, the county received between 150-200% above average rainfall. Aquifers and groundwater rose rapidly as ground became saturated and rivers, streams, ditches and drainage systems struggled to cope with the extreme amount of rainfall. 2.2 The impact in the county was localised but in places properties were flooded, farm land inundated and roads closed. The nature of the weather resulted in both sustained periods of flooding at certain sites but also short term (but repeated) intense impact at other locations. The majority of roads, land and property in the county were unaffected. However the localised impacts of flooding were considerable and for home and business owners that were affected extremely challenging and disruptive. 2.3 In response to the wet weather damage to the highway network, the County Council applied for and was successful in getting, additional funding from Department for Transport. In total we were awarded 1 £3.6m to deal with fixing critical damage to structures, fixing critical earthworks failures and for repairs to damaged road surfaces. 2.4 The County Council (and other agencies) have certain roles and responsibilities around immediate and reactive response to flooding events and also more medium term proactive responsibilities following flooding and managing future risk. Property owners and land owners and managers also have individual responsibility for both proactive and reactive risk management concerning flooding. 3. Recommendations 3.1 That the Panel notes the current responsibilities of the relevant agencies in responding to flood incidents. 3.2 That the Panel notes the response taken by the Lead Local Flood Authority to flooding incidents and in investigating those incidents that occurred at Christmas 2013 and February 2014. 3.3 That the Panel notes plans for a publicity campaign to help residents and businesses prepare for incidents, such as extreme weather, as well as improve understanding of different roles and responsibilities during flooding incidents, both internally and externally. 4. Background 4.1 The Flood and Water Management Act 2010 aimed to address the main concerns of Sir Michael Pitt’s review of the 2007 floods. The act established upper tier authorities as Lead Local Flood Authorities (LLFAs). LLFAs are responsible for coordinating the management of ‘local flood risk’ i.e. flooding from surface runoff, groundwater and ordinary watercourses1. Interactions between different types of flooding are also considered in conjunction with the Environment Agency, which has an overview role and has primary responsibility for flood risk from main rivers, reservoirs and the sea. 4.2 The extreme rainfall levels from late December to late February were between 150-200% above average levels in Hertfordshire. The ground quickly became saturated and despite rainfall events not being particularly intense (very heavy rain in a short period of time), the sheer quantity of rain and the extended nature of rainfall resulted in natural and man made drainage systems being, at times and at specific locations, unable to cope with the volumes of water. 4.3 Fluvial flooding (rivers overtopping banks) and surface water run off were the main causes of flooding although rising and emerging groundwater has caused localised issues. Most flooding events were short term but in some cases roads were closed for a number of days and medium and long term impacts from flooding of property are considerable and very disruptive. The majority of flooding occurred in 1 Ordinary watercourse includes every river, stream, ditch, drain, cut, dyke, sluice, sewer (other than a public sewer) which the Environment Agency has not identified as a Main River. 2 known ‘hotspots’ but other sites that have not experienced flooding or not been flooded for a considerable time period were impacted. This pattern reflected the extreme and unique nature of the rainfall amounts and duration. 4.4 In Hertfordshire over 350 properties were affected by flooding (from all sources) and of those, over 120 were flooded internally. These figures were supplied by the Environment Agency and are estimates only. There is no definitive way of determining an exact figure in terms of properties affected by flooding. Only a relatively small handful of incidents have been reported direct to the County Council. 5. Current Flood Incident Responsibilities 5.1 The Flood and Water Management Act 2010 (FWMA) identifies certain organisations as ‘Risk Management Authorities’ (RMAs) which have specified responsibilities, duties and powers related to local flood risk management. Some responsibilities are new, and others are existing duties and powers set out in previous legislation. Table A sets out the risk management authorities in Hertfordshire and Appendix 1 details their specific roles and responsibilities (as set out in Hertfordshire’s Local Flood Risk Management Strategy2 adopted by the county council in February 2013). Table A. Flood Risk Management Authorities (RMAs) in Hertfordshire FWMA designation The Environment Agency 2 Risk Management Authorities in Hertfordshire Environment Agency South East Region (North East area) Environment Agency Anglian Region (Central area) Lead Local Flood Authority District & Borough councils Hertfordshire County Council Internal Drainage Boards Bedford and Ivel Internal Drainage Boards (IDBs) Water (and Anglian Water Services Ltd Broxbourne Borough Council Dacorum Borough Council East Hertfordshire District Council Hertsmere Borough Council North Hertfordshire District Council St Albans City & District Council Stevenage Borough Council Three Rivers District Council Watford Borough Council Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council http://www.hertsdirect.org/services/envplan/water/floods/floodrisk/lfrmsherts/ 3 FWMA designation Sewerage) Companies Highway Authorities 5.2 Risk Management Authorities in Hertfordshire Thames Water Utilities Ltd Hertfordshire County Council Highways Agency All of the above mentioned risk management authorities also have a role in responding to flooding incidents. This resilience function is undertaken in accord with the multi-agency flood plan for Hertfordshire. Specific responsibilities are set out in Table B. Table B. Flood Risk Response Area for RMAs in Hertfordshire 5.3 Risk Management Authority Flood Risk Response Area Environment Agency Flooding from rivers (and the sea) Lead local flood authority Hertfordshire County Council Surface water and groundwater flooding (in its resilience capacity). Highway Authorities Hertfordshire County Council Highways Agency Flooding on the highway Bedford and Ivel IDB Flooding from water bodies within their area with the exception of those designated as main river. District and Borough Councils Flooding from an ordinary watercourse Water (and Sewerage) Companies Anglian Water Services Ltd Thames Water Utilities Ltd Flooding from the sewer In addition local authorities will have responsibilities under the Civil Contingencies Act which includes the following: The Local Resilience Forum (known locally as Hertfordshire Resilience) Constitutes the principal mechanism for multi-agency cooperation under the Civil Contingencies Act 2004. It is a multiagency partnership of over 80 organisations that ensures cooperation and co-ordination in the event of an emergency, as well as establishing and promoting a more resilient county. 4 The Local Resilience Forum has identified flooding as a 'high' risk on its Community Risk Register and also maintains a Multiagency Flood and Reservoir Inundation Plan. Fire and Rescue Service Following the recent flooding incidents, The Chief Fire Officers Association (CFOA), of which CFO Roy Wilsher acts as the National Operations Director, is in the process of revising its position statement to read: “That the local Fire and Rescue Service acts as the lead agency for the co-ordination of rescue operations during the emergency phase of the response to flooding incidents” (subject to ratification by the CFOA Board) Highways Authorities (including the Highways Agency) Within Hertfordshire, the Fire and Rescue Service (HFRS) can provide significant pumping capabilities at a local level and also has the capability of providing and receiving High Volume Pump assistance through the National Coordination Advisory Framework (NCAF) arrangements. HFRS have the capability to carry out water rescues using our DEFRA (Type B Team) utilising equipment such as rescue sleds and power boats along with our swift water rescue trained personnel. The highways authorities operating within the county have a responsibility to maintain the highways for which they are responsible. This includes ensuring that highway drainage systems are clear and that blockages on the highway are cleared where reasonably practicable It is worth noting that the drainage systems maybe fully operational but if the ditch, outfall or river is full, the drainage system will be chocked and flow could back up in the system and result in surface water flooding. The strategy for dealing with flooding on the highway is defined through the defect management approach. This provides the overarching strategy for the CAT1 and CAT2 service across Hertfordshire. During the development of this, flooding was reviewed and the response times and actions of the authority were scrutinised and reviewed. The Surface Water Management Plan is currently in development for known problem sites across the county. The idea of this plan is to gather known information and assess and prioritise works and to undertake schemes that provide best value for money. Lead Local Flood Authority 5 Hertfordshire County Council has a role as Lead Local Flood Authority (LLFA) to co-ordinate the management of local flood risk in the county. As LLFA for Hertfordshire, the county council needs to develop, maintain, apply and monitor a strategy for local flood risk management in our area. It must also establish and maintain a register of structures or features (such as walls or embankments) likely to have a significant effect on flood risk in the area, including their ownership and state of repair. The county council has worked with other local organisations, authorities and partners in developing a Local Flood Risk Management Strategy (LFRMS) for Hertfordshire. The strategy has to assess what is a locally significant flood risk and coordinate local flood risk management activity. It focuses on flooding from surface water, groundwater and ordinary watercourses (a watercourse that does not form part of a main river, such as ditches and streams). This is available to view on hertsdirect.org. The LLFA is not a first response team and it has no responsibility for main rivers or flooding from main rivers, this function remains with the Environment Agency. Where necessary and within the parameters set out in the LFRMS, the LLFA will carry out investigations into flooding incidents. An investigation aims to determine the cause of flooding, recommend actions to reduce future flood risk and identify organisations with the powers to be able to carry out flood risk management work where feasible. Recommendations arising from an investigation are the responsibly of the relevant and/or identified body to progress. Development of schemes, including bids to the Regional Flood and Coastal Committee for regional and national funding. The County Council The county council also has an advisory role and provides information and advice for businesses and residents on preparing for the risk of flooding on hertsdirect.org, including links to other sources of useful information such as the Environment Agency and district/borough councils. 6. The Response to the Christmas 2013 and February 2014 Flooding 6.1 Several incidents of flooding either from surface water, groundwater or from ordinary watercourses have been reported to the LLFA. To date these have resulted in 3 formal investigations under section 19 (s19) of the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 being commissioned. These are concerned with the incidents at Long Marston, Tring, Robbery Bottom Lane, Welwyn and Green Street, Chorleywood. In addition, information is being collated on ten other reported flooding incidents where consideration is being given as to whether a formal s19 investigation may be required. Full details of the incidents and 6 issues reported to the Lead Local Flood Authority, as of the end of March 2014, can be found in Appendix 3. 6.2 Hertfordshire Fire and rescue Service attended over 100 incidents relating to flooding between 7 February and 28 February 2014. The majority of these attendances occurred over the weekend of the 7 th, 8th and 9th of February. A summary table showing the number of incidents attended by property type is provided below. Property Type House Bungalow Flat / Maisonette Self Contained Sheltered Housing Offices and Call Centres Food & Drink Other Building (use not known) Road Vehicle Private Garden / Allotment Road Rail or Riverbank Vegetation Other Outdoor Location Total Total 82 1 5 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 3 101 6.3 There was disruption to many Hertfordshire roads as a result of flooding incidents on the Highway during February. This ranged from full and partial road closures to problems with highways drainage and vehicles being stuck in flooded fords. A list of the full and partial road closures in the county on the 7th February and the 18th February is included in Appendix 5 to this report. 6.4 Incidents of flooding from main rivers occurred on the Rivers Colne, Lee, Rib and Ash. The Colne came out of its banks in the vicinity of Lower High Street in Watford with significant disruption caused to the local area, transport routes and businesses. Internal flooding of properties was minimal. The Lee came out of its banks and exceeded the available flood storage areas in the centre of Hertford. This resulted in a number of flooded properties, both business and residential as well as the overnight evacuation of residential properties due to both flooding and the need to cut off power supplies. The Rib came out of its banks due to a collapsed wall at Puckeridge, approximately 50 properties were affected, many suffering internal flooding. The Ash flooded at Little Hadham and Hadham Cross with several properties suffering significant internal flooding. 6.5 Eight bids have been submitted to the Thames Regional Flood & Coastal Committee (RFCC) for consideration as part of the annual round of bids for regional Flood and Coastal Risk Management Grant in Aid funding. These are as follows: Surface water/fluvial interaction flooding on key routes in Watford 7 Surface water flooding of roads and properties in Long Marston and the surrounding area Surface water flooding in vicinity of High Street, Harpenden Surface water flooding in the vicinity of Darkes Lane, Potters Bar The effect of surface water drainage of rivers in flood or near flood condition in Hertford Edge of settlement surface water flooding at various locations across the county Surface water flooding in London Colney Surface water flooding in Rickmansworth 6.6 This bidding round was completed at the end of March 2014 following notice that it was being moved forward by government to 28 March from the end of May 2014. A fuller description of each of these bids and the costs associated with them can be found in Appendix 4. 7. Raising awareness of roles and responsibilities 7.1 With various agencies having different roles and responsibilities before, during and after flooding incidents, it is understandable that this will cause confusion. 7.2 The communications team is working with Resilience and Environment officers to develop a publicity campaign. The campaign’s main focus will be general resilience advice to help residents and businesses prepare for flooding incidents, but it is also an opportunity to promote understanding of flooding roles and responsibilities. 7.3 The campaign will: Help residents and businesses understand their roles and responsibilities in preparing for potentially disruptive incidents, such as those arising from extreme weather events. Help residents and businesses to prepare for these potential incidents. Provide guidance to colleagues, partners and the public on different roles and responsibilities before, during and after a flooding incident. Clarify the county council’s responsibilities as Lead Local Flood Authority. 7.4 It is anticipated that the campaign will launch during the summer of 2014. 8. Financial Implications 8.1 There are no additional financial implications arising from this report. 8.2 The County Council is currently in receipt of £540k of funding to directly support the new responsibilities falling to it as Lead Local Flood Authority. Any additional funding for flood alleviation schemes has to be secured via annual bidding processes to the relevant Regional 8 Flood and Coastal Committee’s (RFCC’s). Hertfordshire can put forward schemes for funding consideration to the two RFCC’s operating within its administrative area, those for the Thames and Anglian (central) regions. These bids are required to meet the relevant criteria to qualify for funding support which is from two main pots, either national Flood Defence Grant in Aid (government funding) or the Regional Levy (local authority contributions). Hertfordshire county council currently contributes £842.6K per annum to the Thames RFCC and £64k per annum to the Anglian (Central) RFCC. For the next funding round the county council has submitted seven bids to the Thames RFCC for consideration, see appendix 4 for details of these bids. 8.3 In response to the extensive flooding in England over last winter the Government put in place 4 main grant aid/funding streams to promote and support recovery; Business Support Scheme. The offer of Council Tax discounts. The offer of Business Rate relief. The awarding of Repair & Renewal Grants. 8.4 The council tax and business rate relief schemes are being handled by the district and borough councils as the relevant billing authorities. Likewise a number of the district and boroughs are promoting and managing any claims under the repair and renew scheme but claims are anticipated to be minimal and in some areas where flooding was not a significant issue (e.g. Stevenage, Broxbourne, Hertsmere and Dacorum) there has been no requirement to promote the schemes. 8.5 It is possible that subsequent to the outcome of a s19 flood investigation the repair and renewal grant may offer a source of funding. If that is the case residents and / or businesses will be advised accordingly. 8.6 In addition there is a business support scheme aimed at the farming and fishing industries and this is considered to not be relevant for Hertfordshire. Background Information Local Flood Risk Management Strategy for Hertfordshire, February 2014, Hertfordshire County Council. http://www.hertsdirect.org/services/envplan/water/floods/floodrisk/lfrmsherts/ 9 Appendix 1 Responsibilities of Risk Management Authorities A1.1 Hertfordshire County Council Hertfordshire County Council as the Lead Local Flood Authority (LLFA) has an important role to play as the strategic leader for local flood risk management in Hertfordshire. This involves developing the Local Flood Risk Management Strategy document, ensuring that all organisations involved in flood risk management are aware of their responsibilities, monitoring progress and activity by all parties involved in flood risk management and co-ordinating communication with the public and between organisations. As LLFA the county council has a range of duties which includes: Preparing reports and plans to meet the requirements of the Flood Risk Regulations 2009 (FRR). Carrying out investigations of flooding where appropriate and publishing reports (section 19 investigations). Keeping a public register and associated record of structures and features which have a significant effect on local flood risk. The designation of flood risk structures and features where appropriate. The regulation of ordinary watercourses outside of areas covered by Internal Drainage Boards. Establishment of a Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) Approval Body (SAB). This will come into effect upon the commencement of Schedule 2 of the F&WM Act 2010. In addition the authority has incidental powers which allow it to carry out practical works to manage flood risk from surface water and groundwater. Hertfordshire County Council also has a number of other roles that relate to flood risk management; these include: Highways Authority – management of the majority of roads in the county and their associated drainage. Planning Authority - the county council is the planning authority for minerals and waste development together with its own projects e.g. school sites. The authority produces a Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (SFRA) to support the Minerals and Waste Plan. Emergency Planning – the authority is a category one responder under the civil contingencies act and the role is set out in the Multi Agency Flood Plan. Historical and Natural Environment - maintenance of databases which are shared with other authorities. The information is relevant to planning of practical works and assessing of potential for environmental impacts. A1.2 Environment Agency The Environment Agency has a role in flood risk management both as a national strategic body and also more locally operating as a Risk Management Authority (RMA) at a catchment and area level. Aspects of the strategic role that are relevant are: 10 Using strategic plans like the Catchment Flood Management Plan (CFMP) and the Shoreline Management Plan to set the direction for Flood Risk Management. Collation and review of the assessments, plans and maps that LLFAs produce to meet the Flood Risk Regulations 2009. Providing the data, information and tools to inform government policy and aid risk management authorities in delivering their responsibilities. Supporting collaboration, knowledge-building and sharing of good practice including provision of capacity-building schemes such as trainee schemes and officer training. Managing the Regional Flood and Coastal Committees (RFCCs) and supporting their decisions in allocating funding for flood defence and flood resilience schemes. Monitoring activity and reporting on flood and coastal erosion risk management. Providing grants to RMAs to support the implementation of their incidental flooding or environmental powers. The Environment Agency’s local role as an RMA is relevant in the following areas: Managing flooding from main rivers and reservoirs. Communication about flood risk warnings to the public, the media and to partner organisations. Supporting communities to be flood resilient through sharing best practice and provision of information. Advising on the planning process. Input to emergency planning, multi-agency flood plans, which are developed by local resilience forums. Bringing forward flood defence schemes through the RFCCs, working with LLFAs and local communities to shape schemes which respond to local priorities. A1.3 District and Borough Councils The District and Borough Councils have a flood risk management function relating to ordinary watercourses and in addition have a range of functions which are relevant to the Local Flood Risk Management, these include: As planning authorities, the district councils prepare a local plan to guide development. Flood risk is taken into account based on a Strategic Flood Risk Assessment which must consider flood risk from all forms of flooding. Under the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 (FWMA), district councils have the powers to carry out works to reduce flood risk and to manage flooding from ordinary watercourses. Activity relating to powers under the Land Drainage Act 1991 to make bylaws relating to ordinary watercourses District authorities own and manage public spaces which, may already, and could potentially perform a flood risk management function 11 District authorities have responsibilities for emergency planning as a responder under the Civil Contingencies Act and this role is outlined in the Multi Agency Flood Plan. A1.4 Internal Drainage Boards In addition to the universal responsibilities under the FWMA, Internal Drainage Boards (IDBs) have the following new responsibilities: A power to designate structures and features that affect flooding. A duty to act consistently with local and national strategies. The regulation of ordinary watercourses within the IDB district area. As statutory consultees to the SuDS approval process where proposed drainage systems will involve discharge of water into an ordinary watercourse in an IDB’s district. A1.5 Water Companies There are two types of water companies serving Hertfordshire. Affinity Water Central is a water supply company, while Anglian Water and Thames Water are water and sewerage companies providing both water supply and wastewater services. Water Supply Companies Water supply companies are not RMAs and do not have the same obligations to co-operate and be subject to scrutiny by the LLFA. However, like all persons, they will be required to provide information related to flood risk to Hertfordshire County Council and the Environment Agency. They will also be affected by the change to the Reservoirs Act 1975. Water and Sewerage Companies Water and sewerage companies have the following responsibilities around flood risk management: Respond to flooding incidents involving their assets. Maintenance of a register of properties at risk of flooding due to a hydraulic overload in the sewerage network (DG5 register). Undertake capacity improvements to alleviate sewer flooding problems on the DG5 register. Provide, maintain and operate systems of public sewers and works for the purpose of effectually draining an area. Have a duty to co-operate with other relevant authorities in the exercise of their flood and coastal erosion risk management functions. Must have a regard to national and local flood and coastal erosion risk management strategies. May be subject to scrutiny from LLFAs’ democratic processes. Have a duty for the adoption of private sewers. Statutory consultee to the SAB when the drainage system is proposed to communicate with the public sewer. 12 A1.6 Highways Agency The Highways Agency is an Executive Agency of the Department for Transport (DfT), and is responsible for operating, maintaining and improving the strategic road network in England on behalf of the Secretary of State for Transport. It acts as the Highways Authority for a number of major highways in Hertfordshire and is responsible for the maintenance of the following motorways and trunk roads in Hertfordshire: M1 - Junction 4 – Junction 10. M25 - Junction 16 – Herts /Essex border (managed by Connect Plus). A1(M) - Junction 1 – Junction 10. A5 - M1 Junction 9 – Bedfordshire Border. A414 from the M1 Junction 8 to A405 at St. Albans. A405 between M1 J6 and M25 J21a The roads mentioned in the list belong to Area 5 (Connect Plus Services) (with the exception of M1 J8-10, A1(M) J6-10 and A5). The M25 is in the Highways Agency’s Area 5 the other roads are in Area 8. As a Highways Authority, the Highways Agency has the same obligation to co-operate on flood risk issues as the other RMAs. It also has the following responsibilities under other legislation: Responsibility to maintain the highways, which includes ensuring that highway drainage systems are clear and that blockages on the highway are cleared, where reasonably practicable. Powers to deliver works considered necessary to protect the highway from flooding. Highway Authorities may divert parts of a watercourse or carry out any other works on any form of watercourse if it is necessary for the construction, improvement or alteration of the highway or provides a new means of access to any premises from a highway. Adoption of SuDS on its property as the SuDS Approval Body (SAB) has no obligation to adopt any part of a drainage system which is a publiclymaintained road. If it is on a Highways Agency road, the Highways Agency is expected to adopt and maintain the part of the drainage system on its property in accordance with the approved proposals and the National Standards for sustainable drainage. 13 Appendix 2 How to report flood incidents in Hertfordshire Flood type Responsible authority Flood emergency If flooding is causing a risk to life and/or property ring 999 or look at HCC’s emergencies webpage: http://www.hertsdirect.org/contact/emergencies/ Flooding from roads HCC, Highways/Roads and Environment: www.hertsdirect.org/highwayfaults Flooding from sewers The relevant water and sewerage companies for Hertfordshire: Thames Water: 0845 9200 800 Anglian Water: 08457 145 145 Flooding from private drains Private drains are the responsibility of the homeowner/occupier. Your local water company or drainage contractors will fix the damage for a fee. Flooding from burst water main The water supply companies for Hertfordshire: Affinity: 0845 782 3333 Thames Water: 0845 9200 800 Anglian Water: 08457 145 145 Flooding from a river Environment Agency: Floodline: 0845 988 1188 Flooding from an IDB controlled water body Bedford and Ivel Internal Drainage Board: The Board’s priorities during flooding are: ensuring the Board’s systems are working efficiently; protection of people and residential properties; protection of commercial properties; and protection of agricultural land and ecologically sensitive sites. The Board provides a 24 hour contact number (07764 239891) and during severe emergencies operates extended office hours. Flooding in your home Any flood damage in a home is the responsibility of the homeowner/occupier. If the flooding is from one of the sources above (except private drains) then you should contact the relevant organisation. 14 Flood type Responsible authority Surface water flooding from an unidentified source HCC General enquiries: 0300 123 4040 15 Appendix 3 2013/14 Flooding Issues reported to the County Council as Lead Local Flood Authority for Hertfordshire Under the governing legislation of the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 the Flood Risk Management Team at Hertfordshire County Council is undertaking its duties to assess and where necessary investigate incidents arsing from the recent flooding between December 2013 and February 2014. Section 19 Flood Investigations As required under section 19 of the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 Hertfordshire County Council as Lead Local Flood Authority, on becoming aware of a flood in its area, must, to the extent that it considers it necessary or appropriate: investigate the incident; identify the Risk Management Authorities3 (RMAs) with relevant flood risk management functions; establish if the relevant functions have been exercised or if it is proposed to exercise them; publish its findings in a Flood Investigation Report; consult and inform the relevant Risk Management Authorities of its findings. The criteria for assessing whether a section 19 investigation is required is set out in procedure 2 of the Local Flood Risk Management Strategy. This states Investigation of flooding events will be carried out: In situations where there is uncertainty as to the source of flooding and the organisation with primary responsibility for resolving it. All cases of internal domestic flooding will be recorded and a basic investigation carried out. The criteria to be considered in assessing whether a detailed investigation is required is as follows: In the case where internal flooding has occurred at a property on more than one occasion in a ten year period. Where internal flooding of five or more properties has occurred during one flooding incident. Where internal flooding of a business property has occurred during one flooding incident. Where external flooding of land adjacent to a property has occurred more than five times in a 10 year period. Where a critical service has been affected by flooding. Where roads (excluding fords) and railways have been impassable for in excess of 10 hours. 3 Designated Risk Management Authorities are: the County Council, District and Borough Councils; Highways Authorities; The Environment Agency; Internal Drainage Boards and water companies. 16 Where flooding potentially posed immediate, direct and real risk to life. As of the end of March 2014 the following Section 19 Flood Investigations have been commissioned (these have met the criteria as set out above): Green Street, Chorleywood- flooding of Green Street which is a main route into Chorleywood and main bus route for the local school. Robbery Bottom Lane, Welwyn- (x houses). Long Marston Nr Tring - internal property flooding (x houses). The following reported flood incidents may not meet the criteria for a formal Section 19 Investigation (or a s19 investigation has been declined) but are subject to investigation: Hunsdon – single property flooded (on more than one occasion). Little Wymondley - flooding of main high street. Confirmed internal flooding at five properties, four residential one business. London Colney - flooding of cricket ground and associated business premises Whitwell Village - report of up to 3 properties with internal flooding. Derwent Road, Harpenden- report of 1 property flooded. Lower High Street, Watford – flooding from both surface water and the river Colne reported on two separate occasions in this area Oakhurst Avenue, Harpenden - At least one property flooded. Redbourn – Confirmation of 3 internal flooding incidents. Knebworth – Confirmed one property with internal flooding. Hemel Hempstead – internal property flooding at up to 2 properties from a yet to be identified source. Relevant Enforcement Activity The Lead Local Flood Authority (LLFA) has powers to enforce any works that contravene relevant legislation. This includes works affecting flow within certain watercourses without consent, non compliance of a consent and lack of maintenance of a watercourse. Current assessments where enforcement may be necessary following flooding incidents: Hitchin, Ash Brook at Brook View. Marshmoor Lane, Welham Green. Barkway Village. Pirton Village, Blacksmith's Pond. Little Wymondley Dassels, East Herts Any identified problems in any of these locations may then be subject to discussions with relevant land owners, if these are not successful resolved they could result in HCC taking legal action to require remedial action to take place. 17 Groundwater Issues Kimpton, North Hertfordshire Cow Roast, Tring At present the responsibility of the LLFA is to monitor these groundwater issues, any emergency action to deal with problems arising from groundwater flooding would fall to the relevant resilience team to co-ordinate. 18 Appendix 4 Hertfordshire County Council Bids for Submission to Thames RFCC Medium Term Plan March 2014 The table below summarises candidate schemes which have been submitted to the Thames RFCC for Consideration for inclusion in the Medium term Plan. Issue District Impacts Outcome Measures Proposals Costs Surface water /fluvial interaction flooding key routes in Watford Watford / Hertsmere Closure of number of routes through central Watford due to what is believed to be interaction between surface water and high river levels impeding drainage. Access to a number of businesses is directly and indirectly affected. Water Lane and A411 have been closed on at least 3 occasions in the past 12 years. OM1 – costs of congestion in excess of 50,000 vehicle movements per day affected, direct impact on at least 7 businesses, costs of managing and impacts and clear up. Working in partnership with the Environment Agency to examine potential for strategic solution. Initial study £50 -100K Surface water flooding of Dacorum These and other key routes were closed for a period of time 07/02/14 causing considerable disruption in Watford. Flat poorly draining area in the west of OM2 limited direct impact on residential property there are some properties in the vicinity potential benefit to flood risk dependant on scope of any proposals. Scheme justification will be on OM1 impacts on infrastructure and businesses. OM1 disruption to local businesses, damage to Detailed modelling to understand flooding mechanism and interaction between surface water, watercourses, highway drainage and sewers. Potential Scheme costs unlikely to be less than £500K and upper level ceiling would be defined through cost benefit calculations. Some local measures such as storage and pumping already in place but are not effective under all conditions. Follow up ongoing section 19 investigations to develop Initial study £50K 19 Issue District roads and properties in Long Marston and surrounding area Harpenden, surface water flooding in vicinity of High Street St Albans Impacts Outcome Measures Proposals Hertfordshire on the edge of the Vale of Aylesbury. Roads and properties have flooded on a number of occasions in the road infrastructure a hydraulic model for the interaction between surface water, watercourses (including main river) and the influence of canals and associated reservoirs. Areas of potential flood risk have been identified along the line of the High Street through modelling work carried out for development of a Surface Water Management Plan. OM1 number of businesses affected directly and indirectly OM2 upwards of 10 properties flooded 07/02/14 OM2 150 properties within 1% flood outline on latest version of surface water flood map (uFMfSW 2013) A scheme was proposed to provide linked attenuation for 4 sub catchments. This approach was not found to be favourable at pre feasibility as detailed integrated modelling and scheme costing demonstrated costs would out way benefits. The proposals need to be revisited to determine if there is a feasible approach for flood risk reduction locally in the sub catchments or by providing attenuation higher up the catchment. Costs Anticipated that this will inform priorities for management of existing infrastructure but may require control structures on or improvements to watercourses. Initial study £25 – 50K Cost benefit would limit total scheme costs to a ceiling of £600K 20 Issue District Impacts Outcome Measures Proposals Costs Darkes Lane Potters Bar Hertsmere There have been 11 major flooding incidents recorded since 1987, which equates to surface water flooding on average once every 2 years. OM1 and OM2 internal and external flooding to 120 commercial and residential properties in the Darkes Lane area of Potters Bar. Confirm flooding mechanism which may be linked to hydraulic incapacity in culverted watercourses. Potential for a storage scheme underneath a public car park. To complement work proposed by the Environment Agency and carry out a surface water study to better understand hydraulic dependencies of surface water drainage on fluvial systems and what combination of events may lead to significant surface water flooding events. Interim results from sect 19 Flood investigations will inform relative feasibility of external schemes or property level protection for each group of houses that have been flooded Initial study £25 – 50K Hertford East Herts Surface water drainage being affected by rivers in flood or near flood condition. OM1 and OM2 businesses and properties directly affected potential for significant disruption to A414. Edge of settlement flooding Various locations across the county Water running of large saturated farmed catchments into villages and areas on the fringes of larger settlements OM1 at least 3 business affected directly OM2 at least 50 residential properties affected in 10 confirmed locations Scheme costs unlikely to be less than £200K Initial study £50 -100K Property level protection will be addressed through schemes currently offered by government as this will allow measures to be put in place in a shorter timescale than funding 21 Issue District Impacts Outcome Measures London Colney St Albans Surface water flooding OM1 and OM2 Rickmansworth Three Rivers Surface water flooding OM1 and OM2 Proposals Surface Water study to complement fluvial study proposed by Environment Agency Surface Water study to complement fluvial study proposed by Environment Agency Costs through FDGiA. External group schemes would be limited by cost benefit to order of £80 – 100K Initial study £25 – 50K Initial study £25 – 50K 22 Appendix 5 Date 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 Full and Partial Road Closures as recorded on the 7 and 18 February 2014 Location Road Complete Road Closure/Restrictions /Diversions Lower High St, Watford A-Road X Waterfields Way, Watford A-Road X Water Lane, Watford A-Road X Harefield Road, Rickmansworth A-Road X Coopers Green Lane, St Albans B-Road X Park Road, Rickmansworth A-Road X Station Road, Welham Green Partial Closure/1 lane closed Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford X A4008 Stevenson Way, Watford A-Road X A4146 Leighton Buzzard Road, Dacorum A-Road X A5 Markyate A-Road X Primrose Hill, Hemel Hemstead A-Road X M1 Watford A-Road X Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford M25 St Albans A-Road X St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield A600 Bedford Road, Hitchin A-Road 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 District X North Herts & Stevenage Notes Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendence Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendence Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendence Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendence Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance - 1 lane closed S/bound @ J5. Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance anti clockwise - 1 lane closed @ J21 A405. Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance 23 Date 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 Location A602 Stevenage Road, Little Wymondley B181 Roydon Road, Stanstead Abbotts B487 Hemel Hempstead Road, Redbourn B651 High Street, Sandridge Road Complete Road Closure/Restrictions /Diversions A-Road X B-Road X B-Road X B-Road X Tring Road, Long Marston Gresley Way, Stevenage X B-Road Railway Terrace, Kings Langley A120 - Both directions X X Partial Closure/1 lane closed District Notes North Herts & Stevenage East Herts & Broxbourne Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford North Herts & Stevenage Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance A-Road X Mix Diversion: A1174, B1000, A1170, A1170 Ware High Street and B1004 A602 Hooks Cross/ Bragbury End Diversion: B197 Monkswood Way South, A1000 WGC and B195 Black Fan Road Mixture X Mix Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance A-Road X East Herts & Broxbourne Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Mixture X Mix Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance A507 at Clothall Road Baldock A-Road X A10 - Puckeridge A-Road X Lower Hatfield Road, Essendon B-Road X North Herts & Stevenage East Herts & Broxbourne St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance Duration of restrictions unknown. Delays Expected. Emergency services in Attendance 24 Date Location Road Complete Road Closure/Restrictions /Diversions Old Knebworth Lane, Stevenage B-Road Burymead, Stevenage District Notes X North Herts & Stevenage Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassible. Emergency services in Attendance B-Road X North Herts & Stevenage Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassible. Emergency services in Attendance Coopers Green Lane, Hatfield B-Road X St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassable. Emergency services in Attendance Colney Heath Lane, St Albans A-Road X St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassable. Emergency services in Attendance Sandpit Lane, St Albans B-Road X St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassable. Emergency services in Attendance Shenley Road, London Colney A-Road X St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassable. Emergency services in Attendance C171 Stevenage Road, Little Wymondley C-Road X North Herts & Stevenage Duration of restrictions unknown. Significant Delays expected as a number of routes are impassable. Emergency services in Attendance Green Street, Chorleywood A-Road X Coppermill Lane, Rickmansworth A-Road X St Marys Lane Hertford B-Road X Warren Lane, Braughing - Land slide A-Road X Blakemore End, Kimpton B-Road X Hitchwood Lane, Preston B-Road X 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 07/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 Partial Closure/1 lane closed Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford East Herts & Broxbourne East Herts & Broxbourne North Herts & Stevenage North Herts & Stevenage Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required 25 Date 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 Location Road Complete Road Closure/Restrictions /Diversions Hitchin Road, Stevenage (Subway) A-Road X Porters End Lane Kimpton X Watton Road, Stevenage B-Road X Sandpit Lane, St Albans B-Road X Mackerye End Harpenden B-Road X Green Lanes Hatfield B-Road X Bushey Hall Road, Bushey B-Road X Bushey Mill Lane, Watford A-Road X Walkern Road, Luffenhall (Other side of Walkern) Watton Road, Stevenage X B-Road Mackerye End Harpenden X X A411 Lower High Street Watford A-Road Moor Lane, Rickmansworth A-Road X X Water End Lane Wheathampstead (Lemsford) X Old Knebworth Lane, Stevenage X Beane Road, Hertford X Cappell Lane, Stanstead Partial Closure/1 lane closed B-Road X District North Herts & Stevenage North Herts & Stevenage North Herts & Stevenage St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford North Herts & Stevenage North Herts & Stevenage St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield North Herts & Stevenage East Herts & Broxbourne East Herts & Notes Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Road Closure still required Now Open and passable Now Open and passable Road Closure still required Road Closure still required One Lane of two open Road now reopen Road now reopen Road now reopen Road now reopen Road now reopen 26 Date 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 18/02/14 Location Abbotts A41 Colne way dome roundabout and J5, Watford, diversion set up via St Albans Road - Beechen Grove Stephensons Way - Police approved & aware. Horns Mills Lane Hertford Road Complete Road Closure/Restrictions /Diversions District Notes Broxbourne Mixture X B-Road X Sandridgebury Lane, St Albans X Longcroft Lane, Hemel X Plough Roundabout Subway, Hemel X Wood Lane End, Hemel X Shephards Way, Hatfield B-Road X Lower Road, Nash Mills B-Road X Picknage Road, Barley B-Road X Watery Lane, Tring X Langley Lane Langley X Bank Mill Lane, Berkhamstead X A414 Park Street Roundabout Subway Hitchin Road, Stevenage (Subway) Partial Closure/1 lane closed X A-Road X Mix East Herts & Broxbourne St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford North Herts & Stevenage Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford Dacorum, Three Rivers & Watford St Albans, Hertsmere & Welwyn Hatfield North Herts & Stevenage Road Closed Road Closed Road Closed Road Closed Road Closed. Pedestrian crossing and footbridge available to pass safely Swallow Hole Road Closed Open Open Open Majority of the road is now open Tree removed - road now open Now open - lot of silt but passable Now open 27 28